Confirming the opportunities for Irish Suppliers within the UK Gluten/Wheat Free Market Data ending 52 weeks17th February 2013 © Kantar Worldpanel KANTAR WORLDPANEL METHODOLOGY Purchase Demographically Representative Social Class Main Shopper Age Number of Children Size of Household Region of residence 30,000 GB Households continuously reporting their purchasing Key Areas Purchase Data can be Used 1. Understanding the shopper and their behaviour 2. Building trade relationships 3. Growing Brands/ Category 4. Gaining & protecting listings 2 © Kantar Worldpanel KANTAR MARKET DATA IS THE CURRENCY WITHIN THE INDUSTRY 4 © Kantar Worldpanel How big is Gluten Free and how does it perform? Which sectors are best to play in? Where are the retailer opportunities? Who are the key brands? Which shoppers should we go after? 5 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE GF BAKERY 6 © Kantar Worldpanel DEFINITION OF KANTAR GLUTEN/ WHEAT FREE MARKET Any product with (GF) / Wheat Free (WF) in the barcode description and well known GF Brands. Termed Gluten Free as all Gluten Free is also Wheat Free For example: ALDI GF HAM JOINTS DEBBIE AND ANDREW GF SAUSAGES KALLO ORG GF RICE CAKES NAIRNS WF OAT CAKES MR MASH GF TESCO FF CHEESE YOUNGS FF FISHFINGERS 7 © Kantar Worldpanel How big is Gluten Free and how does it perform? © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE GLUTEN FREE: MEDIUM SIZED, EXCEPTIONAL GROWTH Total Grocery +3.7% Total Free From +24% Same size as: Shellfish £180m +37% Extra £48m Larger than: Nuts Herbs& Spices Tinned Fruit Lemonade 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 9 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE SHOPPERS DRIVE OVER HALF OF GROWTH, DEMONSTRATING AN APPETITE FOR GLUTEN FREE (GF) £27m £12m £3m £6m Penetration Frequency Trip Size Price / pack 42% of HHs 6 trips a year 1.7 packs £1.65 +8% +2% +4% 11m HHs 18% *Penetration contributions includes Population growth of 1% 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 10 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE IN THE LAST YEAR, MORE AND MORE SHOPPERS HAVE ENTERED THE MARKET AND BASKET SIZES HAVE INCREASED Frequency Trip Packs Price per Pack Penetration (%) Total Contribution (£000s) Accelerated growth 60,000 Contribution 50,000 40,000 30,000 20,000 10,000 0 -10,000 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 11 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE TESCO FREEFROM DRIVE A HIGH PROPORTION OF GROWTH IN GLUTEN FREE BUT THE OVERALL IMPACT OF THE SMALLER RANGES CONTRIBUTE THE MOST Asda Free From Debbie & Andrews Marigold Mrs Crimbles M+S Contribution to YOY% The Black Farmer Dietary Specialities Doves Farm Kallo Organic Doves Farm Organic Kallo Nairns Naked Food Co M+S Free From Sainsbury Freefrom Aldi Genius Look What We Found Warburtons Gluten Free Tesco Freefrom All Others Only splits out top 20 ranges 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 12 © Kantar Worldpanel 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 13 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE THESE THREE SECTORS ALONE ACCOUNT FOR NEARLY 80% OF TESCO FREE FROM GROWTH Which sectors contribute the most to Tesco Free From growth? Liquid Dairy Alternatives Chilled Desserts 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 14 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE WARBURTONS CONTINUAL GROWTH NOW MAKES IT LARGER THAN DIETARY SPECIALITIES Tesco Freefrom Warburtons Gluten Free Genius Dietary Specialities Sainsbury Freefrom Nairns 20,000 18,000 16,000 Value sales £000s) 14,000 12,000 10,000 8,000 6,000 4,000 2,000 0 Graph only displays top 6 ranges 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 15 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE WARBURTONS FIRST LAUNCHED INTO THE GLUTEN FREE MARKET IN JANUARY 2011 AND HAVE SINCE EXPANDED THEIR RANGE 2012 2011 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 16 © Kantar Worldpanel 17 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE WARBURTONS TARGET SUFFERERS WITH THEIR NEW ‘SPECIALIST’ LOOK More specialised – focusing on sufferers 18 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE THIS SPRING ANOTHER A-LIST FMCG PLAYER, HEINZ LAUNCHES “shoppers were often reluctant to try gluten-free products as they tended to be made by relatively unknown brands” Corn, Potato and Lupin Flour Available in Tesco, Morrisons and Asda stores from Spring 2013 19 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE 49% OF ALL GLUTEN FREE BUYERS THIS YEAR ARE NEW TO THE CATEGORY (5.6M HHs) Who are the lost shoppers? • 98% nonsufferers • Sweet Biscuits • Pasta • Chilled • Rice cakes Bought both years 51 61 Repeat Only bought in 2013 New 49 39 Only bought in 2012 Lost Last year This year 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 20 © Kantar Worldpanel Is a trend to buy Gluten Free behind the influx of new shoppers? 