Paper 3 Human Options
UNIT 2 Environmental management
Recommended Prior Knowledge Not essential, but candidates who have studied IGCSE Geography, Natural Economy or a Science subject are likely to
have some knowledge of the basics of energy and power supplies.
Context There will be some linkage to the material studied in the AS Physical Core, Unit 2.4, regarding the human impact on the environment: urban effects
on climate, particularly pollution. In addition, AS Human Core, Unit 3.2 Urban trends and issues of urbanisation, may have looked at the difficulties of
upgrading parts of urban areas, in terms of dealing with pollution, etc. This unit will take the topic further by looking at and evaluating the success of possible
solutions to the problems.
Outline This section is divided into two discrete but inter-related sections: energy supplies and environmental degradation.
This unit will examine the patterns of supply and demand for different energy resources, and the factors that encourage or limit their development/exploitation.
It will examine both renewable and non-renewable resources and the environmental impacts resulting from their exploitation. Case studies of the
development of different energy sources will illustrate the issues raised. The distribution of power sources is geographically uneven, necessitating the
formulation of energy strategies by local and national governments to ensure the best possible exploitation/procurement of their energy needs, with the least
harmful impact on the physical environment. Exploitation of other natural resources may contribute to the economic wellbeing of an area, but may also
produce undesirable environmental consequences. There is a need for the development of strategies to combat the effects of over-exploitation of natural
resources in rural areas, and the effects of industrial and urban growth in urban areas. The solutions are not always successful. A key expansion of content
in the revised syllabus is water resources and water quality (2.3).
www.XtremePapers.net
Content
2.1 Sustainable
energy supplies
Objectives
To understand the
differences between
renewable and nonrenewable energy
resources
Terminology
Sustainability
Renewable energy
Non-renewable
energy
Energy budget
Fossil fuels
Hydro-electric
power (HEP)
Solar energy
Biofuels
Tidal power
Wind power
Nuclear power
Technology
Suggested Teaching Activities
Classification of resources:
renewable and non-renewable.
Facts and statistics for energy
use can be taken from an atlas
or from one of the references
given here.
Analysis of trends in use of
energy should be a starting point
e.g. energy demand and supply
in a country in 2005 and 2020.
It is important that there is detail
about each of the sources of
energy in this section. Questions
may focus on a particular source
of energy - requirements for
production, location, contribution
to energy budget, etc.
Suggested case studies:
USA - energy alternatives for the
future
Wind farms in Europe - a topical
issue
Online
Resources
http://www.uic.c
om.au/educatio
n.htm
This includes
items on
nuclear energy
and the
greenhouse
effect.
Other resources
Nagle & Spencer
(Diagrams) pp.118-119
Waugh chapter 18 pp.488501
Guinness and Nagle
pp.63-66
Bowen & Pallister p.236
Waugh chapter 18 pp.492498
June 2004
Q. 11(a)
June 2005
Q. 11
June 2006
Q. 3(a)
June 2007
Q. 3(a)
November
2008 Q. 3
All these
questions
demand
detailed
knowledge.
www.XtremePapers.net
Geothermal Energy (Geo
Factsheet 76 Sept 1999)
To understand why
levels of supply and
demand for energy
resources vary at the
national level
This section is
focussed on demand
and supply and the
relationships between
them
To examine trends in
the patterns of energy
consumption in
LEDCs and MEDCs
Demand
Supply
Resource
endowment
Technology
Energy gap
Factors that
influence energy
policy e.g. level of
development, capital,
energy policy,
environmental
concerns, Kyoto
targets, etc.
Maps and statistics can be
studied to show that the main
producers of energy are not
necessarily the main
consumers.
Local case studies are
encouraged and often highly
effective.
June 2004
Q. 11(b) energy
consumption in
LEDCs
A good starting point is Waugh
489-491 (graphs and data).
Relate to changes in technology.
Trends in consumption.
