Chapte 6 Slides Developed by: Terry Fegarty Seneca College Financial Planning Chapter 6 – Outline (1) • Business Planning Component Parts of a Business Plan The Purpose of Planning and Plan Information Four Kinds of Business Plan Financial Plans as a Component of a Business Plan • Making Financial Projections Planning for New and Existing Businesses The General Approach and Planning Assumptions The Procedural Approach and the Debt/Interest Problem Percentage of Sales Method © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 2 Chapter 6 – Outline (2) External Funding Requirement The Sustainable Growth Rate Plans With More Complicated Assumptions Planning at the Department Level The Cash Budget Receivables and Payables—Forecasting with Time Lags Debt and Interest • Management Issues in Financial Planning Risk in Financial Planning in General Financial Planning and Computers © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 3 Business Planning • A business plan is a model of what management expects a business to become in the future Expressed in words and financial projections • Financial statements are pro forma What the firm’s financial statements will look like if the planning assumptions are true • A good business plan should be comprehensive Includes projections concerning products, markets, employees, technology, facilities, capital, revenue, profitability, etc. © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 4 Component Parts of a Business Plan(1) • Typical outline Contents Executive summary Mission and strategy statement • Basic charter and long-term direction Market analysis • Why the business will succeed against its competitors Operations of the business • How the firm creates and distributes its products/services © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 5 Component Parts of a Business Plan (2) Management and staffing • Firm’s projected personnel needs Financial projections • Projects the firm’s financial statements into the future • The firm’s financial plan • Main focus of this chapter Contingencies • What the firm will do if things don’t go as planned © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 6 The Purpose of Planning and Plan Information • Major audience of business plan includes Firm’s own management • • • • Planning process helps pull management team together Provides a road map for running the business Provides a statement of goals Helps predict financing needs • Especially important for firms that use outside financing Outside investors • Tells equity investors what returns they can expect • Tells debt investors where firm will get the money to repay loans © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 7 Four Kinds of Business Plan • Four variations on basic idea of business planning Strategic planning Operational planning Budgeting Forecasting • All contain financial projections © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 8 Four Kinds of Business Plan • Four variations on basic idea of business planning Strategic planning • Addresses broad, long-term issues; contains summarized, approximate financial projections • Three to five-year horizon is common • Deals with concepts expressed mainly in words; numbers are summarized • Firm analyzes itself, the industry and the competitive situation • Firm states its mission and goals © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 9 Four Kinds of Business Plan • Four variations on basic idea of business planning Operational planning • One-year planning horizon • States goals and managers responsible for meeting the goals • Translates business ideas (day-to-day operations) into detailed, annual projections • Includes projected income statements and balance sheets • Even mix of words and numbers © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 10 Four Kinds of Business Plan • Four variations on basic idea of business planning Budgeting • Short-term updates of the annual plan when business conditions change rapidly • Typically covers a quarter (3 months) • Predominately financial projections © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 11 Four Kinds of Business Plan • Four variations on basic idea of business planning Forecasting • Very short-term projections of profit and cash flow • Consist almost entirely of numbers • Most large firms perform monthly cash forecasts © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 12 Four Kinds of Business Plan • The Business Planning Spectrum Most large companies produce all the parts of a business plan Strategic plan and operating plan are updated annually 4 quarterly budgets and 12 monthly forecasts