22 © Kantar Worldpanel Possibly. Celebrities are encouraging a gluten free diet World No. 1 Novak Djokovic has played in three Grand Slam finals since switching to a gluten-free diet. „Gluten Free is the way to be‟ 'Everyone should try no gluten for a week. The change in your skin, physical and mental health is amazing. U won‟t go back!‟ © Kantar Worldpanel However, it’s not all good publicity “Every single nutritionist, doctor and health-conscious person I have ever come across… seems to concur that (gluten) is tough on the system and many of us are at best intolerant” © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE INDICATING A TREND, 97% OF NEW GF SHOPPERS ARE NOT SUFFERERS However, new shoppers buy a wide range of brands, indicating an interest in the category overall Wheat or Gluten Intolerant HHs Non allergic HHs 2.8 Mr Mash 6 8 Look What We‟ve Found Aldi 10 Tesco Free From 10 97.2 New, Non sufferering shoppers (Spend % 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 25 © Kantar Worldpanel TOTAL FREE FROM ALTHOUGH A TREND MAY HAVE ENCOURAGED SHOPPERS RECENTLY, GF HAS POSTED SIGNIFICANT GROWTH FOR THE LAST THREE YEARS AND HAS ALWAYS DRIVEN FREE FROM SALES Total Free From Gluten &/or Wheat Free Other Free From 40 37 35 30 24 YOY % Value Change 25 20 17 15 12 8 10 5 19 14 12 10 8 8 3 0 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 26 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE THE FUTURE OF GLUTEN FREE… Room to grow: ˃Gluten Free Brands in the UK look to the US to predict trends in the UK ˃US Gluten free foods industry $4.2 billion 1% of US grocery ˃Gluten Free in the UK is still only 0.1%. Greater exposure: ˃Large FMCG brands continue to launch: Tesco, Heinz & Warburtons Increasing need: ˃Extra 5.6 Million more GB households buying Gluten Free this year ˃Coeliac Disease 4 X more common than 50 years ago ˃Houses can turn into a Gluten Free Zone 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 27 © Kantar Worldpanel How big is the Gluten/ Wheat Free Market? £180M Is it growing and for how long? +37% 10 x faster than grocery and not slowing yet What drives growth? Shoppers who are not just Gluten/ Wheat intolerant © Kantar Worldpanel Which sectors are best to play in? © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE BREAD AND CHILLED GOODS ACCOUNT FOR 20% OF THE MARKET AND BOTH SEE GROWTH OF OVER 10% Chocolate Confectione ry Bread Main Meals Pizzas Sweet Biscuits Decline more than -5% Frozen Cook + Pour Over Sauces Macaroons Seasonal Whole/Slab Cakes Decline between -5 and 0% Cereal Bars - Multi Pack Dry Pasta Sweet Pastry Morning Goods Cake Liquid Slices/Cake Dairy Free Bars Altrntv Growth between 0 and 5% Cereal Bars Individual Flour Chilled Desserts USA Muffins Rice/Corn Snacks Growth between 5 and 10% Speciality Bread Growth more than 10% Cereal Meal Solutions Crackers+Sav Rolls/Baps/B oury Biscuits uns/Bagels Excludes Other and Liquid Dairy Free Alternatives 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 30 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE GLUTEN FREE AISLE IS PURELY AMBIENT OFFERING • Dual siting • Wide variety but cluttered • Promotional activity Tesco store, Surrey, UK 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 31 © Kantar Worldpanel Gluten Free Ambient Bakery © Kantar Worldpanel GF BAKERY AMBIENT BAKERY CATEGORY DEFINITION Bread Cake Slices/Bars Macaroons Morning Goods Rolls/Baps/Buns/ Bagels Rye Bread Speciality Bread USA Muffins Whole/Slab Cake 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 33 © Kantar Worldpanel Gluten Free Ambient Bakery Total Free From +24% Total Gluten Free +37% £46m +18% Ambient Bakery accounts for just over a ¼ of all GF sales Total Ambient Groceries +4.2% 26 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 34 © Kantar Worldpanel GF BAKERY IN CONTRAST TO TOTAL MARKET - WARBURTONS DRIVE GROWTH. TESCO FREEFROM HAS A NEGATIVE IMPACT TO GROWTH WHICH THEY WILL WANT TO ADDRESS All Others Livwell Contribution to YOY% Dietary Specialities Asda Free From Tesco Freefrom Ok Foods M+S Mrs Crimbles Village Bakery Biona M+S Free From Antoinette Savill Lazy Day Morrisons Free From Wait Love Lfe Gluten Free Sunstart Sainsbury Freefrom Yes You Can Gluten Free Waitrose Lve Lf Free From Genius Warburtons Gluten Free Only splits out top 20 ranges 35 © Kantar Worldpanel GF BAKERY WITHIN GF AMBIENT BAKERY, BREAD IS LARGEST; SPECIALITY BREAD, CAKE SLICES & MORNING GOODS ARE ALL KEY. USA MUFFINS PROVE THAT A NEW CATEGORY CAN QUICKLY BECOME A KEY PART OF GF 3 3 7 3 6 7 Rye Bread 9 Macaroons 10 7 9 12 11 16 14 Whole/Slab Cakes USA Muffins Rolls/Baps/Buns/Bagels Morning Goods 38 42 Cake Slices/Cake Bars