Foreword To my Colleagues/ Students There are a number of very strong arguments in favour of using newspapers and other media material in the language classroom: general education value cultural information language change reading interest & strategies authentic material subject-specific material language difficulty in the media language, etc. This booklet is not intended to be studied from cover to cover, but for you to dip into as and when you need to. It is divided into several parts: Contents Foreword British and American Newspapers and Magazines The Whole Newspaper Newspaper Reading Habits Questionnaire Analysing Newspapers Broadsheets vs Tabloids The British Press Battle Newspapers Headlines and Language Unlocking headlines Ambiguity in headlines Just for fun (newspaper misprints) Class Presentation 1 Reporting the Article Vocabulary & collocations Translation assignments Class Presentation 2 Newspaper Sections/Columns News Flash News in Brief Potted Biographies Photographs& Caricatures & Strip Cartoons 3 3 5 5 5 11 12 15 15 16 17 17 18 20 22 22 22 24 Class presentation 3 Advertisements Weather Forecasts Weather – Newspaper Stories Contemporary Media and the Change The Nature of News Will Newspapers Survive? ‘_We Media: Introduction to Participatory Journalism’ Further Discussion: Everyday Ethical Dilemmas Facing Journalism Appendix 1 Appendix 2 Appendix 3 Resources and Further Reading 26 27 30 33 35 36 37 45 47 51 53 55 Each part deals with one particular feature of newspapers, the whole newspaper or the other media, such as the Internet. In practice, this means that you’ll find it easy to refer to the relevant part. In addition, the booklet contains appendixes on newspaper language and style, abbreviations used in the media, web-links to several online sites of world popular quality and tabloid newspapers and magazines and the list of printed and Internet resources used to compile this booklet, make up activities or used for illustration. All the material which was originally written and first published on the Internet is a free download and available at the sites listed. 4 British and American Newspapers & Magazines The Whole newspaper Newspaper reading habits questionnaire This questionnaire is designed to find out about your newspaper reading habits. Read the questions carefully and answer them as fully as you can. 1 Write the names of 3 national newspapers in your country. What reputation and/or political bias do they have? (a) (b) (c) 2 What is the local newspaper in your area? 3 Which English-language newspapers do you know? What do you know about these newspapers? 4 Is there a particular newspaper you like to read? Why? 5 Do members of your family read the same newspaper as you? 6 How often do you read a newspaper? 7 Do you pay for the newspaper? 8 Is there a particular time of day when you read a newspaper? 9 Is there a particular place where you read a newspaper? 10 . How long do you spend reading a newspaper? 11 Are there any sections of the newspaper you never read? 12 Do you always read a newspaper in the same order? 13 Which section of the newspaper do you read first? 14 Which sections do you read next? 15 Do you ever talk to people about things you read in the newspaper? 16 Do you think it is important for people to read newspapers? Why? 17 Do you believe everything you read in the newspaper? 18 Do you think a newspaper is good value for money? 19 What do you do with a newspaper once you have read it? 20 How do you think reading English-language newspapers can help your language learning? Text 1. Read the text and answer the questions. 1. What types of press are there in Great Britain/USA? 5 2. What are the differences between broadsheets and tabloids? Are there many? What is the modern tendency in development of the press? 3. What is a newspaper layout puffs/ blurbs a front page a slogan a masthead a lead story a menu a by-line 4. Make sure you can explain words and phrases in bold/ their meaning in the context of the sentence(s) they are used in. ANALYSING NEWSPAPERS (abridged from the Internet resources) The first thing you notice when you look at a newspaper is the size! Traditionally, newspapers have been divided up into tabloids and broadsheets, broadsheets being the larger, more serious papers that you have to fold to read. The gap between tabloids and broadsheets is a wide one. They look different, they contain different news, they have a different style of writing and they aim to attract different readers. Here are a few of the main differences: Tabloids eg Standard Broadsheets eg The Guardian 'Popular' press Aimed at lower social groupings Bold layout (eg colour on the masthead, very bold typeface, easy to read), with large, dramatic pictures Shorter articles, more pictures, less 'in-depth' reporting Puns and jokes in headlines More focus on human interest stories, celebrity gossip Use of gimmicks such as bingo games, free travel tickets, phone-in surveys 'Quality' or 'serious' press Aimed at higher social groupings Plainer layout (no or little colour on the front page, smaller typeface suggests readers will make more effort to read it), and subtle, possibly