Analysis & Design of Common Chemical Engineering Systems What is Analysis? Analysis is the process of identifying a question or issue to be addressed, modeling the issue, investigating model results, interpreting the results, and possibly making a recommendation. Typical analysis for process design may include: Market and Technical Feasibility Choice of Technology (Proven, Innovative, path/ rating) Identification Process Equipment in the Plant Choice of Design theme and mode Availability of raw materials, utilities, human resource and process constraints Costs of providing the services, skills, materials, equipment, taxes and other economic issues. Invention and Design INVENTION An invention is something produced for the first time through the use of imagination or ingenious thinking and experimentation. A famous quote is: "Necessity is the mother of invention DESIGN Engineering Design is like an invention to suit the unique demand of the customer (customized solutions). What is Design? Design is the human power to conceive, plan, and realize products that serve human beings in the accomplishment of any individual or collective purpose." Process Design is the sizing of equipment and facilities necessary to carry out the process. Engineering Design may require (A). Design for new process (B). Process design (C). Mechanical design (D). 3D design (E). Fabrication (A). Design for New Processes – What is the Design Process? Typical five steps through which scientific principles are applied for the solution of Engineering problems are: 1. 2. 3. 4. Define the Problem Finding solutions and ideas Documentation of ideas Testing and Refining 5. Production Defining the Problem The design process is undertaken after a specific problem or need has been identified. The identification of the problem occurs in the research and development stage of manufacturing. Once scientists and engineers working in R&D have identified the need for a product or discovered a problem, the design process is used to make the new product or solve the problem The design process The wagon... Either fix the wheel ...broke Or add tires so it doesn't brake again Finding solutions and Ideas In this phase, ideas are examined and a concept of the overall design is developed. Preliminary sketches are used to document the design and/ or computer software used for it. One can document by hand or... ... use a CAD system Documentation of Ideas In this phase, all preliminary drawings or sketches from the previous phase are transformed into a finished package. Today, this is accomplished using Computer Aided Drafting and Design (CADD) systems. To test, a computer simulation can be made ... ... and examined using virtual reality .... ... and a SLA/ CNC machine can be used to make a physical prototype. Testing and Refining In this phase, the design is tested in more realistic modes. This usually involves pilot plants and computer simulations for better visualization. Machining equipment is used to mass produce the final product. Production In the production phase, the design is sent off to be produced. With the use of a CADD system, the data from the design is translated into a form that a Computer Aided Manufacturing (CAM) system can understand. Typical examples are CNC and CIM. Some productions processes involve Robotics as well. (B). Process Design Process design is the design of processes for desired physical and/or chemical transformation of materials. The deep understanding of physical, chemical, thermodynamic properties in relation with working conditions, separation phenomena, rates of reactions, laws of transfer, transformation etc is desired. The availability of technology and kind of machinery and it’s range of applicability should be well understood. The overlapping areas of mechanical, electrical, chemical, metallurgical and civil engineering need to be well understood. (C). Mechanical Design Using Drawing boards/CAD (Horizontal Cylindrical Tank supported on compression load cell) Conical Hopper (D). 3D design Drawing and Model (E). Fabrication Fabrication is a specialized job jointly done by the collaboration of Chemical, Mechanical and Instrumentation engineers. How to design 1). Mathematical Model/Equations 2). Software 3). By Analogy 1). Using Mathematical Model/Equations (The continuity equation) (Heat conduction equation) (Bernoulli equation) 2). Using Software Design software can be categorized as : 1. Design and Draft (e.g AutoCAD) 2. Modeling and Simulation (Solid Edge, Hysys, AspinPlus, AspinDyn,PRO-II, SuperChem) 3. Analysis Software (Hysys, Asys, PRO-II) Right software for right job ! Software Tools for Design ASPIN PLUS PIPECAD HYSIS SOLID EDGE CONSYD SOFTWARE TOOLS AUTOCAD TUTSIM MATLAB AUTOPLANT MATRIX-X Characteristics of Drafting Softwares Main capability is Drafting (Generate Drawings, Fabrication & Assembly Diagrams) Low 3-D capabilities Different Environments available in Software to suit Mechanical, Civil, Architecture etc. Fabrication details can be provided such as ( Materials, welding, grinding, Tolerances and Surface Finish information) Characteristics of Modeling Software Can generate drawings Can model a process for better visualization Models can be used with other softwares for further processing Can Generate machine code for fabrication Model Visualization Gasifier Characteristics of Analysis Softwares Requires most input from other software e. g. Drawing/Model, Material Properties, Boundary Conditions and other Computational constraints Elementary Analysis e.g. Assembly, Fixing and Alignment, Collision, Force Working in layers Integration with other software Standard procedures need to be followed in the design (Hysys, Fluent, Asys, Aspin etc) 3). Scale up By Analogy Common Chemical Engineering Systems Furnace Heat Exchanger Auxiliaries Ancillaries Crystallizer COMMON Chemical Engg. systems Distillation Column Filters Boiler Tanks Vessels Centrifuges Reactor Case Study Design & Fabrication of a Down Draft Gasifier Rig Facility Developed at Chemical Engineering, UET Downdraft Gasifier Wet Scrubber Blower Water Recirculation Tank Recycle Pump