Speciality Bread Bread 2012 2013 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 36 © Kantar Worldpanel GF BAKERY ONLY MUFFINS PERFORM AHEAD OF THE GF MARKET. BREAD POSTS STRONG GROWTH, SIGNIFICANT, GIVEN THAT IT IS THE LARGEST SECTOR YOY Growth USA Muffins 180 TOTAL GLUTEN FREE MARKET 37 Bread 29 AMBIENT BAKERY 18 Rye Bread 16 Morning Goods 15 Cake Slices/Cake Bars 9 Macaroons 4 Speciality Bread 2 Rolls/Baps/Buns/Bagels -8 Whole/Slab Cakes -9 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 37 © Kantar Worldpanel GF BAKERY THE MAJORITY OF BAKERY CATEGORIES ATTRACT MORE SHOPPERS THIS YEAR Penetration % Purchase Frequency Trip Packs Price per Pack Contribution 7m 4m 2m 0.5m 0.4m 0.1m 0.1m AMBIENT BAKERY Bread USA Muffins Morning Goods Cake Slices/Cake Bars Speciality Bread Rye Bread Macaroons -0.3m -0.3m Whole/Slab Cakes Rolls/Baps/Buns/Bagels -2,000 -1,000 0 1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000 7,000 8,000 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 38 © Kantar Worldpanel Total Market Trends GF could capitalise on © Kantar Worldpanel TOTAL UK GROCERY A GF ALTERNATIVE TO CRUMPETS, BAGELS AND BRIOCHE COULD MEET DEMAND Fastest growing ambient bakery and morning good sectors Crumpets +12% Bagels +7% *Sectors in the total market and £68M not GF £123M Brioche +25% £59M Crepes and Pancakes +7% £48M Sandwich Thins +100% £27M Pitta, Wraps and Naans +100% £23M 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 40 © Kantar Worldpanel TOTAL UK GROCERY HEALTHY BISCUITS WOULD APPEAL TO HEALTHY GLUTEN FREE BUYERS. Healthier Biscuits £188M +28% 41 © Kantar Worldpanel TOTAL UK GROCERY READY MEAL OFFERING IS LIMITED FOR GLUTEN FREE, YET IT IS A FAST GROWING LARGE SECTOR IN THE TOTAL MARKET Total Market Chilled Ready Meals £2.4Bn +8% Total Market Chilled Pizza and Bases £430M +6% EXISTING GLUTEN FREE ALTERNATIVES GROW, DEMONSTRATING A NEED Gluten Free Meal Solutions and Pizza Growth +100% 42 © Kantar Worldpanel TOTAL UK GROCERY READY MEALS CAPITALISE ON THE GROWING CONVENIENCE FOCUS Continued strong growth in online and convenience - target of opening 1 to 2 small stores per week DRIVEN BY CONSUMER DEMAND Yoy Growth % Online to launch in H2 2013. Launch of London M Local stores supported by new distribution centre TOTAL UK GROCERY TRADE GAIN HIGHER PRICES & LOWER RELIANCE ON PROMOTIONS THROUGH TARGETING THE ‘FOR TONIGHT’ MISSION „FOR TONIGHT‟ MISSIONS PAY A „FOR TONIGHT‟ MISSIONS BUY 13% 25% PRICE PREMIUM OVER „MAIN SHOP‟ LESS ON DEAL THAN „MAIN SHOP‟ This is especially the case within Chilled Ready Meals TOTAL UK GROCERY ‘FOR TONIGHT ‘ IS LARGEST WITHIN CONVENIENCE CHANNELS; GLUTEN FREE NEED A PRESENCE TO AVOID MISSED SALES 7.4 9 25.6 27.1 19.8 16.9 34 38.5 Specific Journey 57.8 53 9 12.1 Main Shop For Tonight 37.2 9.3 Replenishment 32.5 10.9 Tesco excl Conv Sainsbury's excl Tesco Express & Online Conv & Online Sainsbury's Local Total MFP, 52 w/e Feb 17th 2013 Which sectors should we play in? Chilled and Bread are the largest. Morning Goods and Cake Bars are also important to Bakery Opportunity in Gluten Free Crumpets, Bagels, Pizza, Healthier Biscuits and Ready Meals © Kantar Worldpanel Who are the key brands? © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE A GLUTEN FREE(GF) PRODUCT CAN BE A GF SUCCESS WITHOUT BEING A SPECIALIST PRODUCT WITHIN THE GF AISLE TOP SELLING GF SKU’S £4.5m -5% £4.4m 7% £2.8m 3% £2.4m 103% £3.8m 179% £2.4m £3.6m 14% £3.2m 40% £2.1m £2.1m +++% New Smaller Size 535gm 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE BRANDS DOMINATE THE MARKET AND HAVE DONE FOR THE PAST 5 YEARS Brands are even more prominent in GF Bakery: 74% 2013 2012 2011 31 30 2010 29 32 2009 Branded 38 62 68 71 Private Label 70 69 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 54 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE OPPORTUNITY IN BOTH BRANDS AND PRIVATE LABEL WHERE BOTH SEE STRONG GROWTH In GF Bakery – brands drive growth +25% as PL only grows at 3% Branded 50 44 40 33 30 YOY % Value Change Private Label 29 20 16 10 4 0 20 18 -3 -10 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 55 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE BRANDS STILL ATTRACT MORE SHOPPERS, WHILST PRIVATE LABEL RELIES ON EXISTING FOR GROWTH Penetration % This is Purchase Frequency a similar story in GF Bakery Trip Packs Price per Pack – attracting 230,000 more shoppers Branded +33% £30m Private Label +44% £17m -5,000 0 5,000 10,000 15,000 20,000 25,000 30,000 35,000 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 56 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE IN ALL BIG 4 RETAILERS, BRANDS ARE MOST IMPORTANT. TESCO RELY MORE ON THEIR PRIVATE LABEL Branded 69 TOTAL MARKET 31 65 Tesco 35 77 Asda 23 71 Sainsbury's 29 75 Morrisons 25 96 Co-Operative 4 90 Waitrose Hard