CLERMONT AGENDA FOR THE FUTURE 2014 Report A community-driven 10-year Agenda for a greater Clermont County Supported by: Prepared by: A letter from Clermont Agenda for the Future Chairman Dave Gooch: “We live in a great country. We are a few people blessed with a land of beauty and bountiful resources. We have opportunities most citizens of the world can only dream to achieve. Our community represents all of this. We are bordered by one of the great rivers, the Ohio, and our land rolls with gentle hills and valleys bisected by other scenic waters and two superb lakes. Many were born here and stay to carry on names covering several generations. Others of us have moved here because of rural values, quality schools, affordable land, and good jobs…” Pulled from the introduction of the “Clermont 2001” report, these words, which so beautifully describe our county, were the result of an initiative that began more than 25 years ago. In October 1988, Ed Parish and Bill Over convened a group of community leaders to have a conversation about the future of Clermont County. With this meeting, they launched a yearlong endeavor that engaged more than 350 citizen-volunteers to create a vision for the future for Clermont County. The recommendations that came out of this effort were compiled into a report entitled “Clermont 2001.” Clermont 2001 called upon citizens, business leaders, elected officials, and community groups to pursue a number of key economic development and qualityof-life initiatives over the ensuing decade. One of the outcomes of this initiative was the establishment of LEAD Clermont, a high-quality, intensive leadership and team building study, delivered in a manner that links class members to volunteer service in Clermont County. Since its inception 22 years ago, LEAD Clermont has graduated more than 400 individuals. The positive impact these individuals have had in Clermont County is immeasurable. From the members of the LEAD Clermont Class of 2012, came a call to create a new “Agenda for the Future of Clermont County.” The class concluded that while the Clermont 2001 initiative produced a number of very positive outcomes in Clermont County, a great deal had changed in our community in the past 25 years. Duke Energy stepped up to generously provide funding, and the Community Agenda project was launched. When the community leadership began this process, it was with two goals in mind. The first was to create an agenda for the future that would build on the best of the County. The second was to involve a whole new generation of residents in the process. Subsequently, 500 community members attended more than 50 community conversations held throughout Clermont County. Several themes and values remained consistent throughout the conversations. The following Themes were drawn out to establish a framework for moving forward: Economic Opportunity; Transportation; Parks, Nature and Recreation; Community; Lifelong Learning; Health and Wellness; and Housing. The four key values that emerged were as follows: balancing growth and development with a rural, small town feel; making Clermont County a great place for every phase of life; being productive citizens and community members; and preserving and promoting our historic and natural assets. 2 Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report To date, hundreds of people have participated in this process. They’ve identified values, created work teams around themes that were identified by the community as most important, and developed an actionable set of recommendations that will move the county forward, while protecting the core values that matter most. As the introduction so eloquently describes, we are indeed very fortunate to live in an incredible community, filled with strong core values and a wealth of natural resources. To preserve these values and resources, individual communities and organizations need to plan, but they also need a comprehensive “Agenda for the Future.” It can be argued that because Clermont is such a community-based and geographically-diverse county, it is not practical or useful to create a countywide agenda. However, the vast majority of individuals who have joined this initiative understand that these are the very reasons we must do so. On behalf of the many individuals who have had a voice in this process, I challenge each citizen to set aside personal agendas and partner with us for the benefit of our residents and the success of our County. Dave Gooch Chairman, Clermont Agenda for the Future 3 Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction 5 Public Process & Leadership 7 State of Clermont County 9 Land Use 11 Recommendations 12 Economic Opportunity 18 Transportation 23 Parks, Nature, and Recreation 29 Community 34 Lifelong Learning 39 Health and Wellness 46 Housing 51 Implementation 55 Appendix 56 INTRODUCTION When the community leadership in Clermont County began this process it was with two things in mind: to create an agenda for the future that would build on the best of the County and to involve a whole new generation of residents in the process. What follows is an Agenda for the Future that does both of these things. Last winter over 500 people; new residents, old-timers, business owners, high school students, retirees, librarians, and hikers, and more hosted their neighbors and friends at over 50 community conversations about what makes Clermont County a great place to live. They talked about great parks and open spaces, about wanting to make sure there were good jobs for their children and comfortable housing for their aging parents, and about Jungle Jim’s! In all these hundreds of opinions, four values kept coming out (see Values inset). People in Clermont County value and appreciate the rural, small-town feel of this place that is close to a major metropolitan area, they want the County to move forward with a growth strategy that is balanced, and respects and preserves the small town feel of the place while providing jobs, amenities, and institutions that support residents. The Land Use Map (see page 9) illustrates areas where productive farming and an agricultural way of life should be preserved and protected. It identifies community centers like Milford, Amelia, and Batavia where the County gets its image and small town feel. It highlights important open spaces that should be preserved for recreational use and to preserve rich natural treasures - hillsides, waterfalls and forests. It also highlights an emerging suburban zone that provides jobs, great educational options and other amenities within easy reach for everyone. In Clermont County balanced growth means enjoying suburban amenities and preserving important agricultural and natural resources. 5 Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report Values Conversations and survey responses consistently brought out certain Values that residents were most focused on preserving and improving: Balancing growth and development with a rural, smalltown feel. Making Clermont County a great place for every phase of life. Being productive citizens and community members. Preserving and promoting our historic and natural assets. Residents want Clermont County to be a great place for people in every phase of their lives. There should be opportunities for residents of all ages to reach and maintain healthy lifestyles. Clermont should be a great place to raise your kids, to get started as a young adult, and to have a productive interesting retirement. Creating lifelong learners with things to explore at all ages, having ways to get around with a car and without one, having lots of employment opportunities and career training opportunities to go with them are important to Clermont residents. Preserving the natural and historic resources of the county is a core value to most of those who participated in the process. While it is easy to undervalue or underestimate the importance of things seen every day, people were quick to point out that it is these natural and historic resources that make Clermont unique and that are worth saving and highlighting. Clermont County residents want to contribute. They want to be part of the solutions they seek. People are proud of the contributions they make as neighbors, employers, and taxpayers. They are looking for more ways to communicate and connect and get involved, and more ways to support each other. Hundreds of people participated in this process. They identified values, created work teams around themes that were identified by the community as most important, and developed an actionable set of recommendations that will move the County forward and still respect what matters most to the County. The next step in this process is to stay connected, engaged and work together to create change. 