Charlotte Historic District Commission Staff Review HDC 2015-286 LOCAL HISTORIC DISTRICT: Wesley Heights PROPERTY ADDRESS: 420 South Summit Avenue SUMMARY OF REQUEST: New Construction OWNER/APPLICANT: Don Duffy Application for a Certificate of Appropriateness Date: January 13, 2016 PID# 07102409 The application was denied December 9, 2015 for 1) Size – the relationship of the project to its site. The house and garage are too large for the site, 2) Scale – The relationship of the building to those around it. The house should be no taller than the tallest existing house, 3) Massing – The relationship of the building’s various parts to each other. The house is wider than other houses on the block, 4) Context – the overall relationship of the project to its surroundings. The applicant has submitted a new application for review. The Commission will determine if the project has been substantially redesigned and now meets the guidelines for new construction. Details of Proposed Request Existing Context The existing structure is a one story house constructed in 1981. The foundation is slab on grade construction, siding is vertical T1-11 wood. The property is listed as Non-contributing in the Wesley Heights National Register. Adjacent buildings are one and two story. Proposal The proposal is a two story single family structure. The proposed front setback is 30 feet from the building as noted in the deed. Total height from finished floor is approximately 28’-8”. Materials include cedar shingles and wood trim. Windows are aluminum clad Simulated True Divided Light (STDL). Foundation exterior is stucco. Other features include wood hand rails and columns. The detached garage is accessed from an alley and connected to the house by a brick breezeway. The design and material palette of the garage reflects the principal structure. The summary of revisions includes: 1. Reduction in the size of the garage. 2. Increase in pervious area in the rear yard. 3. Reduction in the width of the house from 48’ to approximately 38’-6”. Policy & Design Guidelines for New Construction, page 34 New construction in Local Historic Districts has an obligation to blend in with the historic character and scale of the Local Historic District in which it is located. Designs for infill projects and other new construction within designated Local Historic Districts must be designed with the surroundings in mind. The Historic District Commission will not specify a particular architectural style or design for new construction projects. The scale, mass and size of a building are often far more important than the decorative details applied. However, well designed stylistic and decorative elements, as well as building materials and landscaping, can give new construction projects the attributes necessary to blend in with the district, while creating a distinctive character for the building. New construction projects in Local Historic Districts must be appropriate to their surroundings. 1 The Historic District Commission will review the building details for all new construction as part of their evaluation of new construction project proposals. Staff Analysis - The Commission will determine if the proposal meets the guidelines for new construction. 2 Charlotte Historic District Commission - Case 2015-265 4th St Ex t W aln ut Av W 2n d St S y Av ! I 0 100 Ca lve rt S t N I77 H Li ta ke r Su m m it A v Gr an di n Rd W 420 S. Summit Avenue Wesley Heights Historic District Property Lines 200 400 Feet December 2, 2015 Building Footprints 420 South Summit Avenue Charlotte, NC Private Residence 424 416 420 58'x30' 35.6'x24' 28'x38' 45'x68' 400 75'x73' 429/433 38.5'x64.8' 38.5'x66' 35'x53' 424 420 32'x65' 416 400 S. SUMMIT AVENUE 433 429 43'x47' 423 419 415 28'x42' 29'x53' 35'x55' 80' 409 405 40'x36' 407 401 40' 20' 0 N PRELIMINARY 44'x57' 43'x54' SUMMIT GREENWAY CT 401 423 DonDuffy Architecture 301 Providence Rd C h a r l o t t e , NC 2 8 2 0 7 (p)704 - 358 - 1878 (f )704 - 358 - 1721 www.donduffyarchitecture.com THIS DRAWING IS AN INSTRUMENT OF SERVICE. THE DRAWING AND THE INFORMATION THEREON IS THE PROPERTY OF DON DUFFY ARCHITECT. ANY REPRODUCTION, ALTERATION, OR USE FOR OTHER THAN THE INTENDED PROJECT, WITHOUT THE WRITTEN CONSENT OF DON DUFFY ARCHITECT, IS EXPRESSLY FORBIDDEN. COPYRIGHT © DON DUFFY ARCHITECT Date: 1/4/2016 Revisions: 419 415 409 405/407 Drawn By: KCM Sheet: EX1.1 Private Residence 508 Grandin Rd 704 Grandin Rd 424 Grandin Rd 201 S. Summit Ave 420 South Summit Avenue Charlotte, NC 413 Grandin Rd Private Residence 309/311 Grandin Rd PRELIMINARY DonDuffy Architecture 301 Providence Rd C h a r l o t t e , NC 2 8 2 0 7 (p)704 - 358 - 1878 (f )704 - 358 - 1721 www.donduffyarchitecture.com THIS DRAWING IS AN INSTRUMENT OF SERVICE. THE DRAWING AND THE INFORMATION THEREON IS THE PROPERTY OF DON DUFFY ARCHITECT. ANY REPRODUCTION, ALTERATION, OR USE FOR OTHER THAN THE INTENDED PROJECT, WITHOUT THE WRITTEN CONSENT OF DON DUFFY ARCHITECT, IS EXPRESSLY FORBIDDEN. COPYRIGHT © DON DUFFY ARCHITECT Date: 1/4/2016 Revisions: Drawn By: KCM Sheet: 432 Walnut Ave. 442/444 Walnut Ave. 601 Walnut Ave. EX1.2 Private Residence 30' ridge = 704.9' SUBJECT PROPERTY ridge = 693.8' 20' ridge = 689.1' 30.3 #424 19.4 10' #416 30' 37.9 20' #420 Grade=675.9' 1st level = 678.3' 1st level = 676.6' 40' #400 "The Wadsworth Estate" #420 South Summit Avenue Private Residence ridge = 713.9' 40' 420 South Summit Avenue Charlotte, NC DENIED DECEMBER 2015 1st level 683.5' = 10' 1st level = 675.0' 14.7 Grade=675.9' Grade=675.0' Grade=674.4' Grade=674.4' LITAKER AVENUE Sidewalk=671.5' Sidewalk=667.4' Sidewalk=667.9' Sidewalk=669.2' Sidewalk=669.9' Grade=674.5' Grade=677.2' Grade=674.6' Grade=674.4' 2 A2.0 SOUTH SUMMIT WEST SECOND STREET Existing Survey SCALE: 1" = 20' AVENUE 40' 416 S. SUMMIT AVENUE 30' 420 S. SUMMIT AVENUE NEW 'PROPOSED' SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCE ridge = +/- 704.9' ridge = +/- 703.3' DonDuffy 301 Providence Rd C h a r l o t t e , NC 2 8 2 0 7 (p)704 - 358 - 1878 (f )704 - 358 - 1721 30.3' +/- 28.8' (PROPERTY LINE) (5' SIDE YARD SETBACK; R5 ZONING) Architecture www.donduffyarchitecture.com 19.4' 10' (PROPERTY LINE) ridge = 693.8' (7' SIDE YARD SETBACK; DEED) 20' (5' SIDE YARD SETBACK; R5 ZONING) 424 S. SUMMIT AVENUE THIS DRAWING IS AN INSTRUMENT OF SERVICE. THE DRAWING AND THE INFORMATION THEREON IS THE PROPERTY OF DON DUFFY ARCHITECT. ANY REPRODUCTION, ALTERATION, OR USE FOR OTHER THAN THE INTENDED PROJECT, WITHOUT THE WRITTEN CONSENT OF DON DUFFY ARCHITECT, IS EXPRESSLY FORBIDDEN. 678.3' 676.6' 1st FLOOR 1st FLOOR 676.0' 1st FLOOR COPYRIGHT © DON DUFFY ARCHITECT Date: 11/30/2015 GRADE = 674.5' GRADE = 674.4' SIDEWALK = 667.4' GRADE = 674.4' GRADE = 674.4' SIDEWALK = 667.9' Revisions: GRADE = 675.0' GRADE = 674.6' SIDEWALK = 669.2' 1 A2.0 'Proposed' Street Scape NOT TO SCALE 0 2' 4' 8' Drawn By: KCM Sheet: A2.0 Private Residence 40' JANUARY 2016 1st level = 676.6' d Si ew a 6 = lk .4 7 6 Gr ridge = 689.1' #420 420 South Summit Avenue Charlotte, NC 10' 14'-8 1/2" #424 19'-5 1/8" ridge = 693.8' 20' R E 30'-3 1/4" SUBJECT PROPERTY #420 South Summit Avenue Private Residence 30' ridge = 704.9' #416 1st level = 678.3' 1st level = 675.0' ' a Grade=674.4' = e d 4' . 4 7 6 e Sid Grade=674.5' w 6 = k al .9' 7 6 e Sid Grade=674.4' Grade=674.6' Existing Street Survey 2 A2.0 40' #420 South Summit Avenue ridge = 704.9' #424 S. Summit Ave. ridge = 693.8' PRELIMINARY DonDuffy 28'-9 1/2" 19'-5 1/8" 1st level = 676.6' Architecture 30'-3 1/4" (above median grade) 30' +/- 1'-9" ridge = 703.2' 10' NOT TO SCALE #416 S. Summit Ave. (NEW 'PROPOSED' SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCE) 20' w . 2' 9 6 =6 k l a Grade=675.0' 1st level = 675.9' 301 Providence Rd C h a r l o t t e , NC 2 8 2 0 7 (p)704 - 358 - 1878 (f )704 - 358 - 1721 www.donduffyarchitecture.com THIS DRAWING IS AN INSTRUMENT OF SERVICE. THE DRAWING AND THE INFORMATION THEREON IS THE PROPERTY OF DON DUFFY ARCHITECT. 1st level = 678.3' ANY REPRODUCTION, ALTERATION, OR USE FOR OTHER THAN THE INTENDED PROJECT, WITHOUT THE WRITTEN CONSENT OF DON DUFFY ARCHITECT, IS EXPRESSLY FORBIDDEN. COPYRIGHT © DON DUFFY ARCHITECT Date: 1/5/2016 Revisions: Grade=674.5' Grade=674.4' Sidewalk=667.4' Grade=674.4' Grade=674.4' Grade=674.6' Sidewalk=669.2' Sidewalk=667.9' 8' 1 A2.0 4' 2' 0 'Enlarged' Street Scape NOT TO SCALE Grade=675.0' Drawn By: Sheet: A2.0 Private Residence 60.00(R) EIR #4 EIR #4 N36°13'44"E 59.98 gravel motor court DENIED DECEMBER 2015 PP new planting bed, typ. existing structure new 4'w.x5'h. gate new 4'w.x5'h. gate existing structure new 1-1/2 story garage GRANDIN ROAD METAL FENCE W. 2ND STREET 40'x73' (13'x22' pervious play area) 37'x48' (swimming pool) MB 332, PG 254 (spa/ fire pit) LOT 10 BLOCK 9, WESLEY HEIGHTS MB 332, PG 254 pervious surface material throughout, typ. GTP GTP 5 187.50(R) S53°46'43"E 187.56 187.50(R) 27'x24' tree protection, typ. N53°45'27"W 187.55 BLOCK 9, WESLEY HEIGHTS 28'x21' 5' SIDE SETBACK (ZONING) LOT 8 5' SIDE SETBAC(ZONING) 50'x60' 40'x68' 34'x68' new 5'h. fence, typ. tree to be removed 7' SIDE SETBACK (DB 497, PG 420) 36'x62' covered breezeway 7' SIDE SETBACK (DB 497, PG 420) 33'x52' 8'h. masonry screen wall, typ. WOOD FENCE 39'x48' existing light pole to be removed; new underground power 8'-6 1/4" CHAIN LINK FENCE 58'x30' low-profile skylight assembly (bronze finish) 28'x38' 48'x26' 45'x68' new 2-story (above grade) residence existing 1-1/2 story (above grade) residence existing 1-1/2 story (above grade) residence HVAC (within roof well) 38'x66' GM GTP 48'x56' 424 PM 75'x73' (NEW 'PROPOSED' PRIVATE RESIDENCE) 35'x53' 420 METAL FE NC E GTP 32'x65' 416 trees to be removed, typ. 400 PRELIMINARY (existing house to be demolished) new 4'w.x5'h. gate new 5'h. fence, typ. DonDuffy S. SUMMIT AVENUE Architecture 8.8 433 429 423 419 415 80' 409 405 407 401 40' 20' 0 CONC [ESTABLISHED SETBACK) [ESTABLISHED SETBACK) BRICK WALK N 30' FRONT SETBACK (DB 497, PG 420) new brick paver walk, typ. tree to remain, typ. 5 301 Providence Rd C h a r l o t t e , NC 2 8 2 0 7 (p)704 - 358 - 1878 (f )704 - 358 - 1721 www.donduffyarchitecture.com 20' FRONT SETBACK (ZONING) 29.8 LITAKER AVENUE tree to remain, typ. Private Residence 30' REAR SETBACK (ZONING) 420 South Summit Avenue Charlotte, NC LOT 9 BLOCK 9 43'x47' 28'x42' 29'x53' 40'x36' new planting bed, typ. trees to remain, typ. THIS DRAWING IS AN INSTRUMENT OF SERVICE. THE DRAWING AND THE INFORMATION THEREON IS THE PROPERTY OF DON DUFFY ARCHITECT. 