Discounters Private Label 11 17 83 M&S 0 100 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 57 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE 5 TOP SELLING GLUTEN FREE BRANDS 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 58 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE WARBURTONS IS THE ONLY TOP BRAND TO OUT PERFORM THE MARKET. GENIUS REMAINS THE #1BRAND. DIETARY SPECIALITIES GROWTH SIGNIFICANTLY BEHIND THE MARKET 2. £10.6m +103% 1. £12.3m +22% 4. £7.1m +17% 3. £9.7m +5% 5. £4.8m +25% 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 59 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE WARBURTONS ARE STILL ATTRACTING NEW SHOPPERS DESPITE THEIR RANGE LAUNCHING OVER 2 YEARS AGO Penetration % -2,000 Purchase Frequency -1,000 0 1,000 Trip Packs 2,000 Price per Pack 3,000 4,000 5,000 Contribution Share 5.4m 5.9 2.2m 6.8 1m 3.9 1m 2.7 0.4m 5.4 6,000 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 60 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE 5 TOP SELLING GLUTEN FREE PRIVATE LABEL RANGES 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 61 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE ALDI OUT PERFORM THE MARKET, ALONG WITH TESCO’S FREE FROM. ASDA’S FREE FROM RANGE IS THE ONLY PL TO SEE A DECLINE IN SALES 2. £10.7m +19% 1. £17.9m +97% 3. £5.5m +66% 4. £3.9m -18% 5. £3.5m +8% 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 62 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE ASDA WILL BE LOOKING TO ALTER THEIR RANGE TO ATTRACT SHOPPERS INTO THEIR GLUTEN FREE RANGE LIKE ALL OTHER RETAILERS Penetration % Purchase Frequency -2,000 0 Trip Packs 2,000 4,000 Price per Pack 6,000 8,000 Contribution Share 8.8m 9.9 2.2m 3.1 1.7m 5.9 0.3m 2.0 -0.8m 2.2 10,000 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 63 © Kantar Worldpanel GF BAKERY HOW MANY GLUTEN FREE BAKERY SECTORS DO THE TOP BRANDS OPERATE IN? 1. Bread 2. Morning Goods 3. Rolls/Baps/Buns/Bagels 4. Speciality Bread 5. Whole/Slab Cake 1. Bread 2. Morning Goods 3. Rolls/Baps/Buns/Bagels 4. Speciality Bread 5. Whole/Slab Cake 1. Bread 2. Morning Goods 3. Rolls/Baps/Buns/Bagels 4. USA Muffins 1. Bread 1. Bread 2. Rolls/Baps/Buns/Bagels 3. Speciality Bread 1. Cake Slice/Cake Bars 1. Cake Slice/Cake Bars 2. Macaroons 3. USA Muffins 1. Bread 2. Rye Bread Bakery brands worth more than £500k 52 w/e up to 17th March 2013 64 © KantarWorldpanel Worldpanel © Kantar GF BAKERY 6 RANGES GENERATE 78% OF GF BAKERY VERSUS +20 RANGES IN TOTAL AMBIENT BAKERY. MOST BRANDS OUTSIDE OF GENIUS AND WARBURTONS LOSE SHARE 2012 23 Share Spend % 24 11 2013 9 6 5 5 3 3 2 2 1 1 1 Morrisons FF Biona Sunstart Yes You Can Gluten Free Waitrose Lve Lf Free From Livwell (Livwell Ltd) Asda Free From Tesco Freefrom Mrs Crimbles M+S Sainsbury Freefrom Dietary Specialities Warburtons Gluten Free Genius Top Selling GF Bakery Ranges 52 w/e up to 17th March 2013 65 © KantarWorldpanel Worldpanel © Kantar GF BAKERY COMPETITIVE TO LAUNCH IN KEY BAKERY SECTORS 90% Bread is made up of Genius and Warburtons 90% Speciality Bread is Dietary Speciality 90% Morning Goods is Warburtons and Livwell 60% of Cake Bars/Slices is Mrs Crimbles and Sunstart 67 © KantarWorldpanel Worldpanel © Kantar GF BAKERY ALTHOUGH KEY BRANDS DOMINATE, NPD GENERATES MORE SPEND IN GF BAKERY THAN TOTAL BAKERY Gluten Free Market Spend £000‟s NPD Market Share 180,002 139,866 Excluding NPDs NPD 2,453 £40m Gluten Free Bakery 22% Total Ambient Bakery 15% Bread 8% Morning Goods 18% Cakes & Pastries 20% Including NPDs 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 68 © Kantar Worldpanel Which SKUs generate the most sales? Not just specific GF brands Does Own Label dominate the market? No, Brands dominate and attract more shoppers Who is the branded competition? Genius & Warburtons generate 50% of the Bakery market & gain share at the expense of other brands Which brands underperform? –Dietary Specialities, Livwell and Mrs Crimbles all lose share, putting their shelf space at risk © Kantar Worldpanel Where are the retailer opportunities? © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE ASDA USED TO OUT PERFORM THE MARKET, SINCE TESCO EXPANDED FREEFROM RANGE THEY LOSE OUT TO TESCO, HARD DISCOUNTERS AND M&S 140 TOTAL MARKET Tesco Asda Sainsbury's Morrisons Co-Operative Waitrose Hard Discounters Marks & Spencer 120 YOY % Value Change 100 80 60 40 20 0 -20 -40 -60 CAUTION! Lower M&S Buyer Numbers 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 71 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE ALTHOUGH M&S ONLY GENERATE 5% OF GLUTEN FREE, THEY ARE THE THIRD BIGGEST CONTRIBUTOR TO THE GROWTH OF THIS MARKET Penetration % Purchase Frequency Trip Packs Price per Pack Contribution £ 20.1m Tesco 8m Sainsbury's Marks & Spencer 4.2m Asda 3.5m Waitrose 3.1m Hard