CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, NORTHRIDGE STABILIZING THE ECONOMIC BASE OF PALMDALE, CALIFORNIA AN APPLIED ECONOMIC GEOGRAPHY STUDY A thesis submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in Geography by LaMoyne Berger Kinzell May, 1982 The Thesis of LaMoyne Berger Kinzell is approved: Chairman California State University, Northridge ii To my mother ;;; ACKNOvJLEDG~1ENTS This thesis would not have been written without the encouragement and assistance of a number of individuals. r~y thanks to the research librarians of the Palmdale City Library and Los Angeles County Public Library in Lancaster for their assistance in finding historical and statistical works; to Diane Hamill, my real estate agent-friend, who guided me through the complexities of real estate information; and to the numerous public agencies of Palmdale and Lancaster who shared their reports and statistics with me. ~1y gratitude and love to my long-suffering family as I struggled with the compiling of statistics and writing of this thesis: my hus- band, Les, for proofreading and endless encouragement; my children, Yvette, Anitra, and Antony, for assisting me with the field surveys. A special acknowledgment is due my advisor, Or. David Hornbeck. His guidance, advice, encouragement and good humor have been invaluable. iv Table of Contents iii Dedication Acknowledgments iv List of Tables vii List of Figures xi List of xii ~1aps xiii Abstract Chapter I Introduction 1 Scope and Study Area Methodology and Data Literature Review Organization Chapter II Population and Commercial Development Early Development: Growth Period: Chapter III 1884-1951 1950-1980 Population and Occupations 25 Summary Chapter IV Economic Base and Transportation 44 Economic Base Transportation Patterns Fiscal Structure Summary Chapter V Future Growth Trends 72 Population, Housing and Employment Trends Expansion Plans and Employee Skill Requirements v @ . Summary Chapter VI Residential and Commercial Land Use 93 Proposed Land Use Potential Land Use Chapter VII Conclusion 112 Bibliography 117 Appendix A 124 Appendix B 125 Appendix C 130 vi List of Tables 2-1 Service and Retail Activities 15 Palmdale - 1930 3-1 Population Changes of Antelope Valley Communities - 26 1975 to 1980 3-2 Population Growth - 1970 to 1980 27 Palmdale-Lancaster Areas 3-3 28 Years of Residence Palmdale, Lancaster, Antelope Valley 3-4 Housing Unit Growth - 1970 to 1980 30 Palmdale-Lancaster Areas 3-5 30 Type of Housing - 1980 Palmdale, Lancaster, Antelope Valley 3-6 Residential Building Permits 31 Palmdale - 1970 to 1980 3-7 Age Structure of Adult Population - 1980 32 Palmdale, Lancaster, Antelope Valley 3-8 35 Education Levels - 1980 Palmdale, Lancaster, Antelope Valley Residents 3-9 Occupational Type Profile - 1980 36 Palmdale-Lancaster 3-10 38 Place of Work - 1980 Palmdale, Lancaster, Antelope Valley 3-11 Local Shopping Area - 1980 Palmdale-Lancaster vii 38 3-12 Shopping Trip Frequency - 1980 39 Palmdale-Lancaster 3-13 Merchandise Types - 1980 40 Palmdale, Lancaster, Antelope Valley 4-1 Agriculture Production - 1960 to 1978 46 Los Angeles Portion of Antelope Valley 4-2 Aviation Activities - 1979 49 Antelope Valley 4-3 Employment by Industry - 1959 to 1977 50 Palmdale-Lancaster Labor Market Area 4-4 Percent Employment by Industry - 1980 53 Palmdale, Lancaster, Antelope Valley 4-5 Employment Distribution by Industry - 1980 55 Antelope Valley 4-6 Number of Employees by Percent Employers - 1980 54 Palmdale, Lancaster, Antelope Valley 4-7 Distribution of Firms by Annual Payroll - 1980 56 Palmdale-Lancaster 4-8 Percent of Payroll Paid to Employees Residing Outside 57 City of Employment - 1980 Palmdale-Lancaster 4-9 Average Daily Traffic California State Highways - 60 1970 to 1979 4-10 24-Hour Traffic Volumes on Selected County and City 62 Roads - 1965 to 1980 4-11 Financial Institution Activity - 1975 to 1979 Palmdale-Lancaster viii 66 4-12 Growth of Tax Revenues - 1964 to 1980 67 Palmdale 5-1 Population Trends and Forecast 73 Palmdale, Sphere of Influence, Antelope Valley 1970 to 1990 5-2 Housing Trends and Forecast 75 Palmdale, Sphere of Influence, Antelope Valley 1970 to 1990 5-3 Employment Growth Trends 76 Palmdale-Lancaster Labor Market Area - 1959 to 1980 5-4 Employment Growth by Industry 78 Antelope Valley - 1980 to 1985 5-5 Business Employment Growth by Industry 79 Palmdale - 1980 to 1985 5-6 Planned Expansion of Existing Firms 81 Antelope Valley - 1981 5-7 Employee Skills Needed by Employers 82 Palmdale, Lancaster, Antelope Valley 5-8 Employee Skill Needs by Industry Group 83 Antelope Valley 5-9 Employee Skills Needed by Industry Group 84 Palmdale 5-10 Business Generated Passenger Air Travel by Airport 85 of Origin 5-11 Air Freight Service Demand - 1980 86 5-12 Frequency of Air Freight Use by Industry 88 ix 5-13 Number of Business Trips Requiring Air Transportation 89 by Industry - 1980 5-14 Percentage of Yearly Production Shipped by Air Freight 90 Users - 1980 6-1 Single-Family Housing 95 Palmdale - 1980 to 1981 6-2 Multi-Family Housing 97 Palmdale - 1980 to 1981 6-3 Residential Growth Areas 98 Palmdale - 1980 to 1981 6-4 102 Traffic Volume - 1981 Palmdale 6-5 Public Transportation Schedule - 1981 104 Palmdale 6-6 Potential Growth Area Zoning 105 Retail and Service Activities 6-7 Potential Growth Area Zoning Manufacturing X 109 List of Figures Fig. 2-1 Population Trend of Palmdale From 1900 to 1980 14 3-1 Income Distribution - 1980 34 Palmdale, Lancaster, Antelope Valley 3-2 Employment Profile - 1980 37 Palmdale, Lancaster, Antelope Valley 4-1 Antelope Valley Trends - 1965 to 1980 70 5-1 Population Growth - 1970 to 1990 74 xi List of Maps 1 Antelope Valley Topography 3 2 Study Area 4 3 Pioneer Towns and Roads 11 4 New Palmdale, 1892 13 5 Palmdale Airport and Plant 42 17 6 Commercial Expansion 18 Palmdale, 1950 - 1980 7 Palmdale Zoning Map 8 The Commercial Structure of Palmdale - 1980 20 130 Appendix C Residential Areas of Palmdale 29 10 Antelope Valley Aerospace Bases 48 11 Antelope Valley Traffic Volume - 1979 59 12 Palmdale Traffic Volume - 1979 64 13 Palmdale Residential Expansion 94 9 1980 - 1981 14 Proposed Commercial Areas 15 Palmdale Traffic Volume and Flow - 16 Potential Commercial and Industrial Areas xii 100 1981 103 106 ABSTRACT STABILIZING THE ECONOMIC BASE OF PAU~DALE, CALIFORNIA AN APPLIED ECONOMIC GEOGRAPHY STUDY Geography by Lal1oyne Berger Kinzell This thesis investigates the types of commercial and industrial activities that would best expand and stabilize the economic base of Palmdale and the surrounding region. There are two objectives. The first is an economic assessment of Palmdale revealing the city's current economic picture. The second formulates a land-use plan for Palmdale and develops forecasts of population and employment growth. Multiple data sources w~re utilized. Data on the economic char- acteristics of Antelope Valley and Palmdale were accumulated from government documents and survey questionnaires of households and employers. By cross tabulation and frequency distribution of data, the economic base of the Valley and Palmdale was determined. Physical sur- veys were conducted of the commercial-industrial activities, residential areas and traffic volume of Palmdale. xiii These data were coded, tab- ulated and mapped giving the current land-use picture of the city. Historical profiles combined with the household and employer survey results developep forecasts of population and employment growth. Data present a current picture of Palmdale as the manufacturing center of the Valley with a dramatic population growth in the last decade. Analysis indicates Palmdale has not kept pace with population growth in housing and retail-service activities. Projections indicate major expansion in population and employment for Antelope Valley and Palmdale over the next decade which will create demands for additional retail-service activities. Commercial, manufacturing and residential expansion zones are proposed in an effort to expand and stabilize Palmdale's economic base. Regional planning by the Valley's two leading cities, Palmdale and Lancaster, is suggested as a method of stabilizing Palmdale's economic base. With regional planning, Palmdale could expand manufacturing and develop these retail and service businesses which would best serve the local needs. xiv CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION Antelope Valley and its communities have been economically bypassed in the past. Historically, the Valley's economic growth has depended upon two principal industries, agriculture and aerospace. Cyclical activity in these industries has resulted in a notable economic lag. However, over the past ten years, the region has become more urbanized and economically diversified, leading to a reasonably stable population and economic growth rate. In recent years local officials and business groups of Palmdale have made impressive strides in the promotion and development of the community's commercial and industrial facilities. The completion of a new freeway linking Los Angeles with the Valley since 1973 has been the main focal point of this development. An indepth study of this rapidly expanding area is needed at this time. The future economic growth of Antelope Valley and Palmdale, in particular, is directly related to the expansion of existing industries, the development of new businesses, and the influx of population. The purpose of this thesis is to investigate the types of commercial and industrial activities that would best expand and stabilize the economic base of Palmdale and the surrounding region. Scope and Study Area Antelope Valley, a 2500 square mile agriculture and industrial region, is situated an hour's drive northeast of metropolitan Los Angeles. Roughly triangular in shape, this high desert plain is 1 2 bounded by the San Gabriel Mountain range to the south, the Tehachapi Mountains ranging to the north and west, and desert buttes on the east (Map 1). Palmdale, a city of approximately 12,000 people, is located near the southern boundary of the Valley. The incorporated city of Palmdale cannot be studied as a separate entity. It must be regarded as a vital and expanding community of Antelope Valley as a whole. Therefore, although Palmdale is the focal point of this study, its sphere of influence 1 is much greater than its boundaries indicate (Map 2). The study area includes all commercial and industrial activities within the incorporated boundaries of Palmdale. These boundaries are Avenues M and S on the north and south respectively and transversely lOth Street on the west and 40th Street to the east. Comparative studies of the Valley as a whole have also been conducted regarding the economic and population development. Temporally, the study encompasses the years 1960 to 1980. Methodology and Data This thesis has two objectives. The first is an economic assessment of Palmdale to reveal the city's current economic picture. Multiple data sources have been used. Material on population, employ- ment, housing, tax revenue, education and transportation have been gathered from government documents. Analyzed and evaluated, these data indicate the economic characteristics of Antelope Valley and Palmdale during the time period of 1960 to 1980. Data have been accumulated based on surveys of households and employers. Household data have been generated by Stratified Random Digit Dialing. 2 This technique has been utilized by the Los Angeles County Planning Group and designed to represent the total Antelope 3 Map 1: TOPOGRAPHY OF ANTELOPE VALLEY Jill 1/ LOS ANGELES ,,J PACIFIC OCEAN DESERT lE~}0/~~ DRYLAKES ~ MOUNTAINS IDII!IIIIID 15 4 Map 2: STUDY AREA 395 ··~ LOS ANGELES PACIFIC OCEAN Palmdale Sphere of Influence Total Study Area •- SOURCE: Antelope Valley Board of Trade, 1980 Antelope Valley Progress California City . ' 5 Valley and Palmdale's sphere of influence. In examining the economic base of Antelope Valley, the delineation of business groups is necessary. Since the basic sources of em- ployment and income in an urban economy are many and varied, businesses have been grouped and mapped according to retail trade, retail service, construction, producers, manufacturers and wholesalers, health and public utility services, and government service. 3 The economic base of the Valley is arrived at by cross tabulation and frequency distribution of the proportion of basic employment to service employment.4 The second objective is to formulate a land-use plan for Palmdale and develop forecasts of population and employment growth. A physical survey of all commercial activity has been conducted and these data have been coded and mapped according to the Standard Land Use Coding Manua1. 5 Physical surveys of current housing expansion and traffic volume and flow at key intersections have also been conducted. Data accumulated from these surveys has been tabulated and mapped. 6 These survey data have been utilized in developing a patential commercial and industrial land-use plan. An employer survey has been conducted by a San Francisco-based research firm to generate both the current and future population and employment growth within the Valley. 7 Historical profiles with the survey results and economic models 8 are used to develop the forecasts. Literature Review Antelope Valley and its communities have had a long, colorful and interesting history. As is typical of many California areas, gold and the railroad have played important parts in this history. 9 Commu- 6 nities, established originally because of their proximity to the railroad, have experienced an unsteady economic growth. The region, pri- marily agriculture, has gradually altered its economic base. Develop- ing first a thriving aerospace industry, the region presently is moving toward increased commercial and industrial diversification. 10 Examination of a community's economic characteristics and its historical patterns is necessary in the attainment of optimum locating of commercial and industrial activities. One tool employed in analyz- ing the economic background of a community as well as in forecasting the future is economic base theory, developed by Homer Hoyt. This theory identifies the base activities of a community as those which export goods, services and capital to locations outside the economic limits of the community. Thus, a community's residentiary employment, income and population can be explained and predicted by reference to employment in its basic activities. 11 A second tool, economic rent theory, provides a basis for the evaluation of individual business locations. In evaluating locations it takes into consideration accessibility, competition, customer distribution and commercial trade area. Also having their roots in the rent theory are business conformations involving accessibility and the functional roles of these businesses. 12 Associated with this theory in locating commercial activities is an understanding of consumer beEthnic background, income, age and store preference perform a role in developing the consumer's behavior. 13 havior. Organization This thesis is presented in six chapters. Following the intro- duction chapter, Chapter II establishes the geographic and historical 7 population and economic background of Palmdale as it has grown from a primarily rural community to a more autonomous, urbanized city. also describes Palmdale's present commercial structure. It Chapter III investigates the demography, population and shopping patterns of Palmdale historically and currently. Comparative studies of Antelope Valley are given delineating Palmdale's influence in the Valley. The current economy and economic base of the Valley and Palmdale are the subjects of Chapter IV. This chapter assesses the region's economic base providing a basis for formulating future economic growth and development. Chapter V projects into the future, forecasting growth trends in population, housing and employment. The final chapter de- velops land-use strategies in the Palmdale area, utilizing the current commercial structure and projected growth trends. Footnotes 1sphere of influence is defined as the geographical area that identifies with a given major city in terms of employment, shopping and services. 2For further discussion of Stratified Random Digit Dialing see Appendix A. 3Field survey and mapping of commercial activities by author. 4An indepth discussion of the steps used to establish a community's economic base can be found in: Ralph 1~. Pfouts, editor, The Techniques of Urban Economic Analysis (West Trenton, New Jersey--:-Chandler-Davis Publishing Company, 1960). 5The Standard Land Use Coding Manual provides each type of commerical activity with a specific category. These categories can then be coded to yield a map providing a simplified overview of the entire land-use pattern and structure. 6Field surveys and mapping by author. 7Discussion of the Employer Survey can be found in Appendix A. 8Ralph W. Pfouts, editor, The Techni ues of Urban Economic Analysis (Hest Trenton, New Jersey, 1960 23-38.'" 9Historical background on Antelope Valley can be found in: Adabelle Cogswell, Tiburcio Vasquez: Il Bandido sin~ (Volcano and Pioneer, California, 1974); 50th Anniversary Edition: 1886-1936 Antebope Valley Ledger-Gazette (Lancaster, California, 1936); Shelton J. Gordon, Incredible Tales of the Antelope Valley Pioneers (Palmdale, California, 1973); Domenic Massari, Autobiography of Domenic, 18931977 (Palmdale, California, 1977); Lucie Morris, The Histor of the Town of Lancaster, Center of Antelope Valley, California M.A--.Thesis, Department of History, University of Southern California, 1934); Glen A. Settle, Along the Rails from Lancaster to Mojave (Lancaster, California, 1967); Glen A. Settle, The Antelope Left and the Settleers Came (Rosamond, California, 1975); Glen A. Settle, Tropico: Red Hill with~ Glamorous History of Gold (Rosamond, California, 1959); Richard Boblett Starr, A History of Antelope Valley from 1542 to 1920 (M.A. Thesis, Department of History, University of Southern California, 1938). 