Using ICT to Improve Patient Care ZEPRS Gordon Cressman, Chris Kelley, Niamh Darcy June 22 2007 RTI International is a trade name of Research Triangle Institute Context: 2002 Maternal mortality rate 940/1000 Lifetime risk of death in pregnancy 1/25 Disability Adjusted Life Years (DALY) at birth 30.7 Virtually all modern health care for 2 million women in Lusaka provided by 23 clinics and the University Teaching Hospital (UTH) 13 of 23 clinics provide antenatal care, 9 with labor wards 47,000 estimated total obstetric cases (2002) All medical records on paper Patients may move among clinics, but limited sharing of patient records No central database for monitoring patient population or quality of care Children outside Chainda Clinic, Lusaka Scope, Funding, Client Scope Lusaka, Zambia 23 public health clinics –ZEPRS University teaching hospital Central Board of Health Center for Infectious Disease Research in Zambia (CIDRZ) Funding Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation – ZEPRS Elizabeth Glaser Foundation/PEPFAR ART Client University of Alabama Birmingham Project Objectives 1. Improved health of patients 1.1 Improved access to patient records 1.2 Improved patient record quality 1.3 Improved patient follow-up & drug adherence 1.4 Improved information for research and analyzing interventions 1.5 Useful information for Zambian health administrators Patient files at University Teaching Hospital, Lusaka, 2004 RTI Component Objectives A Local Area Network (LAN) of up to five workstations in each of 23 (became 24) public health care clinics selected by the UAB A LAN of up to five workstations in the University Teaching Hospital A LAN of up to five workstations in the Ministry of Health A data center supporting the electronic perinatal records management system A wireless Wide Area Network (WAN) connecting clinic LANs, UTH, CIDRZ, and MoH LAN into a single network with access to the perinatal records management system. A Web-based perinatal records management system designed in conjunction with UAB to serve the needs of the Lusaka Urban Health District ZEPRS Key Concepts Guides medical personnel through Zambian standard of perinatal care Concept of “flows” within the system and related data Shared terminal usage Usage of ZEPRS data for quality assurance and supervision Patient confidentiality Adaptability/Extensibility of ZEPRS system (HIV/ART, Safe Motherhood) Using mini applications to build computing skills ZEPRS Key medical features Safe Motherhood Pregnancies linked together Convert typical visit to problem visit Graphical Partograph (matches WHO partograph) Patient Referral System Use of EDD/EGA calculation and update in display (with options for manual over-ride) – very useful automation for nurses Antenatal and Postnatal card generation (supports patient mobility) Infants linked to mother for each separate pregnancy Reports Problem Management including problems across multiple pregnancies ZEPRS Key Technical features Data export facilitates reporting in Access, SAS, SPSS etc Connected and disconnected mode Standalone mode for remote clinics with occasional connectivity - can sync records automatically with the main system. Open Source – Java J2EE – Tomcat/Struts/MySQL ZEPRS Design Principles User driven, collaborative and iterative Software developed using open source tools (cost-effective) and best-of-breed web architecture Software adapted easily to other contexts and applications ZEPRS software released under ASL2 open source license ZEPRS documentation published under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 2.5 license ZEPRS Home page Patient Status Demographics Pregnancy Dating Medical/Surgical History Routine Ante-natal Visits Chart: Routine Antenatal visits Tracking PMTCT/VCT in Safe Motherhood Counseling Visits ARV Regimen Regimen Results Entering Lab results – CD4 Pregnancy Dating/Previous Pregnancies Demo: Antenatal Referrals Referrals – Viewing the record that triggered the referral Referrals: UTH perspective System Generated Problems Comments on Problems Problem List Partograph Partograph: Complex data entry with simple user interface Tracking Cervix/Decent plot Entering data: Result: Partograph Timing Alert Partograph conclusion Delivery Delivery Summary Links to Infant record Correcting a patient record Improvement: Highlights on key fields Demo: Labor and Delivery Reports Report selection ANC Monthly Report Reflex Register Software Development Agile+ programming approach: iterative development (CMM Level II) Referral application used to seed development approach, training, roll-out and support RFP issued to South African/Indian firms – rand appreciation and responsiveness resulted in developing in-house Multiple supporting applications developed (administration of users, training, web-based email, web-based PM, bugtracker) User Manual drives training plans Detailed test plans and testing, using local medical students who we trained in software testing