Small businesses tend to develop a single business plan when in need of funding • Contains strategic, operating and budgeting elements © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 13 Figure 6.2: The Business Planning Spectrum © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 14 Financial Plans as a Component of a Business Plan • Financial plan is a set of pro forma financial statements projected over the time periods covered by the business plan • Financial statements are a piece of the projection, but not usually the center of the projection However, with annual operating plans the financial projections are the centerpiece © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 15 Planning for New and Existing Businesses • Harder to forecast an operation that is very new or not yet begun No history on which to base projections • The Typical Planning Task Most financial planning involves forecasting changes in ongoing businesses based on planning assumptions Pro forma statements must reflect the assumptions made such as • Unit sales will rise by 10% annually • Overall labour costs will rise by 4%, etc. © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 16 The General Approach and Planning Assumptions • What We Have and What We Need to Project We must forecast future financial statements, based upon last period’s results and our planning assumptions • Planning Assumption An expected condition that dictates the size of one or more financial statement items • Could be planned management actions such as cost control • Could be items outside management control such as interest rate levels or demand by consumers © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 17 Planning Assumptions Example Example 6.1: Q: This year Crumb Baking Corp. sold 1 million coffee cakes per month at $1 each for a total of $12 million. The firm had year-end receivables equal to two months of sales, or $2 million. Crumb’s operating assumptions for next year are: Price will be decreased by 10% Sales volume will increase to 15 million units Only one month of sales will be in receivables at year end. Forecast next year’s revenue and ending receivables balance. Assume sales are evenly distributed over the year. © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 18 Planning Assumptions Example Example 6.1: A: The first two assumptions establish the revenue forecast. Next year, the firm expects to sell 15 million coffee cakes at $0.90 each, for total revenue of $13,500,000. The third assumption regarding receivables requires the use of the total revenue forecast. Receivables are expected to be $13,500,000 12, or $1,125,000. © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 19 The Procedural Approach and the Debt/Interest Problem • The Procedural Approach Financial plans are built line-by-line beginning with revenues • First, all income statement (IS) items are projected, stopping just before interest expense line • Then all balance sheet (BS) items are projected except long-term debt and equity © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 20 The Procedural Approach and the Debt/Interest Problem • Debt/Interest Planning Problem The next items needed are interest expense (IS) and debt (BS) However, this causes a dilemma because • Planned debt is required to forecast interest, but interest is required to forecast net income, retained earnings and debt • Results in a circular argument • Every financial plan runs into this technical problem • Can be resolved using an iterative approach beginning with a guess at the solution © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 21 Figure 6.5: The Debt/Interest Planning Problem © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 22 An Iterative Numerical Approach Example 6.2: Example Q: Complete the financial plan for Graybarr Inc., assuming that Graybarr pays interest at 10% and has a tax rate of 40%. No dividends are to be paid and no new shares are to be sold. Financial Plan for Graybarr Inc. ($000) Income Statements Balance Sheets Next Next Year Beginning Revenue $ 10,000 ASSETS Cost/Expenses $ 9,000 Total Assets $ 1,000 EBIT $ 1,000 LIABILITIES AND EQUITY Interest ? Current Liabilities $ 300 EBT ? LT Debt $ 100 Tax ? Equity $ 600 NI ? Total L&E $ 1,000 © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited Year Ending $ 3,000 $ 700 $ ? ? 