Discounters 2.7m Morrisons 2.5m -100k Co-Operative -5,000 0 5,000 10,000 15,000 20,000 25,000 72 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE TESCO GENERATES A THIRD OF SALES AND GROWS- CANNOT IGNORE. SAINSBURY’S WILL BE KEEN TO CLAW BACK LOST SHARE. Tesco Sainsbury's Asda Waitrose All Others Marks & Spencer Hard Discounters Co-Operative 100% 10 1 6 7 5 7 2 6 7 5 4 3 6 8 4 3 4 6 3 4 5 6 9 8 70% 9 11 12 12 11 60% 10 10 11 15 13 26 23 25 22 28 29 26 26 30 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 90% 80% Value Share of Trade % Morrisons 5 50% 40% 21 30% 20% 10% 0% 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 73 © Kantar Worldpanel METHOD OF IDENTIFYING RETAILER OPPORTUNITIES PRINCIPLE: ˃ A RETAILER‟S SHARE OF A CATEGORY SHOULD BE THE SAME AS THE MARKET. ˃ EXAMPLE: ˃ ASDA HAS A 14.7% SHARE OF GROCERY AND A 12.7% SHARE IN GLUTEN FREE. THEY SHOULD HAVE 14.7% SHARE IN GLUTEN FREE. ˃ CALCULATION FOR ASDA SIZE OF PRIZE: 14.7% OF GLUTEN FREE MARKET £180M= £26.4M ˃ £26.4M MINUS WHAT THEY CURRENTLY MAKE- £22.8M ˃ ASDA STAND TO GAIN £3.6M IF THEY WERE TO GENERATE THEIR FAIR SHARE OF GLUTEN FREE 74 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE OPPORTUNITY IN ASDA, MORRISONS AND CO-OP AS ALL HEAVILY UNDER TRADE IN TOTAL GLUTEN FREE 27.2 Tesco 30 15 Sainsbury's 20.5 14.7 Asda 12.7 11.1 Morrisons Co-Op 2.9 £3.6m £6m 7.8 5.6 Total Grocery £4.8m 4.3 Waitrose 10.6 M&S 3 Aldi 2.5 Gluten Free 5 3.7 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 75 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE OPPORTUNITY IN SAINSBURY’S, MORRISONS AND WAITROSE TO GROW GLUTEN FREE FASTER. SAINSBURY’S AND WAITROSE DEMOGRAPHICALLY SIMILAR TO GF SHOPPER- EASIER TO CONVERT Marks & Spencer 86 Hard Discounters 65 Tesco 59 TOTAL MARKET 37 Sainsbury's 28 Morrisons 22 Waitrose 20 Asda Co-Operative 18 -1 £2.7m £1.7m £2.8m £3.6m £2.1m 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 76 © Kantar Worldpanel Gluten Free Ambient Bakery © Kantar Worldpanel GF BAKERY ASDA AND MORRISONS COULD GAIN £1.8M IF FAIR SHARE OF GF AMBIENT BAKERY IS ACHIEVED. OPPORTUNITY WITHIN ALDI WHO CURRENTLY DO NOT OPERATE IN THIS AREA 27.2 Tesco 32.2 15 Sainsbury's 18.5 14.7 Asda 12.2 11.1 Morrisons £1.1m £755K 9.5 5.6 5.9 Co-Op 4.3 Waitrose GF Ambient Bakery 12.4 3 M&S Aldi Total Grocery 6.4 2.5 0 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 78 © Kantar Worldpanel GF BAKERY IF SAINSBURY’S ASDA, M&S AND WAITROSE GREW IN LINE WITH THE GF BAKERY MARKET THEY COULD GAIN AN ADDITIONAL £3.3M Total Tesco 55 Total Morrisons 19 TOTAL MARKET 18 The Co-Operative 18 Total Sainsbury's 11 Total Asda 8 Total Marks & Spencer Total Waitrose -1 -10 £523K £508K £555K £1.8M 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 79 © Kantar Worldpanel GF BAKERY Outperform Gluten Free Bakery LONG TERM OPPORTUNITY Undertrade GF Bakery Market SHORT TERM OPPORTUNITY Overtrade GF Bakery Market Underperform in Gluten Free Bakery © Kantar Worldpanel GF BAKERY Value Share of Trade % TESCO HEAVILY OVER TRADE IN BREADS AND MUFFINS BUT UNDER TRADE IN ALL OTHER SECTORS. THE REST OF THE BIG 4 COULD EXPAND THEIR BREAD OFFERING Tesco Sainsbury's Asda Waitrose All Others Marks & Spencer Hard Discounters Co-Operative 6 6 5 7 8 11 10 13 12 12 8 4 9 6 10 12 8 13 6 12 16 21 19 31 30 32 9 7 12 12 18 5 12 5 10 19 20 11 22 5 14 9 23 13 4 22 23 19 15 35 60 34 22 18 16 12 17 41 Morrisons 19 46 45 7 7 24 14 CAUTION! Low Buyer Numbers 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 82 © Kantar Worldpanel No.1 Retailer: 30% share Drive the market: +60% No. 1 OL Range Tesco have seen phenomenal growth in Gluten Free and their Free From range is now No. 1 Sufferers are an important group, spending £200k more on grocery a year in Tesco than the average shopper Tesco under trades in Branded Gluten Free, Morning Goods, Cake Bars & Slices and Rolls, Baps and Buns. Should Tesco achieve their fair share, they stand to gain £1.5M (£540, £604k and £359k) Bagels, Crumpets, Brioche perform well in the market, could the retailer stock a GF version to help gain their fair share? 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 © Kantar Worldpanel No.2 Retailer: 20% share Underperform: +28% Turnaround GF Bread (-6%) Whilst Sainsbury’s over trade in Gluten Free and have a similar average shopper, the retailer under performs. If Sainsbury’s grew in line with the market they would gain an additional £2.7M Sufferers are an important group in Sainsbury’s spending £100k a year more than their average grocery shopper Sainsbury’s under trades in Free From Bread and also under performs (-6% versus the markets 30% growth). Should they gain their fair share this would be worth an additional £629K Dietary Specialities Bread declines by 17% in the market, and within Sainsbury’s, could the retailer replace some of their SKU’s with a new GF Bakery product to help drive growth? 