1 RCS Lecture 4 10/12 AEC Roman Culture and Society Lecture 4 – Citizens, Freed, and Slaves Attitudes to slavery Becoming a slave in Roman society Warfare: Salassi, Alpine tribe c.25 BC - Strabo, Geography 4.6.7 [= LACTOR Age of Augustus N12]: This Alpine tribe possessed gold mines and controlled their territory, at least through brigandage, even at the time of Julius Caesar and the triumvirate. Later, however, Augustus completely overthrew them, and sold them all as booty at Eporedia, a colony which the Romans had established as a garrison against the Salassi, but which could only offer slight resistance until the tribe had been wiped out. 8,000 fighting men were captured and 36,000 other people, but Terentius Varro, the general who overthrew them, sold them all as war-booty. Situation changes by 1st C AD Pirates/bandits: Suetonius, Life of Augustus 32: Bandit parties infested the roads armed with swords, supposedly worn in self-defence, which they used to overawe travellers - whether free-born or not - and force them into slave-barracks built by the landowners. Slave markets: Puteoli: TPSulp. 90, 16 Feb AD 61: At Puteoli in the Sextian Portico of Augustus there has been fixed to a column a notice in which was written what appears below: ‘The [slave] woman Fortunata, whom Marcia Aucta was said to have handed over as security on payment of a single sesterce to Gaius Sulpicius Onirus, will come up for sale under the auctioneer on 5 March next at Puteoli in front of the Chalcidicum of Caesonius, for ready cash. The [slave given as] security in this matter was first advertised for sale on 4 February 61.’ By birth: verna(e) SC Claudianum, AD 52: Tac. Ann. 12.53. During these proceedings he proposed to the Senate a penalty on women who united themselves in marriage to slaves, and it was decided that those who had thus demeaned themselves, without the knowledge of the slave's master, should be reduced to slavery; if with his consent, should be ranked as freedwomen. Exposure: Egypt "to rescue from the dung-pile for enslavement". Numbers of slaves - Lex Fufia Caninia Status of slaves 'Chattel' slavery slave as property Varro On Agriculture 1.17 cf Shelton no.208 The instruments by which the soil is cultivated: Some men divide these into three categories: 1. Articulate instruments, i.e. slaves; 2. Inarticulate instruments, i.e. oxen; 3. Mute instruments, i.e. carts. Slave as puer 2 RCS Lecture 4 10/12 AEC Slave collars/tags CIL XV 7194 [= Sherk no.178J]: Rome: ‘I am a runaway. Hold me. When you return me to my owner, Zoninus, you will receive a gold coin’. Slave names: Felix, Celsinus; Narcissus, Epaphroditus Types of slaves Agricultural chains & manacles slave labour + seasonal free labour Mines/quarries Diodorus Siculus 5.38.1 = Shelton no.209: The slaves engaged in the operation of the mines secure for their masters profits in amounts which are almost beyond belief. They themselves, however, are physically destroyed, their bodies worn down from working in the mine shafts both day and night. Many die because of the excessive maltreatment they suffer. They are given no rest or break from their toil, but rather are forced by the whiplashes of their overseers to endure the most dreadful of hardships; thus do they wear out their lives in misery… although they often pray more for death than for life because of the magnitude of their suffering. Alternative to death penalty: Plin. Ep. 10.58 – Fl. Archippus Limits on profitability: Strabo, Geography 12.3.40: realgar mine in Paphlagonia Mt. Sandaracurgium is hollowed out in consequence of the mining done there, since the workmen have excavated great cavities beneath it. The mine used to be worked by publicans, who used as miners the slaves sold in the market because of their crimes; for, in addition to the painfulness of the work, they say that the air in the mines is both deadly and hard to endure on account of the grievous odour of the ore, so that the workmen are doomed to a quick death. What is more, the mine is often left idle because of the unprofitableness of it, since the workmen are not only more than two hundred in number, but are continually spent by disease and death. Household: slave retinue of Musicus Scurranus: ILS 1514 [= Sherk no.178D]: To Musicus (slave) of Tiberius Caesar