NORTH NORFOLK DISTRICT COUNCIL ASSET MANAGEMENT PLAN 2010 Contents Foreword 1. Introduction and Policy Context Purpose of the Asset Management Plan 4 About North Norfolk 4 Strategic Overview and National Policy Context 5 Role of the Property Services Team 6 Governance and Communications 6 2. The Asset Portfolio The Existing Asset Portfolio 8 IFRS 9 Changes to the Asset Portfolio 10 Asset Protection – Property Maintenance 11 Current Asset Conditions and Maintenance Programme 11 3. Asset Management Strategy North Norfolk Corporate Plan 15 North Norfolk Sustainable Community Strategy 15 Carbon Reduction, Climate Change and Energy Performance 18 Community Empowerment Projects 20 Coastal Pathfinder Project 20 Administration Buildings 21 Public Conveniences 22 Car Parks 23 Beach Huts and Chalets 23 1 14/02/2011 Industrial Units 24 Retail Outlets and Cafes 24 Leisure Centres 24 Sports Clubs 24 4. Capital Programme 2009/10 25 2010/11 26 2011/12 27 5. Revenue Budget Operational Action Plan Data Management, Records & Information 31 Performance Management 32 Estates and Valuation 33 Project Management 33 Policies & Procedures 34 Risk Management 34 APPENDICES Appendix 1 Asset Management Board Terms of Reference 35 Appendix 2 Summary Schedule of the Council’s Property by Operational Type including list of car parks and public conveniences 38 Appendix 3 Asset Register Summary Schedule of Asset Values 48 Appendix 4 Five Year Maintenance Programme 49 Appendix 5 Property Disposal, Investment and Acquisition policy 54 2 14/02/2011 FOREWORD Our vision for North Norfolk is that it should be a place where everyone can enjoy a high quality of life and where the unique and attractive environment is sustained. In order to maintain services and community facilities and to enhance the built environment and public realm, we must make the best use of resources. The effective use of the Council’s property assets has a big impact on our services and our communities as our assets are valued at some £41m. The Council’s Asset Management Plan takes a strategic approach to asset management enabling a response to a range of issues from carbon reduction to equality impact assessments, from asset transfer to supporting economic development and tourism infrastructure. We must ensure our assets meet the needs of our community now and into the future. Peter Moore Cabinet Portfolio Member for Corporate Assets 3 14/02/2011 1. INTRODUCTION Purpose of the Asset Management Plan (AMP) 1.1. Asset Management is the process that seeks to ensure that best value is secured from property assets which serve the Council’s key objectives. Assets are an essential component in the delivery of Council services and aims and therefore require good management and pro-active planning to ensure adequate maintenance. 1.2. Asset Management Plans describe the progress that has been made in the development of the Council’s asset portfolio and to indicate how it will be developed to address the Council’s corporate priorities in the future. The Asset Strategy outlines the approach taken with regard to acquisitions and disposals and provides a framework for decisions taken by the Council and its Asset Management Board. 1.3. The aims of the AMP are: • To ensure that assets are fit for purpose and provide value for money by being managed in an efficient, effective, economic and sustainable manner; and • 1.4. To develop a co-ordinated approach to asset management that links with the corporate objectives of the Council and the North Norfolk Sustainable Community Strategy AMP. This AMP has been prepared in order to: • Provide policy context for the Asset Strategy; (Chapter 1) • Provide a statement of the Existing Asset Portfolio owned by NNDC and their current condition; (Chapter 2:) • Provide a forward looking strategic framework within which to manage the Council’s property assets; (Chapter 3) • Show how the strategy will be implemented and how property assets will be maintained, modernised and rationalised to ensure that they are fit for purpose, through a range of projects both for the 2010/11 and 2011/12 capital programmes. This chapter provides a link to the Council’s Capital Strategy (Chapter 4); and, • Identify operational activities, based on revenue budgets for how the assets will be recorded, monitored and managed. (Chapter 5). About North Norfolk 1.5. North Norfolk is one of the largest local authority Districts in the country, its boundaries encompassing 373 square miles. Situated on the north-east coast of East Anglia, the District stretches for 43 miles alongside the North Sea. 1.6. The District is predominantly rural, with a population of just over 100,000 people living in 200 distinct communities. There is no main urban centre, with the majority of the population living in the seven small market and resort towns of Cromer, Fakenham, Holt, 4 14/02/2011 1.7. 1.8. North Walsham, Sheringham, Stalham and Wells-next-the-Sea. North Norfolk District Council (NNDC) transferred its Council Housing stock to Victory Housing Trust (formerly North Norfolk Housing Trust) in a large scale voluntary transfer which was completed in February 2006. The Council’s main office is situated on the Holt Road, Cromer. The Council has a small but diverse property portfolio which includes administrative buildings, industrial units, leisure facilities, public conveniences, beach chalets, car parks, community centres, woodlands and public amenity areas, the net book value of which was some £41million at 31 March 2010. Strategic Overview and National Policy Context 1.9. Effective asset management can play a major role in delivering better outcomes for citizens, creating a sense of place and generating efficiency gains. Strategic Asset Management “seeks to align the asset base with the organisation’s corporate goals and objectives. It ensures that the land and buildings asset base of an organisation is optimally structured in the best corporate interest of the organisation concerned.”1 1.10. Building On Strong Foundations – A Framework for Local Authority Asset Management outlines the benefits of good asset management. This Asset Management Plan has been prepared within the context of the Government’s Framework for Local Authority Asset Management.2 For example, good local authority asset management can: • Deliver exceptional services for citizens, aligned with locally agreed priorities, whilst focusing investment clearly on need; • Empower communities and stimulate debate; • Improve the economic well-being of an area; • Ensure that, once built, assets are correctly maintained; • Introduce new working practices and trigger cultural organisational changes; • Reduce carbon emissions and improve environmental sustainability; • Increase co-location, partnership working and sharing of knowledge; • Improve the accessibility of services and ensure compliance with the Disability Discrimination Act (DDA) 2005; • Generate efficiency gains, capital receipts, or an income stream; and • Improve the quality of the public realm. 1.11. The Coalition Government published the Localism Bill on 13th December 2010 and this proposed legislation will have a major impact on the way in which the Council runs services and manages property. The bill intends to transfer power to local communities through six steps: lifting the burden of bureaucracy, empowering communities to do things their way, increasing local control of public finance, diversifying the supply of public services, opening up government to public scrutiny and strengthening accountability to local people. 1.12. The proposal of the Community Right to Buy requires local authorities to maintain a list of assets of community value3. When listed assets come up for disposal, communities will be RICS 2008 Public Sector Asset Management Guidelines Building on Strong Foundations: A Framework for Local Authority Asset Management. February 2008 3 Proposals to introduce a Community Right to Buy – assets of a community nature: Consultation paper published 4 February 2011 5 14/02/2011 1 2 given the chance to develop a bid and raise the capital to buy the asset when it comes on the open market. This will give communities power to save local assets threatened with closure, allowing them to bid for the ownership and management of community assets. Role of Property Services Team 1.13. The objectives of the Property Service are: • To use the Council’s land and buildings to help deliver corporate priorities and service delivery needs in order to help deliver wider community benefits, and in particular: - To invest in those assets achieving the Council’s aims and key objectives; and - • • To dispose of redundant assets in order to realise funds which can be better applied to addressing Corporate objectives; To ensure the proper maintenance and sustainability of the Council’s property assets including: - To achieve value for money and to embed an annual programme of planned maintenance based on the Asset Management Plan and a rolling programme of property surveys which clearly identifies future maintenance requirements; - To ensure as far as reasonably practical that the properties are safe, accessible and fit-for-purpose; - To maintain records for each asset containing accurate and up to date information including efficiency, effectiveness and running costs which can be used to support decision-making on investment/disinvestment decisions; - To improve the energy efficiency of the Council’s buildings, which will reduce carbon emissions in line with the Council’s Environmental Sustainability Strategy (adopted April 2009), the Council’s Carbon Management Plan, approved by Cabinet in April 2010. - To ensure that the Council’s property assets are adapted to withstand the future predicted changes in climate (National Indicator 188) To ensure that the Council’s property assets are focused on the needs of users and the public. Governance and Communications 1.14. The Council’s Asset Management Board is responsible for the strategic direction of the Council’s assets via implementation of the Asset Management Plan. The Board meets quarterly and is chaired by Cllr. Peter Moore, Portfolio-holder for Corporate Assets and these meetings are minuted to provide a formal record of decisions and recommendations. The terms of reference for the Asset Management Board were revised in December 2010 and are attached in Appendix 1. However, all decisions on property assets are taken either by Cabinet or under delegation as set out in the Council’s standing orders and the by Dept. Communities and Local Government and sets out the provisions being made in the Localism Bill 6 14/02/2011 Acquisitions, Investment and Disposals Policy in Appendix 5. 1.15. Asset management issues are reported to Councillors on a regular basis and the Board makes recommendations to Cabinet on current issues. The Asset Management Plan is presented to Cabinet annually with updates during the year as required. Pre-Scrutiny of policy is encouraged wherever appropriate and the Committee can also exercise its “call in” powers. 1.16. In terms of general communications, the website and intranet are regularly updated and provide information about the range of services provided by Property Services. Information is conveyed to Members via items in the Members Bulletin and to staff via the Staff Briefing. Items in the District’s magazine “Outlook” are used to keep residents and the wider community up to date about Property Services initiatives. Local Members, Town and Parish Councils and other stakeholders are advised of any capital works being undertaken in their area and are consulted on any redevelopment proposals. 7 14/02/2011 2. THE ASSET PORTFOLIO The Existing Asset Portfolio 2.1. North Norfolk District Council does not have a particularly extensive property portfolio. The holdings comprise Council buildings, industrial units, retail outlets, public conveniences, car parks and a miscellaneous range of land holdings. A schedule of the Council’s property assets is provided in Appendix 2. Appendix 3 shows the Corporate Asset Register by IFRS categorisation and the total valuation of £41,034,758. 4 2.2. It should be noted that both Appendix 2 and Appendix 3 are derived from the current Corporate Asset Register. As detailed in paragraphs 2.5 to 2.11 below, this Register is undergoing review and change and is intended to be integrated with new asset management software to be introduced into the Property Services team (paragraphs 4.10 and 5.2), therefore it is possible that properties listed in Appendices 2 and 3 will be reclassified, amended or added to during 2011. 2.3. The International Financial Reporting Standard (IFRS) 2010, require the categorisation of the Council’s assets into the categories of Operational and Non-operational: • • 2.4. Operational – property in which the Council has a legal interest, either freehold or leasehold, which is either occupied by the Council’s own staff or by a third party, together with those which provide a service objective of the Council; Non-operational - property in which the Council has a legal interest, either freehold or leasehold and which is not being used for operational reasons or to meet a service need but is for the purpose of improvements to the District or the proper planning of the area or is let to a third party.5 Lettings are generally secured on commercial terms which provide an income and this will be an important consideration as leases fall due for renewal. The Councils property assets can be summarised as shown in the table below:6 Asset Type No of buildings/units Operational 4 5 6 Administrative Buildings Depots/storage Car Parks 3 2 35 (of which 26 are Pay & Display) Public Conveniences 41 (including 2 closed for redevelopment) Tourist Information Centres 4 Leisure Centres 3 Sports clubs 6 Theatres and museums Surveyor’s Allotments Retained Housing Sites Gypsy & Traveller Sites Community Centres 5 87 34 2 2 Shown as £41million throughout this report. Definition of Land and Property Categories from HMG Communities and Local Government Office Refer Paragraph 2.2. This summary of building types is as currently held by Property Services and not as Appendix 2. 8 14/02/2011 Asset Type No of buildings/units Operational (Continued) Shelters Miscellaneous (putting greens, Amenity Areas etc) 37 50 Non-Operational Assets Industrial Units (3 sites) 17 Retail outlets Beach chalets 17 132 Beach hut sites 244 Parklands caravan site (pitches) 37 Assets Held for Disposal As separately identified 3 2.5. A review of the Council’s properties within these categories is being considered in conjunction with revisions that might be required in accord with the new International Financial Reporting Standard (IFRS) 2010. 2.6. The asset base was re-valued in April 2009 and a rolling programme of valuations has been instituted; the current valuation remains substantially unchanged from last year at £41million.7 The assets are valued for the purposes of the financial accounts, to provide a net book value (NBV) (as recommended by CIPFA Statement of Recommended Practice), as either • Open Market Value (OMV); • Existing Use Value (EUV) for operational assets; • Existing Use Value (Depreciated Replacement Costs, (DRC)) for operational assets with specialised use. IFRS 2.7. Local Authorities are required to prepare their Statements of Accounts under the new International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) based Code of Practice on Local Authority Accounting from 2010/11. 2.8. The impact of IFRS will vary from body to body but the most significant changes which will impact on next years Asset Management Plan relate to changes to property, plant and equipment (formerly known as fixed assets). 2.9. For example, the accounting treatment for assets classed as ‘Investment Properties’ under current accounting practices as per the Statement of Recognised Accounting Practice (SORP)) is very different to the treatment under the new IFRS requirements. The definition of an Investment Property under IFRS is that the land or building must be held solely to earn rentals or for capital appreciation or both, rather than in connection with any service or policy objective, such as economic development or tourism, which is far more prescriptive than the SORP requirements. 7 Valuation in 2009 £40.7million 9 14/02/2011 2.10. These new IFRS requirements in relation to Investment Properties may have implications for how assets are categorised in the future (compared to the current Balance Sheet) and therefore on the values reported for these assets. Investment Properties are currently valued at Market Value, but any assets which need to be reclassified may also need to be re-valued on a different basis, depending upon the category into which the asset has to be transferred. 2.11. Any changes that are required due to the introduction of IFRS will be fully detailed within the Final Accounts report and Council’s Financial Statements for 2010/11. These changes will then feed into the update of next year’s Asset Management Plan. Changes to the Asset Portfolio in 2010/11 2.12. The Asset Portfolio is under regular review to reflect any changes to service delivery. The impact of the budget cuts will mean that further rationalisation of the portfolio may be required over the next few years. The details of the capital programme are reported in Chapter 5, but in summary, during the financial year 2010/2011 the following changes were/will be made to the portfolio: Investment in Properties • Public convenience improvements • Car park refurbishments (Stearman’s Yard Wells, & East Cliff Sheringham) • Car park ticket machine replacement (Cromer, Holt, Mundesley, Sheringham, Wells) • Major refurbishment to Seaview Pre-school North Lodge Park, Cromer (funded by the Government’s Surestart capital programme, administered by Norfolk County Council). Disposals – freehold • Public Conveniences, Church St, Holt (June 2010) • Public Conveniences, Bond St. Cromer (June 2010)8 Disposals – long-term lease • Seaview Pre-school, North Lodge Park, Cromer • Maltings and Sackhouse Complex, Wells (estimated March 2011) Acquisitions • Coastal Pathfinder Project: Happisburgh between 2-9 residential properties on Beach Road, Properties identified for disposal being taken forward in 2011/12 8 • Lockerbie Flats, Sheringham, disposal at part of Tesco development • Public Conveniences, East Promenade, Sheringham as potential for private development • Depot, Blowlands Lane, Upper Sheringham as potential for affordable housing. Refer paragraphs 2.2 and 2.5 to 2.11 - not included in Appendix 3. 