Harnessing the Power of Technology to Improve Chronic Care Management A Whitepaper Harnessing the Power of Technology to Improve Chronic Care Management Contents Executive Summary .............................................................................................................................................................................................. 3 The Cost of Care .................................................................................................................................................................................................... 4 Self-Management Scenario .............................................................................................................................................................................. 6 Care Coordination Scenario.............................................................................................................................................................................. 8 Caregiver/Patient Collaboration Scenario .................................................................................................................................................11 Improved Decision Support Scenario .........................................................................................................................................................13 Future of Healthcare ..........................................................................................................................................................................................15 Start Building a Better Future Today ...........................................................................................................................................................17 Appendix: Microsoft Technologies Supporting Chronic Care Management ..............................................................................18 Why Microsoft?....................................................................................................................................................................................................19 Appendix: Microsoft Solutions at Work Today .......................................................................................................................................20 2|Page January 2012 Harnessing the Power of Technology to Improve Chronic Care Management Executive Summary The prevalence of chronic conditions is increasing in Canada, and the financial impact on health system is mounting. In the current environment, technology can be harnessed to support new approaches of coordinating and managing chronic conditions benefiting providers, patients and all Canadians. The Canadian healthcare system is perceived to be a successful model by international comparison. However, governments and providers of healthcare services will need to develop new approaches in order to address key trends and challenges such as long wait times, growing consumer demand for access to higher quality healthcare, rising costs, rise in chronic illnesses, and an aging population. Overcoming these challenges will require a combination of initiatives such as coordinated disease management, patient self-care programs, and timely interventions to identify early warning signs of potential problems that could result in costly acute situations. In particular, Canadian healthcare can benefit from both existing information technologies, as well as adaptation of newer information technologies and services that facilitate: Improved on-line patient interaction: Web based technologies that enable patients to self-manage conditions, access and share critical information about their health, and connect to biometric devices such as blood pressure monitors, glucometers and more. Improved coordination of care: Empowering health professionals to have access to critical patient information as patients move across the continuum of care. Remote monitoring and virtual communication: Tools that enable telehealth scenarios where consultations and collaboration take place via low cost and pervasive web conferencing tools and commodity devices, rather than face-to-face. Population health intelligence: Making data readily available to provide a clear view of patient populations, helping drive better treatment for both the individual and the broader population health initiatives. This thought paper illustrates the financial impact of chronic disease in Canada, and how a move towards the use of technology has the potential for improving the delivery of services, while helping to keep costs down. Many healthcare organizations in Canada as well as across the globe are realizing the benefits of taking advantage of existing infrastructure and information technologies. Advances in web and mobile technologies, and telehealth services are helping improve efficiencies in care team collaboration, patient-doctor consultation, and patient education. Gaming technologies are gaining recognition for their potential in supporting health and wellness, physical activity and even rehabilitation scenarios. Cloud technology gives healthcare providers an opportunity to rapidly build and deploy scalable and interoperable systems without a large capital investment in infrastructure. Microsoft has made significant investments to develop technologies that connect the health community, enable healthcare providers to unlock the power of data to help improve care, and to provide consumers the tools they 3|Page January 2012 Harnessing the Power of Technology to Improve Chronic Care Management need to better manage their own health and specific conditions. In this paper, you will learn how technology can help improve chronic care management in the areas of: Patient Self-management Care coordination across the health continuum Caregiver/patient collaboration Improved decision support and analytics The Cost of Care The Canadian healthcare system is perceived to be a successful model by international comparison. Spending on healthcare was expected to reach 11.6 percent of gross domestic product (GDP) in 2011,1 which compares favorably to the United States’ expenditure of around 17 percent of GDP.2 The future of Canadian healthcare, however, is facing serious risks. The current system is grappling with long wait times, growing consumer demand for access to high quality care, rising costs, and an aging population. Canada needs to find affordable ways to meet the increasing demands on their healthcare system. The cost of healthcare is perhaps the most pressing issue. It’s rising rapidly in Canada – from $39.7 billion in 1975 to $200.5 billion in 20111 – an increase that more than doubled per-capita spending. Costs are being driven by a number of factors – data show that hospitals make up the largest component of healthcare spending, accounting for 29.1% of total health expenditures in 2009. Drugs represent the second-largest share at 16.2%, while physicians make up the third-largest share at 13.6%. While hospitals, drugs and physicians account for almost 60% of the total healthcare spending, many experts believe that one important way to reduce healthcare spending is to shift care delivery from costly acute settings to more cost effective community and home based settings. There are a number of critical factors required to make this shift, including policy enablers (such as payment models), information and communication technologies, and consumer empowerment – to help individuals take a more active role in managing health. The largest single driver of healthcare costs in Canada is chronic disease. In 2010, the direct cost of care for chronic disease in Canada reached $68 billion, more than half of all health care spending 3. Take diabetes, for example. The number of people diagnosed with diabetes in Canada [was] expected to double between 2000 and 2010, from 1.3 million to about 2.5 million. By 2020, another 1.2 million