5 ATOMIC SPECTROSCOPY 5.1 Introduction Atomic species include neutral atoms, as well as elemental ions. They are not bonded or associated with any other species, and thus are termed "free". Only the valence (outer-shell) electrons orbiting the nucleus are capable of absorbing energy. In atomic species, the energy levels are few and far between. As a consequence, the atomic spectrum, whether absorption or emission, will consist of a series of single wavelengths, known as a line spectrum, as you have already seen in Chapter 1. Both atomic emission and absorption techniques are generally limited to metallic elements, since one of the characteristics of metals is that they have valence electrons that are “easily” moved from their normal orbital. Remember, when a metal atom ionises, it loses its electron completely. So the absorption of energy to move the electron to a higher energy level can be considered as simply the first step towards ionisation. Non-metal atoms, such as oxygen and chlorine, hold their valence electrons tightly in the lowest orbitals, since non-metals generally are electronegative, and "search" for more electrons rather than losing them. Therefore, it is much less likely that non-metal valence electrons would be capable of absorbing energy to move to a higher orbital. The same applies to ionised metals, such as Na +, which have a full outer shell of electrons. The critical aspect of atomic spectroscopy – absorption or emission - is that the analyte atom must be in the form of free and neutral atoms, known as an atomic vapour, a gaseous cloud of atoms. Obviously, the production of a such a state requires considerable energy in itself. Over the years, various means of achieving this aim have been developed, among them flames, electrical arcs and heating, plasmas and lasers. In this chapter we will cover the following techniques: flame atomic absorption spectrophotometry (AAS) flame emission photometry inductively coupled plasma (ICP) emission spectroscopy 5.2 Flame generation of the atomic vapour Sample Requirements The principal sample requirement for each technique examined in this chapter is that it must be in a liquid state, so that it can be drawn into (aspirated) the flame (or plasma). Thus, solid or gaseous samples must be dissolved in a suitable solvent (which can be organic, but not a highly flammable one) for analysis. The liquid sample needs to have the following characteristics: non-viscous (otherwise it will not aspirate properly and will most likely clog up the sample transport system) free of suspended solids (which will block up the nozzle) free of dissolved gases (which will disrupt the even combustion of the flame gases) CLASS EXERCISE 5.1 How do you ensure your solution will meet the requirements above? Viscosity Suspended solids Dissolved gases 5. Atomic Spectroscopy Sample atomisation The most common atomisation device consists of a nebuliser, which produces a fine spray from the liquid sample, and an energy source – for example, a flame - which evaporates the solvent and decomposes any compounds into the atomic state. Figure 5.1 shows the sequence of processes undergone before any radiation is absorbed or emitted. Solution nebulisation – formation of fine droplets; large droplets removed to waste NEBULISER Aerosol removal of solvent by evaporation Solid particles FLAME/ PLASMA molecules melt and boil Gaseous molecules ionic molecules are not stable in gaseous state, so they fall apart into atoms Atomic vapour FIGURE 5.1 Atomisation processes CLASS EXERCISE 5.2 For a solution of sodium chloride, write a series of chemical equations that describe what is happening. Nebulisation NaCl (aq) Loss of solvent Vaporisation Atomisation Energy sources As mentioned above, a number of energy sources have been employed in atomic spectroscopy. In this section and later sections, we will concentrate on the flame. The flame is generated by a combination of gases, supplied under high pressure. These gases can be divided into two types, the flame requiring one of each: fuels and support/oxidants. The most common fuels used for flame production are ethyne (acetylene) and natural gas (propane). The common oxidants are air, oxygen and nitrous oxide (N2O). Figure 5.2 shows the temperature ranges obtained from the common gas combinations. Sci Inst Analysis (Spectro/Chrom) 5.2 5. Atomic Spectroscopy Natural gas/air 1800 Acetylene/air 2100 Acetylene/N2O 2400 2700 3000 3300ºC FIGURE 5.2 Flame temperatures 5.3 Atomic Absorption Spectrophotometry The technique of atomic absorption spectrophotometry (AAS) has become