3/14/89 STUDY PLAN BIRD USE OF SNAGS IN EASTSIDE PINE HABITATS IN NORTHEASTERN CALIFORNIA PROBLEM REFERENCE FS–PSW–42O2–1: WILDLIFE, RANGE, AND MONITORING RESEARCH (approved 2/4/88). MANAGEMENT SITUATION AND LITERATURE REVIEW Current Snag Management Issue Snags, or standing dead trees, are important nesting and foraging substrates for many species of wildlife, especially birds. In addition, the dead tops of live trees also provide foraging and nesting substrates for some species. The importance of this resource to wildlife, and its removal for other purposes, have caused National Forest units to set objectives for maintenance of specific snag densities in the environment. In May of 1987, the Washington Office conducted a review of the Region's Fish and Wildlife Management Program. One finding of this review was concern over the issue of snag management in eastside pine habitats on the Modoc National Forest. Evidence presented to the review team suggested that information on natural snag densities in eastside pine and densities of snags needed to support cavity-nesting bird populations is lacking. Their general conclusion was that little quantitative information is available on which to base reasonable guidelines for snag densities in eastside pine. They recommended that the Regional Office initiate a snag study to begin quantifying relationships between snag numbers and wildlife use, principally birds, in the eastside pine habitats of northeastern California. Snag Densities and Historical Management Direction for management of snags on National Forests in Region 5 (California) was set forth in the Forest Service Manual in 1979. This direction, "one snag per acre, 11 inches dbh or greater, 12 feet high or higher in all forest types, plus an average of one-half snag per acre, 16 inches dbh or greater, 12 feet high or higher, in all forest types except lodgepole pine" (FSM 2405.14 11/79 R-5 Supplement 221), was judged to be sufficient for wildlife based on information available at that time. The Minimum Management Requirements developed for forest land-management planning are intended to maintain snags in sufficient density and distribution to provide habitat capability of not less than 40 per cent for primary cavity-nesting birds on commercial forest lands. Diameter and height standards were designed to meet the requirements of snag-using birds and mammals. Studies (e.g., Bull and Meslow 1977, McClelland 1979) done since the manual direction for snags was released in 1979 indicated that diameter and height standards should be increased to meet the needs of all snag-using birds and mammals within Region 5. The direction was therefore changed to: "to the extent possible, within each timber compartment provide, maintain, and manage for an average of 1.5 snags per acre with the following specifications: 1. 1.2 snags per acre between 15-24 inches dbh and greater than 20 feet high; 2. 0.3 Snag Study Plan - 2. snags per acre greater than 24 inches dbh and greater than 20 feet high" (Background Paper - Snag MMR, Forest Service, Pacific Southwest Region Land Management Planning Files). In eastside pine areas in northeastern California, snag densities do not appear to meet the above mentioned Minimum Management Requirements. On the Modoc National Forest, approximately 90% of the eastside pine habitat fails to meet the minimum standard of a mean density of 1.5 snags per acre (3.7 snags per ha) (Studinski and Ross 1986). For example, snag densities in commercially available eastside pine on the Devil's Garden Ranger District range from 0.4 to 0.6 snags per acre (1.0 to 1.5 snags per ha), and other Districts on the Forest appear to support fewer than 1.5 snags per acre (3.7 snags per ha) (Studinski and Ross 1986, M. Ross, pers. comm., G. Studinski, pers. comm.). The situation on the Lassen National Forest, although not well quantified, appears to be similar (S. Kowalski, pers. comm., L. Schultz, pers. comm.). Historically, snags have been regarded as an undesirable component of managed eastside pine forests. Prior to the early 1970s, the objective was to eliminate snags and dying trees that were about to become snags. Snags sometimes (1) constitute a fire hazard because they may serve as lightning rods, increasing the risk of wild fire, (2) increase the spread of wild fire because movement by wind of burning punk, and (3) constitute a human safety hazard because of the risk of snag limbs or boles falling and injuring land users (Studinski and Ross 1986); dying trees serve as reservoirs for tree-damaging insects. Consequently, timber sales generally required removal of all snags in the sale area and many salvage sales were done to harvest recently dead snags for commercial purposes (Studinski and Ross 1986). In the 1970s management of snags became passive. No longer were snags to be removed from timber sale areas. However, they were not actively recruited either. Snags continued to decline in numbers as a result of continued salvage sales and fuelwood harvest (Studinski and Ross 1986). Finally, in the early 1980s, snag management policy became more active. The Regional Office required forests to (1) set minimum snag density requirements, (2) begin to inventory and monitor snag density, size, and distribution, and (3) plan for snag availability through time. Relationships of Birds to Snags Snags are an important feature of the environment for many species of plants, invertebrates, and vertebrates (Thomas et al. 1979). In the eastside pine habitats of northeastern California, 45 bird and 24 mammal species use snags for nesting or cover (Table 1). Many of these species use cavities excavated by species or naturally occurring in snags and, in some cases, living trees. Sixteen birds and 4 mammals require trees with cavities for their persistence. In addition, 12 birds and 20 mammals use habitats that include trees with cavities, or some other environmental variable that can be substituted for trees with cavities, to a greater extent than habitats without trees with cavities (see Table 2). Because of the value of snags to wildlife, National Forests of Region 5, in preparing forest landmanagement plans and plan implementation procedures, are establishing guidelines to provide for snags under future conditions. In addition, some National Forests in Region 5 have initiated snag recruitment programs for eastside pine to alleviate the perceived shortage of snags in this vegetation type. Although a body of information links wildlife use to snags and, in some cases minimum snag densities, information regarding the numbers of snags needed by snag-using and cavity-nesting birds in Snag Study Plan - 3. eastside pine of northeastern California is not extensive. In fact, little is known about the densities of snags that should be expected in eastside pine habitats under unmanaged conditions. OBJECTIVES 1. Develop an understanding of snag dynamics in eastside pine of northeastern California to resolve management concerns about the appropriateness of the Regional snag guidelines. 2. Develop an understanding of historical snag density patterns in eastside pine of northeastern California. 3. Develop an understanding of and a database for cavity-nesting and other bird relationships to snags in eastside pine of northeastern California. 4. Evaluate current snag-management guidelines for eastside pine in eastside pine of northeastern California and recommend changes thereto if data so indicate. 5. Document and monitor use of snags in eastside pine of northeastern California by birds, especially primary and secondary cavity nesters. 6. Explore the question of snag densities needed to support viable populations of cavity nesters in eastside pine of northeastern California. METHODS 1. Study Areas Pilot studies revealed that of the 394 potential eastside pine study sites, 355 (90%) had snag densities of < 1.2 per ha (< 0.5 per acre), 12 (4%) had snag densities of >3.7 per ha (>1.5 per acre), and 4 (1%) had snag densities of >7.4 per ha (>3.0 per acre). Consequently, the original study design was limited by the number of sites in the two snag-density classes >3.7 per ha (>1.5 per acre) and a revised design using seven snag-density classes was developed. In 1988, 24 (plus 8 alternates) study areas were established in the seven snag-density classes in eastside pine habitats on the Modoc and Lassen National Forests. The snag-density classes were: 0 per ha (0 per acre), >0 - 1.2 per ha (>0 - 0.5 per acre), >1.2 - 2.5 per ha (>0.5 - 1.0 per acre), >2.5 - 3.7 per ha (>1.0 - 1.5 per acre), >3.7 - 4.9 per ha (>1.5 - 2.0 per acre), >4.9 - 7.4 per ha (>2.0 - 3.0 per acre), >7.4 per ha (>3.0 per acre). Three study areas and two alternates were selected for each of the four lower snagdensity classes (< 3.7 per ha (< 1.5 per acre)) whereas the number of study areas in the three higher snagdensity classes depended on the number of sites that meet density criteria for each class--i.e., six in the >3.7 - 4.9 per ha (>1.5 - 2.0 per acre) class, two in the >4.9 - 7.4 per ha (>2.0 - 3.0 per acre) class, and four in the >7.4 per ha (>3.0 per acre) class. 