10 14/02/2011 • Public Conveniences, Market Place, North Walsham as a possible sale, development and lease-back • Morston Quay Public Conveniences – offered to National Trust at nil cost. Asset Protection – Property Maintenance 2.13. Maintaining the Council’s assets is an essential component of the Asset Management Strategy. Appropriate maintenance ensures not only that the asset maximises its market value, but also that the assets remain safe and accessible for staff and the community; that operational assets remain fit for purpose and income derived from non-operational assets is not compromised by any failings of the property. The responsibility for the maintenance of all the Council’s properties and that property for which the Council has a legal liability is organised corporately within the Property Services team, who either directly or via external contractors carry out repairs, routine maintenance, service checks and refurbishment as necessary. Current Asset Condition and Maintenance Programme 2.14. A programme of condition surveys commenced in 2010, revising those surveys carried out during 2006 and 2007. Condition surveys will be carried out on a rolling three-year programme so that all assets will have either a structural or condition review during this programme. Completed surveys will have the recommendations incorporated into a 5-year Planned Maintenance Schedule. A total of 61 structural condition surveys plus a further 33 car park access surveys have been carried out in 2010. 2.15. In respect of the Council’s main administration premises, a specialist whole-life and option study including condition survey is being commissioned and this is detailed in paragraph 3.25 within the Asset Management Strategy section of this report. 2.16. The new condition surveys and 5-year Planned Maintenance Schedule incorporate the Association of Chief Corporate Property Officers in Local Government (COPROP) building condition scoring and the National Property Performance Management Initiative (NAPPMI) indicators applicable to any identified maintenance work. A summary of the 5-year Planned Maintenance Programme is provided in Appendix 4. 2.17. As part of the revised format for the Council’s Condition Surveys, each survey identifies any remedial work necessary for a five-year period as a 5-Year Forward Maintenance Plan with the work rated according to NAPPMI indicators. This data is then consolidated into the overall Planned Maintenance schedule for all the Council’s properties with the aim of providing a structured improvement regime to all the Council’s assets within budget control and achieving best value. 2.18. The benefits of such a 5-year Forward Maintenance Plan include the ability to clearly identify the potential costs of any asset beyond the historical expenditure of rental income, rates, utility costs and other contractual costs. 2.19. The overall 5-Year Forward Maintenance Plan is by its nature a constantly changing and developing schedule of works; items are added as condition surveys are carried out, but it is also important that when work done the item is removed from the plan. This must include where work has had to be carried out as a result of damage, vandalism, breakdown or unexpected deterioration (reactive maintenance) and which affects an item identified within 11 14/02/2011 the planned maintenance schedule. Failure to remove work completed from the planned maintenance schedule soon results in the Plan appearing to be over-committed. It has, therefore, been devised in a format that can be assimilated into the new asset management software, as detailed in paragraphs 4.10 and 5.2. 2.20. The 5-Year Forward Maintenance Plan does not include reactive maintenance, although the budget figures shown in the summary in Appendix 4 are the full repairs and maintenance budget and as such includes reactive, planned and service contracts. The 5Year Forward Maintenance Plan does not include budget figures for items or work which are subject to capital programmes. Planned maintenance will include items where a condition survey has identified a potential major issue such as damp, building movement, roof deterioration etc, but only to the extent of costs incurred to carry out specialist investigation work. Should it be established that major work is required, whilst the item description will remain on the Forward Maintenance Plan as a record, it will be noted as a potential capital bid and these major costs not included in the Plan. This is so that the Plan does not become separated from the overall Repairs and Maintenance revenue budget, but still includes reference to major works being planned. 2.21. The summary of the Plan shown in Appendix 4 is a “snap-shot” of the overall detailed plan at the time of writing. However, it is intended to provide a guide to the identified repair work needed to each asset necessary to either improve or maintain the stock to COPROP Building Score B (Property satisfactory and performing as intended but showing minor deterioration). 2.22. Annual service maintenance contracts, in addition to providing regular preventative maintenance at a pre-agreed price, also include routine testing, examination and reporting as necessary under Health and Safety legislation e.g. lift testing, water quality testing etc. The Council’s existing contracts are in the course of being reviewed to ensure adequacy and competency and that best value is being achieved. As part of this review, new contracts have been agreed during 2010 whilst some others changed or enhanced. It is the aim of this process that these annual service contracts will reduce the number of unexpected breakdowns and the need for costly emergency repairs. These service contracts are included in Appendix 4. 2.23. The priority accorded to individual maintenance work or tasks, both reactive and planned has been changed. Categorising the majority of required maintenance work as “emergency” has been replaced with a structured prioritisation. This has the advantage of focusing effort into key health and safety emergency issues as they arise and giving other work a greater lead-time in order to achieve efficiencies and cost savings. 2.24. Within the maintenance remit, consideration is given to the materials used for redecoration, refurbishment and repair, seeking wherever possible to use recycled products, low V.O.C. paints and similar. 2.25. An essential aspect of the maintenance programme is to ensure as far as reasonably practicable that the Council premises are safe for all users and that any work carried out on the Council’s behalf is done so in a safe and controlled manner. To ensure this, there is a close working relationship with North Norfolk District Council’s Corporate Health and Safety team. 2.26. The ownership, control and use of assets also include statutory and moral responsibilities and these are identified as Corporate Risks within the North Norfolk District Council Risk Management Framework 2008. Specific risks are detailed in the Corporate Risk register and many of these risks are either directly or indirectly property related. Therefore, it is 12 14/02/2011 essential that these key elements are assessed and addressed as part of the property maintenance regime. 2.27. Specific property-related health and safety issues are currently being reviewed and this reassessment includes the following: • Asbestos The Council has a legal duty to manage asbestos under regulation 4 of the Control of Asbestos Regulations 2006 and as part of its asbestos management plan has commissioned specialist risk assessments of all buildings where asbestos could be present. These surveys were carried out in early 2009 and an action plan was developed giving priority to the removal of all discovered damaged asbestos containing materials identified in the surveys. The management plan prepared in early 2009 is currently under review in line with HSG264 issued in 2010 and a revised policy has been developed and is in the process of adoption. This policy includes the stricter controls recommended within the latest Health and Safety Executive guidance, enhanced record keeping, monitoring and greater dissemination of information relating to where asbestos-containing materials have been identified within Council buildings. The revised policy does not contain a carte-blanche provision that all asbestos must be removed from Council buildings, as the removal may pose a greater risk than leaving the material in situ and regularly monitoring its condition. • Fire Fire risk assessments were completed by the Council’s Corporate Health and Safety team in July 2010 and the various recommendations arising are currently being addressed and/or reviewed in conjunction with the Corporate Health and Safety team, in order to achieve best practice. All the premises occupied by the Council for its operations and activities contain fire fighting measures and these are under maintenance contracts with a national provider. A review of these contracts will take place in 2011 to ensure best value is being achieved. • Electricity All electrical work is carried out by an approved NICEIC contractor and test certificates and notices obtained where significant alterations are made to fixed wiring. A portable appliance testing regime is in place with the annual testing of all Council staff tradesmen’s electrical tools and equipment. Fixed electrical testing and certification has been in effect, but in 2011 a revised programme of premises to be tested has been devised and quotations will be sought from specialist Electrical Contractors Association (ECA) members in testing and reporting to current 17th Edition Electrical Regulations. • Gas Annual gas safety inspections are carried out on all applicable operational premises with tests carried out by a fully registered Gas Safe contractor appropriate for the type of installation i.e. commercial or domestic as applicable. Gas Safe certificates being issued and recorded as appropriate and any identified remedial measures acted upon. • Legionella and Water Quality In accordance with the HSE code of practice (L8), an initial generic assessment determined that a thorough series of individual risk assessments including pipe-work schematics was required. A survey programme with a specialist was instigated in early 2009 and risk assessments are on-going with recommendations arising prioritised and 13 14/02/2011 action taken. Improvements identified by the assessments such as the removal of dead-legs and other obsolete pipe-work have been undertaken. A programme of water temperature monitoring is in place in accordance with the risk assessments. This work remains as a continuing process of monitoring and improvement in accordance with HSE L8 guidelines and is being carried out in conjunction with the specialist contractor and the Corporate Health and Safety team with a view to the production of an overall management plan and improvements to the existing procedures during 2011. To this extent discussions have already been entered into with the specialist contractor as to means of improving the monitoring, recording and information process. In respect of all safety matters, the need to complete the surveys and maintain a programme of inspection and review is identified within the Council’s Corporate Risk Register and advice is sought from the Council’s Corporate Health and Safety team to ensure compliance with legislation. The rolling programme of premises condition surveys will identify health and safety issues and these will be accordingly prioritised in the 5-year Forward Maintenance Plan according to NAPMI criteria as described in paragraph 2.15. 14 14/02/2011 3. ASSET MANAGEMENT STRATEGY North Norfolk Corporate Plan 3.1. The management of the portfolio is a key corporate objective as identified within the Council’s Corporate Plan ‘Changing Gear’, as it is clear that excellent asset management is central to delivering corporate objectives. ‘Changing Gear – The Road to Excellence’ is the Council’s current Corporate Plan for 2008 – 2011. Within this document sits the Organisational Development Plan, which identifies eight key organisational themes which the Council feels are fundamental to underpinning the successful delivery of our targets for service improvement and resource management. Asset Management has been identified as one of the Corporate Plan’s key themes. The Corporate Plan will be reviewed in 2011 along with a review of the Sustainable Community Strategy. North Norfolk Sustainable Community Strategy 3.2. 3.3. The Corporate Plan stressed the link with the North Norfolk Sustainable Community Strategy (2008-2011). The strategy states that the Vision for North Norfolk is a place: • Where people feel safe and live in decent homes • Where equality and diversity are valued and celebrated • Where people have diverse career and training opportunities, and jobs which add value • Where residents choose healthy lifestyles in sustainable communities and can access a wide range of activities which meet everyone’s needs • Where the environment is protected and where the identity and special character of the areas is retained. This vision is translated into three key outcomes • Improving housing • Better jobs and prospects • Sustaining a high quality of life – a nice place to live, work and visit. 3.4. Asset management has a strong role to play in supporting this vision for North Norfolk and to underpin the visions set out in the Sustainable Community Strategy, Local Area Agreement and the Local Development Framework Core Strategy (Adopted September 2008) 3.5. The Asset Management service supports these aims in a number of ways, both in terms of supporting the local economy and in provision of facilities to improve residents’ quality of life. In particular, provision of car parks and public conveniences improves the tourist offer for the district and provides the amenities required by visitors as well as local residents. Similarly tourist information centres, beach huts and chalets and the wider foreshore environment are key aspects of visitors’ enjoyment when visiting our coastal resorts. Adequate car parking in our market and resort towns is also essential for the role of these towns as local service centres. Industrial units provide support for local employers, while open space and leisure facilities are essential in achieving a good quality of life. 3.6. The Asset Management Plan has been prepared to show how the use of assets reflects 15 14/02/2011 corporate priorities shown in the diagram below. It has been prepared in order to provide a framework for decisions on the Council’s assets. It is intended to dovetail with the Council’s LDF Core Strategy and other Council Strategies such as the Carbon Reduction strategy. The approach taken will therefore be subject to participation and consultation asking how Council-owned assets in an area might be best managed to meet the needs of the locality. The Strategy set out here considers the key assets of the Council and their role in supporting the Sustainable Community Strategy and corporate objectives. The table below shows how the vision is expressed through the Council’s assets. The Strategy is delivered through major investments via the Capital programme (works over £10,000) and through revenue budgets, such as maintenance programmes. North Norfolk Sustainable Community Strategy & NNDC Corporate Plan NNDC Asset Management Plan Sustainable Community Strategy Vision Where people feel safe and live in decent homes Where equality and diversity are valued and celebrated Where people have diverse career and training opportunities, NNDC Financial and Capital Strategy Asset Local Development Core Strategy Community Engagement Strategy Other Strategies, Plans and Policies NNDC Corporate Asset Management Strategy Parklands Lockerbie Flats All buildings/spaces designed with safety in mind. The Council’s only residential holdings are Lockerbie Flats and Parklands Caravan Site Equality Impact Assessments undertaken for all policies/services/facilities Car Parks, Public Toilets Beach Huts & The natural and built environment is vitally important for the local economy and promoting tourism. Assets supporting tourism and 16 14/02/2011 and jobs which add value Where residents choose healthy lifestyles in sustainable communities and can access a wide range of activities which meet everyone’s needs Where the environment is protected and where the identity and special character of the areas is retained. 3.7. 3.8. Chalets, Retail Outlets & Cafes and Industrial Units Leisure Centres, sports clubs, amenity areas and Community Centres. Open Space, Parks, public realm, Promenades, etc economic development will be maintained to the best standard within current resource levels. Leisure centres and community halls are important elements to achieve this vision. Community buildings may be best held in community ownership. NNDC will promote asset transfer to community where appropriate. The foreshore built environment is important in maintaining and enhancing the character of the area. However, many of these assets are in a poor state and there is limited funding to maintain them. Area Asset Reviews will be instigated to rationalise and channel investment into these areas. The Asset Management Strategy reflects these key themes as shown in the table below with further information provided in the subsequent sections. As well as the issues outlined below, the Asset Management Plan links to individual service plans and other Council strategies and corporate initiatives, in particular the following: • Health and Safety • Risk Management • Business Continuity • Procurement strategy • Crime Reduction • Economic Development strategy • Property data management and GIS The table below shows the Council’s thematic objectives and the property related projects being undertaken as part of these themes. Council Thematic Objective Projects/Initiatives Climate Change / Carbon Reduction Carbon Trust pledge Equality and Diversity Community Engagement Coastal Management Equality Impact Assessments of Property Services, DDA improvements to all Public Conveniences. Consultation with interest groups in new projects. Pilot scheme for asset transfer project in Wells, and working with NNCP on a range of projects such as the Resource Centre in Fakenham, etc. Consultation on development projects such as the Red Lion Redevelopment in Cromer and the proposed new public conveniences at East Prom, Sheringham. Support for the Coastal Management Pathfinder project for the provision of community infrastructure and land and property acquisition in settlements affected by coastal erosion. 17 14/02/2011 Promoting Tourism and economic development Public Conveniences Car Parks Beach huts and chalets Industrial units Carbon Reduction Programme, Climate Change and Energy Performance 3.9. The use and efficiency of the Council’s main administration building in Holt Road, Cromer is central to the 5 Year Carbon Reduction Strategy within the Council’s Carbon Management Plan (CMP). The CMP has a proposed target reduction in carbon emissions of 33% by 2014. Data from year ending March 2010 demonstrates a 7% carbon reduction over the 2008-2009 base year figures and this reduction is on-track to achieve the 2014 target. The Council does not currently have to participate in the Carbon Reduction Commitment cap and trade scheme as the Council does not consume more than 6,000MWh electricity per annum. However, if the criteria change in the future then there is a risk of financial penalties to the Council if carbon reduction targets are not met. 3.10. The present projects highlighted within the CMP relating to the Holt Road offices include: Improvements to general lighting Enhancements to building insulation Installation and integration of a Building Energy and Management System (BEMS) However, it is considered that a complete specialist feasibility study of these and other improvement measures being undertaken at the Holt Road offices during the 2010/2011 will provide comment on the viability and cost-effectiveness of these projects. 