people are expected to be diagnosed with diabetes, bringing the total to about 3.7 million. As that number grows, diabetes will consume a growing share of healthcare budgets. By 2020, diabetes is expected to cost Canada more than $16 billion. It now accounts for about 3.5 percent of public healthcare spending in Canada, a share that is expected to rise significantly. Other chronic disease costs driven by obesity, cardiovascular conditions, and other illnesses, are expected to increase in a similar 1 Canadian Institute for Health Information, CIHI, (2011), National Health Expenditure Trends, 1975 to 2011, http://secure.cihi.ca/cihiweb/products/nhex_trends_report_2011_en.pdf 2 Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, National Health Expenditures 2009 Highlights, National Health Expenditure Data, Historical, https://www.cms.gov/NationalHealthExpendData/downloads/highlights.pdf 3 Public Health Agency of Canada, Chronic Diseases – Most Significant Cause of Death Globally (2011), http://www.phac-aspc.gc.ca/media/nr- rp/2011/2011_0919-bg-di-eng.php 4|Page January 2012 Harnessing the Power of Technology to Improve Chronic Care Management fashion.4 The Canadian healthcare sector can make strides toward managing these costs and improving chronic disease management through the use of existing information technologies, and leveraging new innovative technologies and services. Many healthcare organizations in Canada and worldwide are already realizing the benefits of the technologies. These technologies enable greater patient self-management, improve care coordination through better access to patient information, provide ways to support caregiver/patient collaboration using remote monitoring and virtual communication, and allow healthcare providers better access to population health intelligence data and improved decision support. Improving the healthcare system and keeping costs down is important to the Canadian public as well. According to a press release published by the Canadian Medical Association entitled, Canadians see "Moral Imperative" to Fix Health Care System Ottawa, August 10, 2011; the Canadian public is ready for a change in the healthcare system. In reference to the Voices into Action: Report on the National Dialogue on Health Care Transformation, the Canadian Medical Association states, “The report shows clearly that, while the public recognizes that our system does not work as well as it should, there remains a strong national commitment to transform our system so that it can deliver timely, compassionate and efficient care in the appropriate setting.” 5 4 Canadian Diabetes Association (December 2009), New Canadian Diabetes Cost Model Paints a Sobering View of Diabetes in Canada http://www.diabetes.ca/get-involved/news/new-canadian-diabetes-cost-model-paints-a-sobering-view-of-diabetes-in-cana/ 5 Canadian Medical Association, CMA, (August 2011), Canadians See "Moral Imperative" to Fix Health Care System, http://www.cma.ca/advocacy/canadians-see-moral-imperative 5|Page January 2012 Harnessing the Power of Technology to Improve Chronic Care Management Self-Management Scenario For the Vancouver-based family of Sara, helping her husband, Bob, manage his diabetes is an everyday task. He sometimes struggles to keep his blood-sugar in balance which puts him at risk for further complications. Sara lacked an easy way to keep track of Bob’s diabetes treatment. Records from visits to specialists, prescriptions, lab results, plus personal records of diet and glucose levels were kept in various locations, and not readily available. Having a centralized location to store and access all this information could help them a great deal to successfully manage his condition. Sara also needed to keep track of her own health records as well as those of her two teenage sons. One place for everything was the ideal solution. Recently, Sara read an article about a new, web-based tool to manage personal health information, and she gave it a try. Using her computer and her mobile device, Sara was able to collect, store and manage health records for her entire family – even for her parents, who live in Toronto. She could also store copies of records from doctors’ appointments and prescriptions, and share that information with other healthcare providers, saving time and ensuring that relevant records are available and usable. Bob, meanwhile, could now send data from his blood glucose meter directly to his online health record and diabetes management application. That way, both he and his doctor see blood sugar patterns over weeks or even months, and better understand how to help Bob keep control of his health. Similarly, Sara can add personal information about family conditions, upload data from a variety of medical devices and tools such as blood-pressure monitors, and share all of this important information with doctors and health professionals. Scenarios described here are for illustration purposes only, and people described in the scenarios are fictional. While online personal health record solutions are offering a way for people to manage their health information, their functionality can be extended to meet the specific needs of a healthcare providers and patients, creating an inter-connected hub to allow provider, patients and care teams work together and share critical information more efficiently. By harnessing the power of technology, providers can access useful and comprehensive data in order to gain continuous insight into the patients’ status. Timely interventions can help prevent the need for spur-of-themoment appointments and preventable acute episodes. For patients, being able to track health-related information into one easily accessible view and share that information with doctors and specialists enables them to be more informed and proactive in partnering with their care teams. The more patients are engaged, the more likely they will become active participants in managing their health and wellness. Recent studies demonstrate that Canadians are ready. 6|Page January 2012 Harnessing the Power of Technology to Improve Chronic Care Management Over 65 per cent of Canadians said they would favor having a government-provided electronic health record that could be used by themselves and their health providers; a similar number support medical devices that enable them to check their health condition and send information electronically to their doctor.6 In December 2008, Cleveland Clinic and Microsoft collaborated on a pilot project that pairs the hospital’s electronic medical records system with the software company’s online HealthVault service to monitor patients’ health conditions. The participants of the program used a set of information technology tools and portable, digital medical devices to upload health data to HealthVault – a security-enhanced, web-based data storage platform for patients – which then connected the data to their electronic medical record system used by the patient’s healthcare providers at A project that paired the patients of the Cleveland Clinic with Microsoft HealthVault offers a promising model of how technology can help improve patient selfmanagement. Cleveland Clinic. The project found a significant change in the average number of days between physician office visits for patients. Diabetic and hypertensive patients were able to make doctor’s office visits less often, increasing the number of days between appointments by 71 percent and 26 percent respectively, indicating that patients had better control of their conditions.7 The project demonstrated how technology can help link patients with caregivers, and it offers a promising model for improving patient self-management and physician oversight of patients with chronic diseases. Technology innovation, however, is not only prevalent in US-based examples – these technologies and tools are quickly gaining momentum in Canada. In May 2010, TELUS® Health Solutions announced the launch of TELUS health space, powered by Microsoft HealthVault – Canada’s first Canada Health Infoway certified online platform for personal health. This cloud-based solution will give Canadians greater control on the organizing and managing of their personal and family health information in one place, and with a powerful ecosystem of health tools and applications on the platform.8 TELUS health space will allow patients to play a more active role in their health and manage their chronic conditions in a number of ways including tracking medications, lab results, and readings from devices (such as blood pressure cuffs and blood glucose meters), and sharing that information with their physicians and other allied health professionals. 