UCI Internal Medicine Residency Training Program
Journal Club Evaluation
Resident
Faculty Name
Practice-based Learning/ Improvement
Not
Not
Competently Comments
applicable competently performed
to this
performed
exercise
Creates an appropriate PICO Question
Identifies the source material & evaluates the
quality of the journal
Clearly states goals of the paper
Cleary delineates research type, parameters of
the study (including inclusion criteria), and
outcome measures
Clearly states results
Demonstrates basic understanding of the
statistical approach
Performs a Methods & Outcomes (Clinical
Significance) Evaluation using Algorithms
from the EBM Guidebook. REQUIRED
Professionalism
Commitment to Process
Creates an appropriate report on paper or
PowerPoint
Teaching Skills
Ability to Engage & Stimulate
Slides or Handouts
Systems-based Practice
Provides appropriate clinical context for
study. Clearly understands the
implications of the results.
Overall Competence (Must perform all
relevant elements including the Methods
& Outcomes Evaluation.)
Paper/Manuscript: See attached documents
Comments: Specific comments given at the conference
_____________________________________________
Faculty Signature
Date