3.11. Included within the current projects of the CMP is the installation of voltage optimisation equipment in the leisure centres and Holt Road offices. A full competitive study of the options and alternatives was undertaken during 2010 and a contract for installation will commence late 2010 with completion early 2011. It is predicted that this measure will produce an annual energy saving of £17,500 and CO2 reduction of 125 tonnes. 3.12. When work is contemplated or undertaken, both refurbishment and new construction, full consideration needs to be taken to maximise opportunities for carbon reduction and sustainable development and work is on-going with Council’s Sustainability Co-ordinator to achieve this. 3.13. The largest user of energy within the Council’s activities is that of the leisure centres. These centres are managed on the Council’s behalf by D.C. Leisure and the Council are in continual discussion with them with a view to introducing measures to reduce energy consumption. 3.14. The Council has in place mechanisms for renewal of the necessary Display Energy Certificates (DEC), currently required for buildings greater than 1,000 m2. 3.15. Consideration is being given to the best method of monitoring electrical consumption throughout the Council’s properties. The main administration office is a half-hourly metered site but investigation regarding the installation of smart meters in other locations is currently on-going. 3.16. The table below shows an extract from the Climate Change Action plan, showing the Adaptive Responses required by Property Services to address the anticipated impacts of climate change. 18 14/02/2011 Adaptive Responses to Climate Change for Property Services Risk/Vulnerability Adaptive response Owner Timescale Cost Increased flooding of assets Identify which assets are in EA flood risk zones, North Norfolk SFRA zones and areas that have previously experienced flooding (Environmental Protection) Property Manager By March 2012 Staff time Risk assessment undertaken for car parks included climate change scenarios (May 2010 Scrutiny) Property Manager Completed Staff time Review of car parks to establish if significant flood risk exists Property Manager Internal survey review and report implemented by March 2012 Staff time but could be incorporated in current checks Survey of guttering and surface water drainage of all buildings Property Manager After surveys completed Staff time but could be incorporate in current checks Guttering replacement programme if required when other works undertaken Include requirement for ventilation strategy as part of requirement for contractor undertaking building survey Property Manager Property Manager Survey to be undertaken Winter 10/11 Will require Capital cost Will require capital investment Continue to maximise night-time cooling of building especially environmental health section Maintain current legionnaires testing programme Caretaker Ongoing Staff time Property Manager Ongoing Staff time Consider introducing annual ammonia sulphide cleansing in WC cisterns and insulate WC cisterns if testing programme records temp increases Property Manager In response to testing programme Will impact on costs of maintenance Undertake risk assessment of staff showers if testing programme records temp increases Property Manager In response to testing programme Staff time Don’t install large air conditioning plant as part of ventilation strategy Property Manager Survey to be undertaken Winter 10/11 Staff time Maintain current air conditioning plant and change filter regularly Monitor spread of pests and diseases from SE of country Property Manager Property Manager Ongoing Increase in uncomfortable conditions for building/office occupants Increase in cases of legionnaires disease within LA owned buildings Increased pest populations e.g. termites Ongoing Current maintenance costs Staff time 19 14/02/2011 Community Empowerment Projects 3.17. Working with the town and parish councils, the North Norfolk Community Partnership and the seven Local Area Partnerships, the Council is working to align its asset management with the aspirations of local communities. Examples of how the Council used its assets for the furtherance of community ambition include the development of Oddfellows Hall and the Mo Museum in Sheringham. On-going community engagement projects include those in Wells, Sheringham, North Walsham, Cromer and Fakenham, as well as the Coastal Pathfinder project, described below. 3.18. During 2010/11 a feasibility study for the Maltings and the Sackhouse, two historic buildings at the heart of Wells, the car park area and the TIC has been undertaken to identify how this complex of buildings can be developed to provide, in addition to the existing community centre uses, a year round visitor attraction. Extensive community consultation was undertaken and has been assisted by the Government’s Advancing Assets Programme which funded a facilitator to undertake a visioning exercise. The feasibility study was joint-funded by the CABE SEACHANGE programme, the District Council and the North Norfolk Community Partnership. The Trust was established in August 2010 and the District Council has contributed approximately £30,000 funding for a Programme and Development Manager to take forward the project. A new long term lease was agreed by Cabinet in October 2010 and is expected to be signed in March 2011. 3.19. In Sheringham, after community consultation, a proposal to replace the temporary toilets with a permanent facility is due to proceed during 2011. This project is intended to provide fully DDA and mobility compliant facilities, (possibly including “Changing Places” facilities for the severely disabled), including low energy and low water usage facilities. They will be designed to withstand the harsh environment of the seafront and be vandal-proof. The project and block design has been influenced by the input of local stakeholders. 3.20. In North Walsham, a project funded by Regional Improvement East, has brought together all public services and voluntary groups to consider better utilisation of office space. This is being informed by public involvement of both stakeholders and the business community in North Walsham. A £70,000 bid has been agreed to help pump-prime this project. 3.21. A new project, based around regeneration of the West Promenade in Cromer will be instigated in 2011. This project will be informed by a steering group of community interests and will consider how to revitalise and regenerate the West Promenade. It will involve reprovision of public conveniences and will be designed to ensure facilities are provided for the less mobile. 3.22. In Fakenham, a project is underway, which will involve the County, District and Town Councils as well as the Area Partnership to consider the modernisation of the Fakenham Connect/Fakenham Community Centre site. At present a bid for funding for a feasibility study has been submitted to kick-start the project. Coastal Pathfinder Project 3.23. The Government has awarded North Norfolk District Council £3 million as part of Defra’s Coastal Change Pathfinder project to trial new approaches to managing the impacts of coastal change. The Council’s bid involved three elements: Integrating actions and interventions to manage the existing impacts of coastal change within the single community most affected (Happisburgh), while developing initiatives to foster resilience and adaptation to coastal change in the future; 20 14/02/2011 3.24. Mitigating the impacts of blight and disinvestment resulting from the predictions of coastal change over a wide coastal frontage, where the predicted impacts may not be fully apparent but where uncertainty is undermining investment decisions, on coastal businesses, community facilities and dwellings; and, Infrastructure works, responding to past, present and predicted coastal change and which will improve the economic prospects of the District. Each element involves the Property Service team in a range of activities in relation to provision of new/replacement facilities such as car parks and public conveniences, as well as footpath provision and, potentially, other land acquisition including residential land (which may include the right to develop replacement houses under the Council’s planning policy (“EN12”)). For instance, there may be a requirement to be involved in the purchase and subsequent sale of a development site or sites which will mean that the Council’s investment in the coastal community of Happisburgh is recycled. The scale of this project and the timescale required for action are ambitious and at this stage the detailed projects have yet to be finalised, but it will form an important element of the work of the team over the next 2-3 years. Administration Buildings 3.25. The Council’s main administration offices are at the Holt Road, Cromer premises and virtually all the Council’s activities are run from this location. This building was constructed in 1990 and has been the subject of a number of major capital bid projects to partially refurbish and/or correct some building issues that have arisen due to wear etc. These capital bids are summarised in Section 4 Capital Programme, however some time has elapsed since the initial application for Capital Funding for these individual items and whilst there remains a need to consider remedial and improvement works as identified, the priority of these measures and their suitability to achieve the desired results overall needs to be re-assessed. Therefore the offices are to be completely surveyed by specialist structural, mechanical and electrical engineers to provide the Council with a complete report detailing: • The existing condition of the building and its infrastructure. • Building structural defects currently apparent or those which might be reasonably foreseen to become a potential problem during the next 5-10 years. • Defects or potential issues with the existing mechanical and electrical plant within the building including where items are no longer compliant with standards and where replacements should be anticipated during the next 5-10 years. • Potential energy-saving or energy creation measures which could be incorporated with any of the building or mechanical, electrical measures requiring change during the next 5-10 years. • Considering the use of space within the building and identifying any measures which could be taken to improve the utilisation of the building. • Costs to implement those items found or suggested. • A recommended priority phasing of necessary expenditure on the premises to ensure continued full operation for the next 5-10 years. Final quotations for this independent study are currently being obtained with a view to work commencing end-January 2011. 21 14/02/2011 3.26. The Council partially occupies as a local district office, the Fakenham Connect Single Point of Access; premises shared with Fakenham Town Council, County Registrars and Adult Education. This building is leased by the District Council from Norfolk County Council on a full repairing and maintaining lease basis. 3.27. The former local district office at North Walsham is no longer occupied or utilised by the Council, the building currently tenanted predominantly by North Walsham Town Council. A full condition survey of this building was carried out in 2010 by Norfolk Property Services. Public Conveniences 3.28. The approach to public convenience provision set out here is based on the work of the Council’s Public Convenience Policy Panel (PCPP) which held meetings between October 2004 and July 2006. The Council agreed a Public Convenience Improvement Programme at its Cabinet Meeting in September 2008. A further report was considered by Scrutiny Committee in May 2009. 3.29. The Council runs 41 public toilet blocks across the District, with higher numbers in the seaside resorts, reflecting the tourism needs of these areas. The current list of public toilets operated by the Council is shown in Appendix 2. 3.30. The objective of the public convenience strategy is to provide good quality, clean, accessible, well-maintained toilets that people want to use, within the Council’s budgetary constraints. The intention will be to move towards more energy and water efficient facilities and to provide for DDA compliance and mobility standards where possible. This will support the tourist economy as well as providing an important facility for local people. 3.31. Given current and likely future budget constraints, there is a need to minimise on-going expenditure on public conveniences while at the same time finding creative ways of providing this necessary facility. There are a number of options in terms of transfer of the facility to a local provider or town/parish council as well as agreements with local businesses who may be able to offer their customer toilets to the general public if supported by the District Council. The overall approach for minimum provision will be: • • • Seaside Resorts – central toilets, facility at main car park and provision on Prom/seafront areas during summer season; Market towns – central facilities, at main car park where appropriate; and Village resorts – adjacent to beach/village centre as appropriate. 3.32. The Council has spent £ 563,514 from the Capital Programme for the period 2006/7 through to 2009/10 for public conveniences. This work was completed in April 2010 and November 2010. This involves upgrades to 28 facilities including major rebuilds at Sea Palling, Mundeslely Prom and Albert St, Holt. The NNIC and Rocket House do not require upgrades. 3.33. Of the remaining 11 blocks, 3 replacement facilities are due to be completed during 2011, including at North Walsham Market Place and Potter Heigham, but both are subject to private sector development and agreement on legal issues. It was agreed by Cabinet on 10th January 2011, following completion of a feasibility study and consultation that the existing Sheringham East Promenade toilet building should be sold and new facilities provided nearby. 22 14/02/2011 3.34. This leaves 8 facilities which as a result of the PC Policy Panel recommendations, were not included in the current Improvement Programme. These include: • • • • • • • • 3.35. Cromer, Melbourne Slope, Cromer West Prom Cromer Pier Cromer, North Lodge Park Fakenham, Highfields Morton Quay (offered to National Trust at nil cost. Currently awaiting response from their national Policy and Acquisitions Committee which meets 8th February 2011) Sheringham, High St Stalham The Council intends to undertake area based asset reviews of these facilities involving wider community engagement to ensure investment is in line with community priorities. This will be undertaken for the Cromer public conveniences through the feasibility study for a major refurbishment of the West Prom as outlined in the capital programme. The other facilities will be subject to area-wide asset reviews and the review in Fakenham will be undertaken in conjunction with the County Council. Car parks 3.36. North Norfolk District Council runs 35 car parks across the District, of which 26 are pay and display car parks. In May 2009 Cabinet agreed to a £135,000 investment in new pay and display ticket machines (with chip & pin) for 22 machines at 13 car parks in Cromer, Mundesley, Sheringham, Holt and Wells. The new machines were installed in March 2010 and as well as providing chip and pin facilities and ease of use for customers, they provide better security and improved management information. Replacement of remaining machines is subject to a separate growth bid for 2011/12 as identified in Chapter 4. 3.37. It is important to ensure that car parks are maintained and improved as these provide a significant income for the Council. There is also a need to ensure a quality environment for visitors as car parks are often gateways to our resorts and market towns. Car park resurfacing and re-lining has taken place during 2010 on a number of car parks and these works will continue into 2011. In addition, there is separate growth bid for environmental improvements for 2011/12 as identified in Chapter 4. Beach Huts and Chalets 3.38. During the summer of 2009 a review of the beach hut and chalet service took place, covering a range of issues, including reviewing management arrangements, leases, pricing structure and maintenance programming. As a result of this review, a capital bid to purchase huts for the Council to let out as weekly lets was accepted and 14 have been purchased. The current asset base is as follows: Location Cromer Overstrand Sheringham Mundesley Total Beach Huts 85 18 76 (& 4 weekly lets) 50 & (10 weekly lets) 244 Chalets 104 0 28 0 132 23 14/02/2011 Industrial Units 3.39. The Council owns industrial units in Catfield, North Walsham, (Cornish Way) and Fakenham, the first two providing important opportunities for local business start-ups and developments. Due to the current economic climate, voids have been higher than might otherwise have been expected. However, with a combination of careful negotiation and management of both existing and new occupiers, all units are currently occupied and income producing with rent arrears significantly reduced. The occupier of the Fakenham unit, J W Automarine, a major local employer, had requested an extension to the current unit. The capital bid for this work was agreed by Cabinet in 2009 at a cost of £425,000. Surrender and lease renewal negotiations are well advanced with construction likely in early 2011. Retail Outlets and Cafes 3.40. These outlets are investment properties, which add to the provision for tourists in our seaside towns, particularly in Cromer and Sheringham. The approach is to ensure that the buildings are maintained by tenants in good repair together with monitoring tenant covenant compliance and that the Council’s statutory duties as landlord, are adhered to. Leisure Centres 3.41. The Council owns three leisure centres; Fakenham Sports and Leisure, Sheringham Splash and Victory Pool. 3.42. The management of these three leisure facilities are contracted to DC Leisure Management Ltd (DCLM) who are responsible for the day-to-day operational matters and who are also responsible for all machinery, plant and equipment plus internal decoration maintenance and repairs. 