ENGINEERING TECHNICAL FIELD INFORMATION TECHNICAL NOTES DATA REPORTS CURRENT RETRIEVAL TEXTS AWARENESS SYSTEM Field Volume 4 f Numbers 9 and 10 a Massively Thomas K. Thomas W. S October 1972 of and Billie Crankcase G. Hicks Oils Stockdale Preservation F. - Unstable Region Collins Classification George September Geology Engineering in Notes -_ of Tree Land Corners Butts FOREST SERVICE U.S. DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE FIELD NOTES ENGINEERING This The a monthly newsletter is publication among Forest ideas publication material is in the Service not published exchange to Engineering information intended publication be exclusive to all engineers for However engineers. technicians and engineering because publication Center to like number the issues It all provide would Service from material Engineers The length submitted of to Each has Region accommodate an and written neatly The The contained in Alfred R-3 Dan R-4 Fleet R-5 Jim this the The the interpretation use of reader. of whom - Buerger Stanton McCoy has Department information of to several or acceptable is personnel field increase instructions typewritten edited prepare before the Bakke Kjell R-8 R-9 Clifford R-10 Gerald WO Stan its submit both should are Ernest Quinn been developed Forest Service mandatory Office will edit and Coordinators Roper report this to for Hill Coghlan Bean the guidance contractors assumes Agriculture by other than its of and its employees of the cooperating no responsibility for own employees. trade firm or corporation names is for the information and convenience of Such use does not constitute an official evaluation conclusion recommendation endorsement be or use Coordinator space. R-6 R-2 S. printed copy and a personal sentences Washington to contain cannot several format and allowable Coordinator Department of Agriculture Federal and State agencies. The U. Regional are for this or printed R-1 Information Information Forest copies purpose. Copies of back and can be ordered on form 7100-60. Office may vary from Office. our Information all receiving Use form 7100-60 be informative article and material for publication. questions or the Regional to Adequate of the always an directly the type Field Notes be primarily written and used by Forest material from other publications may be used. in however the Washington to camera copy Office Offices. you are not now Washington the Material need not be typed pages. If sent to your office. that the Field copy. ask your Office Manager copies also available policy. being a personal Note material should Field or who wish of are distributed from the Washington Laboratory and Research Area one intended is is Station of read each monthly should issue. The and personnel. suitable. or approval of any product or service to the exclusion of others which may NOTES FIELD REGION A MASSIVELY UNSTABLE EARLY DETECTION OF SLIP-SURFACE GEOMETRY ENGINEERING By GEOLOGY IN Thomas K. Collins and Billie G. Hicks Klamath National Forest Region 5--California The Klamath National Forest in northern California contains one of most landslide-prone regions of the world. High rainfall steep slopes and weak foundation materials have combined to produce hundreds of landslides. The greatest instability is found in the the western part of the Forest in a zone 20 miles wide centered along the Klamath River. Graphitic slates and serpentinized-ultrabasic rocks are especially unstable in this zone. on the Klamath Forest about 70 miles of new roads are timber harvesting and recreational access. One of the jobs of the engineering geologists is to make foundation studies for road route planning and design. The foundation studies provide location data for building roads which will have the least impact in terms of triggering new landslides or reactivating dormant landslides. The following deals with one aspect of these foundation studies Making a preliminary estimate of slip-surface geometry based on the field expression of head scarps and lateral scarps. Every year built for ROADS AND INCIPIENT LANDSLIDES massively unstable zone on the Klamath National Forest one common situations encountered during reconnaissance engineering geology is the discovery of a ground crack across a The ground crack may be very subtle but it proposed road route. can usually be traced up the slope then across the slope and finally down the slope to where it crosses the proposed road route A landslide is developing and the ground crack marks the again. In the of the trace of the and lateral scarps. If the landslide is scarp the scarps will be visible and their angles can be head more developed measured. con-struction on this field data the effect of the landslide on road must be determined. How large and how deep is the landslide What is the shape of the slip surface and will the road cut slope undermine it with other foundation Along conditions some estimates of the landslide geometry must be made to determine Based 1. Whether this section of causing unacceptable at Engineering Geologists held 1971 can be built without resource damage Annual Meeting of the Association of in Portland Ore. 1/Presented the road 1 What 2. to alteration of design standards may be required the landslide with least disturbance and cross Whether potential maintenance costs or resource damage justifies expenditures for landslide stabilization. 