Civics & Government Unit 2 “Your Day in Court is Coming” SSCG6 The Student will Demonstrate knowledge of civil liberties and civil rights. A P P S 3 Based on Probable Cause Issued by an Impartial Judge Search Warrant Name the Person, Place, and Item to be searched for. Must be a reasonable Search & Seizure Bill Of Rights Application 1. Luke was found innocent of armed robbery, but the state decided to bring him to trial again anyway. 2. After being found guilty of driving while intoxicated, the court ordered that Carolyn spend the next 30 years in solitary confinement 3. The citizens of upper Creek voted to double the taxes of all Catholics. 4. In a civil trial where the dispute was more than $20, both sides were denied a jury trial. 5. For no apparent reason, the police stopped Rita while she was driving and began to search through her car trunk and personal luggage. SSCG 6b Analyze due process of law expressed in the th Fifth (5 ) and th Fourteenth (14 ) Amendments. SSCG 6c Explain Selective Incorporation of the Bill of Rights. Process in which the Supreme Court determines, on a case by case basis, which amendments states must obey. Cleveland Ohio police officers forcefully entered Mapp’s house alleging they had a search warrant. Never showed the Search Warrant to Mapp! Seized obscene Items (Pornography) Did not produce a Search Warrant as evidence at trial. Mapp was found guilty but appealed her case to the U.S Supreme Court. 4th Amendment Rights against unreasonable searches & Seizures The State of Ohio argued that the 4th Amendment only applied to the Federal government –NOT THE STATES! The 14th Amendment requires that states, like Ohio, provide due process of law before it deprives a person of life, liberty, or property. The 4th Amendment protection against unreasonable searches & seizures pertains to the states. The exclusionary rule should apply to states. SSCG 6d Explain how government seeks to maintain the balance between individual liberties and the Public Interest. SSCG 6d Individual Liberties Public Interest The U.S. Constitution attempts to protect peoples rights to Private Property. Sometimes the public needs come before Individual needs. Public Interest he welfare or well-being of the general public; commonwealth. 2. appeal or relevance to the general populace: a news story of public interest.“ Civil Liberties -personal guarantees and freedoms that the government cannot abridge, either by law or by judicial interpretation. Private Property Public Needs Individual Right to Privacy Public Safety SSCG 6e Explain every citizen’s right to be treated equally under the law. Homer Plessy arrested for not sitting in Black section on a train. Plessy was 1/8th Black and sued that segregation was violation of 14th Amendment Equality Clause. Court established “Separate but Equal” doctrine. Ruled that it was not unconstitutional to separate the races as long as they had equal services. Segregation (separation of races) legal. Homer Plessy Using the Equal Protection clause in the 14th Amendment Decided that the policy of “Separate but equal” was unconstitutional. Overturned Plessy decision! Forced States to integrate schools and allow African Americans access to public schools with white students. Supreme Court Circuit Courts of Appeals District Courts SSCG 16 The Student will demonstrate knowledge of the operation of the federal judiciary. Judicial Branch Main job is to Interpret the law U.S. District Courts Only federal court that have Jury Trials 1 Judge 1 Jury Original Jurisdiction 1st to hear case Supreme Court Circuit Courts of Appeals District Courts Directory of United States district Courts (11th circuit) State District #Judgeships Location Alabama Northern Middle Southern 7 3 3 Birmingham Montgomery mobile Florida Northern Middle Southern 4 11 16 Tallahassee Jacksonville Miami Georgia Northern Middle Southern 11 4 3 Atlanta Macon Savannah Northern District of Georgia: The Northern District comprises the counties of Banks, Barrow, Bartow, Carroll, Catoosa, Chattooga, Cherokee, Clayton, Cobb, Coweta, Dade, Dawson, De