2. Transects We located one transect 500 m (1640 ft.) long and 100 m (325 ft.) wide (5 ha (12.5 acre)) within each study area. A dot grid, with each point numbered sequentially, was placed over the study areas as mapped, on 7.5-minute topographic maps. The transect end point was selected by randomly drawing a single dot. Transect direction--potentially four cardinal directions and four intermediate directions (e.g. northeast)--were determined randomly. No transect was permitted to intersect the study area boundary. Counting stations were placed at 50-m (165-ft.) intervals along the center line of the long axis of the plot. Snag Study Plan - 4. 3. Vegetation information Vegetation information will be collected using two methods, one for overstory trees and a second for understory trees and shrubs. Information on the overstory trees will be collected using standard prism points (2.5-factor metric prism) located at alternate bird counting stations along each transect (six prism plots at all odd-numbered points on each strip transect). Information to be collected from each prism point includes an estimate of total stand density (measured by basal area), stand density (measured by basal area) by size class (15.2-cm (6-in.) diameter classes) of all trees with dbh greater than 12.7 cm (5 in.), stand age (two trees in each size class will be bored and their heights will be estimated), and percent of basal area contributed by snags percent slope and aspect also will be determined for each prism point. Productivity of the transect area will be estimated using forest survey site-class procedures on vegetation data collected as described above. The maximum number of canopy layers within a 50-m (165-ft.) radius of the point will be counted. Dead-and-downed woody material will be assessed by counting the number of logs with diameters exceeding 30 cm (12 in.) and lengths exceeding 3 m (10 ft.), and an estimate of the fuel loading will be made using the photo series for quantifying natural forest residues for ponderosa pine (Blonski and Schramel 1981) in a 25-m (82-ft.) radius circle centered on each prism point. For each tree or snag in the prism plot, species, dbh, and height will be recorded. Understory trees and shrubs as well as grasses, forbs and exposed ground surface will be sampled using two 25-m (82-ft.) line-intercept lines initiated at the prism points used for overstory trees. The direction of each line will be randomly determined using the same procedures described for transects above. Each understory tree or shrub encountered will be identified and the length of the line it intercepts will be measured. Grasses, forbs, patches of bare ground, rocks, and litter will also be measured, as well water courses if they are crossed. 4. Snag information Snag density will be determined by a direct count of all snags in each strip transect. Each snag will be assigned a unique number relative to the transect and will be mapped on snag maps for each transect. Information collected for each snag will include species, dbh, height, cause of mortality if possible, decay condition, percent of bark cover, and the number of nesting cavities; the relative amount of sapwood to heartwood will be estimated using an increment borer. Decay condition will be measured in three ways: (1) using classes of decay based on visual standards--e.g., declining, loose bark--(Thomas et al. 1979:64), (2) using a pilodyn at breast height to evaluate condition of the outer portion of the tree, especially the sapwood, and (3) using a shigometer at breast height to evaluate the amount of decay in the heartwood. All snags from each transect will be monitored yearly for the duration of the study (a maximum of 4 years), using the above methods, to begin to quantify snag longevity patterns. During these visits, all new snags will be mapped, measured, and added to the snag inventory. Information collected during monitoring visits will include snag status (that is, whether it is still a snag or has fallen and become a log), decay condition (as described above), change in decay class (if any), and additional nest holes. Snag Study Plan - 5. 5. Other landscape characteristics To the extent possible, location information on springs, streams, and other water sources will be collected. If found within the boundaries of a study transect, such attributes will be mapped. If not, proximity to study transects will be noted if appropriate. 6. Bird mapping Bird-mapping procedures will generally follow those of Christman (1984) as modified by Noon (pers. comm.). Briefly, the procedure requires walking each 500-m (1640-ft.) transect in about 1 hr, recording on a map of the transect all species detected (those within the 50-m (165-ft.) transect border and birds beyond), their positions along the transect line, and estimated perpendicular distance from the transect line to within 5 m (16 ft.) of their location (see Table 3 for a list of bird species expected in eastside pine). Observers will be permitted to move slightly off the transect to ensure that locations are mapped accurately. Additional information to be taken includes whether the sightings were visual or based on calls or songs, and if there was simultaneous singing by two or more individuals of the same species. Bird-mapping efforts will be confined to morning hours beginning shortly after dawn and continuing for a maximum of 5 hours. Approximately three transects will be surveyed by each observer each field day. Information from each visit to a transect will be plotted on a fresh map of the site; summary maps for each of the cavity-nesting species will be developed following field visits. Each transect will be surveyed 10 times during the breeding season in each of the 4 field years, beginning at the first of May and ending in mid-June. Each of four field observers will survey each transect at least twice each field season, to standardize observer variability. Each survey of a transect will be concluded in approximately 1 hour--about 2 minutes at each of the 11 counting stations and about 4 minutes walking each of the 10 intervals between counting stations. Because the time needed to walk a transect interval will vary depending on the number of birds seen and mapped, the time spent at each counting station will be used to recalibrate the timing of the survey--6 minutes will be spent at each combined interval and point. This approach, combining mapping and time-constrained counting procedures, will permit estimates of breeding pairs, and relative abundance and, perhaps, densities of birds for each transect. 7. Use of snags by cavity nesters Use of snags by cavity nesters will be studied separately. After completing the morning survey work, each observer will remain at the last transect to search for nest sites used by all cavity nesters on the transect and for all cavity nesters encountered in the larger, presumably homogeneous area in which the transect is located. The time constraints should permit at least three visits to each transect for this purpose in the season. Additional follow-up visits to transects will be scheduled following the transect survey period; the number of these visits will vary depending on the amount of time allocated for field work for the year. Information collected for each nest found of a cavity-nesting bird will include bird species, snag identification number, nest height, snag diameter at nest height, azimuth of nest entrance, whether nest is in living or dead part of the tree, distance the nest is below the top of the tree, and snag condition at nest height (when possible to measure with the pilodyn and shigometer); each nest located will be mapped on the daily map and summary map for that species. Preferences by cavity nesters for nest snag and tree species and diameters will be evaluated using a randomized process to select the nearest alternative snag or tree. If the nest is in a snag, the observer will search for an alternative nest snag; if the nest is in a tree, the observer will search for an alternative nest Snag Study Plan - 6. tree. From each nest snag or tree, the observer will pace 30 m (100 ft.) in a randomly determined direction (N, NE, E, SE, S, SW, W, NW). After pacing 30 m (100 ft.), the observer will randomly determine whether to turn left or right. The selected snag or tree will be the first snag or tree greater than 15.2 cm (>6 in) dbh detected within 5 m (16 ft.) of either side of the arc. If no alternative snag or tree are found within the 30 m (100 ft.) radius circle, the observer will continue out another 10 m (33 ft.) and repeat the process until an alternative snag or tree is located. The same information recorded for nest snags and trees will be taken from each of these snags and trees. If nests are found in snags or trees less than 15.2 cm (>6 in.) dbh, selection criteria for alternative snags and trees will be adjusted accordingly. 