3,000 23 An Iterative Numerical Approach Example 6.2: Example A: The huge increase in assets will cause the company’s debt to increase at a dramatic rate. The first iteration: Financial Plan for Graybarr Inc. ($000) Income Statements Balance Sheets Next Next Year Beginning Revenue $ 10,000 ASSETS Cost/Expenses $ 9,000 Total Assets $ 1,000 EBIT $ 1,000 LIABILITIES AND EQUITY Interest $ 200 Current Liabilities $ 300 EBT $ 800 LT Debt $ 100 Tax $ 320 Equity $ 600 NI $ 480 Total L&E $ 1,000 2: Compute NI. 1: Guess at the firm’s interest expense. Most firms use last year’s value as a guess. © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited Year Ending $ 3,000 $ $ $ $ 700 1,220 1,080 3,000 3: Calculate Ending equity as beginning equity plus NI less dividends. 4: Calculate Ending LT debt as total L&E less ending equity less ending current liabilities. 24 An Iterative Numerical Approach Example 6.2: Example A: Average debt: ($100,000 + $1,220,000) 2 = $660,000. Calculated interest: 10% × $660,000 = $66,000 Initial guess: $200,000. Perform a second iteration using an interest guess of $66,000 Financial Plan for Graybarr Inc. ($000) Income Statements Balance Sheets Next Next Year Beginning Revenue $ 10,000 ASSETS Cost/Expenses $ 9,000 Total Assets $ 1,000 EBIT $ 1,000 LIABILITIES AND EQUITY Interest $ 66 Current Liabilities $ 300 EBT $ 934 LT Debt $ 100 Tax $ 374 Equity $ 600 NI $ 560 Total L&E $ 1,000 Year Ending $ 3,000 $ $ $ $ 700 1,140 1,160 3,000 Using the guess of $66,000, the average LT debt is $620,000 and the calculated interest is $62,000, a difference of only $4,000. A third iteration using $62,000 would finalize the forecast with LT Debt = $1,137,000 © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 25 Percentage of Sales Method • A short-cut, less exact, easier method of forecasting financial statements (The “quick and dirty” approach) • Based upon forecast for the firm’s sales growth rate • Assumes most financial statement line items will vary directly with sales © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 26 Example 6.3: Percentage of Sales Method Example Q: The Overland Manufacturing Company expects next year’s revenues to increase by 15% over this year’s. No new capital assets beyond normal replacements will be needed. This year’s income statement and ending balance sheet: Overland Manufacturing Company This Year ($000) Income Statement Balance Sheet Revenue $ 13,580 ASSETS COGS $ 7,470 Cash $ Gross Margin $ 6,110 Accounts receivable $ Expenses $ 3,395 Inventory $ EBIT $ 2,715 Current assets $ Interest $ 150 Net capital assets $ EBT $ 2,565 Total Assets $ Tax $ 1,077 LIABILITIES AND EQUITY NI $ 1,488 Accounts payable $ Accruals $ Current Liabilities $ LT Debt $ Equity $ Total L&E $ 348 1,698 1,494 3,540 2,460 6,000 125 45 170 1,330 4,500 6,000 © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 27 Example 6.3: Percentage of Sales Method Example Assume the firm pays income taxes at a rate of 42%, borrows at 12% interest, and expects to pay no dividends. Project next year’s income statement and balance sheet by using the modified percentage of sales method. A: We’ll increase everything except net capital assets by 15%. Overland Manufacturing Company This Year ($000) Income Statement Balance Sheet Revenue $ 15,617 ASSETS COGS $ 8,591 Cash $ Gross Margin $ 7,027 Accounts receivable $ Expenses $ 3,904 Inventory $ EBIT $ 3,122 Current assets $ Interest Net capital assets $ EBT Total Assets $ Tax LIABILITIES AND EQUITY NI Accounts payable $ Accruals $ Current Liabilities $ LT Debt Equity Total L&E $ 400 1,953 1,718 4,071 2,460 6,531 144 52 196 6,531 © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited All highlighted items were increased by 15%. At this point we are at the debt/interest impasse. We’ll guess at interest (using last year’s interest of $150,000 as a starting point) and work through the procedure. 28 Example 6.3: Example A: Percentage of Sales Method Overland Manufacturing Company This Year ($000) Income Statement Balance Sheet Next Year This Year Revenue $ 15,617 ASSETS COGS $ 8,591 Cash $ 348 Gross Margin $ 7,027 Accounts receivable $ 1,698 Expenses $ 3,904 Inventory $ 1,494 EBIT $ 3,122 Current assets $ 3,540 Interest $ 150 Net capital assets $ 2,460 EBT $ 2,972 Total Assets $ 6,000 Tax $ 1,248 LIABILITIES AND EQUITY NI $ 1,724 Accounts payable $ 125 Accruals $ 45 Current Liabilities $ 170 LT Debt $ 1,330 Equity $ 4,500 Total L&E $ 6,000 Next Year $ $ $ $ $ $ 400 1,953 1,718 4,071 2,460 6,531 $ $ $ $ $ $ 144 52 196 112 6,224 6,531 EAT was computed using an Interest of $150,000. The resulting NI was added to Equity and the LT Debt figure was a plug, calculated by subtracting Equity and Current Liabilities from Total L&E. Taking the average debt at 12% yields a calculated interest of $86,000 which is considerably less than the $150,000 assumed. 