Kalb, Douglas, Fannin, Fayette, Floyd, Forsyth, Fulton, Gilmer, Gordon, Gwinnett, Habersham, Hall, Haralson, Heard, Henry, Jackson, Lumpkin, Meriwether, Murray, Newton, Paulding, Pickens, Pike, Polk, Rabun, Rockdale, Spalding, Stephens, Towns, Troup, Union, Walker, White and Whitfield. Court for the Northern District is held in Atlanta, Gainesville, Rome and Newnan. Middle District of Georgia: The Middle District comprises the counties of Baker, Baldwin, Ben Hill, Berrien, Bibb, Bleckley, Brooks, Butts, Calhoun, Chattahoochee, Clarke, Clay, Clinch, Colquitt, Cook, Crawford, Crisp, Decatur, Dooly, Dougherty, Early, Echols, Elbert, Franklin, Grady, Greene, Hancock, Harris, Hart, Houston, Irwin, Jasper, Jones, Lamar, Lanier, Lee, Lowndes, Macon, Madison, Marion, Miller, Mitchell, Monroe, Morgan, Muscogee, Oconee, Oglethorpe, Peach, Pulaski, Putnam, Quitman, Randolph, Schley, Seminole, Stewart, Sumter, Talbot, Taylor, Terrell, Thomas, Tift, Turner, Twiggs, Upson, Walton, Washington, Webster, Wilcox, Wilkinson and Worth. Court for the Middle District is held in Macon, Albany, Columbus, Athens, Thomasville and Valdosta. Southern District of Georgia: The Southern District comprises the counties of Appling, Atkinson, Bacon, Brantley, Bryan, Bulloch, Burke, Camden, Candler, Charlton, Chatham, Coffee, Columbia, Dodge, Effingham, Emanuel, Evans, Glascock, Glynn, Jeff Davis, Jefferson, Jenkins, Johnson, Laurens, Liberty, Lincoln, Long, McDuffie, McIntosh, Montgomery, Pierce, Richmond, Screven, Taliaferro, Tattnall, Telfair, Toombs, Treutlen, Ware, Warren, Wayne, Wheeler and Wilkes. Court for the Southern District is held in Savannah, Augusta, Dublin, Waycross, Brunswick and Statesboro. U.S. Circuit Courts of Appeal No Jury Appeals only Panel of 3 to 5 Judges Appellate Jurisdiction Supreme Court Circuit Courts of Appeals District Courts Uphold Circuit Court Decisions •Agree with lower court •Reverse Trial Overturn Court decision •Send back to Remand lower Court for Retrial U.S. Supreme Court No Jury 9 Justices Supreme Court Mostly Appellate Jurisdiction Limited Original Jurisdiction Circuit Courts of Appeals District Courts U.S. Supreme Court Original Jurisdiction 1 State v. State 2 State v. U.S. 3 Diplomats other Nations SSCG16a Explain the jurisdiction of the federal courts and the state courts. Jurisdiction The authority a court has to interpret and administer the law. Original Jurisdiction Means that a case is heard for the first time. Jury Trial Only District courts have this U.S. Supreme Court has limited Original jurisdiction. –No Jury Types of Criminal Cases Heard in District Court Treason Bank Robbery Kidnapping Mail Fraud Tax Evasion Types of Criminal Cases Heard in Georgia Courts Speeding Divorce Burglary Robbery (not Bank) Assault SSCG 16b Describe how the Supreme court decides Cases Appointment Supreme Court Justices are appointed for life by the President of the United States. Session A session of the U.S. Supreme Court begins the st 1 Monday in October and ends (adjourns) in late June. Writ of Certiorari Document asking the Court to hear a case. Rule of 4 4 of the 9 Justices must agree to review a case for the case to be accepted for Supreme Court review. Review Under Judicial Review, the Supreme Court will decide if the a law or Executive action is Constitutional or not. Docket Once a case has been selected for review by the “Rule of 4” it will be put on the Court calendar or Docket to be decided. Brief Each side of the argument before the U.S. Supreme Court must submit to the Court their written arguments. Hearing - Oral Arguments In an open and public hearing, each side will have the opportunity to stand before the court and say out loud their argument. Each side has 30 minutes to make verbal arguments. Opinion After reading and hearing both sides arguments the justices will retire to their chambers and meet to discuss their decision. The decision of the court is then released in written form explaining the reasoning used to decide the case. Majority Opinion A simple majority of 5 out of the 9 decide the case. This decision is binding law and the case cannot be appealed past this point. Dissenting Opinion The remaining 4 Justices that disagreed with the majority opinion will write why they disagreed. Sometimes