Delaying Seeing a Doctor Due To Cost:

advertisement

Delaying Seeing a Doctor Due To Cost:

Disparity Between Older Adults With and

Without Disabilities in the United States

Jae Chul Lee, PhD

Institute for Healthcare Studies

Feinberg School of Medicine

Northwestern University

Older Adults with Disabilities

 The population aged ≥ 65 is projected to increase from

38.9 million in 2008 (13% of the U.S. population) to 72 million in 2030 (20%) (USDHHS, 2008) .

 “Oldest-old” aged ≥ 85 are the fastest growing segment of the U.S. older population (Himes, 2002) .

 Increased longevity is accompanied by higher prevalence of chronic diseases and conditions (USDHHS, 2006) .

 The impact of disability on society increases with the growth of the older population.

2

Disparities in Access to Health

Care for Older Adults with

Disabilities

 Ensuring adequate health care access is critical for older people with disabilities.

 More prevalent secondary health conditions among those with disabilities.

 Great risk of developing additional health-related challenges.

 There is a paucity of research investigating disparities in access to health care for older adults with disabilities.

 Older Americans aged ≥ 65 are almost universally covered by

Medicare.

 Medicare covers only 45% of health care expenses for institutionalized and non-institutionalized beneficiaries.

 Lack of focus on finding the determinants of disparities in research on health access disparities for older adults.

3

Conceptual Framework

(Andersen, 1995)

 Predisposing : sex, age, race, marital status, education

 Enabling : annual household income, social and emotional support

 Health need : general health status, physical health, mental health, chronic diseases (diabetes, asthma, heart attack, coronary heart disease, stroke)

4

Objectives

 To examine whether there is a disparity in delaying seeing a doctor due to cost between older adults with and without disabilities, after controlling for predisposing, enabling, and health need factors.

 To determine to what extent such a disparity could be accounted for by predisposing, enabling, and health need factors.

5

Methods: Data Source

 Data Source: 2006 Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance

System (BRFSS)

 Collaborative project of the CDC and U.S. states and territories

 Health status, health conditions, preventive health practices, and access to health care

 A probability sample of all households with a telephone

 A cross-sectional telephone survey

 A disproportionate stratified sample design

 Random-digit telephone interview of non-institutionalized civilians aged ≥ 18

6

Methods: Study Sample

 Nationally representative sample of community-dwelling adults aged ≥ 65 who health insurance and a usual source of care (n=86,610).

 Over 97 percent of elderly people aged ≥ 65 are covered by

Medicare.

 Independent and protective effects of having health insurance and a usual source of care on accessing health care (Devoe et al. 2003; Phillips et al. 2004).

 Individuals that do not have these social protections will experience even greater difficulties.

7

BRFSS Questionnaire

 Delay in seeing a doctor due to cost

 “Was there a time in the past 12 months when you needed to see a doctor but could not because of cost?”

 Individuals with disabilities

 “Are you limited in any way in any activities because of physical, mental, or emotional problems?” or

 “Do you now have any health problem that requires you to use special equipment, such as a cane, a wheelchair, a special bed, or a special telephone?”

8

Contd.

BRFSS Questionnaire

 Perceived health

 “Would you say that in general your health is—”

 Excellent, Very Good, Good, Fair, Poor

 “Now thinking about your physical health, which includes physical illness and injury, for how many days during the past 30 days was your physical health not good ?”

 “Now thinking about your mental health, which includes stress, depression, and problems with emotions, for how many days during the past 30 days was your mental health not good

?”

9

Statistical Analyses

 Four consecutive models for multivariate logistic regression analyses

 Model 1: Disability status

 Model 2: Model 1 +

Predisposing

Factors (sex, age, race, marital status, education)

 Model 3: Model 2 +

Enabling

Factors (annual household income, social and emotional support)

 Model 4: Model 3 +

Health Need

Factors (general health status, physical health, mental health, five chronic diseases)

 Analysis Tools

 SAS-callable SUDAAN 10.0

 IVEware

10

Multiple Imputation

 Missing data are prevalent in empirical research.

 Nature of missing data

 Non-response items

 Don’t know/Not Sure, and Refused

 0 to 22.5%

 Outcome and independent variables were used in MI.

 Missing values for each individual in the data set are imputed

“conditional on all values observed for that individual.”

 Five multiply imputed data sets through ten iterations for each data set.