44'x57' 35'x55' demolish existing drive, typ. 43'x54' ANY REPRODUCTION, ALTERATION, OR USE FOR OTHER THAN THE INTENDED PROJECT, WITHOUT THE WRITTEN CONSENT OF DON DUFFY ARCHITECT, IS EXPRESSLY FORBIDDEN. existing brick steps/wall to remain, typ. SUMMIT GREENWAY CT EIR #4 new planting bed between walk & retaining wall, typ. L1 POB new +/-2'h. brick retaining wall to match existing step wall (height & detailing), typ. CONCRETE WALK 50'x36' COPYRIGHT © EIR #4 ALLOWABLE IMPERVIOUS CALCULATIONS demolish existing curb cut & drive, typ. - TOTAL AREA TO REAR OF EXISTING HOUSE: 7,606 S.F. 36'x44' Date: 11/30/2015 [ALLOWABLE IMPERVIOUS AREA = 1/2 OF TOTAL AREA TO REAR OF EXISTING HOUSE: 3,803 S.F.] WM - 'NEW' HOUSE [IMPERVIOUS AREA]: 1,335 S.F. N 6" CONCRETE CURB DON DUFFY ARCHITECT - 'NEW' BREEZEWAY [IMPERVIOUS AREA]: 349 S.F. 36'x43' Revisions: - 'NEW' GARAGE [IMPERVIOUS AREA]: 1,104 S.F. - 'NEW' POOL & SPA [IMPERVIOUS AREA]: 695 S.F. 20' CV1.1 Plot Plan SCALE: 1" = 40' 9 '0 2 " W N 6 5 °3 (TIE) 5 6 .4 1 3 SOUTH SUMMIT AVEUNE VARIABLE WIDTH PUBLIC RIGHT OF WAY 10' 1 CV1.1 5' 0 TOTAL 'NEW' IMPERVIOUS AREA TO REAR OF EXG' HOUSE: 3,483 S.F. Sheet: SitePlan SCALE: 1" Drawn By: = 10' CV1.1 Private Residence 60.00(R) SQUARE FOOTAGE CALCULATIONS EIR #4 EIR #4 N36°13'44"E 59.98 gravel motor court - FIRST FLOOR ('NEW' HOUSE HEATED S.F.): [ALLOWABLE 'PERMEABLE' AREA = 1/2 OF TOTAL REAR YARD AREA OF 'NEW' HOUSE: 2,779 S.F.] 1,896 existing structure LOT 9 BLOCK 9 (SQUARE FOOTAGE CALCS TAKEN FROM EXTERIOR FACE OF MASONRY/SHEATHING) - 'NEW' HOUSE REAR PORCH/GRILL AREA [IMPERMEABLE AREA]: 132 S.F. - 'NEW' GARAGE [IMPERMEABLE AREA]: 1,205 S.F. TOTAL 'NEW' IMPERMEABLE REAR YARD AREA OF 'NEW' HOUSE: 1,337 S.F. JANUARY 2016 30' REAR SETBACK (ZONING) new 4'w.x5'h. gate new 4'w.x5'h. gate existing structure new 1-1/2 story garage new 5'h. (black metal) fence, typ. GRANDIN ROAD existing chain link fence to be demolished, typ. 50'x60' 40'x68' 34'x68' 40'x73' existing wood fence to remain, typ. existing light pole to be removed; new underground power tree to be removed BLOCK 9, WESLEY HEIGHTS MB 332, PG 254 GTP 5 187.50(R) 187.50(R) LOT 10 S53°46'43"E 187.56 GTP 7' SIDE SETBACK (DB 497, PG 420) MB 332, PG 254 27'x24' tree protection, typ. N53°45'27"W 187.55 BLOCK 9, WESLEY HEIGHTS 5' SIDE SETBACK (ZONING) LOT 8 28'x21' 5' SIDE SETBAC(ZONING) 36'x62' 37'x48' new 5'h. (black metal) fence, typ. pervious surface material [grass] throughout side & rear yards, typ. 7' SIDE SETBACK (DB 497, PG 420) 33'x52' existing chain link fence to be demolished, typ. EXISTING CHAIN LINK FENCE 39'x48' W. 2ND STREET 58'x30' 28'x38' 35.6'x24' (HVAC units on rear low-pitch roof) 45'x68' HVAC units existing 1-1/2 story residence (NEW 'PROPOSED' PRIVATE RESIDENCE) PM 75'x73' existing 1-1/2 story residence GM GTP 38.5'x64.8' 38.5'x66' on low-pitch roof new 2 story residence GTP 35'x53' 32'x65' 424 420 416 trees to be removed, typ. 400 new 4'w.x5'h. gate pervious surface material [grass] throughout side & rear yards, typ. PRELIMINARY pervious surface material [grass] throughout side & rear yards, typ. new 5'h. fence, typ. S. SUMMIT AVENUE DonDuffy 13'-7 3/8" Architecture 8.8 429 43'x47' 423 419 415 409 405 28'x42' 29'x53' 40'x36' 407 401 new footprint equates to a 22% overall square footage reduction new brick paver walk, typ. 30' FRONT SETBACK (DB 497, PG 420) 5 44'x57' 35'x55' [ESTABLISHED SETBACK) tree to remain, typ. trees to remain, typ. N 50'x36' 80' 40' 20' new planting bed between walk & retaining wall, typ. L1 new +/-2'h. brick retaining wall to match existing step wall (height & detailing), typ. CONCRETE WALK SCALE: 1" = 40' CV1.1 S.F. Reduction Diagram SCALE: 1" = 20' SOUTH SUMMIT AVEUNE VARIABLE WIDTH PUBLIC RIGHT OF WAY Revisions: N 6" CONCRETE CURB 0 2 DON DUFFY ARCHITECT Date: 1/5/2016 demolish existing curb cut & drive, typ. WM 9 '0 2 " W N 6 5 °3 (TIE) 5 6 .4 1 CV1.1 Plot Plan COPYRIGHT © EIR #4 POB 20' 3 ANY REPRODUCTION, ALTERATION, OR USE FOR OTHER THAN THE INTENDED PROJECT, WITHOUT THE WRITTEN CONSENT OF DON DUFFY ARCHITECT, IS EXPRESSLY FORBIDDEN. existing brick steps/wall to remain, typ. EIR #4 36'x43' THIS DRAWING IS AN INSTRUMENT OF SERVICE. THE DRAWING AND THE INFORMATION THEREON IS THE PROPERTY OF DON DUFFY ARCHITECT. demolish existing drive, typ. SUMMIT GREENWAY CT 36'x44' www.donduffyarchitecture.com new planting bed, typ. 43'x54' 2,242.86 sq ft new footprint equates to a 15% overall square footage reduction 301 Providence Rd C h a r l o t t e , NC 2 8 2 0 7 (p)704 - 358 - 1878 (f )704 - 358 - 1721 20' FRONT SETBACK (ZONING) 29.8 433 [ESTABLISHED SETBACK) 30'-15/16" LITAKER AVENUE tree to remain, typ. 420 South Summit Avenue Charlotte, NC - TOTAL REAR YARD AREA OF 'NEW' HOUSE: 5,557 S.F. PP new planting bed, typ. Private Residence ALLOWABLE 'PERMEABLE' CALCULATIONS 10' 1 CV1.1 5' Drawn By: KCM 0 Sheet: SitePlan SCALE: 1" = 10' CV1.1 Private Residence 'low-profile' skylight assembly beyond (bronze finish) 12 5 +20'-11 5/8" ROOF +20'-3 5/8" 'Western Red' cedar shingle siding (flaired @ gable cross boxing), typ. 12 +/-28.75 (cased 'punched' opening, typ.) 2nd floor ceiling 4"x5/4 solid wood casing w/ 1x2 backband, typ. aluminum clad 'SDL' double-hung window w/ 2" historical sill (equal to 'Marvin'), typ. 