Augutsus, Scurranus, administrator of the Gallic treasury of the province of Lugdunensis, from his underslaves who were with him in Rome when he died, welldeserving man: Venustus, wholesale dealer; Decimianus, in charge of household expenses; Dicaeus, amanuensis; Mutatus, amanuensis; Cretisuc, amanuensis; Agathopus, physician; Epaphra, financial aide; Primio, in charge of clothin; Communis, attached to the imperial bedroom; Pothus, manservant; Tiasus, cook; Facilis, manservant; Anthus, financial aide; Hedylus, in the bedroom; Firmus, cook; Secunda. slave quarters Discussion: Can we locate slaves' quarters archaeologically? House on via sacra, Palatine, Rome House of the Menander, Pompeii Problems festivals: Saturnalia; 7th July; 13th Aug involved in business - eg Pompeii, CIL IV 138: In the Insula Arriana Polliana of Cn. Alleius Nigidius Maius … [various apartments]… will be let out from July 1st onwards. For letting, consult Primus, slave of Cn. Alleius Nigidius Maius. abuses: o corporal punishmt 3 RCS Lecture 4 o 10/12 AEC slave's evidence in court - Cic. Pro Milone 57-59 = Shelton no.229: He was afraid, I suppose, lest they should give information against him; lest they should be unable to bear pain; lest they should be compelled by tortures to confess that Publius Clodius was slain in the Appian road by the slaves of Milo….There is no law which authorizes slaves to be examined as witnesses against their master, except on accusations of impiety, as was the case in the prosecution instituted against Clodius. Clodius has been raised nearly to the gods, more nearly than even when he penetrated into their sanctuary, when an investigation into the circumstances of his death is carried on like one into a profanation of sacred ceremonies. But still, our ancestors did not think it right that slaves should be examined as witnesses against their masters, not because the truth could not be discovered, but because it seemed a scandalous thing to do, and more oppressive to the masters than even death itself. o Sexual relations: Seneca, Letter 95.37: He may know that a mistress is a most grievous form of insult to his wife, but his lust may impel him to the opposite Plut. Mor. 140B: it is respect for her which leads him to share his debauchery, licentiousness and wantonness with another woman. Public slaves Owned by the state: Cf Shelton no.205. Frontinus, On Aqueducts 2.116-18: 116. It remains to speak of the maintenance of the conduits; but before I say anything about this, a little explanation should be given about the gangs of slaves established for this purpose. There are two of those gangs, one belonging to the State, the other to Caesar. The one belonging to the State is the older, which, as we have said, was left by Agrippa to Augustus, and was by him made over to the State. It numbers about 240 men. The number in Caesar's gang is 460; it was organized by Claudius at the time he brought his aqueduct into the City. 117. Both gangs are divided into several classes of workmen: overseers, reservoir-keepers, inspectors, pavers, plasterers, and other workmen… 118. The wages of the State gang are paid from the State treasury, an expense which is lightened by the receipt of rentals from water-rights, which are received from places or buildings situated near the conduits, reservoirs, public fountains, or water-basins… The gang of Caesar gets its wages from the emperor's privy purse, from which are also drawn all expenses for lead and for conduits, reservoirs, and basins. Imperial High status potentially: ILS 1514 [= Sherk no.178D]: Musicus Scurranus, slave of Tiberius Caesar Augustus, accountant of the Gallic Treasury in the Province of Gallia Lugdunensis, from those of his underslaves who were with him when he died at Rome. Attitudes to slaves Cruelty Vedius Pollio Dio 54.23.1-4; cf Pliny the Elder Natural History 9.39.77 = Shelton no 212: Vedius Pollio, a Roman equestrian, a friend of the emperor Augustus, found that lamprey eels offered him an opportunity to display his cruelty. He used to toss slaves sentenced to death into a pond of lampreys, not because wild animals on land were not able to kill a slave, but because with any other type of animal he was not able to enjoy the sight of a man being torn to pieces. Galen, The Diseases of the Mind, 4 [=Wiedemann, Greek