3. pro-gram On the Klamath Forest evaluation of incipient landslides must be made without benefit of and seismic drilling usually exploration. The landslides are usually inaccessible by hiking and there except are so many landslides that the cost of a detailed exploration for each one is prohibitive. field evidence was Therefore examined to see what clues there might be to the size and shape of the slip surface. Scores of landslides in various stages of examined. We found that the topographic expression development were of ground cracks head scarps and lateral scarps on some incipient landslides could be used to make rough estimates of slip-surface These projections were found most applicable to slumps geometry. and to bedrock failures e.g. wedge failures. slip-surface addition reconnaissance geometric analysis exploration program The preliminary estimate of on existing roads._ the geometry guided placement of drill holes and seismic foundation data with least cost and spreads to obtain maximum of the a better estimate exploration costs. proposed In to location road this pro-vided in drawing up was helpful for landslides LANDSLIDE a drilling and seismic WIDTH stability analysis usually pictures a landslide in longitudinal cross section from the crown to the foot. Based on the known slope distance and the elevation difference of the crown and the foot various hypothetical slip surfaces are fitted to the longitudinal When the only limiting conditions are the slope cross section. distance and the elevation difference between crown and foot then many slip surfaces must be considered in safety factor analysis and many geometric variations from the actual slip surface must be Slope considered. determine the slip-surface geometry especially depth more Landslide the width of a landslide can be very useful. accurately width can lead to more realistic boundary limits than landslide Three problems are found in using length length slope distance. To alone 1. As time passes the head scarp often continues to fail the crown migrates upslope. The potentiality of many variations in landslide length introduces many variations in estimating slip-surface geometry especially On most landslides width is a more stable boundary depth. measurement. In general length will change more than width. and 2 2. length is a greater distance than the length may be 800 feet and the width 200 feet. If only the length and width are known there is more room for errors in determining the depth of the slide surface by using length rather than width. On many landslides width. 3. TRANSVERSE example For Length alone will not indicate the correct orientation Some of the longitudinal profile of a slip surface. landslides e.g. wedge failures do not move directly down the dip of the slope they move at some angle to the dip of the slope. By considering the symmetry or asymmetry of the width boundaries lateral scarps the orientation of the slip surface can be better located. PROFILES A landslide can be viewed along its width by a transverse cross section just as its length can be viewed by a longitudinal cross section. Some typical transverse profiles of slip surfaces can be After the landslide debris examined on existing slope failures. has moved downslope out of the source area the slip surface is Field examination of numerous exposed slip surfaces reveals exposed. similar to the profiles in transverse profiles of slip surfaces of bedrock failures 1. The is characteristic V-shaped figure profile controlled by major geological structures such as faults and bedding The U-shaped profile is characteristic of failures in planes. as soil and marine or weakly consolidated materials such terrace deposits. uncon-solidated it is possible to obtain a rough Using this schematic geometry of surface on many landslides. For example depth approximation slip fail. A fresh head and lateral hillside has started to a scarp In plan view fig. the lateral scarps are are visible. scarps the width of the landslide is therefore fairly roughly parallel constant. The width measured from the left to right lateral scarp 4 is 100 feet. lateral scarp 2 In transverse profile fig. dip 450 and measure 5 feet each the in left slope and right distance. is likely to reach the maximum depth that the slip surface The 450 lateral scarps are projected to maximum will be considered. depth in this case 50 feet See transverse profile of slip surface A in fig. 2. A wedge failure along the intersection of two faults could such a produce V-shaped profile. However unless there is evidence to suggest a wedge failure the slip surface will probably the slip surface not have such a steep Instead V-shpaed profile. the lateral scarps will be more U-shaped. Based on this assumption Transverse be to more transverse can projected probable profiles. First profiles U-shapes. B C The and D in figure general shape 2 and are projections of some typical maximum depth of profiles B C 3 and Figure 1. --Transverse Profiles Landslide 4 of Slip Surfaces ORIGINAL GROUND SURFACE LATERAL S CARP LANDSLIDE D 0 SURFACE -- - - --/ 41 C 10 20 30 B \ 00 / 40 50 VERTICAL Figure 2. CROSS SECTION --Transverse Profiles Landslide of Slip Surfaces D are based on field measurements of exposed on slip surfaces found On landslides having a U-shaped slip surface such other landslides. slumps as consolidated materials the maximum depth from the surface to the slip surface often ranges from 10 to the landslide width. in weakly initial ground percent of 35 Depending on how much of the lateral scarp is exposed and on the the estimated shape of the ground surface range for maximum depth can be narrowed down even further. Also the topographic expression of other landslides in the area may provide some