8. Nesting success of cavity nesters When fledgling or young birds are encountered during regular morning surveys or searches for nest sites, information on the number and developmental stage of each bird will be collected. ANALYSES 1. Vegetation information Estimates of means and variances will be made for each measure. Multivariate procedures may be used to explore patterns of vegetation characteristics and differences in vegetation composition and structure among the study areas. 2. Snag information Estimates of means and variances will be made for each measure. Estimates will be made of existing snag densities. Estimates of potential snag density for each study area will be developed; these estimates will be based on characteristics of the study area including tree stocking and site productivity. 3. Bird mapping All locations of cavity-using birds will be summarized on transect maps for each species for each year. Territories will be estimated for each pair of birds. Abundances of each species will be estimated for each year. A species list will be prepared for each transect from information gathered from the spotmapping procedures as well as encounters with other species in the surrounding area of homogeneous habitat. 4. Use of snags by cavity nesters Estimates of means and variances will be made for each measure collected for nesting snags and nest sites by species and transect. If transects can be grouped into the above snag-density classes, analysis of bird abundance relative to snag-density class will be accomplished with analysis of variance procedures. If transects cannot be grouped, analysis of density relationships will be accomplished through correlation or regression procedures. DURATION OF THE STUDY The study is expected to terminate at the end of FY-92. The first year of the study was devoted to selection of 32 study areas (including 8 alternate study areas), establishment of transects, and pilot work Snag Study Plan - 7. on vegetation and bird study methods. The following 4 years will emphasize monitoring of snag status and condition, bird studies, and collection of vegetation information. Completion of analyses, development of management guidelines if necessary, and reporting final results of the study to both management and the scientific community will be completed in the final year of the study. PUBLICATIONS The study will result in at least five publications including: estimation of existing snag densities on the Modoc National Forest, estimation of bird abundances and use of snags in areas with different snag densities, a plan for monitoring snags and wildlife that use them, recommendations on snag management guidelines for eastside pine in California, and necessary technology transfer products for National Forests, Ranger Districts, and other users, for on-the-ground application. PERSONNEL ASSIGNMENT A fulltime wildlife biologist will be assigned to the study for its duration. As needed, three to four temporary wildlife biologists will be hired for assistance with field and office phases of the study (see tabulation below). Activity Assignment Person-days Prepare study plan Wildlife biologist 15 Select field locations Wildlife biologist 200 Prepare field sites Wildl. biol. & temporaries 200 Conduct bird surveys Wildl. biol. & temporaries 1000 Conduct vegetation work Wildl. biol. & temporaries 200 Data entry Wildl. biol. & temporaries 100 Preparation of manuscripts Wildl. biol. 645 TOTAL 2360 Snag Study Plan - 8. ESTIMATED COSTS (total for 5 years) Wildlife Biologist (GS-12 PFT) salary……………………………………$209,090 Benefits For GS-12 PFT…………………………………..……$ 20,920 Temporary salaries……………………………………………………….. $ 74,930 Vehicles--fixed costs..…………………………………………………… $ 12,910 --mileage………………………………………………………… $ 17,570 Travel--commercial fares………………………………………………… $ 5,800 --per diem………………………………………………………….. $ 27,590 Materials and supplies…………………………………………………… $ 8,000 Construction and services…………………………………………………$ 5,000 Automated Data Processing……………………………………………… $ 14,500 TOTAL $396,310 Snag Study Plan - 9. LITERATURE CITED Blonski, K.S., and J.L. Schramel. 1981. Photoseries for quantifying natural forest residues: Southern Cascades, Northern Sierra Nevada. USDA For. Serv. Gen. Tech. Rep. PSW-56. Bull, E.L., and E.C. Meslow. 1977. Habitat requirements of the pileated woodpecker in northeastern Oregon. J. Forestry 75:335-337. Christman, S.P. 1984. Plot mapping: estimating densities of breeding bird territories by combining spot mapping and transect techniques. Condor 86:237-241. McCaskie, G., P. De Benedictis, R. Erickson, and J. Morlan. 1979. Birds of Northern California. Golden Gate Audubon Society, Berkeley, California. 84 pp. McClelland, B.R. 1979. The pileated woodpecker in forests of the northern Rocky Mountains. pp 283299 in J.G. Dickson, R.N. Connor, R.R. Fleet, J.A. Jackson, and J.C. Kroll (eds.). The role of insectivorous birds in forest ecosystems. Academic Press, New York. Oosting, H.J. 1956. The study of plant communities. W.H. Freeman and Co., San Francisco. Studinski, G., and M. Ross. 1986. Modoc National Forest Snags: Analysis of the management situation. USDA For. Serv., Modoc Nat'l. Forest, Alturas, Calif. Thomas, J.W., R.G. Anderson, C. Maser, and E.L. Bull. 1979. Snags. Chapter 5, pp 60-77 in J.W. Thomas, tech. ed. Wildlife habitat in managed forests--the Blue Mountains of Oregon and Washington. USDA For. Serv. Agric. Handbook No. 553. Snag Study Plan - 10. Table 1. Snag-using birds expected in transects in eastside pine habitats, their expected seasonal occurrence (from the California Wildlife Habitat Relationships System), and estimates of relative abundance (McCaskie et al. 1979). Codes for relative abundance ratings are abundant = 1, common = 2, fairly common = 3, uncommon = 4, very uncommon = 5, rare = 6, and irregular = 7. Species Season Relative abundance Turkey Vulture Sharp-shinned Hawk Cooper's Hawk Spring/Summer Yearlong Yearlong Northern Goshawk Swainson's Hawk Red-tailed Hawk Ferruginous Hawk Rough-legged Hawk Golden Eagle American Kestrel Merlin Band-tailed Pigeon Common Barn Owl Flammulated Owl Western Screech Owl Great Horned Owl Northern Pygmy-Owl Spotted Owl Long-eared Owl Yearlong Spring/Summer Yearlong Winter Winter Yearlong Yearlong Winter Spring/Summer Yearlong Spring/summer Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Short-eared Owl Yearlong Northern Saw-whet Owl Lewis' Woodpecker Yearlong Yearlong Yellow-bellied Sapsucker Red-breasted Sapsucker Williamson's Sapsucker Downy Woodpecker Hairy Woodpecker White-headed Woodpecker Northern Flicker Olive-sided Flycatcher Western Wood-Pewee Violet-green Swallow Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Spring/summer Spring/summer Spring/summer Clark's Nutcracker Mountain Chickadee Red-breasted Nuthatch Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong 3 to 4 3 to 4 5 to 6 in spring/summer 3 to 4 in fall/winter 5 to 6 3 to 4 1 to 2 5 to 6 1 to 2 3 to 4 1 to 2 5 to 6 1 to 2 1 to 2 3 to 4 3 to 4 1 to 2 3 to 4 5 to 6 5 to 6 in spring/summer 3 to 4 in fall/winter 3 to 4 in spring/summer 1 to 2 in fall/winter 5 to 6 5 to 6 in spring/summer 3 to 4 in fall/winter 3 to 4 3 to 4 3 to 4 1 to 2 1 to 2 3 to 4 1 to 2 1 to 2 1 to 2 1 to 2 in spring/summer 7 in fall/winter 3 to 4 1 to 2 1 to 2 Snag Study Plan - 11. Table 1 (continued). Species Season Relative abundance White-breasted Nuthatch Pygmy Nuthatch Brown Creeper Western Bluebird Mountain Bluebird Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Loggerhead Shrike Yearlong European Starling Yearlong 1 to 2 3 to 4 1 to 2 3 to 4 1 to 2 in spring/summer 5 to 6 in fall/winter 1 to 2 in spring/summer 3 to 4 in fall/winter 1 to 2 Snag Study Plan - 12. Table 2. Cavity-nesting birds expected on transects in eastside pine habitats, their season of occurrence, and importance of trees with cavities (from the California Wildlife Habitat Relationships System). Species preceeded by an * are primary cavity nesters that construct nesting cavities in snags and those preceeded by an @ are cavity nesters which often use existing cavities for nesting but have been known to construct their own nesting cavities. Definitions for the importance of cavities are: essential--cavities must be present within the home range of the species if the