smaller, pictures Longer articles, more detailed Serious headlines More focus on politics, international news 6 The Front Page Newspaper front pages fulfil several different functions. They must: attract readers reinforce the newspaper's identity through easily recognisable style features demonstrate clearly what the newspaper's attitude is towards the news of the day show that this particular edition of the newspaper contains certain stories - hopefully including better coverage of main stories than any other newspaper Broadsheet newspapers tend to print across six columns. Although each has their own individual style, you will find the following elements on the front page of all newspapers; these are the conventions of a front page. Masthead - the newspaper's name, often in traditional gothic lettering. It may not have changed for many years and is the easiest way to identify a newspaper "All the News That's Fit To Print" Slogan - a 'catchphrase' for the newspaper The NY Times 'Puffs' or 'blurbs' - colour bands which aim to attract readers to stories inside the newspaper or 'coming soon' Headlines - the largest typeface on the page for the most important stories Sub-heads - in smaller typeface, sometimes italicised, that explain more about the story 7 A Hong Kong School was today rocked to its foundations by a number of minor explosions. Eye-witnesses said there were... By-line - journalist's name & details Spending too long on the internet may ruin your eyes, medical researchers warned today. New evidence suggests that there is a definite link... Lead story - one that has been chosen as being of most interest to the most readers Clark Kent, Education Correspondent Secondary Lead - still an important story, but less than the lead Photographs!!! Sometimes colour, sometimes black and white. They may refer to the lead story, or be there to make a reader "turn to page 6..." Don't forget the all-important captions which accompany photographs. Menu - A 'table of contents' showing what is in each section and where to go to find articles inside Small ad - containing no images Display ad - includes a picture 8 In some countries, especially the UK and USA, broadsheet newspapers are commonly perceived to be more intellectual in content than their tabloid counterparts, using their greater size to examine stories in more depth, while carrying less sensationalist and celebrity material. This distinction is most obvious on the front page: whereas tabloids tend to have a single story dominated by a headline, broadsheets allow two or more stories to be displayed, the most important at the top of the page - "above the fold." However, the competition for readers is intense, and tabloids and broadsheets may steal tricks off each other in order to win the circulation war, for example, many broadsheet newspapers in Britain run 'Fantasy Football Leagues' which originated as a tabloid tactic. Thus, the distinction regarding specific content is at best a generalization, and the term "tabloid" technically refers only to the paper's size. Some tabloid-format papers (such as the Daily Mail and Daily Express in the UK) use phrases such as "broadsheet quality in a tabloid format" in an attempt to distinguish themselves from their "tabloid" reputation. In addition, broadsheets often publish supplements, such as sports reviews and less news-oriented content (e.g. the Guardian's "G2" (formerly) or the Times's "Times 2"), in tabloid format. A Little History: pretty & authentic? In medieval and renaissance Britain, news was passed around chiefly through the use of ballads or narrative songs performed by Bards. With the invention of the printing press in the 15th century, these ballads were written down onto small pieces of paper and sold at markets or in large towns and called broadsides. These Broadsides became not only a way for the common man to get his entertainment, but also as a description of current affairs, for ballads were often written on the subject of current events. Through the centuries, the Broadsides were made larger and more detail was included. Better transport systems allowed for The word "tabloid" comes from the name given by a pharmaceutical company to a painkiller sold in compressed tablet. The connotation of tabloid was soon applied to other small items and to the "compressed" journalism that condensed stories into a simplified, easily-absorbed format. The label of "tabloid journalism" (1901) preceded the smaller sheet newspapers that contained it (1918). An early pioneer of tabloid journalism was Alfred Harmsworth (1865–1922), who amassed a large publishing empire of halfpenny papers by rescuing failing stolid papers and transforming them to reflect the 9 these broadsides to reach a much wider audience in a short time, and proved an effective way for current affairs to be distributed. Eventually they were edited to contain multiple pages, a more formal and informative use of language, and were compiled by large groups of journalists. Broadsheet newspapers had been invented. popular taste, which yielded him enormous profits. Harmsworth used his tabloids to influence public opinion, for