one of the most widely used analytical tools for the determination of metal concentrations. AAS is used for the analysis of over 60 metals and metalloids, and works well for concentrations typically ranging from 1-100 mg/L. It was developed by the Melbourne laboratories of the CSIRO in the late 1950s. Unfortunately, like numerous other Australian inventions, no one was prepared to invest the time and money required to take the idea through to the final product. Thus, the rights to the idea were sold to Varian Corporation in the USA, who have reaped considerable profits in the last 25-30 years selling the instruments around the world. Only recently has an Australian company bought 50% of the rights to the technology. However, it is considered that the main reason for Varian loosening its grip on the rights is because AAS will be eventually superseded by a new technology, known as ICP (inductively coupled plasma), which has several advantages over AAS. Instrumentation The basic components of an AA spectrometer is shown in Figure 5.3, and in general is similar to other absorption instruments. However, two of the components are substantially different in their detail to those previously described for UV-visible and IR instruments. The major differences are: the radiation source is specific for each element, and the sample cell is a flame Hollow cathode lamp Monochromator Detector & readout Sample aspirator FIGURE 5.3 Schematic diagram of an atomic absorption spectrometer RADIATION SOURCE Atomic absorption lines are very, very narrow: the peaks are approximately 0.005 nm wide. For this reason, a continuous spectrum radiation source, such as those in the UV/Vis and IR instruments would not work. The tiny “sliver” of radiation absorbed would be undetectable: like trying to count how many grains of sand are missing from the beach! So to make atomic absorption measurable, we must get rid of all the wavelengths other than the exact right one for a particular element. Monochromators can’t do this because they can only cut down the range to 0.1 nm, which is 20 times too wide. The development of a special radiation source for each element – known as a hollow cathode lamp – was the major invention by the CSIRO which led to the development of the AAS instrument. Sci Inst Analysis (Spectro/Chrom) 5.3 5. Atomic Spectroscopy FLAME GASES As described in an earlier section, the purpose of the flame in atomic spectroscopy is to create an atomic vapour of the analyte. The flame needs to be hot enough to vaporise and atomise the sample without being too hot, because other problems can then arise. Three gas combinations are commonly used in AAS: natural gas/air, acetylene/air (the most common) and acetylene-nitrous oxide. Table 5.1 summarises the characteristics and applications of the three gas combinations. TABLE 5.1 Flame gas temperatures and applications Gas combination Natural gas/air Max. Temp. (K) 1800 Elements Group IA (eg Li, Na, K) Acetylene/air 2250 Transition metals (eg Fe, Cu, Zn)/ lanthanides (eg Ce) /actinides (eg U) Acetylene/N2O 3000 Groups 2A (Ca, Mg, Ba), 3A (Al) The fuel:oxidant ratio, known as the flame stoichiometry, is an important variable in flame spectroscopy. The fuel and oxidant are generally combined in approximately their standard reaction ratio - a stoichiometric flame). However, in some circumstances, a reducing flame, which contains an excess of fuel, is used, even at the cost of some heat. A hotter flame is obtained by maximising the combustion of the fuel by ensuring that the oxidant is in excess - an oxidising flame. Quantitative Analysis Beer's Law applies equally well to atomic absorption measurements, and the same principles apply as described in Chapter 2: calibration standards are prepared to cover the absorbance range of 0.1 to 1.0 (or thereabouts) and samples measured under the same conditions. However, matrix interference is much more of a problem in AAS than it is in UV/VIS absorption, for example. Matrix interference is the change in measured response of the analyte due to substances in the analyte. Basically, what it means that a sample containing, for example 10 mg/L of the analyte, gives a different reading to a standard with the same concentration. Looked at another way, if a sample gave the same reading as a standard, you would assume they have the concentration, but if matrix interference is occurring then an error arises. To get around this problem, it is necessary to duplicate the matrix in the sample as closely as possible in the standards. This is known as matrix matching and is not particularly easy, for while the major matrix components are generally known, minor ones may vary from sample to sample, and it may be these which cause the interference. STANDARD ADDITION Where matrix matching is not possible, a method known as standard addition can be used to correct for matrix interference. In this method, a known amount of analyte is added to the sample (this solution becomes the “standard”), and its absorbance compared with that of the original sample. In this way, the matrix of the standard is exactly that of the sample, since the sample is being used as the "solvent". You are not required to undertake standard addition calculations in this subject. 