6 Marketwire (August 2011), A Majority of Canadians Report They Are in Good Physical and Emotional Health, but Challenges With Wellness, Healthy Living and Chronic Disease Are on the Rise: Deloitte 7 Cleveland Clinic (2010, March 1). Cleveland Clinic/Microsoft Pilot Promising; Home Health Services May Benefit Chronic Disease Management. Retrieved from myclevelandclinic.org March 2012. 8 TELUS Personal Health Record introduced at eHealth 2011 Conference (May 2011). Retrieved August, 2011. http://telushealth.com/en/newsroom/news/2011/may30-a.aspx 7|Page January 2012 Harnessing the Power of Technology to Improve Chronic Care Management Care Coordination Scenario Dr. Jones – Sara and Bob’s family physician – has her own challenges. When treating Bob, she needs to know what medications Bob is taking and what other kinds of treatment he may be receiving. Dr. Jones has an electronic medical record for Bob and her roster of patients, but other health professionals and clinicians with whom she works (such as dietitians, endocrinologists, or ophthalmologists) have their own systems, which don’t “talk” to one another. This makes it difficult for Dr. Jones and her peers to get consolidated access to Bob’s data, monitor his care plans, make patient medical performance visible to other clinicians, and see complete records of specialist referrals, hospitalization history, and more. A connected system that enables information sharing between providers could allow Dr. Jones to practice more “team-based” medicine, and take a coordinated-care approach toward Bob’s needs. Scenarios described here are for illustration purposes only, and people described in the scenarios are fictional. Patients’ health data is frequently confined to individual providers’ information systems (whether electronic or paper-based); consequently, physicians must often make treatment and prescription decisions without all available clinical data, or else spend valuable time and resources attempting to aggregate data. Improving care coordination would enable better chronic condition management, as described by the Chronic Care Model, a framework developed in the 1990s by E.H. Wagner and his team. At the core of the Chronic Care Model is a fundamental premise that the best quality chronic care is accomplished by having collaborative, productive interactions between patients and their clinical care teams. The model focuses on strengthening these through self-management support, improved therapeutic decision-making, care team collaboration and managed follow-up. The Chronic Care Model is specifically designed to address the increasing problem of chronic disease, and the disparity of approaches for the management and care of chronic illnesses.9 While in some sectors, today’s consumers are accustomed to dealing with organizations that understand and even anticipate their needs – in the healthcare sector – patients go from the hospital, to their doctor and other specialists without a sense that their care providers understand their complete history or needs – which can negatively impact consumer confidence. Tools that have long been a staple of the business world, such as customer relationship management (CRM) systems, can help bring a similar ‘customer orientation’ to healthcare by leveraging case management, care coordination and patient outreach programs. Through the use of CRM technology, providers can streamline administrative tasks, automate communications and manage patient outreach – often referred to as patient relationship management. CRM technology provides a central hub to process and integrate the patients' data collected by clinicians, care teams and staff, and manage 9 E.H. Wagner, “Chronic Disease Management: What Will It Take to Improve Care for Chronic Illness?” Effective Clinical Practice 1, no. 1 (1998), Retrieved May 2012 . 8|Page January 2012 Harnessing the Power of Technology to Improve Chronic Care Management complex workflows. CRM technology also supports shared access to patient information to monitor critical procedures and track patient symptoms. As a result, physicians can spend time more efficiently with patients, spend less time accessing hard-to-find or paper-based information, and effectively change the care paradigm, from treating episodes of illness to enabling proactive care by establishing productive, ’shared decision making’ relationships with patients. Maccabi Healthcare Services,10 a healthcare provider serving one of every four people in Israel with full range of facilities - hospitals, clinics, dental offices, and pharmacies - needed a means for bringing the data from these disparate systems together. Implementation of CRM technology helped Maccabi improve service levels and open up information from multiple systems to their care teams In order to garner a 360-degree view of member data, information from multiple systems would be integrated into a single service application. The team integrated Microsoft Dynamics CRM solution with Maccabi’s core system. Every transaction that is performed in the older legacy system is populated into the CRM platform using automated processes to move tasks and work-flows from person to person through to completion. As a result, customer service representatives have a full, real-time view of member data. Each interaction picks up where the previous one ends, boosting productivity and efficiently routing issues and tasks appropriately. Members no longer have to repeat their history because representatives have access to comprehensive member data at their fingertips. Implementing portal platforms to both present and capture data in real time can improve operational efficiencies and patient services. In Australia,11 the Improvement Foundation produced a portal platform to connect more than 1,000 general practices to their patients. Using Microsoft SQL Server to house a wide range of data and Microsoft SharePoint portal to present the data, general practice physicians and staff were better able to collect and report data themselves, and share information across systems. Quick access to this data led to improvements in chronic care. 10 Microsoft Case Study Portal (July 2009.) Maccabi Healthcare Services, Healthcare Provider Improves Customer Service with Real-Time Patient Data Visibility. Retrieved August 2011. (see Appendix) 11 Microsoft Case Study Portal (June 2010) Improvement Foundation Australia, How Sharepoint helped IFA connect with healthcare professionals. Retrieved August 2011 (see Appendix) 9|Page January 2012 Harnessing the Power of Technology to Improve Chronic Care Management Often, disconnected data systems that don’t talk to each other provide a huge challenge for coordinated care. The freiburger spital,12 a consortium of six public hospitals in Fribourg, Switzerland, joined together to integrate their various applications into one IT system using Microsoft BizTalk Server. As a result, a large number of point-to-point connections were replaced by a central hub, through which data from a wide variety of systems is consolidated, synchronized, and forwarded. “Thanks to this integration solution, we have increased our flexibility, reduced costs, and connected all hospital