Comparison of statistics for
present demand/ supply and
future demand/supply. e.g. for
2005 and 2020. Possible
comparison of LEDCs and
MEDCs. This could be picked up
as part of the case study (2.2).
www.XtremePapers.net
Bowen & Pallister pp.238241
Nagle (Development &
Underdevelopment)
pp.111- 114
Nagle & Spencer
(Diagrams) p.115 (dated,
but can be used for
comparison purposes).
Guinness & Nagle pp.5662
Waugh pp.489-91
To understand the
environmental impact
of energy production,
transport and usage at
the local scale
Note Impact on
people (human
impact) is not needed.
To understand the
environmental impact
of energy production,
transport and usage at
the global scale
Environmental
impact
Natural
environment
Pollution
Degradation
Conservation
All energy production has some
environmental impact (including
renewables). Fuel extraction and
electricity production create
industrial waste, transport may
spill crude oil, etc. This can be
demonstrated by use of case
studies e.g. Exxon Valdez oil
spill or the Trans-Alaska pipeline
which has great effects on the
natural environment. Nuclear
energy has distinct actual and
potential impacts locally which
may impact wider areas e.g.
Chernobyl.
Data of carbon dioxide
emissions and levels of
deforestation can be analysed,
considering ‘Carbon sinks’, and
a link made to Tropical
environments, Physical Options
Unit 1. Could compare burning
fossil fuels with nuclear energy,
which may be seen as “clean”
but has other possible dangers.
http://www.iclei.
org/EFACTS/GL
BWFIG1.GIF
(diagram)
http://www.iclei.
org/EFACTS/GL
OBWARM.HTM
(global
warming)
Other links on
this site explore
alternative
energy sources
and their
effects.
June 2006 Q.
3(a)(i) Fig. 2
http://www.uic.c
om.au/educatio
n.htm
deals with
Australian
uranium
www.XtremePapers.net
Nagle (Development &
Underdevelopment) p.111
Cook, Hordern et al. pp.
119-20 is very good.
Cook, Hordern et al.
p.125, p.129
Waugh p.495
2.2 The
management of
energy supply
To examine and
evaluate the supply of
electrical energy in
one country at two
scales
Demand
Supply
Energy gap
Production
Location
1. Overall energy
strategy (national)
2. Named, located
energy scheme (local)
2.3
Environmental
degradation
To understand the
nature and causes of
the many types of
pollution
To distinguish
pollution from
environmental
degradation
To analyse the factors
which have led to
degradation of rural
environments.
Causes and
consequences of
misuse or overuse of
rural land
Environmental
degradation
Land pollution
Air pollution
Water pollution
May also include:
Noise pollution
Visual Pollution
Population pressure
Soil erosion
Land degradation
Deforestation
Desertification
Poor farming
practices
One case study is sufficient as
long as it covers both scales,
e.g. of Zimbabwe and Kariba
(HEP). Teachers may develop
more than one case study, e.g.
the home country and a contrast
(LEDC or MEDC).
It is anticipated that the scheme
studied will be from the same
country as the strategy, to offer
greater detail and depth.
Industries in all four sectors can
pollute land, air and water.
Definition. Classification.
Causes and sources of pollution
as an introduction. Can use
spider diagram to brainstorm the
topic.
Add water as a resource to the
discussion. Could link to AS Unit
1 Hydrology through water
quality, abstraction, etc. Could
Physical Options, Unit 4 Arid
and semi-arid environments.
Past questions can indicate
emphasis that should be made
when interpreting the syllabus.
Degradation of rural
environments occurs in both
MEDCs and LEDCs.
Suggested case study from
home country or any context
which students can readily
understand.
June 2007
Q. 3(b)
Nov 2006
Q. 3(b)
Nagle (Development &
Underdevelopment)
pp.111-114
Geo Factsheet 95 April
2000 UK Energy – Update
Nov 2005
Q. 11(b)
Nov 2008 Q.