11 11 , 8 9 10 Information concerning Antelope Valley's economic progress and transition can be found in: Antelope Valley Board of Trade, 1980 Antelope Valley Progress Documentary (Lancaster, California, 1980): 1-27; 11 A Story of Achievement and Transition - 1930 Progress Edition 11 , Antelope Valley Ledaer-Gazette (Lancaster, California, 1930); City of Palmdale and Chamber of Commerce, Communit Economic Profile for Palmdale, Los Angeles County, California September, 1977); .. Greater Antelope Valley Edition .. , Antelope Valley Ledger-Gazette (Lancaster, California, 1941); Lancaster Chamber of Commerce, Communit Economic Profile for Lancaster, Los Angeles County, California 1975); Palmdale Chamber of Commerce, Communit Economic Profile for Palmdale, Los Angeles County, California January 1971); Southern California-rdison Company, The Antelope Valley: An Area Inventory (1961}, 11 Roger K. Chisholm and Gilbert R. Whitaker, Jr., Forecasting Methods (Homewood, Illinois, 1971): 8-15, 41-50, 51-56; William L. Henderson, Larry C. Ledebur, Urban Economics: Processes and Problems (New York, London, Sydney, Toronto, 1972): 3-9; Ralph W. Pfouts, editor, The Techniques of Urban Economic Analysis (West Trenton, New Jersey, 1960) . 12 william Applebaum, Saul B. Cohen, 11 The Dynamics of Store Trading Areas and Market Equilibrium 11 , Annals, Association of American Geographers, 51 (March, 1961): 73-101; Brian J, L. Berry, 11 Ribbon Developments in the Urban Business Pattern 11 , Annals, Association of American Geographers, 49 (June, 1959): 145-155; F. W. Baal and D. B. Johnson, 11 The Functions of Retail and Service Establishments on Commercial Ribbons, Canadian Geographer, 9 (1965): 1-35; John A. Dawson, John C. Doornkamp, Evaluating the Human Environment (London, 1973): 99-156; Bart J. Epstein, 11 Geography and the Business of Retail Site Evaluation and Selection Economic Geography, 47 (April, 1971): 192199; Curt Kornblau, editor, Guide to Store Location Research (Reading, r~ass., 1968): 25-98; Jack C. Ransome, The Organization of Location Research in a Large Supermarket Chain 11 , Economic Geography, 37 (January, 1961): 42-47; Paul H. Sisco, Geographic Training and Method Applied to Trade Area Analysis of Local Shopping Centers Journal of Geography, 54 (May, 1957) : 201-212. 11 , 11 11 11 , 13 Jessie Bernard, American Community Behavior (New York, 1949); Martin Cadwaller, '1A Behavioral Hodel of Consumer Spatial Decision Making 11 , Economic Geography, (October, 1975): 339-349; ~J. A. V. Clark and Gerard Rushton, 11 Models of Intra-Urban Consumer Behavior and Their Implications for Central Place Theory 11 , Economic Geography, 46 (July, 1970): 486-497; Keith Harries, Ethnic Variations in Los Angeles Business Patterns 11 , Annals, Association of American Geographers, 61 (December, 1971): 736-743; Eugene VanCleef, 11 Things Are Not Always What They Seem for the Economic Geographer .. , Economic Geography, 45 (January, 1969): 41-44, 11 CHAPTER II POPULATION AND Cm1~1ERCIAL Early Development: DEVELOPMENT 1884-1951 About 1870, so the legend goes, covered wagons containing German and Swiss families moved westward from Illinois and Nebraska toward Los Angeles. They had been told that when they saw palm trees the Pacific Ocean would be near. The travelers arrived in Antelope Valley and, seeing the Joshua trees, 1 mistakenly thought they were the palm trees spoken of by others. Consequently the families settled in the area, naming the new colony Palmdale. A thriving community was formed inland from the Southern Pacific Railroad in 1876, The site was approximately two miles east of the present location of central Palmdale on what is now Avenue R. The ' settlers developed farms of alfalfa, fruit orchards, vineyards and livestock. The village consisted of a livery stable, blacksmith, shoe shop, mercantile store, school, church, post office and a land office. It also was a stagecoach stop for the Butterfield Stage Lines, carrying freight, bullion and passengers between San Bernardino and Bakersfield (Map 3). In 1892, the Palmdale Colony site was abandoned and New Palmdale, a community of less than 250 inhabitants, was established nearer the railroad line. Two factors contributed to the abandonment, a lack of water and the inability to obtain deeds for land already boutht. The new site was laid out by the railroad agent from Harold settlement 2 10 Map-3:.PIONEER COLONIES ~ Wicks 1883 John Brown No.2 1888 Manzana 1891 LANCASTER Fairmont 1890 - 1884 John Brown No.1 1888 Scale 0 5 10 Miles + Llano 1890 & 1914 N SOURCE: Antelope Valley Ledger· Gazette, 1936. --' --' . ,, ' 12 using the then existing Southern Pacific Railway depot as the focal point. 3 The community's boundaries were approximately Avenues Q-6 and Q-9 to the north and south respectively, lOth Street to the east and the railroad line and Mint Canyon Road to the west. Mint Canyon Road, later named Sierra Highway, followed the railroad line through the Valley to Los Angeles. Pear orchards, vineyards and livestock ranches surrounded the community to the east and west. Hater for agricultural and community needs was obtained from Littlerock Creek via a ditch and reservoir completed in 1897 (Map 4). Population, an essential factor in economic growth, during the early 1900's exhibited a slow, gradual increase (Fig. 2-1). Agricul- ture formed the economic base of the community with the railroad as the major employer. Palmdale's commercial picture, although not static, followed population growth in a gradual increase until the 1940's. Service and commercial activities, in 1892, consisted of a school, post office, blacksmith, church, grocery store and the railway depot. By the 1930's this picture had expanded to a total of 27 activ- ities (Table 2-1). During this period Palmdale inhabitants began to form a shopping pattern which has endured to the present time. Mer- chandise deficiencies apparently forced the people to travel to Lancaster, San Fernando, Pasadena and Los Angeles. enced this shopping pattern: (l) ~1int Two factors influ- Canyon Road, the main artery from the Valley to San Fernando and Los Angeles, was paved and renamed Sierra Highway, expediting travel; and, (2) Palmdale, lacking a banking institution, used the nearest facilities located in Lancaster. Shopping trips to Lancaster, combined with banking, became the natural pattern. 13 ' -\ ~ - Map 4: NEW PALMDALE 1892 ~ - -_,_ - - 0-6 ui1 0-6 Pos~Q Office ~ I "' 0:: - s'r -_o -E. ""\ ~-~0 School ~· 0-7 Gro~ervo ~ J5 Shop ~ ci5 _s:;: Depot 0-9 0Blacksmith -- r0 ~ z--\ Inn zm ~ ~ ~ ("") ")> z - --\ ("") ")> z -< 0 z :::0 0 ")> 0 z -< -~ - 0 z :::0 0 -~ ")> 0 ""I"" -r- - SCALE 0 % Miles ~ N -t- -r PALMDALE BLVD. P"lmdale 050 -~ 0 Church 0 ' 0-9 14 Fig. 2-1: POPULATION TREND OF PALMDALE FROM 1900 to 1980 10,500 10,000 9500 I 9000 I I( 8500 8000 7500 7000 6500 6000 I 5500 I I I I I ,I 5000 4500 4000 3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 ...,_ 500 v ,) ,I J 0 1900 1910 1920 1930 1940 YEARS 1950 1960 1970 1980 15 SERVICE AND RETAIL ACTIVITIES Palmdale - 1930 Table 2-1 SERVICES RETAIL Barber Shop Grocery Store Schools (2) Hotel (2) Blacksmith Restaurant (3) Service Station (2) Auto Agency (2) Post Office Drugstore Church r.1ercant i 1e Store Telephone Office Ice Cream Parlor Railway Depot Hardware Store Motel (2) Bar and Poolroom Dance Hall Newspaper Activity types found in Palmdale in 1930 Sources: 16 In the 1940's and 50's the gradual transition from an agrarian to an industrial economy began. The first runway of the Palmdale Air- port was built for the city in 1940 by the Works Progress Administration (WPA). 4 During the following two decades the airport and its land passed from city ownership to Los Angeles County and finally to the Federal Government. 5 The airport terminal was enlarged, adding runways, and the first large industry, aircraft, entered the Valley. Plant 42 was created as a facility to augment industrial production of prime aircraft contractors in the Los Angeles area (Map 5). 6 With the arrival of the aircraft industry, population and business began an upward trend (Fig. 2-1). Growth Period: 1950-1980 The commercial development of Palmdale began in the 1950's with the arrival of large industries and population. Residences, mainly single-family dwellings, were constructed in three distinct areas, Desert View Highlands to the west, Palmdale, and Palmdale East (~1ap 6). 7 With residential areas established and gradually expanding, the number of retail, service and industrial activities began to increase. The business nucleus 8 of the community remained, with new businesses developing along the two main arterial highways, north-south Sierra Highway and east-west Palmdale Boulevard (Highway 138). 9 A variety of establishments lined these arteries becoming the first step in the commercial ribbon development 10 of Palmdale (Map 6). Following the initial development in the early 1950's, urban arterial business areas 11 and nucleated shopping centers 12 appeared. Expansion of single-purpose-trip establishments 13 occurred along Sierra Highway. Sixth Street East, lying parallel to the railroad, became a combina- Map 5:PALMDALE AIRPORT- PLANT 42 w w (J) (J) ... ui ..: (J) ..: ... .s::. .s::. 0 0 M ""' / / Avenue N ' N I ui ..: D-~ 0 LOCKHEED L-1011 (J) £ f6 ---- __, _/ Avenue 0 0 % Mi~ Avenue P __, '-J ., Map 6:COMMERCIAL - SCHOOL DEVELOPEMENT 1950 - 1980 1----- A""'"·-----1t-~~;:---------tr==,.,---t------1r-----------~1-----------_jl-------J t ~ /~/ / I/DESERT VIEW HIGHLANDS I L F.lit~heth I t~lu•Rnnrt· I 1 I I I - Av'""''rn -----11 t-----i,_.b,.......,....,,...""''M'-rr!::-::!!-+-----=~=,...,=-=,....==-="":=,.._,=-==-=,....,="""'===""'=,l,=-=,....==-==-=.,1 ------~-----------PALMDALE EAST PALM DALE L-J D ~-·~-~ 10 '"".r, COMERCIAL AREAS: Prior to 1950 ~ ~ 1950- 1960 E~~2~22l 1960-- 1970 1970- 1980 i!t l'l'l't 1 1,1,1,1 k>.· ..l PROPER .. v SCHOOLS: Priorto1950 ~ ~ 1950 1960 ~ 1960 ··- 1970 ~ Will ---+- i--A••""'"_u.._._ _._ _"""il-"""'~f'l!tl"j~4f'II--------F'-"=..d!JW";.&;..O~!'i.:lli:i:OL------J-------~ 1'1'1 l!t\t \0 \ I ___ I N W+E { s """'""'""" 0 '/,Mile ~ 00 ·-- -19 tion of light manufacturing and service activities. Accessibility to rail transportation was the leading factor in the growth of this street. Nucleated business centers were constructed in Palmdale East and Palmdale proper (Map 6), These centers emerged where the largest number of customers could be served in close proximity. Each were clusters of grocery stores, variety and clothing stores, drugstores, . 1ty s hops. The con. 1 serv1ces . 14 , an d spec1a persona 1 an d pro f ess1ona struction of five schools, four public and one parochial, in the late 1950's was an indicator of population growth (Map 6). Although Palmdale experienced cyclical periods due to the vagaries of the aircraft industry, the effect was minimal on the general upward trend of population and commercial endeavors (Fig. 2-1). Additionally, three public schools were constructed to accommodate the increasing population during the 1960's. 1962. The city was incorporated in Incorporation required zoning, thus presenting the first step toward a planned community (Map 7). However, a concentrated effort in city planning was not initiated until 1970 when a Planning Commission was created. The construction of the Southern Pacific Railroad's CUt-off route between Palmdale and Colton 15 to the east in 1967 and the completion of the Antelope Valley Freeway 16 in 1973 alleviated 11 11 many transportation problems of local industries. With improved transportation, commercial and industrial expansion was encouraged. The era 1960 to 1980 was a period of rapid expansion in population and commercial activities throughout the Valley, especially noticeable in Palmdale and Lancaster. Increasing travel on the free- way and Highway 138 created the need for activities requiring large sites and ready accessibility. As in Berry's studies, highway-oriented 20 ~LM ' ...,..__......,...-i!-t-----~...,..--Map m m ~ ~ r 7: PALMDALE ZONING MAP L ~ ~ ;; -< :=m -< C-3 M-A PJ---A--2--S--' ~ Ave. 0 ' Ave. P MPO ~(RP0- SPB M-2 12U -, H C-3 r--+---u.v ~ R-1 Ldo R-1 CPO w m CPO C-3 ~ .,LV R-1 I _m .. w ~ ~ "'m "'m ~ ?!? m C-2 ~ ~ I ~ ~~ .- ,,~~ I ~ \ ~ ~R-3 11Jl~L~p;;t~::r:~==~::j:::::::~PA~LM~O!All~ETB~L~V~O~--t---------i ~ C-3 • ib1 t~R3 ~L R-;-- R-3 t\:-7- rf RPO-+ Ave.R 2 E J ~·21PO 1 R-1 R-1 RP0-12U fr ~ Ave. S ~.u- C3 I~ r-k- 2 m~~~~~~~--~~---R~-3~----~C~-3~g~po~-~12~U--~-----~~R-.-3-+---+--~~~--f ~ Lr .1'1) 3 ' - - - - ; - . r - - j S ( ' --.., -..,. .___A_-_'-, 1 A-2-5 1 / R-1 R·U 1 1"- MPD m LEGEND COMMERCIAL ZONES MANUFACTURING AND INDUSTRIAL ZONES C-1: Ne•ghborhood \11-1: Light C-2: Light M-2: Medium C-3: Medium M-A: Aircraft CPO: Planned Development MPO: Planned Developmenr RESIDENTIAL ZONES AGRICULTURAL ZONES R-1: Single Family A-1: Light R-2: Low Dens1tv MultiPle A-2: Heavy R-3: Medium Dens•tv Multiple RPO: Planned Development SCALE OTHER ZONES 0 SPD: Parking and Buffer S·R: Recreauon 2000 Feet 1000 3000 N 21 ribbons emerged, especially to the east and west of the freeway on Palmdale Boulevard. Specialized functional areas developed; Palmdale•s medical center on Avenue S and the automobile agencies, new and used, lining Sierra Highway between Palmdale and Lancaster. As the population increased, neighborhood shopping centers entered the picture. redevelopment. Older business centers underwent renewal and Notable in this case were the beginnings of total re- newal of the original business nucleus of Palmdale, Avenues Q-6 to Q-9, and remodeling plus expansion of the centers in Palmdale proper and Palmdale East, Sections of the central business district had degener- ated to a slum condition, especially along Sierra Highway from Palmdale Boulevard to Avenue Q-9. the late l970•s. Removal of structures in this area began in City governmental and cultural services 17 were newly constructed in this central node of Palmdale. A third nucleated shop- ping center was developed in the early l970 1 s between Division Street and Third Street East on Palmdale Boulevard to meet the needs of customers in the western section of Palmdale, especially Desert View Highlands. This time span also witnessed the expansion of service and retail activities along the urban arterials, joining with and ranging beyond the nucleated centers. Two industrial parks were erected, Fox Industrial Park in the early 1970 s on Sixth Street East south of Avenue R and Palmdale 1 Industrial Park on 20th Street East north of Avenue Q in the late 197o•s. Industrial parks are a fairly recent innovation. They are designed to accommodate light manufacturing industries and minimize transportation problems, these functions. Both parks were constructed to fulfill However, the earlier park, Fox, is the only one 22 which meets this functional idea. It is composed entirely of light manufacturing industries and has ready access to both railway and truck transportation. The location of Palmdale Industrial Park is based on the future development of the Palmdale International Airport. Since transportation is not readily accessible, the park has become service oriented. Nevertheless, spotty development of aircraft-relat- ed industries have occurred in areas of close proximity to the existing airport and Lockheed's large facility. A visual description of the contemporary commercial structure of Palmdale is shown on Map 8 (Appendix C). The economic and social well-being of a community is influenced by the number of wage-earners, their qualifications, employment and income. Chapter III will review the population and demography of the study area. Footnotes 1The Joshua tree (Yucca brevifolia) is the largest member of the narrow-leaf yuccas. The plant attains a height of forty or more feet, developing many branches with overlapping, long, spiny leaves. It blooms from March to May, exhibiting large tight clusters of lilylike blossoms at the tips of the branches. It is restricted in its range to the Mojave-Colorado Desert, of which it is the principal indicator. 2Harold was a Southern Pacific Railway depot, approximately three miles south of present day Palmdale Boulevard. Complete with a telegraph agent, it was a link on the railroad between Lancaster and Acton. Dr. Michael, the agent-planner of New Palmdale, moved the entire community of Harold to the new location. 3 The Palmdale railway depot was the main passenger and freight depot for Antelope Valley. The depot and freight offices were removed in 1969. 4The original runway of Palmdale Airport was used by commercial airlines whenever the Los Angeles airports were fogged in. Passengers were then taken by bus to Los Angeles. 5The Air Force, in 1951, negotiated with Los Angeles County to purchase the Palmdale Airport lands. Their motive was to have a facility that would assure the continued delivery of jet aircraft production in the Los Angeles area. 6Plant 42 was developed by Lockheed, a leading aircraft manufacturer. It housed Lockheed, North American, Northrop and Convair. The main purpose of the plant was the testing, inspection, rehabilitation and storage of Air Force and aircraft industrial equipment. 7The number of housing units in each area is not indicated on Map 6, only the area. This was not a static period; on the contrary, it was extremely dynamic. 8Avenue Q-6 to Q-9 and Sierra Highway to lOth Street East. 9Highway 138 is the main state highway linking San Bernardino with Bakersfield. 10 oetailed discussion of commercial ribbon development can be found in: Brian J. L. Berry, 11 Ribbon Developments in the Urban Busi23 24 ness Pattern 11 , Annals, Association of American Geographers, 49 (June, 1959): 145-155; Brian J. L. Berry, Edgar C. Conkling, D. Hichael Ray, The Geography of Economic Systems (Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey, 1976); F. W. Baal and D. B. Johnson, "The Functions of Retail and Service Establishments on Commercial Ribbons 11 , Canadian Geographer, IX (1965): 154-196; Ross L. Davies, Marketing Geography {London, 1976): 117-156. 11 urban arterial businesses are those which seek out urban areas but are more successful along arterial highways, such as auto repair shops, printing services, second-hand stores, bars, pawn shops, and hotels. 12 Nucleated shopping centers are located centrally with respect to their trade area. They represent the neighborhood and community shopping center. Centers are closely or widely spaced in accordance to the available purchasing power. 13 single-purpose-trip establishments are those which require large, expansive sites and ready accessibility. Motels, restaurants, service stations, household suppliers and repair facilities require such sites. 