'Western Red' cedar shingle siding (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label), typ. wood trim closed boxing w/ wood 'bead board' soffit, typ. flat seam copper return, typ. over-size bronze finish gutter/downspout, typ. +11'-2 1/8" 2nd floor +10'-1 1/2" 1st floor ceiling 1x solid wood trim entablature, typ. 10"sq. wood trim 'Tuscan' architectural column, typ. (cased 'punched' opening, typ.) aluminum clad 'SDL' casement windows w/ 2" historical sill (equal to 'Marvin'), typ. 'decorative' solid wood rail system (not req'd per code; less than 30" above grade), typ. 'Western Red' cedar decorative heavy timber bracket, typ. stucco parging (painted) over poured-in-place concrete foundation w/ 'bluestone' surface, typ. Private Residence copper curb at roof pitch transition, typ. 420 South Summit Avenue Charlotte, NC 'Western Red' cedar shingle roof (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label), typ. ±0" 1st FLOOR -1'-10 3/4" Lower level ceiling -12'-1/4" Basement floor 2 A2.1 Left Side Elevation SCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0" 'Western Red' cedar shingle roof (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label), typ. copper curb at roof pitch transition, typ. +20'-11 5/8" +20'-11 5/8" ROOF +20'-3 5/8" ROOF +20'-3 5/8" 4"x5/4 solid wood casing w/ 1x2 backband, typ. (PROPERTY LINE) (5' SIDE YARD SETBACK; R5 ZONING) (7' SIDE YARD SETBACK; DEED) (7' SIDE YARD SETBACK; DEED) (PROPERTY LINE) DENIED DECEMBER 2015 2nd floor ceiling (5' SIDE YARD SETBACK; R5 ZONING) 2nd floor ceiling aluminum clad 'SDL' double-hung window w/ 2" historical sill (equal to 'Marvin'), typ. 'Western Red' cedar shingle siding (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label), typ. wood trim closed boxing w/ wood 'bead board' soffit, typ. over-size bronze finish gutter/downspout, typ. +11'-2 1/8" +11'-2 1/8" 2nd floor 2nd floor +10'-1 1/2" +10'-1 1/2" 1st floor ceiling 1st floor ceiling 1x solid wood trim entablature, typ. 10"sq. wood trim 'Tuscan' architectural column, typ. PRELIMINARY DonDuffy Architecture 301 Providence Rd C h a r l o t t e , NC 2 8 2 0 7 (p)704 - 358 - 1878 (f )704 - 358 - 1721 www.donduffyarchitecture.com 'custom' wood ext. entry door & sidelites 'decorative' solid wood rail system (not req'd per code; less than 30" above grade), typ. stucco parging (painted) over poured-in-place concrete foundation w/ 'bluestone' surface, typ. ±0" ±0" 1st FLOOR 1st FLOOR -1'-10 3/4" -1'-10 3/4" Lower level ceiling THIS DRAWING IS AN INSTRUMENT OF SERVICE. THE DRAWING AND THE INFORMATION THEREON IS THE PROPERTY OF DON DUFFY ARCHITECT. ANY REPRODUCTION, ALTERATION, OR USE FOR OTHER THAN THE INTENDED PROJECT, WITHOUT THE WRITTEN CONSENT OF DON DUFFY ARCHITECT, IS EXPRESSLY FORBIDDEN. COPYRIGHT © DON DUFFY ARCHITECT Lower level ceiling retain existing brick steps & flanking brick walls, typ. new brick retaining wall (match detailing & height of existing step wall), typ. Date: 11/30/2015 Revisions: Drawn By: 1 A2.1 Sheet: Front Elevation SCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0" A2.1 Private Residence 'low-profile' skylight assembly beyond (bronze finish) 12 5 +20'-11 5/8" ROOF +20'-3 5/8" 'Western Red' cedar shingle siding (flaired @ gable cross boxing), typ. 12 'Western Red' cedar shingle roof (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label), typ. +/-48"h. brick veneer screen wall w/ stone cap (along perimeter of grill area, typ. +/-28.75 (cased 'punched' opening, typ.) 2nd floor ceiling 4"x5/4 solid wood casing w/ 1x2 backband, typ. aluminum clad 'SDL' double-hung window w/ 2" historical sill (equal to 'Marvin'), typ. 'Western Red' cedar shingle siding (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label), typ. 'Western Red' cedar operable gate wood trim closed boxing w/ wood 'bead board' soffit, typ. flat seam copper return, typ. over-size bronze finish gutter/downspout, typ. +11'-2 1/8" 2nd floor +10'-1 1/2" 1st floor ceiling 1x solid wood trim entablature, typ. 10"sq. wood trim 'Tuscan' architectural column, typ. (cased 'punched' opening, typ.) aluminum clad 'SDL' casement windows w/ 2" historical sill (equal to 'Marvin'), typ. 'decorative' solid wood rail system (not req'd per code; less than 30" above grade), typ. 'Western Red' cedar decorative heavy timber bracket, typ. stucco parging (painted) over poured-in-place concrete foundation w/ 'bluestone' surface, typ. Private Residence copper curb at roof pitch transition, typ. 420 South Summit Avenue Charlotte, NC 'Western Red' cedar shingle roof (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label), typ. ±0" 1st FLOOR 36"h. glass guardrail system, typ. -1'-10 3/4" Lower level ceiling -12'-1/4" Basement floor 2 1st floor ceiling = 1'-0" 'Western Red' cedar shingle roof (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label), typ. copper curb at roof pitch transition, typ. +20'-11 5/8" ROOF +20'-3 5/8" (PROPERTY LINE) aluminum clad 'SDL' double-hung window w/ 2" historical sill (equal to 'Marvin'), typ. 