clues to the shape maximum depth of the transverse profile to be projected. For example colluvium in a certain area might usually fail on a bedding the slip surface will plane which parallels the slope therefore have a longer flatter central profile than a deep slump would have. Another aid is the head scarp. The angle of the head scarp can be measured and a probable slip surface can be projected from it onto a and Then the slip surface on the longitudinal longitudinal cross section. cross section can be correlated with the slip surface on the transverse cross section. The geometry of the slip surface can be further delimited by interpretation of the boundary scarp of the landslide. PLAN VIEW The boundary the left of lateral can plan views scarp Two shapes of a landslide includes scarp right both the head The plan view scarps. sometimes indicate the general shape of and slip are illustrated in figure 3 as of the the scarp and boundary slip surface. representative of two surfaces. In plan view A the boundary scarp has an inverted The V-shape. distinctive feature is the asymmetry and linearity of the lateral The trace of one or both lateral scarps on the ground scarps. surface does not run directly down the dip of the slope. A linear lateral scarp which trends downslope at a large angle to the dip of the slope is characteristic of many landslides controlled by a major geological structure e.g. a fault a bedding plane or a prominent When major geological structures are planar their trace on joint. a uniform slope is linear. When randomly orientated planar structures are involved in landslides they often produce linear asymmetrical lateral scarps. For a given slope the trend of the lateral scarp will depend on the strike and dip of the planar structure. On controlled by the intersection of two planar surfaces the transverse profile of the slip surface from lateral scarp to lateral will usually have an asymmetrical.V-shape fig. scarp item A. land-slides 1 3 B In the second item plan view fig. the trace of the head scarp on the ground surface is a curve and the traces of the lateral are rough symmetrical lines which trend directly down the scarps dip of the slope. Sometimes the boundary scarp will include only 6 B Figure 3. --Landslide Plan View 7 Boundary Scarps The significance of the head scarp to the rough symmetrical lateral the from a steep to a more gentle dip along type of landslide the transverse profile of from the left to the right lateral scarp is the curved COMPARISON section. OF THE TWO from the change scarps is the curved change On this slip surface. the slip surface taken U-shaped. PLAN VIEWS first plan view the asymmetry and linearity of the boundary characteristic of landslides controlled by major geological The landslide i.e. faults bedding plans and joints. structures In the are scarp can be viewed failure as in an anisotropic medium. In the second uncon-solidated view boundary scarp and in weakly consolidated are characteristic of landslides materials e.g. colluvium and marine terrace deposits. In some the landslide can be viewed as failure in an respects plan the curve and the rough symmetry of the isotropic medium. THE CHORD A landslide whose boundary scarp has a plan view similar to figure 4 often has a slip surface which drops off steeply from the crown and the lateral scarps then flattens out between to an angle approximately the The longitudinal equal to or less than original ground slope. profile of the slip surface in figure 5 is a schematic representation the actual slip of this relationship. This profile is diagrammatic be On the view in 4 a chord surface may more curved. plan figure line is drawn which connects the extremities of the curve of the and which lies within the plane of the original ground surface. crown From the top of the crown a perpendicular line to the chord can be constructed which lies within the plane of the original ground surface. The slope distance along this perpendicular line is labeled In S. 5 D longitudinal cross section fig. a perpendicular line labeled surface is constructed from the chord to to the original ground the slip surface. This perpendicular line will intersect the slip surface near the area along which the slip surface abruptly changes from a steep to a more gentle is a dip. Perpendicular line D If approximation of the maximum depth to the slip surface. of the head scarp and the original ground slope are known angle can be solved trigonometrically. For example depth line rough the the D 50 feet S Slope crown distance to 500 Angle of head 250 Angle of from top of chord scarp original ground slope 8 rn D n D N cý o v a 6 1HS SCARP 1da31d1 LATERAL dýdýS LEFT 1 rn ý $ o HEADSCARP 50 j / Gj PROJECTION OF CHORD s o SýýpE \ ýPNp / / VERTICAL i ýPQ PROý\MP Figure 5. --Longitudinal Profile of Landslide Slip Surface CROSS SECTION D S Tan of angle of head scarp - angle original ground slope D 50 Tan D 23 feet 50 - 25 0 portion of the slip surface from the crown to the abrupt the and not as continuously steep as dip may be curved the angle of the head head scarp it is usually best to decrease will used in the formula by several degrees depth scarp Since the change in D corre-spondingly be reduced. SUMMARY measure-ments gathering all field measurements which limit the topographic expression of the slip surface and then correlating these in longitudinal and transverse cross section the geometry of This geometric a slip surface can be estimated within certain ranges. but it is not helpful on numerous landslides analysis has been found