14 Personal services are represented by barber and beauty shops, laundering and dry cleaning establishments, etc. Professional services are medical and legal services, insurance agencies, banks, etc. 15 The Colton Cut-off is a 78-mile link between Palmdale and Colton. It provides a shortcut for freight shipped from the northwest to the east, eliminating the passage through the Los Angeles yard, thus saving hours and, in some cases, days for transcontinental shipments. 16The freeway links Antelope Valley to the los Angeles metropolitan center via the Golden State, San Diego and Hollywood freeways. The first segment from the Golden State Freeway to Acton was completed in 1963, the remaining segment to Mojave in 1973. 17 city Hall, City Engineers, the Planning Commission and the Chamber of Commerce compose the governmental services. The Culture Center is comprised of the library, theater, gymnasium and meeting rooms for civic organizations. CHAPTER III POPULATION AND OCCUPATIONS The composition and characteristics of population are paramount in the study of land-use in an area undergoing economic diversification. The description of the current status and changes over time in the size, density and composition of a population is an indicator of the economic and social stability of an area. Antelope Valley's total population in 1980 is approximately 175,000, an increase of 23 percent over 134,750. th~ 1970 population of Compared to Los Angeles County's growth of 2.5 percent for the same period, the growth of the Valley has been quite dramatic. Growth of the communities comprising Antelope Valley from 1975 to 1980 is presented in Table 3-1. The greatest density of population in Antelope Valley is located in four areas, China Lake-Ridgecrest, Edwards, Lancaster and Palmdale. Although the first two areas are military installations, they contribute to the economic base of the Valley. Palmdale and Lancaster, as well as their spheres of influence, experienced a greater percentage population growth than the entire region between 1970 and 1980 (Table 3-2). ~lithin the incorporated boundaries of Palmdale the greatest concentration of residents can be found in Palmdale East as well as surrounding the central business area. Outside the boundaries another high concentration is located to 25 26 POPULATION 1975 45,000 Lancaster 11 ,400 Palmdale ll ,000 Edwards** 700 Llano 2,500 California City 2,570 Mojave 2,950 Boron 700 Acton 8,500 Quartz Hill 2,800 Littlerock-Sun Village Pearblossom 725 Leona Valley-Lake Hughes 2,300 4,500 Tehachapi 20,700 Ridgecrest-China Lake 1,200 Rosamond ***Total Antelope Valley 149,000 1980 47,931* 12 'll3* 14,791 2,500 2,800* 3,000 2,500 925 8,800 3,260 890 2,270 3,900 22 'll6 1,500 Percent of Antelope Valley in 1980 Percent Change 1975 to 1980 27.4% 6.9 8.5 1.4 1.6 1.7 1.4 0.5 5.0 1.9 0.5 6.5% 6.3 34.5 257.1 12.0 16.7 -15.3 32.1 3.5 16.4 22.8 1.3 -1.3 2.2 12.6 0.9 -13.3 6.8 25.0 175,000 * Incorporated boundaries ** Includes Edwards Air Force Base ***Does not equal the sum of above for 1975 and 1980 Table 3-1 Population changes of Antelope Valley communities from 1975 to 1980. Sources: U.S. Census, Preliminary Population Figures 1980; California Department of Transportation; Antelope Valley Board of Trade; Kern County Board of Trade. 17.4 27 POPULATION GROWTH 1970 1980 Percent Change 8,511 12,113 42.0% Palmdale Sphere of Influence 31 ,429 38,876 24.0% City of Lancaster 30,948 47,931 55.0% Lancaster Sphere of Influence 51 ,446 62,790 22.0% City of Palmdale Table 3-2 The Percentage of Population Growth in the Palmdale and Lancaster Areas. Source: Antelope Valley Board of Trade. 28 the west in Desert View Highlands. During the past five years, 1975 to 1980, these three residential areas have been expanding (~1ap 9). An additional indication of growth in these two cities was the significant percentage of residents who have lived in these areas less than five years. Of the two cities, Palmdale has had a higher rate of recent population growth, 52.4 percent, suggesting changes in the community's economy (Table 3-3). YEARS OF RESIDENCE Palmdale Lancaster Ante 1ope Va 11 ey Area Less than 1 year 19.8% 12,9% 16.3% 2 - 5 years 32.6 21.7 27.2 - 10 years 15.0 15.5 15.2 11 - 15 years 9.0 11.0 10.0 16 - 20 years 10.2 14. 1 12.2 21+ years 13.4 24.8 19.1 Total 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% N= (313) {419) (732) Years of Residence 6 Table 3-3 Percentage of years of residence for the cities of Palmdale, Lancaster, and Antelope Valley in 1980. Source: Los Angeles County Planning Group. Parallel with the region's population growth in the past decade is a growth in housing, especially significant in the Palmdale and Lancaster areas (Table 3-4). The majority of the region's population is housed in single-family dwellings (Table 3-5). However, in the Palmdale-Lancaster area an increasing proportion of the housing units authorized by building permits, 33,3 percent, is multifamily units, 29 I ~c Q) -o ·u; Q) 0: Cl c ·;:; .!!! X w .. .!! w :i ~] 30 HOUSING UNIT GROWTH 1970 1980 Percent Change 2,816 4,945 76.0% Palmdale Sphere of Influence 10,610 14,310 35.0% City of Lancaster 9,581 18 '1 00 89.0% 16,434 26,700 62.0% City of Palmdale Lancaster Sphere of Influence Table 3-4 The percentage of housing unit growth in the Palmdale and Lancaster areas. Source: Los Angeles Planning Group. TYPE OF HOUSING Antelope Valley Area Palmdale Lancaster 81.8% 78.6% 80.2% Apartment 7.0 8.7 7.8 Condominium 0.3 1.2 0.8 r~obil e 9.9 10.6 10.3 1.0 0.9 0.9 Total 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% N= (313) (426) (739) Type of Housing Single-family Detached Home Other Table 3-5 Percentage of residents by type of housing, 1980. N equals the number of respondents to the household survey. Source: Los Angeles Planning Group. 31 both apartments and condominiums. Issuance of building permits and housing construction increased from 1970 to 1980, except during the decade's recession period, 19741976. An annual average for the ten-year span was 898 housing units for the Palmdale-Lancaster area (Table 3-6). Major residential devel- opment has occurred in four areas in Palmdale; two large subdivisions between 25th and 40th Streets East south of Palmdale Boulevard, an area near the golf course east of lOth Street West and north of Avenue P, Desert View Highlands west of lOth Street West, and Manzanita Heights south of Palmdale Boulevard between Division Street and lOth Street West (Map 9). RESIDENTIAL BUILDING PERMITS CITY OF PALMDALE Year Single Famil,l Multi-Family Total Dwelling Units 1970 1971 1972 1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 1979 1980 108 33 55 79 80 188 97 381 465 25 436 544 6 0 0 27 3 6 5 2 3 Table 3-6 27 114 168 111 14 32 920 225 182 1272 1388 2660 677 Tota 1 64 243 The number of housing units authorized by residential building permits in the Palmdale area from 1970 to 1980. The number of permits in 1980 was to the month of May. Source: City of Palmdale, Department of Building and Safety. The age profile of the region exhibited a shift in emphasis consistent with the upward trend of in-migration in the area and 32 national trends. The region's largest population group in 1970 was 5 to 15 years of age. The year 1980 found the 18 to 29 age group the region's largest population segment (Table 3-7). The age structure of Palmdale was similar to that of the entire region, with one notable exception. A considerably higher percentage of the 60 to 69 age group resides in Palmdale than Lancaster, 14.3 percent and 10.6 percent respectively, which implies future needs in the city's social and public services for the elderly. AGE STRUCTURE OF ADULT POPULATION Palmdale 18-29 30-39 40-49 50-59 60-69 70-79 80+ 26.0% 25.4 15.9 12.7 14.3 4.4 1.3 27.0% 22.6 16.9 14.7 10.6 5.8 2.4 26.5% 24.0 16.4 13.7 12.4 5.1 1.9 Total 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% N= ( 315} (415) (730) Table 3-7 Lancaster Antelope Valley Area Age GrouE The age structure of the adult population in the cities of Palmdale and Lancaster and the Antelope Valley, 1930. N equals the number of respondents to the household survey. Source: Los Angeles Planning Group. The household survey 1 established that 88 percent of households in Palmdale currently included women in the child-bearing years, 18 to 50 years, as compared to 77 percent in Lancaster. Fertility levels were also slightly higher in the Palmdale population. Based on the child-woman ratio, 2 Palmdale's fertility level was 0.36, Lancaster's was 0.32. Palmdale's greater population in-migration in the past five years could account for its higher fertility level. In 33 1977, Palmdale's population of five and eighteen years was 7,709. 1980, this age group had declined to 6,318, or 18.0 percent. By However, although there was a decline, the five to eighteen age group comprised 52 percent of Palmdale's total population in 1980. The average house- hold size in Antelope Valley declined during the past ten years. Household size in 1970 was 3.3, dropping to 2.8 in 1980. However, Palmdale and Lancaster households currently were larger than the region as a whole, 3.2 and 3.0 respectively. Household size in these areas was related directly with the fertility level and in-migration. As demonstrated with the elderly age bracket, the above indicated future demands for child-related services, especially in Palmdale. Data obtained from the household survey placed the median income for Palmdale households at $20,744. This was somewhat lower than the median income for the entire Valley, $21,240, but not a significant difference. 15,8 percent of Palmdale's households had an income be- tween $20,000 and $25,000 which was comparable to the entire region. A notable feature of Palmdale's income distribution was the large concentration of households having an income less than $5,000. This heavy percentage was partly caused by the large group of residents 60 years of age and older which comprised 20 percent of Palmdale's population (Fig. 3-1), A fairly high level of education was attained by Antelope Valley residents. pleted. An average of twelve years of schooling was com- Of the responses from the Palmdale area, almost 60 percent had received a high school diploma, while 35 percent had attended at least one year of college and 4 percent had received graduate degrees (Table 3-8). 34 Fig. 3-1: INCOME DISTRIBUTION 1980 18 17 16 Antelope Valley 15 Lancaster 14 Palmdale 13 12 11 Q) en ..... "' 10 Q) 9 c: ....~ 0.. 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 0 # "69 ,. I ~ ~ G9 "69 , ......$ I o· ~ # ,.. .... G9 s;~· S$ ~· "'' ~ ,..I 0)' ~ ~· s;-~· ~ I !:)' ~ Income Level f I ~· ~· ~ # ~ GJ ~· "69 !).)' ~ ~· o· ~ ~· ~· ~ # ~· ~ 35 EDUCATION LEVELS Palmdale Education Level 2.9% 5-8 years Antelope Valley Area Lancaster 3.4% 3.8% 9-12 years 58.7 48.2 53.4 13-16 years 34.6 39.3 37.0 17 or more years 3.8 8.7 6.2 Total 100.0% 100,0% 100.0% N= (315) (425) (740) Table 3-8 The education level percentages of the residents of Palmdale, Lancaster and the Antelope Valley, 1980. N is the number of respondents to the household Survey. Source: Los Angeles Planning Group. The level of education of the region is reflected in the occupational categories of the residents and their employment status. labor force is at present heavily service-oriented. The As shown in Table 3-9, the occupational structure of Palmdale and Lancaster is similar; however, the former has a larger industrial labor force. Better than 50 percent of the region's labor force is working full-time. However, about 8 percent of Palmdale's work force is unemployed due, in part, to the cyclical layoffs of the aircraft industry. ment status Palmdale's employ- is a reflection of its age and fertility structure in that almost 15 percent of the population list their occupation as "Keeping House" and 2 percent are in school (Fig. 3-2). This large percentage, 42 percent, of residents not employed also contributed to Palmdale's lower income status. 36 OCCUPATIONAL TYPE PROFILE Palmdale Occupational Type Professionals Lancaster 30.0% 32.0% Managers-Administrators 9.0 12.0 Sales Workers 6,0 6.0 Clerical Workers 14.0 16.0 Service Workers 8.0 8.0 Craftsmen-Skilled Workers 19.0 15.0 Operatives-Transportation Workers 11.0 6.0 3,0 5.0 100.0% 100.0% Laborers Total Table 3-9 Occupational types are segregated into eight categories. Profile is for 1980. Source: Antelope Valley Board of Trade; Questor Associates. Although Antelope Valley has become more autonomous, 46 percent of Palmdale's principal wage earners are employed elsewhere, whereas only 26 percent of the work force in Lancaster have their primary place of employment outside the city (Table 3-10). Diversification and expansion of manufacturing is occurring, but apparently not rapidly enough to satisfy the available work force in Palmdale. Another factor suggesting the need of increased economic diversification in the Palmdale area is noticeable in the residents' shopping pattern. One-third of the households shop in Lancaster or else- where, whereas only 2 percent of the Lancaster households shop outside their area (Table 3-11). make at least one, Nearly 70 percent of Palmdale's residents generally more, shopping trips a month outside the 37 Fig. 3-2: EMPLOYMENT STATUS .. 55 50 f-- . I": ~co/~ '§itf~ I"' s . 45 Q..'(§ %~q, ,f !ZI "·',.g.~~ .• (;' ~ .. 40 . . •' 35 30 ·. .. ·. .... 25 20 - .' ..: : 15 - .. 5 . : :- ~ sCb ·~ ~~ ~0 :-... ~ '<. . ...... .. ... - r:" ·.1-- 0 . .... . . 10 r-: ~ ·~ .s * '.;:; ~ ~$' Q.. g..~ § rf .:::f . . . .. - .... . ~ ,I .: r:"! i:. ·' Cb "':' ~ :.§ ~ n o- (;' "ff " Gj(j . fl ~ ·~ [;. ~ ~ .::i ~ n.IJl... ~ ;S 0 9 38 PLACE OF HORK Palmdale Lancaster Ante 1ope Va 11 ey Area Palmdale 54,0% 18.8% 36.4% Lancaster 22.4 74.0 48.2 Other parts of Los Angeles County 23,0 6.8 14.9 0.6 0.4 0.5 Total 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% N= {174) (250) (424) City of Work Other Table 3-10 The percentage of residents in Palmdale and Lancaster as to the city or area in which they work for 1980. Source: Los Angeles County Planning Group LOCAL SHOPPING AREA Area of Most Frequent Shopping Area of Residence Palmdale Lancaster Antelope Valley Area Lancaster 33. 8~~ 98.3% 66.0% Palmdale 66.2 1.7 34.0 Total 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% = (305) ( 419) (724) N Table 3-11 The cities of Antelope Valley where residents of Palmdale and Lancaster as well as spheres of influence most frequently shop, 1980. Source: Los Angeles County Planning Group. 39 Antelope Valley region. Compared with Lancaster's trip frequency of 29 percent and the Valley as a whole of 49 percent, this becomes a primary factor in pointing out the retail deficiencies of Palmdale. (Table 3-12). SHOPPING TRIP FREQUENCY Lancaster Palmdale Trip Frequency Antelope Valley Area Less than once a month 31.1% 71 .0% 51.0% Once a month 15.0 17.4 16.2 2 - 5 times a month 39.8 10.4 25' 1 6 - 10 times a month 7.8 0.3 4.1 11 or more times a month 6.3 0.9 3.6 Total 100.0% 100 .m~ 100.0% = (287) (400} (697) N Table 3-12 The percentage of residents making shopping trips outside the Palmdale-Lancaster area, 1980. Source: Los Angeles County Planning Group. Further confirmation of these deficiences can be found in the types of items shopped for outside the region. Frequent trips for food are more localized, but households throughout the Antelope Valley make longer trips for clothing and household items (Table 313). This seems to establish succinctly the demand for retail estab- lishments handling these items which would be a step toward a more stable economy. Summary Antelope Valley, as a whole, has become more autonomous and economically diversified since 1960. The data indicate, however, that 40 MERCHANDISE TYPES Palmdale Type of Item Lancaster Ante 1ope Va 11 ey Area Clothing, apparel 49.0% 50.7% 49.8% Food, 1i quor 15.1 7.5 11.3 Home furnishings 11.1 12.0 11.5 General merchandise 11.8 10.3 11.1 Automobiles and related items 5.4 4.8 5.1 Other 7.6 14.7 11.2 Total 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% = (484) (292) (776) N Table 3-13 The types of merchandise items residents shopped for outside the Palmdale-Lancaster area, 1980. Source: Los Angeles County Planning Group. 41 Palmdale will benefit from expansion and diversification of its industrial base. As much as 46 percent of Palmdale's wage earners are em- ployed outside the city, either in Lancaster or other parts of Los Angeles County. As will be determined in the following chapter, Palmdale's industrial base consists mainly of aerospace industries. Unfortunately, these industries are subject to cyclical activity, and the city's businesses, at this time, are unable to fully employ the available labor force. Economic expansion should therefore be a prime objective of the future. Evidence concerning the age structure of Palmdale's residents as well as their shopping patterns establishes further the need for expansion. Palmdale has a relatively high proportion of its population in the upper age brackets. Additionally, it has a high fertility level, 0.36, and a large household size, 3.2. These data indicate a demand for social and public services, including education. Currently, the city's public services consist mainly of bureaucratic activities, and Palmdale basically relies upon Lancaster to provide other types of governmental services. Considering the current population of children 5 to 18 years, the fertility level, and household size of residents in Palmdale, the need for expanded social and public services will be aggravated in the near future. Deficiencies in Palmdale's retail trade are established in evidence related to the residents' shopping patterns. Merchandise defi- ciencies, especially clothing and household items, result in a significant percentage of the residents shopping in Lancaster or making one or more shopping trips per month out of the Valley. ture of Palmdale (~1ap The retail struc- 8, Appendix C) further confirms a shortage of 42 retail businesses handling items residents require. Palmdale, conse- quently, is losing potential benefits in the form of sales tax revenue. Of prime importance is the construction of housing to accommodate the present demand and encourage economic expansion. Further- more, Palmdale will benefit by encouraging the expansion of existing retail activities and the development of new businesses to fulfill the demands of its residents and available labor force. I 43 Footnotes 1 The household survey was conducted by the Los Angeles Planning Group in 1980. A sample of the questionnaire used may be seen in Appendix B. 2The child-woman ratio is calculated by dividing the number of children from birth to 4 years of age by the number of women 18 to 50 years of age. ' CHAPTER IV ECONOMIC BASE AND TRANSPORTATION Economic Base The urban economic base is composed of those activities of a community which involve the export of goods and services to firms or individuals outside the community's economic boundaries. This export function earns a dollar inflow for the community from the surrounding region. However, the base activities can be considered in another sense as the wage-earners of the community family. Without them, or if their earning power declines, the economic health of the community suffers. The economic portion of a community which the base supports is referred to as the service activity. The service activities in- elude those enterprises whose main function is to provide for the needs of persons within the community's economic surroundings. 