3.43. The existing management contract with DCLM is due to expire 31 March 2014. However, discussions are in place with regards to an extension of this contract and as part of these negotiations a full condition survey will be carried out in 2011 at each of the centres to establish: • Any existing defects with the existing fixed plant and equipment including mechanical. electrical, heating and ventilation (the responsibility of DCLM) • The potential life expectancy of the existing fixed plant and equipment (the responsibility of DCLM) • Any defects in the building structure or other defects which might be reasonably be foreseen as needing to be remedied over the next 5-10 years. Sports Clubs 3.44. The District Council owns a number of sports clubs which are leased to clubs at peppercorn or non-commercial rent. During 2011, in response to the Localism Bill, a policy will be developed to identify where asset transfer or disposal may be appropriate. 24 14/02/2011 4. CAPITAL PROGRAMME 4.1. The Capital Programme is based on the objectives set out in the Asset Management Plan. The table below summarises the capital programme expenditure for property related projects, for the last financial year. It should be noted that the amount spent on property related capital projects has increased significantly in recent years compared with for example expenditure of some £315,725 in 2005/69. 2009/2010 4.2. During 2009/10 the council spent over £720,000 on improvements to its public conveniences, car parks, industrial estates and offices. This represents a major investment in our properties and is a significantly higher spent than in previous years. Table 4.1 : North Norfolk District Council Capital Programme 2009/10 Actual Expenditure Catfield Cromer Cromer Cromer Cromer East Fakenham Faklenham Holt Mundesley North Walsham North Walsham Sheringham Sheringham Various Various Various West Various Sea Palling Wells Total Catfield Ind Est Car Park Works Trading Services Depot, Stonehill Way Council Offices Purchase of Annexe Cromer Council Offices, Toilets and Showers Cromer Council Offices Roofworks PCP 003 Public Convenience Improvement Programme - Central East (NW, Bacton, Walcott) Fakenham Connect Fire Escape Fakenham CC Kitchen Works and Windows Albert St Public Conveniences PCP 002 Mundesley Prom Public Conveniences Actual Expenditure Incurred 2009/10 as per final accounts 14,907.16 25,203.00 36,647.28 26,612.00 11,199.85 48,680.28 8,233.71 39,600.08 49,239.49 74,901.77 Industrial Estate Road Works 33,922.53 Council Office Roof Repairs Splash Fenestration Splash Screens Car Park Ticket Machines (Cromer, Holt, Mundesley, Sheringham, Wells, ) Cliff Top Car Park Fencing Asbestos Works PCP 001 Public Convenience Improvement Programme - West (Fak, Blak, Wal, Sher, Holt) Public Convenience Improvements Sea Palling Toilets Maltings feasibility study 17,661.74 52,765.24 29,048.83 117,732.00 10,326.46 32,444.55 £ 69,948.65 13,178.08 12,313.91 27,500.00 752,066.61 NB this table excludes items less than £5,000, so that the actual capital budget is slightly higher at £753,598.53. (This list excludes the two Gypsy and Traveller sites, Cromer Pier and the Fakenham Employment Land) 9 Excluding Fakenham Industrial Estate and as NB applicable to Table 4.1 25 14/02/2011 2010/11 4.3. During 2010/11 the Council anticipates spending in excess of £460,000 on the continuing programme of improvements to its built assets. In recent years the Council has up-graded 27 sets of public conveniences, including major re-builds at Albert St, Holt, Mundesley Promenade and Coast Road, Bacton. This work has included provision of hot water, upgrades to DDA requirements, internal repairs and redecoration. 4.4. Unfortunately a number of schemes have been delayed for reasons outside the Council’s control, such as improvements to the Market Place PCs in North Walsham and the PCs at Potter Heigham which are subject to private redevelopments. 4.5. Table 4.2 includes schemes due to be undertaken during 2010/11 4.6. The Red Lion Toilets on East Prom, Cromer were closed in 2006 and surplus to requirements. This project involves conversion of the buildings to provide the Glide Surf School and North Norfolk Surf Life Saving club with premises. This redevelopment will provide a rental income for the Council as well as providing improved facilities which should encourage expansion of surfing in Cromer and extend the season. A planning application was submitted in November 2010 and permission granted in January 2011. It is anticipated that the works will take place in March in time for opening in June/July 2011. 4.7. The proposed Multi-Use Games Area at Stalham High School Shared Use Facility will provide improved all weather, flood-lit sports pitches for a range of outdoor games. A planning application was submitted in November 2010 to the County Council. It is hoped that, subject to planning permission, construction will start in April 2011 and open by June 2011. 4.8. The factory at Enterprise Way in Fakenham has been occupied by JW Automarine for a number of years and they have been keen to expand the premises, increasing the floor space by a third. The Council have agreed to fund this expansion to achieve economic development objectives. This work has planning permission and the tender process will commence as soon as lease negotiations are complete. This is a major project costing some £425,000 and will be managed internally. It is likely to be a sixteen week programme. 4.9. Remedial works are required to the second storey flooring of The Sackhouse at Wells next the Sea as the current floor is overloaded and could cause future structural problems. This work is intended to provide increased use of this facility to the overall benefit of the Maltings Project which is due to commence in Spring 2011. 4.10. Although not identified in Table 4.2 as not directly property related, the Council will also purchase a new Asset Management Software system to ensure accurate recording and management of all assets. The cost of this project is £75,000. 26 14/02/2011 Table 4.2: North Norfolk District Council Capital Programme – Complete or planned for 2010/11 2010/11 Updated Estimate 2010/11 Updated Budget Various PCP 004 Public Convenience Refurbishment Programme Central West £47,300.00 Various PCP 005 Public Convenience Refurbishment Programme East £43,000.00 Various PCP 007 Public Convenience Refurbishment Programme Wells £14,700.00 Mundesley PCP 002 Public Convenience Refurbishment Programme Mundesley £9,356.00 Various Car Park Surfacing & Lining Works £45,465.00 Various Beach Huts £17,500.00 Cromer Red Lion Toilets £15,471.00 Stalham Multi Use Games Area £41,477.00 Fakenham Fakenham Factory Extension Wells Wells Sackhouse Total £214,165.00 £15,752.00 £464,186.00 NB this table excludes items less than £5,000, so that the actual capital budget is slightly higher at £467,958.00 2011/12 4.11. Table 4.3. overleaf represents those schemes identified in the capital programme for 2011/12, but excluding growth bids which are summarised below. As can be seen from the table, there is continued investment in public assets. A number of these projects were identified some years ago and the need for the project has changed. 27 14/02/2011 Table 4.3: North Norfolk District Council Capital Programme 2011/12 Updated Budget - As at 2010/11 Revised Estimate 2011/12 Updated Budget Stalham Multi Use Games Area £69,000.00 Fakenham JW Automarine Factory Extension £206,000.00 Wells Sackhouse Remedial Works Wells Maltings Complex Cromer Rocket House H&S Works £39,736.00 Cromer NNDC Offices Access Walkway * £75,000.00 Cromer NNDC Offices Structural Works * £155,000.00 Cromer NNDC Offices Lift Replacement * £45,000.00 Cromer Red Lion Toilets £32,000.00 Various Car Park Surfacing and Lining Works £44,000.00 Various Car Park Ticket Machines £16,000.00 Various Asbestos Works £16,855.00 Various Potter Heigham Beach Huts PCP 006 Public convenience refurbishment programme North Walsham PCP Potter Heigham Public Convenience Refurbishment Programme Various Car Park Fencing £9,636.00 Fakenham Fakenham Connect £6,218.00 North Walsham Total £28,500.00 £100,000.00 £7,500.00 £68,700.00 £26,900.00 £946,045.00 * Refer paragraph 4.12 NB this table excludes items less than £5,000, so that the actual capital budget is slightly higher at £948,445. (NB includes increase in budget for MUGA to £130,000.) 4.12. The table above identifies a number of projects in respect of NNDC’s main administration offices at Cromer. As previously detailed in paragraph 3.25, a full specialist condition survey at these offices is shortly to be completed. One of the principal objectives of this survey is to consider these individual projects and to advise as to whether the initial proposals remain valid or whether there are alternatives achieving a similar or better outcome at reduced cost. 4.13. In addition to the projects outlined above, growth bids have been submitted for additional investment which is subject to approval by Full Council on 23rd February 2011. These projects are likely to be spread over the next three years and are summarised below. 28 14/02/2011 Bid Title/Brief Description Total Estimated Project Costs Estimated Costs 2011/12 Cromer Pier and West Prom Refurbishment Project - Major refurbishment of promenade and public toilets, including additional rental units/facilities to regenerate the West Prom10. Sheringham East Prom Public Conveniences - Provision of new purpose built public toilets, baby changing and shower facilities. 2012/13 200,000 45,000 155,000 85,000 85,000 0 North Walsham, Regeneration Fund 70,000 20,000 50,000 Car Park Improvements - General Works, Resurfacing and Signage Improvements to a range of car parks, to bring up to DDA and Car Parking Orders compliance 52,000 52,000 0 103,000 103,000 0 Worstead Churchyard Wall - Partial rebuild to flint churchyard walling 15,000 15,000 Fakenham Community Centre 45,000 45,000 Provision of Car Park Ticket Machines - Replacement of ticket machines in 22 locations 4.14. 4.15. 10 Cromer West Promenade Refurbishment This project will involve a major Refurbishment of Promenade and Public Toilets (including toilets on Pier). It would include Improvements / replacement of Melbourne & West Promenade Public toilets and refurbishment of Art Deco Chalets. The project would include provision of additional rental units/ facilities to regenerate West Prom Cromer. This project will take place over several years and could involve architectural design competition and would be managed by a steering group of local stakeholders. Estimated costs - PC £85,000. New cafe/retail rental units - possibly removable for winter (£60,000). Provision of mobility impaired beach huts could be included and the new public convenience block could include the “changing places” facilities for the severely disabled who require the assistance of a carer. A stakeholder steering group will be established to ensure full support of the local community and businesses. As a long-term project in addition to estimated costs above, £100,000 has been identified for period 2013/2014 29 14/02/2011 4.16. 4.17. 4.18. 4.19. 4.20. 4.21. 4.22. East Promenade Sheringham Provision of new purpose built public toilets, baby changing and shower facilities to replace temporary seasonal toilets on East Prom at Sheringham. This project was approved by the Council’s Cabinet in January 2011. A planning application for change of use for the existing block has recently been submitted with a planning application for the new facilities to be lodged shortly.. The works will be coordinated with Coastal Defence works to the East Promenade at Sheringham and are due for completion at the end of 2011. North Walsham Regeneration Fund Following on from the Leadership of Place project funded by REAP, and the joint County and District Council Asset Review, this project identifies funding to pump-prime development in North Walsham to provide a more coordinated public sector service provision in North Walsham. In addition to the £70,000 identified here, the project brings together funding from a number of other related capital programme schemes which together could create a fund of almost £200,000 for investment in North Walsham. These include: • £39,705 for the North Norfolk Enterprise and Innovation Centre, • £69,000 for the Market Place public convenience redevelopment • £20,000 for car park improvement works Fakenham Community Centre Fakenham Community Centre and Fakenham Connect buildings are located on a site on Oak Street owned by the County Council and leased to the District Council. In Autumn 2010 investigation by structural engineers identified that the Community Centre roof was moving against a structural wall and building failure could be imminent. The building is currently partly closed. At the same time, a feasibility study for a new Resource Centre for Fakenham is to the taken forward and the County and District intend to review options for the future of the site. The funding will contribute to providing solutions to the provision of community and resource use in the town. Car Park Environmental Improvements This project covers improvements to a range of car parks across the district, to bring to DDA compliance; general works and surfacing (£44,000) and provision of new signage for compliance with new Car Parking Orders (£8,000). Provision of Car Park Ticket Machines Provision of new car park ticket machines in 22 remaining machines (£103,000). This will ensure that all the Council’s car parks are equipped with modern pay and display machines providing better service to customers, a credit card payment option, being security and better management information in order to reduce operating costs. 30 14/02/2011 5. REVENUE BUDGET OPERATIONAL ACTION PLAN The action plan outlines action to be taken during 2011/12 and constitutes the basis of the Property Service Team’s Service Business Plan. This section considers the on-going monitoring of condition, management and recording of the Council’s assets, including performance management Data Management, Records and Information 5.1. The Council recognises that in order to manage the portfolio effectively the availability of accurate and appropriate data is essential. The Council currently holds asset information on a customised Access database, known as the Corporate Asset Property Database providing legal, tenant, maintenance and condition information on all properties. Deed packets and lease information has been added to the database, together with stock condition survey data, valuation and building running costs. The database is under constant review to ensure that records remain accurate. 5.2. Funds were identified to purchase a new software system for the management of asset records and maintenance schedules. A feasibility study was prepared in 2010, as a result of which tenders in respect of the acquisition of a new system are currently undergoing evaluation with the hope that a new system will be implemented in 2011. 5.3. The Council’s holdings are currently held on a map - based terrier. However, the Corporate GIS (Cadcorp) is being installed and it is anticipated that the map-based data will be transferred to this new Corporate GIS during the first half of 2010. The Council has recently installed the PLANTECH software for Land Charges, Development Control and Building Control. This will link with the Local Land and Property Gazetteer which gives each property a unique reference number (UPRN). A Project Manager has been appointed to prepare the business case, project initiation document and specification for a new Asset Management Software system. This project has the following objectives: • • Upgrade the database to reflect maintenance requirements Upgrade the database to allow financial reporting of the Asset Register as required by CIPFA SORP • Upgrade the database to allow recording and capture of data either required or that might reasonably be expected to be required in the future relating to National Indicators, Key Lines of Enquiry, Use of Resources or similar asset-related items by Central or Regional Government • Map all Council - owned land and property on the GIS system • Link this layer to the Property Database • Cross reference land ownership information with land registry and title deeds • Ensure all other holdings, including open space, parks etc are included in the database; • Provide full training for all staff who need to access the data • Review GIS and land/property information provision across the Council, to explore possible efficiencies and synergies of teams with interest and expertise in property data management. In order to comply with the latest CIPFA / IFRS requirements, external consultants have been appointed to undertake lease classification together with the subsequent provision of valuations of those leases which are determined to be financial leases for accounting purposes. 31 14/02/2011 Performance Management 5.4. Whilst the former National Indicators introduced in 2007 are no longer applicable (HM Government announced in October 2010 the ending of the National Indicator Set), there were a number of previous indicators relating to environmental sustainability where the Property Services team assisted the Council’s Sustainability Coordinator in making the required declarations and performance targets were included in the Carbon Management Plan. Property Services will continue to work closely with the Sustainability Coordinator in achieving, amongst others: i) CO2 reductions from local authority operations. ii) Planning to adapt to climate change 5.5. The Council’s Performance Management System TEN records national and local indicators, all corporate and capital programme projects as well as those in the Corporate Plan and the Property Services Business Service Plan and the recommendations from Audit. Thus most activities undertaken by Property Services are monitored through the TEN system. 5.6. Although the 2007 Use of Resources Key Lines of Enquiry (KLOE) has been superseded, the focus and aims remain valid targets for embedding into the Council’s overall asset objectives, as best practice as do the four indicators set out in the National Property Performance Management Initiative. 5.7. The building condition and required maintenance issues have been detailed within paragraphs 2.14 to 2.25 and the property energy issue detailed in paragraphs 3.9 to 3.16. 