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 © Kantar Worldpanel No.3 Retailer: 13% share Under trade: 13% versus 15% £3.6M Prize Underperform: +18% Asda under trades and under performs in Gluten Free Ambient Bakery. The retailer could gain an additional £1.1M if it was to generate the same share as it does in total Gluten Free Asda have the opportunity to gain their fair share in Bread (£809k) and Macaroons (£100k), Whole Slab Cakes (£133k) if they generated 12% of these sectors as they do Total GF Bakery Dietary Specialities Bread declines by 17% in the market, and within Asda, could the retailer replace some of their SKU’s with a new GF Bread product to help drive growth? 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 © Kantar Worldpanel No.4 Retailer: 10.6% share Over trade yet underperform: +20% and -10% Bakery Waitrose Under performs within Gluten Free in contrast to their fast growth in Total Grocery. If the retailer grew in line with the market they would have made an additional £2.8M The Gluten Free shopper is very closely demographically aligned to a Waitrose shopper, increasing the chance that Waitrose could convert their shoppers to buy Gluten Free. Waitrose declines in GF Ambient Bakery by 10% driven by Rolls, Baps, Buns, Bagels, Speciality Bread and Cake Bars. Waitrose also under trade in Specialty Bread and Cake Bars. Should Waitrose gain their fair share of 12%, the retailer could gain an additional £470K and £300k. 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 © Kantar Worldpanel No.5 Retailer: 7.8% share Under trade 8 % versus 11% £6M Prize Underperform: +22% Morrisons Under Trades and under performs in Gluten Free and stands to gain an additional £6M if it generated the same 11% grocery share in Gluten Free. The retailer currently struggles in the Total grocery market, and would be keen to ensure that all growth areas are covered Morrisons under trades in Total GF Ambient Bakery and specifically Morning Goods. If the retailer gained their fair share in Morning Goods (10%) this would be worth an additional £130k 33 brands are sold in Morning Goods in the Total GF Bakery market, Morrisons stock only 4. Could Morrisons dedicate more space to this area that is seeing growth of 15%? 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 © Kantar Worldpanel Which retailers do I need to play in? Tesco and Sainsbury‟s Which retailers need help? Asda and Morrisons under trade Waitrose and Sainsbury‟s under perform © Kantar Worldpanel Which shoppers should we go after? © Kantar Worldpanel WE IDENTIFIED THE GLUTEN FREE SHOPPERS THAT HAVE AN ALLERGY/ INTOLERANCE AND COMPARED THEIR PURCHASING TO NON SUFFERING GLUTEN FREE SHOPPERS 91 © Kantar Worldpanel 1M HH HAVE A GLUTEN ALERGY/ WHEAT INTOLERANCE, WHICH IS ALMOST 4% OF GB HOUSEHOLDS GLUTEN FREE PRODUCTS ARE ALSO WHEAT FREE, ALLOWING WIDER TARGET AUDIENCE Wheat Intolerant HHs 47% 32% 21% Gluten Allergic HHs MAT Feb 13 – 1yr continuous panel 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 92 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE SUFFERERS ARE AFFLUENT AND MORE LIKELY TO BE SOUTHERN AN ATTRACTIVE GROUP TO APPEAL TO Gluten and Wheat Allergic ˃ Majority 1-2 member households ˃ Majority don‟t have children in the household ˃ Over-index on ABC1 ˃ More likely to be 35-54 year old ˃ Bias towards pre-families and older dependents ˃ Strong over-index on South 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 93 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE SUFFERERS GENERATE 51% OF GLUTEN FREE SPEND. EQUAL SPLIT OF TARGETTING SUFFERERS AND NON SUFFERERS. IMPORTANT FOR TRADE TO NOT LIMIT PRODUCTS TO GF AISLE 60 31 76 73 GF Ambient Bakery 50 Total Gluten Free 40 30 Wheat or Gluten Intolerant HHs 20 10 0 8 7.7 Buyer % 51 50.8 Spend % 41 41.5 Vol % MAT Feb 13 – 1yr continuous panel 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 © Kantar Worldpanel GF BAKERY ALTHOUGH SUFFERERS ONLY ACCOUNT FOR 31% OF BUYERS THEY GENERATE 76% OF SALES AS THEY ARE MUCH HEAVIER SHOPPERS Shopper habits within Gluten Free Bread GF Bread Spend Volume Price per Trip per trip per Kg Frequency Spend Volume Sufferer 13.2 £41 15.94Kg £3.1 Non Sufferer 3.5 £11.19 4.34Kg £3.17 1.204Kg £2.57 1.23Kg £2.58 Per Household © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE NON-SUFFERERS DRIVE THE MAJORITY OF GROWTH-AN IMPORTANT GROUP Who contributes to Gluten Free growth? Gluten &/or Wheat Free = +37% Wheat or Gluten Intolerant HHs +34% Non allergic buying GF +71% Less than Gluten &/or Wheat Free Greater than Gluten &/or Wheat Free 0 MAT data 20 40 60 80 Expenditure YoY (%) 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 96 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE HEALTH IS IMPORTANT TO NON SUFFERERS AND A LIKELY DRIVER TO PURCHASING GLUTEN FREE. A HEALTHY PRODUCT WILL APPEAL TO THIS IMPORTANT GROUP My diet is very important to me I try to lead a healthy lifestyle Total Responders Recently I have become more aware of whether the foods I buy are good for me Wheat or Gluten Intolerant HHs The nutrional labelling on food & drink products has an effect on what I buy Non allergic buying GF I restrict how much sugary food I eat 0 Health of Britain – 1-yr continuous 20 40 60 80 100 % of Households agreeing 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 97 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE NON SUFFERERS BIGGEST OPPORTUNITY IS ENCOURAGING THE PURCHASING OF MORE CATEGORIES. PRODUCTS SHOULDN’T BE LIMITED TO GLUTEN FREE AISLE. Total Responders 2.1 Wheat or Gluten Intolerant HHs 7.2 Non Gluten or Wheat 1.6 0 2 4 6 8 Average number of GF sectors bought per year MAT Feb 13 – 1yr continuous panel 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 © Kantar Worldpanel GF BAKERY HARDER FOR GF TO COMPETE WITH MAIN STREAM PRODUCTS AS CURRENTLY AT A PREMIUM Grocery Av Price GF Av Price Price Diff Bread 86p £2.58 £1.72 Morning Goods 79p £2.04 £1.25 Speciality Bread 79p £1.85 £1.06 Rolls / Baps / Buns / Bagels 97p £1.83 86p Whole / Slab Cakes £1.93 £2.66 73p Cake Slices / Cake Bars £1.05 £1.72 67p USA Muffins £1.08 £1.68 60p Rye Bread £1.17 £1.46 29p 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 99 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE SECTORS LESS RELIANT ON SUFFERERS HAVE MAIN STORE SITING 89 Main Meal Pizza 87 USA Muffins 81 Speciality Bread 80 Bread 79 Cereals 77 Whole/ / Slab Cakes Wheat or Gluten Intolerant HHs 76 Total Ambient Bakery 73 Morning Goods 68 Rolls / Baps / Buns / Bagels Non Gluten or Wheat 65 Cake Slices / Bars 63 Sweet Biscuits 44 Macaroons 43 Rice / Corn snacks 38 Rye Bread 36 Cereal Bars 17 Meal Solutions 0 20 40 60 80 100 SPEND % 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 102 © Kantar Worldpanel GF BAKERY ASDA MUCH MORE POPULAR WITH NON SUFFERERS THAN SUFFERERS SO IT WOULD PAY OFF FOR ASDA TO TARGET THIS GROUP SPEND % Total Hard Discounters 100 90 4.8 2.1 4.3 3.3 80 11.1 11.2 20.7 19.8 70 60 50 13.3 18.5 40 30 20 42.3 36.8 Total Waitrose The CoOperative Total Morrisons Total Sainsbury's 10 Total Asda 0 Total Tesco Wheat or Gluten Intolerant HHs Non Gluten or Wheat allergic 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 105 © Kantar Worldpanel KEY TO ATTRACTING NON SUFFERERS WILL BE AVAILABILITY OF GLUTEN FREE IN THE WHOLE STORE ONLY 2% SHOPPERS VISIT MORE THAN HALF THE STORE IMPORTANT FOR GLUTEN FREE TO NOT BE LIMITED TO THE FREE FROM AISLE GLUTEN FREE CHILLED READY MEALS, PIZZA, HEALTHY BISCUITS WILL HELP BRANCH PRODUCTS OUTSIDE OF GF AISLE 106 © Kantar Worldpanel … HOWEVER, IT IS IMPORTANT TO REMEMBER THAT ALMOST 80% AMBIENT BAKERY SPEND IS GENERATED BY SUFFERERS Wheat or Gluten Intolerant HHs 75.8 TOTAL MARKET 78.2 Total Tesco Non Gluten or Wheat allergic 69.3 Total Asda 76.6 Total Sainsbury's 75.7 Total Morrisons 67.2 The Co-Operative 77.5 Total Waitrose Total Hard Discounters 100 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 SPEND % Chart Footnote 107 © Kantar Worldpanel KEY TO ATTRACTING SUFFERERS WILL BE EXPANDING THE SELECTION REQUIREMENT FOR GLUTEN FREE ALTERNATIVES TO SECTORS IN DEMAND SUCH AS MORNING GOODS HEALTH IS IMPORTANT TO SUFFERERS SO A FOCUS ON LOWER CALORIE PRODUCTS COULD HELP TO GROW FURTHER REMEMBER TRUST AND QUALITY IS KEY TO THIS GROUP 108 © Kantar Worldpanel Which shoppers should we target? Both Sufferers and Non Sufferers through a „by the way, we‟re gluten free‟ approach. © Kantar Worldpanel How big is Gluten Free and how does it perform? £180m +37% 115 © Kantar Worldpanel Which sectors are best to play in? Bagels, Crumpets, Speciality Bread, Ready Meals & Healthy Biscuits 116 © Kantar Worldpanel Who are the key brands? Warburtons and Genius dominate Bakery Opportunities in both brands and PL elsewhere 117 © Kantar Worldpanel Where are the retailer opportunities? Short term – Tesco and JS Long term – Morrisons and Asda 118 © Kantar Worldpanel Which shoppers should we go after? Target both sufferers and non sufferers through main store location 119 © Kantar Worldpanel …and by the way, it’s Gluten Free 120 © Kantar Worldpanel Appendix- slides to add © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE AN INFLUX OF SHOPPERS DRIVES OVER HALF OF GLUTEN FREE GROWTH 52 w/e 19 52 w/e 17 Change Feb 12 Feb 13 (Actual) Measure Spend (£000) Packs (000s) Penetration (%) Frequency Spend per Buyer (£) Volume per Buyer (Packs) Spend per Trip (£) Volume per Trip (Packs) Price per Pack (£) 131,766 83,223 35.23 5.41 14.27 9.01 2.64 1.67 1.58 180,023 108,890 41.49 5.84 16.43 9.94 