1 The major flow of income into a community is in the form of payment received for goods and services exported to the outside areas. The part of this income which is of major significance to the community is the portion paid to workers as income. These workers spend the greater part of their income within the community, thus creating a demand for goods and services. That demand, in turn, determines the number of local businesses and the number of persons employed. Con- sequently, the income earned by those businesses is paid to their employees as income which they use to consume local goods and services. 44 45 This processt the multiplier effectt 2 creates a circular stream of income flows vital to the economic functioning of a community. Income leaves a community's economic stream through savings and the importation of goods and services by both basic and service activities. If a community has insufficient retail and service businessest the inhabitants will spend their incomes outside the community which will tend to retard growth of the local commercial establishements. Community service industries are as vital to community life as the basic industries. Their presence allows the community's income to follow the circular path which ensures economic health and stability. 3 Antelope Valley's basic industries in the past have been agriculture and aerospace. Prior to 1950, agriculture was the principal _contributor to the Valley's economy. As the Valley became more urban- ized, agriculture's importance in the regional economy waned. Employ- ment and production value due to price increases of products and greater yields per acre increased by 275.0 percent and 183.6 percent respectively since 1960. However, during the same time span, agri- culture acreage decreased by 28.1 percent. The major decline occurred in the 1970's indicating the region's trend toward a more stable economy and urbanization (Table 4-1). Aviation and aviation-related industries contributed significantly to the growth and development of Antelope yalley•s economic base. Conditions in the Valley were conducive to this industry in two respects; favorable climate with a clear atmosphere and minimal adverse weather conditions, as well as adequate space. These condi- tions prompted the Air Force to institute flight-test operations in 1930 at Edwards Air Force Base. AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTION Los Angeles Portion of Antelope Valley 1960-1978 1978 Percent Change 1969-1978 1960-1978 1960 1965 1969 1974 -- Fruits and Nuts Field Crops* Vegetables Nursery Stock 2,772 73,020 1,650 75 2,384 56' 119 425 80 1,838 75 '170 130 100 1 ,540 44,570 405 70 1 '180 52,450 2,001 82 -33.7 2.9 -92.1 33.3 -35.8 -30.2 1,446.9 -18.0 -57.4 -28.2 21.9 9.3 TOTAL* 77,517 59,008 77,238 46,585 55' 723 - 0.4 -27.9 -28.1 Fruits and Nuts Field Crops Vegetables Nursery Stock $1,079 7,072 880 66 $ 966 9,247 374 87 $1,136 8,021 69 113 $2,249 12,759 369 115 $3,l53 15,955 6,523 180 - 5.3 13.4 -92.2 66.2 177.6 98.9 9,353.6 59.3 192.2 125.6 641.3 164.7 TOTAL*** $9,100 $10,674 $9,339 $15,492 $25,811 2.6 176.4 183.6 1960-1969 Acrea~: Value** Table 4-1 *Not including pasture and range. **In thousdands of dollars. ***Does not include government transfers. Source: Agricultural Commissioner, County of Los Angeles. •.J::::o 0"\ 47 The region's aerospace nucleus is comprised of operations at Edwards Air Force Base, China Lake Naval Weapons Station, Palmdale International Airport, Lancaster's Fox Airport, and airports in Mojave, California City, Ridgecrest-Inyokern, and Tehachapi (Map 10). Companies forming the core are Boeing, Northrop, General Electric and Rockwell International which assemble and conduct flight-test operations. The Jet Propulsion Laboratory and Rocket Propulsion Laboratory instigate and perform major experiments on solar energy and fuel efficiency. The National Aeronautics and Space Administration conducts tests of unmanned and manned aerospace vehicles. Plant 42 at Palmdale International Airport serves as an assembly and flight-test center for both military and commercial aircraft (Table 4-2). Since 1959 the Palmdale-Lancaster economic base expanded and diversified significantly. 1959 to 1977. 1970's. Total employment increased by 18,300 from The major portion of this increase occurred during the Manufacturing, trade and government were responsible for 71.3 percent of the total employment in 1959. t•1anufacturing carried the largest percent due to the influx of aircraft industries. By 1977, the major employment areas had become manufacturing, services and government. Employment in these categories was evenly distributed, accounting for 59.8 percent of the total employment. The greatest increase in number of employees was in services, government, construction and manufacturing. However, the most rapid growth in employment was in services, finance and real estate, construction, and agriculture. Growth in the first three areas, corresponded with the rapid population increase. The population increase created increased demand for housing, financing and many varied services (Table 4-3). 48 Map 10: ANTELOPE VALLEY AEROSPACE BASES CHINA LAKE NAVAL WEAPONS CENTER ..... ..... .CALIFORNIA CITY Hvvy. 58 Hwy. 58 Rosamond Blvd. EDWARDS AIR FORCE BASE Hwy.138 t:9 FOX AIRPORT LANCASTER Hwy.138 San Gabriel Mountains SCALE 0 , 5 1 10 • Miles N AVIATION ACTIVITIES Location Activity Type Frequency Use (1979) Palmdale International Airport Golden Hest: Air Force Plant 42 Northrop: Assembly, flight test Lockheed: Assembly, flight test North American Rockwell: Assembly, flight test Edwards Air Force Base t·1ilitary flight testing 14,000 arrivals and departures China Lake Naval Station Passenger and freight service Flight testing 35,000 arrivals and General William J. Fox Airport Lancaster Mojave Airport Private and U. S. Forest Service 141 ,000 arrivals and departures 14,046 arrivals and departures California City Airport Private service Special flights and jet testing Private and recreational service Ridgecrest-Inyokern Airport Commuter service Tehachapi Airport Private and charter service Crystallaire Airport Private and recreational service Table 4-2 Source: FAA Airmen's Information Commercial 4,957 passengers; 5.72 tons freight d~partures 5,000 arrivals and departures 6,000 glider arrivals and departures 2,900 arrivals and departures 5,000-7,000 arrivals and. departures 85 arrivals and departures 10,126 glider arrivals and departures. ~1anua1 +::> \.0 EMPLOYMENT BY INDUSTRY PALMDALE-LANCASTER LABOR MARKET AREA 1959-1977 1959 TOTAL* 1977 1973 % Number % Number % Number % Number % Number 400 1000 3500 3.3 8.2 28.7 350 750 5300 2.5 5.3 37.5 400 800 2300 3.0 5.9 17.0 500 900 2500 3.1 5.6 15.6 900 2600 4800 3.8 11.1 20.4 1500 3800 6100 -& 4.9 12.5 20.0 600 4.9 600 4.2 800 5.9 900 5.6 975 4.1 1100 3.6 3100 25.4 3050 21.6 3300 24.4 3600 22.5 4000 17.0 4550 14.9 300 1200 2100 2.5 9.8 17.2 300 1300 2500 2.1 9.2 17.7 400 2000 3500 3,0 14.8 25.9 400 3500 3700 2.5 21 '9 23.1 -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- 850 4600 4750 50 3,6 19.6 20.2 0.2 1200 6100 6050 100 3.9 20.0 19.8 0.3 12200 100.0 14150 100.1 13500 99,9 16000 99.9 23525 100.0 30500 99.9 Number Agriculture Construction Manufacturing Transportation, Communication, Utilities Trade, Wholesale, Retail Finance, Real Estate, Insurance Services Government Other (Mining) 1968 1965 1962 *Percent totals may not equal 100.0 due to rounding. Table 4-3 Sources: California Department of Human Resources; U. S. Census Bureau; Antelope Valley Board of Trade; California Employment Development Department. ()"1 0 EMPLOYMENT BY INDUSTRY (cont.) Change in Emelo~ment Agriculture Construction Manufacturing Transportation, Communication, Utilities Trade, Wholesale, Retail Finance, Real Estate, Insurance Services Government Other {Mining) TOTAL* 1959-1977 1968-1977 1959-1968 Number % Number Ol h Number % 100 -100 -1000 25.0 -10,0 -28.6 1000 2900 3600 200.0 322.2 144.0 1100 2800 2600 275.0 280.0 74.3 300 50,0 200 22.2 500 83.3 500 16.1 950 26.4 1450 46.8 100 2300 1600 33.3 191.7 76.2 800 2600 2350 200.0 74.3 63.5 300.0 408.3 188.1 -- -- -- -- 900 4900 3950 100 3800 31.1 14500 90.6 18300 150.0 NA 01 ...... .,. 52 In assessing the current economic base of Antelope Valley and Palmdale, the business activities, employment and payroll were analyzed. This analysis was primarily based on the results of the em- ployer survey (Appendix A). 215 responses were obtained. From this regional sample of employers Major employers in the Valley comprised 20 of these responses. To facilitate the analysis, the basic sources of employment were combined into six categories: ( 1) producers, manufacturers, wholesalers (2) construction contractors (3) . . 4 serv1ces government an d bus1ness (4) health and public utility services (5) retail trade . 5 retai 1 serv1ces. (6) Producers, manufacturers, wholesalers and government and business services comprised 76.8 percent of Antelope Valley's total employment. Palmdale emerged as the manufacturing center of the Valley, accounting for 79.4 percent of its total manufacturing employment. Lancaster was more service-oriented. In contrast, Fully 72.5 percent of this city's total employment was attributed to government, business, health and public utility services (Table 4-4). Employment of the businesses surveyed was 24,365, which represented 64.1 percent of the Valley's total employment of 38,011. The Valley's major industries employed 17,609, 46.3 percent of theregion's total employment. sons. These businesses employed 100 or more per- However, the majority of the businesses, 55.7 percent, were small, employing 1 to 10 persons. A significantly high percent of the ______ a_ __ ·~---- -~---- --------------- 53 PERCENT EMPLOYMENT BY INDUSTRY Total Study Area Palmdale Lancaster Producers, Manufacturers and Wholesalers 79.4% 7.8% 40.9% Construction Contractors 0.0 1.3 2.2 Government and Business Services 9.3 27.5 35.9 Health and Public Utility Services 1.4 45.0 13.6 Retail Trade 8.6 15.2 6.2 Retai 1 Services 1.3 3.2 1.2 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% (7,357) (5,788) (24,365) Industry Group TOTAL N= Table 4-4 Percent of employment by industry in 1980 Source: Questor Associates Employer Survey. 54 small businesses comprised the retail trade and service activities (Table 4-5). An additional indication of Palmdale as the manufactur- ing center of the Valley was evident in the fact that 16.7 percent of this city•s businesses employed 50 or more persons. In turn, only 9.4 percent of Lancaster•s firms employed more than 50 persons. An- other notable feature was the fairly high percentage, 14.6, of selfemployed businesses in Palmdale. It indicated the development of a number of small businesses, especially in the light-manufacturing category (Table 4-6). NUMBER OF EMPLOYEES BY PERCENT EMPLOYERS Palmdale Number of Employees Self employed 14.6% Lancaster Total Stud,l Area 9.0% 7.9% 1- 10 47.9 62,2 55,7 11- 50 20.8 20.5 19.5 51-100 8.3 2.7 4.8 100-300 2.1 2.7 4.3 Over 300 6.3 4.0 6.7 Total 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% N= (48) ( 151 ) (21 0) Table 4-6 Employment distribution in Palmdale and Lancaster as to number of employees in 1980. Source: Questor Associates Employer Survey, The annual payroll of Antelope Valley employers is approximately $315,000,000. Of that total amount, Palmdale employers• portion is $106,970,000 (Table 4-7). The significance of the payroll is evident in the percentage paid to employees residing outside the city of their employment. An average of 26.5 percent of the Palmdale payroll is EMPLOYMENT DISTRIBUTION BY INDUSTRY Number of EmE1..21ees Producers Manufacturers Wholesalers Self Employed 0.0% Construction Contractors 0.0% Government Business Services 0.0% Health Public Utility Services 0.0% Retail Trade Retail Services 13.0% 13.1% Total 9.0% 1- 10 32.0 57,1 33.3 21.5 64.2 74.0 55.7 11- 50 20.0 o.o 38.9 28.6 19.5 4.3 19.5 51-100 12.0 14.3 5.6 7.1 2.5 4.3 4.8 101-200 4.0 14.3 o.o 7.1 0.0 4.3 1.9 201-300 16.0 0,0 0.0 71 0.0 0.0 2.4 301 or more 16.0 ~3 22.2 28.6 0.8 0.0 6.7 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 486 236 TOTAL Mean Employment per Firm 100.0% 399 100.0% 78 0 12 NTable 4-5 13 116 (210) The employment distribution by industry in Antelope Valley in 1980. Source: Ouestor Associates Employer Survey. (}1 (}1 56 I DISTRIBUTION OF FIRMS BY ANNUAL PAYROLL Palmdale Lancaster Total* Self-employed 12.5% 3.1% 4.3% $1-$10,000 12.5 9.2 8.7 $10,001-$20,000 12.5 9.2 8.7 $20,001-$30,000 8.3 14.3 11 .6 $30,001-$50,000 12.5 9.2 8.7 $50,001-$100,000 4.2 23.4 17.5 $100,001-$200,000 25.0 8.1 10.1 $200,001-$500,000 8.3 12.2 10. 1 $500,001-$1,000,000 0.0 1.0 8.0 $1,000,001-$5,000,000 0.0 1.0 8.0 $5,000,001 or more 4.2 5.1 8.7 TOTAL 100.0% 100.0?-~ 100.0% = (24) (98) Amount N (138) Mean $363,538 $613,501 $2,277,969 Median $ 36,125 $ 59,103 $ 69,003 *Includes major employer group as well as Lancaster and Palmdale groups. Table 4-7 The distribution of the annual payroll paid out by employers in 1980. Source: Questor Associates Employer Survey. 57 paid to employees residing outside of this city (Table 4-8). Because of these data it is obvious that Palmdale is losing potential benefits in the form of property and sales tax revenues from their employment base. PERCENT OF PAYROLL PAID TO EMPLOYEES RESIDING OUTSIDE CITY OF EMPLOYMENT % Paid Out of Area Cit~ of Palmdale Em~lo~ment Lancaster 0 - 5% 34.6 61.3 5 - 10% 11.5 5.3 10 - 20% 11.5 14.8 20 - 30% 19.2 5.3 30 - 40% 3,8 4.4 40 - 50% 0,0 3.5 50 - 75% 3,8 3.5 75 - 90% 0,0 0.9 100% 15.4 0.9 TOTAL 100.0 100.0 N= (26) (114) 90 Table 4-8 Percent of payroll paid to employees residing other than the city in which they are employed for 1980. Source: Questor Associates Employer Survey. Transportation Patterns The transportation structure was an additional indication of Antelope Valley•s upward economic trend and transition from a rural to an urban region. Highway transportation patterns were characteristic of the Valley•s growth and an indication the region was beginning to 5.g serve its employment needs. Traffic volume within Antelope Valley in- creased in the 1970's, especially since 1973. An increase in traffic volume was particularly notable from the fringe areas of the Valley converging on the Lancaster area. Traffic on Route 14, Antelope Valley Freeway, increased by 15.8 percent from the west and 20.0 to 21.4 percent from the north. Highway 138 from Littlerock leading into Palmdale experienced a 33.1 percent increase (Map 11). During this same time span, traffic from the region declined 14.8 percent, indicating less dependancy upon employment in the Los Angeles area (Table 4-9) 0 Internal movement in the Valley as a whole has increased; however, a significantly large volume of this traffic is traveling from -Palmdale. Traffic volume increased 17.5 percent from 1973 to 1979 moving along Palmdale Boulevard toward Antelope Valley Freeway. Over the past five years, 1975 to 1980, traffic volume has increased 36.1 percent moving north from Avenue P along Sierra Highway. These data present further indication of potential benefits lost to Palmdale. Lost benefits due to employees residing in Lancaster and consumers seeking retail establishments in Lancaster or Los Angeles (Table 4-10, Hap 12). Fiscal Structure Significant data concerning changes in Antelope Valley's fiscal structure was also indicative of the region's urbanization trend and expanding economy. Deposits in financial institutions in both Palmdale and Lancaster grew at a greater rate than inflation between 1975 and 1979. During this time span, total deposits in these insti- tutions increased by $180,599,000 or 73.3 percent. This represented 50 Map 11:. PERCENT CHANGE IN TRAFFIC VOLUME IN THE ANTELOPE VALLEY 1973- 1979 100 equals 1973 traffic volumes Mojave Desert 0 1- Hwv.5a Rosamond Blvd. 121.4 t Hwy.138 116.2 Lancaster 0.9 San- Gabriel Mountains SCALE 0 5 Miles '------~ AVERAGE DAILY TRAFFIC CALIFORNIA STATE HIGHHAYS 1970 AA 1971 AA 1972 AA 1973 AA 1974 AA Rte. Jet. Jet. Jet. 5 Rte. 14 Rte. 126 East South Leg Rte. 138 59,500 29,500 21,050 68,500 32,500 22,000 76,500 34,000 24,500 69,500 40,000 26,000 69,500 37,750 23,500 Rte. Jet. Jet. Ward 14 Rte. 5 Rte. 126, Saugus Road Interchange 36,000 35,000 38,000 37,000 14,550 41 ,500 36,250 19,000 44,000 39,000 19,000 44,000 37,500 19,000 14 '1 00 11,600 16,000 16,500 16,500 7,750 7,350 7,700 11 '150 11 '150 2,200 2,400 2,300 2,300 2,300 10,000 9,500 8,250 5,400 4,300 10,000 7,750 8,750 6,200 4,750 10,000 7,600 8,750 6,200 5,100 11,000 8,750 8,650 6,200 4,500 11 ,000 Palmdale, Jet. Rte. 138 Palmdale Blvd. Ave. J-8, 20th St. West Interchange Jet. Rte. 48 Rte. 138 Jet. Rte. 5 Palmdale, Jet. Rte. 14 Antelope Valley Freeway Palmdale, 20th St. East Pearblossom Road (Ave. T) Littlerock, 96th St. East Jet. Rte. 18 East 8,950 8,950 8,750 7,450 7,450 4,750 AA = Annual Average Table 4-9 The average daily traffic on major highways in the Antelope Valley from 1970 to 1979. The years 1975 to 1979 continue on the following page. Source: CALTRANS, Traffic Volumes on California State Highways. 