Losing the Middle Class Research Project Team Members

advertisement

Losing the Middle Class

Research Project

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy

Team Members

•Daniel Barajas: Co-Leader

•BrendaSue Dickey: Leader

•Alfonso Falcon

•Arturo Ortiz

•Alfonso Pinto

•Tony Trent

•Indelisa Zarate

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 2

1

1

Loss of the Middle Class –

Presentation Outline

• Executive Summary

• Needs Analysis

• Solution Descriptions

• Solution Criteria

• Solution Choice

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 3

Fall 2005

Executive Summary

Daniel Barajas

Digital Bridge Academy 4

2

Project Goals

• To collect information and data about:

– The shrinking of the Middle Class

– Privatization

• To create a solution that will address:

– High cost of living in Santa Cruz County

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 5

Research Questions

• How has the Middle Class changed in our community?

• How is the busy lifestyles of families/dual incomes, etc… tied to the loss of the Middle Class?

• What connection does our community perceive between the loss of the

Middle Class and privatization?

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 6

3

Responsibilities

• Daniel– Executive Summary

– Team Co-Leader

• BrendaSue– Need Statement

– Team Leader

• Tony– Need Statement

• Arturo– Need Statement

• Indelisa– Solution Statement

• Alfonso P. – Solution Statement

• Alfonso F.– Solution Statement

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 7

Background

• Surveyed 206 people

– 60% - Students who have jobs

• Interviewed people from:

– The Plaza in Watsonville

– Cabrillo College Aptos and Watsonville

Campuses

– Agencies and large stores

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 8

4

Survey Respondents

Gender:

• 34% men

• 66% women

Ethnicity:

• 75% Hispanics / Latinos

Age Distribution:

• 48% between the ages of 15-20

• 17% between 21-25

• 10% between 26-3 0

• 24% are ages 31+

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 9

Survey Respondent

Demographics

Income level:

• 50% of people are earning $0 to $25,000

Primary Language:

• Spanish - 52%

• English – 41%

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 10

5

Many students interviewed…

• 62% of respondents are students

– 48% are attending college

– 60% of all students live with their parents

– 64% of students are employed

• Below 5 hrs - 5%

• 5-20hrs - 32%

• 20-40hrs - 37%

• 40+hrs - 30%

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 11

Survey Respondent

Households

Family Size:

• Families have an average of 3-4 and up to 5-7 people living in their homes

Number of Families per Household:

• 15% have more than one family living in their homes

Family members working:

• 33% of households have 3-5 people working to maintain a living

• 2% of people have 6+ people working

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 12

6

Survey Respondent

Educational Level

48% 60%

40%

20%

0%

21%

15%

High School

Diploma

Some College

College Diploma

• High School Diploma-- 21%

• Some College-- 48%

• College Diploma-- 15%

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 13

Survey Respondent

Citizenship & Voting

• 77% are citizens

• 23% are not citizens

• 37% voted

• 63% did not vote

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 14

7

Fall 2005

Higher Income and

More Jobs

By BrendaSue, Alfonso Pinto and

Arturo

Digital Bridge Academy 15

Data Collection

¾ Surveyed 206 people

¾ 3% - Homeless

¾ 7% - D.I.N.K.s (Double Income No Kids)

¾ 15% - Live in multiple Family Homes

¾ 6% - Single Parents

¾ 60% - Students who have jobs

¾ Surveys distributed to and collected from:

¾ The Plaza in Watsonville

¾ Cabrillo College Aptos and Watsonville Campuses

¾ Saladud para la Gente in Watsonville and Santa Cruz

Emiline Clinic

¾ Target

¾ Albertsons

¾ Star Bucks

¾ Home Depot

¾ Our families

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 16

8

What is the need?

• Citizens in Santa Cruz County are living in a very expense place

• The middle class is being squeezed

• Working poor need:

– more income

– help with covering the cost of their essentials

– to learn the skills to increase their incomes and live within their means

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 17

80%

70%

60%

50%

40%

30%

20%

10%

0%

74%

Education

Income

Family Size

Owning or Renting

Property

Undecided

• 74% said Income is what makes someone middle class.

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 18

9

How much money do you make in one year?

60%

40%

20%

0%

50%

16% 16%

7%

$0-$10,000

$10,001-$25,000

$25,000-$45,000

$45,001-$75,000

• Of 206 people surveyed 66% said they make $25,000/ year or less

• As defined by income less than 30% would be considered middle class

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 19

How many families live in your home?

100%

50%

0%

9% 3% 3%

1 family

2 families

3 families

4+ families

15% (or 31 respondents) surveyed have 2 our more families living in their homes

– 9% -- 2 families live in their home

– 3% -- 3 families live in their home

– 3% -- 4+ families live in their home

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 20

10

Do you consider yourself a

Middle Class citizen?

• Yes-- 76%

• No-- 24%

– However 76% who consider themselves middle class are not as defined by income

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 21

If you consider yourself Middle

Class, what do you find to be stressful in trying to keep up that lifestyle?

50%

40%

30%

20%

10%

0%

43%

• Money –43%

• Jobs –16%

16%

Nothing

Money

Jobs

Lack Of Govn't

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 22

11

of staying in or becoming Middle

Class?

60% 53%

30%

0%

Education

Obligations

Family

Jobs

Community

Other

• 53% surveyed say that Jobs is the most stressful part of being in the

Middle Class

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 23

Have you noticed the

Middle Class shrinking?