2.81 1.70 1.65 +48,257 +25,667 +6.26 +0.43 +2.16 +0.92 +0.17 +0.04 +0.07 Change (%) Value up 36.6% worth £48.3m +36.6% +30.8% +17.8% +8.0% +15.1% +10.3% +6.6% +2.1% +4.4% 0 10,000 20,000 30,000 40,000 50,000 60,000 Spend (£000) £180m (+36.6%) +£48.3m Packs (000s) Price per Pack (£) 108.9m (+30.8%) +£41.8m £1.65 (+4.4%) +£6,428k Volume per Buyer Penetration (%) 9.9 (+10.3%) +£14.7m 41.5% (+17.8%) +£27.2m Frequency Volume per Trip (Packs) 5.8 trips (+8%) +£11.6m 1.7 (+2.1%) +£3,079k * Penetration contribution includes population growth of 0.8% 123 © Kantar Worldpanel GF BAKERY GLUTEN FREE BAKERY – BRANDS 52 w/e 19 52 w/e 17 Change Feb 12 Feb 13 (Actual) Measure Spend (£000) Packs (000s) Penetration (%) Frequency Spend per Buyer (£) Volume per Buyer (Packs) Spend per Trip (£) Volume per Trip (Packs) Price per Pack (£) 27,451 13,215 5.20 7.25 20.15 9.70 2.78 1.34 2.08 34,276 16,136 6.02 7.51 21.58 10.16 2.87 1.35 2.12 +6,825 +2,921 +0.82 +0.25 +1.43 +0.46 +0.10 +0.02 +0.05 Change (%) Value up 24.9% worth £6,825k +24.9% +22.1% +15.7% +3.5% +7.1% +4.7% +3.5% +1.2% +2.3% 0 1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000 7,000 8,000 Spend (£000) £34.3m (+24.9%) +£6,825k Packs (000s) Price per Pack (£) 16.1m (+22.1%) +£6,170k £2.12 (+2.3%) +£655k Volume per Buyer Penetration (%) 10.2 (+4.7%) +£1359k 6% (+15.7%) +£4,811k Frequency Volume per Trip (Packs) 7.5 trips (+3.5%) +£1,015k 1.4 (+1.2%) +£344k * Penetration contribution includes population growth of 0.8% 124 © Kantar Worldpanel GF BAKERY GLUTEN FREE BAKERY – PRIVATE LABEL 52 w/e 19 52 w/e 17 Change Feb 12 Feb 13 (Actual) Measure Spend (£000) Packs (000s) Penetration (%) Frequency Spend per Buyer (£) Volume per Buyer (Packs) Spend per Trip (£) Volume per Trip (Packs) Price per Pack (£) 11,952 6,071 3.31 5.55 13.76 6.99 2.48 1.26 1.97 12,292 6,347 3.40 5.38 13.70 7.07 2.55 1.32 1.94 +340 +276 +0.08 -0.18 -0.06 +0.09 +0.07 +0.06 -0.03 Change (%) Value up 2.8% worth £340k +2.8% +4.5% +2.5% -3.2% -0.4% +1.2% +2.8% +4.5% -1.6% -1,000 -500 0 500 1,000 Spend (£000) £12.3m (+2.8%) +£340k Packs (000s) Price per Pack (£) 6347k (+4.5%) +£538k £1.94 (-1.6%) -£198k Volume per Buyer Penetration (%) 7.1 (+1.2%) +£152k 3.4% (+2.5%) +£386k Frequency Volume per Trip (Packs) 5.4 trips (-3.2%) -£382k 1.3 (+4.5%) +£535k * Penetration contribution includes population growth of 0.8% 125 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE OCADO CONTINUE TO GROW AT TOTAL GROCERY BUT GLUTEN FREE SALES SEE A MASSIVE UPLIFT FROM LAST YEAR Total Grocery 508,238 52 w/e 20 Mar 11 52 w/e 17 Apr 11 +10% +14% Gluten Free 1,845 52 w/e 20 Feb 11 637,458 577,453 52 w/e 15 May 11 52 52 w/e w/e 12 10 Jul Jun 11 11 3,092 2,005 52 w/e 07 Aug 11 52 w/e 04 Sep 11 52 w/e 02 Oct 11 52 w/e 30 Oct 11 52 w/e 27 Nov 11 52 w/e 25 Dec 11 52 w/e 22 Jan 12 +9% 52 w/e 19 Feb 12 52 w/e 18 Mar 12 +54% 52 w/e 15 Apr 12 52 w/e 13 May 12 52 52 w/e w/e 10 08 Jul Jun 12 12 52 w/e 05 Aug 12 52 w/e 02 Sep 12 52 w/e 30 Sep 12 52 w/e 28 Oct 12 52 w/e 25 Nov 12 52 w/e 23 Dec 12 52 w/e 20 Jan 13 52 w/e 17 Feb 13 52 w/e up to 17th March 2013 126 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE Gluten Free Mixes 1600 TOTAL GF MIXES 1400 Bread Mixes 1200 913 1000 800 Breadcrumbs Cake Mixes 600 Packet Stuffing 400 Pancake Mix 200 Pastry Mixes 0 52 w/e up to 17th March 2013 127 © Kantar Worldpanel GLUTEN FREE Gluten Free Flour 4000 3500 TOTAL GF FLOUR 3000 2500 Bread Flour 2000 1500 Other Plain Flour 1000 500 Self-Raising Flour 0 52 w/e up to 17th March 2013 128 © Kantar Worldpanel GF BAKERY ASDA AND MORRISONS COULD GAIN £1.8M IF FAIR SHARE OF GF AMBIENT BAKERY IS ACHIEVED 25.9 Tesco 32.2 14.7 Sainsbury's 14.2 Asda 12.2 9.5 8.4 Co-Op £1.2M 5.9 4.1 Waitrose £1.1m £1.1m 11.9 Morrisons 12.4 GF Ambient Bakery 4.7 M&S Aldi Total Ambient 18.5 6.4 3 0 52 w/e up to 17th February 2013 129 © Kantar Worldpanel Gluten Free Bakery – Gains/Loss Total Tesco Total Asda Total Sainsbury's Total Morrisons The Co-Operative Total Switching Total Iceland Shoppers Held Total Waitrose Ocado Internet Shoppers Won Aldi Lidl Category Arrivals Total Marks & Spencer All Others -2,000 -1,000 0 1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000 Switching based on Spend (£000s) to year ending 17-Feb-13 130 © Kantar Worldpanel Asda‟s Switching losses in GF Bakery Switching Spend (£000s) to Total Asda - year ending 17 Feb 2013 Total Morrisons Total Waitrose The Co-Operative Total Marks & Spencer Total Iceland Net switching - Spend (£000s) Aldi Lidl Ocado Internet All Others Total Sainsbury's Total Tesco -200 -150 -100 -50 0 50 100 131 © Kantar Worldpanel Switching Flow Summary Total Tesco Total Sainsbury's Total Iceland Total Morrisons Total Marks & Spencer Total Waitrose Total Asda Aldi The Co-Operative Lidl All Others Ocado Internet 132 © Kantar Worldpanel