4(b) water
pollution
June 2008 Q. 4
June 2007 Q. 4
Fig. 2 shows
water supply - a
useful teaching
resource.
Nov 2006 Q. 4
pollution
June 2004 Q.
12(b) involves
evaluation of
factors such as
finance in the
upgrading of the
environment.
www.XtremePapers.net
Cook, Hordern et al.
pp.114-123
Nagle (Development &
Underdevelopment) pp.6667
Hart et al. pp.133-136
To examine and
evaluate policies
designed to improve
the quality of
degraded rural
environments
To understand why
selected urban
environments have
become degraded
Note Teachers may
want to compare one
MEDC and one LEDC
city but this is not
necessary.
To understand the
relative success or
failure of policies
designed to address
urban environmental
degradation
Reclamation
Land reform
Soil conservation
Afforestation
Environmentally
Sensitive Areas
(ESAs)
Waste disposal
Urbanisation
Urban decay
Zones of discard
and assimilation
Inner city
Informal settlement
Waste management
- solid, liquid, gas and
particulates
Urban regeneration
Urban redevelopment
Case study – Basilicata, Italy, is
a very good, up-to-date case
study to use.
Case study 1: The problems of
the city of Rome, Italy
Hill (Advanced Geography
Case Studies) pp.54-60
Nov 2005 Q. 12
(a) urban
degradation
Hill pp.89-95
Case study 2: Cairo, Egypt:
Africa’s largest city
Hill pp.96-105
Case study 3: American cities
Case study 4: The quality of life
in cities
Guinness & Nagle pp.7074
Guinness & Nagle pp.8994 on American cities
Guinness & Nagle pp.95105
Nagle & Spencer
(Diagrams) p.94, an older
project but still useful
Cook, Hordern et a. pp.9294
Guinness & Nagle pp.109113, pp.114-119
Waugh pp.402-3, p. 408
Case study 5: urban
redevelopment in Glasgow, UK
http://www.foei.
0rg/media/index
.html
Case study 6: inner city areas
Case study 7: São Paulo, Brazil
Case study 8: London
Docklands
There may be links to AS Unit
3.4 The management of urban
settlements
Case studies are a matter of
individual choice.
www.XtremePapers.net
Geo Factsheet 121
January 2002 Urban
Problems in Rio de
Janeiro
Knowledge of risk
factors affecting
environments,
environmental
protection policies and
their impact
2.4 The
management of
a degraded
environment
To acquire detailed
knowledge of one
degraded environment
Factors, causes,
problems, issues,
management strategy,
attempts or initiatives,
and relative success
or failure are the key
elements
Examples are diverse
and may include:
National Parks
Nature reserves
Mining agreements
Tropical rainforest
(TRF)
Ecotourism
Earth summits
Kyoto protocol
CO2 emissions
targets
Factors that cause
and influence
degradation:
economic, social,
environmental,
political. Positive and
negative.
Identifying risk factors: general
risk factors e.g. population
pressure and specific risk
factors (to time and/or place)
e.g. road building project.
Awareness of the need for some
form of environmental
protection. Measures: proposed
or taken. Outcomes: relative
success/failure. Unexpected
effects, further needs, etc.
Study of the Earth summits of
Rio de Janeiro 1996 and Kyoto
1997 and the targets of the
Kyoto Protocol.
Possible link back to AS Unit 2
Atmosphere and weather, 2.4
The human impact
This section may be covered by
reference to any case study of a
teacher’s or student’s choice.
Note Be careful to ensure that
the chosen case study has all
the attributes needed. It is
advisable to check the wording
of past questions in order to
select a case study that fulfils
the question requirements.
Nov 2006
Q. 4(b)
government as
a factor
June 2005
Q. 12(b)
www.XtremePapers.net
Geo Factsheet 91 April
2000 Cardiff Bay
Redevelopment, UK