2 more iterations should yield a final projection of $84,000. © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 29 Percentage of Sales Method— Algebraic Approach • Algebraic Approach Forecast total assets - forecast current liabilities - last years equity + forecast dividends = forecast debt + (1-T)[EBIT – Int%(.5)(last year’s debt + forecast debt)] © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 30 Example 6.3: Percentage of Sales Method • Algebraic Approach For Example 6.3 Example $6,531 – $196 – $4,500 + 0 = forecast debt + (1.42)[3,122 - .12($1330 + forecast debt/2)] $1,835 = forecast debt + $1,810.76 – $46.284 - .0348 forecast debt $70.524 = .9652 forecast debt forecast debt = $73.07 interest cost = .12($1,330 + $73)/2 = 84 equity = $4,500 + $1,762 = $6,262 © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 31 Percentage of Sales Method— Spreadsheet Approach Example • Spreadsheet Approach for Example 6.3 Use the Goal Seek function in Excel. Set cell for E16 (Total L&E) To value: $6,531 (the value for total assets) By changing cell: E14 (Long term debt) Click OK. Goal Seek will then solve for the Long term debt and the income statement and balance sheet © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 32 Percentage of Sales Method Example Example 6.3: © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 33 Example Example 6.3: Percentage of Sales Method Overland Manufacturing Company Next Year ($000) Income Statement Balance Sheet Revenue $ 15,617 ASSETS COGS $ 8,591 Cash $ Gross Margin $ 7,026 Accounts receivable $ Expenses $ 3,904 Inventory $ EBIT $ 3,122 Current assets $ Interest $ 84 Net capital assets $ EBT $ 3,038 Total Assets $ Tax $ 1,276 LIABILITIES AND EQUITY NI $ 1,762 Accounts payable $ Accruals $ Current Liabilities $ LT Debt $ Equity $ Total L&E $ 400 1,953 1,718 4,071 2,460 6,531 144 52 196 73 6,262 6,531 © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 34 External Funding Requirement • Forecasting Cash Needs A growing firm must buy assets to support growth Some funds will be generated internally via • Current liabilities • Retained earnings When a plan shows increasing debt, the implication is that additional external financing will be needed A key reason for doing financial projections is to forecast the firm’s External Funding Requirement Funds can be obtained by • Issuing debt or bank financing • Issuing new shares © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 35 External Funding Requirement • External Funding Requirement (EFR) growth in assets – growth in current liabilities – earnings retained = external funding requirement © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 36 External Funding Requirement (EFR) • If we assume that Net capital assets will grow at the same rate as sales growth (g), then Growth in assets = g Assetsthis year Growth in current liabilities = g x Current liabilitiesthis year NInext year = ROS (1 + g)Salesthis year d = dividends/net income Earnings retained = (1 – d) NInext year EFR=g[Assetsthis year-Current liabilitiesthisyear - NI(1-d)] - NI(1-d) © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 37 Example 6.4: External Funding Requirement Q: Reforecast the external funding requirements of the Overland Example Manufacturing Company (Example 6.3) assuming net capital assets and NI grow at the same rate as sales (15%). Assume the firm plans to pay a dividend equal to 25% of earnings next year. Overland Manufacturing Company This Year ($000) Income Statement Balance Sheet Revenue $ 13,580 ASSETS COGS $ 7,470 Cash $ Gross Margin $ 6,110 Accounts receivable $ Expenses $ 3,395 Inventory $ EBIT $ 2,715 Current assets $ Interest $ 150 Net capital assets $ EBT $ 2,565 Total Assets $ Tax $ 1,077 LIABILITIES AND EQUITY NI $ 1,488 Accounts payable $ Accruals $ Current Liabilities $ LT Debt $ Equity $ Total L&E $ 348 1,698 1,494 3,540 2,460 6,000 125 45 170 1,330 4,500 6,000 © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited The line items needed to apply the EFR equation are highlighted. We also need the expected revenue growth of 15% and the dividend payout ratio of 25%. 