0'1 0 ., AVERAGE DAILY TRAFFIC CALIFORNIJ\ STATE Rte. Jet. Jet. Jet. 5 Rte. 14 Rte. 126 East South Leg Rte. 138 Rte. 14 Jet. Rte. 5 Jet. Rte. 126, Saugus Ward Road Interchange Palmdale, Jet. Rte. 138 Palmdale Blvd. Ave. J-8, 20th St. West Interchange Jet. Rte. 48 Rte. 138 Jet. Rte. 5 Palmdale, Jet. Rte. 14 Antelope Valley Freeway Palmdale, 20th St. East Pearblossom Road (Ave. T) Littlerock, 90th St. East Jet. Rte. 18 East HIGH~JAYS (cont.) I 1975 AA 1976 AA 1977 AA 1978 AA 1979 AA 74,500 38,500 27,250 76,000 42,000 26,500 76,000 42,000 26,500 77,500 43,250 27,000 105,000 43,250 25,500 43,500 39,000 17,750 45,000 40,500 18,750 46,000 41,500 19,400 37,500 37,250 22,000 37,500 37,250 22,000 16,500 15,450 15,500 16,400 16,850 10,200 9,700 11 '1 00 10,060 10,800 9,550 11,200 8,750 11 ,250 10,400 2,300 2,300 2,300 2,300 2,300 11 ,000 8,750 7,450 7,450 4,750 11 ,000 8,750 7,450 7,450 5,250 13,400 8,750 8,000 8,250 5,250 22,000 8,750 6,950 8,250 5,250 22,000 8,750 6,950 8,250 5,350 t I O'l ...... 24-HOUR TRAFFIC VOLUt·1ES ON SELECTED COUNTY AND CITY ROADS* 1965 Lancaster ~lest of West of East of Blvd. Gadsden Cedar Sierra Hyw. Palmdale Blvd. West of Sierra Hyw. Hest of lOth West of 15th 1966 1968 1969 11,284 8,789 10,233 Source: 1971 12,096 11,882 7,545 10,300 1972 1973 1974 11 '1 07 11 ,725 10,015 15,796 9,427 14,783 14,917 4,724 9,300 15,762 6,684 13,959 3,140 7,146 20,200 23,693 14,933 15,573 520 *Figures above are traffic counts for a single 24-hour period. Only week-day counts are included. Table 4-10 1970 9,824 Sierra High\<~ax South of Ave. E North of Ave. I South of Ave. M North of Ave. P. West of Antelope Valley Freeway North of Palmdale Blvd. 1967 501 1 ,961 10,513 They are not average daily traffic counts. Roads Department, Los Angeles County. 0"1 N 24-HOUR TRAFFIC VOLUMES ON SELECTED COUNTY AND CITY ROADS (cont.) 1975 Lancaster West of 14est of East of Blvd. Gadsden Cedar Sierra Hyw. Palmdale Blvd. West of Sierra Hyw. West of lOth West of 15th Sierra Highwa~ South of Ave. E. North of Ave. I South of Ave. M North of Ave. p West of Antelope Valley Freeway North of Palmdale Blvd. 1976 1977 1978 1979 1980 16,837 12,017 9,337 18,561 15,291 1 ,413 4,177 7,002 12,800 11 '171 4,217 6,327 4,476 13,552 12,702 14,362 13,455 17,424 745 11,147 Q) w 11\Map 12:PERCENT CHANGE IN TRAFFIC VOLUME IN PALMDALE ~----------~--~--------•A•v-e.•o.___+----41+ 1973-1979 97.1 i ~g 1 l \j +~ ~ 1- I "n· I"'::;; ~ ~~~-~ \ 116.7 ~z (/) -5 ~ 1-1111.1.-!- :~ ·- '~ r1rn :n 0 Elizabeth lake Rd. Ave. 0 ~ 100% equals 1973 base y 00 ,.,.m,~••~ % Miles ...._117.sii'i 0 0 N M ~ ~. . . i "!:; ~.... ~ ~ ~ ' 106.0 !11 PALMDALE BLVD. ...... 133.1 m 8~ . + 6'o-. ~ N SCALE Z 0 - -1 ~E'rr~ ~Traffic Direction ~ i :I: ~~ ~~ f!J; . i;:; ~.... "l] ):> ~ . % \+- c;;g 0 ,.... 0 ...· Ave. P ) b ~ < V& ~ 4m~ )> 115.8 < Aw.R t 1 1 11 O'l .f::> 65 an average annual growth rate of 14.7 percent (Table 4-11). Adjusted for inflation, 6 the growth in deposits was 27.8 percent, 6.3 percent annually. Beside the increased growth in deposits, growth in Palmdale•s tax revenue also disclosed the city•s expanding economy. From 1965 to 1979 increases of 488.6 percent in taxable sales, 863.5 percent in assessed valuation of property and 656.9 percent in the property tax levy were attained. Revenues grew at a rapid rate during the 1970 1 s. The property tax levy reflected the expansion of the city•s boundaries, as well as increased property values and tax rates. However, with the implementation of Proposition 13 in 1978, the city•s property tax revenues declined 4.6 percent. Other taxes, such as franchise, transient lodging, and business license, also substantiated the expansion of Palmdale•s businesses (Table 4-12). Summary In a 20-year span Antelope Valley has become more economically diversified and urbanized. Business activities forming the economic base of the Valley indicate the trend toward diversification. In 1959 the base was primarily manufacturing, centered around the aircraft industry. By 1977, the base has been evenly distributed between manu- facturing, services and government. Of the 20 major employers of the Valley, employing more than 100 persons, eight are aerospace industries. This is an additional indication of the trend toward diversi- fication. It suggests less dependancy upon aircraft industries to form the economic base. However, the location for five of these eight industries is in Palmdale. Employment in Palmdale is also predomin- ately in the manufacturing category, making it the Valley•s manufac- FINANCIAL INSTITUTION ACTIVITY 1975-1979 Average Annual % Change** 1975-1979 % Change 1975 1976 1977 1978 1979 Commercial Banks Demand Deposits Savings Deposits Total Deposits* $ 44,146 $ 45,316 69,784 125,039 83,829 143,627 $ 52,357 92,991 157,105 $ 64,041 101 .657 186,580 $ 74,498 117,939 219,260 68.8 69.0 75.4 14.0 14.0 15. 1 121,482 139,981 163,890 183,619 207,860 71.1 14.4 $246,521 $283,608 $320,995 $370,199 $427,120 73.3 14.7 Savings and Loans Deposits TOTAL Deposits *Total Deposits will not equal sum of above due to variations in bookkeeping regarding interest earned on accounts of individual institutions. **Compounded Table 4-11 The banking activity in Palmdale and Lancaster from 1975 to 1979. thousands of dollars. Source: Deposits are in Urban Decision Systems, Inc. 0"1 0"1 "" GROWTH IN TAX REVENUES 1964-65 Average Annual % Change 1964-1969 1969-1974 1974-1979 1969-70 1974-75 1978-79 1979-80 $18,690 $34,019 $43,361 $73,535 8.4 12.7 11.1 187 340 434 735 8.4 12.7 11.1 0 85 108 184 Property Tax Revenue Assessed Valuation 12,134 Property Tax Levy*** 924 23,803 2,114 73,349 8,013 87,946 5,459 116,907 6,994 14.4 18.0 25.2 30,5 9.8 -2.7 Other Taxes Franchise Taxes Transient Lodging Business License 23,703 4,650 22 '140 60,176 45,417 23,641 110,734 60,687 21,267 NA NA NA 12.7 20.5 57.7 1.3 16. 5* 7.5* -2.6* Sales Tax Revenue** Total Taxable Sales $12,494 Sales Tax Remitted To City 125 Sales Tax Remitted To County 0 13,020 0 14,332 11.2 9.1 *Percent change from 1974-75 to 1978-79. **Calendar year corresponding to the first half of fiscal year. ***For county, school, and flood control purposes. Table 4-12 The growth of tax revenues in Palmdale from 1964 to 1980. thousands of dollars. Sources: Revenues are given in California State Board of Equalization; Tax Payers• Guide, Los Angeles County m ........ - - -~-__..._____~- - 68 turing center. Although the trend in the Valley is toward diversifi- cation, this is not evident in Palmdale. Employment and the city's economy are thus still subject to the cyclical activity of the aircraft industries. Growth in the fiscal structure of Antelope Valley presents evidence of increased community wealth, spending power, and growth. De- posits in the financial institutions in Palmdale and Lancaster have grown at a greater rate than inflation between 1975 and 1979. The tax revenue base is characteristic of a growing urbanized economy. This base is a positive indicator of the region's ability to finance public services, especially in Palmdale. Growth in Palmdale's tax revenues since fts incorporation in 1962 has increased at a greater rate than the Los Angeles-Long Beach-Anaheim Metropolitan Area CPl. have grown noticeably during the latter half of the 1970's. Revenues However, these data demonstrate that potential revenues have been lost by the city. This evidence is established first in the percent of payroll paid to employees residing outside Palmdale. It is again evidenced in the transportation pattern. The transportation pattern is further indication of the internal growth and urbanization of the Valley. It directs attention to the region's reduced dependancy on the Los Angeles area for employment. The pattern suggests the Valley is beginning to serve its employment needs (Fig. 4-1). These data, however, present additional evidence of Palmdale's loss of potential tax revenues. Increased traffic volume north on Sierra Highway at Avenue P is a definite indication of aircraft-industry employees residing elsewhere. Additionally, increased traffic north on Sierra Highway from Palmdale Boulevard and west of 69 Sierra Highway toward Antelope Valley Freeway suggests consumer movement, These consumers are compelled to look elsewhere to remedy retail and service deficiencies. The multiplier effect has been interrupted in Palmdale. Al- though employment is high, housing has not been adequate to meet the increased demand. At the same time, the city has insufficient retail and service businesses. Therefore, many inhabitants are spending their incomes outside the city. This tends to retard commercial dev- elopment and reveals the need of the community for more balanced development. ----- -- ...---- - 70 Fig. 4-1: ANTELOPE VALLEY TRENDS 1965- 1980 INDEX SOURCE: QUESTOR ASSOCIATES 4.5 4.0 3.5 3.0 r- r- r- Year CPI Popu. Empl. 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969 1970 1971 1972 1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 1979 1980 1.00 1.02 1.04 1.09 1.14 1.19 1.24 1.28 1.35 1.49 1.65 1,76 1.88 2.01 2.23 1.00 1.00 2.58 1.19 1.18 1.74 1.35 2.26 1.59 Agri. Acreage Traffic Volume Taxable Sales 1.00 1.05 1.11 1.04 1.31 1,24 0.89 0.71 0.72 0.79 0.84 0.62 1.03 0.94 1.00 1.01 1.00 0.97 1.03 1.06 1.12 1.22 1.29 1.29 1.28 1.32 1.35 1.10 1.10 I 1.37 1.55 1.64 1.90 2.10 2.21 2.35 2.53 3.02 3.45 4.15 2.81 2.5 2.0 .5 ._--+---+---+---+---+---~--+---+---+---;---+---+---+---+---1 0._~ ___.__~------------~--~----~---------------.. 1980 1975 1965 1970 YEAR 71 Footnotes 1Ralph W. Pfouts, editor, The Techniques of Urban Economic Analysis (\>Jest Trenton, New Jersey, 1960): 5-17-. 2Indepth discussion of the multiplier effect can be seen in: Robert K. Chisholm and Gilbert R. Whitaker, Jr., Forecasting Methods (Homewood, Illinois, 1971); Hilliam L. Henderson, Larry C. Ledebur, Urban Economics: Processes and Problems (New York, London, Sydney, Toronto, 1972); Ralph W. Pfouts, editor, Techniques of Urban Economic Analysis (West Trenton, New Jersey, 1960). 3Pfouts, pp. 318-320. 4susiness services are defined as finance, insurance, real estate, legal, advertising, stenographic, engineering, architectural, employment and credit services, 5Retail services are defined as personal such as beauty, barber, dry cleaning, etc., services and repair services. 6Growth rate was adjusted by the Los Angeles-Long Beach-Anaheim Metropolitan Area Consumer Price Index. This area had an average annual inflation rate from 1975 to 1979 of 7.9 percent. .n_ '- -- ~ CHAPTER V FUTURE GROWTH TRENDS The preceding chapters illustrated the socio-economic characteristics of Antelope Valley and the city of Palmdale in particular. The region as a whole grew steadily in population, housing, employment and businesses during the past two decades. Expansion in these areas was particularly rapid in the past five years. Palmdale, as an incorpor- ated city since 1962, kept pace with the region•s growth, emerging as the manufacturing center of the Valley. Economic growth of the Valley and Palmdale in the next ten years is dependent upon continuing expansion of the population, housing, and existing businesses. Growth of these factors will stimulate the dev- elopment of new business activities, specifically retail and service activities. It is therefore desirable to investigate future growth trends of the above stated factors. Population, Housing and Employment Trends Forecasts of the future population and houstng growth trends are determined using the average annual growth rate. Population increase in Antelope Valley is expected to continue more rapidly than Los Angeles County as a whole. 101 ,666. The region•s current population figure is This figure represents a gain of 23 percent in population since 1970. It compares with only a 2.5 percent overall gain in Los Angeles County over the same time period. In turn, Palmdale•s sphere 73 of influence currently represents 38,876 of the total Valley population figure; 12,113 of the sphere•s population reside in the city of Palmdale. While the Palmdale area attained a 23.7 percent growth gain, the city shows a 42.3 percent gain from 1970 to 1980, or a 4.2 percent annual gain. Using an annual growth gain of approximately 3 percent, Antelope Valley•s population is expected to increase at least 31,334 persons in the next decade. The population of Palmdale•s sphere of influence is anticipated to increase by 10,724 by 1990, a 27.6 percent gain. Popu- lation by 1990 in the city of Palmdale is predicted as 17,239, again a 42.3 percent increase (Table 5-l, Fig. 5-1). This continuing growth in population suggests a corresponding growth in market size. POPULATION TRENDS AND FORECAST PALMDALE, SPHERE OF INFLUENCE AND ANTELOPE VALLEY 1970-1990 Year City of Palmdale Palmdale Region Antelope Va 11 e.}:': 1970 8,511 31 ,429 82,875 1980 12,113 38,876 101 ,666 1985 14,451 44,300 115,800 1990 17,239 49,600 133,000 Table 5-l Sources: 1970 U. S. Census; 1980 U. S. Census; Southern California Association of Governments, ~·1ay 1978; 1985-1990 Planning Group, Los Angeles; Questor Associates. With a rapidly growing population, construction of an adequate number of housing units is essential. Again using the current growth rate of units, approximately 6.8 percent annually, housing units in 74 Fig. 5-1: POPULATION GROWTH 1970- 1990 Population ( OOO's) SOURCE: THE PLANNING GROUP, LOS ANGELES 160 I I Antelope Valley - 140 ~almdale phere of Influence .................. City of Palmdale 120 100 80 ~ - ~ / v ~ 60 40 ,..... -~ ~- --- --- - .._..,.... -~ -... ----- -~- ............... 20 ...................... ....................... ~- .,_. ••••• lie . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0 1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 75 Antelope Valley are expected to number 68,935 by 1990. This repre- sents an increase of 68.1 percent, or 27,925 units, during the decade. Of the total number of new housing units in the Valley, 23,812 will be attributed to Palmdale•s sphere of influence, representing a The city of Palmdale is expected to increase 66.4 percent increase. its housing to 7,714 units or 56 percent by 1990 (Table 5-2). These data suggest housing for the population increase should be adequate. HOUSING TRENDS AND FORECAST PALMDALE, SPHERE OF INFLUENCE AND ANTELOPE VALLEY 1970-1990 City of Palmdale Palmdale Region Antelope Year 1970 2,816 10,610 27,044 1980 4,945 14,310 41 ,010 1985* 6,329 18,459 53,169 1990* 7,714 23,812 68,935 Valle~ *Based upon present gro\'Jth rate. Table 5-2 Sources: 1970 U. S. Census; 1980 U.S. Census; 1985-1990 Planning Group, Los Angeles; Antelope Valley Board of Trade. Employment growth is expected to coincide with population growth and the expansion plans of the Valley•s existing employers. 1 The region•s employment base is expected to expand at an average annual rate of 7.5 percent during the next five years, 1980 to 1985. This growth rate is consistent with the growth from 1959 to 1980 (Table 53). Utilizing this percentage, approximately 8,400 new jobs will be created over the next five years in the Valley. Employment in the basic activities 2 is anticipated to expand -·- --- - - ~· - 76 EMPLOYMENT GROWTH TRENDS PALMDALE-LANCASTER LABOR MARKET AREA 1959-1980 Average Annual Growth Rate* Year Employment 1959 12,200 1962 14 '150 5.1 1965 13,500 -1.6 1968 16,000 5.3 1973 23,525 8.0 1977 30,500 6.7 1980 37,985 7.6 *Compounded Table 5-3 Sources: California Department of Human Resources; U. S. Census Bureau; Antelope Valley Board of Trade; California Employment Development Department. 77 rapidly from 1980 to 1985. This, in turn, will stimulate employment growth in the service activities 3 and promote further population inmigration. In view of this anticipation, forecasts indicate producers, manufacturers and wholesalers plus retail trade and services will comprise the Valley•s fastest-growing industries. Existing firms in the basic activity category are expected to grow at an average annual compounded rate of 11.0 percent, creating 6,318 new jobs. Retail trade and service businesses are expected to increase by 6.6 percent and 8.8 percent during the same time period, establishing 633 additional positions (Table 5-4). Palmdale, as the manufacturing center of the Valley, is expected to show significant growth in basic activities over the next five years. It is forecast that existing firms will increase their employment by an average annual compounded rate of 6.7 percent. The fastest-growing industries will be producers, manufacturers, wholesalers and construction contractors. Retail trade and all services will increase but not as significantly, thus increasing pressure on Palmdale•s existing public service capacity (Table 5-5). Expansion Plans and Employee Skill Requirements To arrive at economic growth projections, the existing businesses in the Valley were surveyed as to their plans for expansion in the future and the employee skill levels needed to support their economic activities. 4 The businesses surveyed indicated a significant level of facility expansion over the next five to ten years. Approximately 22.6 percent of the employers stated their businesses would expand in 1981 for a total increase of 29.4 percent in physical space (Table 5-6). Current employment among the firms surveyed is approximately 24,365, representing 64.1 percent of the Valley•s total employment. 78 EMPLOYMENT GROWTH BY INDUSTRY ANTELOPE VALLEY 1980 Total Employment Industry Producers, Manufacturers, Wholesalers 1985 Tot a1 Employment % Change 1980-1985 Average Annual % Change* 1980-1985 9,196 15,514 68.7 11.0 542 649 19.7 3.7 Government, Business Services 7,621 7,713 1.2 0.2 Health and Public Utilities 3,281 3,946 20.3 3.8 Retail Trade 1,282 1,764 37.6 6.6 288 439 52.4 8.8 Construction Contractors Retail Services Weighted Average** 6.2 *Compounded **Based on 1977 employment by industry in the Antelope Valley. Table 5-4 Sources: Antelope Valley Board of Trade; Qeustor Associates Employer Survey. p ' 79 BUSINESS EMPLOYMENT GROWTH BY INDUSTRY PALMDALE % Change 1980-1985 Average Annual % Change* 1980-1985 Industr,x: 1980 1985 Producers, Hanufacturers, l~ho 1esa 1ers 5,550 11,770 112 '1 16.2 45 70 55.5 9.2 Government, Business Services 684 767 12. 