example, by bringing down the wartime government of Prime Minister Herbert Henry Asquith in the Shell Crisis of 1915. The more recent usage of the term 'tabloid' refers to weekly or semi-weekly newspapers in tabloid format. Many of these are essentially straightforward newspapers, publishing in tabloid format, because subway and bus commuters prefer to read smaller-size newspapers due to lack of space. These newspapers are distinguished from the major daily newspapers, in that they purport to offer an "alternative" viewpoint, either in the sense that the paper's editors are more locally-oriented, or that the paper is editorially independent from major media conglomerates. Other factors that distinguish "alternative" weekly tabloids from the major daily newspapers are their less-frequent publication, and that they are usually free to the user, since they rely on ad revenue. As well, alternative weekly tabloids tend to concentrate on local- or even neighbourhood-level issues, and on local entertainment in the bars and local theatres. Alternative tabloids can be positioned as upmarket (quality) newspapers, to appeal to the better-educated, higher-income sector of the market; as middle-market (popular); or as downmarket (sensational) newspapers, which emphasize sensational crime stories and celebrity gossip. In each case, the newspapers will draw their advertising revenue from different types of businesses or services. An upmarket weekly's advertisers are often organicgrocers, boutiques, and theatre-companies while a downmarket's may have those of trade-schools, super-markets, and adult-services, both usually contain ads from local bars, auto-dealers, movie theaters, and a classified-ads section The term "tabloid" can also refer to a newspaper that tends to emphasize topics such as sensational crime stories, astrology, gossip columns about the personal lives of celebrities and sports stars, and junk food news. Often, tabloid newspaper allegations about the sexual practices, drug use, or private conduct of celebrities is borderline defamatory; in many cases, celebrities have successfully shown that tabloid stories have defamed them, 10 and sued for libel. It is this sense of the word that led to some entertainment news programs to be called tabloid television. Tabloid newspapers are sometimes pejoratively called the gutter press. Supermarket tabloids are large, national versions of these tabloids, usually published weekly. They are named for their prominent placement along the checkout lines of supermarkets. Supermarket tabloids are particularly notorious for the over-the-top sensationalizing of stories, the facts of which can often be called into question. These tabloids - such as The Globe and The National Enquirer - often use aggressive and usually mean spirited tactics to sell their issues. Unlike regular tabloid-format newspapers, supermarket tabloids are distributed through the magazine distribution channel, similarly to other weekly magazines and mass-market paperback books. Leading examples include The National Enquirer, Star, Weekly World News (now defunct), and Sun. The oldest supermarket tabloid known to date was the American "Daily News" in 1919; if it didn't have news to publish, it would simply make up a story, have the newspaper staff stage a photograph, then use an editing technique called the composograph to combine the fake image with a real one. Tabloid newspapers in Britain, collectively called the "tabloid press", tend to be simply and sensationally written, and to give more prominence than broadsheets to celebrities, sports, crime stories and even hoaxes; they also more readily take a political position (either left-wing or right-wing) on news stories, ridiculing politicians, demanding resignations and predicting election results. The term red top refers to tabloids with red nameplates, such as The Sun, the Daily Star, the Daily Mirror and the Daily Sport, and distinguishes them from the black top Daily Express and Daily Mail. Red top newspapers are usually simpler in writing style, dominated by pictures, and directed at the more sensational end of the market. Broadsheets vs Tabloids Put the following words & phrases under the headings. Broadsheets Tabloids the qualities, far exceeding in the sales, many photographs, personalities in the public eye, the heavies, attention-grabbing headlines, informative, objective, keeping news and opinion firmly apart, serious news, support by detail, informed analysis, sensational stories, involving prominent figures, pejorative, tabloidese/journalese, accurate &appropriate, exaggerated & distorted 11 Reading & Discussion Text 2. Read the article and 1) say what the ‘British press battle’ is and what tactics the newspapers employ to win the battle. 