and Roman Slavery 180-81] The story is told that the Emperor Hadrian struck one of his attendants in the eye with a pen. When he realised that [the slave] had become blind in one eye as a result of this stroke, he called him to him and offered to let him ask him for any gift to make up for what he had suffered. When the victim remained silent, Hadrian again asked him to make a request of whatever he wanted. He declined to accept anything else, but asked for his eye back — for what gift could provide compensation for the loss of an eye? 4 RCS Lecture 4 10/12 AEC Fair treatment Pliny the Younger, Letters 8.16 = Shelton no.220: the illnesses of my slaves, and now the deaths of some of the young men, have upset me. Two thoughts console me… first my willingness to manumit slaves… second I permit my slaves to draw up documents which resemble wills and I treat them as if legal wills.' Cf affection in some epitaphs: Isola Sacra (Portus) = Thylander A221: To the Departed Spirits. Scribonius Priscianus and Sulpicia Stratonice set this up deservedly to Donata their sweetest household slave (verna), who lived for 8 years, 11 months, 21 days. Criticism of treatment of slaves: Seneca, Letter 47: Shelton no.221 I was happy to learn from people who had just visited you that you live on friendly terms with your slaves. This attitude is quite in keeping with your good sense and your liberal education. Some people say, "They're just slaves." But they are fellow human beings!… I have to laugh at those silly people who think it is degrading for someone to eat dinner with his slave. Why do they think this way? Only because we have this very arrogant custom of surrounding a master who is dining with a crowd of slaves standing at attention. The master eats more than he can hold…so that he vomits up everything…But the poor slaves are not allowed, while all this is going on, to move their lips to speak… Christianity Colossians 3.22: Slaves, obey in everything those that are your earthly masters, not with eyeservice as men-pleasers, but in singleness of heart, fearing the Lord. Ephesians 6.5-8: Slaves, be obedient to those who are your earthly masters, with fear and trembling, in singleness of your heart, as to Christ. Slaves and death Funerary commemoration Columbarium of Livia Epitaphs for slaves Problem of invisibility Representation in art inscriptions Lack of lit. records o Epictetus, ex-slave: Discourses 4.1.33-37 The slave wishes to be set free immediately… Then he is set free; and forthwith having no place where he can eat, he looks for some man to flatter, someone with whom he shall sup: then he…works with his body and endures the most dreadful things; and if he can find someone to feed him he falls into a slavery much worse than his former slavery…He says, What evil did I suffer in my state of slavery? Another clothed me, another supplied me with shoes, another fed me, another looked after me in sickness; and I did only a few services for him. But now a wretched man, what things I suffer, being a slave of many instead of to one. Lack of opposition Opposition to individual masters. o SC Silanianum, AD 10 o Tac. Ann. 14.42-45. AD 61, murder of City Prefect L. Pedanius Rufus. Shelton no.214 5 RCS Lecture 4 10/12 AEC Gaining freedom in Roman society Types of manumission: By testament By the rod (vindicta) Legislation on manumission Aug. period. [LACTOR Age of Augustus S31-36] Lex Fufia Caninia, 2 BC. Lex Aelia Sentia, AD 4 Lex Iunia ‘Junian Latins’ L. Vennidius Ennychus at Herculaneum: Birth declaration, 24th July AD 60 = AE (2006) 306 ‘In the consulship of Gaius Velleius Paterculus and Marcus Manilius Vopiscus, on 24th July, Lucius Venidius Ennychus has solemnly declared that a daughter has been born to him by his wife Livia Acte. Transacted at Herculaneum’. {A list of witnesses follows.