locations to a common IT infrastructure. This, in turn, enables us to provide our patients with a better level of care and support,” said Marc Devaud, Head of Projects and Development of the freiburger spital. “The new integration Healthcare providers managing chronic diseases could also benefit from technology solution enables us to that simplifies research, identifies drugs and side effects, and provides evidence provide our patients based recommendations for how to manage patients with multiple chronic diseases. with a better level of In the United Kingdom, for instance, business tools such as Microsoft SharePoint care and support.” Server and FAST Search technology in combination with Microsoft ASP.NET were - Marc Devaud, Head of Projects and Development, freiburger spital. used to build a web-based search portal called NHS Evidence.13 Developed by the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE), part of the United Kingdom’s National Health Service (NHS), NHS Evidence is a single-source location where healthcare providers can find the latest and most authoritative clinical and nonclinical evidence, and use that information to better treat their patients. NHS Evidence had 12,000 visits on its first day (in April 2009), and, as of November 2010, traffic averaged about 1 million visits a month. NHS Evidence users love the new service. The doctors can now find information in a fraction of the time it used to take. Also, because NHS Evidence is built with Microsoft products, it integrates well with other Microsoft products already in use by the NHS. 12 Microsoft Case Study Portal (June 2010) freiburger spital Hospital Network Reduces Costs and Improves Care by Consolidating Disparate IT Systems. Retrieved August 2011 (see Appendix) 13 Microsoft Case Study Portal (January 2011), National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence Health Agency Simplifies Information Access for Health Professionals with Web Portal, Retrieved August 2011 10 | P a g e January 2012 Harnessing the Power of Technology to Improve Chronic Care Management Caregiver/Patient Collaboration Scenario Dr. Jones is responsible for scores of patients. Some live nearby, some in remote areas. Indeed, geography is a constant problem for Canadian healthcare providers, many of whom are responsible for patients in thinly populated areas where it’s not feasible to locate permanent healthcare facilities. She found that many of her patients were going too long between appointments making it difficult to catch changes in symptoms which put them at risk for medical complications, emergency care or hospitalization. One patient in particular who lived over two hours away, relied on virtual on-line visits from a nurse to report changes in symptoms rather than having to travel to Dr. Jones’s office. During a recent on-line visit, the nurse suspected the patient may have been experiencing negative sideeffects from a medication. The nurse was able to arrange a virtual consultation with Dr. Jones about this patient’s symptoms and seek guidance on the appropriate protocols. It turned out the nurse’s evaluation was very timely and a short video conference with Dr. Jones prevented complications and a costly trip to the nearest emergency room. Dr. Jones found that her patients who kept themselves educated about their conditions and overall health, and those able to keep up with regular consultations did much better overall, requiring fewer interventions. This was true for both her long-distance patients, as well as those living nearby. Oftentimes a quick consultation (on-line or face-to-face) with another member of a patient’s care team was all she needed in order to make effective intervention decisions. Scenarios described here are for illustration purposes only, and people described in the scenarios are fictional. Patients with chronic diseases – and the physicians who treat them – can benefit from harnessing technology solutions that allow more efficient collaboration, patient-doctor consultations, and patient education. In January 2009, the Hawaii Medical Service Association (HMSA)14 became the first health plan in the U.S. to offer every Hawaiian resident and HMSA member medical care online, providing patients with the opportunity to speak to a physician or specialist via web-based video conferencing, telephone, or secure on-line chat. Patients can immediately speak to a local physician anytime and virtually anywhere and get answers to medical questions without waiting weeks for a scheduled appointment. 14 HMSA (January 2009) First in the nation, HMSA’s Online Care goes live, http://www.hmsa.com/mediacenter/press/2009/090115_onlinecare_launch.aspx 11 | P a g e January 2012 Harnessing the Power of Technology to Improve Chronic Care Management Built in a partnership with American Well™, the HMSA system solves several problems relevant to Canada’s needs: Time — Illnesses and accidents rarely happen at the best times. And some patients must be seen immediately, unable to wait for weeks for a scheduled appointment. Online Care is an on-demand service that provides almost immediate access to doctors. Distance — Hawaii is a rural state with a scattered population and a limited number of doctors. Online Care connects patients with doctors statewide. Mobility/disability — Patients with impaired ability to get around may find it difficult to leave their homes for doctor visits. Online Care allows patients to speak with doctors without having to leave their own home. Canada also is realizing some of the benefits of telehealth. The Ontario Telemedicine Network, for instance, uses video capabilities to deliver healthcare in remote locations. It employs some 1,200 video conferencing endpoints in locations across Ontario, and currently is rolling out capabilities that will allow doctors and nurses to access the network from personal computers. More than 3,000 healthcare providers in Ontario use the network, and manage remotely about 135,000 patient visits each year.15 According to a recent study commissioned by Canada Health Infoway,16 Telehealth Benefits and Adoption – Connecting People and Providers across Canada, telehealth services grew more than 35 percent in the past five years. This is resulting in improvements in care such as better chronic disease management and improved care coordination. Expanding telehealth offerings in Canada could help drive more efficient use of provider resources, delivering healthcare to remote areas, and give patients everywhere better access to health information and advice. Unified communication technologies, such as Microsoft Lync and Skype, offer solutions that bring the many ways healthcare professionals communicate into one familiar user interface. With the click of a mouse or a simple voice command, a caregiver can initiate an email, an instant message, a phone call, a web conference or book a meeting. By using an audio or video conference, caregivers can quickly find colleagues by department or role and connect with them using the presence information integrated within clinical and administrative portals. Distributed care teams can share test results, X-rays, and other clinical information with each other on a variety of systems and devices. Such an approach can help resolve issues faster. Microsoft Lync also makes it easy to schedule patient appointments, plan follow-ups and set up alerts. Patients and caregivers can communicate more efficiently before, after and between office visits. That may include remote delivery of patient education, post-treatment counseling and virtual group sessions. 