1 2.3 Health and Public Utilities 76 78 2.6 0.5 Retail Trade 539 645 19.7 3.7 Retail Services 110 117 6.4 1.2 Construction Cant ractors ** Weighted Average** 6.7 *Compounded **Based on 1977 employment by industry in the Antelope Valley. Table 5-5 Sources: Antelope Valley Board of Trade; Questor Employer Survey. p ' 80 The employee skill levels needed by these employers to support their economic activities were ranked as follows: basic skills, technical skills, professional skills, administrative and advanced professional skills, and other skills. 5 Of the employers surveyed, 49 percent needed employees with such qualities as personality and sales ability. The economic structure of Antelope Valley is dominated by manufacturing, retail trade and services; therefore, Palmdale and Lancaster employers generally require similar skill levels (Table 5-7). requirements vary also by industry group. Skill Producers, manufacturers, and wholesalers in the Valley need employees with technical, professional and other skills (Table 5-8). Moreover, Palmdale's manufactur- ers require a high percentage of technical and professional employees because of their involvement in the aircraft and space industries. Skill level requirements in the other industry groups are mainly the same with the Palmdale employers as they are throughout the Valley (Table 5-9). The skill levels required by a majority of the employers are for the basic and technical skills. Advanced professional skills are the least needed. Air Transportation This paper would be incomplete if mention of air transportation were not discussed. In 1980 the average number of passenger trips per business was 38.9 (Table 5-10) and approximately 16.4 percent of all Antelope Valley employers used air freight to some degree (Table 5-11). Both direct and indirect economic benefits will result if the Palmdale International Airport is constructed. Direct benefits are those re- sulting from operating, maintaining and providing services to users of the airport facilities. Indirect economic benefits result from busi- 81 PLANNED EXPANSION OF EXISTING FIRMS ANTELOPE VALLEY 1981 Mean Square Feet of Physical Space Expansion of Physical Space* Industry Group % of Firms Expanding Producers, Manufacturers, Wholesalers 33.3 179,341 35.9 Construction Contractors 28.6 192 '140 44.3 Government, Business Services 16.7 60 '115** 1.7 Health and Public Utilities 35.7 59,700 8.2 Retail Trade 18.8 6,910 32.2 Retail Services 30.4 10,179 59.5 t4ei ghted Average 22.6 29.4 N = 200 *Expressed as a percentage of existing space. **Not including Edwards Air Base. If Edwards were included, the average would increase to 652,821 square feet. Table 5-6 Source: Questor Associates Employer Survey 02 EMPLOYEE SKILLS NEEDED BY EMPLOYERS PALMDALE, LANCASTER AND ANTELOPE VALLEY Palmdale Ski 11 s Needed Lancaster Antelope Valley Basic 22.3% 24.8% 24.5% Technical 23.2 25.2 24.5 Professional 1o. 7 7.5 9.8 2.7 2. 1 1.8 41.1 40.1 39.4 TOTAL 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% N= ( 112) (322) (483) Administrative/ Professional Other Table 5-7 Source: Questor Associates Employer Survey. EMPLOYEE SKILL NEEDS BY INDUSTRY GROUP ANTELOPE VALLEY Producers, Manufacturers, Wholesalers Construction Contractors Government, Business Services Health Public Utility Services Basic 19.0% 27.3% 31.5% 22.2% 23.7% 29.2% Technical 31.0 54.5 25.7 18.5 18.5 37.5 Professional 23.8 0.0 17.1 29.7 1.5 4.1 0.0 0.0 0.0 18.5 0.0 0.0 26.2 18.2 25.7 11.1 56.3 29.2 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100. 0~~ 100.0% 100.0% Skills Most Needed Administrative/ Professional Other TOTAL Retai 1 Trade Retail Services N = 274 Table 5-8 Source: Questor Associates Employer Survey. co w "' EMPLOYEE SKILLS NEEDED BY INDUSTRY GROUP PALMDALE Producers, Manufacturers, Hholesalers Skills Needed Basic 0.0% Government, Business Services Health and Public Utility Services 22.2% 16.7% 28.2% 50.0% Retail Trade Retail Services Technical 55.5 33.3 33.3 12.8 0.0 Professional 40.0 11 •1 16.7 2.6 0.0 Administrative/ Professional 5.0 o.o 16.7 0.0 0.0 Other 0.0 33.3 16.7 56.4 50.0 100.0% 99.9% 100.2% 100.0% 100.0% TOTAL N = 66 Table 5-9 Source: Questor Associates Employer Survey. (X) -::::- 35 BUSINESS GENERATED PASSENGER AIR TRAVEL BY AIRPORT OF ORIGIN Airport of Origin Number of Trips % of All Trips Palmdale Airport 554 7.9 Los Angeles International 5' 143 73.3 Hollywood-Burbank 1,104 15.7 Orange County 6 0.1 Ontario International 7 0.1 Long Beach 1 0.0 203 2.9 7,018 100.0 Other TOTAL N = 180 Table 5-10 Source: Questor Associates Employer Survey. 86 AIR FREIGHT SERVICE DEMAND 1980 Industr~ Percent of Industry Using Air Freight Groue Percent of Total Air Freight Users Producers, ~1anufacturers, Wholesalers 33.3 25.0 Construction Contractors 0.0 0.0 Government, Business Services 13.3 6.3 -Health and Public Utility Services 15.4 6.3 Retail Trade 13.0 46.9 Retai 1 Services 23.8 15.6 16.4%* TOTAL 100.1% *Weighted Average Table 5-11 Source: Questor Associates Employer Survey. 87 nesses have been formulated with the development of this airport in mind. Two Antelope Valley employer groups, producers, manufacturers and wholesalers and government and business service, demonstrate the greatest demand for air transportation (Table 5-12). Of these two groups, the producers, manufacturers and wholesalers account for the greatest demand for both passenger service (Table 5-13) and air freight service (Table 5-14). Forecasts anticipate growth in this industry in the next five years at a greater rate than the local economy as a whole. As this industry group grows, the demand for increased air transportation will grow also. Summary Projections indicate there will be major expansion in the Antelope Valley's population and employment over the next ten years. The Valley's population is expected to increase by 31,334 persons. By 1990, the city of Palmdale will have a population of over 17,000. Coinciding with the anticipated population growth and expansion plans of existing businesses, the creation of 8,400 new jobs is expected. The projected growth in these areas has been based on the anticipated development of an international airport, the Valley's current low housing costs and the expansion of the aircraft industry for defense. These factors have encouraged employers to consider expansion and should act as stimuli in the development of new businesses. With these anticipated growth changes will come an increased demand for all services and retail activities. New business development plans in Palmdale should aim at expanding its economic base. As the population grows, the development of government, business and retail p ' 88 FREQUENCY OF AIR FREIGHT USE BY INDUSTRY Very Frequent Industry Group Frequent Occasionally Total Producers, Manufacturers, Wholesalers 42.9% 14.3% 42.8% 100.0% Government and Business Services 50.0 0.0 50.0 100.0 Health and Public Utility Services 0.0 0.0 100.0 100.0 Retai 1 Trade 21.4 7.2 71.4 100.0 Retail Services 40.0 20.0 40.0 100.0 N - 60 Table 5-12 Source: Questor Associates Employer Survey. NUMBER OF BUSINESS TRIPS REQUIRING AIR TRANSPORTATION BY INDUSTRY 1980 Number TriQ.L Producers, Manufacturers, \•Jho 1esa 1ers 0-5 Construction Contractors Government, Business Services Health and Public Utility Services Retai 1 Trade Reta i 1 Services 46.5% 85.7% 66.7% 64.3% 88.9% 85.0% 6-10 8.3 0.0 6.7 7. 1 6.5 5.0 11-25 16.7 14.3 6.7 0.0 2.8 5.0 26-50 4.2 0.0 13.3 21.4 0.9 5.0 51-100 8.3 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 101-200 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 Over 200 16.0 0.0 6.6 7.2 0.9 0.0 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% TOTAL N = 188 Table 5-13 Source: Questor Associates Employer Survey. co \.0 PERCENTAGE OF YEARLY PRODUCTION SHIPPED BY AIR FREIGHT USERS 1980 Producers, Manufacturers, Percentage Shipped t~holesa1ers Less than 10% Government, Business Services Health and Public Utility Services Retai 1 Trade Retai 1 Services 66.7% 0.0% 100.0% 84.6% 20.0% 10-25% 0.0 0.0 0.0 15.4 60.0 26-50 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 51-75 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 76-90 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 20.0 91-100 33.3 100.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% 100.0% TOTAL N = 27 Table 5-14 Source: Questor Associates Employer Survey. 1..0 0 "" 91 services will be essential to the city•s economic stability. 92 Footnotes 1Estimation is based on information obtained from the Antelope Valley Board of Trade and Questor Associates• recent growth trend analysis. 2Basic activities compose those activities of a community involved in the export of goods and services to firms or individuals outisde the community•s economic boundaries. 3service activities include those enterprises which provide for the needs of persons within the community•s economic limit. 4Refer to the Employer Survey in Appendix B. 5Basic skills are those developed at the high school level; technical skills are those acquired in vocational or technical training; professional skills included those obtained with a college degree; administrative and advanced professional skills include those requiring postgraduate or advanced training; other skills include subjective qualities such as personality and sales ability. . - CHAPTER VI RESIDENTIAL AND COt1t~ERCIAL LAND USE The preceding chapters illustrate the economy of Palmdale, one of Antelope Valley•s major cities. Utilizing the current commercial structure and projected growth trends of Palmdale, several land use strategies are proposed with a goal of rectifying the deficiencies and developing potentials. Proposed Land Use The city of Palmdale is aware of the fact that potential benefits are being lost because of inadequate housing and lack of retail and service businesses. Toward rectifying these deficiencies, the city has been exploring a number of plans. The Palmdale Redevelopment Agency is working with the city council and Planning Commission in renovating Palmdale•s central business district and the construction of additional housing. A Community Development Corporation, in cooper- ation with the United States Small Business Administration, has been created by the city council. Their function is to explore financing and encourage commercial development. The combined effort of these community agencies has resulted in four main residential redevelopment areas. These areas are, for the most part, expansions of existing residential areas (Map 13). The construction of low interest, single-family housing, begun in 1980, is progressing toward easing the acute housing shortage (Table 6-1). Additionally, over 1000 apartment and condominium units have been con93 94 40th Street E. 0 I co 0) (/) z 3 5th Street E. 0 1- ~--J[~~J--t--t~--_j~ ~z -ci ~ Q) ""'"' _J .r: .... 20th Street W · Q) .c .!::! "' iii I. "' E <X: "0 Q) "0 Jt "' ..!! ~ ~] 95 SINGLE-FAMILY HOUSING PAU1DALE 1980-1981 Units Constructed Proposed Constructed* Manzanita Heights Fifth Street West south of Palmdale Boulevard 125 300 Va11 ey Vi s ta West of Tenth Street West 77 100 Country Club area North of Avenue P and east of Tenth Street West 90 250 Harris Homes Avenue R and Fifteenth Street East 37 50 Casa Linda Twenty-fifth Street East to Thirtieth Street East between Avenue R and Avenue S 177 250 Joshua Hills Twenty-fifth Street East to Thirtieth Street East south of Avenue S 280 600 35 50 821 1 ,600 Area Concord Estates West of Tierra Subida and north of Avenue S TOTAL Table 6-1 Sources: Field Survey; Palmdale Redevelopment Agency; Antelope Valley Board of Trade. 96 structed since early 1980 (Table 6-2), The units being constructed range in price from $60,000 to $180,000 and are offered at 9-7/8% interest. This price range places the units within the reach of the majority of Palmdale residents (Table 6-3). space industry is expanding in Palmdale. Additionally, the aero- The industry anticipates an influx of 4,000 to 5,000 families into the city during the next few years. However, the majority of the housing units have sold before this growth occurred. These facts combined with Palmdale's current vacancy rate of only one percent indicates the city will not be able to house the anticipated population increase unless housing construction is rapidly expanded. The Planning Commission and related agencies have also been striving for commercial development in the city. An earlier chapter mentions the renovation of the central business district and the construction of new government and cultural buildings. planning stage are three additional shopping centers. Currently in the Two centers are planned on Palmdale Boulevard near Twentieth Street East. One is to be situated between Seventeenth Street East and Twentieth Street East, the other at Twenty-fifth Street East where a large chain general merchandise center has recently opened. These centers are designed to accommodate financial institutions, restaurants and other commercial establishments and to stimulate commercial activity in the eastern section of Palmdale. The third shopping center is planned to accomplish the same aim, commercial activity stimulation, for Palmdale's western section. The location of this shopping center will be on Palmdale Boulevard near Fifth Street West. It is intended that this center include an intertainment center and a number of specialty 97 HULTI-FANILY HOUSING PALHDALE 1980-1981 Units Constructed Area Country Club Area (Condominiums) North of Avenue P and east of Tenth Street West 250 The Villas of Palmdale (Condominiums) Avenue R-4 and Thirtieth Street East 56 Post Office Area Ninth Street East to Eleventh Street East 390 Fifth Street East Area North of Palmdale Boulevard 242 Fifth Street East to Sixth Street East South of Palmdale Boulevard 46 Division Street to Third Street East South of Palmdale Boulevard 64 Lark Apartments Avenue Q-12 and Eleventh Street East Avenue Q-7, East of Division Street 48 36 TOTAL Table 6-2 1,132 Sources: Field Survey; Palmdale Redevelopment Agency; Antelope Valley Board of Trade. ". ......... - - 98 RESIDENTIAL GRO\.JTH AREAS PALMDALE 1980-1981 Present Population* Area Growth Income Range** Desert View Highlands Area West of Tenth Street West at Avenue P-8 South of Palmdale Boulevard between Division Street and Tenth Street Hest 9,709 $15,000 - $50,000 Country Club Area Avenue P between Tenth Street West and Sierra Highway 4,000 $50,000 - $150,000 Joshua Hills Area Twenty-fifth Street East to Thirtieth Street East south of Avenue S 7,500 $30,000 - $150,000 Sagetree Area Twenty-fifth Street East to Fortieth Street East between Avenues R and S 5,500 $20,000 - $40,000 *Approximate present population due to monthly in and out-migration. **Income range can be greater. Table 6-3 Sources: Field survey; Palmdale Redevelopment Agency. 99 stores. In addition to the proposed commercial expansion, two large industrial plants are to be built within the next two years at Thirtieth Street East and Avenue P (Map 14). As has been mentioned previously, Palmdale can expect an increase in population and employment. To gain the benefits of poten- tial sales and tax revenues, the city must encourage the development of additional housing, retail and service activities and manufacturing within its limits. Potential Land Use Major considerations in locating retail, service and manufacturing activities are population, economic stability and accessibility. Within the next decade predictions indicate Palmdale•s population will be approximately 18,000. Two factors influence this prediction. First, low-cost housing is available. A large number of units, both single and multifamily, are currently under construction, and the construction of additional units in the near future is planned (note Map 13). A second factor influencing population projections is the expan- sion of the aerospace industry which will create 4,000 or more new jobs. Population density is paramount in developing retail and serv- ice locations. Studies suggest that consumers will attempt to mini- mize the distance they must travel to shop by visiting the nearest store to their home. 1 Again, noting Map 13 regarding residential expansion, an insight as to the optimal locations begins to form. Three areas of population concentration emerge: Desert View Highlands area, extending from Fifth Street West to Eighteenth Street West and Avenues R to P; Palmdale proper, Division Street to Fifteenth Street East and Avenues R to P; and, Palmdale East, Fifteenth Street East to Thirtieth INDUSTRIAL AREAS 1981 I. Proposed Areas Commercial Industrial 0 • SCALE % % Miles + N ...... 0 0 101 Street East and Avenues S to Q. Furthermore, this population consists mainly of the middle income group. Accessibility and traffic volume and patterns are the key to optimum locations. To analyze the flow and volume increase, a recent survey was conducted. A significant volume increase is evident since 1979 at key intersections (Table 6-4). The main flow of traffic is toward and on Palmdale Boulevard, the main east-west street of Palmdale (Map 15). Public transportation may prove an important factor in the location of businesses. such transportation. Until recently the city has had little or no However, this situation has changed during the past year with the development of a daily scheduled bus route (Table 6-5) and bus stops along Palmdale Boulevard (Map 15). Currently, a major hindrance to accessibility is a street divider which runs the length of Palmdale Boulevard. Left turn lanes are at a minimum from Tenth Street East to Twentieth Street East. Although locations have excellent visibility, ready accessibility is negligible. This is a problem which should be rectified in the near future to improve access to the available sites in this area. Earlier studies indicate the city•s need for increased social and public services. This need is because of the high percentage of elderly persons and the high fertility level in the city. Steps to- ward centrally housing the elderly have been developing with the construction of low-rent apartments in the post office area, Ningh Street East to Eleventh Street East. all shopping requirements. This area is within walking distance of Future renovation of the area from Palmdale Boulevard to Avenue Q-10 and Sierra Highway to Tenth Street East should include health and social services for the elderly and the very young TRAFFIC VOLUME - PALMDALE 1981 Intersection % Increase Travel Direction 1979* 1981* Palmdale Boulevard and Sierra Highway East and west on Palmdale Boulevard 20,200 23,616 16.9 Palmdale Boulevard and Tenth Street West East on Palmdale Boulevard 18,561 19,680 6.0 Palmdale Boulevard and Twentieth Street East West on Palmdale Boulevard 10,500 11,808 12.5 Sierra Highway and Avenue P East and west on Avenue P 11,147 17,328 55.4 *Daily Volume Table 6-4 Source: Field survey. --' C> N "" 103 z I $ 0 ....J u.. "3 lBBJlS 4l0E c:i Cl z > ..1 L.U w <( IXl ~0 ..1 ::>CO ~+ ....JC> 0.