6 Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report Themes ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY TRANSPORTATION PARKS, NATURE AND RECREATION COMMUNITY LIFELONG LEARNING HEALTH AND WELLNESS HOUSING PUBLIC PROCESS & LEADERSHIP Public Process Defining the Agenda: 50 conversations with more than 500 Setting Priorities: community members > 365 75 surveys help set priorities at wksp and with surveys Developing Recommendations: Feedback on Recommendations and Prioritizing Goals: 7 Work Teams (WT) 91 WT members > 43 WT mtgs 594 at workshop and with surveys Final Plan 7 > 25 other mtgs est. 1,020 hours volunteered Implementation Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report In early 2014, community leaders began to think about economic development and quality of life issues in all parts of the county – to reset priorities for future growth and development throughout Clermont County. The last Clermont County communitywide visioning initiative was conducted nearly 25 years ago. While the resulting Clermont 2001 report released in 1991 produced a number of positive accomplishments, a great deal has changed in our community over the past 25 years. This process represents a similarly bold initiative. A community-wide process was convened to hear from all voices in the county, generate positive, productive discussions about the future, and develop strategies that will guide future growth, target resources, and build on all that is great about Clermont County. This document encapsulates the tireless work of many volunteers over the last year. It is a guide and a springboard for implementation and progress. Leadership Agenda for the Future was guided by an Executive Team and Work Teams. The Executive Team was responsible for guiding the process and ensuring that all voices were heard throughout the process. The Work Teams took feedback from hundreds of Clermont residents and worked over several months to develop recommendations. Both the Executive Team and Work Teams have been champions of the Agenda during its development and will continue to be champions during implementation. Executive Team: Dave Gooch, Park National Bank George Brown, Project Manager John Melvin, Clermont Chamber Matt Van Sant, Clermont Chamber Warren Walker, Duke Energy Work Team Co-Chairs Chris Smith Economic Opportunity Dave Spinney Economic Opportunity Larry Fronk Transportation Rex Parsons Transportation Sheila Hinton Parks, Nature & Rec. Jim Meyer Parks, Nature & Rec. M.E. Steele-Pierce Lifelong Learning Chris Wick Lifelong Learning Work Team Support Liz Blume, Community Building Institute (CBI) Valerie Daley, CBI Andrew Stahlke, CBI 8 Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report Sandy Bradford Community Lisa Davis Community Sarah Ghee Health and Wellness Margaret Jenkins Health and Wellness Tim Hershner Housing Larry Keith Housing STATE OF CLERMONT COUNTY Located in Southwest Ohio within the Cincinnati metropolitan region, Clermont County is a collection of unique communities both new and historic, urban and rural. Initially jumpstarted by post-WWII housing development and interstate highway expansion, Clermont’s growth continues, and the county has just surpassed 200,000 residents. population: 200,218 area: 458 sq. miles 13 municipalities 14 townships Largest: Milford (pop. 6,680) Smallest: Chilo (pop. 63) Largest: Union (pop. 46,416) Smallest: Washington (pop. 2,278) 0 95,725 50,000 80,530 Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report (projected) 197,363 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 2020 Year 9 177,977 150,187 100,000 128,483 150,000 42,182 Clermont County Population 200,000 225,342 250,000 $60,590 [$48,246 in Ohio] Median Household Income, 2012 5.2% [6.0% in Ohio] Unemployment, July 2014 and 79 parks preserves $50 million Infrastructure improvements (2014-2015) 12.1% 33% [11.6% in metro region] [37% in metro region] Adults with no high school diploma annual LEAD 425 54 Major community Clermont events +5 years 10 graduates Increase in median age, 2000-2010 Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report Adults with a college degree -12% Loss in rural population, 2000-2010 [-1% in Ohio] Wayne Goshen 28 727 Newtonsville Milford LAND USE 133 Stonelick 132 131 Owensville 50 286 Jackson 275 32 276 222 Batavia Union 125 32 132 Pierce Williamsburg Amelia 52 Future Land Use Williamsburg Batavia 133 749 275 Loveland Ohio How land will be used in the future has been a part of New Richmond 132 125 Bethel many conversations involving the future of Clermont 232 Monroe 48 Miami County. From improved transportation links to 126 Tate 222 Goshen economic development projects to land preservation 232 28 initiatives, residents have 727 743 756Milford consistently expressed Township Boundary 774 their desire to maintain Municipal Boundary Moscow a balance between rural, 133 Stonelick Potential Land Use Washington Felicity 132 Owensville small-town character and Natural 275 Agriculture/Rural 32 growth and development. 276 Franklin Suburban 222 Land use patterns now and Neville Batavia Mixed-Use Community Center Chilo in the future are particularly 133 Union 125 Economic Ready Zone important to Clermont 00 2.5 55 2.5 Parks and Greenspace County. 132 Batavia Pierce Newtonsville 133 50 286 Jackson Williamsburg Williamsburg 133 New Richmond 232 Monroe 222 125 Bethel Tate 232 Township Boundary Park or nature preserve areas (State, Township, Village, City), and lands owned publicly or privately that are considered to be park, greenspace, or preserved for natural use (excluding golf courses). Municipal Boundary Potential Land Use Natural 743 756 133 Washington Felicity Franklin Suburban Mixed-Use Community Center 774 Moscow Agriculture/Rural Neville Chilo 133 Economic Ready Zone Parks and Greenspace 00 2.5 2.5 55 Miles Miles Natural (Hillsides and Forests) Areas of predominately forest or tree-cover, typically near rivers, streams and lakes, and including area of hills and slope near the Ohio River. 11 Areas with strong economic development potential, where infrastructure exists for growth and development now and in the future. Ohio Areas of low to medium density development of primarily residential, with commercial and industrial uses as well. Parks and Greenspace Economic Ready Zone 32 749 Suburban 131 Miles Miles Amelia 52 Wayne Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report Agricultural/Rural Areas that are generally sparsely populated, predominately agricultural (an important economic use in Clermont County), with occasional residences. Mixed-Use Community Center Municipalities, Township centers and areas of population concentration, commercial activity and mixed uses. RECOMMENDATIONS Within the seven Themes (below), 23 Goals (pages 13-15) were set covering a broad range of topics. The Goals are listed on the following pages, with more detailed information for each Goal including Action Steps and Partners starting on page 18. $ Economic Opportunity Parks, Nature, & Recreation Health and Wellness 12 Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report Transportation Community A B C Housing Lifelong Learning $ 1 Economic Opportunity We will have active, competitive, and fully serviced commercial sites from which to offer office and industrial options to accommodate new and expanding firms. 2 We will organize a team of community stakeholders (public and private) to create a rapid and customized program to provide employee training and recruitment specific to business needs to achieve county-wide gainful employment. 3 We will have a robust marketing and branding strategy for Clermont County designed to attract and support expansion of companies in our community. 13 Parks, Nature, & Recreation Transportation 4 The transportation 8 system is maintained and enhanced for residents and its capacity is increased to facilitate economic development. 5 Public transportation and accessibility in Clermont County is promoted, enhanced, and expanded to connect destinations. 9 There are more preserved and protected natural areas in Clermont County that can be enjoyed by current and future generations. 6 Create connections between community centers and other important destinations that enhance economic development opportunities and quality of life in a balanced way. 7 Promote bikeways and sidewalks that enhance the rural character of the County and mobility options for the non-motoring public. Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report Clermont County residents are better served by parks at all levels (State, County, Township, City and Village) which are an asset that makes Clermont County the place to live, work and play in Greater Cincinnati. 10 Quality of life for Clermont County residents is enhanced by improving the variety and availability of recreational activities in Clermont County. Community 11 12 13 14 14 Clermont County residents have easy access to information about activities, events, services, and places in the county and this information is shared with residents of surrounding communities. Clermont County will have a defined recognizable brand. A B C 15 16 17 Volunteerism increases connections and strengthens the County. Clermont County has an increased level of leadership effectiveness. 18 Health and Wellness Lifelong Learning Clermont residents and stakeholders understand the importance of, and invest in, the social and economic value of learning. 19 20 Every child enters kindergarten prepared for success in school. Every child in Clermont County has equal access to learning that helps them succeed in school and life. Every adult in Clermont County continuously develops skills, knowledge, and experiences to achieve personal, professional, and community goals. Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report 21 Clermont County will be a drug free community. The community will be more aware and supportive of mental health services as integral to the quality of life of all citizens in helping them live quality lives and achieve maximum health and independence. Clermont health (mental and physical) and wellness outcomes are bolstered and the community will report having excellent or very good health through expanded partnerships and collaborations. Housing 22 23 15 Clermont County understands future population growth demands and existing and future capacity of land and buildings. Housing in Clermont County can meet growth demands in all population segments. Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report The final 23 Goals were voted on at a Public Workshop and online survey, and the overall ranking of each Goal is listed below. See Appendix (pages 56 - 58), for complete prioritization results from both the online survey and public workshop. Rank Goal 1st Clermont County will be a drug free community. 2nd $ 3rd B C A We will have active, competitive, and fully serviced commercial sites from which to offer office and industrial options to accommodate new and expanding firms. Every child in Clermont County has equal access to learning that helps them succeed in school and life. 4th Promote bikeways and sidewalks that enhance the rural character of the County and mobility options for the non-motoring public. 