2) make sure you can explain words and phrases in bold/ their meaning in the context of the sentence(s) they are used in. Edition 6 - December 2008 Tabloids vs Broadsheets: the British Press Battle Continues There must be a synapse-or-several inside the mind of anybody who has been attacked in the British press that flickers into life and leaps with delight in the first week of every month. I say this only because the audited sale of the UK tabloid newspapers - by which I mean the combined circulation of the popular tabloids such as the Sun and mid-market papers such The broadsheets - still lagging as the Daily Mail - has now been declining for a behind in terms of sales protracted period, according to the official Audited Bureau of Circulation (ABC) numbers. And each month, sometime in the first week or so, the ABC figures are published and discussed in the media: there for all to see. Here is not the place for a detailed analysis. Safe to say that if you add the sale of the Daily Mail (which is not declining itself), the Daily Express, the Sun, the Mirror and the Daily Star the overall figure hasn’t gone up for a very long time indeed. Until last year I used to edit the biggest of these - the Sun - so I have lived and fought this battle from the other side and occasionally dreaded the upcoming ABCs and what my boss, Rupert Murdoch, might conclude from them. In my experience the pressure from him was as high when they were up as when they were down - because when they were up he wanted them to be up again next month. Nothing breeds the appetite for success like success. But despite the temporary and occasional upward swings the downward decline has been undeniable for some time. For those reading this outside the UK it should be explained that Britain is a unique newspaper market - there are 11 daily papers and nearly as many on a Sunday. Politicians and business leaders in this country constantly grill me on 12 what the tabloid sales trends mean. Some, ever hopeful, think the sales decline means they should push fewer resources into those parts of their communications strategy aimed at this end of the market. It is far too early to do that. The market share of the Sun, for example, remains more than 25 per cent in the UK market, which means that one in four of all papers bought here - including the broadsheets - are copies of the Sun. If you add up the market share of all the tabloids it comes close to 75 per cent. Such incredible success has been hard fought and will not be given up easily. If you look at the business leaders involved you can be guaranteed that they will fight for every copy. Murdoch controls both the market leaders in the daily market and the Sunday market - the Sun and the News of the World. He also owns the Times and the Sunday Times. Associated Newspapers, controlled by Lord Rothermere, owns the Daily Mail, the Mail on Sunday, the Evening Standard in London and the fast growing free paper, Metro. The other player in the market is Richard Desmond, whose Express Newspapers owns the Daily Express, the Daily Star and the Sunday Express. Murdoch is the most powerful newspaper magnate anywhere in the world since William Randolph Hearst, Rothermere has inherited a British powerhouse and Desmond is not to be dismissed. His business is cash generative and he is an ambitious man. All these factors, plus the great talent and vibrancy within these newspapers, combine to make it unlikely that this trend will lead to a crash anytime soon - no matter what their detractors may hope for. At the other end of the UK market the recent decision by Robert Thomson, the editor of the Times, to turn the paper into a tabloid (or ‘compact’, as it is termed) will lead to an increase in sales. This has already happened for his rival editor at the compact Independent, Simon Kelner. Having said that, anybody who thinks this repositioning is going to lead to a significant narrowing of the sales gap between the ‘heavies’ and the ‘tabloids’ is in for a shock. The current sale of the Times is 620,870 and that of the Independent is 228,174. Contrast that with still healthy Sun sales of 3,336,322 and the Daily Mail’s 2,346,229 - or even the Mirror’s 1,793,718 - and you can see that the realities of the UK market are that the more serious papers lag behind. This contrasts markedly with the United States, where the biggest selling dailies nationally are the Wall Street Journal and the New York Times. The issue here is twofold, though, because those who want tabloid material tend to go to TV and those two papers are among the few who print nationally. Most other papers, including tabloids such as the New York Post - where I was deputy editor in the 1990s - and the New York Daily News are single-city papers. 13 Newspaper sales are falling all over the world in nearly every market. There are some good performers but generally, just as with network TV, customers lead such busy lives these days that either they are buying fewer newspapers or no newspapers at all. Despite all that, the message to anybody hoping for an early decline in the British red tops is very simple: the decline will not reduce their power for many, many years. By David Yelland, senior vice chairman, Weber Shandwick, UK & Ireland. © 2008 Weber Shandwick Retrieved from http://www.webershandwick.co.uk/outcomes/issue6/story1.html Newspaper Headlines & Language (refer to Appendix 1) Read the following articles and find as many examples of typical features of broadsheet and tabloid style. Consider the following: length of