- >'C> <(LO c.. (.)I' -C> u.. ..- . N .- 0 U..LJ.J <(,....J 0::<( --.. ..."_._ "3 laaJlS 4l02: 0 1-o ~ z~ -....J L.U<( (.!)O.. z <( :r:: ... (.) 1- z -. of 1- L.U (.) t- 0:: L.U ·I- . 0.. 1..0 ..c. ro ~ 1 Il . 3 lBBJlS 4l0 ~ southern Pacific R. R. I I -1 I I I I I -, ; I -I -- SIEflfiP.. HWY · I I 1 .... ...-- 0 ~ ~ I I I 1.2 ~ 6 tn street E J r7 0 I 0 .; ~ .. "'"' "'"J 0 a: .; > <( > <( '<:t OJo Lri LO "lS UO!S!II!O c.. )ANTELOPE VP..LLEY ff\EEWP..Y ~ \ <( 0 .; > <( ~/ Oo -b~ ":!:)" .._,"';:j ~ .,._J- 1. ~ ~z " ,(~ 0 "Ml88JlS 4l0~ " 0 tO -ca: ~ "' ..1 ... ..c:: 1l "' ~ w "'ell :a: ::: !: .Q 8-"' -~ ... .... .... en ..."' "'::> IXl 1u. ~ w ..1 <( (.) en ~I ~ 0 0 --104 PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION SCHEDULE PAU.1DALE 1981 Daily Time Number of Buses Destination 7 Every 3 hrs. for 24 hrs. Burbank 3 8 a.m. - 12 noon - 4 p.m. Los Angeles International Airport 6 Every 2 hrs. Palmdale Boulevard Lancaster 3 Every 2 hrs. from 9:30 a.m. Palmdale General Hospital on Avenue S to 3:30 p.m. Table 6-5 Sources: Field survey; Antelope Valley Bus, Inc. 105 The same area should incorporate some form of multifamily housing, especially for the elderly. Again this would place them within walking distance of all retail and service needs, as well as bus stops. After analyzing the information and studies of the socio-economic characteristics of Palmdale, three areas within the city can be considered as potential retail growth sites. These areas are: l) the area west of the Antelope Valley Freeway along Palmdale Boulevard, 2) the area along Palmdale Boulevard between Twentieth Street East and Twenty-fifth Street East, and, 3) the area encompassed by Sierra Highway on the east, Avenue P on the south and Division Street on the west (Map 16). These areas are compatible with existing zoning regulations (Table 6-6). POTENTIAL GROWTH AREA ZONING RETAIL AND SERVICE ACTIVITIES Zone* Area Palmdale Boulevard between Tenth Street West and Division Street C-3 and CPO Palmdale Boulevard between Twentieth Street East and Twenty-fifth Street East C-3 Sierra Highway at Avenue P to Division Street C-3 and CPO Palmdale Boulevard to Avenue Q-10 and Sierra Highway to Tenth Street East C-3 and R-3 *C-3 r~edium Commercial CPO Commercial Planned Development R-3 Residential-Medium Density Multiple Table 6-6 The map of existing retail structures (Map 8, Appendix C) shows that the majority of retailing in Palmdale is centrally located, concentrated between Division Street to the west and Tenth Street on the ....- - l 06 -r I r I I - + + til Sli=RRA_ 1-\W'f. I ,,, == = ~ = - . 3 lBBJlS 4l0 L I T T - ... '-' ,,I 71' ~ I ~ = = 0 l z r"--r---~/ - "M ~aaJlS 4l0"T 13 ~ ~ :§ 0 E 0 u s e c.. I I ~ ·s~ "0 c: ~ ~:~I - I 107 east. The fringe areas, both west and east, consequently tend to be attractive for retail and service activities. Currently the majority of retailing activities in the area west of the freeway consists of motels, restaurants, fast-food establishments and gasoline service stations. Several factors enhance this area. First, there is a large number of existing residential units as well as a large number of new units and units under construction (note Table 6-1). A second factor adding to the advantages of this area is the increased traffic volume and flow from Tenth Street West traveling east on Palmdale Boulevard. As noted earlier, consumers attempt to minimize the distance they must travel to shop if possible. With the establishment of new retail busi- nesses in this area, consumers would have the incentive to reduce their travel distance. Other factors enhancing this area are the easy on- and-off ramps of the nearby freeway, numerous bus stops along the boulevard, and the close proximity of a number of motels. Since this area already contains a number of fast-food businesses and gas stations, other retail activities are recommended. Such activities include a good department store and a number of specialty shops. Also recommended for this area is an entertainment center in- cluding a movie theater. Currently Palmdale has one very small the- ater located in the center of the city. The new entertainment activi- ties should be successful since approximately 50 percent of Palmdale's population is between the ages of 18 and 35, an entertainment oriented age group. The second potential retail growth site is in the area between Twentieth and Twenty-fifth Streets East along Palmdale Boulevard (note Map 16). Presently, one gas station is occupying the southwest corner p ' 108 at the intersection of Twenty-fifth Street East and the boulevard. This is an area of rapid residential expansion extending from south of Avenue S to Avenue Rand north (note Map 13). Twenty-fifth Street East is also a direct travel route from the residential area to the airport and industrial area of Palmdale. is competition. Another factor enhancing this area In close proximity is a general merchandise store, drugstore and several specialty shops. Activities recommended for this area are food stores, clothing stores, specialty shops, service activities, liquor store and a major restaurant. The third potential retail growth area encompasses the area from Sierra Highway to Division Street along Avenut P (note Map 16). retail activities exist in this area currently. No The same advantages occur in this area as the previous areas with the added incentive of no existing retail activities. New residential units, both single- family and multifamily, are being constructed (note Map 13). vol~me Also the of traffic on Avenue P from the industrial area has increased greatly. New retail firms would act as intervening opportunities for shoppers traveling between the residential area and the major existing retail center in Palmdale as well as Lancaster, It would also offer opportunities for shoppers enroute from place of work to their homes. Recommended activities for this area could range from gas stations and various service businesses to a shopping mall with varied retail firms including a convenience food store, liquor store, specialty shops, and other activities of similar market requirements. Predictions indicate that Palmdale, as the manufacturing center of the Valley, will have significant growth in basic activities. Therefore, potential manufacturing areas should be investigated. --109 Again three specific areas can ing growth sites. be~considered as potential manufactur- These areas are: 1) the area along Sierra Highway between Avenues P and 0, 2) the area on the east side of Tenth Street West between Avenues P and P-8, and, 3) the area between Fifteenth and Twenty-fifth Streets East and Avenues P and Q (Map 16). Currently these three areas are compatible with existing zoning regulations (Table 6-7). POTENTIAL GROWTH AREA ZONING MANUFACTURING Zone* Area Sierra Highway between Avenues P and 0 t·1-2 and t·1PD Tenth Street West between Avenues P and P-8 MPD Fifth Street East to Twenty-fifth Street East from Avenues P to Q M-2 and M-A *M-2 Medium Manufacturing and Industrial M-A Aircraft Manufacturing t1PD ~1anufacturi ng Plan ned Development Table 6-7 The overall advantage of these areas is the close proximity to the airport and/or a direct transportation route to the airport. Also present in the immediate vicinity are several freight-hauling businesses (note Map 8). Since transportation is a crucial factor in the location of industries, these areas incorporate optimum sites for manufacturers. Palmdale is a rapidly growing community and promises to continue to develop. The projected population increase, the large number of middle-income housing units under construction and in the planning stage, and the emergence of new industries should provide a growing -110 market for both new and existing retail and service businesses, With careful and thoughtful planning for its present and future needs, this city can have a vital and thriving economy, an economy which realizes all its potentials in both tax and sales revenues. In the future, Palmdale should emerge, not only as the manufacturing center, but as a leading city in retailing and service activities of Antelope Valley. 111 Footnotes 1Discussion of consumer behavior can be found in: William Applebaum and Saul B. Cohen, "The Dynamics of Store Trading Areas and t~arket Equilibrium, .. Annuals, Association of American Geographers, 51 (March, 1961): 73-101; Brian J. L. Berry, ''Ribbon Developments in the Urban Business Pattern, .. Annals, Association of American Geographers, 49 (June, 1959): 145-155; F. W. Baal and D. B. Johnson, 11 The Functions of Retail and Service Establishments on Commercial Ribbons, .. Canadian Geographer, 9 (1965): 154-196; Saul B. Cohen and 11 ~Jilliam Applebaum, Evaluating Store Sites and Determining Store Rents,'' Economic Geo{raphy, 36 (January, 1960): l-35; Ross L. Davies, Marketing Geography London: Methuen & Co. Ltd,, 1976): 198-229. CHAPTER VII CONCLUSION Initially, the city of Palmdale was a rural community on the high desert. Because of its geographical location, a gradual transi- tion from agriculture to industry began in the late 1940's. The air- craft industry found the locality ideal for developing and testing their products. Consequently, Palmdale began converting from a strictly rural area to the manufacturing center of Antelope Valley. This conversion effected changes in the population and commercial development of the city. Development, however, was dependent upon the basic industry, aircraft, which was subject to periodic economic fluctuations. Therefore, an investigation of commercial and industrial activities that would expand and stabilize Palmdale's economic base was deemed feasible. In developing such a plan, Palmdale's current economic picture was assessed and future trends projected. Palmdale has experienced a dramatic population growth, especially during the past ten years, 1970 to 1980. 42 percent gain occurred. In this time span a An additional 42 percent population growth is conservatively forecast for the next ten years. The data also dis- close that 26.5 percent of Palmdale's employees reside outside the city, In this context, the first step in the development plan should examine housing. Examination of housing growth data in Palmdale reveals an in- 112 113 crease of 76 percent from 1970 to 1980. The forecast indicates a 56 percent growth rate of new housing units for the next decade. How- ever, Palmdale•s vacancy rate for 1980 is only one percent, in contrast to a rate of four to seven percent generally considered necessary for a fluid and balanced housing market. This being the case, the city should increase the construction of new housing units, both single and multi-family, Expansion of housing to meet present and future demands could be feasible. Vacant land borders the established residential areas allowing for expansion. This fact, coupled with an active Planning Commission, makes expansion probable, assuming current interest rates drop. Population data indicate that currently 20 percent of Palmdale•s residents are 60 years of age and older. Services, both social and public, should be incorporated in the city•s redevelopment plan for the business nucleus. The data also establish that child-related services are needed due to a high fertility rate and children under the age of eighteen years. Nursery schools, private and public, and recreation-park areas should be considered. Recreation areas should be incorporated in each of the residential expansion plans to accommodate the needs of the increasing population. Provision for recrea- tional and cultural areas is important when anticipating a future population influx due to the expansion of commercial and industrial activities. Palmdale, as the manufacturing center of Antelope Valley, accounts for 79 percent of the total industrial employment of the Valley. The prediction is that existing basic activities will in- crease their employment 6.7 percent annually for the next five years. 114 During this same time span 22.6 percent of existing businesses, both service and basic, indicate intentions of expanding their facilities. The future expansion of existing firms should parallel the introduction of new businesses. expansion. Several factors indicate the desirability of One is that 46 percent of Palmdale•s work force is em- ployed outside the city. A second factor involves the shopping pat- tern of Palmdale residents where one-third of the households shop in Lancaster or elsewhere. Thirdly, a high percentage of service acti- vities, public and retail, are located in Lancaster. In an effort to expand and stabilize Palmdale•s economic base, commercial and manufacturing expansion zones have been proposed. Three commercial areas are considered optimum location sites as a result of their proximity to residential areas, traffic volume and flow, accessibility and competition. Various types of retail and service activities have been suggested based on the population age profile, shopping distance minimization, travel to place of work and competition. The manufacturing sites are considered optimum locations due to the close proximity of transportation, air, rail and truck. This study, combined with a forward-looking, active city council and Planning Commission, could conceivably expand and stabilize the economic base of Palmdale. As noted previously, Palmdale has become the manufacturing center of Antelope Valley. Projection data indicate the city will main- tain this role, while Lancaster will continue expanding as the retail center of the Valley. Currently, the two cities are steadily extend- ing their growth, residential and commercial, toward each other. An overlapping of the two cities• boundaries is entirely probable during 115 the next decade. This being the case, Palmdale and Lancaster should consider regional planning in the near future. Cooperative planning by the two cities should include government, transportation and retail activities. A regional government serving both cities would solve several of Palmdale•s current public service deficiencies, especially those serving the elderly. During the past year, a regional transportation plan has been developed, The initial efforts of this plan have been well received; however, the transportation network should be enlarged thus serving a considerable proportion of the area•s population. A large regional shopping center should be considered for the future for several reasons. One reason is the shopping patterns developed over a number of years by the Valley•s residents, especially Palmdale•s residents, are difficult to change. Another is the projected data which indicate Palmdale•s eco- nomic base will continue as manufacturing and Lancaster•s as retailservice. With a large regional shopping center developed approximate- ly at midpoint between the two cities, Palmdale could then encourage the development of specialty retail and service businesses which would best serve the local residents• needs, Regional planning is a realistic outcome resulting from the data presented herein. Regional planning would not deter Palmdale•s effort to expand and stabilize its economic base, but would most likely enhance the effort, This study is open ended. The economic picture of Palmdale is changing even while this thesis is being written. Such changes are to be expected in a community where the economy is not static. How- ever, this study is not intended to present definitive answers for ~ . 116 Pa1mdale•s economic problems. It is an examination of the city•s economic growth over a twenty-year time period and an investigation of commercial activities that would best expand and stabilize the economy. It is hoped this research will be of value as background for future analyses of the community•s economic growth and development. BIBLIOGRAPHY 11 A Story of Achievement and Transition--1930 Progress Edition ... Antelope Valley Ledger-Gazette. Lancaster, California: Cameron and Hubbard, Publ., November, 1930, Antelope Valley Board of Trade. 1980 Antelope Valley Progress Documentary. Lancaster, California, 1980. 1-27. Antelope VAlley Board of Trade. 1981 Antelope Valley Progress Documentary. Lancaster, California, 1981. 1-22, 1-39. Antelope Valley Ledger-Gazette. 1970-1980. Antelope Valley Press. Lancaster, California, 1950-1960, Palmdale, California, 1960-1965, 1970-1979. Applebaum, William. 11 Can Store Location Be a Science? .. Geography, 41, 3 (July, 1965) 234-237. Economic Applebaum, William and others. Guide to Store Location Research. Ed. by Curt Kornblau. Reading, ~·1assachusetts: Addison-Hesley Publishing Co., 1968. Applebaum, William. 11 Teaching Marketing Geography by the Case Method. 11 Economic Geography, 37, 1 (January, 1961) 48-60. Applebaum, \<Jilliam, Saul B. Cohen. The Dynamics of Store Trading Areas and ~1arket Equilibrium. Annals, Association of American Geographers, 51, 1 (March, 1961) 73-101. Bell, Thomas L., Stanley R. Lieber, and Gerard Rushton. 11 Clustering of Services in Central Places, 11 Annals, Association of American Geographers, 64, 2 (June, 1974) 214-225. 11 11 Bernard, Jessie. American Community Behavior. Press, 1949. New York: The Dryden Berry, Brian J. L. 11 The Impact of Expanding t1etropolitan Communities Upon the Central Place Hierarchy_.~ Annals, Association of American Geographers, 50, 2 (June, 1960) 112-116. Berry, Brian J. L. 11 Ribbon Developments in the Urban Business Pattern.11 Annals, Association of American Geographers, 49, 2 (June, 1959) 145-155. Berry, Brian J. L., Edgar C. Conkling, D. ~·1ichael Ray. The Geography of Economic Systems. Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: PrenticeHall, Inc., 1976. 