'Western Red' cedar shingle siding (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label), typ. wood trim closed boxing w/ wood 'bead board' soffit, typ. over-size bronze finish gutter/downspout, typ. 2nd floor +10'-1 1/2" 1st floor ceiling 1x solid wood trim entablature, typ. 10"sq. wood trim 'Tuscan' architectural column, typ. PRELIMINARY DonDuffy Architecture 301 Providence Rd C h a r l o t t e , NC 2 8 2 0 7 (p)704 - 358 - 1878 (f )704 - 358 - 1721 www.donduffyarchitecture.com 'custom' wood ext. entry door & sidelites 'decorative' solid wood rail system (not req'd per code; less than 30" above grade), typ. stucco parging (painted) over poured-in-place concrete foundation w/ 'bluestone' surface, typ. ±0" Lower level ceiling 4"x5/4 solid wood casing w/ 1x2 backband, typ. +11'-2 1/8" ±0" 1st FLOOR -1'-10 3/4" (5' SIDE YARD SETBACK; R5 ZONING) 7'-6" (7' SIDE YARD SETBACK; DEED) 2nd floor ceiling 3'-2 1/8" +10'-1 1/2" SCALE: 1/4" 8'-0" +11'-2 1/8" 2nd floor (7' SIDE YARD SETBACK; DEED) (PROPERTY LINE) JANUARY 2016 (5' SIDE YARD SETBACK; R5 ZONING) 2nd floor ceiling 27'-4 1/4"(height above 1st floor subfloor) +20'-11 5/8" ROOF +20'-3 5/8" 28'-9 1/2"(height above median grade) A2.1 Left Side Elevation 1st FLOOR (median grade height) 38'-6"(vs.48'; equates to a 20% width reduction & equal left side neighbor dim.) THIS DRAWING IS AN INSTRUMENT OF SERVICE. THE DRAWING AND THE INFORMATION THEREON IS THE PROPERTY OF DON DUFFY ARCHITECT. ANY REPRODUCTION, ALTERATION, OR USE FOR OTHER THAN THE INTENDED PROJECT, WITHOUT THE WRITTEN CONSENT OF DON DUFFY ARCHITECT, IS EXPRESSLY FORBIDDEN. COPYRIGHT © DON DUFFY ARCHITECT -1'-10 3/4" Lower level ceiling retain existing brick steps & flanking brick walls, typ. new brick retaining wall (match detailing & height of existing step wall), typ. Date: 1/5/2016 Revisions: Drawn By: 1 A2.1 Sheet: Front Elevation SCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0" A2.1 Private Residence 5 12 'Western Red' cedar shingle roof (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label), typ. Detail 3/A2.2 12 +/-28.75 7'-6" aluminum clad 'SDL' double-hung window w/ 2" historical sill (equal to 'Marvin'), typ. 'Western Red' cedar shingle siding (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label), typ. wood trim closed boxing w/ wood 'bead board' soffit, typ. over-size bronze finish gutter/downspout, typ. aluminum clad 'SDL' D.H./picture window w/ 2" historical sill (equal to 'Marvin'), typ. 1x solid wood trim entablature, typ. 8'-0" 10"sq. wood trim 'Tuscan' architectural column, typ. 3'-2 1/8" flat seam copper return, typ. 'decorative' solid wood rail system (not req'd per code; less than 30" above grade), typ. stucco parging (painted) over poured-in-place concrete foundation w/ 'bluestone' surface, typ. 28'-7 7/16"(height above media grade) 'Western Red' cedar shingle siding (flaired @ gable cross boxing), typ. 4"x5/4 solid wood casing w/ 1x2 backband, typ. 27'-3 11/16"(height above 1st floor subfloor) copper curb at roof pitch transition, typ. (cased 'punched' opening, typ.) 'Western Red' cedar shingle roof (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label), typ. steel frame breezeway roof structure (painted), typ. 'Western Red' cedar operable gate 8'h. single wythe brick (solid/void) screen wall w/ brick rowlock cap, typ. standing seam copper roof, typ. 12 brick veneer column w/ rowlock cap, typ. 5 Detail 2/A2.2 420 South Summit Avenue Charlotte, NC 'low-profile' skylight assembly beyond (bronze finish) Private Residence DENIED DECEMBER 2015 'Western Red' cedar decorative heavy timber bracket, typ. (median grade height) stucco parging over poured-inplace concrete foundation, typ. retain existing brick steps & flanking brick walls, typ. brick veneer 'egress' areaway w/ solid bluestone cap new brick retaining wall (match detailing & height of existing step wall), typ. 4 A2.2 'Western Red' cedar shingle roof (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label), typ. 12 5 12 5 Right Side Elevation SCALE: 1/4" HVAC equipment within roof well = 1'-0" 12 'Western Red' cedar shingle roof (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label), typ. 5 'low-profile' skylight assembly beyond (bronze finish) copper curb at roof pitch transition, typ. over-size bronze finish gutter/downspout, typ. ROOF +20'-3 5/8" 'full height' glass wall similar to storefront [beyond], typ. (PROPERTY LINE) 4"x5/4 solid wood casing w/ 1x2 backband, typ. aluminum clad 'SDL' double-hung window w/ 2" historical sill (equal to 'Marvin'), typ. 3 A2.2 Enlarged Boxing Detail SCALE: 1/2" = 1'-0" standing seam copper roof, typ. +11'-2 1/8" 2nd floor ceiling 5 (cased 'punched' opening, typ.) (cased 'punched' opening, typ.) 