Foster—ENC 1102—Spring 2016 1
Peer Editor: _____________________________________________
Writer’s Name: ___________________________________________
Annotated Bibliography Peer Review Rubric
EXPERT
4 pts
Does the
annotated
bibliography
explain the
significance and
purpose of the
bibliography?
Does the
annotated
bibliography
explain and justify
the types of
sources included?
Does each
annotation include
rhetorical
information about
its source?
PROFICIENT
3 pts
APPRENTICE
2 pts
NOVICE
1pt
Foster—ENC 1102—Spring 2016 2
Does it summarize
the source’s
content?
Has the writer
evaluated the
source for its
relevance and
usefulness to your
research?
Are the
annotations clearly
and concisely
written? Have you
avoided confusing
wordiness while
still adopting an
appropriately
formal tone for an
annotated
bibliography?
Are the sources
cited according to
MLA
conventions? Are
the sources in
alphabetical
order?
Foster—ENC 1102—Spring 2016 3
Missing section will be assigned “0” points.
EXAMPLE
EXPERT
4 pts
PROFICIENT
3 pts
APPRENTICE
2 pts
NOVICE
1pt
Total
3
2
1
0
Missing
0 pts
0
NOVICE
1pt
Missing
0 pts
EXPERT
4 pts
PROFICIENT
3 pts
Total
Overall additional comments: (Optional)
APPRENTICE
2 pts