15 Ontario Telemedicine Network, Copyright © 2008 OTN. All rights reserved. http://otn.ca/en/otn/about-otn, http://otn.ca/index.php?uri=/en/services/video-conferencing 16 Canada Health Infoway, Telehealth Benefits and Adoption – Connecting People and Providers across Canada Source: https://www.infoway- inforoute.ca/about-infoway/news/news-releases/740 12 | P a g e January 2012 Harnessing the Power of Technology to Improve Chronic Care Management Cancer Care Ontario (CCO) replaced their private branch exchange (PBX) systems17 with Microsoft Office Communications Server to make their conferencing and communications systems more robust and agile, thus reducing the infrastructure costs required for a new employee. By implementing the Microsoft Unified Communications system, CCO was able to reduce or avoid additional equipment costs, improve employee efficiency and communication as well as provide employee’s location information that was so critical for 911 services. Improved Decision Support Scenario Over time, Dr. Carey noticed that a number of her patients were showing increased risks of developing diabetes, heart disease and other chronic conditions. While some patients were exhibiting negative trends in the progression of their conditions, she didn’t have access to comprehensive data that would support her observations or offer insights as to cause. She felt that having this insight could help her better identify “at risk” patients and improve care coordination across her extended care team. Access to comparative outcomes and analysis of different treatments and procedures could help her better manage patient care, and create efficiencies in clinic services. Dr. Carey knows from reading peer review journals and attending conferences that healthcare providers and health systems around the world are putting new business intelligence technologies to work in healthcare environments. The data from these technologies is helping doctors understand which patients are at greater risk for hospital readmissions and how changes in treatment options can help with transitional care. Scenarios described here are for illustration purposes only, and people described in the scenarios are fictional. Commercial enterprises and advanced medical systems worldwide use advanced business intelligence tools to better understand their customers and optimize their business performance. Yet today, many healthcare organizations and governments lack the ability to effectively collect and use valuable information to gain insights, improve patient care, manage patient populations, improve operational performance, and speed up research cycles. University of Washington Medicine’s Institute of Translational Health Sciences (ITHS)18 utilized Microsoft Amalga – a health intelligence platform that integrates vast amounts of data from disparate information systems and turns that information into critical knowledge – in an effort to accelerate and improve translational research. This type of research involves applying knowledge gained from basic sciences and research to real-world clinical and 17 Microsoft Case Study Portal (July 2010) Cancer Care Ontario - Government Healthcare Agency Implements Unified Communications Solution to Reduce Costs. Retrieved August 2011 (see Appendix) 18 University of Washington to Use Microsoft Amalga to Support Clinical and Translational Research, September 2008 http://www.microsoft.com/presspass/press/2008/sep08/09-30UWAmalgaPR.mspx 13 | P a g e January 2012 Harnessing the Power of Technology to Improve Chronic Care Management community settings. University of Washington Medicine (UW Medicine) now is expanding its use of Amalga to support a range of clinical and research projects across the health organization. In one study, UW Medicine is using the Amalga platform to launch a study of children and adolescents who have diabetes. Over the course of five years, a massive database of diabetic patients will be compiled and analyzed to better understand the potential number of new diabetes cases apt to appear among U.S. children, as well as describe the complications and quality-of-life issues of those with the disease. The system makes it possible to collect and analyze the large amounts of data that will be collected during the study. Business intelligence tools can make it possible for organizations to better understand clinical and operational performance - for example - identifying which patients are at risk for being re-admitted to a hospital after discharge and the overall impact of preventable readmissions on cost and outcomes. Those tools help clinicians gain valuable insights into an acute care population by helping proactively manage at-risk patients throughout their stay and at discharge, effectively monitor patient cohorts across the organization, and reduce data collection time. As well, root causes of readmissions can be analyzed, with patient readmit probability reports based on predictive models. At Providence Alaska Medical Center, professionals are using the Modified Early Warning System (MEWS) – powered by Microsoft Amalga – to help proactively monitor early clinical signals among all inpatients to help prevent infections, escalations to intensive care and fatalities.19 Manual tracking processes weren’t sufficient and missed early warning signs unnecessarily. With this platform, Providence has been able to immediately engage the appropriate clinician as soon as an early warning signal was flagged. In the first two months of use, the technology has increased the desired interventions by 40 percent, and Providence estimates that it could save as much as $450,000 annually from unreimbursed expenses that are associated with preventable intensive care admissions. Computing power in support of laboratory and clinical research is an increasingly important factor in delivering appropriate care – systems that can handle quick analysis of genetic samples, for example, can help researchers deliver actionable results to clinicians. The Melbourne-Parkville branch of the Ludwig Institute for Cancer Research Ltd., which conducts clinical-related laboratory research, found that by converting to an all-Windows-based platform, deploying Microsoft HPC (high Performance Computing) Server, they gained needed computing power, reduced costs and improved their analysis.20 Cloud computing environments – such as Microsoft Azure - can also provide clinicians and the research community with efficient and scalable HPC compute and storage services – helping to speed up research cycles and unlocking computing resources and storage in cost effective ways. Leveraging cloud computing models allow organizations to utilize or ‘rent’ processing power and storage using on-demand models. On-demand service is more cost effective as it avoids costly up-front capital costs and permits organizations to pay for what they use. 19 Microsoft Users Group 2011 Innovation Awards Honors Forward-thinking Health Companies Powering Patient-Centered Medical Homes, Chronic Condition Management and Mobile Consumer Health, April 2008 http://blogs.msdn.com/b/microsoft_in_health/archive/2011/04/27/microsoft-users-group-2011-innovation-awards-honors-forward-thinkinghealth-companies-powering-patient-centered-medical-homes-chronic-condition-management-and-mobile-consumer-health.aspx 20 Microsoft Case Study Portal (January 2011) Ludwig Institute of Cancer Research Windows Supercomputer Speeds Quest to Identify Cancer Proteins. Retrieved August 2011 14 | P a g e January 2012 Harnessing the Power of Technology to Improve Chronic Care Management Another aspect of managing chronic disease includes making sure patients get regular checkups, appropriate referrals or tests – and that the information is accurately recorded. Without accurate patient records and data, healthcare providers will find managing patients more labor intensive and a strain on their valuable time. Djerriwarrh Health Services (DjHS) of Australia was struggling with a patient management system consisting of inaccurate patient records and poor data quality, while also combating patient absenteeism.21 Because DjHS must provide accurate information to government about patient volumes, the health service was being underfunded according to the levels of care it was providing. Implementation