species is to be present; secondarily essential (sec essential)--cavities must be present within the home range of the species if the species is to be present or it must be compensated by the presence of other secondarily essential elements; and preferable-cavities are used to a greater extent than their abundance would suggest and the presence of cavities enhances the habitat's capability to support the species. Species Season Importance of Cavities Wood Duck Bufflehead American Kestrel Spring/summer Yearlong Yearlong Common Barn Owl Yearlong Western Screech Owl Great Horned Owl Yearlong Yearlong Northern Pygmy-Owl Yearlong Spotted Owl Yearlong Long-eared Owl Northern Saw-whet Owl Yearlong Yearlong *Lewis' Woodpecker Yearlong *Yellow-bellied Sapsucker Yearlong *Downy Woodpecker Yearlong *Hairy Woodpecker Yearlong *White-headed Woodpecker Yearlong *Northern Flicker Yearlong Ash-throated Flycatcher Violet-green Swallow Spring/summer Spring/summer Mountain Chickadee Yearlong @Red-breasted Nuthatch Yearlong Essential for breeding Essential for breeding Essential for breeding Preferable for cover Preferable for breeding Preferable for cover Sec essential for cover Preferable for breeding Preferable for cover Essential for breeding Essential for cover Sec essential for breeding Preferable for cover Preferable for breeding Essential for breeding Sec essential for cover Essential for breeding Sec essential for cover Essential for breeding Preferable for cover Essential for breeding Sec essential for cover Preferable for foraging Essential for breeding Preferable for cover Essential for breeding Sec essential for cover Preferable for foraging Preferable for breeding Preferable for cover Essential for breeding Sec essential for breeding Sec essential for cover Essential for breeding Essential for cover Essential for breeding Snag Study Plan - 13. Table 2 (continued). Species Season @White-breasted Nuthatch Yearlong @Pygmy Nuthatch Yearlong Brown Creeper Yearlong Bewick's Wren Winter Wren Western Bluebird Mountain Bluebird Yearlong Fall/winter Yearlong Yearlong European Starling Yearlong Importance of Cavities Preferable for cover Essential for breeding Preferable for cover Essential for breeding Preferable for cover Sec essential for breeding Preferable for cover Sec essential for breeding Preferable for breeding Essential for breeding Sec essential for breeding Preferable for cover Preferable for breeding Preferable for cover Snag Study Plan - 14. Table 3. List of bird species expected to be encountered on eastside pine transects with abbreviations of species names to be used in spot mapping (= Sp. Code) and, season of occurrence (list is provided by the California Wildlife Habitat Relationships System). Species Sp. Code Season of Occurrence Great Blue Heron Snowy Egret Wood Duck Bufflehead Turkey Vulture Osprey Bald Eagle Northern Harrier Sharp-shinned Hawk Cooper's Hawk Northern Goshawk Swainson's Hawk Red-tailed Hawk Ferruginous Hawk Rough-legged Hawk Golden Eagle American Kestrel Peregrine Falcon Prairie Falcon Chukar Blue Grouse Turkey California Quail Mountain Quail Band-tailed Pigeon Mourning Dove Common Barn Owl Flammulated Owl Western Screech Owl Great Horned Owl Northern Pygmy-Owl Spotted Owl Long-eared Owl Short-eared Owl Northern Saw-whet Owl Common Nighthawk Common Poorwill Black-chinned Hummingbird Calliope Hummingbird Lewis' Woodpecker Yellow-bellied Sapsucker Red-breasted Sapsucker Williamson's Sapsucker Downy Woodpecker GBHE SNEG WODU BUFF TUVU OSPR BAEA NOHA SSHA COHA GOSH SWHA RTHA FEHA RLHA GOEA AMKE PEFA PRFA CHUK BUGR TURK CAQU MOQU BTPI MODO BAOW FLOW SCOW GHOW PYOW SPOW LEOW SEOW SWOW CONI POWI BCHU CAHU LEWO YBSA RBSA WISA DOWO Yearlong Spring/summer Spring/summer Yearlong Spring/summer Spring/summer Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Spring/summer Yearlong Winter Winter Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Spring/summer Yearlong Yearlong Spring/summer Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Spring/summer Spring/summer Spring/summer Spring/summer Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Snag Study Plan - 15. Table 3 (continued). Species Sp. Code Season of Occurrence Hairy Woodpecker White-headed Woodpecker Northern Flicker Olive-sided Flycatcher Western Wood-Pewee Hammond's Flycatcher Dusky Flycatcher Gray Flycatcher Say's Phoebe Ash-throated Flycatcher Violet-green Swallow Barn Swallow Steller's Jay Scrub Jay Pinyon Jay Clark's Nutcracker Common Raven Mountain Chickadee Red-breasted Nuthatch White-breasted Nuthatch Pygmy Nuthatch Brown Creeper Bewick's Wren Winter Wren Golden-crowned Kinglet Ruby-crowned Kinglet Western Bluebird Mountain Bluebird Townsend's Solitaire Swainson's Thrush Hermit Thrush American Robin Cedar Waxwing Northern Shrike Loggerhead Shrike European Starling Solitary Vireo Warbling Vireo Orange-crowned Warbler Nashville Warbler Yellow Warbler Yellow-rumped Warbler Black-throated Gray Warbler Hermit Warbler MacGillivray’s Warbler Wilson’s Warbler Western Tanager HAWO WHWO NOFL OSFL WWPE HAFL DUFL GRFL SAPH ATFL VGSW BASW STJA SCJA PIJA CLNU CORA MOCH RBNU WBNU PYNU BRCR BEWR WIWR GCKI RCKI WEBL MOBL TOSO SWTH HETH AMRO CEWA NRSH LOSH STAR SOVI WAVI OCWA NAWA YEWA YRWA BGWA HEWA MGWA WIWA WETA Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Spring/summer Spring/summer Spring/summer Spring/summer Spring/summer Spring/summer Spring/summer Spring/summer Spring/summer Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Fall/winter Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Spring/summer Spring/summer Yearlong Fall/winter Fall/winter Yearlong Yearlong Spring/summer Spring/summer Spring/summer Spring/summer Spring/summer Spring/summer Spring/summer Spring/summer Spring/summer Spring/summer Spring/summer Snag Study Plan - 16. Table 3 (continued). Species Sp. Code Season of Occurrence Black-headed Grosbeak Lazuli Bunting Green-tailed Towhee Rufous-sided Towhee Chipping Sparrow Brewer’s Sparrow Lark Sparrow Sage Sparrow Fox Sparrow Song Sparrow Lincoln’s Sparrow Golden-crowned Sparrow White-crowned Sparrow Dark-eyed Junco Western Meadowlark Brewer’s Blackbird Brown-headed Cowbird Northern Oriole Purple Finch Cassin’s Finch House Finch Red Crossbill Pine Siskin Lesser Goldfinch American Goldfinch Evening Grosbeak BHGR LABU GTTO RTTO CHSP BRSP LASP SASP FOSP SOSP LISP GCSP WTSP DEJU WEME BRBL BHCO NOOR PUFI CAFI HOFI RECR PISI LEGO AMGO EVGR Spring/summer Spring/summer Spring/summer Yearlong Spring/summer Spring/summer Spring/summer Spring/summer Spring/summer Yearlong Spring/summer Fall/winter Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Spring/summer Spring/summer Spring/summer Spring/summer Yearlong Yearlong Yearlong Spring/summer Fall/winter Yearlong Snag Study Plan - 17. SNAG DATA FORM #1 Transect: Use the Quad/Polygon numbering system rather than the random number for the plot. Observer and Date: Complete name and date, please. Snag #: Number each snag encountered, locate on map of transect using a circled number, and attach a numbered aluminum tag to the snag. Numbers will start at 1 for each transect but will not be in any particular order on the transect. Spec.: Identify the tree species that produced the snag. Use the following codes: PP = ponderosa pine; JP = Jeffrey pine; PI = pine if you cannot determine if the predecessor tree was a ponderosa or Jeffrey pine; IC = incense cedar; JU = juniper; WF = white fir; RF = red fir. Hgt.: Estimate the height of the snag using either the clinometer or relascop. Report height in meters. Diam.: Measure the diameter of the snag; report diameter in centimeters. Decay Condition: Vis.: Use the visual criteria set forth in Thomas 1979: 64. Record as follows: ST = a live tree with a Spike top, LT = live tree; DE = declining; DD = dead: LB = loose bark; CL = clean; BR = broken; DC = decomposed; DM = down material; ST = stump. Pilo.: Take a measurement with the Pilodyn at breast height. Shigo.: Take a measurement with the Shigometer at breast height. % Bark: Visually estimate the percent of the tree surface still covered with bark. # Nest Cav.: Count the numbers of nesting cavities and nest starts visible. Report as follows: # NC/ # NS. # Feed Cav.: Estimate the number of feeding holes by the following classes: L = less than 20: M = 20 to 50; H = greater than 50. Snag Study Plan - 18. SNAG DATA Transect: ________________/_______________ Date: FORM #1 Observer_______________________________ _________/___________/__________ Snag # Spec. : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : Hgt. : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : Diam. : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : <- - - - Decay Condition- - - -> Vis. Pilo. Shigo. :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : :: : : % Bark :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: # Nest Cav. : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : # Feed Cav. : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : Snag Study Plan - 19. OVERSTORY VEGETATION FORM #2 Transect: Use the Quad/Polygon numbering system rather than the random number for the plot. Point #: Record the transect point number (1-11) where sample is taken. Date and Observer: Complete name and date, please. Prism Factor: Record the prism factor used. Most, if not all, prism plots will be done using a metric 2.5 factor prism. Slope: Record the slope of the land at the sample point from the topo map. Aspect: Record the aspect (N, NE, E, SE, S, SW, W, NW) at the sample point from the topo map. # Stems in Prism Point: Record the total number of stems in the prism point. Tree Species: Record appropriate code from Tree Species at right. dbh: Measure diameter in centimeters at breast height. Size cl.: Record appropriate code (1-7) from Size Classes at right. Height: Record tree height in meters from Relascop or inclinometer. Age: Record age of cored trees from core (reading cores may need to be done in the lab, so ensure that cores and age data cell on this form are labeled by transect, point number, and key label for the tree cored {M64/131--1--PP1}). Canopy layers: Record the maximum number of canopy layers existing in a 50-m circle centered on the prism point. Logs: Record the count of all logs with average diameter exceeding 30-cm and 3-m in length within a 25-m circle centered on the prism point. Fuel Loading Class (< 7.6. cm): Using the photo series for quantifying forest residues (Blonski and Schramel 1981) record the appropriate code from the Fuel Loading Classes at the right. Fuel Loading Class (> 7.6 cm): Using the photo series for quantifying forest residues (Blonski and Schramel 1981) record the appropriate code from the Fuel Loading Classes at the right. Snag Study Plan - 20. OVERSTORY VEGETATION FORM #2 Transect: _____________/_______________ Point #: ____________________________ Date: Observer: __________________________ ________/_________/___________ Prism Factor: __________________________ Slope: __________ Aspect: __________ # Stems in Prism Plot: ___________________ Tree Species dbh : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : Size Cl. : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : Height : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : Canopy Layers (in 50-m radius circle) = : Logs (> 30 cm x 3 m) = : Age : Fuel Loading Class ( < 7.6 cm) = : : Fuel Loading Class ( > 7.6 cm) = : : : : : : : : : ; : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : Tree Species Incense Cedar (IC) White Fir (WF) Ponderosa Pine (PP) Jeffrey a Pine (JP) Snag IC (S-IC) Snag WF (S-WF) Snag PP (S-PP) Snag JP (S-JP) Size Classes 1 = 12.7-27.9 cm 2 = 27.9-43.1 cm 3 = 43.1-58.3 cm 4 = 58.3-73.5 cm 5 = 73.5-88.7 cm 6 = 88.7-103.9 cm 7 = >103.9 cm Fuel Loading Classes 1-MP-4 1-PP-2 2-MP-4 2-PP-2 3-MP-4 3-PP-2 4-MP-4 4-PP-2 5-MP-4 1-PP-3 2-PP-3 3-PP-3 4-PP-3 1-PP-4 2-PP-4 3-PP-4 : <- - - -: : : : in 25-cm circle : : <- - - -: Snag Study Plan - 21. UNDERSTORY VEGETATION FORM #3 Transect: Use the Quad/Polygon numbering system rather than the random number for the plot. Point #: Record the point # (1-11) of the transect. Observer and Date: Complete name and date, please. Line 1 / Line 2 Direction: Record the direction (N, NE, E, SE, S, SW, W, NW) of the line intercept from the point. Species: Record the species measured. Use scientific names preferably. Length: Record to the nearest .1 meter, the length of the line occupied by a plant species or ground cover. Snag Study Plan - 22. UNDERSTORY VEGETATION Transect: / Line 1 - - Point #: / Date: FORM #3 Observer: / Line 2 - - Direction: Direction: Species Length : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : Species :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: _ Length : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : Snag Study Plan - 23. BIRD/SNAG MAP FORM #4 General bird survey procedure is to follow Christman (1984) which is attached. Transect: Use the Quad/Polygon numbering system rather than the random number for the plot. Observer and Date: Complete name and date, please. Wind: Use the appropriate Beaufort Number (0-5) defined as follows: Beaufort Number Wind Speed miles per hr. 0 1 2 3 less than 1 1 to 3 4 to 7 8 to 12 4 13 to 18 5 19 to 24 Indicators of Wind Speed Smoke rises vertically Wind direction shown by smoke drift Wind felt on face; leaves rustle Leaves, small twigs in constant motion; light flag extended Raises dust and loose paper; small branches are moved Small trees in leaf sway; crested, wavelets on fallen waters Sky: Record the following Weather Bureau code numbers. 0 – Clear or only a few clouds 1 – Partly cloudy (scattered) or variable sky 2 – Cloudy (broken) or overcast 3 – Overcast 4 – Fog or smoke 5 – Drizzle 6 – Snow 7 – Showers When mapping snags, use the number on the snag tag. When mapping birds, use the attached two letter codes for species and symbols for activity. Snag Study Plan - 24. Table 1. Abbreviations of bird species names to be used with spot mapping. American Robin Anna’s Hummingbird Band-tailed Pigeon Black-headed Grosbeak Black Swift Black-thr. Gray Warbler Blue Grouse Brewer’s Blackbird Brown Creeper Brown-headed Cowbird Bushtit Calliope Hummingbird Cassin’s Finch Chipping Sparrow Common Raven Cooper’s Hawk Dark-eyed Junco Dusky Flycatcher Evening Grosbeak Flammulated Owl Fox Sparrow Golden-crowned Kinglet Great-horned Owl Green-tailed Towhee Hairy Woodpecker Hammond’s Flycatcher Hermit Thrush Hermit Warbler House Wren Lesser Goldfinch Lincoln Sparrow Mountain Chickadee Mountain Quail Nashville Warbler Northern Flicker Northern Goshawk Northern Pygmy-Owl r ah bp g bs bw bg B c b bt ch cf cs R co j df eg fo x gk go G ha hf T hw ho L ls m Q nw F ng po Northern Saw-whet Owl Olive-sided Flycatcher Orange-crowned Warbler Pileated Woodpecker Pine Siskin Purple Finch Pygmy Nuthatch Red-breasted Nuthatch Red-breasted Sapsucker Red Crossbill Red-tailed Hawk Red-winged Blackbird Ruby-crowned Kinglet Rufous Hummingbird Rufous-sided Towhee Sharp-shinned Hawk Solitary Vireo Song Sparrow Spotted Owl Steller’s Jay Swainson’s Thrush Townsend’s Solitaire Vaux’s Swift Violet-green Swallow Warbling Vireo Western Bluebird Western Flycatcher Western Tanager Western Wood-Peewee White-breasted Nuthatch White-headed Woodpecker Williamson’s Sapsucker Willow Flycatcher Wilson’s Warbler Winter Wren Yellow-rumped Warbler Yellow Warbler wo o ow pw ps pf pn n rs rc rt rb rk rh ru H sv s so J st ts vs vg v wb we t p N wt ws wi w wr aw yw Snag Study Plan - 25. APPENDIX IV PROCEDURES FOR SPOT MAPPING STANDARD TERMINOLOGY 1. Contact: Any detection of a bird in the field, whether by sight or sound. 2. Contact with high territorial significance: A contact associated with actions typically indicating a bird (or birds) on a territory. Different types of contacts differ in the extent to which they indicate territorial behavior. The following three groups of contacts are in order from highest to lowest reliability as indicators of territoriality: A. Territorial dispute; nonvocal territorial display (e.g., diving performance of a hummingbird, drumming of a woodpecker); singing bird; territorial call; nest with warm eggs or with nestlings; B. Obviously mated pair; adult carrying nest materials; adult carrying food for young; family group; C. Distraction display; alarm call. Some of these are applicable only to certain species, so it is important that the observer be familiar with the biologies of the species being sampled. 3. Precisely located: A bird located to within a 5 m radius circle (for birds with large territories use a larger radius circle such as 10 m or even 50 m. Use this larger radius circle for species such as STJA, BTPI, MOQU, most woodpeckers, and all raptors). 4. Imprecisely located: A bird that you cannot locate within a 5 m radius circle or to the larger radius circle if it is a species with large territories. 5. Contemporary contacts: Two or more simultaneous contacts with the same species, so no doubt exists that they are different birds. Contemporary contacts are essential for later analysis of results, especially if they involve contacts with high territorial significance. 6. Probably contemporary contacts: Contact with an individual bird that is probably not the same individual of the same species contacted immediately preceding the contact in question, although the two individuals were not contacted simultaneously. This leaves the decision up to the observer in the field. For example, a singing male often stops singing as an observer passes. If a singing male is then heard further along the trail, or at some distance away, but the first male was most unlikely to have moved to the new location undetected by the observer, it is reasonable to assume that two individuals are involved. 