UNIT 5 SEMINAR: Planning & Developing an Essay GOALS Recap thesis statements Discuss outlining and Unit 5 Project Consider the place of modes in the presentation of information HELPFUL READING Chapter 21 shows the whole process for writing an expository essay. Section VI also covers the different modes, or ways to develop the information—cause and effect, compare and contrast, etc. Chapter 13 covers outlining in detail. Chapter 12 and the “APA Quick Reference Guide” will help with giving research the credit it’s due. Pages 129-138 will help with integrating the research with your ideas for fluid point presentation. THESIS REVIEW The beginning of Chapter 14 covers thesis statements in depth. Thesis statements are specific. Vague: There are many causes of childhood obesity; there are many effects, too, and there are lots of ways people can keep their kids from being obese. The start of something specific: Three particularly scary causes of childhood obesity are x, y, and z. REVIEW What’s the problem? Any essay must provide lots of vivid details and examples to support each key point. This would mean providing several examples of causes and explaining those, then providing several effects and explaining those, and then several methods of prevention and explaining those. This is simply not possible in 4-7 pages. THESIS STATEMENT If you’re having problems focusing your thesis statement, the WC has two great tutorials on thesis statements: http://kucampus.k aplan.edu/Platfor m/AcademicSuppo rt/AcademicSucces s/PeerTutoring/Wr iting/pdf/process/F rom_Topic_Resear ch_Thesis.pdf http://kucampus.k aplan.edu/Platfor m/AcademicSuppo rt/AcademicSucces s/PeerTutoring/Wr iting/pdf/typestool s/Writing_a_Thesi s_Statement.pdf THESIS STATEMENTS REVIEW Thesis statements are just that—statements. They are NOT questions. Research questions are questions, and the thesis answers the question. What effects do smoking bans have on the public? Because of smoking bans in public places, people have x, y, and z. By following the x,y,z formula, you will make writing the topic sentences much easier. For example: The first major effect of the smoking ban is x. By reinforcing the key points in the topic sentences, readers will know exactly where they are in the essay, and you as a writer will know exactly what kind of supporting details should be inside that paragraph. OUTLINING AND THE UNIT 5 PROJECT Chapter 13 is all about outlining. If you haven’t read it yet, you should now! QUESTION: WHAT IS THE OUTLINE AND HOW SHOULD IT WORK? We use an outline because it provides the structure we need to create an organized essay. Although our writing can use creativity, the essay that the outline will help you write is not creative writing. It is informative writing based on ideas and facts. SEE WHAT YOU THINK OF THE OUTLINE BELOW. HOW USEFUL WOULD SUCH AN OUTLINE BE FOR DRAFTING A 4-7 PAGE RESEARCH PAPER? Thesis: College is overrated, lean just as much and do just as good on the job. Introduction College 4 year degree Higher pay NEXT PARAGRAPH DISADVANTAGES On the Job No schooling Money right out of high school No debt NEXT PARAGRAPH DISADVANTAGES Conclusion I know this outline doesn’t fulfill the required format, but I did indeed receive this outline from a student once. REVIEW UNIT’S MATERIALS. Review the online reading. It also breaks down the crucial components of an essay. Visit all links for the Unit, as well as the links under “Course Home” that assist with the project (“Maggie’s Journey,” “APA Quick Reference Guide,” etc.). DocSharing also has useful downloads that may help you. Be sure you have chosen the topic for the outline from the list in Unit 1, and that your thesis has three key points for the different body paragraph sections of the outline. Make sure you have credible research handy (all of which is likely from your Unit 3 Project). You can provide some pieces of outside information in the outline. USE MAGGIE DURHAM’S EXAMPLE OUTLINE. In fact, you can use Maggie’s work as a template. Save her outline as a Word document and type over her work to be sure you have the right format. Pay close attention to presentation items such as punctuation and spacing. Be sure to use complete sentences. Remember, you need to follow Maggie’s work— you cannot make up your own outline format! UNDERSTAND MAGGIE’S OUTLINE The first level of Maggie’s outline is her introduction. She uses Roman numerals to divide her outline. The introduction is Roman numeral “I.” A = Her attention-engaging technique (filmmaker analogy) B = Her topic background C = Her specific thesis sentence (topic + key points = thesis sentence). Note: If Maggie does not cite an item in her outline as being from an outside source, it is her own idea. See pages 181-189 in your handbook for extra help with introductions. UNDERSTAND MAGGIE’S USE OF SOURCES If Maggie has already written draft body paragraphs (such as in the example in Unit 5’s reading), the primary purpose of her outline is to plan how outside sources fit with her own ideas. Therefore, Maggie (and you, too!) can use topic sentences from body paragraphs at the Roman numeral levels II-IV and follow these topic sentences with source paraphrase and quotation that support the topic sentences (A, B, C, etc.). For help with topic sentences, see pages 167-8 in your textbooks. Keep in mind that Maggie is not going to string together a series of sources and expect this to be an essay. She will use her own ideas and use outside sources to support her ideas. The outline is a plan for this process. UNDERSTAND MAGGIE’S CONCLUSION FORMAT. Roman numeral “V” represents the conclusion paragraph. A = Restatement of the thesis sentence in brief B = Wrap up of significant ideas associated with the thesis key points C = Circle back to the attention-capturing technique of the introduction See pages 189-194 in your handbook for extra help with conclusions. WHAT ARE MODES OF WRITING? Modes are organizational strategies that help convey information and a purpose. For this presentation, we will focus on just three of these: 1. 2. 3. Cause and Effect Comparison and Contrast Process Analysis Please see Section VI in your textbooks for examples of these modes. DEFINE THREE MODES Cause and effect – By explaining or analyzing the causes and effects of something, you provide your readers with ways to understand a topic and sometimes cope with new ideas. Comparison and/or contrast – Often, explaining how things are alike and/or different, or how they were and how they have changed, will present new information. Process analysis – Sometimes explaining how something is done, made, or works, or how it came to be, will clarify a topic for a reader. Process writing is another kind of expository writing. EXAMPLES OF EACH MODE Cause and effect: Change can lead to anxiety and stress. Contemplating the change of a new work or family dynamic often creates ripples of stress that affect every area of daily life. In fact, even good changes such as job promotion or new relationships can cause anxious feelings of adjustment. In these few sentences, the writer demonstrates cause and effect. Change causes anxiety and stress. MORE EXAMPLES: Comparison and contrast: Although the former filing system for our company used only alphabetical order, the new filing system uses both alphabetical order and chronological order. Therefore, while the older system allowed quick access only to client names and invoices, the new system allows employees to find invoices in certain timeframes for certain clients. Using this new system decreases time spent searching for invoices with the old system and the frequent misfiling that occurred with that system. However, this new method retains the alphabetical order of the old system because this order has served the company well. These sentences set up a comparison and contrast. The difference (chronological order) is pointed out with the likeness (alphabetical order). THE FINAL EXAMPLE: Process Analysis: Although photography is a complex process, the amateur version of this art usually involves simple steps. First, the photographer loads the film into an analog camera. Next, the person behind the camera arranges the desired image, makes sure the flash is engaged and film advanced if necessary, and presses the shutter button. Finally, when the film roll is complete, the photographer takes the film to a developing lab and awaits the results. These sentences explain a process. Notice the words used to transition between ideas “First,” “Next,” and “Finally.” Writing requires this kind of transition, but the words used to transition change from mode to mode. A WORD ON USING RESEARCH Chapter 12 is vital in helping you avoid accidental plagiarism. We’re not going to dwell on this much this week, but if you follow the rules in the chapter, you should be fine for the project. UNDERSTAND THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN PARAPHRASE AND QUOTATION. Again, a paraphrase occurs when the writer uses his or her own words to express the ideas of a source. Direct quotation occurs when a writer copies the exact words of a source. One should use more paraphrase than direct quotation, but sometimes we just cannot say it better than the original source. Direct quotes should