Software Platform Platform Component Selected Solution Operating System Red Hat Enterprise 3 (Currently CentOS 4.2) Server Backup Arkeia Backup 5.2 Wireless Authentication AEGIS Premium Server 1.1.4 Relational Database MySQL 3.23 (currently MySQL 5.0) Web Application Server Apache (httpd) 2 Tomcat 5 (servlet container) E-mail Cyrus IMAP, Postfix, Spam Assassin E-mail Web Interface Squirrel Mail Firewall SonicWALL Client Anti-virus McAfee E-mail Server Anti-virus AMaVIS Sample Screen Flow Software Development - IDE and Development What skills does a developer need to work on ZEPRS? Experienced Java developer for code changes Basic pc skills to modiy ZEPRS forms. ZEPRS Dev tools Incremental development Testing Average 2 builds/month – usually simple field changes, reports Process of installing new builds – application updates Unit tests Load tests – jMeter Demo login Documentation – used Drupal CMS for www.idg-rti.org website. Software Development Design: Enterprise Content Management Authorized users may login to the Administration section of the ZEPRS application and create new forms, add/modify fields to a form, and add/modify enumerations to a field. Systems administrators may query common values using the Report section Query interface. These ad-hoc reports may be useful for previewing data intended for a published standard report. Rules: Rules may be added to the ZEPRS forms via the Administration section’s web interface. Values entered into a form field that has a rule can trigger the creation of a problem, which will be displayed in the Problem listing. These problems can prompt the user to refer the patient to UTH, complete a form, or provide information. ZEPRS Administration Form-based Administration Create Form Editing Forms Adding a new field Editing a field Generating Dynasite source Application Updates ZEPRS Administration – making changes Open ZEPRS project source code in Eclipse or Idea Launch local version of ZEPRS app via IDE’s Tomcat instance to browse app and make form modifications via web interface After form editing is complete, click “Generate Dynasite Source” to generate java and xml files that manage form rendering and patient flow. In IDE, use the Ant task “dist-zip” to create a distribution of the ZEPRS war file and other related sql and installation files. SFTP files to the server. Run batch file which installs new version and updates any db schema changes. ZEPRS Summary - User Acceptance Ease of Use Question 12. Which is easier to complete (use), the manual "blue book" or ZEPRS? a. The blue book was much easier 14.3% b. The blue book was a little easier More than 80% of respondents reported the automated system as easy or easier to complete (use) than the manual system. 7.1% c. Both are about the same 35.7% d. The ZEPRS system was easier 42.9% n = 14 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ZEPRS Summary - Patients in System More than 39,000 patients Cummulative Patients by Week 45,000 40,000 New Patients 35,000 30,000 25,000 20,000 15,000 10,000 5,000 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 32 34 36 38 40 42 44 46 48 50 52 54 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 2006 2007 Week * 5 Feb 2006 – 16 May 2007. Weeks include one-day weeks at beginning and end of year, resulting in 54 weeks for 2006. ZEPRS Summary - Conclusions With some training, clinicians with no prior computer experience may adopt computerized record systems readily The value of a patient record database for monitoring and improving health status can help sustain an electronic patient record system The communications network is being used for several health programs Local staff can maintain and manage the communications network ZEPRS Summary - Major Correction Points Problem Correction Time spent developing detailed medical record structure Discharged consultant and initiated agile development for patient record system Lead software developer diverted to ART patient management system No-cost extensions Failure of application and database servers in close succession Used PC for temporary application server Quality failure of South African contractor developing referral software Cancelled subcontract and completed software inhouse Replaced failed servers ZEPRS Summary - Critical Success Factors Close collaboration with health workers and UAB Thorough testing Effective user training User acceptance and participation Reliability and performance of network Reliability of computers in facilities Project management Use of on-line tools, and IM for remote project support Questions and Comments RTI ZEPRS team Eileen Reynolds, Project Manager, Chris E. Kelley, Senior Software Developer, Niamh Darcy, Senior Technical Advisor, Pablo Destefanis, Senior Networking and Telecommunications Specialist, Gordon M. Cressman, Senior Project Advisor UAB ZEPRS team Dr. Perry Killiam, Dr. Dwight Rouse, Dr. Francis Nuthalapaty RTI Website with full ZEPRS details http://www.idg-rti.org