5.4 Flame Emission Spectroscopy Historically, the oldest spectroscopic technique, flame emission of metals have been observed since the eighteenth century, when various experimenters observed the colours introduced into candle flames by different metals. It was shown by the inventor of the Bunsen burner that the source of the metal (be it pure element or any salt) did not change the colour or the wavelengths of the emission spectrum. Once spectroscopes were developed sufficiently, the individual wavelengths characteristic of each metal were examined, and found to be constant for a particular metal, and characteristic of that metal. Thus, qualitative identification of metal mixtures became relatively easy, and indeed a number Sci Inst Analysis (Spectro/Chrom) 5.4 5. Atomic Spectroscopy of elements, including caesium and rubidium, were discovered through the presence of previously unknown spectral emission lines. The first experiment in quantitative flame analysis dates back to 1873, where a basic visual comparison system was used for sodium-containing samples. The first instrumental device for the detection of emission intensity was developed in the 1930s, and employed a monochromator, a lightsensitive cell as a detector and an ammeter. The replacement of the monochromator with a far simpler, smaller and cheaper filter system came about soon after, and forms the basis for a range of modern flame emission instruments, known as flame photometers. The basic construction of a such a device is shown in Figure 5.4. Filter Detector & readout Sample aspirator FIGURE 5.4 Schematic representation of a flame photometer Flame photometers are built as an economical and simple-to-operate alternative to atomic absorption spectrophotometers for the analysis of certain elements. As mentioned, the absence of a monochromator makes the instrument much cheaper and smaller, and also less sensitive to outside influences, such as vibration. The flame photometer is therefore much more rugged and less prone to breakdown. Modern instruments for the analysis of Na/K/Li cost about $2,000. A filter system would not work if the flame produced too many emission lines other than the analyte’s. So the other difference to AAS is the use of a propane/air mixture for flame gases. This produces a lower temperature and reduces the number of emission lines down to only those very easily excited elements: Na, K, Ca and Li. It also makes the burner simpler and cheaper! The most intense lines emitted by these elements - those used for quantitative analysis - are listed below in Table 5.2. TABLE 5.2 Emission lines used for quantitative analysis Element Li Wavelength (nm) 670.8 Na 589.0, 589.6 K 765.5, 769.9 Filters The radiation emitted by a sample will be a combination of the characteristic wavelengths of each element in the sample. Even those elements not suitable for flame photometric analysis still give a weak emission spectrum in the flame. For example, copper gives a pale green colour to even a Bunsen flame. Therefore, a filter which blocks out all radiation other than that of the analyte is needed. As can be seen in Table 5.1, the characteristic lines of the three common analytes are well spaced, and filters that selectively allow only the analyte radiation are easily chosen. Generally, the manufacturer builds a filter system into the instrument, and the technician needs only to change the element selector, rather than swapping filters. This does mean that analysis of elements not originally designed for the instrument is impossible, since there is no easy way of including a filter for the new analyte. Sci Inst Analysis (Spectro/Chrom) 5.5 5. Atomic Spectroscopy Calibration Emission is measured by the intensity of radiation, and there are no “rules” about intensity ranges, like there are for absorption measurements. The actual intensity number has no meaning by itself, only by comparison with other values measured at the same time. The normal methods for calibration of an emission instrument is: 1. Select the correct filter setting for the analyte. 