the dissenting opinion has influenced future Courts to change their mind and rule differently. Concurring Opinion Some of the Justices may agree with the majority opinion but for different reasons used by the other members. Legal reasoning influences other opinions. Nothing New / Status Quo Relies on Precedent Justice Uses Logic to make decision Justices use personal opinions to make decision Decision establishes a new rule of law New Law Made SSCG 16d Compare the philosophies of judicial activism and judicial restraint. Homer Plessy arrested for not sitting in Black section on a train. Plessy was 1/8th Black and sued that segregation was violation of 14th Amendment Equality Clause. Court established “Separate but Equal” doctrine. Ruled that it was not unconstitutional to separate the races as long as they had equal services. Segregation (separation of races) legal. Homer Plessy Decided that the policy of “Separate but equal” was unconstitutional. Overturned Plessy decision! Forced States to integrate schools and allow African Americans access to public schools with white students. Do police have to advise suspects under custodial arrest of their constitutional rights? Went before the Supreme Court. Majority Opinion was that anytime a policeman questions a suspect in custody must read rights first. Can a state make it illegal for a woman to have an abortion? Went before the Supreme Court. Majority Opinion was the a woman has a 4th Amendment right to privacy to her own body. States cannot pass laws that make it illegal for women to have abortions. SSCG 21 The Student will demonstrate knowledge of criminal activity. SSCG 21a Examine the nature and causes of Crime. Poverty Urbanization Illegal Drug Use Causes of Crime Permissive Society Illegal Drug Use Poverty Urbanization Permissive Society SSCG 21b Explain the effects criminal acts have on their intended victims. • Broken Bones • Gunshot • Loss of bodily function (Disability) • Disfigurement • Death • • • • Medical Bills Physical Therapy Mental Health Loss of or damage to property • Funeral & burial expenses • Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) • Helplessness / Fear • Terror • Anger/Rage Physical Psychological/ Emotional Financial Spiritual • Turn to beliefs Crimes Against Persons White Collar Crime Crimes Against Property Victimless Crimes Types of Crime Organized Crime • Rape •Robbery •Aggravated Assault •Homicide (Murder) • Burglary •Larceny – Illegal taking of ones property •Theft •Shoplifting •Criminal damage to property •Drug Use •Gambling •Prostitution •Racketeering •Tax Evasion- Perpetrator attempts to avoid taxes they owe •Extortion – Obtaining something, especially money through force •Drug Trafficking •Assassination •Blackmail •Counterfeiting- The practice of manufacturing goods •Fraud – crime that involves deceiving someone for monetary gain. •EmbezzlementImproperly taking money from someone to whom you owe some type of duty •Office Supplies Felony Serious crime such as Kidnapping or Homicide that result in prison time. Misdemeanor Less serious crimes such as traffic violations and disorderly conduct that do not result in prison time. Alibi SelfDefense Insanity Entrapment SSCG 21d Explain the different types of defenses used by perpetrators of crime. If someone can testify that you were somewhere else other than the crime scene. If the act that was committed was done to preserve your life or the life of another. If the idea to commit the crime originated with the police. A defense that an individual is mentally unable to control their conduct or know right from wrong. A defense that an individual is under coercion or threat of immediate danger to life or personal safety. A defense that an individual is under 7 years old and incapable of committing crime. Arrest Preliminary Hearing Indictment Arraignment Trial SSCG 22a Analyze the steps in the criminal justice process. Sentencing •Held no later than 10 days after the arrest. •Hearing determines if there is enough evidence against an accused person and if the person should received a trial. •Hearing is also held for the Judge to set Bail. • Accused goes before a Grand Jury •Grand Jury