6 Epigenetic Mechanisms Regulating Gene Expression TOC Fig. 1. Alternate states of DNA methylation in mammalian DNA. Methylation occurs only on cytosines present in CpG dinucleotides in mammalian DNA. A CpG dinucleotide sequence in one DNA strand mandates the presence of a complementary CpG dinucleotide in the other strand of double-stranded DNA. (A) If both cytosines in such a site are unmethylated, the site is said to be completely unmethylated. This structure is often found in actively expressed or potentiated genes, especially in the 5' regulatory region. (B) An unmethylated site can undergo de novo methylation to form a fully methylated site in which both cytosines are methylated. This structure is often found associated with repressed genes. Conversely a demethylase activity can convert a fully methylated site to a fully unmethylated site in the absence of DNA replication. (C) Upon semi-conservative replication of a fully methylated site, a hemimethylated site is formed. This structure is typically transient as a maintenance DNA methyl transferase rapidly recognizes a hemimethylated site and returns it to a fully methylated state. The function of the maintenance methylase provides a mechanism to heritably maintain DNA methylation patterns. C, cytosine; G, guanine; N, any base; p, phosphate bond; CH3, methyl group. Fig. 2. Alternate states of chromatin structure. (A) In eukaryotic cells double-stranded DNA is typically complexed with clusters of histones called nucleosomes to form a beads on a string structure. This structure, which forms a fiber of approx 10 nm in diameter, is typically found in genes that are undergoing active transcription as shown in the Expressed State in this figure. The RNA polymerase II complex is able to traverse and transcribe portion of this structure to produce mRNA transcripts. (B) Long-term repression of gene transcription is accomplished by condensation of chromatin to form a 30 nm fiber as shown in the Repressed State in this figure. This condensed structure is refractory to binding by transcription factors and/or RNA polymerase II inhibiting initiation of transcription. Open circles, nucleosomes within the transcribed portion of the gene; filled circles, nucleosomes between genes; hatched oval, the RNA II polymerase complex. TOC Fig. 3. Organization of DNA loop domains. Adjacent chromatin loop domains can exist in alternate states of condensed (closed) or decondensed (open) structure. Genes within closed domains are typically repressed. Genes within open domains are potentiated for transcriptional activation. Activation of transcription requires transcription factor binding and initiation of RNA synthesis by RNA polymerase II. (Modified with permission from Krawetz, et al. [1999]). Fig. 4. Distinction of genes or alleles based on differential replication timing. The potential for differential timing of replication during S phase to maintain an epigenetic distinction between different genes or between different alleles of the same gene is depicted in this figure. The model is based on the concept that protein-DNA interactions become disrupted during DNA replication. These interactions must be re-established following replication. If certain proteins are present in limiting quantities, those genes or alleles that replicate earliest during S phase will gain preferential access to bind these proteins. In this way one gene or allele will bind a disproportionate quantity of a specific protein(s) and become distinguished from another gene or allele, even if both genes or alleles share similar protein-binding sequences. (Reproduced with permission from Simon, et al. [1999]). TOC Fig. 5. Interactions among epigenetic mechanisms to regulate gene expression. Multiple epigenetic mechanisms contribute to regulation of transcriptional activity in mammals. An example of how this may occur is presented in this figure. (A) A fully repressed gene is often found to be hypermethylated, complexed with methylated-DNA binding proteins, comprised of deacetylated histones, and in a condensed chromatin structure characterized by a 30-nm structure that inhibits binding of transcription factors or RNA polymerase. (B) Derepression leading to transcriptional activation begins with demethylation of the gene, which in turn leads to dissociation of methylated-DNA binding proteins and acetylation of histones. (C) Potentiation of chromatin structure is marked by decondensation of the chromatin fiber from the 30 nm structure to the 10 nm beads on a string structure. (D) Displacement of nucleosomes creates an assayable DNase I hypersensitive site which marks the presence of naked DNA that is available for binding by transcription factors. (E) Binding of ubiquitous transcription factors to the core promoter region and tissue-specific transcription factors to enhancer regions attract the RNA polymerase II complex to the gene promoter. (F) Binding of the RNA polymerase II complex initiates transcription. (G) Ongoing transcription is characterized by sequential binding of multiple RNA polymerase II complexes to facilitate synthesis of multiple RNA transcripts. Open circles, nucleosomes within the transcribed portion of the gene; filled circles, nucleosomes between genes; squares containing Ms, DNA methylation; hexagons, methylated-DNA binding proteins; small filled hexagons, circles and rectangles, bound transcription factors; large, hatched oval, RNA polymerase II complex. TOC