Policies aimed at improving access to food Text extracted from

advertisement

Policies aimed at improving access to food

Text extracted from

The World Food Problem

Leathers and Foster, 2004 http://www.lastfirst.net/images/product/R004548.jpg

Its all about distribution isn’t it?

• 2,807 calories of food/day available per person

• Average requirement is 2,350 calories of food/day/person

– Thus net surplus is 457 calories/day/person

• Could increase surplus

– 480 calories/day/person

• By eliminating waste

– 634 calories/day/person

• By eliminating meat http://www.stonyfield.com/WebLogarchives/CreatingHealthyKids/pyramid.gif

Diet for a Small Planet

• Claim:

– If U.S. reduced meat consumption by 10%

• it would free up 12 million tons of grain a year.

• enough to feed 60 million starving people

• Assumptions:

– World food supply is fixed

• If less is taken by some, it can be used by others

– The increase in available grain could be allocated to the world’s hungry http://www.gladrags.com/blog/wpcontent/uploads/2007/11/diet-for-a-small-planet.jpg

What if the U.S. reduced meat consumption by 10%?

• 102 Calories/day/person reduction in U.S.

– Partially offset by increased meat and grain consumption elsewhere

– Price of grain driven down

– Increase in grain available offset by 60% reduced production

– Results in increase of 4 calories/person/day in developing world

• If everyone in developing world gave up meat:

– would result in 120-180 calories/person/day

– Need 200 calories/day/person http://brendoman.com/gallery/d/74-2/02ruthwithmeat.jpg

Redistribution

• Redistribution policies would require

Reduction of overconsumption in developed countries

– Production maintained at current levels

– Under-consumption must be reversed in developing countries

• Targeted to those who are undernourished http://www.sptimes.com/2002/11/24/photos/taste-overeating.jpg

Reducing over-consumption

Carl’s Jr. 1 lb burger:

1420 Calories http://www.sgtstryker.com/weblog/archives/004476.php

• Impractical

– Would require huge taxes on food

• Currently

– U.S. consumes 3750

Calories/day/person

– Income $32,350

• 1968

– U.S. consumed 3000

Calories/day/person

– Adjusted income was $17,266

• To return to 3000 Calories

– Would require an income surtax of about 45% plus a 4% food tax

Productivity

• How can productivity be kept unchanged

– If developed countries lower consumption?

• Government purchase of food required

– By developed countries

• For U.S. to purchase

20% of its farm output

– Would cost $50 billion http://www.kestan.com/travel/dc/monument/images/IMG_1383%20US%20C apitol%20&%20reflecting%20pool%20(+).jpg

Feeding the undernourished

Subsistence farming, Tanzania

• Current U.S. foreign aid about $11 billion

– Less than half goes to lowincome countries

• Getting food to undernourished a problem

– Especially in a marketoriented system

• Alternatives not very effective:

– Central control of production and consumption

– Subsistence agriculture http://www.untotheleast.com/blog/uploaded_images/013006_%20b783-760459.jpg

Technology is important

http://www.joe.org/joe/2003february/figures/tt5-fig1.gif

• Should not conclude that

– Halting growth of food production will protect natural resources

– Technology to increase food production is unnecessary

• Disagrees with Food First

• Need new technologies to

– Increase food productivity

– Protect environment

• Integrated Pest Management

• Low impact tillage

• Drip irrigation

• Need redistribution of food

– Improves nutrition of undernourished

– Requires political will

Download