5.8. Accessibility surveys have been undertaken on public conveniences and this work informed the Public Convenience Improvement Programme whereby some toilet blocks were up-graded to ensure DDA compliance and this will continue as more improvement works take place. The Council has recently undertaken DDA review surveys on its car parks and improvements have been incorporated into the capital programme provision as detailed in paragraph 4.13 5.9. The Council’s Estate Management Service has been subject to an internal audit in 2009/10 and received an adequate assurance. As a result of recommendations from the audit, the Estate Management Performance was monitored from 2009/10 in relation to: • Vacancy rates for industrial units and retail outlets – with a minimum target of 80% occupancy • Maintenance of rent arrears less than 5% on all debts 90 days and over; and • 5.10. Offer of and take up of rent-free/reduced rent offers. A summary of attainment of the previous Indicators which were monitored in Property Services as part of the 2009 Asset Management Plan are as the table below: 32 14/02/2011 Performance Measure Target Maintenance Establish rolling programme of stock condition surveys, with minimum of 20% completed per year. Proportion of Council properties in each condition category (A-C). Estates and Valuation Vacancy rates for industrial units and retail outlets – with a minimum target of 80% occupancy. Maintenance of rent arrears less than 5% on all debts 90 days and over. Offer of and take up of rent-free/reduced rent offers. Performance as at December 2010 Programme of structural condition surveys established with 60% of all Operational Assets (excluding Surveyors Allotments and car parks) completed in first year Council properties rated according to categories A-C where suitable condition survey has been carried out in last 5 years (refer Appendix 4) Currently achieved 100% occupancy. Target achieved. Now in practice. Estates and Valuation 5.11. The Authority has a wide range of assets which range from community benefit to investment return. In addition to the Council’s own assets, it has further holdings under a mix of long lease and short commercial terms. 5.12. A programme of ongoing lease renewals and rent reviews has commenced in respect of a range of assets in a variety of areas. It is encouraging to note that existing Council tenants are willing to enter into lease renewal negotiations with many seeing the benefits and certainty of a social landlord. There has been success in significantly reducing the number of void properties despite the current difficult economic climate. 5.13. Asset disposals have taken place following earlier policy decisions. Prudent pre - planning and investigation is crucial to ensure successful delivery. One critical element is to ensure the legal title integrity of the asset under consideration prior to proceeding with disposal. 5.14. There have been a number of approaches made from both external community and non community based organisations with encouraging signs of willingness to work in partnership with the Council in order to provide facilities and services for communal benefit such as mixed - use developments incorporating, for example, existing public conveniences. The benefits of such cooperation are anticipated to be mutual and are therefore to be encouraged. It is anticipated that there will be significant involvement in the funded Coastal Pathfinder project which is likely to present further opportunities in this regard. Project Management 5.15. A Guide to Project Management has been prepared and published in June 2009. This document provides clear guidance on project planning and generic templates to be used for all large projects across the Council. 5.16. Large projects are now reported on the Council’s performance management system (TEN) and reported to the Risk and Performance Management Board quarterly. This ensures that 33 14/02/2011 projects are on-track and in budget and any slippage is identified and actioned. Policies and Procedures 5.17. The Council reviewed its Asset Disposal Policy and adopted a new Property Disposals, Investment and Acquisitions Policy at its Cabinet meeting of 6th September 2010 (Appendix 7). 5.18. A Property Services Procedure Manual is being developed, which captures recommendations from internal audits and will provide guidance to staff and Members on how a range of activities are undertaken. This will be a live document which will be updated on a regular basis and will cover the following areas: • Procurement • Off-Street Car Parking Operation Guidelines • Estates and Valuations Procedures • Beach Hut and Chalet Procedures Risk Management 5.19. The Council has an established Performance and Risk Management Board (PRMB) who take an overarching view of the Council’s corporate risk, and report to Cabinet or the Audit Committee as appropriate. The Strategic Risk Register considers key organisational risks around reputation, finance/assets, business continuity, human resources/staffing, legal issues, leadership, potential impact and likelihood. All risks assessed are then given a ‘risk rating’ and assigned to a responsible officer, with monthly reviews undertaken by the PRMB and bi-annual reviews undertaken by Corporate Management Team and Cabinet. The Corporate Risk Register shows the items included in the Corporate Risk Register and these are the risks that could potentially impact on the Asset Management Strategy. 5.20. In relation to the Asset Management Strategy the key areas of risk are: • Central Government Funding – lack of resources to address Asset Management; • Revision to Central Government Priorities and/or Strategy in respect of Local Authorities and Asset Management • Coastal Management – there is an ambitious plan to address coastal change through the Pathfinder project which will require input from the Property Services Team; • Asset Health, Safety, Environment and Security –continuous reviews, appraisals and improvements where found necessary require significant time resources and input from Property Services; • Partnership working is important in a number of property schemes as outlined above; • Asset Management risks are reduced through a comprehensive Asset Management Strategy, but the Government agenda for shared asset use across the public services will be place continued pressure on the service. The need for an upgraded Corporate Asset Property Database is the largest risk affecting good quality asset management; 34 14/02/2011 Appendix 1 Asset Management Board Terms of Reference 1. Purpose of the Asset Management Board (AMB) The purpose of the AMB is provide a cross-departmental group within the Authority who operate at a sufficient level in order to make a positive contribution to the strategic direction of the Council’s capital investment and asset management decisions. The Board is not intended to address operational or non-strategic issues or to manage the work of the Property Services team. The AMB also has powers under the Council’s Asset Disposal Policy which states that all proposals for disposal will be considered by the AMB and the disposals programme will be reported to the AMB annually. Surplus assets identified by Services should be reported to the AMB. 2. Structure and Composition of the Board The AMB is Chaired by the Portfolio holder Cabinet Member with responsibility for resources. The Deputy Chair is the Cabinet Member for Planning Policy and Coastal issues. Minutes will be taken by the PA to the Deputy CE. The Board includes the following members: Elected Members • The Portfolio Holder Cabinet Member for Resources (Chair) • The Portfolio Holder Cabinet Member for Planning Policy and Coastal issues (Deputy Chair) • The Champion Member for Community Assets Officers • The Deputy Chief Executive/ Section 151 Officer • Strategic Director, Community • Strategic Director, Environment • Strategic Director, Information/ Monitoring Officer • The Corporate Asset Manager • The Head of Coastal Strategy Other officers may attend as required including staff from the Property Services Team, and the Communications Manager The Board will meet on a three monthly basis. Additional meetings will be called if required. Minutes will be taken and the agenda and reports will be circulated a week before the date of the meeting. 3. Objective ¾ To advise on corporate strategic decisions on the management of the Council’s assets, particularly in relation to capital projects, disposals and acquisitions; 35 14/02/2011 4. Role of the AMB The role of the AMB is outlined in the purpose and objective above and includes the following activities; ¾ Production of the Asset Management Plan and Capital Strategy To agree an Asset Management Plan and capital strategy that supports the strategic direction of the authority as articulated through its Corporate Plan and Financial Strategy. ¾ Oversee Strategic Asset Review To oversee the on-going review of assets, and set out an appropriate charging regime to ensure the best possible return on investment is achieved and provides a strategy for asset rationalization and asset transfer. ¾ Identifying new Capital Projects The Board will be responsible for the identification of new capital projects and resources and ensuring that they are in common with the Council’s overall aims and objective, before they are considered by Members. The group will provide a quality check on the submission of all capital bids. ¾ Ensure delivery of cross-cutting issues and identify key performance indicators This will enable the success of the capital programme to be measured in delivering the Council’s aims and objectives. Ultimately this will be linked to Performance Indicators incorporated within the Corporate Plan. ¾ Review of the Capital Programme The Capital Programme is updated on a quarterly cycle. Issues arising from this monitoring will be discussed by the group prior to options being presented to Management Team and the Cabinet. The Board will promote any necessary action and make recommendations to Management Team. ¾ Monitor the Improvement Plan for the Council’s Asset Management The group will be responsible for ensuring that the all capital investment decisions take full account of the Council’s Asset Portfolio and that a backlog maintenance programme is in place. The group will need to ensure that the Council meets the aspirations of the Audit Commission’s Use of Resources in respect of asset management in order to achieve excellent status. ¾ Specific roles in respect of managing the Council’s asset portfolio include; Ensuring an up-to-date asset inventory is in place and that this links to the Council’s Financial Accounts. A maintenance programme is agreed and feeds into the Financial Plan and Budget process. Prioritise and review those assets where further work is required around utilisation / disposal options, and make recommendations to Management Team. Consideration of strategic and operational risks associated with Capital Spend and Asset 36 14/02/2011 Management. 5. Individual Responsibilities The ability of group members to take a corporate view, as well as representing service areas, is vital to the success and effectiveness of the working group. ¾ To ensure the co-ordination of all information required for the existing Capital Programme to include non-financial data and performance monitoring. ¾ The ability to inform the bidding process for third party funding ¾ Provide a quality check on the bidding process for new capital schemes including; • • Ability to address cross-cutting issues Ensure capital schemes (both existing and new) take full account of corporate policies eg procurement strategy ¾ Make an initial recommendation on the allocation of the capital resources ¾ Ensure that appropriate linkages are made with the Performance Management and Risk Management Boards. 37 14/02/2011 Appendix 2.11 Schedule of Council’s Property Assets Operational Assets IFRS Category AM Category Cromer Council Offices Other Land and Buildings Administration Building Cromer Porta Cabin Offices adjacent Council Offices Other Land and Buildings Administration Building Fakenham Fakenham Connect Offices Other Land and Buildings Administration Building North Walsham Council Area Office Other Land and Buildings Administration Building Cromer Stonehill Way Ind Unit Other Land and Buildings Depot Upper Sheringham Upper Sheringham Depot Other Land and Buildings Depot (held for disposal) Cromer Runton Road Car Park Other Land and Buildings Car Park Cromer The Meadow Car Park Other Land and Buildings Car Park Cromer Cadogan Road Car Park Other Land and Buildings Car Park Fakenham Queens Road Car Park Other Land and Buildings Car Park Fakenham Bridge Street Car Park Other Land and Buildings Car Park Fakenham The Limes Car Park Other Land and Buildings Car Park Fakenham Hall Staithe Car Park Other Land and Buildings Car Park Fakenham Car Park, Highfield Road Other Land and Buildings Car Park Happisburgh Cart Gap Car Park Other Land and Buildings Car Park Happisburgh Beach Road Car Park Other Land and Buildings Car Park Holt Station Road Car Park Other Land and Buildings Car Park Holt Albert Street Car Park Other Land and Buildings Car Park Horning Swan Hotel Car Park Other Land and Buildings Car Park Mundesley Beach Road Car Park Other Land and Buildings Car Park North Walsham Mundesley Road, Car Park Other Land and Buildings Car Park North Walsham New Road Car Park Other Land and Buildings Car Park North Walsham Bank Loke Car Park Other Land and Buildings Car Park North Walsham Vicarage Street Car Park Other Land and Buildings Car Park North Walsham Midland Road Car Park Other Land and Buildings Car Park Overstrand Paul's Lane Car Park Other Land and Buildings Car Park Runton East Beach Road Car Park Other Land and Buildings Car Park Sea Palling Clink Road Car Park Other Land and Buildings Car Park Sheringham Chequers Car Park Other Land and Buildings Car Park Sheringham East Cliff Car Park Other Land and Buildings Car Park Sheringham Morris Street Car Park Other Land and Buildings Car Park Sheringham Station Road Car Park Other Land and Buildings Car Park Stalham High Street Car Park Other Land and Buildings Car Park Wells next the Sea Stearmans Yard Car Park Other Land and Buildings Car Park Wells next the Sea Staithe Street Car Park Other Land and Buildings Car Park Wells next the Sea Coach and Lorry Park, Polka Road Other Land and Buildings Car Park 11 Refer Section 2 paragraph 2.2 for qualifications regarding this asset listing. 38 14/02/2011 Weybourne Beach Lane Car Park Other Land and Buildings Car Park Other Land and Buildings Tourist Information Centre NB other car parks associated with council buildings are identified under the building or land asset. Cromer North Norfolk Information Centre Holt Holt Tourist Information Centre Other Land and Buildings Tourist Information Centre Sheringham Tourist Information Centre Other Land and Buildings Tourist Information Centre Wells next the Sea Wells Tourist Information Centre Other Land and Buildings Tourist Information Centre Bacton PC Coast Road Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Blakeney PC The Quay Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Cromer PC West Promenade Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Cromer PC Runton Road Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Cromer PC Cadogan Road Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Cromer PC North Lodge Park Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Cromer PC Melbourne Slope Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Cromer PC below Red Lion Steps Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Cromer PC Cromer Pier Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Cromer PC Meadow Car Park Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Fakenham PC Queens Road Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Fakenham PC Bridge Street Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Fakenham PC Highfield Road Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Happisburgh PC Beach Road Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Happisburgh PC Cart Gap Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Hickling PC Hickling Staithe Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Holt PC Holt Country Park Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Holt PC Albert Street Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Horning PC Swan Hotel Car Park Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Hoveton PC adjacent Broads Tourist Information Centre Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Ludham PC Womack Staithe Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Ludham PC Ludham Bridge Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Morston PC The Quay, Quay Lane Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Mundesley PC Marina Road/Beach Road Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Mundesley PC Promenade Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience North Walsham PC The Butchery Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience North Walsham PC New Road Car Park Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Overstrand PC Paul's Lane Car Park Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Potter Heigham PC Bridge Road (adjacent QD store) Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Runton East PC East Runton Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Runton West PC The Gap Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Sea Palling PC Beach Road Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Sheringham PC Station Approach Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Sheringham PC East Promenade Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Held for disposal Sheringham PC Lushers Passage Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Sheringham PC The Leas Archway Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience 39 14/02/2011 Stalham PC Chapelfield Footway Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Walcott PC Coast Road Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Walsingham PC High Street Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Wells next the Sea PC The Quay Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Wells next the Sea PC Stearmans Yard Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Wells next the Sea PC Newgate Lane Other Land and Buildings Public Convenience Fakenham Fakenham Sports and Fitness Centre Other Land and Buildings Leisure Centres North Walsham Victory Swim and Fitness Centre Other Land and Buildings Leisure Centres Sheringham Splash Leisure and Fitness Centre Other Land and Buildings Leisure Centres Cromer Cromer Lawn Tennis, Squash Courts and Clubhouse Other Land and Buildings Sports Clubs Cromer Suffield Park Bowls Club Other Land and Buildings Sports Clubs Cromer Marrams Bowls Club Other Land and Buildings Sports Clubs North Walsham Football Club, Sports Ground and Pavilion Other Land and Buildings Sports Clubs Wells next the Sea Tennis Courts & Clubhouse Other Land and Buildings Sports Clubs Cromer Cromer Museum, East Cottages Other Land and Buildings Theatres & Museums Cromer Pier Pavilion Theatre Other Land and Buildings Theatres & Museums Cromer Rocket House, Museum Other Land and Buildings Theatres & Museums Mundesley Mundesley Maritime Museum Other Land and Buildings Theatres & Museums Cromer Shelters x 25 Other Land and Buildings Shelter (covered seating) Mundesley Shelters x 3 Other Land and Buildings Shelter (covered seating) Runton East Shelter x 1 