•47% -- Yes

How have you noticed?

• 12% - People leaving Santa Cruz County

• 19% - Less jobs

• 41% - Cost of living is rising

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 24

12

How is it effecting you and/or your community?

• Not enough money

• Cost of living increasing

– 48% Rent

– 22% Gas

– 20% Food

– 13% Clothes

– 11% Entertainment

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 25

When is the need evident?

• At the end of the month when rent is due in a few days and people are sweating trying to figure out where the money will come from

• When students are working and going to school so they don’t have to burden their parents anymore

• When gas is $2.80 per gallon and that is cheap!

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 26

13

Compared to your income how much are you going into debt each month?

60%

40%

20%

0%

19% 15%

9%

$0-$100

$101-$250

$251-$500

$500+

– 43% are going into debt $101 - $500+

Every Month!!

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 27

Why does this need occur?

• Former high wage jobs have left the United

States and been outsourced to overseas where the same job can be done for pennies on the dollar

• A living wage for one person in Santa Cruz

County is so high the jobs available do not meet the income range needed to live

– $11/hour with benefits*

– $12/hour without benefits*

* Community Action Board of Santa Cruz County, Inc. website -

12/6/2005

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 28

14

Why does this need occur?

• Citizens who make good money are living paycheck to paycheck

• Working citizens that make minimum wage depend on having more than one job

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 29

• More people utilizing government resources

• Saving money for retirement

• Financial security

• Bigger middle class

• Citizens have more confidence in their finances

• Less stress for families

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 30

15

• Residents fleeing the area

• Middle Class keeps shrinking

• Decline in our community

• Increase in high school drop-outs

• Creating a self-fulfilling prophecy

– People will talk about this forever

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 31

What is needed to overcome these problems

Give working poor:

– more income

– help with covering the cost of their essentials

– the skills to increase their incomes and live within their means

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 32

16

Root cause

Help working poor increase income

– Minimum wage is too low for our county’s cost of living

– Raise the Minimum Wage to the living wage of

Santa Cruz County

Cost of essentials is rising substantially

– Cost of rent is rising substantially in our area

– Cost of gasoline

Lack of skills to increase their incomes and live within our means

– Skills for higher-wage jobs

– Handle money and finances (budgeting)

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 33

Fall 2005

for Dealing with the

Shrinking Middle Class

Indelisa, Alfonso P., Alfonso F.

Digital Bridge Academy 34

17

Three recommended solutions

1. Raise Minimum Wage in Santa Cruz County to living wage

2. Lower the Cost of Living by having Rent

Control

3. Provide workshops to teach skills to manage finances and develop careers to increase income

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 35

Solution 1: Raising the minimum wage…

Increase the minimum wage for Santa

Cruz County residents to a living wage

– all who live in Santa Cruz County can continue to live here

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 36

18

Solution 2: Rent Control

Lower the cost of living in Santa Cruz

County by creating a rent control policy countywide

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 37

Solution 3: Finance

Management Workshop

Teach people in Santa Cruz County how to:

– budget effectively to match their income,

– save for the future and

– develop the skills needed for high wage careers that match their strengths

38 Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy

19

Selection Criteria

1. Probability of happening

2. Long-term solution

3. Number of people affected

4. Number of people to attend

5. Resources required:

– Volunteers & donations

– On-going Costs

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 39

Selecting the Solution

1.Probability of happening

Minimum

Wage Hike

X

2.Long-term solution X

3.Number of people affected

Fall 2005

XXX

Rent

Control

Finance &

Career

Management

Workshop

XX

XX

X

Digital Bridge Academy

XXX

XXX

XXX

40

20

Selecting the Solution

Minimum

Wage Hike

Rent

Control

Finance &

Career

Management

Workshop

XXX

4.Number of people to attend

5.Resource

s to implement

6.On-going

Costs

Fall 2005

X X

X

Digital Bridge Academy

X

XXX

XXX

41

Description of Chosen

Solution

A series of workshops to help residents of

Santa Cruz County understand how to:

– manage their finances

• deal with debt so that it is not as overwhelming as it is currently

• save for the future

• grow their savings

– increase their long-term income

• find careers that suit their strengths

• create a plan to get the education required for that career

Support groups for participants:

– to learn from each other how they are managing

Digital Bridge Academy 42

21

Goals

Santa Cruz County citizens will:

– have more disposable income

– save money

– create confidence in themselves regarding money

– have a future source of income built on their strengths

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 43

One Year Objectives

In the first year of implementation:

1. 25% of minimum citizens will have successfully completed the workshops

2. 100% of participants will understand their finances better

3. 10% will have the ability to put money away

4. 5% will have more disposable income

(income-savings)

5. 5% will have found higher wage careers

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 44

22

Five Year Objectives

In the fifth year of implementation:

1. 90% of minimum citizens will have successfully completed the workshops

2. 100% of participants will understand their finances better

3. 50% will have the ability to put money away

4. 25% will have more disposable income

(income-savings)

5. 75% will have found higher wage careers

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 45

Outcomes

People of S.C. County will learn and be able to:

1. Budget for their limited income

2. Have more disposable income

3. Creatively work with their finances

4. Know their strengths and career options

5. Have more income

Fall 2005 Digital Bridge Academy 46

23

Download