7. Registration: The record of a contact, entered on a field map of the study plot. Snag Study Plan – 26. 8. Cluster: After all registrations for a single species, made during all field visits, have been transferred to one summary map for that species, clusters of registrations are delineated and assumed to correspond to territories (or at least to centers of activity within territories). SAMPLING THE BIRD COMMUNITY Maps. -- Take enough maps (at least 7) of the study plot to the field each day to use a separate map for each grid line traversed that day. This reduces the number of registrations per map, permitting greater accuracy, and it allows you to use the same data to estimate densities by various transect methods. It also permits color-coding of observations by grid line traversed when final species maps are compiled, facilitating interpretation of clusters. Field notations. -- Abbreviate or symbolize all registrations unambiguously. Abbreviations for names of bird species are given in Table 1. Symbols to denote different types of registrations are given in Table 2. Other symbols can be developed as required, but a detailed key to all of these must be made and turned in with the completed maps. Table 2. Symbols to be used for recording registrations. These use several recommended by the International Bird Census Committee; others have been developed for this study. A A sight or sound contact with a bird of species A. Symbols may added to identify sex when appropriate. 3A, 4A Contact with three, four etc. birds of the same species in the same place. A _ A Contact with a bird giving a vocal utterance other than song, thought to have territorial significance. Contact with an imprecisely located bird giving a vocal utterance, other than song thought to have territorial significance. A [in solid triangle] Contact with a precisely located bird singing part of its song. A [in dashed triangle] Contact with an imprecisely located bird singing part of its song. A [in solid circle] Contact with a singing bird that was precisely located. A [in dashed circle] Contact with a singing bird that was not precisely located. A Contact with a bird performing a nonvocal, territorial display. AA Contact with a pair. AA [in a solid circle] Contact with a pair, with the male singing. A--->A Contact in which a bird moved from one location to another. An arrow may be used to indicate the direction of movement. A---> Contact with a bird that was first seen at ‘A’ and flew out of sight at the point of the arrow. Snag Study Plan – 27. Table 2. Continued. --->A Contact with a bird that was first seen in flight at the tail of the arrow and then landed at ‘A’. - -A-> Contact with a bird flying overhead. A- - -A Contemporary contact with two different birds of species A. In this and the previous notation, letters could be circled, underlined, or in other ways supplemented, as appropriate. A~~A Probably contemporary contact with two different birds of species A. A (nm) Contact with a bird carrying nest materials. A) (A Territorial dispute between two birds. A* Nest of species A. The number of eggs or young may be added. A (fn) Contact with a bird feeding nestlings (appropriate sex symbol may be added). A (ff) Contact with a bird feeding fledglings (appropriate sex symbol may be added). A(f) Contact with a fledgling of species A. A(y) Contact with an independent juvenile of species A. Sampling the grid. - - Begin walking the first line at 10 min after official sunrise and continue at a steady pace until all seven lines for that day’s visit have been completed. You are free to leave the grid lines for short periods when doing so would significantly improve the information obtained, as follows: 1. To confirm locations of contemporary contacts, especially those of high territorial significance. 2. To follow moving birds and plot their movements. Even employ the consecutive flush technique described by Wiens (1969). 3. Search for active nests. This is particularly important for delineating clusters for the following bird species: MOCH, RBNU, DEJU, and BRCR. If you see birds carrying food or nesting material, it’s worth spending some time to look for a nest. After such detours, return to the point at which you left the grid line to assure a systematic search of all portions of the plot. It should take you between 6 and 9 hours to complete one visit to the plot. Every registration out to about 75 m from the grid line should be recorded during each traverse of a line (even if you think you recorded the same bird on a line walked earlier that day). For some species, especially MOQU, WHWO, HAWO, PIWO, STJA, HETH, and AMRO, it’s critical that you record Snag Study Plan – 28. registration even if you only have an inexact idea of their location and they seem to be far away. If your first location of a bird is imprecise but you later precisely locate it, erase the imprecise locations and write down the precise one. Make sure all nests are recorded on both the daily field sheets and on the summary sheets. Sampling beyond plot boundaries. - -Recording registrations out to 50 meters from the boundary should be adequate for most species. For birds with large territories (e.g., WHWO, HAWO, PIWO, STJA, MOQU, and raptors), however, it’s important to record even farther out to help determine boundary cluster size and to minimize overestimation of the proportions of territories on the plot. __________________________________________________________________________________ *INTERPRETING RESULTS* Species summary maps. - -All registrations of a given species made during all visits to the plot are transferred from the daily field sheets to a separate map. EACH FIELD VISIT IS GIVEN A LETTER CODE to represent the registrations of any given species for that date. For a given visit, TRAVERSES ALONG SEPARATE GRID LINES ARE SEPARATELY COLOR-CODED on the species map, making it easier to recognize registrations of the same individual resulting from the observer’s passing through the same territory along two or more grid lines on the same date. Definition of a cluster. A cluster is a group of registrations representing one bird’s territory (or at least a center of activity). A cluster must include one of the following in order to be accepted: 1. Registrations on at least three different visits (i.e. dates), at least two having high territorial significance, and with at least 5 days separating extreme dates; or 2. Registrations on at least five different visits, none or one with high territorial significance, with at least 7 days separating extreme dates. Identifying clusters. - -Contemporary and probably contemporary contacts with high territorial significance contribute most to reducing ambiguity when delineating clusters; contemporary and probably contemporary contacts without high territorial significance are less useful. Therefore, the first step in delineating clusters is to draw “territorial boundaries” across lines connecting contemporary and probably contemporary registrations. This will leave some unresolved problems. If you can’t separate clusters using contemporary or probable contemporary registrations, then you can use one of the two following options: 1. At least two pairs of territorially significant registrations recorded in each cluster as you walked the same line (e.g., singing males on each of two days in both areas, or a pair in one area and a third bird in the other, or …) could be used to define clusters. 2. Share at least three registrations from different visits (not necessarily the same lines) with each of the surrounding clusters it could be merged with. Two of the three registrations must be territorially significant and any two of the three must be separated by at least five days. In counting registrations, do not count fledglings. Count known females as one when not with a male; pairs count as one registration. If a territorial dispute is in a cluster, it counts as one registration. Snag Study Plan – 29. Even these criteria may leave doubts about where boundaries ought to be drawn around clusters. Registrations of movements by individual birds can further help to resolve questions, but in the final analysis common sense and knowledge of the species must rule the day. In our opinion, contemporary and probably contemporary contacts and observations of extended movements of individuals are the most objective sorts of information that can be used to delineate clusters. For this reason, we agree with Tomialojc (1980) that it is worth considerable extra effort to obtain such data. We can’t overemphasize the importance of simultaneous registrations. Determining the number of territories: Complete clusters. Simply add up the number of complete clusters. Coping with boundary clusters.