Other Land and Buildings Shelter (covered seating) Runton West Shelter x 1 Other Land and Buildings Shelter (covered seating) Sheringham Shelters x 7 blocks Other Land and Buildings Shelter (covered seating) Ashmanhaugh Ashmanhaugh No 1 Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Ashmanhaugh Ashmanhaugh No 2 Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Aylmerton Aylmerton No 2 Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Bacton Bacton Water Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Catfield Catfield Sand Holes Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Colby Colby No 1 Town Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Colby Colby Water Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Colby Banningham No. 2 Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Erpingham Erpingham No 1 Water Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Erpingham Erpingham No 2 Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Erpingham Erpingham No 3 Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Fakenham Crockley Pit Sculthorpe Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Fakenham Great Snoring Gravel Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Fakenham Hindringham No 1 Gravel Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Fakenham Hindringham No 2 Gravel Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Fakenham Hindringham No 3 Gravel Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment 40 14/02/2011 Fakenham Hindringham No 4 Gravel Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Fakenham Hindringham No 5 Water Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Fakenham Kettlestone No 2 Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Fakenham Little Snoring No 1 Gravel Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Fakenham Little Snoring No 2 Gravel Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Fakenham Sculthorpe No 2 Public Watering Place Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Fakenham Thursford No 1 Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Fakenham Thursford No 3 Gravel Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Fakenham Thursford No 4 (Water Pit) Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Fakenham West Raynham No 2 Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Field Dalling No. 2 Water Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Great Ryburgh Great Ryburgh Gravel Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Hindolveston Hindolveston No 1 Gravel Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Holt Bodham No 1 Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Holt Bodham No 5 Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Holt Bodham No 6 Marl Pit (Surveyors Allotment) Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Holt Bodham No 2 & 3 Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Holt Field Dalling No 1 Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Holt Holt No 2 Gravel Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Holt Holt No 4 Marl Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Holt Kelling No 1 Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Holt Kelling No 2 Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Holt Langham No 1 Gravel Pit Bilsey Hill Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Holt Langham No 2 Clay Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Holt Langham No 4 Water Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Holt Morston Sand & Gravel Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Holt Weybourne No 1 Marl Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Holt Weybourne Sandy Hill Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Holt Wiveton No 2 Gravel Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Holt Wiveton No 4 Clay Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Hoveton Hoveton Public Watering Place Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Ingham Ingham Calthorpe Street Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Itteringham Itteringham Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Lessingham Lessingham Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Ludham Ludham No 1 Upper Sandholes Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Ludham Ludham No 2 Lower Sandholes Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Ludham Ludham No 3 Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Melton Constable Gunthorpe (Bale) No 1 Gravel Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Melton Constable Gunthorpe (Bale) No 2 Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Melton Constable Briningham No 1 & 2 Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Melton Constable Brinton No 1 & 2 "Nine Holes" Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Melton Constable Edgefield No 3 Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Melton Constable Gunthorpe No 1 Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Melton Constable Sharrington No 1 Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment 41 14/02/2011 Melton Constable Stody Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Neatishead Neatishead Sand & Gravel Pit Lodge Common Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment North Walsham Bryants Heath Felmingham Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment North Walsham Felmingham No 1 Stow Heath Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Scottow Sco Ruston Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Scottow Scottow Water Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Sheringham Upper Sheringham No 1 Gravel Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Sheringham Upper Sheringham No 2 Marl Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Sloley Sloley Common Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Sloley Sloley Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Smallburgh Smalburgh No 3 Clay Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Stibbard Stibbard Gravel Pit Guist Bottom Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Sustead Sustead Gravel Pit Sustead Common Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Swanton Abbott Swanton Abbott No 1 Sand Pit Swanton Hill Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Swanton Abbott Swanton Abbott No 2 Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Swanton Novers No. 2 Cattle Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Tattersett Tattersett Gravel Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Walsingham Barsham No 1 Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Walsingham Barsham No 2 Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Walsingham Great Walsingham No 2 Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Walsingham Little Walsingham No 1 & 2 Surveyors Allotments Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Walsingham Little Walsingham No 3 Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Wells next the Sea Stiffkey No 1 Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Witton Witton No 1 Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Wood Norton Wood Norton No 1 Surveyors Allotment Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Wood Norton Wood Norton No 2 Gravel Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Wood Norton Wood Norton No 3 Clay Pit Other Land and Buildings Surveyors Allotment Binham Land at Priory Crescent (0.89ha) Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site Calthorpe Site off Erpingham Road (0.04ha) Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site Edgefield Allotment Land (2.32ha) Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site Erpingham Field at Eagle Road Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site Fakenham Remainder of Land from - land lying to the North of Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site Felmingham The Green at Highfields, Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site Great Ryburgh Land off Highfield Lane (0.61ha), Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site Hindringham Grass Verge at The Elms, Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site Holt Playground Site off Swans Close Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site Holt Grass Verge at Kerridge Way Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site Holt Narrow Strip of Grass Verge Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site Holt Grass Verge at Kerridge Way, adj Phone Exchange & CP Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site Ingworth Land adjacent to No 1 Banningham Road (0.15ha) Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site Itteringham Land South of 4 Wolterton Road (0.19ha), Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site 42 14/02/2011 Knapton Land off Hall Lane/School Close (0.74ha), Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site Little Snoring Land off The Croft, Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site Ludham Land r/o Nos 1-7 The Crescent, Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site Matlaske Land on the North side of Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site Mundesley Site of Former Greenhouse Northfield House Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site North Walsham Land off Burton Avenue (0.29ha), Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site North Walsham Land off Bears Road Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site North Walsham Land at Cornish Avenue (0.72ha), Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site North Walsham Informal Parking/Allotment Area Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site North Walsham Land at Brick Kiln Lane Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site Roughton Site off Brownsfield Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site Sheringham Land at Weston Terrace (0.33ha) Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site Skeyton Land at Coronation Corner Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site Stiffkey Site off Camping Hill (0.08ha), Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site Sutton Land at Elmhurst Avenue, Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site Swanton Novers Land at The Croft, Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site Wells next the Sea Remainder of Land from - the South Side of Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site West Beckham Playground Site Other Land and Buildings Retained Housing Site Non-Operational Assets IFRS Category Catfield Industrial Starter Units at Catfield Fakenham JW Automarine, Industrial Unit North Walsham Industrial Starter Units at North Walsham Cromer Julio's Café Cromer Booking Office and Footprints Gift Shop Cromer Tides Restaurant Cromer Collectors Cabin Cromer Runton Road Café, Blue Sky Café Cromer Children's Amusements (Fair Ground site) Cromer Westcliffe Café and Shop Cromer Tea Rooms (& Public Shelter) Cromer Rocket House Restaurant Cromer Seafood Kiosk site Cromer Seafood Stall Site Cromer Amusement Arcade Mundesley Beach Café and Shop Sheringham West Promenade Café Cromer Cromer Beach Hut sites x 87 AM Category Investment Property Industrial Unit Investment Property Industrial Unit Investment Property Industrial Unit Investment Property Retail Outlet Investment Property Retail Outlet Investment Property Retail Outlet Investment Property Retail Outlet Investment Property Retail Outlet Investment Property Retail Outlet Investment Property Retail Outlet Investment Property Retail Outlet Investment Property Retail Outlet Investment Property Retail Outlet Investment Property Retail Outlet Investment Property Retail Outlet Investment Property Retail Outlet Investment Property Retail Outlet Investment Property Beach Hut Site 43 14/02/2011 Cromer Cromer Beach Chalets x 103 Mundesley Mundesley Beach Hut sites x 60 Overstrand Overstrand Beach Hut Sites x 19 Sheringham Sheringham Beach Hut sites x 78 Sheringham Sheringham Beach Chalets x 29 Pudding Norton Parklands Caravan Site, 37 sites Thursford Land West Side of Parr Land, Investment Property North Walsham Un surfaced parking area Hall Lane Investment Property Fakenham Land, part sold, Norwich Road Investment Property Holt DSU Depot Investment Property Wells next the Sea Maltings Investment Property Sheringham Odd fellows Hall, Lifeboat Plain Investment Property Sheringham Little Theatre Investment Property Wells next the Sea The Sackhouse Investment Property North Walsham The Oaks Investment Property Cromer Evington Lawns & Boating Lake Investment Property Cromer Marrams Bowling Green Investment Property North Walsham Sports Ground & Pavillion (?) Investment Property Sheringham Beeston Putting Green Investment Property Investment Property Beach Chalets Investment Property Beach Hut Site Investment Property Beach Hut Site Investment Property Beach Hut Site Investment Property Beach Chalets Investment Property Residential Amenity Area Car Park Amenity Area Depot Community Centre* Other Building* Theatres & Museums Other Building Other Building Sports & Recreation Area Sports Clubs Sports Clubs Sports & Recreation Area VEHICLES Green Waste & Recycling - Vehicles Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Leisure Vehicle (Mobile Gym) Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Garden Bin Vehicle Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Splash Leisure Pool, Sheringham - Plant Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment North Walsham Pool - Plant Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Fakenham Sports & Fitness Centre - Plant Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Cromer Office - Boiler Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Office Furniture - Office Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Cromer Office Lighting Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Fakenham CCTV Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Sun Computer Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Env Health System - Hardware Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment MECHANICAL PLANT FIXTURES & FITTINGS OTHER EQUIPMENT 44 14/02/2011 Sun Computer (Cfacs) Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment CCTV - Control Room Equipment, Fakenham Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Sun Computer (Reach-Out) Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Leisure Pool, Sheringham Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Implementing Electronic Govt Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Green Waste & Recycling - Bins (Green) Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Green Waste & Recycling - Bins (Brown) Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Benefits System Replacement Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Air Quality Monitoring Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment PDG - EDM Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment PDG - Access System Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Cromer Office Smoking Shelter Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Waste Management & Environmental Health System Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment BPR EDM Project Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment PC Replacement Fund Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Virtual Business Support (Laptops) Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment CCTV - New Hardware Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Seafront Signage Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Overstrand Railings Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Cromer Pier Handrails Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Car Park Fencing Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Playground Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Business Continuity Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Probass (Plantech Software) Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Infrastructure Assets Coast Protection Pedestrian Passage Under Railway, North Walsham Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Site of 64 High Street, Wells next the Sea Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Land for Boat Storage, East Quay, Wells next the Sea Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Site for Bus Shelter, Norwich Road, Cromer Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Land adjoining East of The Gangway, Cromer Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Admiralty Slipway & Beach, West End, Sheringham Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Area of Scrub Land, Howards Hill, Cromer Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Site of Community Centre, New Road, North Walsham Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Public Open Space , Gt Eastern Way/ The Drift, Fakenham Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Public Open Space, Fakenham, Wigg Road Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Amenity Land, Lynfield Road, North Walsham Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Recreation Ground, Weybourne Road, Sheringham Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Lawn Tennis Club Grounds, Norwich Road, Cromer Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces INFRASTRUCTURE ASSETS Coast Protection/Coastal Defences COMMUNITY ASSETS Parks and Open Spaces 45 14/02/2011 Rocket House Gardens, East Promenade, Cromer Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Picnic Area, Holway Road, Sheringham Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces The Leas, The Esplanade, Sheringham Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Site of Old Lifeboat Shed, West Cliff, Sheringham Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Amenity Land, Le Grice Cres / Elinor & Sampson Rd, N. Walsham Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Amenity Land, Off Smiths Lane, Fakenham Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Foreshore Land, East of Water Lane, West Runton Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Land Facing Cliff Slope, Overstrand (Clifftop & Gangway) Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Cliff Top & Slopes (Part Cliff Slopes, Foreshore, Overstrand) Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Watch House Green and Mundesley Museum, Mundesley Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Tennis Court & Clubhouse, Theatre Street, Wells next the Sea Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Fearns Field, Suffield Park, Cromer Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces 40 Church Street, Shelter & Garden, Cromer (Cromer Museum) Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Land in Happy Valley, Happy Valley, Cromer Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Cliff Falls, Near Old Watch House, Cromer Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Marrams