By The cases presented are meant to apply to all landslides. general meant as guides. The of unstable slopes will often complex causes For example produce many variations from this schematic geometry. the plan view of a boundary scarp in an isotropic medium may be rather than symmetrical because of the non-uniform asymmetrical distribution of ground water. work is continuing on these and other aspects of slip-surface More data some of these initial modify geometric geometry. may The is to the best 3-dimensional projections. goal put together picture of the slip surface that limited data permits. Field CLASSIFICATION OF CRANKCASE OILS com-bined By Thomas W. Stockdale Region 3--Albuquerque conditions under which internal combustion engines have been operating have gradually become more severe. These conditions with anti-pollution devices and higher operating temperature have made it necessary to develop higher gradecrankcase lubricating The oils. For many The user the MIL years there was no one industry-wide rating system for oils. of a MIL specification found it very difficult to correlate specification with an SAE specification for example. 11 SAE American Petroleum Recently the Society of Automative Engineers Institute American Society of Testing Material many and the military combined forces to of the vehicle manufacturers classification The set of and one specifications system. develop one API ASTM desig-nations following two and charts show descriptions the of latest each in oil the the previous classes normal gasoline and commercial categories New API Old Class Crankcase Oil Classification Gasoline Engine Type New Class SA ML - Description of Oil oil w/o Mild conditions additive except possibly a foam depressant anti-oxidant and antiscuff. MM Minimum protection afforded by some antioxidant SB compound-ing and antiscuff capa-bilities. In use since 1930s. MS1964 SC Covers 1964-1967 manu-facturers warranty low temperature antisludge and antirust performance. MS1968 SD Covers 1968-1971 manu-facturers warranty more protection against low temperature antisludge and antirust performance. May be None SE used in place of SC. Covers highest require-ments of 1972 model vehicles high temperature antioxidation plus low temperature antisludge and Note designated in the station type lubricants for gasoline Oils to service 12 S antirust. series crankcase engines. refer New API Crankcase Oil Classification - Commercial Engine Type Old Class old MIL-A MIL-B Sup. 1 old old New Class Description of Oil diesel with quality fuel and mild gasoline engine service. Used in late 1940s and 1950s. Normal protection from corrosion and deposits. CA Light DG duty aspira-tion MIL-A MIL-B Moderate duty diesel with low quality fuel and mild gasoline engine Introduction in service. 1949. Normal aspiration protection from corrosion CB CB 1 Sup. DM old old and deposits. super-S-3 MIL-B Moderate CC 101-B DM duty diesel and lightly Introduced in. charged. 1961. Protection from gasoline old high temperature deposits diesel only engines and low rust tempera-ture corrosion deposits. DS duty diesel with supercharger and in high MIL-L-45199B speed high output S-3 CD Severe pro-tection from corrosion high temperature deposits with any fuel range. Note C designated in the series refer commercial type crankcase lubricants for gasoline and diesel engines. Oils to Dou-bling SA and SB pumps furnace older engines only or general lubrication for and electric.motors. SD type oils are much better than SC especially in rusting and deposit resistance. the zinc dithosphate from 0.09 to 0.18 percent has helped make the SE type oil. Other additives include sulfurized phenates and oils are for blowers 13 The SE type oil may be used in place calcium alkyl phenyl sulfides. The new classification for both normal gasoline of SD or SC oils. engine oils and commercial engine oils is open ended new categories Manufacturers may be added without changing the old designation. needs and petroleum companies may indicate may indicate lubrication suitability by the new classification. However overall testing of SE oils is handled by the ASTM. General Motors assist in the testing. manufacturers also auto many for low temperature rust and high temperature for example tests for oil insolubles Ford tests sludge lubricating qualitie6. manufacturers also help in the Other formation and varnishing. The U.S. testing. Department of Defense tests for bearing corrosion The cost to be qualified is approximately in the SE type oils. The $8000. SE it be used when the type oils should always Most and manuals. in his owners guides station wagons require 1/2 SE manufacturer all 1972 Chevrolet recommends oil. recommends sedans and SE for oil 3/4.and 1-ton trucks. Dodge and Ford recommend SD quality oils. However a driver may want to use SE oil after summarizing his specific driving habits loads trailer pulling 1972 their grease-like accessories oil switch and on to the SE speeds. driver notices a a solidified draining oil low oil might solve the problem. dip type If stick slow oil pressure a A number of oils are now available that may be used as a single lubricant source for all types of equipment--from the sedan station wagon light truck variety to large turbocharged crawler-type diesel tractors. These so-called goofproof-type oils enable a diversified and fleet to use only one oil.which saves on time inventory oils may It is important to note however that many of these be rated SE or CD but not both. Depending upon the type of a fleet manager may not want to consider