of Microsoft SharePoint technologies led to a 20 percent increase in funding, early warning of data entry issues, less patient absenteeism, better resource management, and better visibility into activities. Future of Healthcare There’s no argument – technology holds the promise of transforming healthcare for health providers and patients. A major emerging innovation comes from the cloud. Cloud technology gives healthcare organizations the opportunity to build and deploy leading-edge technology quickly and relatively inexpensively. The cloud offers opportunities to help reduce costs, move information outside the four walls of a healthcare institution, and engage with patients in new ways. From a cost savings perspective, a study conducted by Microsoft for the European Union concluded that Cloud computing brings the benefit of unprecedented economies of scale to IT operations, and the combined impact of economies of scale can result in long-term savings of up to 80%. Cloud services will enable IT groups to focus more on innovation while leaving non-differentiating activities to reliable and cost-effective providers.22 Using technology such as Microsoft Windows Azure, for example, a healthcare organization can deploy a largescale chronic disease study within weeks, and without a large investment in infrastructure. This is achievable because applications can be built, hosted, and scaled on Microsoft datacenters with limited IT local resources required. Developers can use familiar tools such as Microsoft Visual Studio, so applications can be built quickly, and then deployed to the cloud. Microsoft teamed up with experts from Emory University to create the H1N1 Response Center,23 a Web site where people can receive information about flu and guidance based on a self-assessment. Visitors fill out a selfassessment form and Emory's algorithms determine the severity of the situation and offer guidance that individuals can use as input to make decisions about next steps. The web site needed to be able to handle big spikes in traffic. When the media broke a story about the virus, it caused dramatic increases in site visits. 21 Microsoft Case Study Portal (February 2011) Djerriwarrh Health Services Reporting and analysis technology improves resource management, reduces patient absenteeism and secures additional funding. Retrieved August 2011 (see Appendix) 22 Microsoft (November 2010), The Economics of Cloud Computing for the EU Public Sector, http://www.microsoft.eu/Portals/0/Document/EU_Public_Sector_Cloud_Economics_A4.pdf; summaryhttp://www.microsoft.eu/Cloudeconomics.aspx 23 https://h1n1.cloudapp.net/ 15 | P a g e January 2012 Harnessing the Power of Technology to Improve Chronic Care Management The solution was Windows Azure. The site saw peak traffic on November 9, 2009 with 123,746 page views-an unexpected 365% increase over the previous day. In addition, by using Windows Azure we were able to go from idea to deployment in just three weeks. The H1N1 Response Center is a great showcase of how organizations can use Windows Azure to help people who are facing potentially dangerous situations, like H1N1. And by The H1N1 solution built on Windows Azure helps people have the information they need to make good decisions, we can help reduce the burden on the public health system and help keep healthy individuals from being exposed to serious risks unnecessarily. The H1N1 Response Center is a great example of how organizations can use Microsoft Windows Azure to guide people help people facing a scary and potentially dangerous situation, like H1N1, thereby helping to reduce the burden on the public health system. Using the cloud, Canadian healthcare providers also can engage patients more effectively. TELUS health space, powered by Microsoft HealthVault is a Canadianbased private cloud platform that is designed to empower patients. TELUS health space helps people be more actively involved in their health and wellness by enabling them to collect, store and share health information with family members and participating healthcare providers, and access to a variety user-friendly thirdparty applications and devices to help them manage their fitness, diet, and health. The increasing power of mobile devices also will play a big role. Smartphones such as Windows Phone 7 open rich new possibilities for improved productivity because they work seamlessly across a myriad of technologies. With familiar Microsoft productivity tools, like Microsoft Office and Microsoft Exchange, Windows Phone 7 enables professionals to wirelessly connect to information and resources from virtually any environment. For physicians – it’s an opportunity to get real-time, relevant information when and where they need it – viewing and interacting with personal healthcare records “on the go”, viewing schedules and lab results, receiving notifications, connecting with peers, and more. Interactive gaming technologies will play an ever-increasing role in a variety of health scenarios. Microsoft knows the power gaming technology can play when it comes to supporting health, wellness and physical activity. Imagine Kinect in pediatric centers where children can connect virtually with family and friends to play games, or in elderly homes with supervised exercise programs, or capturing a person’s biometric health data and connecting that data to Microsoft HealthVault so family members and their care providers can monitor and manage their health in new, collaborative ways. 16 | P a g e January 2012 Harnessing the Power of Technology to Improve Chronic Care Management Start Building a Better Future Today Today’s technology offers healthcare organizations affordability, ease of use, and power on a scale that could not have been imagined 10 years ago. That means there is no reason to wait for the “next big thing” in technology – it is around us now, and ready to go to work. Microsoft has the technology, the partnerships, and the know-how to help Canadian healthcare organizations reach their goals of improving care. As chronic diseases become more prevalent and consume a larger portion of each healthcare dollar, it is important for healthcare providers to find new, innovative ways to manage those conditions proactively and collaboratively within a connected network of care providers and patients. Whether through powerful data management tools such as Microsoft SQL Server, Windows Azure and Microsoft Amalga; Caregiver Collaboration tools such as Lync; personal health platforms such as Microsoft HealthVault; or consumer technology such as Kinect and Windows Phone 7, Microsoft can help Canadian healthcare providers build a better future for themselves and their patients. Start now. 17 | P a g e January 2012 Harnessing the Power of Technology to Improve Chronic Care Management Appendix: Microsoft Technologies Supporting Chronic Care Management Self-Management Coordinated Care Technology that provides access to health information and resources for supported self-management with chronic conditions. Technology that enables multidisciplinary care teams to integrate information sources and coordinate care around the needs of patients. • Microsoft® HealthVault™ is a privacy- and security-enhanced online service that puts patients in control of their health information with selfmanagement health tools and devices and supports connectivity between clinical systems. • Microsoft® SharePoint® Server‑based patient portals provide a way to deliver personalized information and resources to patients. • Windows Phone provides opportunities to create anytime and virtually anywhere access to critical health information for providers and patients alike. • Office 365™ provides virtually anywhere access to email, web conferencing, documents, and calendars. • Microsoft® BizTalk® Server connects clinical information systems. • Microsoft SharePoint Server enables effective information sharing amongst providers and a mechanism to