Bowling Green, Runton Road, Cromer Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Clifftop Land, West End, Runton Road, Cromer Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Land & Wall, Drs Steps Path, Putting Green, North Lodge Park Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces North Lodge Park, Overstrand Road, Cromer Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Strip of Beach, West Promenade, Cromer Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces St Nicholas Gardens and War Memorial, Sheringham Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Land, End of Cliff Road, Sheringham Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Cliff Slopes, East of The Leas, Foreshore, Sheringham Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Franklin Hill, Off Hooks Hill Road, Sheringham Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Land, Beeston Hill, Sheringham Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Land, Cliff Edge, Mundesley, Back of Hotel Continental Car Park Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Fishermans Green, Cliff Road, Overstrand Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Beach & Groyne (Above HWMOT), Foreshore, Sheringham Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Cliff Slope & Footpath, Overstrand (Cliff Slopes Nr Sea Marge) Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces The Mo (Full Prom Length Lighting), Promenade, Sheringham Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Warren Woods, The Warren, Cromer Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Links Wood, Overstrand Road, Cromer Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Burnt Hills Wood, Roughton Road, Cromer Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Holt Country Park, Norwich Road, Holt Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Pretty Corner Woods, Upper Sheringham Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Community Assets Cromer Pier – Structure & Deck Woodlands Playgrounds Playground, Cromer Road, Sheringham Pier Cromer Pier – Structure & Deck (Includes Legs) 46 14/02/2011 ASSETS UNDER CONSTRUCTION 8510 - Stalham Sports Hall Assets Under Construction Various Sites 8512 - Fakenham Community Centre (Complete) Assets Under Construction Various Sites 8515 - Pier Works (Phase 1) Assets Under Construction Various Sites 8521 - Pier Works (Phase 2) Assets Under Construction Various Sites 8540 - Mundesley Toilet & Env Works (Complete) Assets Under Construction Various Sites 8541 - North Norfolk Information Centre (Complete) Assets Under Construction Various Sites 8543 - Sea Palling Toilets (Complete) Assets Under Construction Various Sites 8550 - Fakenham Industrial Units (Complete) Assets Under Construction Various Sites 8550 - Fakenham Employment Land (Sold) Assets Under Construction Various Sites 8224 - Fakenham Connect Fire Escape (Complete) Assets Under Construction Various Sites 8231 - Public Conv Upgrade Mundesley Promenade (Complete Assets Under Construction Various Sites 8232 - Sheringham Promenade Lighting (Complete) Assets Under Construction Various Sites 8543 - Public Conv Upgarde Sea Palling (Phase 2) (Complete) Assets Under Construction Various Sites 8285 - Gypsy & Travellers Site Cromer (Complete) Assets Under Construction Various Sites 8286- Gypsy & Travellers Site Fakenham (Complete) Assets Under Construction Various Sites 8518 - North Norfolk Enterprise Hub & Innovation Centre Assets Under Construction Various Sites Fakenham Factory Extension (New) Assets Under Construction Various Sites 8542 - Public Convenience Improvements (Complete) Assets Under Construction Various Sites 8562 - Public Conv Upgrade Albert Street Holt (Complete) Assets Under Construction Various Sites Assets Held for Disposal Former HRA Sites Assets Held for Disposal Former HRA Sites Assets Held for Disposal Former HRA Sites Assets Held for Disposal Former HRA Sites Assets Held for Disposal Former HRA Sites Assets Held for Disposal Employment Land at Assets Held for Disposal Other Sites Assets Held for Disposal Other Sites Assets Held for Disposal Other Sites Assets Held for Disposal Other Sites Allotment Land, Off Norwich / Rectory Road, Edgefield Assets Held for Disposal Former HRA Sites Informal Parking / Allotment Area Land, Rectory Road, Edingthorpe Assets Held for Disposal Former HRA Sites SURPLUS ASSETS HELD FOR DISPOSAL Land at Weston Terrace, Sheringham (0.33ha) Land at Priory Crescent, Binham (0.89ha) Land, Off Highfield Lane, Great Ryburgh (0.61ha) Land at Brick Kiln Lane / Sadlers Way, North Walsham (Part Sold 06/07) Land at Cornish Avenue, Trunch, North Walsham (0.72ha) Employment Land at Wymans Way, Fakenham (Majority Sold 06/07) Harbour Commissioners Office/ Museum, Wells next the Sea (Sold 07/08) Quay at Wells next the Sea PC, Church Street, Holt NOW SOLD PC, Beach Road, Happisburgh NOW DEMOLISHED NB the categories of ~” assets under construction” and “assets held for disposal” relate to the NNDC published accounts and refer to April 2010. It should be made clear that there are no plans to dispose of Red Lion Steps, Newgate Lane PCs and Council Yard at North Walsham. Under the IFRS the definition of those assets held for disposal will relate only to those actively being marketed and likely to be disposed of within one year. Consequently this list will be amended in 2011. 47 14/02/2011 Appendix 3.12 Property Related Assets OPERATIONAL ASSETS: Other Land & Buildings Administrative Buildings Depots Car Parks Public Conveniences Tourist Information Centres Leisure Centres Other Operational Land & Buildings Total Infrastructure Assets Coast Protection Total Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Vehicles, Plant & Equipment Total Community Assets Parks & Open Spaces Cromer Pier - Structure & Deck Total NON-OPERATIONAL ASSETS Investment Properties Retail outlets Fakenham Industrial Estate Community Centre, Wells Old Oddfellows Hall, Sheringham Little Theatre, Sheringham Sackhouse, Wells Museum, Cromer Beach Hut Sites Other Sites Total Assets Under Construction Various Sites Total Assets Held For Disposal Employment Land at Fakenham Former HRA Sites Other Sites Total TOTAL TANGIBLE FIXED ASSETS 12 Net book value as at 31/03/10 3,544,612 53,074 12,045,662 1,475,217 536,582 9,079,200 2,992,498 29,726,844 3,299,799 3,299,799 3,298,301 3,298,301 196,164 263,082 459,246 295,000 466,000 2,000 1 24,000 79,000 1 52,000 653,128 1,571,130 331,424 331,424 0 2,252,500 95,514 2,348,014 41,034,758 Refer Section 2 paragraph 2.2 for qualifications regarding this asset listing 48 14/02/2011 APPENDIX 413 Summary 5-Year Building Maintenance Plan Cost Centre Property Date of Condition Survey Current Building Score Service Contracts Yearly Budget Totals 2010/2011 2011/2012 2012/2013 2013/2014 2014/2015 2010/2011 Total Planned (2011/12 + Service Contracts 2010/11) 2010-2011 R&M Budget Administration Offices 2620 Council Main Office, Holt Road Nov 2006 B £1,750 £13,750 £3,000 £7,500 £0 £29,255 £43,005 £36,787 2623 Fakenham Connect Dec 2006 B £2,500 £2,500 £5,000 £7,500 £5,000 £7,201 £9,701 £10,151 2626 North Walsham Main Offices Dec 2010 B £2,007 £3,350 £17,100 £16,350 £20,000 £1,643 2626 North Walsham Barn & Yard Dec 2010 C £0 £9,500 £0 £1,000 £0 £0 £14,493 £9,000 £14,700 £33,945 £19,600 £30,343 Amenity and Promenade 3010 & 3011 3029 & 3012 13 Lighting including amenity lights £14,700 Foreshore Furniture & Fittings incl Prom Management Shelter at Marrams, Runton Road Sept 2009 C £1,500 £1,500 £3,000 £700 £0 Anglian Water Shelter, West-End Prom Mar 2010 B £0 £200 £0 £100 £0 Prom Shelter, Melbourne Slope Mar 2010 B £0 £600 £250 £50 £0 Thatched Shelter, North Lodge Park Mar 2010 C £1,500 £1,250 £0 £0 £0 Shelter, North Lodge Park Sept 2009 C £2,050 £2,500 £1,500 £600 £500 Pagoda Shelter, North Lodge Park Mar 2010 B £0 £800 £0 £800 £0 Old Bandstand, North Lodge Park Mar 2010 B £250 £2,000 £0 £500 £0 Bowls Green Shelter, North Lodge Park Mar 2010 C £500 £1,500 £0 £500 £500 Refer to Section 2 paragraphs 2.13 to 2.21 for full description and details. 49 14/02/2011 Shelter East of the Green, Mundesley Mar 2010 B £500 £0 £1,500 £0 £500 Small Shelter West the Green, Mundesley Mar 2010 D £750 £0 £0 £0 £0 Large Shelter West the Green Mundesley Mar 2010 C £0 £1,000 £0 £750 £500 East Runton Shelter, East Runton Jan 2010 D £2,750 £2,750 £1,250 £500 £250 West Runton Shelter, West Runton Jan 2010 C £3,250 £0 £500 £0 £500 Upper Leas Shelter, Sheringham Jan 2010 B £1,000 £1,500 £1,850 £600 £0 Leas Shelters, Sheringham Jan 2010 A £0 £500 £0 £0 £500 Miscellaneous Sites Jan 2010 B £0 £3,500 £0 £0 £0 Arts and Museums 3070 Little Theatre Sheringham £155 £155 £210 Beach Huts and Chalets 3020 Beach Chalets Mar 2009 C £0 £14,550 £14,550 £14,550 £14,550 £14,550 £23,580 3021 Beach Hut Sites Mar 2009 A £750 £2,500 £2,500 £2,800 £2,200 £2,500 £3,410 £2,608 £46,100 Car Parks 2001 All Car Parks Generally 2001 Albert Street, Holt £2,500 £108 Community Centres 3022 Fakenham Community Centre Jan 2007 C £50 £550 £50 £50 £50 £656 £1,206 £6,024 Nov 2006 C £0 £4,750 £4,250 £5,250 £2,250 £2,631 £7,381 £17,090 B £50 £0 £750 £750 £750 £1,072 £7,158 £4,916 Cromer Pier 3140 Pavilion Theatre, Box Office, Cromer Pier Storage Depots 2622 Stonehill Way, Cromer 2622 Blowlands Lane, Upper Sheringham Dec 2006 D £0 £5,500 £0 £0 £0 £0 2622 Unit 17 Cornish Way, North Walsham Dec 2009 B £1,850 £350 £600 £100 £100 £236 50 14/02/2011 2000 Grove Lane, Holt B £0 Industrial Estates 2013 Cornish Way Units (ex Unit 17) Nov 2006 B £0 £3,000 £4,750 £750 £750 £0 £3,000 £2,952 2010 Catfield Industrial Estate Nov 2006 B £0 £2,000 £1,750 £500 £750 £0 £2,000 £984 £125 £44,560 £55,590 Public Conveniences 3150 All Public Conveniences Generally Bacton, Coast Road Aug 2010 A £50 £100 £200 £350 £200 £36 Blakeney, The Quay Aug 2010 A £150 £250 £50 £500 £50 £36 Cromer, Bond Street SOLD Cromer, Cadogan Road Mar 2010 B £100 £1,200 £500 £1,000 £2,600 £36 Cromer, Melbourne Slope May 2010 C £50 £1,250 £0 £750 £2,350 £36 Cromer, North Lodge Park May 2010 B £200 £200 £1,600 £2,250 £1,000 £36 Cromer, NNIC Public Toilets Sept 2010 B £50 £400 £200 £100 £0 £36 Cromer, Pier Jul 2010 B £2,100 £1,350 £2,500 £1,300 £100 £36 Cromer, Red Lion Steps CLOSED Cromer, Rocket House Sept 2010 B £6,100 £600 £2,000 £0 £500 £36 Cromer, Runton Road Mar 2010 B £100 £0 £0 £0 £1,500 £36 Cromer, West End Promenade May 2010 B £100 £950 £1,750 £500 £0 £36 Fakenham, Bridge Street Aug 2010 B £100 £500 £550 £800 £1,150 £36 Fakenham, Highfields May 2010 B £200 £650 £500 £1,000 £2,000 £36 Fakenham, Queens Road Aug 2010 B £100 £400 £0 £250 £1,500 £36 Happisburgh, Cart Gap Apr 2010 B £850 £2,850 £400 £0 £3,500 £155 Hickling, The Staithe Apr 2010 B £50 £250 £1,250 £750 £2,000 £0 Holt, Albert Street Sept 2010 B £6,550 £250 £0 £1,500 £0 £36 Holt, Church Street SOLD Holt, Country Park Sept 2010 B £250 £0 £0 £0 £1,000 £36 Horning, Swan Car Park Apr 2010 B £50 £350 £1,500 £500 £2,500 £36 51 14/02/2011 Hoveton, Station Road Apr 2010 B £200 £1,000 £1,500 £0 £2,500 £36 Ludham, The Bridge Apr 2010 B £50 £250 £1,750 £500 £2,500 £36 Ludham, Womack Staithe Apr 2010 C £100 £1,800 £6,000 £1,250 £2,500 £36 Morston, The Quay Apr 2010 B £250 £1,750 £750 £2,000 £0 £36 Mundesley, Marina Road Aug 2010 B £500 £500 £0 £250 £1,500 £36 Mundesley, The Promenade Aug 2010 B £700 £800 £0 £0 £1,500 £1,629 North Walsham, Market Place May 2010 B £150 £1,900 £750 £1,250 £1,250 £36 North Walsham, New Road Aug 2010 B £250 £400 £0 £0 £1,500 £36 Overstarnd, Pauls Lane Mar 2010 B £300 £950 £800 £500 £2,000 £36 Overstrand, Temporary Prom N/A N/A Potter Heigham, The Bridge May 2010 C £1,800 £1,550 £1,250 £0 £1,250 £36 Runton - East Runton Apr 2010 B £500 £1,750 £0 £500 £2,000 £36 Runton - West Runton Apr 2010 C £300 £1,600 £0 £0 £0 £36 Sea Palling, Beach Road Aug 2010 B £350 £300 £0 £1,500 £0 £155 Sheringham, Lushers Passage May 2010 B £650 £1,250 £750 £500 £1,250 £36 N/A N/A £0 £500 £0 £0 £0 £0 Sheringham, The Lees Sept 2010 B £150 £250 £0 £0 £1,500 £36 Sheringham, Station Approach Sept 2010 B £200 £6,250 £0 £1,500 £250 £36 Stalham, High Street Apr 2010 B £950 £750 £1,500 £0 £3,100 £36 Walcott, Coast Road Apr 2010 B £100 £1,500 £0 £1,500 £0 £36 Walsingham, High Street Sept 2010 B £150 £250 £1,500 £0 £500 £36 Wells, Newgate Lane Apr 2010 B £150 £1,600 £500 £0 £1,250 £36 Wells, The Quay, Beach Road Apr 2010 B £750 £1,000 £1,500 £500 £4,250 £36 Wells, Stearmans Yard Apr 2010 B £200 £1,750 £500 £0 £1,250 £36 £0 Sheringham, Temporary East Promenade £0 Sports and Leisure 3042 Victory Pool, North Walsham Nov 2006 B £4,750 £10,100 £1,000 £1,500 £1,500 £10,100 £5,423 3035 Fakenham Gym, Fakenham Oct 2006 B £0 £1,000 £11,250 £0 £0 £1,000 £4,500 3041 Splash, Sheringham Oct 2006 B £3,250 £13,000 £17,000 £13,000 £1,000 £13,000 £15,000 52 14/02/2011 North Walsham Sports Centre £1,231 £1,231 Estates (Other Lettings) 3024 The Oaks, North Walsham Nov 2006 B £0 £750 £750 £0 £0 3024 Seaview Playgroup Feb 2007 D £50 £50 £50 £50 3024 Suffield Park Bowls Club £155 3024 Blue Danube Tea Rooms £36 3024 Odd Fellows Hall £36 3024 Sheringham West Prom Café £36 2004 2003 Maltings Sackhouse 3025 Rocket House £1,063 £4,670 £155 £155 £155 £155 £0 £700 £9,240 B £1,150 £4,600 £1,750 £1,250 £1,750 £10,622 £15,222 Lockerbie Flats, Sheringham D £1,750 £650 £0 £0 £0 £1,447 £2,097 Parklands, Pudding Norton C £0 £2,900 £2,600 £2,250 £0 £790 £3,690 £50 £50 £150 £250 £2,000 £1,500 £4,500 £1,500 £0 £0 £9,412 £200 Residential 2040 £13,710 Tourist Information Centres (Customer Services) North Norfolk Information Centre Sheringham TIC Oct 2006 B B Holt TIC Sept 2006 B £250 £250 £100 £0 £2,000 £236 Wells TIC Oct 2006 B £50 £500 £1,500 £2,000 £0 £155 53 14/02/2011 APPENDIX 5 Disposal, Investment and Acquisition Policy This policy sets out the District Council’s policies for the disposal, investment in and acquisition of land and property. The policy is structured as follows: 1. Corporate context 2. Definitions 3. Decision making and delegation 4. Implementation – procedures and guidance on disposal, investment or acquisition of assets. 1. Corporate Context 1.1. North Norfolk District Council holds property in order to carry out its functions, meet its corporate objectives and to deliver services. The policy should be considered alongside the Asset Management Plan and the Capital Strategy which together set the overall framework within which the Council manages its asset portfolio. The property portfolio is held in accordance with the Corporate Asset Management Plan the aims of which are: To ensure that assets are fit for purpose and provide value for money by being managed in an efficient, effective, economic and sustainable manner; and To develop a co-ordinated approach to asset management that links with the corporate objectives of the Council and North Norfolk Sustainable Community Strategy 1.2. The Council should only hold property to support the achievement of the Council’s goals and objectives set out in the Corporate Plan. Consequently property will be held in one of the following classes: Operational Property: To accommodate service delivery To support direct service provision, e.g. economic regeneration or countryside and leisure property Non-operational Property 1.3. To enable the delivery of services by partner organisations or as part of a partnership programme As an investment which makes a sustainable financial return to support service delivery or the achievement of the Council’s goals and objectives As community property in support of the Council’s goals and objectives Where it offers prospects of significant future capital appreciation either which means it is more economically advantageous to hold the property for disposal or rationalisation at a later date. The Council will consequently seek to dispose of property which: Can no longer accommodate the delivery of services in an economically, environmentally or culturally sustainable fashion, or 54 14/02/2011 1.4. Constitutes a significant future risk to the Council, e.g. through accrued liabilities, Is no longer required for delivery of a partnership programme, or, Offers no real potential for long term realisable capital appreciation, and/or The disposal would offer social, economic or community benefits via a transfer to a Third Sector Organisation. The Council will seek to invest in improvements to property where this satisfies the objectives in paragraph 1.2. above, and where: Investment will enable the property to accommodate or deliver services in an economically and environmentally sustainable fashion and Investment in the property offers the optimum solution in terms of value for money and service delivery or Expenditure will improve the performance of the property as an investment or assist in enhancing the proceeds from a future sale 1.5. The Council will seek to acquire property where this satisfies the objectives outlined above, and where: There is no alternative property readily available within the Council or a partner agency’s portfolio; or Acquisition offers a more advantageous solution than conversion or refurbishment of property already held within the portfolio; or The property is to be acquired as part of a partnership programme 1.6. All proposals for retention, disposal, investment and acquisition of property assets should be submitted for initial consideration to: The Asset Management Board, then to; Any appropriate partnership executive function where such proposals form part of a partnership programme, and comply with the Council’s constitution and financial contracts procedures and standing orders. 2 Definitions - Acquisition, Disposal and Investment 2.1 The legal basis for property management is set out in Appendix 1. Local Government Act 1972 provides guidance on the definition of disposal namely that it may consist of: a) A freehold transfer; or b) A grant of a lease; or c) The assignment of a lease d) The grant of an easement, 2.2 These definitions could similarly be applied to define an acquisition of property. 2.3 However, for the purposes of this policy disposal and acquisitions are defined as: a) A freehold transfer; or 55 14/02/2011 b) The grant or taking of a lease of any term c) The disposal or acquisition by assignment of a lease of any term d) The disposal, creation or acquisition of any other interest or contract in land 2.4 For the purposes of this policy, investment is defined as items included in the capital programme, which include all projects over £10,000. More minor investment may also take place as part of the repairs and maintenance revenue budgets. 2.5 It is not necessary to outline a detailed policy in relation to the acquisition and disposal of minor interests in land such as wayleaves or easements. In general such matters are standard operational matters and will not be considered by the Asset Management Board except where they are part of a wider property transaction. 3 Decision Making and Delegated Authority 3.1 Proposals for property disposal, acquisition or investment will be submitted to the Asset Management Board, for preliminary consideration and, if the Board considers the proposal is within the terms of this policy, the Board will either make a recommendation to Cabinet or make a decision under delegated powers. 