Peer Review ENGL102 - Analysis
Reviewer:___________________________________________________
FOR THE WRITER: Explain what you are trying to DO in the essay and WHY. Think in terms of purpose:
what are you trying to say (substantive), what effect do you want to have (affective), and how do you
want to be perceived (ethical).
FOR THE REVIEWER: Tell t he writer what you see as the central claims, point out areas that lack clarity,
and ask questions to help them refine their thinking.
What is the thesis? Is it clear, non-obvious, and arguable? Explain why it is or is not working. Offer
potential additions if it needs to be more arguable or specific.
What are the main points that the writer addresses in the essay? Are there logical connections between
them? What are some strengths of this essay? Areas for improvement? Are there ways to look at the texts
they haven’t considered? Pose at least two questions to the writer.
Missed Opportunities: What other ideas, quotes, or references might the writer incorporate into their
essay? Where have they missed a rebuttal or alternate interpretation that should be addressed? Are there
additional questions that the essay brings up that need to be addressed, or implications that should be
discussed?