'Western Red' cedar shingle siding (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label), typ. 4"x5/4 solid wood casing w/ 1x2 backband, typ. built-in linear fire bowl 12 2nd floor +10'-1 1/2" +10'-1 1/2" 1st floor ceiling DonDuffy Architecture 301 Providence Rd C h a r l o t t e , NC 2 8 2 0 7 (p)704 - 358 - 1878 (f )704 - 358 - 1721 www.donduffyarchitecture.com +11'-2 1/8" 2nd floor PRELIMINARY wood trim closed boxing w/ wood 'bead board' soffit, typ. (PROPERTY LINE) 2nd floor ceiling over-size bronze finish gutter/downspout, typ. (5' SIDE YARD SETBACK; R5 ZONING) solid wood bed moulding similar to '8,000 series # 8023 [3/4"x3 5/8"], typ. +20'-11 5/8" (7' SIDE YARD SETBACK; DEED) wood trim closed boxing w/ wood 'bead board' soffit, typ. +20'-11 5/8" ROOF +20'-3 5/8" (7' SIDE YARD SETBACK; DEED) solid wood crown moulding similar to '8,000 series # 8012 [3/4"x4 1/4"], typ. (5' SIDE YARD SETBACK; R5 ZONING) 8003 1st floor ceiling steel frame breezeway roof structure (painted), typ. THIS DRAWING IS AN INSTRUMENT OF SERVICE. THE DRAWING AND THE INFORMATION THEREON IS THE PROPERTY OF DON DUFFY ARCHITECT. 8'h. single wythe brick (solid/void) screen wall w/ brick rowlock cap, typ. brick veneer column w/ rowlock cap, typ. standing seam copper roof, typ. .5 steel frame breezeway roof structure (painted), typ. ANY REPRODUCTION, ALTERATION, OR USE FOR OTHER THAN THE INTENDED PROJECT, WITHOUT THE WRITTEN CONSENT OF DON DUFFY ARCHITECT, IS EXPRESSLY FORBIDDEN. 12 COPYRIGHT © DON DUFFY ARCHITECT 36"h. glass guardrail system, typ. brick veneer column w/ rowlock cap, typ. 8'h. single wythe brick (solid/void) screen wall w/ brick rowlock cap, typ. ±0" 8'h. brick screen wall w/ pilasters ±0" 1st FLOOR 1st FLOOR -1'-10 3/4" -1'-10 3/4" Lower level ceiling Date: 11/30/2015 in-ground swimming pool, typ. Lower level ceiling Revisions: Drawn By: 2 A2.2 Section Thru Breezeway SCALE: 1/2" = 1'-0" 1 A2.2 Rear Elevation SCALE: 1/4" = Sheet: 1'-0" A2.2 Private Residence Private Residence 5 420 South Summit Avenue Charlotte, NC JANUARY 2016 'low-profile' skylight assembly beyond (bronze finish) 12 'Western Red' cedar shingle roof (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label), typ. Detail 3/A2.2 12 +/-28.75 7'-6" aluminum clad 'SDL' double-hung window w/ 2" historical sill (equal to 'Marvin'), typ. 'Western Red' cedar shingle siding (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label), typ. wood trim closed boxing w/ wood 'bead board' soffit, typ. over-size bronze finish gutter/downspout, typ. aluminum clad 'SDL' D.H./picture window w/ 2" historical sill (equal to 'Marvin'), typ. 1x solid wood trim entablature, typ. 8'-0" 10"sq. wood trim 'Tuscan' architectural column, typ. 3'-2 1/8" flat seam copper return, typ. 'decorative' solid wood rail system (not req'd per code; less than 30" above grade), typ. stucco parging (painted) over poured-in-place concrete foundation w/ 'bluestone' surface, typ. 28'-8"(height above median grade) 'Western Red' cedar shingle siding (flaired @ gable cross boxing), typ. 4"x5/4 solid wood casing w/ 1x2 backband, typ. 27'-4 1/4"(height above 1st floor subfloor) copper curb at roof pitch transition, typ. 'Western Red' cedar shingle roof (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label), typ. (cased 'punched' opening, typ.) +/-48"h. brick veneer screen wall w/ stone cap (along perimeter of grill area, typ. 'Western Red' cedar operable gate 12 5 'Western Red' cedar decorative heavy timber bracket, typ. (median grade height) stucco parging over poured-inplace concrete foundation, typ. retain existing brick steps & flanking brick walls, typ. brick veneer 'egress' areaway w/ solid bluestone cap new brick retaining wall (match detailing & height of existing step wall), typ. 3 A2.2 HVAC equipment along 'low-pitch' roof 12 12 5 Right Side Elevation SCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0" 'Western Red' cedar shingle roof (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label), typ. 'low-profile' skylight assembly beyond (bronze finish) 5 copper curb at roof pitch transition, typ. +20'-11 5/8" +20'-11 5/8" ROOF +20'-3 5/8" ROOF +20'-3 5/8" 5 'punched' opening, typ.) 12 +11'-2 1/8" +11'-2 1/8" 2nd floor 2nd floor +10'-1 1/2" +10'-1 1/2" 1st floor ceiling 'Western Red' cedar shingle siding (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label), typ. 4"x5/4 solid wood casing w/ 1x2 backband, typ. built-in linear fire bowl 5 over-size bronze finish gutter/downspout, typ. solid wood crown moulding similar to '8,000 series # 8012 [3/4"x4 1/4"], typ. 8003 wood trim closed boxing w/ wood 'bead board' soffit, typ. solid wood bed moulding similar to '8,000 series # 8023 [3/4"x3 5/8"], typ. 4"x5/4 solid wood casing w/ 1x2 backband, typ. DonDuffy Architecture 301 Providence Rd C h a r l o t t e , NC 2 8 2 0 7 (p)704 - 358 - 1878 (f )704 - 358 - 1721 www.donduffyarchitecture.com 1st floor ceiling THIS DRAWING IS AN INSTRUMENT OF SERVICE. THE DRAWING AND THE INFORMATION THEREON IS THE PROPERTY OF DON DUFFY ARCHITECT. 