- -A boundary cluster is one which overlaps the plot boundary. It must contain at least one registration within the plot. There are problems with calculating the proportion of the cluster that falls within the plot as we do not adequately sample these territories. We feel the best way to determine this proportion is to compare it to the average number of visits contained in complete clusters (those clusters wholly within the plot). For species with three or more clusters that fall completely within the plot, determine the mean number of visits in the complete clusters of that species. The percentage of each boundary cluster assigned to the plot is then calculated by dividing the number of visits it has within the plot by the mean number of visits in the complete clusters. If this method yields a number that is obviously too high (i.e. there are 3 boundary territories and the above method yields a number greater than or equal to 3) then determine the mean number of registrations per complete cluster. The percentage of each boundary cluster assigned to the plot is then calculated by dividing the number of registrations it has within the plot by the mean number of registrations in the complete clusters. If this still results in an estimate that is too high, then use the method described below for species with less than 3 complete clusters. For species with too few territories to estimate the mean number of detections per complete cluster, use a convention similar to that adopted by the National Audubon Society for its annual Breeding Bird Census (Robbins 1970). The proportion of the cluster assigned to the plot is simply the proportion of registrations in that cluster that are within the boundary, rounded to the nearest 0.1 cluster. This method overestimates the proportion of the cluster really within the plot, because little or no sampling is done outside the plot. More sampling beyond plot boundaries can reduce but not eliminate this bias. In all of these methods for dealing with edge clusters, registrations in which a single bird moved from one side of the plot boundary to the other should be given double weighting- -one registration inside the plot and one outside. A registration directly on a boundary line also receives double weighting. In counting registrations, do not count fledglings. Count known females as one when not with a male; pairs count as one registration. If a territorial dispute is in a cluster, it counts as one registration. All proportional territories from the edge clusters are then summed with the complete clusters within the plot to arrive at a total for the species, expressed to the nearest 0.1 cluster. Tips for transferring to summary sheets and for interpreting: Transfer the most common species first and work you way to the least common species. Make a list on each daily field sheet of all of the species on that sheet. Then, as you transfer the different species to their summary sheets, cross off that species from the list. This really speeds up transferring when you get to the least common species. Snag Study Plan – 30. Make sure that you lightly cross off each registration after you transfer it to the summary sheet. This ensures that each registration gets transferred. A highlighter works great for this. When interpreting, start in the “easiest” area of the map and work out from there. This will give you an idea of cluster size and spacing. But also realize that within any given species there will be a range of territory sizes and spacing depending on available resources. Use acetate overlays to draw territories. After you have drawn the final territories, transfer them to the summary map. Snag Study Plan – 31. A 3A, 4A A sight or sound contact with a bird of species A. Symbols may added to identify sex when appropriate. Contact with three, four, etc. birds of the same species in the same place. _ A Contact with a bird giving a vocal utterance other than song, thought to have territorial significance. Â Contact with an imprecisely located bird giving a vocal utterance, other than song thought to have territorial significance. A [in solid triangle] Contact with a precisely located bird singing part of its song. A [in dashed triangle] Contact with an imprecisely located bird singing part of its song. A [in solid circle] Contact with a singing bird that was precisely located. A [in dashed circle] Contact with a singing bird that was not precisely located. __ ׀A ] ׀in dashed box] AA Contact with a bird performing a nonvocal, territorial display. Contact with a pair. AA [in solid circle] Contact with a pair, with the male singing. A-->A Contact in which a bird moved from one location to another. An arrow may be used to indicate the direction of movement. A---> Contact with a bird that was first seen at ‘A’ and flew out of sight at the point of the arrow. --->A Contact with a bird that was first seen in flight at the tail of the arrow and then landed at ‘A’. - -A-> Contact with a bird flying overhead. A- - -A Contemporary contact with two different birds of species A. In this and the previous notation, letters could be circled, underlined, or in other ways supplemented, as appropriate. A~~A Probably contemporary contact with two different birds of species A. A Contact with a bird carrying nest materials. (nm) A) (A Territorial dispute between two birds. A* Nest of species A. The number of eggs or young may be added. A Contact with a bird feeding nestlings (appropriate sex symbol may be added). (fn) A Contact with a bird feeding fledglings (appropriate sex symbol may be added). (ff) A(f) Contact with a fledgling of species A. A(y) Contact with an independent juvenile of species A. Snag Study Plan – 32. BREEDING BIRD SPECIES AT SJER BEAUFORT WIND SCALE Codes for spotmapping 00 = Smoke rises vertically SPECIES CODE SPECIES ACWO A MODO M AMKE AK AMRO ar NOFL NF ANHU a NOOR NO ATFL F NPOW po NUWO N OCWA o 15 = Small branches moved, raises dust and dry leaves CODE 02 = Direction shown by smoke, 21 = Small trees in leaf begin to sway but not wind vane 05 = Felt on face; moves wind 28 = Large branches in motion vane BAOW BO BEWR be BGGN bg BHCO bc PHAI PH BLPH BP PLTI P BRBL B BRTO T RCSP rs BUSH b ROAD RO ROWR r CATH TH RTHA rt CAWR ca RSTO ru 1 = light drizzle CAQU Q RWBL rb 2 = steady rain COHA co CORA R GHOW GO GOEA G constant motion SCJA J STAR ST TRSW t TUVU TV VGSW V HAWO ha HOFI hf HOSP hs HOWR ho WBNU n HUVI HV WEBL wb HUMM hu WEXI WK WEME W WREN wr KILL K 10 = Leaves and twigs in RAIN 0 = No rain WSOW SO LAGO LA LASP LK LEGO L LEOW LO LOSH LS Snag Study Plan – 33. BIRD/SNAG MAP Transect: Date: Scale: / / / + - - - - - - -- - -+ <---- 50m ---> FORM #4 Observer: Wind: Sky: 11 +- - - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - - + : : : : : : : : 10 : +- - - - - - - - +- - - - - - - - + : : : : : : : : 9 : +- -- - - - - - -+- - - - - - - + : : : : : : : : 8 : +- - - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - - + : : : : : : : : 7 : +- - - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - - + : : : : : : : : 6 : +- - - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - - + : : : : : : : : 5 : +- - - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - - + : : : : : : : : 4 : +- - - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - - + : : : : : : : : 3 : +- - - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - - + : : : : : : : : 2 : +- - - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - - + : : : : : : : : 1 : +- - - - - - - - -+- - - - - - - - + FINISH Time: : PDT START Time: : PDT Snag Study Plan – 34. BIRD USE OF SNAGS FORM #5 Transect: Use the Quad/Polygon numbering system rather than the random number for the plot. Observer and Date: Complete name and date, please. Wind: Use the appropriate Beaufort Number (0-5) defined as follows: Beaufort Number Wind Speed miles per hr. 0 1 2 3 less than 1 1 to 3 4 to 7 8 to 12 4 13 to 18 5 19 to 24 Indicators of Wind Speed Smoke rises vertically Wind direction shown by smoke drift Wind felt on face; leaves rustle Leaves, small twigs in constant motion; light flag extended Raises dust and loose paper; small branches are moved Small trees in leaf sway; crested wavelets on fallen waters Sky: Record the following Weather Bureau code numbers. 