expose data from existing systems. • Microsoft Dynamics® CRM provides an out-of-the-box solution for case management and care coordination. • Microsoft SQL Server® aggregates data from diverse healthcare systems to provide health analytics. These can be linked to patient data, financial and operational data, decision support tools and geographic information to be displayed in relevant, role-based dashboards. • Microsoft Amalga provides a platform to coordinate care and engage patients by identifying, tracking & managing chronic populations and promoting selfcare. •Forefront helps deliver end-toend security and access to information via an integrated line of protection, access, and identity management products. •Windows Server/System Center enables IT professionals to increase the reliability and flexibility of their server infrastructures to support applications, clinicians and Care-teams. Caregiver/Patient Collaboration Technology that makes it easy for care teams to collaborate and communicate effectively. Decision Support • Office 365™ provides virtually anywhere access to email, web conferencing, documents, and calendars. • Microsoft Unified Communications powered by Microsoft® Lync bring together voice, video, email, text messaging and fax. • Microsoft SharePoint Server clinical portals provide fast easy ways to share patient information, clinical documents, test results medication reviews, images and care plans. • Clinical documents such as referrals, discharge summaries and care plans can be created and exchanged using Microsoft® Office and the Microsoft Clinical Document Solution Accelerator. •Windows Phone - creates new opportunities for health professionals to share information and to consult with colleagues in real time. •Windows Server/System Center enables IT professionals to increase the reliability and flexibility of their server infrastructures to support applications, clinicians and care teams. •Forefront - helps deliver endto-end security and access to information through an integrated line of protection, access, and identity management products. • Windows Azure and SQL Azure enable you to build, host and scale applications in Microsoft datacenters, requiring no up-front expenses, no long term commitment, and enabling payment only for the resources used. • Microsoft Amalga aggregates disparate data together and makes it easy to identify and act on insights into clinical, financial, or operational performance. • Microsoft SQL Server® aggregates data from diverse healthcare systems to provide health analytics. These can be linked to patient data, financial and operational data, decision support tools and geographic information to be displayed in relevant, role-based dashboards. •Microsoft SharePoint Server ‑ based patient portals provide a way to deliver personalized information and resources • Windows Server /System Center enables IT professionals to increase the reliability and flexibility of their server infrastructures to support applications, clinicians and Policy-makers. •Forefront - helps deliver endto-end security and access to information through an integrated line of protection, access, and identity management products. Computer-based decision support tools that enable patients, clinicians and policymakers to make informed evidence-based decisions. 18 | P a g e January 2012 Harnessing the Power of Technology to Improve Chronic Care Management Why Microsoft? Microsoft has been committed to healthcare for the long term. Together with technology partners, Microsoft is creating powerful solutions that will help providers collaborate with people to connect processes and information and make insightful decisions. Microsoft has a strong track record in developing user-friendly interoperable technology to be able to deliver cost-efficient technology solutions that work. Microsoft also provides unique comprehensive solutions for organizations and individuals that give direct integrated access to information using safety, security, and privacy technology/features. Microsoft also understands that clinics and hospitals are increasingly being asked to do more with less. That is why Microsoft is dedicated to offering easy-to-implement, off-the-shelf commodity technology to healthcare providers, so that they quickly and directly help benefit patients. And because Microsoft makes some of the world’s most widely used and supported software, most people in an organization are familiar with Microsoft products - and healthcare enterprises can build on existing investments and leverage current infrastructure to do more. And because Microsoft technologies are interoperable, they can be combined with existing systems and prepared to integrate them with future technologies, and remain flexible and scalable. Lastly, Microsoft knows that people make decisions based on knowledge, not just data, and they often don’t need more information, they need better information. That is why Microsoft solutions don’t just bring data together, they turn it into information that people can use to take knowledge-driven action. People can use Microsoftbased technologies to accomplish more throughout their day because they are familiar, intuitive, and userfriendly. 19 | P a g e January 2012 Harnessing the Power of Technology to Improve Chronic Care Management Appendix: Microsoft Solutions at Work Today Note: Each dot indicating the location on the map is linked to its respect details in the table below. To know more about the location indicated on the map, press Ctrl and click the dot. 20 | P a g e January 2012 Harnessing the Power of Technology to Improve Chronic Care Management United States Chronic Condition Management – American Heart Wellness: Mayo Clinic 24 The Mayo Clinic Health Manager helps people track progress towards recommended and personal goals, assess risk, monitor vital health stats like blood pressure, weight, and cholesterol, and offers personalized condition and wellness guidance developed by the experts at Mayo Clinic. Technologies: Association (AHA) Heart36026 This online wellness center from the AHA helps people track and manage risk factors for heart attack, heart disease and stroke. People can receive information from HealthVault-enabled devices and applications, and share that data with the caregiver. According to research by Kaiser Permanente, patients who used home monitoring and web-based reporting tools were 50 percent more likely to have their blood Microsoft HealthVault pressure in control than those who were monitored in the doctor’s office. Technologies: Chronic Condition Management - American Cancer Society Circle of Sharing allows people to share personalized cancer information with loved ones and caretakers, and access a vast array of personalized cancer resources. Connected to the health ecosystem, it enables data sharing between other applications on the platform. Technologies: Microsoft HealthVault Microsoft HealthVault Home-based digital BP monitor Caregiver/Patient Collaboration - Mason General Hospital & Family of Clinics (MGH&FC)27 MGH&FC wanted to give patients easier access to their visit summaries and medical histories and to engage patients, families, and referring physicians in more-coordinated ongoing care. MGH&FC built a web portal through which patients can view their Personal & Family Health Management: New York information and, soon, share it with other caregivers. Presbyterian Hospital The result was improved patient experience and 25 MyNYP.org wanted to reduce delays in getting patient health information to the appropriate healthcare provider, in order to avoid redundant tests and coordination of care, increased organizational efficiency and support of future enhancements. Technologies: procedures. NYP was able to consolidate their clinical data and make it accessible to both providers and patients. Technologies: Microsoft Amalga Microsoft HealthVault Microsoft SharePoint Server Microsoft Amalga Microsoft HealthVault Home Health Monitoring May Significantly Improve Blood Pressure Control, Kaiser Permanente Study Finds http://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/home-healthmonitoring-may-significantly-improve-blood-pressure-controlkaiser-permanente-study-finds-94576164.html 27 Microsoft Case Study Portal (June 2011) Mason General Hospital 26 24 Microsoft Case Study Portal (January 2010): Cleveland Clinic Prestigious online wellness resource launches with help of Commerce Server 2009. Retrieved October 2011. 