oils that do not meet con-fusion. equip-ment highest quality the in levels boththe normal gasoline and commercial categories. in providing a crankcase oil requirements of Caterpillar and the low ash content To meet the warranty requirements of Detroit Diesel. must be less requirements for Detroit Dieselthe total ash content than 1 percent. Most of the diversified type fleet oils rated CD will meet Caterpillar and Detroit Diesel specifications. These oils may be used without restriction in all Forest Service diesel In the that past would some difficulty has meet both the Series arisen 3 equip-ment. In summary with and oils difficult has for most the controls fleet definitely taken regulations becoming more strict the classification of crankcase for the better. The API SAE ASTM and manager a step 14 have combined Department of Defense and many automotive companies in providing a most useful and practical classification of crankcase oils. In most cases the quality of oil required by the manufacturers owners guides and manuals is satisfactory. It may be beneficial to use higher quality recommended by the manufacturer especially class one of oil in vehicles all in a lubricants if than those it is possible fleet. By LAND CORNERS to use using one class it is possible to save on storage space take advantage of bulk prices and eliminate the possibility of a lower grade oil being used in an engine requiring the highest quality lubricant. PRESERVATION By OF TREE George F. Butts Registered Land Surveyor Green Mountain National Forest How should we remonument a living tree corner This question was asked in the Restoration and Monumentation Committee LSD ACSM in March of 1971. Our discussion of a method developed and used on the Green Mountain National Forest seemed to answer the question. A written procedure of this method may assist other in surveyors answering the same question. This method uses a 5/8-inch diameter by 36-inch long copperweld survey marker with a brass head as a reference marker. Normally two markers per corner tree are used however three or four are used when conditions dictate. The markers are driven flush with the ground very close to the tree but not so close that the growing tree will displace the marker. The flush markers are not easily seen and possibly misinterperted by lay users of the property bounds. The flush markers resist being displaced by falling timber logging vehicles or other traffic. When setting the markers good reference must be practiced. marking A dimple is cut in the brass head to mark the on exact the point 1 marker. Object No. The exact point of the tree by set up surveyor developed at over of On reference and Forest we our BO-2 ofa the this to obtain follows etc. corner 1-foot point the tree an identifying character is stamped generally stamp BO-1 Bearing is generally accepted as the center instrument cannot Because an stump height. a procedure must be used required measurements. 15 The that enables the procedure we 1. The 2. With copperweld the rods bearing instrument occupying to corner tree distances C-12 and angle to BO-1 to set are C-12 BO-1 see to BO-2 corner described above. as fig. angle measured are tree 1 and C-12 and BO-1 to BO-2 are preserve the actual side shot on the tree a tack is placed for sight and a nail placed on the side survey of the tree for distance so that observations from BO-1 will define the exact corner point as near as may be determined without cutting the tree. Figure 2 shows a typical view of taken. a 3. 4. To corner The tree as seen from the instrument. instrument is moved to BO-2 to BO-1 and BO-2 D-1. to C-12 B9-2 to tree corner to corner tree and are are C-12 to D-1. angles turned and distances C-12 measured. trees center from BO-2 need not be If a enough to detect major blunders. closed run sufficient observations have been made to detect large blunders in the remaining lines. The error generated by a short backsight is eliminated by The determination of exact the accurate only traverse is sighting on C-12 from BO-2. CORNER TREE STA -2 11116 / STA C-12 Figure 1. --Diagram 16 of traverse. D-I A TACK NAIL Figure 2. --Corner tree tack and In addition showing nail. being recognized by laymen living trees other land corner monument possesses--they to have an dis-appearance advantage impossible to move. no The trees are however subject to are nearly rapid bulldozers or other hazards. by fire hurricane If the tree is destroyed corner the exact corner can be precisely relocated with little effort from the copperweld markers. If only one marker remains the bearing thus EDITORS NOTE exact the corner can be original corner relocated by running the proper point is preserved. Note that the copperweld monument is used for a reference mark. Actual legal land corner monuments installed under the Forest Service Cadastral Program must meet or exceed standards in FSM 7150. Engineer-ing 17 CORRECTIONS for 1972--Whos Field Who in 4 Volume Numbers 7 and 8 July-August Washington Office Division of Engineering. Notes the 1 On page Richard G. Deleissegues name was inadvertently Please line out misspelled and placed in the wrong position. Data System Dicks name and leave that position Technical Place Mr. Deleissegues name in the position marked vacant. Recruitment Development vacant at the top of page 2 Technical and Training. 4 The Photographic Laboratory has moved to Rosslyn Va. page to area code 703 Ralph Fortunes phone number has changed On 557-3150. On 5 page extension third to paragraph Change 70491. 18 William R. Kinworthys phone