11

Variables and Subcategories

Variables

Outcome   Variables

Independent

Variables

Predisposing  

Factors

Enabling

Factors  

Health   Need  

Factors

Subcategories

Delay   in   Seeing   a   Doctor   due   to   Cost

Sex   (male;   female)

Age   (65   to   74;   75   to   99)

Race   (white;   AA;   HS;   other   race   or   multiracial)

Marital   Status   (married;   widowed;   never   married)

Education   ( ≥ college;   some   college;   HS;   <HS)

Income   ( ≥ $50,000;   $35,000   to   <   $50,000;   $25,000   to   <   $35,000;   $15,000   to   <   $25,000;   <   $15,000)

Social   and   Emotional   Support   (usually   or   always;   sometimes;   rarely   or   never)

General   Health   Status   (good   or   better;   fair   or   poor)

  Health   (<14   days;   14   days   to   30   days)

Mental   Health   (<14   days;   14   days   to   30   days)

Five   Chronic   Diseases

12

Characteristics of Sample

Population

Characteristics

Predisposing Female

Married

Variables With   Disabilities  

(n=33,385;    39%)

62%

Without   Disabilities  

(n=53,225;    62%)

58%

52%

19%

20%

63%

14%

12% Enabling

Less   than   High   School

Less   than   $15,000

Social   &   Emotional   Support  

(Usually   or   Always)

Health   Need General   Health   Status  

(Fair   or   Poor)

Unhealthy   Days   for   Physical  

Health    (14   days   to   30   days)

Unhealthy   Days   for   Mental  

Health    (14   days   to   30   days)

Diabetes   

Stroke  

77%

49%

38%

73%

24%

14%

81%

16%

73%

86%

15%

5%

Differences   between   two   samples   were   statistically   significant   for   all variables   ( p <.001)

Results

 Adjusted Odds Ratios (AORs) for Delay in Seeing a

Doctor Due To Cost

Model   1:   Disability   status

Model

Model   2:   Model   1   +   Predisposing   Factors  

Model   3:   Model   2   +   Enabling Factors

Model   4:   Model   3   +   Health   Need   Factors

AORs   (95%   CI)

2.34

(2.02,   2.70)

2.23

(1.92,   2.58)

2.05

(1.75,   2.39)

1.54

(1.30,   1.81)

 Older adults with disabilities were more likely to delay seeing a doctor due to cost than those with disabilities, after controlling for predisposing, enabling, and health need factors.

14

Results of Model 4

Independent   Variables

Female    [Male]

Age:   75   to   99    [65   to   74]

Non ‐ Hispanic   African   American    [Non ‐ Hispanic   White]

Divorced/widowed/separated    [Married]  

<   High   School    [ ≥ College]

<   $15,000    [ ≥ $50,000]

Social   &   Emotional   Support:   Rarely   or   Never    [Usually   or   Always]

General   Health   Status:   Fair   or   Poor    [Good   or   better]

Unhealthy   Days   for   Physical   Health:   14   to   30   days    [<14   days]

Unhealthy   Days   for   Mental   Health:   14   to   30   days    [<14   days]

Stroke   [No]

* p   <.01;   [      ]:   Referent

Adjusted   ORs    (95%   CI)

1.13

     (0.97,   1.31)

0.79

*    (0.68,   0.93)

1.60

*    (1.29,   1.98)

0.90

     (0.75,   1.09)

1.45

*    (1.12,   1.88)

2.76

*    (2.05,   3.72)

1.67

*    (1.33,   2.08)

1.33

*    (1.11,   1.60)

1.17

     (0.96,   1.44)

1.98

*    (1.51,   2.58)

1.30

*    (1.06,   1.59)

15

Study Limitations

 Limitations related to the participation of people with disabilities in national population surveys.

 Disability Questions: Activity limitation, Use of special equipment

 Potential factors that could affect health care access for older people with disabilities could not be examined.

 Access to public transportation

 Time since onset of disability

 Health care coordination

 Types and sources of health insurance

 Limited number of chronic illnesses were assessed.

 Association ≠ Causation.

16

Conclusions

 Older adults with disabilities who had health insurance and a usual source of care were more likely to report a delay in seeing a doctor due to cost compared to older adults without disabilities.

 Health need factors collectively accounted the most for the delay in doctor visits.

17

Policy Implications

 Policy makers need to judiciously address the economic burden that older adults with disabilities face in maintaining timely doctor visits, especially within the context of the recent health care reform act.

 Efforts to improve the timeliness of physician visits may need to target those who have significant health needs.

18

Next Steps

 Impact of types and source of insurance on access disparities

 Supplemental health insurance

 The impact of healthcare reform legislation

 No preexisting condition restrictions

 Outpatient prescription drug benefit

 Annual wellness visit and personalized prevention plan

 Access disparities by a specific disability

 Disparities from a lifelong perspective

19

Acknowledgements

Collaborators:

Romana Hasnain-Wynia, PhD

Denys T. Lau, PhD

Funding:

Advanced Rehabilitation

Research Training grant from the US Department of

Education, NIDRR (grant no.

H133P080006).

The content of this presentation does not necessarily represent the policy of the Department of

Education, and you should not assume endorsement by the

Federal Government.

20

Download