5th Clermont County residents are better served by parks at all levels (State, County, Township, City and Village) which are an asset that makes Clermont County the place to live, work and play in Greater Cincinnati. 6th There are more preserved and protected natural areas in Clermont County that can be enjoyed by current and future generations. 7th The transportation system is maintained and enhanced for residents and its capacity is increased to facilitate economic development. 8th Quality of life for Clermont County residents is enhanced by improving the variety and availability of recreational activities in Clermont County. 9th Clermont County residents have easy access to information about activities, events, services, and places in the county and this information is shared with residents of surrounding communities. 10th Clermont County understands future population growth demands and existing and future capacity of land and buildings. 11th The community will be more aware and supportive of mental health services as integral to the quality of life of all citizens in helping them live quality lives and achieve maximum health and independence. 12th Clermont health (mental and physical) and wellness outcomes are bolstered and the community will report having excellent or very good health through expanded partnerships and collaborations. 13th B C 14th B C A A Every child enters kindergarten prepared for success in school. Every adult in Clermont County continuously develops skills, knowledge, and experiences to achieve personal, professional, and community goals. 15th Public transportation and accessibility in Clermont County is promoted, enhanced, and expanded to connect destinations. 16th Clermont County has an increased level of leadership effectiveness. 17th Housing in Clermont County can meet growth demands in all population segments. 18th Create connections between community centers and other important destinations that enhance economic development opportunities and quality of life in a balanced way. 19th $ We will have a robust marketing and branding strategy for Clermont County designed to attract and support expansion of companies in our community. (Goals continued on next page) 16 Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report (Goals continued from previous page) Rank Goal 20th Volunteerism increases connections and strengthens the County. 21st $ 22nd B C 23rd 17 A We will organize a team of community stakeholders (public and private) to create a rapid and customized program to provide employee training and recruitment specific to business needs to achieve county-wide gainful employment. Clermont residents and stakeholders understand the importance of, and invest in, the social and economic value of learning. Housing in Clermont County can meet growth demands in all population segments. Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report $ ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY RECOMMENDATIONS What we heard: What we know: Priority Workshop attendees voted for their top three priority topics within each theme at the April 26, 2014 workshop. An online survey was conducted to gain additional community feedback in late April/early May. A total of 317 community members completed the survey to rank their top three priority topics. Following are a few facts that highlight the current condition of Economic Opportunity within Clermont County: The percentage next to each topic indicates the percent of responses that had that topic as a top priority (workshop and survey). 16% Company attraction (corporate, industrial, high-tech, etc.) 12% Restaurants, shopping and entertainment 11% Employment opportunities for all 9% Marketing and branding of county 3% 18 Tourism Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report ▪▪ An average of 300 new businesses opened in each of the last 5 years ▪▪ 20% of employees in Clermont County are in the retail, entertainment, accommodations or food service industries (2012) ▪▪ 7.6% of families in Clermont County are living below the poverty line, lower than the state-wide level of 11.2% (2012) ▪▪ The median household income in Clermont County is $60,590, higher than the state-wide median of $48,246 (2012) ▪▪ The rate of unemployment in Clermont County is 5.2%, lower than the state-wide rate of 6.0% (July, 2014) $ What should we do? Based on Clermont Agenda for the Future public feedback and existing conditions, the Work Team developed the following recommendations: GOAL 1 We will have active, competitive, and fully serviced commercial sites from which to offer office and industrial options to accommodate new and expanding firms. ACTION 1a Establish public/private partnerships to provide financing of infrastructure needs and establishment of competitive site(s) for development. Economic Ready Zones (areas have strong economic development potential, where infrastructure exists for growth) are identified on page 20. ACTION 1b County/local government/quasi-public agency develop strategy and policies to acquire non-competitive properties for redevelopment and repositioning to present to private sector for final development with an end user. ACTION 1c Assess need and potential for public investment in increasing inventory. ACTION 1d Establish a revolving loan fund for gap financing to encourage preferred development to address a public purpose and benefit. Goal #1 was ranked the 2nd-highest priority goal by workshop and survey participants. Potential Partners Clermont County Commissioners Appalachian Regional Commission Clermont County Port Authority Land Owner(s) Community Improvement Corporation(s) Developer Community Local governments Commercial lenders Public & private utilities State of Ohio 19 Chambers of Commerce United Way of Greater Cincinnati (Eastern Area) Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report $ Potential Future Land Use Economic Ready Zones Map Clermont County, Ohio Warren Loveland Clinton 275 132 71 126 75 48 Miami Wayne Goshen Hamilton 28 727 Newtonsville Milford 133 Stonelick Owensville 50 132 131 286 Jackson 275 32 276 222 Batavia 471 Union 125 32 275 132 Pierce Williamsburg Amelia 52 Williamsburg Batavia 133 749 Brown Ohio Campbell New Richmond 232 Monroe 222 Kenton Township Boundary Municipal Boundary Potential Land Use Natural (Hillsides, Forests, Waterways) Agriculture/Rural Pendleton Economic Ready Zone Parks and Greenspace (Public, Private) 20 Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report Tate 232 743 756 774 Moscow Washington Suburban (Res, Comm, Ind) Mixed-Use Community Center 125 Bethel 133 Felicity Franklin 0 Neville Chilo Bracken 133 2.5 5 Miles Land use boundaries are for estimating purposes only, and are not meant to precisely reflect actual land use/cover. Created by CBI, August, 2014. Data Source: Clermont Co. GIS, US Census Bureau GOAL 2 We will organize a team of community stakeholders (public and private) to create a rapid and customized program to provide employee training and recruitment specific to business needs to achieve county-wide gainful employment. ACTION 2a Assemble appropriate partners/stakeholders and training providers. ACTION 2b Assess partner expertise in selected employment clusters/ sectors. ACTION 2c Convene cluster or sector employers and establish training curriculums. ACTION 2d Establish governance, protocols, and certifications for the training programs to address issues of candidate recruitment, tuition sources, and job placements following training. Potential Partners Jobs Ohio Chambers of Commerce UC Clermont College Representatives from business community Oaks Career Center Grant Career Center Cincinnati State Southern State Clermont County Office of Economic Development 21 Clermont County Public Library OSU Extension –Clermont County United Way of Greater Cincinnati (Eastern Area) Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report $ GOAL 3 We will have a robust marketing and branding strategy for Clermont County designed to attract and support expansion of companies in our community. We support the Clermont Agenda Community collective communications concept of a central media platform/website where multiple community stakeholders, organizations, jurisdictions (public, private, and philanthropic) contribute content and aggregate information. This concept is helpful and supportive of Economic Opportunity efforts. We believe that the brand must be established first, followed by the message. A “DID YOU KNOW” campaign may be useful to deploy through new, updated, and varied social networking channels. ACTION 3a The importance of branding and marketing was expressed in several Work Teams, and collaboration among Economic Development, Community and other implementation teams going forward is vital. Collaborate with the Clermont Agenda Community collective communications concept of a central media platform/website to develop a message that will resonate with external high-level senior management executives, developers, commercial realtors, accountants, attorneys, and other deal influencers that are often outside Clermont County boundaries. Potential Partners Chambers of Commerce Local governments Commercial lenders Clermont County Park District Clermont County Public Library Convention and Visitors Bureau Clermont County Educational Service Center Clermont County Township association 22 Clermont County Mayor’s Association Boy Scouts Girl Scouts Cincinnati Nature Center (Center for Conservation and Leadership) United Way of Greater Cincinnati (Eastern Area) OSU Extension –Clermont County Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report $ TRANSPORTATION RECOMMENDATIONS What we heard: What we know: Priority Workshop attendees voted for their top three priority topics within each theme at the April 26, 2014 workshop. An online survey was conducted to gain additional community feedback in late April/early May. A total of 317 community members completed the survey to rank their top three priority topics. Following are a few facts that highlight the current condition of Transportation within Clermont County: The percentage next to each topic indicates the percent of responses that had that topic as a top priority (workshop and survey). 