3.2 No acquisition, disposal or investment shall be progressed unless the proposal fully accords with the Council’s Financial Standing orders and, where appropriate, the Council’s Contracts Code of Practice. It will also be necessary that any proposed disposal at an undervalue shall comply with the consent provisions set out in s123(2) LGA 1972 and any exceptional expenditure not otherwise justified shall be within the Council’s statutory powers under either s137 LGA 1972 or s2 LGA 2000. Further details of key issues to be included in any proposal are set out in Section 4 below. Where the proposal involves expenditure or receipts over £50,000 or a disposal at less than best consideration the matter must be passed to Cabinet for decision. Once the proposal has been approved, the transaction will be managed by Property Services reporting to the Asset Management Board as appropriate. Where the proposal involves expenditure or receipts of between £10,000 and £50,000 and is not a disposal at best consideration, the matter will be reported to Cabinet. Where the proposal involves expenditure or receipts of between £10,000 and £50,000 and is a disposal at best consideration the decision can be taken under delegated authority by a Chief Officer in consultation with the Corporate Asset Manager, S151 Officer and Monitoring Officer Where the proposal involves expenditure or receipts of £10,000 or less and is not a disposal at less than best consideration, the matter may, if it accords with relevant Council plans and strategic policies, be authorised under delegated powers by a Chief Officer in consultation with the Corporate Asset Manager 3.3 Notwithstanding the above, where Heads of Terms agreed for a transaction are significantly different from the initial proposal or where the consideration falls outside budgetary parameters, the matter should be referred back to the Cabinet (or Chief 56 14/02/2011 Officer/Corporate Asset Manager where the decision was taken under delegated authority). 4 Implementation Identifying Assets for Disposal 4.1 Assets may be identified as potentially surplus by: Service departments in the course of normal business and through service business planning; or Property Services and Service Departments during the Asset Management Planning process and strategy formulation. 4.2 Where an asset is identified as potentially surplus, Property Services will notify the Asset Management Board providing brief details of the accommodation, tenure and condition sufficient to enable other service departments to consider their utility. The Asset Management Board will maintain a database of surplus assets on the Council’s intranet and make this available to partner organisations where appropriate. 4.3 Where a Service Department identifies a potentially surplus asset, this should be notified to the Asset Management Board to enable this interest to be considered alongside other options. 4.4 The Corporate Asset Manager will report to the Asset Management Board setting out proposals for the disposal (or retention) of the asset in sufficient detail to enable the Asset Management Board to make a decision on the proposal. Proposals should include: A brief description of the property and its condition, including any significant accrued 4.5 liabilities and statutory or regulatory failings The reason for its becoming potentially surplus A commentary on potential alternative use, including reference to the current Local Planning Authority policies and opinion Consideration of whether the land may be suitable for use as garden plots, leased to a town or parish council A commentary on title (provided by Legal Services) together with any impact this may have on value or marketability An assessment of Market Value both for Existing Use and alternative development A summary of the options for future management, including interest expressed by other services or partner organisations A recommendation for disposal or retention with financial case Where the proposal recommends disposal the report should also include: A recommendation on the approach to alternative development where this is appropriate A recommendation on whether there would be sufficient merit to warrant applying for planning permission before disposal 57 14/02/2011 A recommendation of the method of disposal and anticipated time taken to dispose together with any significant holding costs A summary of the anticipated Heads of Terms for disposal including parameters of value for delegated authority to operate 4.6 Where the proposal recommends disposal at less than best consideration this should be supported by a detailed business case identifying: The corporate objectives supported by the proposed disposal The rationale for disposal at less than best consideration; and The shortfall against best consideration and the consequential value foregone 4.7 Where the proposal recommends retention for long-term investment or disposal at a later date, e.g. where development potential is not yet realisable but will be available in the foreseeable future, the report should also include: An analysis of investment return or long term capital appreciation A summary of holding costs A plan for securing capital appreciation including relevant planning and land assembly considerations An indicative timetable to disposal where relevant Identifying Assets for Acquisition 4.8 Potential property requirements may be identified in a number of ways including: By services in the course of normal business By Property Services and Service Departments during the Asset Management Planning process By partnership programme managers By the Asset Management Board 4.9 Once a property requirement has been identified this should be notified to the Asset Management Board with a basic specification to enable this requirement to be considered against surplus properties and the existing portfolio. 4.10 The Corporate Asset Manager will then refine the specification with the Service Department/Partner and undertake searches both within the Council’s portfolio and on the open market. 4.11 The Corporate Asset Manager will report to the Cabinet in sufficient detail to enable the Cabinet to make a decision on the proposal, Proposals should include: A summary of the specification and the key characteristics of suitable property A brief explanation of the new requirement A report on suitable properties within the portfolio if any A report on the market search and a shortlist of suitable properties 58 14/02/2011 4.12 Cabinet approval should be sufficiently detailed and robust: To allow the Council to compete in the open market enabling those with delegated authority to make decisions at speed where required. To set clear parameters outside of which further reference to Cabinet is required To enable democratic oversight without compromising the Council’s response to commercial situations Identifying Investment Requirements 4.13 The Asset Management Plan is prepared each Autumn and any investment identified is put forward through the capital programme bidding process which takes place in Autumn each year. Both the Asset Management Plan and the capital strategy are agreed together, usually in January of each year as part of the budget approval process. Methods of Disposal and Acquisition 4.14 North Norfolk District Council will select the method of disposal best suited to maximising the corporate objectives. This may include, but not be limited to the following: 4.15 Auction Private treaty Private treaty with a special purchaser/private negotiation Private treaty followed by either a closed formal or informal tender However, sale by private negotiation will only normally be appropriate where there is a special purchaser, who might be a tenant or adjoining owner and where: The special purchaser will outbid the market The special purchaser will offer social, environmental or economic benefits that would not be attained through open competition 4.16 Where properties are offered for sale by private negotiation the Council should ensure that: Appropriate legal advice has been obtained to ensure that the proposed arrangement satisfies the Council’s responsibilities for financial prudence A third party valuer has been retained: To provide an initial valuation of the property To conduct negotiations on the Council’s behalf To confirm recommendations as to the proposed disposal Heads of Terms and Final Approval 4.17 Once Heads of Terms have been concluded for any transaction the Corporate Asset Manager should report to the relevant delegated authority: Confirming detailed Heads of Terms which have been agreed between the parties Reporting any departures from the indicative Heads of Terms anticipated in the initial proposal Confirming the recommendation to proceed and the anticipated timetable 59 14/02/2011 4.18 Where the negotiated terms are significantly different from those originally reported the matter should be referred back to Cabinet for approval. Transfer of Assets to Third Sector Organisations 4.19 As identified in the Quirk Review14 in 2007, there are occasions when transfer of assets from Councils to Third Sector Organisations can draw down funding and bring benefits to local communities in terms of local management arrangements and community empowerment. 4.20 In such circumstances the Council will ensure: That any disposal is made subject to long term reservations that protect the Council’s interests and requirements to create or retain easements That where disposal is by grant of long lease rather than freehold sale that the Council do not inadvertently retain long term liabilities with the property That the terms of the disposal do not compromise the recipient organisation’s ability to secure grant aid or other support for operating the property That the recipient organisation has sufficient resources to sustain the property That a business case supports the decision 4.21 4.22 As set out in Section 4.6 above any proposal for transfer of assets at less than best consideration should be supported by a detailed business case. Items to be included in a business case include: • Options Appraisal • Revenue budget/ viable business plan • Funding mechanisms • Management arrangements • Timescales and Action Plan Where the Council continues to hold assets for use by Third Sector Organisation it may be asked to provide this accommodation at less than market rent or in some cases at uneconomic rents. (Appendix to Appendix 5 document) Legal Powers for Property Disposal and Acquisition DISPOSAL 1. Local authorities can only dispose of property in accordance with statutory powers. 14 http://www.communities.gov.uk/publications/communities/makingassetswork 60 14/02/2011 2. For non-housing land, the main powers are provided by section 123 (principal councils) and 127 (parish and community councils) Local Government Act 1972 which sections provide powers to principal councils and parish/community councils respectively. 3. Under section 123, the Council has powers to dispose of land in any manner they wish, which means sale of their freehold interest, granting a lease or assigning any unexpired term on a lease, and the granting of easements. 4. One constraint is that a disposal must be for the best consideration reasonably obtainable. 5. Another constraint relates to the sale of public open space. A procedure of advertisement and consideration of any objections applies to the disposal of public open space. 6. Non-housing land may be disposed of for the purpose of building houses. 7. Land held for the housing purposes may be disposed of under section 32 of the Housing Act 1985 with the Secretary of State’s consent. In many cases the Secretary of State’s consent is provided generally under the General Housing Consents 2005 (referred to below). 8. It is government policy that local authorities and other public bodies should dispose of surplus land wherever possible. Generally, it is expected that land should be sold for the best consideration reasonably obtainable. 9. The “best consideration reasonably obtainable” is the market value of the property plus “special value”. This may also take into account the capital value of any voluntary conditions imposed by the vendor where appropriate. The value of voluntary conditions imposed by the vendor as a term of the disposal, or under an agreement linked to the disposal, should be taken into account in the assessment of best consideration where they produce a direct or indirect benefit to the vendor that can be quantified in monetary terms. 10. Such vendors' conditions could include, for example, the retention of an easement over the land, a pre-emption clause allowing the vendor to repurchase on specified terms if the purchaser decides to sell, or covenants on the use of the land that benefit other land in the vendor's ownership. 11. Consideration is not however, limited to the money purchase price, but may include an element in the transaction which has a quantifiable commercial or monetary worth (to the vendor authority). It must be stressed that non-monetary considerations should be quantifiable and reportable. 12. The proposed disposal, or an agreement linked with it, may give rise to non-property benefits to the authority. For example, these might include operational savings or income generated as a result of the transaction where the authority has an associated statutory duty. The monetary value of these benefits to the authority should be included in the value of voluntary conditions. 13. Local authorities’ powers have been made more flexible by the issuing of General Consents by the Department of Communities & Local Government for the disposal of housing and non-housing land. General Consents avoid the need for specific permission from the ODPM for an individual project. 14. For housing land, the General Housing Consents 2005 are a number of different consents relating to disposals to individuals but also RSLs. In particular, Clause 11 of the Appendix allows local authorities to provide (given a number of conditions) RSL’s with financial assistance or gratuitous benefit. This assistance can be in the form of a disposal at a figure less than full open market value. The discount from full open market value being the “assistance” given. 61 14/02/2011 15. The amount of assistance an authority can give in any one financial year, without the need for Secretary of State’s consent, is £10 million. This is an aggregated total which must include any direct local authority grant funding as well as the value of any land. This will mean that close monitoring of a programme would be necessary in order that either the limit is not passed or that consent is sought for significant schemes at the appropriate time. 16. For non-housing land, the Local Government Act 1972: General Disposal Consent 2003 provides powers to a local authority to dispose of property at an undervalue in defined circumstances. 17. The Consent removes the requirement for authorities to seek specific consent from the Deputy Prime Minister and First Secretary of State ("the Secretary of State") for any disposal of land where the difference between the unrestricted value of the interest to be disposed of and the consideration accepted ("the undervalue") is £2,000,000 (two million pounds) or less. 18. The consent only applies where the disposal is for a well-being purpose within the meaning of section 2 of the Local Government Act 2000, namely the purpose of the disposal is likely to contribute to the promotion or improvement of the economic, social or environmental well-being of the whole or part of authority’s area or all or any persons resident in the area. Regard must be had to the Council’s Community Strategy in determining a well-being purpose and the decision must be rational (i.e. one that a reasonable authority with knowledge of the facts would make) and based on evidence. If a disposal falls outside the general consent, specific consent may still be sought from the Secretary of State. Other statutory requirements, e.g. advertising the disposal of open space, must still be complied with. 19. It therefore offers authorities greater freedom than previously to exercise discretion in the disposal of their non-housing land and, in principle; if the wellbeing threshold is met it is possible to “give away” land, which has a value up to £2 million. 20. All disposals need also to comply with the European Commission's State Aid rules. When disposing of land at less than best consideration, authorities are likely to be providing a subsidy to the purchaser, developer and/or the occupier of the land and property, depending on the nature of the development. Where this occurs, authorities must ensure that the nature and amount of subsidy complies with the State Aid rules, particularly if there is no element of competition in the sale process. The State Aid rules seek to prevent the distortion of competition between Member States so would in practice normally only impact on large developments where there would be EC wide competition for disposals and there are a number of exceptions to these Rules. Each case would need to be considered on its merits but failure to comply with the rules means that the aid is unlawful and may result in the benefit being recovered with interest from the recipient. ACQUISITION 1. Powers of acquisition are more extensive and are subject to less qualification than powers of disposal. 2. Section 120 Local Government Act 1972 provides a general power to a principal council, such as NNDC, to acquire land by agreement. 3. Subsections (1) and (2) of this section read as follows (1) For the purposes of— (a) any of their functions under this or any other enactment, or (b) the benefit, improvement or development of their area, a principal council may acquire by agreement any land whether situated inside or outside their area. (2) A principal council may acquire by agreements any land for any purpose for which they are 62 14/02/2011 authorised by this or any other enactment to acquire land, notwithstanding that the land is not immediately required for that purpose; and, until it is required for the purpose for which it was acquired, any land acquired under this subsection may be used for the purpose of any of the council's functions. 4. The scope of the section is, thus, very wide. 5. While there is no “best value” requirement, per se, in relation to acquisition, there is an overriding duty placed on all local government that its decisions must be administratively and fiscally responsible and justifiable. 6. It is not only Local Government Act 1972 which provides powers of acquisition. Many other statutes, for example, the Housing Act 1985 and the Highways Act 1980 provide local authorities with powers to acquire land both by agreement and compulsorily in order to carry out the associated function. 63 14/02/2011