} Edict of the urban praetor, 22nd March AD 62 = AE (2006) 305 ‘Copied and checked from the edict of Lucius Servenius Gallus, praetor, which had been posted up at Rome in the forum Augustum under the Julian portico next to column [?] in front of his platform, in which had been written that which is written below: Lucius Servenius Gallus, praetor, declares: “Marcus Ofellius Magnus and Tiberius Crassius Firmus duumvirs and […] Marcus Nonius Celsinus have reported to me a decree in which the town councillors of Herculaneum in accordance with the lex Aelia Sentia had sanctioned the case of Lucius Venidius Ennychus and of Livia Acte, on the grounds that they had a one-year old daughter born from them at Herculaneum as a result of their lawful marriage, and so since the case in question has been confirmed, I approve that they are Roman citizens.” Reasons for manumission Dionysius of Halicarnassus, Roman Antiquities 4.24.4-8 = Shelton no.232 I know that some men have granted freedom upon their deaths to all their slaves so that they might, when dead, be called good men and so that many people wearing freedmen's caps might follow their bier in the funeral procession. Cicero, Letter to Friends 16.16 = Shelton no.227 (from his brother): You gave me very great pleasure when you decided that he, who did not deserve his bad fortune, should become our friend rather than our slave… these fine qualities in Tiro, especially when we take into account his literary skills, his conversational abilities, and his breadth of knowledge, qualities which are more significant than his ability to perform personal services for us. For marriage: ILS 1519 = Gardner/Wiedemann no. 192 To Titus Flavius Euschemon, freedman of the emperor, who was in charge of his correspondence, and also procurator of the Jewish poll-tax. Flavia Aphrodisia set this up to her patron and husband, who well deserved it. Freedmen's names Freed(wo)men (and slaves) as businessmen Fish-sauce business of Umbricius Scaurus at Pompeii Advantages for masters Peculium Continued ties with ex-masters Evidence of tombstones: portray occupations CIL XIV 393: Publius Nonius Zethus, Augustalis, made (this) for himself and for Nonia Hilara, his fellowfreedwoman, and for Nonia Pelagia, freedwoman of Publius, his wife. Publis Nonius Heraclio. 6 RCS Lecture 4 10/12 AEC Petronius, Satyricon 26-34 (excerpts) a free dinner was promised… "I say, do you not know at whose house it is today? Trimalchio, a very rich man - he has a clock and a uniformed trumpeter in his dining-room, to keep telling him how much of his life is lost and gone."…[they go to baths] all at once we saw a bald old man in a reddish shirt playing at ball with some long-haired boys… the old man, who was in his house-shoes, busily engaged with a green ball. He never picked it up if it touched the ground. A slave stood by with a bagful and supplied them to the players. ..."This is the man at whose table you rest your elbow: indeed what you see is the overture to his dinner… Trimalchio was now anointed all over and rubbed down, not with towels, but with blankets of the softest wool…[he heads home] We followed, lost in wonder, and came to the door…. Just at the entrance stood a porter in green clothes, with a cherry-coloured belt, shelling peas in a silver dish. A golden cage hung in the doorway, and a black and white magpie in it greeted visitors. I was gazing at all this, when I nearly fell backwards and broke my leg. For on the left hand as you went in, not far from the porter's office, a great dog on a chain was painted on the wall, and over him was written in block capitals "BEWARE OF THE DOG"…. I proceeded to ask the house-manager what pictures they had in the hall. "The Iliad and the Odyssey," he said, "and the gladiator's show given by Laenas"…. Trimalchio was conducted in to the sound of music, propped on the tiniest of pillows. A laugh escaped the unwary. His head was shaven and peered out of a scarlet cloak, and over the heavy clothes on his neck he had put on a napkin with a broad stripe and fringes hanging from it all round. On the little finger of his left hand he had an enormous gilt ring… Suddenly the music gave the sign, and the light dishes were swept away by a troop of singing slaves. But an entrée-dish happened to fall in the rush, and a boy picked it up from the ground. Trimalchio saw him, and directed that he should be punished by a box on the ear, and made to throw down the dish again. A chamberlain followed and proceeded to sweep out the silver with a broom among the other rubbish. How to identify freedmen? o House of the Vettii, VI.xv.1, Pompeii – Cooley & Cooley J59-70 A VETTI A VETTI RETVSTT CONVIVAES Freedmen’s role in public life Religious cults - espec Augustales Public benefactors (euergetism) - CIL XI 5400 = Shelton no.250, Assisi Publius Decimius Eros Merula, freedman of Publius, physician, surgeon, and oculist, member of the Board of Six. For his freedom he paid 50,000 sesterces. For his membership of the Board of Six he contributed 2000 sesterces to the public treasury. He donated 30,000 sesterces for the erection of statues in the temple of Hercules. For building roads, he contributed 37,000 sesterces to the public treasury. Citizenship What advantages? Voting-rights Corn-dole Marriage & family Social mobility Property ownership Roman law benefits: o right to a trial o corporal punishment limited o Right to appeal against magistrates. o Right to sue at law Visible signs of status 7 RCS Lecture 4 10/12 AEC BIBLIOGRAPHY Key readings @Jones, A.H.M. (1968) 'Slavery in the Ancient World', in Finley, M., ed. Slavery in Classical Antiquity. Views and Controversies; pp. 1-15 [DE 61 S5] @Wiedemann, T.E.J. (1985) ‘The Regularity of manumission at Rome’ Classical Quarterly 35: 162-175 General Peachin, M. , ed. (2011) Oxford Handbook of Social Relations in the Roman World [on order] - ch. 28 'Slaves in Roman Society' (Leonhard Schumacher); ch. 29 'Women in Roman Society' (Kristina Milnor); ch. 30 'Children in the Roman Family and Beyond' (JensUwe Krause) Bradley, K. (2010) 'Freedom and slavery' in Barchiesi, A. and Scheidel, W., eds, The Oxford Handbook of Roman Studies [DG 209.O94] Bradley, K. and Cartledge, P., eds (2011) The Cambridge world history of slavery [HC 7100.C2] Slavery Barrow, R. (1928) Slavery in the Roman Empire [DG109 B2] @Beard, M. and Henderson, J. (1995) Classics. A very short introduction pp. 48-51 @Bradley, K.R. (1987) "On the Roman Slave Supply and Slavebreeding," in M.I.Finley, ed. Classical Slavery [Arts periodical: Slavery and abolition 8.1 special edn] Bradley, K. (1994) Slavery and Society at Rome [DG 109.B6] Finley, M.I. (1980) Ancient Slavery and Modern Ideology [DE61 S5] Garnsey, P. (1996) Ideas of slavery from Aristotle to Augustine [DE 61 55] @George, M. (1997) 'Servus and domus: the slave in the Roman house', in Domestic Space in the Roman World: Pompeii and Beyond, eds R. Laurence and A. Wallace-Hadrill pp.15-24 @Harris, W.V. (1994) "Child-Exposure in the Roman Empire," JRS 84: 1-22 Hopkins, K. (1978) Conquerors and Slaves [DG 109 H6] Joshel, S. (2010) Slavery in the Roman World [HC 7100.J6] @Rathbone, D. (1983) 'The slave mode of production in Italy', Journal of Roman Studies 73: 160-68 @Saller, R.P. (1998) 'Symbols of gender and status hierarchies in the Roman household', in Women and Slaves in Greco-Roman Culture. Differential Equations, eds S.R. Josel and S. Murnaghan; pp. 85-91 [DE61 W6] 8 RCS Lecture 4 10/12 AEC @Treggiari, S. (1975) 'Jobs in the household of Livia', Papers of the British School at Rome 43: 48-77 [arts periodical] Vogt, J. (1974) Ancient Slavery and the Ideal of Man [DE61 S5] Wiedemann, T.E.J. (1987) Slavery (Greece and Rome New Surveys in the Classics no. 19; Oxford) [DE 61.S5] Yavetz, Z. (1988) Slaves and Slavery in Ancient Rome [DG109 Y2] Freedmen Duff, A.M. (1928) Freedmen in the Early Roman Empire [DG109 D8] Mouritsen, H. (2011) The freedman in the Roman World [HC 7325.M6] @Petersen, L. (2006) The Freedman in Roman Art and Art History [N 5763.P3] pp.16383 'To claim a domus: the house of the Caecilii at Pompeii' Treggiari, S. (1969) Roman Freedmen during the Late Republic [DG109 T7] @Treggiari, S. (1975) "Family Life among the Staff of the Volusii" TAPA 105, 393-401 Weaver, P. (1972) Familia Caesaris. A social study of the emperor's freedmen and slaves [DG109 W3] The free poor @Brunt, P.A. (1980) ‘Free labour and public works at Rome’ JRS 70: 81-100 @Brunt, P.A. (1987) ‘Labour’ in J. Wacher, ed. The Roman World 701-16. [DG 77.R6] @Erdkamp, P. (1999) ‘Agriculture, underemployment and the cost of rural labour in the Roman world’ CQ n.s. 49.2: 556-572 Frayn, J.M. (1979) Subsistence Farming in Roman Italy [S 431.F7] Garnsey, P. ed. (1980) Non-slave Labour in the Greco-Roman World [DE 61.W7] Sourcebooks Gardner, J. and Wiedemann, T. (1991) The Roman Household: a Sourcebook, ch.7 @Parkin, T. & Pomeroy, A. (2007) Roman Social History. A Sourcebook [DG 78.R6 + ebook] Shelton, J-A. (1998) As the Romans Did (2nd edn) chs 8-9 Wiedemann, T. (1980) Greek and Roman Slavery [DE 61.S5]