25 Microsoft Case Study Portal (March 2011): New York-Presbyterian Hospital Pioneers New Personal Health Record—myNYP.org. Retrieved August 2011 & Family of Clinics Hospital Offers Advanced Online Patient Services Through Healthcare Portal. Retrieved August 2011 21 | P a g e January 2012 Harnessing the Power of Technology to Improve Chronic Care Management Business Intelligence - First Choice Home Health The National Institute for Health and Clinical and Hospice Excellence (NICE) provides clinical guidance and helps 28 First Choice, facing the same challenges as healthcare providers throughout the United States, needed to increase efficiency to offset rising costs and reduced Medicare reimbursements. The company gave its clinical workers Windows Phones running Allscripts establish healthcare quality standards in the United Kingdom. To help professionals to easily access up-todate information, NICE launched an Internet portal. There is now a single access point to more than 250 core information sources. software to file the patient reports used to generate invoices resulting in savings of U.S.$500,000 annually in rent, labor, travel and a 4% reduction in hospitalization rates. Technologies: Windows Phone Bing Maps Coordinated Care - Dallas Neurosurgical & Spine (DNS)29 Microsoft SharePoint Server Microsoft FAST Search Server Microsoft ASP.NET Canada Caregiver Collaboration - Cancer Care Ontario (CCO)31 CCO deployed a Microsoft Unified Communications solution, which enabled it to provide robust Dallas Neurosurgical & Spine (DNS) needed a conferencing, scalable VoIP telephony, and integrated telemedicine solution that would enable remote messaging and desktop-sharing capabilities. patients to conduct follow-up visits at their local Technologies: physician’s office. US Medical IT, DNS’s project management and IT service provider implemented a telemedicine solution that enables DNS to use audio conferencing, videoconferencing, and desktop sharing capabilities. The benefits to DNS include: ability to provide more immediate care, reduction in patient costs, while providing cutting-edge technology without the need for technology expertise. Technologies: Microsoft Office 365 Microsoft LYNC Online United Kingdom Decision Support - National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE)30 Microsoft Office Communications Server Microsoft Office Outlook Microsoft Exchange Server Enterprise Edition Switzerland Care Coordination – Public hospital consortium freiburger spital32 To control rising healthcare costs, standardize infrastructure, and streamline IT operations, the freiburger spital, a consortium of the six public hospitals in the territorial subdivision of Fribourg, Switzerland, deployed a systems integration solution 30 Microsoft Case Study Portal (January 2011) National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence Health Agency Simplifies Information Access for Health Professionals with Web Portal Microsoft Case Study Portal (July 2011) First Choice Home Health and Hospice of Utah Home Health Provider Saves $500,000 Annually, Doubles Cash Flow, with Mobile Solution. Retrieved August 2011 29 Microsoft Case Study Portal (June 2011) US Medical IT, Medical IT Company Helps Physicians Provide Immediate Care through Online Solution. Retrieved August 2011 28 Microsoft Case Study Portal (July 2010) Cancer Care Ontario Government Healthcare Agency Implements Unified Communications Solution to Reduce Costs. Retrieved August 2011 32 Microsoft Case Study Portal (June 2010) freiburger spital Hospital Network Reduces Costs and Improves Care by Consolidating Disparate IT Systems. Retrieved August 2011 31 22 | P a g e January 2012 Harnessing the Power of Technology to Improve Chronic Care Management based on Microsoft BizTalk Server 2009. Now the poor data quality, while also combating patient hospital network has access to consolidated, absenteeism. Because DjHS must provide accurate synchronized, and automated systems, enabling better information to government about patient volumes, patient care and reduced support costs. Technologies the health service was being underfunded according used: to the levels of care it was providing. Implementation Microsoft BizTalk Server Microsoft SQL Server Windows Server Microsoft BizTalk Accelerator for HL7 of Microsoft technologies led to a 20% increase in funding, early warning of data entry issues, less patient absenteeism, better resource management, and better visibility into activities. Technologies used: Israel Decision Support - Maccabi Health Care Services33 Maccabi Healthcare Services is a leading healthcare provider in Israel. The company provides lifelong medical and dental services to members. [They] created a plan to help improve the level of service to their members. In order to garner a 360-degree view of member data, information from multiple systems would be integrated into a single service application. Technologies: Microsoft SharePoint Server Microsoft SharePoint Designer Care Coordination – Improvement Foundation Australia35 Through the Australian Primary Care Collaborative Program, Improvement Foundation Australia and OBS use Microsoft SharePoint to produce a portal platform that connect over 1000 General Practices to their patients to assist in the management of chronic care. Technologies used: Microsoft Office Microsoft SharePoint Administration Toolkit Microsoft Office SharePoint Server Technologies Microsoft Dynamics CRM Microsoft Office SharePoint Portal Server Microsoft Windows XP Service Pack Microsoft Exchange Server Microsoft Office Standard Business Intelligence & Research – Ludwig Microsoft SQL Server Institute36 Microsoft Windows Server Australia Business Intelligence - Djerriwarrh Health Services (DjHS)34 The branch needs to analyze patient protein samples very rapidly. However, genetic analysis demands vast quantities of computing power, and the Institute’s budget limits expensive IT purchases. Technologies used: DjHS was struggling with a patient management system consisting of inaccurate patient records and Windows HPC Server Windows Server 33 Microsoft Case Study Portal (July 2009.) Maccabi Healthcare Services, Healthcare Provider Improves Customer Service with RealTime Patient Data Visibility. Retrieved August 2011 Microsoft Case Study Portal (February 2011) Djerriwarrh Health Services Reporting and analysis technology improves resource management, reduces patient absenteeism and secures additional funding. Retrieved August 2011 34 35 Microsoft Case Study Portal (June 2010) Improvement Foundation Australia How Sharepoint helped IFA connect with healthcare professionals. Retrieved August 2011 36 Microsoft Case Study Portal (January 2011) Ludwig Institute of Cancer Research Windows Supercomputer Speeds Quest to Identify Cancer Proteins. Retrieved August 2011 23 | P a g e January 2012 Harnessing the Power of Technology to Improve Chronic Care Management Microsoft High Performance File System Windows Server 2008 Technologies Microsoft Windows Server Data Objects (c) 2012 Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved. This document is provided "as-is." Information and views expressed in this document, including URL and other Internet Web site references, may change without notice. You bear the risk of using it. Some examples are for illustration only and are fictitious. No real association is intended or inferred. 24 | P a g e January 2012