The Intellectual Property Issue in the
Standardization Process
---A Case Study from China’s Experience
Wenwen Li
China National Institute of Standardization
(CNIS)
Contents
SSO develop Standards (Unifier)
International
and National
Standard
IPR
separated
RAND
Patent holders negotiate with
the standards users
Can’t
afford
afford
Use standard
divided
Give up
Whether can we find a new model to prevent
such division trend and bring the Standards
to their original unifier role ?
#!#"#
$
#!!!$ "$! "
##!#%#&
#" ##""#!"
'
(
AVS
Working Group
Patent Pool
Management Organization
(Non-Profit Organization)
!# #!&"
)
AVS
Working Group
#!%$%% !%
$% #$
%% $ "!% %#!
#$
!(%(#
% %"!!'!
##%!(%(#"% %
"!!
&!$!&%! !&"
,
AVS
Working Group
Patent Pool
Management Organization
(Non-Profit Organization)
"!%&&'&"!%&& !&"'&#&!&#""
+"$!$"'#)%&'#(%"$*'!%
"!$!! !%&$&"!"&&!&""!#&!&
!%%&$"!"$!)&&"")!
#$!#%
$%"!!!"!%$ !&"$*
)&% #!#$&!%!%&$'&'$!
'!$" #&&(!%+
Patent Pool
Management Organization
(Non-Profit Organization)
1.AVS patent pool
management committee
2.AVS patent pool
management center
5 members
represent Public
interests
6 members
represent
6 members
patent holders
represent
Standard users
The director of the
AVS WG
The director of the patent
pool management center
AVS patent pool
management committee
AVS patent pool
management center
1. determine
important AVS
patent licenseroyalty
limitation
1.Administrative work
2.Report to committee
AVS
Working Group
Patent Pool
Management Organization
(Non-Profit Organization)
Manage patents
1. Develop standard
2. Get the Licensing
potential from members
(RF, Patent pool, RAND)
AVS patent pool
management committee
AVS patent pool
management center
!&!!
""!"$!" !#
""""!" !"
""
$ "&! "#"""
"!"" %
!%"""!%
" #"!" '""#" #"!""
!(%$!" "
#
!
"
" !"!! !
"!"! ! !
#!"! ! #!" !%#! "
#!%"! " !
$ "!!!!! ! ! !!!!
$!!"! ! !" ! ! "!