4/9/13
Second Liens and the Holdup Problem in First Mortgage Renegotiation | ncbankruptcyexpert.com
Ed Boltz: Bankruptcy Attorney
4th Circuit Court of Appeals
Law Reviews & Studies
News
ncbankruptcyexpert.com
Your North Carolina Bankruptcy Expert
NC Bankruptcy Cases
NC Court Cases
Law Review: Agarwal, et al.- Second Liens
and the Holdup Problem in First Mortgage
Renegotiation
Feb
6
Abstract:
This study from researchers at the Federal Reserve finds that several factors encourage
2nd mortgage lien holders to “hold up” loan modification unless they can recover some
price about the true value of the 2nd lien. This factors include:
(1) That foreclosures frequently generate no proceed above what is owed on the 1st
mortgage, 2nd lienholders have little incentive to proceed themselves;
(2) 2nd lienholders have no obligation to comply with short sales or other voluntary
liquidations;
(3) 1st lienholders fear that modification could alter lien priority; and
(4) 2nd lienholder’s hope that non-performing mortgages may improve in the future.
Based on this, the study finds that 2nd lien-holder often prevent loan modification and
other voluntary resolutions of mortgage issues. This analysis was controlled for the
already known difficulties that securitization presents for voluntary loan modification.
Party Status
Owns 2nd
Log in
Subscribe
Sign up for NC
Bankruptcy Expert Blog
News Letter
First Nam e
Last Nam e
* = required field
Preferred Form at
HTML
& 2nd Liens
Lien
2nd Lien Hold-Up
Securit izat ion Hold-Up
No
No
Y es
Y es
Mobile
Subscribe
powered by MailChim p!
Services 1 st Lien Only
We Offer A Free Bankruptcy
Consultation. We hav e offices in
Raleigh, Cary , Durham ,
Greensboro, Fay ettev ille and
Wilson.
N/A
My Yahoo
Twitter
Facebook
Recent Posts
Bankr. W.D.N.C.: In re
Eagan- Absolute
Priority Rule in
Individual Chapter 11;
Valuation of Minority
Interests
Bankr. E.D.N.C.:
McClendon v. Walter
Home Mortgage- Usury
and Unfair & Deceptive
Trade Practices
4th Circuit: Rogers v.
River Hills- Extrinsic
Evidence cannot be
Used to Supplement
Property Description
Bankr. W.D.N.C.: In re
RTJJ- Confirmation of
Chapter 11 Plan
Categories
4th Circuit Court of
Appeals
About Us
The purpose of the NC
Bankruptcy Expert blog is to
prov ide legal professionals with a
consolidated resource for updates
and case sum m aries about issues
and decisions affecting
bankruptcy , foreclosures,
m ortgages, and debt collection.
Proud Member of:
Services 1 st & 2nd Liens
RSS Feed
Bankr. M.D.N.C.: In re
Gilley- Dischargablity of
SEC Settlements under
11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(19)
Text
FREE Consultation
Summary:
Search...
Register
Em ail Address*
Loss mitigation actions (e.g., liquidation, renegotiation) of delinquent mortgages might
be hampered by conflicting goals of lenders at different seniority. In particular, a servicer
has less incentive to take certain actions to reduce losses of investor-owned first lien
mortgages if the servicer happens to own the second lien claim secured by the same
property. Rather, the servicer has an incentive to hold up loss mitigation as it seeks to
preserve the values of its own, junior, claim. The Study shows that a sizable fraction of
delinquent mortgages with multiple liens are indeed characterized by the servicer holding
a direct financial interest in the junior liens, but not the first-lien mortgage. The Study
further shows that such cases are less likely to be liquidated or modified, and are instead
more likely to not receive any loss mitigation actions from their servicers. Supporting the
idea that second lien lenders pursue more profitable modifications, The Study finds that
modification terms are less concessionary and redefault rate is lower. These results
highlight a specific incentive-driven channel by which separation of mortgage ownership
and servicing may present an impediment to loss mitigation of delinquent mortgages.
Owns & Serv ices 1 st
Members
Y es
No 2nd Lien
Eastern District
Ed Boltz: Bankruptcy
Attorney
Law Reviews & Studies
Middle District
NC Court of Appeals
NC Courts
NC Supreme Court
Cases
News
North Carolina
Bankruptcy Cases
Uncategorized
Western District
This study shows that when there is a 2nd mortgage, the likelihood of a mortgage
modification is substantially lower. This is compounded when the servicer of the 1st
mortgage does not own that mortgage, but also services and owns the second mortgage.
This would seem to present a clear conflict of interest and potential breach of fiduciary
ncbankruptcyexpert.com/2013/02/06/law-review-agarwal-et-al-second-liens-and-the-holdup-problem-in-first-mortgage-renegotiation/
1/2
4/9/13
Second Liens and the Holdup Problem in First Mortgage Renegotiation | ncbankruptcyexpert.com
duty to the actual holder of the 1st mortgage.
Commentary:
This study does not mention that 2nd mortgages can often be eliminated in a Chapter 13
bankruptcy through a “strip-off” of that mortgage. This elimination should increase the
likelihood that 1st mortgages would subsequently agree to a mortgage modification, as
the 2nd mortgage “hold up” has been removed. This is part of the basis for the Principal
Paydown Plan supported by NACBA:
http://www.americanbanker.com/issues/176_246/fhfa-fannie-freddie-bankruptcy1045074-1.html
Monthly Archives
March 2013
February 2013
For a copy of the study, please see:
January 2013
http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2022501
October 2012
July 2012
June 2012
May 2012
Be Sociable, Share!
April 2012
March 2012
February 2012
January 2012
Tags: junior lien-holders, mortgage modification, mortgage servicer
December 2011
November 2011
October 2011
Posted by Ed Boltz
Law Reviews & Studies
Subscribe to RSS feed
Leave a Reply
Y ou must be logged in to post a comment.
Copyright © 2013 ncbankruptcyexpert.com• All rights reserved.
Bankruptcy Information by Ed Boltz: Law Offices of John T. Orcutt | Website Customized By: Wicked Web Art
"We are a debt relief agency. We help people file for bankruptcy relief under the Bankruptcy Code."
ncbankruptcyexpert.com/2013/02/06/law-review-agarwal-et-al-second-liens-and-the-holdup-problem-in-first-mortgage-renegotiation/
2/2