117 118 Bloodgood, Mark H., auditor-controller. Tax Payers• Guide, 1980-1981. Los Angeles: County of Los Angeles Printing Service, 1981. Baal, F. H. and D. B. Johnson. "The Functions of Retail and Service Establishments on Commercial Ribbons." Canadian Geographer, 9, 3 (1965) 154-169. Bogue, Donald J. Principles of Demography. New York, London, Sydney, Toronto: John Wiley & Sons, Inc,, 1969. Bowden, Martyn J. ''Downtown Through Time: Delimitation, Expansion and Interna 1 Growth." Economic Geography, 47, 2 (Apri 1 , 1971) 121135. Briggs, Ronald. "A Model to Relate the Size of the Central Business District to the Population of a City." Geographical Analysis, 6, 3 (July, 1974) 265-279. Bucklin, Louis P. "Retain Gravity Models and Consumer Choice: A Theoretical and Empirical Critique." Economic Geography, 47, 4 (October, 1971) 489-497. Cadwaller, Martin. "A Behavioral Model of Consumer Spatial Decision t1aking." Economic Geography, 51, 4 (October, 1975) 339-349. California Department of Transportation (Caltrans). Traffic Volumes on California State Highways, Sacramento, California, 1980. California State Board of Equalization. Tax Sales in California, Sales and Use Tax. Annual Report. California Document: Sacramento, California, 1980. Carol, Hans. "The Hierarchy of Central Functions Hi thin the City." Annals, Association of American Geographers,.50, 4 (December, 1960) 419-438. Chisholm, Roger K. and Gilbert R. Whitaker, Jr. Forecasting Methods. Homewood, Illinois: Richard D. Irwin, 1971, City of Palmdale and Chamber of Commerce. Community Economic Profile for Palmdale, Los Angeles County, California. September, 1977. Clark, W. A. V. and Gerard Rushton. "~1odels of Intra-Urban Consumer Behavior and Their Implications for Central Place Theory." Economic Geography, 46, 3 (July, 1970) 486-497. Claus, R. J., D. C. Rothwell, and J. Bottomley. "Measuring the Quality of a Low-Order Retail Site." Economic Geography, 48, 2 (April, 1972) 168-178. Cogswell, Adabelle. Tiburcio Vasquez: El bandido sin par. Volcano & Pioneer, California: California Traveler, Inc., 1974. 119 Cohen, Saul B. Chains. 11 11 Location Research Programming for Voluntary Food Economic Geography, 37, 1 (January, 1961) 1-11. Cohen, Saul B. and ~Jilliam Applebaum. 11 Evaluating Store Sites and Determining Store Rents. •• Economic Geography, 36, 1 (January, 1960) 1-35. Dawson, John A., John C. Doorkamp. Evaluatin London: Edward Arnold (Publishers the Human Environment. Department of Human Resources Development, editors. California State Department of Employment, Research and Statistics Section. Sacramento, California, 1967-1968. Epstein, Bart J. 11 Evaluation of an Established Planned Shopping Center. 11 Economic Geography, 37, 1 (January, 1961) 12-21. Epstein, Bart J. 11 External Relations of Cities: City-Hinterland. 11 Journal of Geography, 68, 3 (March, 1969) 134-147. Epstein, Bart J. 11 Geography and the Business of Retail Site Evaluation and Selection, 11 Economic Geography, 47, 2 (April, 1971) 192-199. Feldman, Stephen. 11 Toward a Comparative Systems Theory of Location Analysis: The Historical Equilibrium of Workers' Self Management. •• Economic Geography, 52, 1 (January, 197 6) 24-29. 11 50th Anniversary Edition: 1886-1936. 11 Antelope Valley Ledger-Gazette. Lancaster, California: Cameron and Hubbard, Publ,, December, 1936. Gibson, Lay James. 11 An Analysis of the Location of Instrument Manufacturing in the United StateS, 11 Annals, Association of American Geographers, 60, 2 (June, 1970) 352-367. Goldstucker, Jac L., Danny N. Ballinger, Thomas J. Stanley, Ruth L. Otte. New Development in Retail Trading Area Analysis and Site Selection. Atlanta: Publishing Services Division, College of Business Administration, Georgia State University, 1978. Gordon, J. Shelton. Incredible Tales of the Antelope Valley Pioneers. Palmdale, California: Shelton Gordon, 1973. 11 Greater Antelope Valley Edition. 11 Antelope Valley Ledger-Gazette. Lancaster, California: Cameron and Rupner, Publ., February, 1941. Green, Howard L. "Planning a National Retail Growth Program.'' Economic Geography, 37, 1 (January, 1961} 22-32. 120 Griffin, Donald H. and Richard E. Preston. "Land Use in the Central Commercial Area, Journal of Geograehy, 67, 6 (September, 1968) 342-351. 11 Harries, Keith D. "Ethnic Variations in Los Angeles Business Patterns.~~ Annals, Association of American Geographers, 61, 4 (December, 1971) 736-743. Henderson, William L., Larry C. Ledebur. Urban Economics: Processes and Problems. New York, London, Sydney, Toronto: John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 1972. Imus, Harold R. 11 Projecting Sales Potentials for Department Stores in Regional Shopping Centers. 11 Economic Geography, 37, 1 (January, 1961) 33-41. Johnston, R. J. and P. J. Rimmer. "The Competitive Position of a Planned Shopping Centre. 11 Australian Geographer, 10, 3 (March, 1967) 160-168. Jumper, Sidney R, "Hholesale t1arketing of Fresh Vegetables." Annals, Association of American Geographers, 64, 3 (September, 1974) 387-396. Kenyon, James B. "On the Relationship Between Central Function and Size of Place," Annals, Association of American Geographers, 57, 4 (December, 1957) 736-750. Lancaster Chamber of Commerce. Community Economic Profile for Lancaster, Los Angeles, County, California. 1975, Los Angeles County, California Chamber of Commerce, Agriculture. 1955. Department of t1abogunje, Akin L, "The Evolution and Analysis of the Retail Structure of Lagos, Nigeria." Economic Geography, 40, 4 (October, 1964) 304-323. Massari, Domenic. Autobiography of Domenic, 1893-1977. California: Domenic Massari, 1977. Palmdale, McCarty, H. H. "An Approach to a Theory of Economic Geography." Economic Geography, 30, 2 (April, 1954) 95-101. Morris, Lucie. The History of the Town of Lancaster, Center of Antelope Valley, California. M.A. Thesis, Department of History, University of Southern California, 1934. Murphy, Raymond E. and J, E. Vance, Jr. 11 Delimiting the CBD. 11 Economic Geography, 30, 3 (July, 1954) 189-222. 121 Murphy, Raymond E. , J. E. Vance, Jr, , Bart J. Epstein. "Interna 1 Structure of the CBD," Economic Geography, 31, 1 (January, 1955) 21-46. Nelson, Howard J. "Some Characteristics of the Population of Cities in Similar Service Classifications.~~ Economic Geography, 33, 2 (April, 1957) 95-108. Palmdale Chamber of Commerce. Community Economic Profile for Palmdale, Los Angeles County, California. January, 1971. Parker, A. G. 11 Hypermarkets: The Changing Pattern of Retailing." Geography, 60, 267 (April, 1975) 120-124. Pfouts, Ralph W., editor. The Techniques of Urban Economic Analysis. West Trenton, New Jersey: Chandler Davis Publishing Company, 1960. Preston, Richard E. 11 The Structure of Central Place Systems." Economic Geography, 47, 2 (April, 1971) 136-155. Questor Associates. Economic Assessment of Antelope Valley and the Cities of Lancaster and Palmdale. 2 vols. San Francisco: Questor Associates, 1981, Quinton-Redgate, et al. "Antelope Valley Areawide General Plan." North Los Angeles County General Plan, 1974-1977. Quinton-Redgate, et al. "Palmdale Community General Plan." Angeles County General Plan. 1974-1977. North Los Ransome, Jack C. 11 The Organization of Location Research in a Large Supermarket Chain." Economic Geography, 37, 1 (January, 1961) 42-47. Rose, Harold M. 11 The Structure of Retail Trade in a Racially Changing Trade Area." Geographical Analysis, 2, 2 (April, 1970) 135-148. Schmidt, Charles G. and Yuk Lee. 11 An Intermetropolitan Analysis of Retail Locational Patterns and Competitive Processes ... The Social Science Journal, 16, 1 (January, 1979) 43-52. Settle, Glen A. Along the Rails from Lancaster to Mojave. Lancaster, California: Kern-Antelope Historical Society, Inc., 1967. Settle, Glen A. The Antelope Left and the Settle-ers Came. Rosamond, California: Kern-Antelope Historical Society, Inc., 1975. Settle, Glen A. Tropico: Red Hill with a Glamorous History of Gold. Rosamond, California, 1959. 122 Siddall, l~illiam R. 11 Wholesale-Retail Trade Ratios as Indices of Urban Centrality. 11 Economic Geography, 37, 2 (April, 1961) 124-132. Sisco, Paul H. 11 Geographic Training and Method Applied to Trade Area Analysis of Local Shopping Centers, 11 Journal of Geography, 56, 5 (May, 1957) 201-212. South Antelope Valley Press. Palmdale, California, 1940-1950. Southern California Edison Company. Inventory. 1961. The Antelope Valley: An Area Starr, Richard Boblett. A History of Antelope Valley from 1542 to 1920. M.A. Thesis, Department of History, University of Southern California, 1938. State of California Office of Planning and Research, Economic Practices Manual. Sacramento, California. 16-19, 24-25, 29-47. U. S. Bureau of the Census, Census of Retail Trade, 1972. Vol. I. Summary and Subject Statistics. Hashington, D.C.: U. S. Government Printing Office, 1976. U, S. Bureau of the Census. Census of Selected Service Industries, 1972. Vol. I. Summary and Subject Statistics. Hashington, D.C.: U. S. Government Printing Office, 1976. U.S. Bureau of the Census. Census of Wholesale Trade, 1972. Vol. I. Summary and Subject Statistics. ~~ashington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1976. U. s. Bureau of the Census. County and City Data, 1962. (A Statistical Abstract Supplement). Washington, D.C.: U. S. Government Printing Office, 1962. 11 11 U. S. Bureau of the Census. Statistical Abstract of the United States: 1979 (lOOth edition). Washington, D.C.: U. S. Government Printing Office, 1979. U. S. Urban Renewal Administration. Standard Land Use Coding Manual. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1965. VanCleef, Eugene. 111 Things Are Not Always What They Seem' for the Economic Geographer, Economic Geography, 45, 1 (January, 1969) 41-44. 11 Webber, J. J. "Association Between Population Density and the Market Areas of Towns, 11 Geographical Analysis, 6, 2 (April, 1974) 109-134. 123 Webber, M. J. and Richard Symanski. "Complete Periodic Market Cycles." Annals, Association of American Geographers, 64, 2 (June, 1974) 203-213. Webber, M. J. and Richard Symanski. "Periodic ~1arkets: An Economic Location Analysis." Economic Geography, 49, 3 (July, 1973) 213-227. 124 Appendix A Household Survey The technique, Stratified Random Digit Dialing, is a representative probability sample of all households with telephones, is performed in two stages. The sample First, the number of random telephone numbers is arbitrarily selected. Second, each prefix receives an equal number of telephone numbers ensuring that each prefix has an equal likelihood of obtaining completed interviews. The household questionnaire, compiled by the Los Angeles County Planning Group, consisted of questions segregated into seven major categories: shopping patterns, travel demand, recreation, employment, population, income, and housing (see Appendix B) A total of 756 households were interviewed, representing a 70 percent response rate. Employer Survey Employers in Antelope Valley were selected systematically; every fifth business in the retail sector and every third business from all other industrial and service groups. A total of 600 employers were surveyed; 133 in Palmdale, 447 in Lancaster, and 20 major employers of which five were located in Palmdale, three in Lancaster, and twelve throughout Antelope Valley. The questionnaire covered current and future employment, company air travel patterns, air freight requirements, frequency of customer visits and business expansion plans (see Appendix B). The response rate for major employers was 95 percent and for all other employers 36 percent. @ 125 Appendix B Household Survey Questionnaire 1. Where do you and your family shop for food, clothes, cosmetics and drugs, household items, and services? 2. What means of transportation do you most often use to get to where you usually shop? 3. How many minutes is it one-way from your home to where you usually shop? 4. In an average month, how many times do you have to go outside of Palmdale for shopping? 5. What cities or towns do you shop in when you go outside of Palmdale? 6. Do you shop outside of Palmdale because you can•t get what you want here or because you enjoy shopping at different places? 7. What products or services do you generally buy outside of Palmdale? 8, In an average month, how often do you or any member of your family go outside of Palmdale for recreational, leisure or cultural activities? 9. What do you like to do and where do you go? 10. In the past twelve months, how many times have you gone to an airport for any reason and which airport? 11. What is your age? 12. What is the highest grade in school you have completed and received credit for? 13. What is your present employment status? 14. How many minutes is it one-way from your home to where you work? 15. In what city or town do you work? 16. What means of transportation do you use for most of your trips to work? 17. What kind of work do you do? What is your main occupation? ' 126 18. Including yourself, how many adults and children regularly live in this household? 19. Including yourself, how many people in your household are age 18 or older? 20. Including yourself, how many people in your household are currently working either full-time or part-time? 21. Including yourself, how many people in your household are age 65 or older? 22. How many children are there in your household age 0-4? 23. How many women are in your household age 18-50? 24. What income group are you in? 25. Do you live in a house, an apartment, a condominium, a mobile home or something else? 26. Do you own your residence or pay rent? 27. How much is your monthly mortgage or rent? -28. How long have you lived in Palmdale? 29. Where did you live before you first came to Palmdale? 30. How long have you lived at your present address? 31. What ethnic background or heritage group best describes you? 32. Do you have any other different telephone numbers at this residence? 33. Including this one, how many different telephone numbers do you have here? 34. How many bedrooms are in your house? 35. How many bathrooms are in your house? 36. Is your home newly constructed? 37. What main intersection or road is nearest your home? 127 Employer Survey Questionnaire 1. How many employees are presently in your organization? 2. Are any of your employees military personnel? 3. Specify the number of civilian and military personnel in your organization. 4. How many of yoru employees are male; how many female? 5. How many employees will be in your organization as of December 31' 1980? 6. What will be your projected total employment for 1981? 7. What will be your projected total employment for 1985? 8. What do you perceive to be the most important skills your employees need? 9. How many employees reside in Palmdale? 10. How many employees reside outside of Palmdale? 11. How do the majority of your employees travel to work? 12. Does your organization provide transportation for the employees? 13. What is your annual payroll? 14. What percent of your annual payroll is paid to employees residing out of your immediate city? 15. How many business-related trips requiring air transportation did members of your organization take from January 1, 1979 through December 31, 1979? 16. How many business-related trips requiring air transportation will members of your organization take for the year ending December 31, 1980? 17. Of the total number of business trips using air transportation during 1979, how many were to destinations with distances of 0-500 miles, 500-1000 miles, 1000-2000 miles, 2000-2500 miles, over 2500 miles? 18. Specify the six places most frequently traveled to by members of your organization. 128 19. Of the total number of trips taken in 1979, how many trips originated from Palmdale Airport, Los Angeles International Airport, Hollywood-Burbank Airport, Orange County Airport, Ontario International Airport, Long Beach Airport, other airports? 20. Does your company ship any products by air? 21. How frequently do you use air freight? 22. What percentage of yearly production was shipped by air in 1979? 23. What percentage of yearly production do you expect to be shipped by air in 1980? 24. What percentage of yearly production do you expect to be shipped by air by 1985? 25. Of the production shipped by air in 1979, what percentage originated at LAX, Hollywood-Burbank, Orange County, Ontario International, Long Beach, other? 26. Of the production shipped by air in 1979, what percentage had a destination located within California, Midwest, Southwest, Northeast, Southeast, International? 27. In the course of your business-related operations, do customers visit you from outside your local area? 28. List in order of frequency the most common mode of travel your customers use. 29. When visiting, how long do your customers stay in the area? 30. Do your customers use hotels near your place of business? 31. List the three most common places (locations) your customers stay. 32. What is the total square footage of building(s) you are currently occupying? 33. What percentage of this space is production, administrative, warehouse? 34. Are you planning any construction or leasing of space over the next 12 months? 35. Are you planning to lease or construct space? 36. How many square feet will be leased (constructed)? 37. Where will the new space be added? I ~ 129 38. What type of activity will be located in the new space? 39. How much additional space do you anticipate adding between 1982-1985? 40. Where will this space be located? 41. Considering your business expansion plans, indicate how important each of the following factors were in making your decision: cost of industrial land, suitability of industrial land parcels, local utility service and costs, taxes, availability of professional or skilled labor, availability of unskilled labor, cost of labor, community attitudes, housing costs, availability of housing, adequacy of transportation system, commuting time, cost of compliance with air/water quality regulations, future availablity of energy. 42. Specify the percent of your firm~s products produced in Antelope Valley and sold to the following groups: Federal government, state and local government, other manufacturers, other businesses for final use, other consumers. 43. Specify the percent sold in the following geographic locations: Palmdale, Lancaster, rest of Antelope Valley, rest of California, rest of United States, foreign. 44. What were your company's total 1979 sales? 45. What percent of your overall production do you subcontract to businesses in Antelope Valley, in California, out of California, foreign? 130 Appendix C THE COMMERCIAL STRUCTURE OF PALMDALE 1980 Nap 8 (Large map to be contained in a packet)