determines if there is enough evidence for the case to go to trial. • Grand Jury right established under the 5th Amendment • If the Grand Jury determines there is enough evidence it issues an Indictment. •The Accused will then go to trial. • Accused allowed to enter a plea. •Accused appears before a Judge and enters a plea of Guilty or Not Guilty. •Accused may choose to make a plea bargain with the prosecutor before appearing before the Judge in order to receive a lesser charge or sentence. •Accused will either have a bench trial or a Jury Trial. • A bench trial is a trial without a Jury. • After the evidence has closed and both sides have rested their case the verdict will be given by the Jury. •The Verdict will be either Guilty or Not Guilty. • The Accused then has another hearing set so the Judge can issue the sentence. • The Judge decides the punishment, or Sentence if the defendant is found Guilty by the Jury. • Some sentences are Mandatory Sentences and the Judge cannot change them. • Mandatory Sentences are required in some states because some people feel that criminals are not serving long enough sentences. SSCG 22b Explain the individual’s due process rights. Conditionally Suspended Sentence A judge may unconditionally discharge the defendant of all obligations and restraints. However, the defendant's criminal conviction will remain part of the public record. DUI 1 Year in Jail 1 Year Jail Time Suspended but Can’t get in Trouble Get In Trouble Serve 1 Year in Jail Opening Statement Tell the Jury what the case is about Evidence (Direct & Cross Examination) Testimony of Witnesses, Physical Evidence Closing Argument Summarize the evidence to the Jury SSCG 22c Describe the steps in a criminal trial or civil suit. Difference in Civil & Criminal Process guilty SSCG 22d Examine the different types of sentences a convicted person can receive. Mandatory Indeterminate Concurrent Sentences Restitution Suspended Sentence Death Mandatory Sentences Indeterminate Sentences Sentences should be absolute/Unchangeable Sentences should be based on potential rehabilitation, be allowed for review and possible modification Mandatory Sentence The Judge does not have discretion (a say-so) in how many years the convicted defendant must serve. Sentence is defined by law and cannot be changed. 20 Year Sentence •Ordered 20 year Sentence •Must Serve All Indeterminate Sentence the prison term imposed after conviction for a crime which does not state a specific period of time or release date, but just a range of time, such as "five-to-ten years". 10 Years •Maximum Time Served 6-9 Years •Chance for Early Parole! 5 Years •Minimum Time Served Concurrent Sentence when a criminal defendant is convicted of two or more crimes, a judge sentences him/her to a certain period of time for each crime. Judge rules that the sentences may all be served at the same time, with the longest period controlling. Original Sentence • Begins 3 years • 8/20/11 3 Year • Concurring sentence for 2nd• offense Begins 8/20/13 Suspended Sentence In criminal cases a trial judge has the ability to suspend the sentence of a convicted person. The judge must first pronounce a penalty of a fine or imprisonment, or both, and then suspend the implementation of the sentence. Guilty 1 Year Jail Time Driving UnderThe Suspended Influence 1 year in Jail No Time to Serve Unconditionally Suspended Sentence A judge may unconditionally discharge the defendant of all obligations and restraints. However, the defendant's criminal conviction will remain part of the public record. DUI 1 Year in Jail 1 Year Jail Time Suspended Part of Criminal History No Time to Serve Public Record Conditionally Suspended Sentence A judge may unconditionally discharge the defendant of all obligations and restraints. However, the defendant's criminal conviction will remain part of the public record. DUI 1 Year in Jail 1 Year Jail Time Suspended but Can’t get in Trouble Get In Trouble Serve 1 Year in Jail Restitution The Defendant in an embezzlement case was sentenced to restitution and had to repay all that was stolen from the victim. Death Sentence The sentence of execution for murder and some other capital crimes.