20% Road and traffic improvements 13% Road maintenance 12% Sidewalks and walkability 12% Public transportation (bus, rail, Park-n-Ride, senior, disabled) 9% 23 Eastern/Oasis Corridor Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report ▪▪ Over $50 million in infrastructure improvements are currently underway, or will be by 2015, through the Clermont County Transportation Improvement District (TID) ▪▪ Milford, Eastgate, Amelia, New Richmond and Felicity are all connected to Downtown Cincinnati via bus transit ▪▪ 26% of households in Clermont County only have access to 1 vehicle, and 4.7% (3,467 households) have no vehicle access at all (2012 ACS). What should we do? Based on Clermont Agenda for the Future public feedback and existing conditions, the Work Team developed the following recommendations: GOAL 4 The transportation system is maintained and enhanced for residents and its capacity is increased to facilitate economic development. ACTION 4a Support reconstruction and improvements along critical transportation routes: I-275, SR 32, SR 125, SR 28, US 50, and US 52. ACTION 4b Ensure good access to significant economic development “ready zones” (see Transportation Recommendations Map page 28, Economic Ready Zones Map, page 20). ACTION 4c Provide good site access to facilitate development and preserve tree cover and other natural features to the extent possible. Potential Partners Clermont County Commissioners Local villages, towns, and townships County Engineer Planning and zoning officials Clermont County Transportation Improvement District (CCTID) County Economic and Community Development Department Ohio Department of Transportation (ODOT) Private developers 24 Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report Transportation was the 2ndhighest priority Theme among public workshop and online survey participants. GOAL 5 Public transportation and accessibility in Clermont County is promoted, enhanced, and expanded to connect destinations. ACTION 5c Enhance transit service along major corridors. ACTION 5d Ensure adequate transit service to important employment, education and shopping destinations, especially in the “ready zones” (see Transportation Recommendations Map) Potential Partners Local villages, towns, and townships County Commissioners Transit Board of the County Commissioners County Engineer County Economic and Community Development Department Clermont Transportation Connection (CTC) Ohio Department of Transportation (ODOT) Clermont school districts United Way of Greater Cincinnati (Eastern Area) Clermont County Transportation Improvement District (CCTID) 25 Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report GOAL 6 Create connections between community centers and other important destinations that enhance economic development opportunities and quality of life in a balanced way. ACTION 6a Create appropriate intra-county connections between and among community centers and other significant destinations. ACTION 6b Promote three lane road sections to enhance travel times and safety, provide adequate signage, and incorporate sidewalks and bikeways where appropriate. ACTION 6c Consider a connection between Williamsburg, Bethel, Felicity and the Ohio River should a river crossing at route 133 become a possibility. Potential Partners County Commissioners County Engineer Clermont County Transportation Improvement District (CCTID) United Way of Greater Cincinnati (Eastern Area) Local governments Ohio Department of Transportation (ODOT) 26 Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report GOAL 7 Promote bikeways and sidewalks that enhance the rural character of the County and mobility options for the non-motoring public. ACTION 7a Support community centers as areas for growth and redevelopment for housing and economic development – encourage complete streets as new uses and renovation takes place. ACTION 7b Support streetscaping and pedestrian enhancements in community centers. ACTION 7c Provide walkability and connectivity to a variety of land uses. Potential Partners Local governments County Commissioners County Engineer Clermont County Transportation Improvement District (CCTID) Ohio Department of Transportation (ODOT) 27 OKI (Ohio-Kentucky-Indiana Regional Council of Governments) Green Umbrella Clermont County Park District United Way of Greater Cincinnati (Eastern Area) Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report Goal #7 was the most important Transportation goal, and 4thhighest overall, according to workshop and online survey participants. Transportation RecommendationsClermont Map County, Ohio Transportation Recommendations Loveland RD PI MANILA HE KW 28 INESS BUS Wayne Y TA R AT COOK RD R LO PI HU NT RD D TO NR D R ER SV IL LE RD P O 131 IL FO EL IC M " ) Siemens PLM D ST O R N H UT K-W IL LIA SO M S C O R N W EN RD D T-O BUCKTOWN RD LF AS 50 450 Newtonsville BE £ ¤ PO O P RD RD 727 CEDARVILLE R c Æ Day Heights 131 P O DEN DA CE RD RD N-E LD LE BELFAST RD FIE VIL HO ER AT DE R MA Mount Repose GOSHEN E RD RD C BU PRIC NEWTONSVILLE RD Stonelick State Park MARATHON-EDENTON ILLE RD AIN BRANCH HILL-MIAMIV RD PL VILLE A RD Mulberry P O 450 AS NT MANIL P O Milford 133 48 WOOD " ) P O P O 28 Riverwalk Flats C LU SA HE A LE RD Hamilton RD -P RD Y RLI NG N TO NR C M PU EN EA c Æ Miami Miamiville Goshen RD -S ED Y FA 48 ISO N RD VILLE RD P O Y HE NEWTONS D NR C M RD R 28 OH ER 132 SR IL N RR SH R UIN O L-G HIL C MAIN ST GA P O OLD ST AIN M H P O 126 S N C AN BR § ¨ ¦ 71 D O RD RD XT PA Clinton LN COZAD DALE E ST AR W PY RD L-L HIL UM ST N CH Warren LLE RD OV TIO ID G AN O`BAN NONVI RD TA BR BR D LS AN EL HIL § ¨ ¦ 275 RD RD ON HINS RD EY NTER MO ABER RD N LA CY CO RN -M AR HO AT N RD RK RD APEL RD RD LL SA LM PA AR D RD DE OLD SR 32 e/ B Hik RD S TW IN BR ID GE 133 ONCO RD RD GS MILL ER D-HENNIN CORN P O CONCOR EL-C 749 P A Williamsburg Williamsburg BETH Æ a P O LA c Æ M AL JACK BOOT 52 125 DE 133 LLY RD US P Amelia O LA P O MT HO OLD Pierce RD 32 East Fork State Park CHAPEL RD c Æ 52 BU KEEV MC P O RE s po ) ed Tra il Æ a") Amelia Kroger ER RD SHARPS CUTOFF RD " )" ) Senior Services AC 132 RD Clermont YMCA e/ Bi ke OAK RD Hik MERW IN TEN WHITE P O PI i ke RD MILE BACH-BUXTON RD MC MANN RD RD HOPPER HILL RD FULTON GROVE d) ose Æ a LD TA BA p ro D Modern " ) American Insurance Group CH £ ¤ G D UC Clermont " ) East (P OR Batavia VIA R ail Tr SC BA c Æ C I 32 ke TO ILEEM RO HE OLD SR Bi e/ Hik NIN D RD 132 " ) UC Clermont Batavia College RD FERRIS P O COLLEGE DR R LO Withamsville RD LF RD Y TA 275 ER HA R LE SON AG ro AY 125 § ¦ ¨ FIL 74 Tr ail PI SR (P OLD LN Co .A irp or t Civic Center K on t Æ a CLOU GH JACK P O 222 IC EL P O ER c Æ ER RD Union c Æ " ) " Union Twp. ) SH YK 286 50 P O rm Jungle Jim's TQL " ) Headquarters RD P O £ ¤ Jackson Y PA Cle " ) Eastgate Mall Mount Carmel NO RD BLUE SK AMELIA-OLIVE BRANCH RD 32 275 RK 276 P O § ¨ ¦ FO TONS EC BE 275 WN RD SUMMERSIDE RD Owensville TEALTO C I § ¦ ¨ HY RD County Fairgrounds " ) Summerside US R Cincinnati Nature " ) Center BR E ITM WH 132 HUTC P O VILL E- Stonelick RD NEW RD D HW OO BOTTOM FOMO RIN RD " ) Tata ROUND RD LE-M LINDA T HO LLY RD RD BANTAM CLOVER RTRE E RD BETHEL-CONCORD RD CHARITY ST M NTA UTH RD CRANE SCHOOL HOUSE RD RICHMOND c Æ Bethel RD CORN OAK P O JO NE P O Existing Major Transportation Routes LE RD SWING -MAP S CO 222 Existing Improved Connections L RD RD TIO CH RD 756 P O RD 743 OW P O OSC NR OO TR D LAUR LE Zimmer Power Station Washington IT RID GE Franklin RD ER RD Felicity c Æ Y-H IT IG G [ D R T R D £ ¤ ) Chilo" Chilo Lock 34 Park P O 133 RD CHILO 222 W LO Bracken P O RT SPUR 52 BA Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report YR RD Parks and Greenspace HE SP UR SP Neville Municipalities Census Designated Places IN FRAN KLIN LE VIL Pendleton LOVE RD NE Roads RIC O Kenton 28 ND LE IC BO L FE Railroad Lakes and Rivers 756 133 Asset/Point of Interest Townships P O P O RD U FR Y Health Center HE " ) " ) Moscow RIC c Æ C I C I Library 774 EL-M Park & Ride Location AN E RD OP SW P O ER INT ISABE R LO LAUREL-PO S-F 232 Potential Future River Crossing OAK CORNER RD RNER -PT SODOM RD DONALD RD GIE NE L RD ISABE HY ELBE TH RD Tate EL BETH LLE-LA ONTVI RD ER RD RD VIL LE RD L RD UREL CLERM SPRING GROVE 125 232 LS RE Buckeye Trail Boundaries and Places P O P O Bikeway, Proposed c Æ Brown RD HO -LAU Monroe NG IC KLIN Campbell BETHEL-NEW RLI AIRPORT RD FRAN Bikeway, Built/Planned BETHEL-NEW RICHMOND RD LAUREL-LINDA RD New Richmond STA -N 132 Æ a HOLSVILLE SO LINDALE-NIC RD EL ILE LA UR EM P O Important Connection to Improve (3 lanes) North-South Route (Future) ELV JETT HILL Transportation Routes TW LE RD c Æ BA Ohio Ready Zone Æ a RD RD Community Center r SBURG- SUGA Beckjord Power Station RD AH RD " ) MT PISG Economic Development Zones WILLIAM AM RD BANT 0 r 2 4 Miles Data Sources: Clermont County GIS; US Census Bureau; CBI Created 8/5/2014 PARKS, NATURE, AND RECREATION RECOMMENDATIONS What we heard: What we know: Priority Workshop attendees voted for their top three priority topics within each theme at the April 26, 2014 workshop. An online survey was conducted to gain additional community feedback in late April/early May. A total of 317 community members completed the survey to rank their top three priority topics. Following are a few facts that highlight the current condition of Parks, Nature, and Recreation within Clermont County: The percentage next to each topic indicates the percent of responses that had that topic as a top priority (workshop and survey). 