38 Example 6.4: External Funding Requirement A: Applying the EFR equation we have: Example EFR = g[Assetsthis year - Current liabilitiesthis year - NI(1 – d)] - NI(1 – d) = 0.15[$6,000 – 170 - $1,488(1 - 0.25)] - $1,488(1 - 0.25) = -$408.9 A negative EFR figure means no additional outside funds are needed. A negative result says that Overland will generate enough funds during the period to reduce its debt by about $409,000. © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 39 The Sustainable Growth Rate • The rate at which a firm can grow without selling new shares Results from growth in retained earnings (Net income – dividends) Business operations create new equity equal to the amount of current retained earnings, or (1 – d)NI Sustainable growth rate = NI(1-d) gs = Equity Assumes that new long-term debt will need to be raised to keep the debt/equity ratio constant © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 40 The Sustainable Growth Rate • Incorporating equations from the DuPont equations into the gs equation we obtain EAT sales assets gs 1 d sales assets equity Thus, a firm’s ability to grow depends on the following Its ability to earn profits on sales (ROS) Its talent at using assets to generate sales (total asset turnover) Its use of leverage (equity multiplier) The percentage of earnings retained (1 – d) © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 41 Plans With More Complicated Assumptions • The percentage of sales method is appropriate for quick estimates, but generally isn’t used in formal plans because it glosses over too much detail • Real plans generally incorporate separate planning assumptions for each important financial item Assumption depends on the way the related item is managed and on its accounting treatment © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 42 Plans With More Complicated Assumptions • Direct planning assumptions reflect the factors that will affect the forecasted dollar value of a line item on the financial statements. For example Capital assets are forecast by projecting • New expenditures using the capital plan • Amortization based upon total gross cost Lease expenses are based upon existing and new lease contracts © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 43 Plans With More Complicated Assumptions • Indirect planning assumptions are made about financial ratios, which in turn lead to line item values Accounts receivable are generally forecast by making an assumption about the Average Collection Period and calculating the implied balance Inventory is generally forecast indirectly thru the Inventory Turnover ratio © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 44 Planning at the Department Level • Operational plans Departmental detail supports the expense entries on the planned income statement • Manufacturing Departments A detailed manufacturing plan forecasts spending levels in factory departments, production quantities, and inventory levels at the beginning and end of the year © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 45 Detail for Annual Planning at the Department Level Figure 6.6: © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 46 The Cash Budget • Forecasting cash is an important part of financial planning • The cash budget is a detailed projection of receipts and disbursements of cash Receipts generally come from cash sales, collecting receivables, borrowing and selling shares Disbursements include paying for purchases, wages, taxes and other expenses including rent, utilities, supplies, etc. • It also shows whether the company needs short-term external financing during the budget period. © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 47 Receivables and Payables— Forecasting with Time Lags • Collections of receivables lag projected credit sales • Purchases may lead sales • Payments for purchases may lag purchases, depending on vendors’ credit terms © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 48 Receivables and Payables—Forecasting with Time Lags—Example Q: A firm experiences the following time lags in its collections: Months after sale % collected 1 2 3 60% 30% 8% Example The firm expects its credit sales from January through March to be: Credit sales Jan Feb Mar $500 $600 $700 Determine the company’s expected cash collections from receivables. A: Jan Feb Mar 500 600 700 Jan 300 150 40 Feb 360 180 48 420 210 56 510 640 258 Credit sales Apr May Jun Collections from sales in Mar Total collections 300 © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 56 49 Debt and Interest • Forecasting short-term debt and interest can be tricky if a company is funding current cash needs directly by borrowing If the month’s cash flow is negative, borrow If the month’s cash flow is positive, repay prior loans The current month’s interest payment may be based on the preceding month’s loan balance © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 50 Example 6.8: Q: The Cash Budget The Pulmeri Company’s revenues (actual and forecast) for the six months ended June 30 are as follows ($000). Revenue Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun 5,000 8,000 9,000 5,000 8,000 9,000 Example Pulmeri collects its receivables according to the