Typical Image Selection
Jennifer Lin, James Gajnak,
Robert F. Murphy
Cytometry Development Workshop 2000
Background
Fluorescence microscopy is commonly used
for digital image collection
Current analysis on such images is done by
visual inspection which is not quantitative,
and not feasible for large data sets
We have been working on the automated and
objective interpretation of fluorescence
images
Previous work
Typical Image Chooser (TypIC) – method for
ranking a set of images in order of typicality
using Haralick texture features to describe
images
TypIC1
Uses
only 13 texture features to describe
images
Uses robust estimation of mean and
covariance matrix to eliminate outliers
Requires a minimum of 35 images
TypIC2
Principal components allow the use of more
features without requiring an extremely large
number of images
•
Collapses feature set into a smaller number of
dimensions
Robust or non-robust estimations of mean
and covariance matrix also reduces the
number of images needed
•
Non robust estimations assumes there are no
outliers
Results
Compare
Results
TypIC2 with TypIC1
for mixed sets
Stability of rankings for sets of decreasing
size
Mixed Sets
Assembled
a biased test set of images
from five classes: zero time (30), 10 min
(25), 30 min (20), 60 min (15), basal (10)
Hypothetically images from the largest
(most biased) classes will be ranked as
the most typical
Results – TypIC1
Correlation
coefficient: -0.52708
TypIC1 with 13 Haralick Features (Robust)
Typicality
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
0
1
2
3
Protein Class
4
5
6
Results – TypIC2
Correlation coefficients for varying numbers
of principal components (PC):
Num. of PC
Cor. Coeff.
1
-0.37177
2
-0.30753
3
-0.30598
4
-0.25877
5
-0.28973
Results – TypIC2
Correlation
coefficient: -0.37177
TypIC2 with 1 Principal Component (Robust)
Typicality
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
0
1
2
3
Protein Class
4
5
6
Results - Mixed Sets
TypIC2
performs best with only 1
principal component (2 and 3 similar)
TypIC1 is better at distinguishing
between the protein classes than
TypIC2
Results - Set Size
Use
ten classes of images
Rank full set with various methods
Rank subsets of decreasing size
Measure correlation between rankings
Results - Set Size