17% Family-friendly recreation for everyone 14% Natural habitat, river and wildlife preservation 11% Community/Township parks 8% Promotion and publicity of natural resources and recreation 29 Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report ▪▪ Clermont County has 79 parks, from small village and township parks to large state parks and preserves ▪▪ Clermont County has the most state park land (12,484 acres) of all Ohio counties in the Cincinnati Metro-area ▪▪ The Clermont County Park District offers facility rentals for family reunions, weddings, and special events in shelters, Pattison lodge, and Hartman Cabin What should we do? Based on Clermont Agenda for the Future public feedback and existing conditions, the Work Team developed the following recommendations: GOAL 8 Clermont County residents are better served by parks at all levels (State, County, Township, City and Village) which are an asset that makes Clermont County the place to live, work and play in Greater Cincinnati. ACTION 8a Establish a coalition of Parks, the Park Alliance for Clermont County or “PACC.” PACC will collaborate to catalog, improve, and expand park offerings; promote the parks to the public; share best practices and expertise; and work together to improve public and private funding. ACTION 8b Create public awareness of what is currently available in parks (see Parks and Greenspace Map, page 30). ACTION 8c Create public awareness of park volunteer opportunities. ACTION 8d Create a comprehensive parks resource development plan and advocate for improvements and enhancements. Potential Partners Clermont County Park District Business Owners East Fork State Park Manager OSU Extension – Clermont County Township Administrators, Community Park Representatives Milford, Loveland Park representatives 30 Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report Overall, Parks, Nature, and Recreation was ranked the highest priority Theme by workshop and online survey participants. GOAL 9 There are more preserved and protected natural areas in Clermont County that can be enjoyed by current and future generations. ACTION 9a Inventory Clermont County greenspace. (see Parks and Greenspace Map, page 33, and Future Land Use Map, page 20). ACTION 9b Develop and implement a County-wide Greenspace Plan. ACTION 9c Educate citizens, corporations, public officials, government entities about importance of and best practices for greenspace preservation and management. Potential Partners Clermont County Planning Commission Cincinnati Nature Center (Center for Conservation and Stewardship) Clermont County Soil & Water Conservation District The Land Conservancy of Hamilton County East Fork Watershed Collaborative (includes US EPA Office of Research and Development, US Army Corps of Engineers, US Geological Survey, USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service, Ohio EPA and several others) Township Zoning Departments Park Districts (Clermont County Parks, Townships, State Parks) Green Umbrella (Land Team with Ohio-Kentucky-Indiana Regional Council of Governments) Valley View Foundation Clermont County Office of Environmental Quality OSU Extension – Clermont County Little Miami Conservancy 31 Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report This Goal speaks to a value statement that workshop and online survey participants expressed often - that a balanced approach to future development was important. GOAL 10 Quality of life for Clermont County residents is enhanced by improving the variety and availability of recreational activities in Clermont County. ACTION 10a Develop Clermont County Recreation Task Team. ACTION 10b Survey and inventory what is currently available and what residents would like to have in terms of recreational activities (public and private). ACTION 10c Develop an implementation plan and work collaboratively with the Clermont Agenda Community communication recommendations (GOAL 11). Potential Partners LEAD Clermont Alumni Association YMCA of Clermont County Clermont County Park District Clermont CAN Miami Township Recreation Clermont County Agricultural Society Clermont County Public Library United Way of Greater Cincinnati (Eastern Area) Chambers of Commerce Clermont Convention and Visitors Bureau 32 Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report This Goal ranked as a fairly high priority among online survey participants. Parks and Greenspace Map Parks and Greenspace Clermont County, Ohio Warren Loveland Clinton Goshen Wayne Miami Hamilton Newtonsville Milford Stonelick Jackson Owensville Union Batavia Batavia Williamsburg Pierce Amelia Williamsburg Brown Ohio Bethel New Richmond Campbell Township Boundary Tate Monroe Moscow Washington Municipal Boundary Parks and Greenspace (Publicly and Privately Owned) Felicity State (12,190 acres) Kenton Private (2,513 acres) Township (1,011 acres) County (512 acres) Pendleton Municipal (371 acres) Hamilton County (365 acres) Golf Courses (1,634 acres) [ Franklin Neville Chilo Bracken 0 2 4 Miles Data Sources: Clermont County GIS; US Census Bureau; CBI Created 8/2014. Locations and acreages are for estimating purposes only. CBI is not responsible for the accuracy of numbers presentated. Sources: Esri, USGS, NOAA 33 Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report COMMUNITY RECOMMENDATIONS What we heard: What we know: Priority Workshop attendees voted for their top three priority topics within each theme at the April 26, 2014 workshop. An online survey was conducted to gain additional community feedback in late April/early May. A total of 317 community members completed the survey to rank their top three priority topics. Following are a few facts that highlight the current condition of Community within Clermont County: The percentage next to each topic indicates the percent of responses that had that topic as a top priority (workshop and survey). 20% Safe and clean neighborhoods and streets 10% County-wide Communication (and branding) 9% Community events, festivals and parades 9% Business engagement with communities and schools 6% Volunteerism (and organizations, county pride and unity) 5% Leadership training and governance 34 Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report ▪▪ Over 54 major events in Clermont County in 2014 draw both residents and visitors ▪▪ The 21st Salute to Leaders Awards Banquet honored more than 31 community members; attendance at the Banquet was over 575 ▪▪ Clermont County has 425 LEAD Clermont graduates that have completed high quality leadership and team building training What should we do? Based on Clermont Agenda for the Future public feedback and existing conditions, the Work Team developed the following recommendations: GOAL 11 Clermont County residents have easy access to information about activities, events, services, and places in the county and this information is shared with residents of surrounding communities. ACTION 11a Establish a team of experts as a governing board to create a comprehensive communication plan and financial strategy. ACTION 11b Develop a comprehensive communication strategy that includes web, mobile, social media, and traditional channels. ACTION 11c Establish a governing board to oversee implementation of the plan on an ongoing basis. The board will hire/select appropriate staff for day-to-day operations. ACTION 11d Launch communications outreach effort, including marketing plan. Potential Partners Clermont County Park District Boy Scouts Clermont County Public Library Girl Scouts Convention and Visitors Bureau Cincinnati Nature Center (Center for Conservation and Leadership) Local government agencies Clermont County Educational Service Center Clermont County Township association United Way of Greater Cincinnati (Eastern Area) OSU Extension –Clermont County Clermont County Mayor’s Association 35 Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report This goal encompasses parts of many other goals, and implementation should involve regular communication and collaboration among all teams. Clermont NOW GOAL 12 Clermont County will have a defined recognizable brand. A “brand” is a reputation and a promise. It is the totality of experience. “Brands appeal to the need, anxiety, aspiration.” – Anne Kingston ACTION 12a Collect and evaluate Clermont’s current “reputation,” compare to “vision” and identify gaps. ACTION 12b Develop an umbrella or guiding brand statement and strategy, and supporting tactical items such as logo, tag line, and collateral formats. ACTION 12c Develop and deploy internal and external Clermont County message and channels. ACTION 12d Outline a financial strategy to support the plan. ACTION 12e Conduct annual review. Potential Partners Local branding/marketing firms/ individuals 36 Agenda for the Future Work Teams and associated projects Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report Collaboration with the Economic Opportunity implementation team is important for this Goal. GOAL 13 Volunteerism increases connections and strengthens the County. ACTION 13a Determine platform that will be used as a central hub for those with volunteer opportunities and those looking to volunteer (such as VolunteerMatch.com). This will be linked to the communication platform/website. ACTION 13b Establish operating plan for governance and long-term financial sustainability plan. ACTION 13c Launch volunteer platform. Potential Partners Agencies and organizations that use the assistance of volunteers United Way of Greater Cincinnati (Eastern Area) Businesses who are currently doing active volunteer work in the County Other non-profit entities such as schools, hospitals, youth organizations, service agencies, fine arts programs, churches, etc. 37 Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report Clermont County residents place a high value on their ability to come together and help each other when the need arises. GOAL 14 Clermont County has an increased level of leadership effectiveness. ACTION 14a Assess current leadership in Clermont County and benchmark to best practices. ACTION 14b Train and develop leaders through LEAD Clermont, LOOK to Clermont, United Way BOLD board training, and other similar leadership development programs. ACTION 14c Deploy leaders to lead critical Clermont projects through the LEAD Clermont Alumni Association (LCAA) that no one else can or will do. ACTION 14d Annually assess outcomes and impacts, and make appropriate improvements. ACTION 14e Outline a financial strategy to support the plan. Potential Partners LEAD Clermont LOOK to Clermont United Way of Greater Cincinnati (Eastern Area) LEAD Clermont Alumni Association (LCAA) LEAD Clermont Seniors 38 LEAD Clermont Teachers Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report This Goal calls for leadership development for all types of leaders, from elected officials, to professional leadership, to youth leadership. A B C LIFELONG LEARNING RECOMMENDATIONS What we heard: What we know: Priority Workshop attendees voted for their top three priority topics within each theme at the April 26, 2014 workshop. An online survey was conducted to gain additional community feedback in late April/early May. A total of 317 community members completed the survey to rank their top three priority topics. Following are a few facts that highlight the current condition of Lifelong Learning within Clermont County: The percentage next to each topic indicates the percent of responses that had that topic as a top priority (workshop and survey). ▪▪ 12.1% of Clermont residents 25 or older have no high school diploma, slightly higher than the regional percentage of 11.6% (2012) 23% Local school districts (education, facilities, funding and management) 16% College and career readiness ▪▪ 79% of children are prepared for kindergarten, the same rate as southwest Ohio (2010/11) ▪▪ 33% of Clermont residents 25 or older have at least an Associate’s Degree, compared to 37% in the region overall (2012) 14% Pre-K, Head Start and early literacy 39 14% Lifelong learning 14% Job/vocational training Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report A B C What should we do? Based on Clermont Agenda for the Future public feedback and existing conditions, the Work Team developed the following recommendations: GOAL 15 Clermont residents and stakeholders understand the importance of, and invest in, the social and economic value of learning. The Clermont County Agenda for the Future views education and learning as a lifelong activity across the lifespan and not as limited only to compulsory formal educational settings. ACTION 15a Create an educational services road map by curating a comprehensive list of lifelong learning providers available to Clermont County residents across one’s lifespan. All Clermont residents could locate themselves on the road map and find available resources and information from lifelong learning providers. Potential Partners All learning providers, parents, families, and individuals 40 United Way of Greater Cincinnati (Eastern Area) Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report A B C GOAL 16 Every child enters kindergarten prepared for success in school. ACTION 16a Improve the quality of existing daycare centers and increase the quantity of quality daycare centers. ACTION 16b Establish partnerships with the business community to support improvements in the quality of early learning experiences offered to young children in our community. ACTION 16c Develop a communication/outreach plan. ACTION 16d Improve outreach efforts for young children staying at home. ACTION 16e Support the implementation of best practices, such as the Ready School Initiative and Born Learning Academy, in Clermont County schools. Potential Partners Elementary schools Churches Parents Senior organizations Preschool providers STRIVE Step Up to Quality United Way of Greater Cincinnati (Eastern Area) 4C Help Me Grow Head Start Success By 6 Child Focus Healthcare providers/pediatricians OSU Extension – Clermont County Women, Infants, and Children (WIC) program Archdiocese of Cincinnati UC Clermont Clermont County Public Library 41 Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report A B C GOAL 17 Every child in Clermont County has equal access to learning that helps them succeed in school and life. Goal #17 was the highest-priority Lifelong Learning goal among workshop and online survey participants ACTION 17a Collect data about essential elements of life and work skills programs that Clermont school districts currently offer students within their curriculum and/or they make available through other community resources (see Public Schools Map, page 45). ACTION 17b Inventory student development programs across school districts to identify which programs are similar, and which schools may have gaps in programs. ACTION 17c Gather information about student development initiatives that have been done in the past, are in use now, or are planned in the near future. One example is the Clermont Chamber of Commerce Foundation Work Readiness Initiative which connects students and businesses to give students first-hand experience working with successful local businesses. ACTION 17d Gather information about what school districts are doing regarding shared services or resources that benefit the mission of educating students while containing the costs of operating school districts. ACTION 17e Gather information regarding the current priority goals Clermont school districts have established for students in their respective districts. (i.e. graduation rates, test scores, post-secondary learning, etc.) ACTION 17f Review the United Way regional collective Education Bold Goals to assess how the Lifelong Learning of the Clermont Agenda for the Future aligns. Potential Partners Chambers of Commerce (business members) Clermont Educational Service Center UC Clermont Human Resources Roundtable School District Boards of Education 42 School district administrators (continued on next page) Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report A B C Career Centers (Grant Vocational, Great Oaks, etc.) United Way of Greater Cincinnati (Eastern Area) Partners for a Competitive Workforce Informal Learning Centers (park districts, historical societies, etc.) 43 STRIVE Work Readiness Initiative (Clermont Chamber) OSU Extension – Clermont County Archdiocese of Cincinnati Cincinnati Nature Center Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report A B C GOAL 18 Every adult in Clermont County continuously develops skills, knowledge, and experiences to achieve personal, professional, and community goals. ACTION 18a Benchmark existing educational opportunities and programs in Clermont County and surrounding areas. ACTION 18b Inventory existing and potential facilities that offer, or could provide and/or house future educational programs. ACTION 18c Identify gaps in educational opportunities. ACTION 18d Assess why people do not participate in learning opportunities and consider appropriate action. ACTION 18e Analyze data on current levels of educational attainment in the county by community. ACTION 18f Form a network of decentralized community learning centers to include schools, libraries, community centers, and on-line learning sites. ACTION 18g Develop tool to benchmark measurable progress towards goals for annual review. Potential Partners UC Clermont On-line Providers Clermont Senior Services For-profit Companies (TQL, Multi Color, etc.) Clermont County Public Library Human Resources Roundtable Literacy Council of Clermont and Brown Counties Career Centers (Grant Vocational, Great Oaks, etc.) Informal Learning Centers (park districts, historical societies, etc.) Clermont Educational Service Center Archdiocese of Cincinnati OSU Extension – Clermont County Post-secondary Education 44 Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report A B C Public Schools and Education Map Public Schools and Education Facilities Facilities Clermont County, Ohio Warren PY N RD RD COOK RD RD RD N RD RD MARATHON-EDENTON EL IC N ST O RK FOMO RIN FO RD P O 286 RD HY £ ¤ 50 EY US º Æ ¹ º c ¹ MO Jackson ABER RD G N LA BLUE SK CY CO RN ER -M AR HO AT N RD Y PA RK RD RO HE LD RD RE SA RD RD MC º º¹ ¹ P O 32 HA Batavia 132 BU KEEV DR AC IT AL P O PI SP LF HO LA DE K RD Æ ºc ¹¹ º EL KL IC N DR EGE 132 Batavia ELKLICK RD ¹ º RD P O º ¹ºc ¹ Æ º ¹ AF TO PI WHITE LL RD RD ER RD ER SHARPS CUTOFF RD SON AG OLD SR 32 LA P M AL A LM PA AR D RD DE Williamsburg OLD SR OAK RD 32 CHAPEL RD OLD P Amelia O 52 125 RD S TW LLY RD US c ƹ º ¹ º CHAPEL RD MT HO º ¹ 52 131 RD UTCHINSO D R ER N R O C M S BR D Pierce P O BUCKTOWN RD RD BUCKWHEAT HILL RD LFPE N-PL EASA NT WO RD BACH-BUXTON RD MC MANN RD HOPPER HILL RD R LE FIL 222 RD OR RD JACK P O R LO SC BA RD 74 Y TA TO ILEEM º ¹ FERRIS GH AY SR RD AMELIA-OLIVE BRANCH NIN D CLOU º ¹ OLD LN SH MILE RD MERWIN TEN ER K COLL O RD EL-TOBASC TE BV RD YK IL LE K-W IL LIA E RD PRIC RD D SUMMERSIDE RD IVY POIN Z LT £ ¤ RD GOSHEN ILLE RD BRANCH HILL-MIAMIV HW OO EC BE O MT CARM RD H IC EL 125 RD 276 R LN º¹ º º¹ ¹ NT P O º c Æ ¹ PE P O 275 SV Owensville Union CLEP RD R N W º ¹ AS W HIT ME 275 AIC º ¹ § ¦ ¨ W EN Stonelick RD § ¦ ¨ EASTGATE BV 32 HU D T-O P O P O PI NR LF AS TO AL TE 32 R LO Newtonsville BE 132 P O 727 TO BOTTOM P O DEN ROUND C LU R RD N-E DA CE RD LE BELFAST RD 450 LD º ¹ 50 450 FIE VIL HO ER AT DE R MA 28 PO O P Wayne Y TA P O £ ¤ RD S 133 PI RD S 28 131 º ¹ VILLE P O A RD MANILA S INE P O Milford WOOD AIN RD Hamilton Goshen PL EA ¹ º Miami ¹ º º ¹ º ¹ º¹ ¹ º c Æ NT UIN BU NO MANIL SA L-G HIL 48 RD Y HE A LE CH P O NR C M RD -P º º¹ c ƹ º¹ º¹ RD 48 RLI NG N TO º ¹ Y FA P O PU EN D N-S ED R ISO RD VILLE RD ER Y HE NEWTONS N RD R NR C M OH O 28 IL C AN S BR P O 126 D 132 SR SH AIN M AR W P O OLD ST RR CEDARVILLE N MAIN ST GA NEWTONSV ILLE-H O RD RD XT PA Clinton LN NEWTONSVILLE TIO A UM ST COZAD DALE º ¹ OV LLE RD TA L-L HIL RD LS BR H NC O`BAN NONVI HIL D AN EL NTER ¹ º º º ¹ ¹ º¹ Loveland IN BR ID GE P O 133 BETH Williamsburg EL-C P O 749 ONCO RD T HO LLY BANTAM RD RD SBURG- CLOVER RTRE E RD RD SUGA MT PISG LE-M LINDA WILLIAM AM RD BANT RD AH RD Brown RD CRANE SCHOOL HOUSE RD RD VIL LE CORN RD DONALD RD GIE NE L RD ISABE HY ELBE TH SODOM RD RNER P O LE RD SWING -MAP S CO 222 EL BETH RD RD OAK -N L RD UREL LLE-LA ONTVI SPRING GROVE 125 Tate º ¹ CLERM RD P O -PT RE LS 232 HO -LAU Monroe Township Boundary Bethel P O IC KLIN Campbell Municipal Boundary Æ ¹c º º º¹ ¹ º ¹ RD NG AIRPORT RD FRAN New Richmond RICHMOND LE RD RD BETHEL-NEW RLI ER RD BETHEL-NEW RICHMOND RD STA OAK CORNER RD JETT HILL 132 º ¹¹ º HOLSVILLE RD P O EL ILE LA UR EM LAUREL-LINDA ELV BETHEL-CONCORD RD CHARITY ST RD M LINDALE-NIC TW SO UTH BA NTA Ohio c Æ Public Education Facilities JO P O NE 232 LAUREL-PO L RD RD P O RD 743 P O OW Library CH c Æ TIO Public School RD AN 756 º ¹ E RD OP SW P O ER INT ISABE R LO College S-F EL-M OSC 774 LE NR OO TR D LAUR º ¹ School Districts Moscow GE RD ER Y-H IT IG G IN HE YR [ D SP O R T R D £ ¤ 52 SPUR 222 P O 133 RD Chilo W LO CHILO P O RT Bracken BA Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report RIC RD Williamsburg Local School District FRAN KLIN UR SP West Clermont Local School District Felicity Neville Milford Exempted Village School District New Richmond Exempted Village School District º ¹ c Æ LOVE RD LE VIL Pendleton Loveland City School District RD Franklin NE Goshen Local School District 45 ND LE IC BO L FE Clermont Northeastern Local School District Felicity-Franklin Local School District 756 133 Blanchester Local School District Kenton P O P O RD RID Y IT HE U FR Bethel-Tate Local School District RIC Washington Batavia Local School District 0 1.5 3 Miles Data Sources: Clermont County GIS; US Census Bureau; CBI Created 8/2014. Locations are for estimating purposes only. CBI is not responsible for the accuracy of locations shown. HEALTH AND WELLNESS RECOMMENDATIONS What we heard: What we know: Priority Workshop attendees voted for their top three priority topics within each theme at the April 26, 2014 workshop. An online survey was conducted to gain additional community feedback in late April/early May. A total of 317 community members completed the survey to rank their top three priority topics. Following are a few facts that highlight the current condition of Health and Wellness within Clermont County: The percentage next to each topic indicates the percent of responses that had that topic as a top priority (workshop and survey). 46 22% Substance abuse prevention and enforcement 20% Police, Fire, EMS services 15% Health care facilities and access 10% Mental health care Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report ▪▪ Drug poisoning hospitalizations occurred at a rate of 44 per 100,000 in Clermont County, double the rate in the state (2010) ▪▪ Clermont County residents reported 4 poor mental health days per month, or about one a week, higher than the national average (2013) ▪▪ Clermont County’s population is aging; the median age increased from 35 to 39 between 2000 and 2010, and there are now 23,741 residents 65 or older (2012) What should we do? Based on Clermont Agenda for the Future public feedback and existing conditions, the Work Team developed the following recommendations: GOAL 19 Clermont County will be a drug free community. An Opiate Task Force has been formed to combat illegal drug use in Clermont County. The multi-pronged approach includes reducing supply, increasing advocacy, increasing treatment, preventing use, and reducing harm. The Clermont Agenda for the Future Health and Wellness Work Team supports the work of the Opiate Task Force. ACTION 19a Support the findings and recommendations of the Opiate Task Force. Potential Partners Clermont Mental Health and Recovery Board Opiate Task Force 47 Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report Goal #19 was the overall highestpriority goal among public workshop and online survey participants. GOAL 20 The community will be more aware and supportive of mental health services as integral to the quality of life of all citizens in helping them live quality lives and achieve maximum health and independence. ACTION 20a Support the Mental Health and Recovery Board to improve mental health through education, prevention, and integration of mental and physical health services. ACTION 20b Support the activities identified in the Clermont County Community Health Improvement Plan. Potential Partners Clermont Mental Health and Recovery Board Clermont County Suicide Prevention Coalition Mercy Health Partners United Way of Greater Cincinnati (Eastern Area) Clermont County Schools Clermont County Public Health Greater Cincinnati Foundation University of Cincinnati, East and Clermont campuses Recovery Board 48 OSU Extension – Clermont County Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report It is important to refer to the Health Improvement Plan for more information about the current mental health needs of Clermont County residents (www. clermonthealthdistrict. org) GOAL 21 Clermont health (mental and physical) and wellness outcomes are bolstered and the community will report having excellent or very good health through expanded partnerships and collaborations. Clermont County is currently developing a Community Health Improvement Plan. The plan will guide health system partners over the next five years to work on the top priority issues in the County. The top priority issues include Obesity/Physical Activity/Nutrition, Drug Addiction, Tobacco Use, and Mental Health. The following Action Steps support the implementation of the Community Health Improvement Plan strategies. ACTION 21a Identify and engage potential partners and collaborators around a key issue. ACTION 21b Create an inventory of available health, wellness, and supportive services (see Health and Emergency Facilities Map, page 50). ACTION 21c Map the location of health, wellness, and supportive services. ACTION 21d Identify gaps in access to health, wellness, and supportive services. ACTION 21e Determine ways/means necessary to assure accessibility to health, wellness, and supportive services. Potential Partners Clermont CAN members (Clermont County General Health District Coalition for Activity and Nutrition) Clermont County Safety Net Alliance members 49 United Way of Greater Cincinnati (Eastern Area) Mercy Health Partners The Ridge Private sector health care businesses Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report Health and Emergency Health and Emergency Facilities Facilities Map Clermont County, Ohio Warren LLE RD UM PY RD XT O N RD RD 133 48 MA NIL PI VILLE NEWTONSVILLE COOK RD RD WO OD A RD MANILA RD S A IN RD CK RD BU ICE CA PL EA Wayne W PR LU T IN BRANCH HILL-MIAMIV ILLE RD RD AN U Miami NG AS RD Y RLI LE NR PU N-P L -G 8 Goshen 75 HE C M N-S TO RD ISO RD EN Y Y VILLE RD FA 48 NR ED D HE NEW TONS R RD ER H N C M O R 28 IL O HIL C CH S AN D BR 126 R RR 132 SR O LD ST SH A IN M A W MAIN ST GA HE AT RD TA RD AS T-O W EN SV IL LE RD IL K-W Stonelick O N 15 RIN RD RK ON FO MO RD RD 286 RD FO TC HI NS HY NT TO NS Jackson NEW MO BE AL TO ABER RD TE Owensville 50 EY US EC BR ER RD HU OO R HW ME VILL E- W HIT D RD 1 132 W Union 3 TO BA SC OR O R N O N R D RD V IA SR DR AC SA 32 DE RD K IC KL DE EL N TO OLD SR 32 AF 132 ER RD KEEV SE SA UL S TE CO LL SHARPS CUTOFF RD JAME MC TA RD LD LL RD BA RO ELKLICK RD IL E- C N PI RD Batavia RD RD E BRANCH IS AMELI A-OLIV RR 222 HE SO GA MC MANN RD RD HOPPER HILL RD OR EM 132 Batavia YL NIN D 4 5 7 6 18 14 LL OLD SR 74 TA 11 16 275 LA P M AL A LA PA LM A RD RD Williamsburg OLD D MILE RD MERW IN TEN ER Y H TO RD N RD YK C AT RD R TO RD N RE LE RD LF -BUX AY ER HA CH SH AG RD PI FE NO LA PARK AR RD JACK FIL 222 R LN DR PE EG E ST EA BV G AT MT CARM EL-TO IVY POIN TE CLEP SK Y -M 276 BA CLOUGH 471 125 BLUE E BV 32 G 2 275 ER BU BASCO RD RD SUMMERSIDE RD N 32 131 L IA M S C O R N ER R D LF IC M RD ST TTO D BO EL 450 RO UN WOLFPEN-P 9 Newtonsville D NR 50 727 TO Milford BE RD LE RD IL RD RV RD NT BUCKTOWN DA CEDARVILLE CE D GOSHEN R HU D EN LD LEASA NT FIE PI N-E HILL RD R R HO EE O AT Hamilton D BELFAST RD 13 YL R MA 28 RD PA RD RD E ST Clinton LN COZADDALE ST N L -L O`BANNONVI RD T IO HIL D TA CH AN LS IDG AN EL HIL BR BR OV MARATHON-EDENTON Loveland Pierce WHITE OAK RD 12 OLD 17 LLY MT HO 52 SR 32 CHAPEL RD US TW IN BR ID GE RD S 52 133 RD Amelia BETH Williamsburg EL-C 749 ONCO RD LL T HO BAN TAM RD E RD SBURG- RD RT RE CLOVER SUGA LE -M RD Y RD Brown M LINDALE-NIC HOLSVILLE RD CRANE SCHOOL HOUSE RD RD RICHM OND RD 232 CO RN E L- JO Municipal Boundary RD Township Boundary APLE SW ING EL-M S CO RN RD RD ER-PT TH BE UREL BETH LLE -LA SODO M RD DONALD HY G IE L RD NE RD OAK UR EL -N L RD IC RE Tate ISABE -L AU LE RD LAURE L-LINDA KL IN ON TVI SPRING GROVE RD 125 LE RD BETHE L-NEW AIRPORT RD AN Monroe CLERM RD ER RD BETHEL-NEW RICHMOND RD FR Campbell NG RLI OAK CORNER RD RD JETT HILL New Richmond STA Bethel V IL IL E 132 LS EM HO ELV LA TW SO UTH BA N TA Ohio 10 BETHEL-CONCORD RD RD LINDA WILLIAM AM RD BANT NE LO INT ISABE L RD RD AN E RD TIO CH RD 756 743 OW RD Fire/EMS OP R SW RE LAUREL-PO S -F 232 Healthcare Facilities EL -M O SC 774 LE NR OO T RD LAUR Police RD EY E H G RIC 756 RD RID 133 ND ER RD Felicity Y-H LE IT BO LIC IG G RIC H EY RD SP O R T R D Franklin IN Neville 222 W 133 RD Chilo LO Bracken RT SPUR 52 BA Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report UIT FE 50 Pendleton FR RD Kenton Washington FRANKLIN AMERICA NURSING CARE CHILD FOCUS - YOUTH/ADOLESCENT CHILDREN'S HOSPITAL - OUTPATIENT CLERMONT CO. GENERAL HEALTH DISTRICT CLERMONT CO. GENERAL- NURSING/WIC CLERMONT PEDIATRIC CENTER HEALTH SOURCE OF OHIO - BATAVIA HEALTH SOURCE OF OHIO - GOSHEN HEALTH SOURCE OF OHIO - ADMINISTRATIVE HEALTHSOURCE OF OHIO - NEW RICHMOND HEARING, SPEECH & DEAF CENTER LIFEPOINT SOLUTIONS - AMELIA LIFEPOINT SOLUTIONS - MILFORD MERCY HEALTH - CLERMONT HOSPITAL NORTHLAND TREATMENT CENTER PLANNED PARENTHOOD PREGNANCY CENTER OF CLERMONT CO. CLERMONT RECOVERY CENTER LOVE RD 1. 1. 2. 2. 3. 3. 4. 4. 5. 5. 6. 6. 7. 7. 8. 8. 9. 9. 10. 10. 11. 11. 12. 12. 13. 13. 14. 14. 15. 15. 16. 16. 17. 17. 18. 18. CHILO Moscow Healthcare Facilities 0 2 4 Miles Data Sources: Clermont County GIS; US Census Bureau; CBI Created 8/2014. Locations are for estimating purposes only. CBI is not responsible for the accuracy of locations shown. HOUSING RECOMMENDATIONS What we heard: What we know: Priority Workshop attendees voted for their top three priority topics within each theme at the April 26, 2014 workshop. An online survey was conducted to gain additional community feedback in late April/early May. A total of 317 community members completed the survey to rank their top three priority topics. Following are a few facts that highlight the current condition of Housing within Clermont County: The percentage next to each topic indicates the percent of responses that had that topic as a top priority (workshop and survey). 17% Property maintenance/ enforcement 16% Mix of housing types (single- family homes, apartments, condos, assisted living) 13% Housing for young adults and professionals 11% Advocacy and planning 10% Quality affordable rental housing 51 Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report ▪▪ Clermont County’s population grew by 10.9% between 2000 and 2010, and is expected to grow by another 14.2% by the year 2020 ▪▪ Clermont County is losing rural population more quickly than the state – the County lost 12% of its rural population between 2000 and 2010 while the state only lost 1% (the land classified as “rural” is changing to urban/suburban) ▪▪ There are 6 separate sewer service and 11 water service providers in Clermont County What should we do? Based on Clermont Agenda for the Future public feedback and existing conditions, the Work Team developed the following recommendations: GOAL 22 Clermont County understands future population growth demands and existing and future capacity of land and buildings. ACTION 22a Identify and inventory land areas suitable for residential development, as well as existing structures suitable for rehabilitation, based on demand and opportunity (including zoning, topography, basic sewer/water/utilities, travel times and proximity to amenities). ACTION 22b Analyze population growth trends to project the quantity and types of housing units that will be needed over the next 5-20 years. Potential Partners Sewer Departments (local and County) Local Real Estate Association Office of Clermont Geographic Information Systems Clermont County Commissioners Zoning officers (Township Association, Mayors Association) Realtors (for market and housing trends) OKI (Ohio-Kentucky-Indiana Regional Council of Governments - for projections, traffic, other data) Chambers of Commerce Local Homebuilders Association Lenders Clermont Metropolitan Housing Authority Clermont County Board of Developmental Disabilities Clermont County Community Services Students of local colleges and universities (UC Clermont, Xavier, etc. Developers/Homebuilders 52 Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report Steady projected population growth over the next 25 years, along with residents’ emphasis on balance between development and land preservation, make it especially important to understand existing capacity. GOAL 23 Housing in Clermont County can meet growth demands in all population segments. ACTION 23a Promote to government officials, planners and administrators the modification of community land use plans and zoning codes for residential housing to align with projected demand and sewer/water/utility capacities. ACTION 23b Develop a marketing plan to educate homebuilders and buyers about the importance of providing housing opportunities that meet the needs of all of our citizens. ACTION 23c Design and construct sewers if necessary to address capacity and demand (see County Sewer and Septic Map, page 54). Potential Partners Local business leaders Local elected officials Community leaders (Rotary Alliance and other groups) OKI (Ohio-Kentucky-Indiana Regional Council of Governments) Landowners Clermont County Commissioners Sewer Departments (local and County) Clermont Metropolitan Housing Authority Zoning officers (Township Association, Mayors Association) Clermont County Board of Developmental Disabilities Realtors and Local Real Estate Association (for market and housing trends) Clermont County Community Services Developers/Homebuilders Affordable Housing Coalition Clermont Homebuilders Association Chambers of Commerce Lenders 53 Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report County Sewer and Septic Map 54 Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report IMPLEMENTATION The planning process that took place in 2014 is only the first step in Clermont County’s Agenda for the Future. In 2015 and beyond, leaders, partners and volunteers will be begin to implement the goals and actions steps outlined in this report. The Clermont Chamber of Commerce Foundation will convene quarterly steering committee meetings, as well as an annual public presentation and evaluation of progress. The 7 Work Teams will continue as implementation teams. These teams and their volunteer leadership will serve as Agenda ambassadors and catalysts for implementing action, and are tasked with the following: • Confirm and recruit members of Work Teams • Develop work plans for implementation of goals and action steps • Convene, Collaborate, Connect with other Work Teams, partners, volunteers and the public • Hold regular team meetings TIMELINE 55 January 2015 Launch Implementation phase of Clermont Agenda for the Future Winter-Spring 2015 Form Implementation teams and begin work Summer-Fall 2015 Engage partners to pursue Goals and Action Steps January 2016 and beyond Reconvene, evaluate progress and continue Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report APPENDIX 56 Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report 57 Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report answered question skipped question TOTAL Economic Opportunity - GOAL 1: Competitive sites for new and expanding firms Economic Opportunity - GOAL 2: Customized employee training and recruitment Economic Opportunity - GOAL 3: Marketing and branding strategy Transportation - GOAL 4: Maintain transportation for residents and economic development Transportation - GOAL 5: Public transportation connects community centers Transportation - GOAL 6: Connections between community centers and other important destinations Transportation - GOAL 7: Bikeways and sidewalks Parks, Nature, Recreation - GOAL 8: Parks as assets for residents and Greater Cincinnati Parks, Nature, Recreation - GOAL 9: Preserved and protected natural areas Parks, Nature, Recreation - GOAL 10: Recreational activities enhance quality of life Community - GOAL 11: Easy access to information about activities, events, services, and places Community - GOAL 12: Defined recognizable brand Community - GOAL 13: Volunteerism Community - GOAL 14: Leadership effectiveness Lifelong Learning - GOAL 15: Understanding of social and economic value of learning ("Blue line") Lifelong Learning - GOAL 16: All children prepared for kindergarten Lifelong Learning - GOAL 17: Learning that helps children succeed in school and life Lifelong Learning - GOAL 18: Adults achieve personal, professional, and community goals Health and Wellness - GOAL 19: Drug free community Health and Wellness - GOAL 20: Mental health services seen as integral to quality of life Health and Wellness - GOAL 21: Expanded partnerships to support health and wellness Housing - GOAL 22: Future population growth and County capacity are studied and analyzed Housing - GOAL 23: Housing meets growth demands (through land-use and education) Answer Options 44.0% 9.7% 13.7% 34.1% 15.6% 15.8% 47.2% 43.6% 37.5% 36.8% 32.8% 5.3% 12.0% 17.5% 8.4% 18.5% 48.2% 17.1% 58.5% 25.5% 22.1% 24.4% 16.2% 475 64 209 46 65 162 74 75 224 207 178 175 156 25 57 83 40 88 229 81 278 121 105 116 77 2871 Response Response Percent Count Choose up to 7 Goals that are most important to you. If you choose fewer than 7, those will have a higher importance. 257.1 49.7 74.2 185.8 88.7 85.5 258.6 237.9 226.6 199.4 172.9 25.7 63.0 93.2 43.5 101.0 267.7 90.9 327.1 134.2 114.9 139.0 88.4 3325.0 Count % 7.7% 1.5% 2.2% 5.6% 2.7% 2.6% 7.8% 7.2% 6.8% 6.0% 5.2% 0.8% 1.9% 2.8% 1.3% 3.0% 8.1% 2.7% 9.8% 4.0% 3.5% 4.2% 2.7% WEIGHTED Survey Response 30 13 22 21 21 12 22 29 14 5 20 17 9 8 9 17 14 25 24 13 15 15 10 385 Count 7.8% 3.4% 5.7% 5.5% 5.5% 3.1% 5.7% 7.5% 3.6% 1.3% 5.2% 4.4% 2.3% 2.1% 2.3% 4.4% 3.6% 6.5% 6.2% 3.4% 3.9% 3.9% 2.6% % Public Presentation "Dot Exercise" This table shows how the public prioritized the 23 Goals that Work Teams formulated. Public input was received at the August 27, 2014 presentation at Glen Este High School Performing Arts Center, as well as an online survey that was open for several weeks following the public presentation. 287 63 96 207 110 97 281 267 241 204 193 43 72 101 53 118 282 116 351 147 130 154 98 3710 Count 7.7% 1.7% 2.6% 5.6% 3.0% 2.6% 7.6% 7.2% 6.5% 5.5% 5.2% 1.2% 1.9% 2.7% 1.4% 3.2% 7.6% 3.1% 9.5% 4.0% 3.5% 4.2% 2.7% 2 21 19 7 15 18 4 5 6 8 9 23 20 16 22 13 3 14 1 11 12 10 17 % Rank TOTAL 2 1 6 4 3 7 695 18.7% 712 19.2% 409 11.0% 568 15.3% 628 16.9% 6.8% 252 5 % Rank 446 12.0% Count TOTAL (Themes) Table 1 58 GOAL 10 GOAL 11 GOAL 12 GOAL 13 GOAL 14 GOAL 15 GOAL 16 GOAL 17 GOAL 18 GOAL 19 GOAL 20 GOAL 21 GOAL 22 GOAL 23 GOAL 10 GOAL 11 GOAL 12 GOAL 13 GOAL 14 GOAL 15 GOAL 16 GOAL 17 GOAL 18 GOAL 19 GOAL 20 GOAL 21 GOAL 22 GOAL 23 GOAL 5 GOAL 4 GOAL 3 GOAL 9 0.0% GOAL 9 2.0% GOAL 8 4.0% GOAL 8 6.0% GOAL 7 8.0% GOAL 7 10.0% GOAL 6 Combined Response GOAL 6 GOAL 5 GOAL 4 1c GOAL 3 1b GOAL 2 GOAL 1 Clermont County Agenda for the Future Report GOAL 23 GOAL 22 GOAL 21 GOAL 20 GOAL 19 GOAL 18 GOAL 17 GOAL 16 GOAL 15 GOAL 14 GOAL 13 GOAL 12 GOAL 11 GOAL 10 GOAL 9 GOAL 8 GOAL 7 GOAL 6 GOAL 5 GOAL 4 GOAL 3 GOAL 2 GOAL 1 1a GOAL 2 GOAL 1 Chart 1 These charts visualizes the data from Table 1 on the previous page. Online Survey Response (Weighted Percent) 10.0% 8.0% 6.0% 4.0% 2.0% 0.0% Public Presentation Dot Exercise Response (Percent) 10.0% 8.0% 6.0% 4.0% 2.0% 0.0%