following pattern. Months after sale % collected 1 2 3 65% 25% 10% The firm purchases and receives inventory one month in advance of sales. Materials cost about half of sales revenue. Invoices for inventory purchases are paid 50% in the first and 50% in the second month after purchase. Payroll is $2.5M per month, and general expenses are $1.5M per month. A $0.5M tax payment is scheduled for mid-April. Pulmeri has a short-term loan outstanding that is expected to stand at $5M at the end of March. Monthly interest is 1% of the previous month end balance. Pulmeri does not require any balance in its cash account. Prepare Pulmeri’s cash budget for the April May and June (its second quarter). © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 51 Example 6.8: The Cash Budget A: First lay out revenue and collections according to the historical pattern. Example Revenue Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun 5,000 8,000 9,000 5,000 8,000 9,000 3,250 1,250 500 5,200 2,000 800 5,850 2,250 900 3,250 1,250 Collections from sales made in Jan Feb Mar Apr May Second qtr. collections © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 5,200 8,350 6,300 7,350 52 Example 6.8: The Cash Budget Example A: Next, time inventory purchases (half of sales dollars) one month prior to sale. Time the payments so that 50% of the purchases are paid for in the month after purchase, and the remainder 2 months after purchase. Jan Purchases Feb Mar Apr May 4,500 2,500 4,000 4,500 2,250 2,250 Jun Payment Feb Mar 1,250 Apr 1,250 2,000 May Payment for materials © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 2,000 2,250 3,500 3,250 4,250 53 Example 6.8: The Cash Budget Example A: Summarize these results along with payroll and other disbursements Pulmeri Company Cash Budget Second Quarter 20x1 ($000) Jan Feb Mar Apr 5,000 8,000 9,000 5,000 8,000 9,000 8,350 6,300 7,350 Materials purchases 3,500 3,250 4,250 Payroll 2,500 2,500 2,500 General expenses 1,500 1,500 1,500 Revenue Collections May Jun Disbursements Tax payment © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 500 54 Example 6.8: The Cash Budget Example A: Calculate the interest charges , based upon 1% of the prior month’s loan balance, and the net cash flow Pulmeri Company Cash Budget Second Quarter 20x1 ($000) Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun 8,000 7,250 8,250 Cash flows before interest 350 (950) (900) Interest (50) (47) (57) Net cash flow 300 (997) (957) (4,700) (5,697) (6,654) Disbursements Cumulative cash flow/loan (5,000) © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 55 Management Issues in Financial Planning • The Financial Plan as a Set of Goals The financial plan can be a tool with which to manage the company and motivate desirable performance Problems arise when top management puts in stretch goals • A target for which the organization strives, but is unlikely to achieve • People may give up if they consider the goal impossible © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 56 Risk in Financial Planning in General • Stretch planning and aggressive optimism can lead to unrealistic plans that have little chance of coming true • Top-down plans are forced on the organization by senior management and are often unrealistically optimistic Middle and lower level managers often feel that such plans are unrealistic The risk in financial planning is that the plan overstates achievable performance © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 57 Risk in Financial Planning in General • Underforecasting—The Other Extreme Underforecasting sets up a goal that is easy to meet and ensures future success Bottom-up plans are consolidated from lower management’s inputs and tend to understate what the firm can do • The Ideal Process Ideally the process is a combination of the topdown and bottom-up approaches The end result is a realistic compromise that is achievable © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 58 Risk in Financial Planning in General • Scenario Analysis—”What If”ing Many companies produce a number of plans reflecting different scenarios—”what if” Gives planners a feel for the impact of their assumptions not coming true • Communication A business unit is expected to have confidence in its plan A single plan tends to be published along with its attendant risks © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 59 Financial Planning and Computers • Virtually all planning is done with the aid of computers • Computers make planning quicker and more thorough, but don’t improve the judgments at the heart of the plan © 2006 by Nelson, a division of Thomson Canada Limited 60