2. Zero the instrument by aspirating a blank solution, which may contain all other species used in the standards, other than the analyte. 3. Using the highest concentration standard, adjust emission intensity to full scale or at least 100*, depending on the style of readout. * there is nothing magical about the number 100 – it can be your favourite number, as long as it is a large number, so that the calibration graph will show a wide range of emission intensities, ensuring better precision. Quantitative analysis There is no equivalent to Beer’s Law that defines the relationship between emission intensity and concentration of analyte. However, the intensity does increase with concentration, but is not perfectly linear. Table 5.3 shows the typical concentration ranges for the common elements. TABLE 5.3 Typical concentration ranges Element Na Concentration Range (mg/L) 1-10 K 1-50 Li 3-100 If the calibration standards do not produce a straight line graph between intensity and concentration, use of base 10 logarithms can help: a plot of log10(intensity) vs log10(concentration) should be tried. Excel can do this automatically for you with a scatter graph, where an logarithmic scale option in Format Axis is selected. EXAMPLE 5.1 Potassium standards were prepared over a range of 25-100 mg/L and their emission intensities measured as shown below. The data was plotted directly and by the log-log method to find the better straight line. Concentration (mg/L) 25 50 75 100 Sci Inst Analysis (Spectro/Chrom) Emission Intensity 45 68 85 99 5.6 5. Atomic Spectroscopy 110 100 100 long (intensity) Intensity 90 80 70 60 50 40 10 25 45 65 Conc. 85 10 100 log (conc) Plotting this data in the different ways clearly shows that the log graph produced the better straight line calibration graph. CLASS EXERCISE 5.3 Using graph paper, plot a log-log graph for the data above, and determine the concentration of a sample with an intensity of 74. Hint – what do you have do with sample intensity before using the graph? What do you do with the result from the graph to convert it to concentration? Interferences Similar chemical interferences occur in flame photometry as those in AAS, but because the technique is mainly used for the Group I elements, ionisation effects are the most important. Sodium and potassium are normally both present in any real sample and their presence increases the emission intensity of each other. For example, the addition of 200 mg/L of sodium to a pure 20 mg/L potassium solution almost doubles the emission intensity of potassium. The simplest method of coping with this is to prepare matrix-matched standards which contain not only the analyte at the desired concentrations but also the other major species present in the sample at equivalent levels. Standard addition is also a possibility. However, the emission intensity can change for another reason, totally unrelated to the matrix: flame conditions. It is extremely difficult to maintain consistent flame conditions over the course of an analysis run. Fluctuations in gas flow from the cylinders and other variations in flame temperature will cause changes in intensity from the same sample. Matrix matching and standard addition are of no help here. The method of internal standards described below is very commonly used in flame emission to combat this problem. Internal Standards An internal standard is a substance added to all solutions, blanks, standards and samples at the same concentration in all. Its emission intensity is measured at the same time as that of the analyte for each solution. Make a note of this! You do NOT measure the analyte intensity of all the solutions, then go back and measure the internal standard intensity afterwards! The idea behind the technique is that if analyte emission is affected by certain flame variations, the internal standard will be likewise affected. Sci Inst Analysis (Spectro/Chrom) 5.7 5. Atomic Spectroscopy EXAMPLE 5.2 A sodium standard with lithium internal standard gives a sodium intensity of 100 and lithium 10. Thus the ratio is 10. When run again, the flame temperature has decreased through loss of oxidant pressure, causing a decrease of 20% in emission intensity for both species. Sodium will drop down to 80 and lithium 8, but the ratio of Na/Li intensity will remain unchanged at 10. You are not required to carry out these calculations in this subject. 