'Western Red' cedar shingle roof (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label), typ. 12 PRELIMINARY wood trim closed boxing w/ wood 'bead board' soffit, typ. (PROPERTY LINE) 'punched' opening, typ.) (cased (5' SIDE YARD SETBACK; R5 ZONING) (cased (7' SIDE YARD SETBACK; DEED) (7' SIDE YARD SETBACK; DEED) (PROPERTY LINE) 'full height' glass wall similar to storefront [beyond], typ. 2nd floor ceiling (5' SIDE YARD SETBACK; R5 ZONING) 2nd floor ceiling over-size bronze finish gutter/downspout, typ. ANY REPRODUCTION, ALTERATION, OR USE FOR OTHER THAN THE INTENDED PROJECT, WITHOUT THE WRITTEN CONSENT OF DON DUFFY ARCHITECT, IS EXPRESSLY FORBIDDEN. COPYRIGHT © brick veneer column w/ rowlock cap, typ. DON DUFFY ARCHITECT 36"h. glass guardrail system, typ. +/-48"h. brick veneer screen wall w/ stone cap (along perimeter of grill area, typ. ±0" ±0" 1st FLOOR 1st FLOOR -1'-10 3/4" -1'-10 3/4" Lower level ceiling Lower level ceiling Date: 1/5/2016 Revisions: aluminum clad 'SDL' double-hung window w/ 2" historical sill (equal to 'Marvin'), typ. Drawn By: 2 A2.2 Enlarged Boxing Detail SCALE: 1/2" = 1'-0" 1 A2.2 Rear Elevation SCALE: 1/4" = Sheet: 1'-0" A2.2 Private Residence 12 5 'Western Red' cedar shingle roof (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label)[match house], typ. copper curb at roof pitch transition [match house], typ. DENIED DECEMBER 2015 +/-28.75 aluminum clad 'SDL' double-hung window w/ 2" historical sill (equal to 'Marvin'), typ. (cased 'punched' opening, typ.) 'Western Red' cedar shingle siding (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label)[match house], typ. wood trim closed boxing w/ wood 'bead board' soffit [match house], typ. (cased 'punched' opening, typ.) 'Western Red' cedar decorative heavy timber bracket [match house], typ. 8'h. 'decorative' brick screen wall w/ pilasters Left Side Elev. - Garage 4 A2.3 5 'Western Red' cedar shingle roof (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label)[match house], typ. Private Residence 12 420 South Summit Avenue Charlotte, NC 4x5/4" solid wood casing w/ 1x2 backband [match house], typ. SCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0" 12 4"x5/4 solid wood casing w/ 1x2 backband [match house], typ. (cased 'punched' opening, typ.) 'Western Red' cedar shingle roof (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label), typ. steel frame breezeway roof structure (painted), typ. 'Western Red' cedar operable gate 8'h. single wythe brick (solid/void) screen wall w/ brick rowlock cap, typ. aluminum clad 'SDL' double-hung window w/ 2" historical sill (equal to 'Marvin'), typ. 5 12 +/-28.75 'Western Red' cedar shingle siding (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label)[match house], typ. standing seam copper roof, typ. 12 23'-10 3/8"(height above media grade) copper curb at roof pitch transition [match house], typ. brick veneer column w/ rowlock cap, typ. wood trim closed boxing w/ wood 'bead board' soffit [match house], typ. 'Western Red' cedar decorative heavy timber bracket [match house], typ. (median grade height) 3 A2.3 'Western Red' cedar shingle roof (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label)[match house], typ. Right Side Elev. - Garage SCALE: 1/4" = 'Western Red' cedar shingle roof (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label)[match house], typ. copper curb at roof pitch transition [match house], typ. copper curb at roof pitch transition [match house], typ. wood trim closed boxing w/ wood 'bead board' soffit [match house], typ. +20'-11 5/8" +20'-11 5/8" ROOF +20'-3 5/8" ROOF +20'-3 5/8" 2nd floor ceiling 2nd floor ceiling PRELIMINARY 1'-0" wood trim closed boxing w/ wood 'bead board' soffit [match house], typ. +20'-11 5/8" +20'-11 5/8" ROOF +20'-3 5/8" ROOF +20'-3 5/8" 2nd floor ceiling 2nd floor ceiling 4"x5/4 solid wood casing w/ 1x2 backband [match house], typ. 4"x5/4 solid wood casing w/ 1x2 backband [match house], typ. aluminum clad 'SDL' double-hung window w/ 2" historical sill (equal to 'Marvin'), typ. aluminum clad 'SDL' double-hung window w/ 2" historical sill (equal to 'Marvin'), typ. 'Western Red' cedar shingle siding (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label)[match house], typ. 'Western Red' cedar shingle siding (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label)[match house], typ. standing seam copper roof, typ. steel frame breezeway roof structure (painted), typ. +11'-2 1/8" +11'-2 1/8" 2nd floor 2nd floor +10'-1 1/2" +10'-1 1/2" 1st floor ceiling 1st floor ceiling +11'-2 1/8" +11'-2 1/8" 2nd floor 2nd floor +10'-1 1/2" +10'-1 1/2" 1st floor ceiling 1st floor ceiling 'Western Red' cedar decorative heavy timber 'Western Red' cedar bracket [match house], typ. decorative heavy timber bracket [match house], typ. 8'h. single wythe brick (solid/void) screen wall w/ brick rowlock cap, typ. 'Western Red' cedar wood alum. clad ext. door framed garage doors (Carriage(paneled); by window style design), typ. manuf.