make up no more than 25% of your paper. On your outlines, try to only have one quote per key point so that you also practice paraphrasing at this stage. Pages 128-136 in your textbooks cover the ins and outs of source integration. UNDERSTAND APA IN-TEXT CITATION FOR PARAPHRASE. When a writer paraphrases, he or she cites the author and year of the source. Examples: *Mary Smith (2005) indicates that young voters may feel disconnected from political issues. *A recent study indicates that young voters may feel disconnected from political issues (Smith, 2005). *In 2005, Mary Smith’s study of young voters indicated that these voters may feel disconnected from political issues. Note: In the third example, there are no parentheses because all the information needed for this paraphrase is in the text of the sentence. I’ve posted a nice handout about paraphrasing from the Writing Center into Doc Sharing—check it out! CONSIDER THIS… Original Quote: Chemical fingerprinting involves taking a speck of the material and splitting it into its different atomic elements. The tiniest portions of unusual suites can reveal where something came from. One of the growing uses of this technique is in food forensics, where the integrity of regional brands is big business. Paraphrase 1: The smallest elements of strange sets can show an item’s origins (Eastwood, 2009). Paraphrase 2: According to Eastwood, the smallest portions of weird suites can reveal where something was from. What’s the difference between the two paraphrases? Which is appropriate, and which isn’t? Why? Eastwood, Ken. (2009, July-September). Can this fly solve a murder? Australian Geographic. (95). 8187. Retrieved September 20, 2009, from Academic Search Premier. UNDERSTAND APA IN-TEXT CITATION FOR DIRECT QUOTATION. When a writer quotes directly, he or she will include a page number when one is available. Not all sources have page numbers. Examples: • Mary Smith (2005) points out that “most kids simply are not involved in the typical voting agenda” (p. 25). • A recent study suggests that “most kids simply are not involved in the typical voting agenda” (Smith, 2005, p. 25). • In her 2005 study, Mary Smith suggests that “most kids simply are not involved in the typical political agenda” (p. 25). • Note: These examples are all ways of handling the same quotation. Notice that these examples and Maggie’s examples integrate quotation into the writer’s own sentences. No quotation should stand alone as its own sentence. COMBINE YOUR OWN IDEAS AND RESEARCH FINDINGS. This point is worth repeating: Maggie began this essay with her own ideas and sentences. Research supports Maggie’s ideas and gives her new perspectives from which to write, but the essay is Maggie’s work based on her research. Outside sources are important, but we cannot string them together and call them an essay. Her sources are cited. Non-cited material is Maggie's own. In the body-paragraph levels of the outline, the sub-points (A, B, C, etc.) include citation because Maggie is going to use these to decide how to support her ideas with her research. PAY CAREFUL ATTENTION TO DETAIL. The References Page has a specific spacing and indentation format. Copy this format exactly. Use the APA resources in Doc Sharing and under Course Home to find out what every item in the reference entry means. ASK QUESTIONS! The outline is a detailed project. Read the instructions for the project. Are there any rules you might have overlooked? Are there specific requirements for the sources from which you will borrow information? Use the rubric as a checklist for the project. Use the Kaplan Writing Center’s help. Ask your instructor for help. Leave time to ask questions by beginning work early in the Unit. SOME REMINDERS . . . Read, print, and read at least two more times. Begin immediately; don’t let one minute go to waste. Set a personal plan for completing the outline and submitting it by your own due date and time. Do not use 11:59 PM ET on the Tuesday night the outline is due as a due date. Work ahead. Pat yourself on the back for a job well done! A STEP AT A TIME . . . Learning to outline and use APA requires patience, practice, and timemanagement. Consider the rules for the sources you are using. Do not try to learn all the rules at one time. If you take these issues a step at a time, you will learn with practice. We often learn from making mistakes; do your best and seek help when you need it. LOOKING AHEAD In Unit 6 we will: Recap the major connection between the outline and the essay Look at in-text citation more closely Focus on integrating information from a source into a paragraph.