5.5 ICP Emission Spectroscopy AAS dominated metals analysis for 40 years, but in the 1980s, a new technique, based on emission, was developed: ICP emission spectroscopy. ICP stands for inductively coupled plasma: only the last word of these three need interest you. A plasma is a cloud of ions and electrons, which occurs at high or very high temperatures. The sun is a plasma at a few million degrees. Plasmas can be generated safely in the laboratory at around 7000-10000 K. It is this energy source that is used in the new instruments instead of a flame. The rest of the instrument is more or less the same: monochromator, detector etc. The high temperatures and plasma conditions remove many of the problems associated with flames. In comparison to AAS and flame emission, ICP emission spectroscopy offers the following advantages: less matrix interferences greater sensitivity greater linear response more elements analysable As times goes by, the currently more expensive ICP technique will become the standard method for elemental analysis at concentrations from 50 ug/L upwards. What You Need To Be Able To Do describe how atomic absorption and emission spectra occur describe what an atomic vapour is and why it is necessary in atomic spectroscopy describe the atomisation process indicate what gases are commonly used in AAS and flame photometry indicate what the role of each gas is indicate what elements are commonly analysed by AAS and flame photometry using schematic diagrams, show how a basic flame photometer and AAS are constructed describe the various interferences that occur in flame spectroscopy Terms And Definitions Match the term with the definition. 1. 3. 5. 7. line spectrum oxidising flame nebuliser internal standard A. B. C. D. cloud of ions and electrons cloud of atoms analytical technique designed to compensate for matrix interference flame with an excess of fuel Sci Inst Analysis (Spectro/Chrom) 2. 4. 6. 8. atomic vapour reducing flame standard addition plasma 5.8 5. Atomic Spectroscopy E. F. G. H. spectrum of narrow absorption or emission peaks generated by atoms device used to convert solutions into mist flame with an excess of oxidant analytical technique designed to compensate for flame variations Review Questions 1. Why can't organic molecules be analysed by flame emission or absorption spectroscopy? 2. Describe the processes leading to the absorption of radiation, when a sample containing sodium is introduced into a flame. 3. Why is a filter system used in flame photometry? 4. Why are Na, K and Li often the only elements available for analysis with commercial flame photometers? What changes to such an instrument would be necessary to analyse elements such as copper and iron? 5. An acetylene/nitrous oxide gas mixture is used for production of the flame in the analysis of calcium and magnesium by AAS. (i) What does this gas mixture provide? (ii) Why is it needed for these elements? (iii) Potassium is often added to samples containing calcium before AAS analysis. Explain why. 6. Why does self-absorption of radiation occur in solutions of high concentration only? 7. Why is a propane/air mixture, and not acetylene/air, used for Na and K analysis in both flame photometry and AAS? 8. Why is standard addition used in flame spectroscopy? 9. For the following sets of flame photometry data, determine a linear or logarithmic plot is better, and use it to determine the sample concentration. SET I Conc. (mg/L) Intensity 1 19 2 40 3 59 5 103 Sample 51 10. SET II Conc. (mg/L) 20 40 60 80 Sample Intensity 38 65 83 100 71 0.1032 g of a sample of potato chips were mixed with water until all the salt had dissolved, the liquid filtered and made up to 100 mL. A 25 mL aliquot of this solution was diluted to 200 mL, and analysed by flame photometry, using a calibration graph obtained from the following data. Determine the % Na in the sample. Conc. (mg/L) 10 20 30 40 Sample Sci Inst Analysis (Spectro/Chrom) Intensity 27 51 79 105 60 5.9 5. Atomic Spectroscopy 11. A 12.841 g sample of ground peanuts was continuously extracted with water to dissolve all ionic material. The filtered extract was then made up to 100 mL. To analyse the potassium content in the sample, a 10 mL aliquot was diluted to 250 mL. In each of the potassium standards, enough sodium chloride was added to give a concentration of 200 mg/L Na. Potassium emission values for each solution were as follows. Conc. K (mg/L) 10 20 40 60 Sample Intensity K 17 31 69 100 64 (i) Calculate the mg K/kg peanut in the sample. (ii) Explain why 200 mg/L sodium was included in each standard. Sci Inst Analysis (Spectro/Chrom) 5.10