0 – Clear or only a few clouds 1 – Partly cloudy (scattered) or variable sky 2 – Cloudy (broken) or overcast 3 – Overcast 4 – Fog or smoke 5 – Drizzle 6 – Snow 7 – Showers DATA TABLE For Nesting Site: Bd Sp: Record four letter code for bird species name. Snag ID: Record the unique number for the nest snag (if a snag) on the transect. T/S Sp: Record the code for the tree or snag species. T/S dbh: Record the dbh of the tree or snag in centimeters. T/S Ht: Record the height of the tree or snag in meters. Nest Ht: Record the height of the nest in meters. Nest Dia: Record the diameter of the tree or snag at the nest in cm. Nest Az: Record direction nest entrance faces (N, NE, E, SE, S, SW, W, NW). L/D: Record L if nest is in a live part of a tree or D if in a snag or dead part of live tree. Ht Grnd: Record the height, in meters, the nest is above the ground. S Cond: Snag condition; 1 each pilodyn and shigometer measure if possible, if not accessible, visual condition of the nest area. For Potential Nesting Site: Snag ID: Record the snag ID number if appropriate. T/S Sp: Record as defined above. T/S dbh: Record as defined above. T/S Ht: Record as defined above. Snag Study Plan – 35. FOUR-LETTER ALPHA CODES FOR BIRDS OF THE SIERRA NEVADA Eared Grebe Western Grebe Pied-billed Grebe Great Blue Heron Green-backed Heron Black-crowned Night Heron Whistling Swan Canada Goose Snow Goose Mallard Northern Pintail Green-winged Teal Cinnamon Teal American Wigeon Northern Shoveler Wood Duck Redhead Ring-necked Duck Canvasback Lesser Scaup Barrow’s Goldeneye Bufflehead Harlequin Duck Ruddy Duck Hooded Merganser Common Merganser Turkey Vulture California Condor Black-shouldered Kite Northern Goshawk Sharp-shinned Hawk Cooper’s Hawk Red-tailed Hawk Red-shouldered Hawk Swainson’s Hawk Golden Eagle Bald Eagle Northern Harrier Osprey Prairie Falcon Peregrine Falcon Merlin American Kestrel Blue Grouse White-tailed Ptarmigan California Quail EAGR WEGR PBGR GBHE GRHE* BCNH WHSW CAGO SNGO MALL NOPI GWTE CITE AMWI NOSH WODU REDH RNDU CANV LESC BAGO BUFF HADU RUDU HOME COME TUVU CACO BSKI NOGO SSHA COHA RTHA RSHA SWHA GOEA BAEA NOHA OSPR PRFA PEFA MERL MAKE BLGR WTPT CAQU Spotted Sandpiper SPSA American Avocet AMAV Wilson’s Phalarope WIPH California Gull CAGU Ring-billed Gull RBGU Band-tailed Pigeon BTPI Mourning Dove MODO Greater Roadrunner GRRO Barn Owl BAOW Western Screech-Owl WSOW Flammulated Owl FLOW Great Horned Owl GHOW Northern Pygmy-Owl NPOW Burrowing Owl BUOW Spotted Owl SPOW Great Gray Owl GGOW Long-eared Owl LEOW Short-eared Owl SEOW Northern Saw-whet Owl NSOW Poor-will POWI Common Nighthawk CONI Black Swift BLSW Vaux’s Swift VASH White-throated Swift WTSW Black-chinned Hummingbird BCHU Anna’s Hummingbird ANHU Allen’s Hummingbird ALHU Rufous Hummingbird RUHU Calliope Hummingbird CAHU Belted Kingfisher BEKI Northern Flicker NOFL Pileated Woodpecker PIWO Acorn Woodpecker ACWO Lewis’ Woodpecker LEWO Yellow-bellied Sapsucker YBSA Red-breasted Sapsucker RBSA Williamson’s Sapsucker WISA Unidentified Sapsucker SAPS Hairy Woodpecker HAWO Downy Woodpecker DOWO Nuttall’s Woodpecker NUWO White-headed Woodpecker WHWO Black-backed Woodpecker BBWO Unidentified Woodpecker WOOD Western Kingbird WEKI Ash-throated Flycatcher ATFL Snag Study Plan – 36. FOUR-LETTER ALPHA CODES FOR BIRDS OF THE SIERRA NEVADA Mountain Quail Chukar Wild Turkey Virginia Rail American Coot Killdeer Common Snipe MOQU CHUK WITU VIRA AMCO KILL COSN Olive-sided Flycatcher Violet-green Swallow Tree Swallow Northern Rough-w. Swallow Barn Swallow Cliff Swallow Steller’s Jay Scrub Jay Black-billed Magpie Yellow-billed Magpie Common Raven American Crow Pinyon Jay Clark’s Nutcracker Mountain Chickadee Chestnut-backed Chickadee Plain Titmouse Bushtit White-breasted Nuthatch Red-breasted Nuthatch Pygmy Nuthatch Brown Creeper Wrentit Dipper Winter Wren House Wren Bewick’s Wren Marsh Wren Canyon Wren Rock Wren Northern Mockingbird California Thrasher American Robbin Hermit Thrush Swainson’s Thrush Western Bluebird Mountain Bluebird Townsend’s Solitaire Blue-gray Gnatcatcher OSFL VGSW TRSW NRSW BASW CLSW STJA SCJA BBMA YBMA CORA AMCR PIJA CLNU MOCH CBCH PLTI BUSH WBNU RBNU PYNU BRCR WREN DIPP WIWR HOWR BEWR MAWR CNWR* ROWR NOMO CATH AMRO HETH SWTH WEBL MOBL TOSO BGGN Black Phoebe Say’s Phoebe Willow Flycatcher Hammond’s Flycatcher Dusky Flycatcher Western Flycatcher Unidentified Empidonax Western Wood-Pewee Yellow Warbler Yellow-rumped Warbler Black-throated Gray Warbler Townsend’s Warbler Hermit Warbler MacGillivray’s Warbler Common Yellowthroat Yellow-breasted Chat Wilson’s Warbler House Sparrow Western Meadowlark Yellow-headed Blackbird Red-winged Blackbird Tricolored Blackbird Northern Oriole Brewer’s Blackbird Brown-headed Cowbird Western Tanager Black-headed Grosbeak Blue Grosbeak Lazuli Bunting Evening Grosbeak Purple Finch Cassin’s Finch Unidentified Finch House Finch Pine Grosbeak Gray-crowned Rosy Finch Pine Siskin American Goldfinch Lesser Goldfinch Lawrence’s Goldfinch Red Crossbill Green-tailed Towhee Brown Towhee Savannah Sparrow Grasshopper Sparrow Vesper Sparrow Lark Sparrow BLPH SAPH WIFL HAFL DUFL WEFL EMPI WEPE YEWA YRWA BGWA* TOWA HEWA MGWA COYE YBCH WIWA HOSP WEME YHBL RWBL TRBL NOOR BRBL BHCO WETA BHGR BLGR LABU EVGR PUFI CAFI CARP HOFI PIGR GCRF PISI AMGO LEGO LAGO RECR GTTO BRTO SASP GRSP VESP LASP Snag Study Plan – 37. FOUR-LETTER ALPHA CODES FOR BIRDS OF THE SIERRA NEVADA Golden-crowned Kinglet Ruby-crowned Kinglet Water Pipit Phainopepla Cedar Waxwing Loggerhead Shrike European Starling Hutton’s Vireo Bell’s Vireo Solitary Vireo Warbling Vireo Orange-crowned Warbler GCKI RCKI WAPI PHAI CEWA LOSH EUST HUVI BEVI SOVI WAVI OCWA *Be sure to note species that don’t follow the basic rules. Rufous-crowned Sparrow Black-throated Sparrow Sage Sparrow Dark-eyed Junco Chipping Sparrow Brewer’s Sparrow Black-chinned Sparrow White-crowned Sparrow Golden-crowned Sparrow Fox Sparrow Lincoln’s Sparrow Song Sparrow RCSP BTSP SESP* DEJU CHSP BRSP BCSP WCSP GCSP FOSP LISP SOSP Snag Study Plan – 38. BIRD USE OF SNAGS Transect: Observer: Wind: Sky: / Date: / FORM #5 / < - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Nesting Site - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - > Bd. Sp. : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Snag ID : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : T/S Sp : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : T/S dbh : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : T/S Ht : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : <- - - - - - - - - Nesting Site - - - - - - - - - - - - - > Nest Ht : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : Nest Dia : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : <- - - - - - - Potential Nesting Site - - - - - - - - > Nest Az : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : L/D : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : Ht Grnd : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : S Cond : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : Snag ID : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : T/S Sp : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : T/S dhb : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : T/S Ht : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : 10 : : : : : : : : : Snag Study Plan – 39. SNAG DENSITY FORM #6 Transect #: Use the Quad/Polygon numbering system rather than the random number for the plot. Location: Record the forest or National Park Unit name (Modoc, Lassen, Lassen Volcanic National Park {LVNP}, Lava Beds National Monument {LBNM}) Random #: Record the random number of the polygon or potential transect. Date: Complete date. Direction: Record the general direction of transect (N, NE, E, SE, S, SW, W, NW) its direction accurately in degrees (360◦) Snags on Transect: Record the number of snags (> 15 in dh and > 20 ft tall) found on the transect. Snags/acre: Record the number of snags per acre on the transect (each transect covers 12.5 acres). Snag Density Class: Record the appropriate snag density class (total of seven) into which the transect falls: 0, >0 – 0.5, >0.5 – 1.0, >1.0 – 1.5, >1.5 – 2.0, >2.0 – 3.0 and >3.0 per acre. Observer: Complete name(s), please. DATA TABLE: Record the following for all snags with dbh > 6 in (15.2 cm) Snag Sp.: Species of tree. Distance from start: Distance, in meters, from the start of the transect. dbh: Diameter of snag at breast height (cm). Height: Height of snag in meters. Habitat Description: Do not complete at this time. Directions: Do not complete at this time. Snag Study Plan – 40. Page of SNAG DENSITY Transect #: Location: / Date: Random #: Direction: ( dbh (cm) Height (m) / 100 x 500 m Snags/acre: Snag Density Class: : : : : : : : : NF / Dimensions: ○) Snags on Transect: Snag Sp. Distance from start FORM #6 Observer: /acre : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : /acre : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : RECORD ALL SNAGS GREATER THAN 6 in. DHB (15.2 cm) Habitat Description: Directions: : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :