Emerson v. Amy Chua
Pre-writing Questions
•
Write down at least three main points that Emerson makes in his essay “Self-Reliance.” Think
about the advice he gives and the way in which he thinks you should live your life.
•
Then, write down at least three main points that Ms. Chua made in her article. Think about the
beliefs she has about the way her children should live their lives.
•
Ask yourself the following question: do Emerson and Chua agree? Once you have your answer,
you are ready to write.
Writing the Letter
•
You are writing from the P.O.V. of Emerson!
•
Begin with the phrase, “Dear Ms. Chua,”
•
In the first paragraph, state whether or not you agree with her article. Remember, you are
Emerson! First person pronouns are totally acceptable. Then, explain your point of view from
“Self-Reliance.” Use at least one quotation from “Self-Reliance.”
•
In the second paragraph, use at least one quotation from Chua’s article to explain why you
agree/disagree with her philosophy.
•
Sign the letter, “Sincerely, Ralph Waldo Emerson.”
•
Make sure your name is somewhere on your letter.