[equal to 'Marvin'] 'Western Red' cedar wood framed garage doors (Carriagestyle design), typ. DonDuffy Architecture 301 Providence Rd C h a r l o t t e , NC 2 8 2 0 7 (p)704 - 358 - 1878 (f )704 - 358 - 1721 www.donduffyarchitecture.com THIS DRAWING IS AN INSTRUMENT OF SERVICE. THE DRAWING AND THE INFORMATION THEREON IS THE PROPERTY OF DON DUFFY ARCHITECT. ANY REPRODUCTION, ALTERATION, OR USE FOR OTHER THAN THE INTENDED PROJECT, WITHOUT THE WRITTEN CONSENT OF DON DUFFY ARCHITECT, IS EXPRESSLY FORBIDDEN. COPYRIGHT © DON DUFFY ARCHITECT Date: 11/30/2015 Revisions: Drawn By: ±0" ±0" 1st FLOOR 1st FLOOR 2 A2.3 Rear Elevation - Garage SCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0" ±0" ±0" 1st FLOOR 1st FLOOR 1 A2.3 Front Elevation - Garage SCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0" Sheet: A2.3 Private Residence 5 'Western Red' cedar shingle roof (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label)[match house], typ. 12 copper curb at roof pitch transition [match house], typ. JANUARY 2016 4x5/4" solid wood casing w/ 1x2 backband [match house], typ. +/-28.75 (cased 'punched' opening, typ.) +/-48"h. brick veneer screen wall w/ stone cap (along perimeter of grill area, typ. 'Western Red' cedar shingle siding (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label)[match house], typ. 'Western Red' cedar operable gate wood trim closed boxing w/ wood 'bead board' soffit [match house], typ. (cased 'punched' opening, typ.) 'Western Red' cedar decorative heavy timber bracket [match house], typ. 36"h. glass guardrail system, typ. Left Side Elev. - Garage 4 A2.3 5 'Western Red' cedar shingle roof (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label)[match house], typ. SCALE: 1/4" = Private Residence 12 420 South Summit Avenue Charlotte, NC 'Western Red' cedar shingle roof (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label), typ. aluminum clad 'SDL' double-hung window w/ 2" historical sill (equal to 'Marvin'), typ. 1'-0" 12 (cased 'punched' opening, typ.) 'Western Red' cedar shingle roof (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label), typ. 4"x5/4 solid wood casing w/ 1x2 backband [match house], typ. +/-48"h. brick veneer screen wall w/ stone cap (along perimeter of grill area, typ. aluminum clad 'SDL' double-hung window w/ 2" historical sill (equal to 'Marvin'), typ. 'Western Red' cedar operable gate 12 23'-10 15/16"(height above media grade) copper curb at roof pitch transition [match house], typ. 12 +/-28.75 'Western Red' cedar shingle siding (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label)[match house], typ. wood trim closed boxing w/ wood 'bead board' soffit [match house], typ. 5 (median grade height) 3 A2.3 Right Side Elev. - Garage SCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0" 'Western Red' cedar shingle roof (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label)[match house], typ. 'Western Red' cedar shingle roof (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label)[match house], typ. copper curb at roof pitch transition [match house], typ. +20'-11 5/8" ROOF +20'-3 5/8" +20'-11 5/8" ROOF +20'-3 5/8" 2nd floor ceiling 4"x5/4 solid wood casing w/ 1x2 backband [match house], typ. aluminum clad 'SDL' double-hung window w/ 2" historical sill (equal to 'Marvin'), typ. 'Western Red' cedar shingle siding (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label)[match house], typ. +11'-2 1/8" 2nd floor +10'-1 1/2" +11'-2 1/8" +11'-2 1/8" 2nd floor 2nd floor +10'-1 1/2" +10'-1 1/2" 1st floor ceiling 1st floor ceiling 'Western Red' cedar decorative heavy timber bracket [match house], typ. 1st floor ceiling 'Western Red' cedar decorative heavy timber bracket [match house], typ. alum. clad ext. door (paneled); by window manuf.[equal to 'Marvin'] 2nd floor ceiling 24'-2"(height above median grade) 2nd floor ceiling +20'-11 5/8" 2nd floor ceiling wood trim closed boxing w/ wood 'bead board' soffit [match house], typ. ROOF +20'-3 5/8" ROOF +20'-3 5/8" PRELIMINARY copper curb at roof pitch transition [match house], typ. +20'-11 5/8" wood trim closed boxing w/ wood 'bead board' soffit [match house], typ. 'Western Red' cedar decorative heavy timber bracket [match house], typ. 4"x5/4 solid wood casing w/ 1x2 backband [match house], typ. aluminum clad 'SDL' double-hung window w/ 2" historical sill (equal to 'Marvin'), typ. 'Western Red' cedar shingle siding (Certigrade number 1 grade, blue label)[match house], typ. DonDuffy Architecture 301 Providence Rd C h a r l o t t e , NC 2 8 2 0 7 (p)704 - 358 - 1878 (f )704 - 358 - 1721 www.donduffyarchitecture.com standing seam copper roof, typ. steel frame breezeway roof structure (painted), typ. +11'-2 1/8" 2nd floor +10'-1 1/2" 1st floor ceiling THIS DRAWING IS AN INSTRUMENT OF SERVICE. THE DRAWING AND THE INFORMATION THEREON IS THE PROPERTY OF DON DUFFY ARCHITECT. ANY REPRODUCTION, ALTERATION, OR USE FOR OTHER THAN THE INTENDED PROJECT, WITHOUT THE WRITTEN CONSENT OF DON DUFFY ARCHITECT, IS EXPRESSLY FORBIDDEN. COPYRIGHT © 'Western Red' cedar wood framed garage doors (Carriagestyle design), typ. DON DUFFY ARCHITECT Date: 1/5/2016 +/-54"h. single wythe brick screen wall w/ brick rowlock cap, typ. Revisions: ±0" 1st FLOOR 'Western Red' cedar wood framed garage doors (Carriagestyle design), typ. ±0" 1st FLOOR 2 A2.3 Rear Elevation - Garage SCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0" ±0" 1st FLOOR -1'-10 3/4" (median grade height) ±0" 35'-8"(vs.46';equates to a 22% width reduction) Lower level ceiling 1st FLOOR Drawn By: -1'-10 3/4" Lower level ceiling 1 A2.3 Front Elevation - Garage SCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0" Sheet: A2.3 Private Residence