the article, visual presentation, information included or excluded/ distorted, the order of information, language and style. Text A Woman wins sex bias case young woman's hopes of a career with an estate agents crumbled because they believed highly paid clients would only deal with men, an industrial tribunal in Manchester was told yesterday. Beverley Jackson, aged 19, of Heaton Norris, Stockport, applied for an advertised vacancy as assistant to Mr Nicholas Rowcliffe, a partner of J. R. Bridgford and Sons, at the branch in the village of Prestbury, Cheshire. Mr Rowcliffe replied: 'I thank you for your letter but I feel the position more suits a male applicant but I will keep your name on file, and thank you for replying.' Miss Jackson, who has eight О levels, three A levels and has started a business studies course, told the tribunal the letter made her feel like a second class citizen. Mr Rowcliffe said Prestbury had a strong concentration of men from the 'higher echelons of business and professional life' such as managing directors, airline pilots and barristers, who would not deal with women. The job involved dealing with house sales of up to £300,000. 'It would be impractical from both the 14 firm and clients' point of view to employ a woman assistant. 'It stems from the type of village and the type of people who live there. Many of them insist on talking to men on certain matters like finance and will not take advice from women. This is nothing to do with me; it is the clients.' Miss Jackson's solicitor, Mr Jack Thornley, told the tribunal: 'I am not sure whether this is an insult to the people of Prestbury or whether Mr Rowcliffe is living in the Dark Ages.' Miss Jackson said later: 'It was a matter of principle.' Text B BEV HITS ROOF AT NO-GIRLS JOB BAN BEVERLEY JACKSON had all the qualifications for a career with a top people's estate agents - except one. She wasn't a man. The pretty 19-year-old's hopes crumbled when she was told only men could sell homes to stockbroker belt buyers. But yesterday Beverley struck a blow for women's lib when an industrial tribunal awarded her £600 damages and costs against the estate agents. Mr. Rowcliffe, who runs Bridgford's office in Prestbury, Cheshire, where the average price of a house is £70,000, told the tribunal that executives and managing directors who live there would not deal with a woman. 'Prestbury is a unique village,' he said. 'I find my clients insist on taking advice from a man. 'They are living in quality houses and expect quality treatment. They are from the higher 'echelons and they just won't deal with women.' Mr. Jack Thornley, for Beverley, asked the tribunal: 'Is there something in the water in Prestbury that makes people difficult and demanding? Applied The Manchester tribunal heard that Beverley, of Green Lane, Heaton Norris, Stockport, left school a year ago with eight О levels and three A levels. She applied to the estate agents, J. H. Bridgford, for a job as a junior assistant. A partner in the firm, Mr. Nicholas Rowcliffe, told her in a two-line letter: 'Sorry, we want a man,' 'It seems a place of male chauvinists, and female chauvinists as well.' 'I was livid,' said Beverley, who took her case to the Equal Opportunities Commission. Unlocking headlines Read and unlock the following headlines. Speak about the story behind the headline. a. MANCHESTER MAN WINS FORTUNE b. EARTHQUAKE HORROR c. Prime Minister to see US President d. Garage blast kills driver e. BT to slash calls cost f. Alex: Rooney will be Utd legend Ambiguity in headlines Read the following headline and say in what way they are ambiguous (have double meaning). Suggest ways the headlines could be rewritten to make their intended meaning clear. a. Kids make nutritious snacks 15 b. Squad helps dog bite victim c. Miners refuse to work after death d. Eye drops off shelf e. Teacher strikes idle kids f. US President wins on budget, but more lies ahead g. Shot off woman's leg helps golfer to 66 h. Juvenile court to try shooting defendant i. Stolen painting found by tree j. Drunken drivers paid $1000 k. Red tape holds up new bridge l. Chef throws his heart into helping feed needy m. Arson suspect is held in Massachusetts fire n. Local high school dropouts cut in half o. Include your children when baking cookies Just for fun… (newspaper misprints) In each of the following extracts from a newspaper there is a misprint (usually a word) which completely changes the meaning of the sentence. Write down the word which is wrong and also write down which word should have been used instead. 1. 2. 3. He is now being kept alive by an artificial respirator and huge doses of rugs. The route taken by the King and Queen was lined by clapping, cheering crows. Barry Janes was seriously burnt last weekend when he came in contact with a high voltage wife. 4. Congratulations and best wishes to my daring fiancée on her 21st birthday. 5. He was taken to hospital with heard injuries. 6. Young lady required for publishing company. Previous experience not essential bust must be able to type. 7. 1969 Volvo. One owner. God. Low mileage. 8. A neighbour also claims to have seen the ghost and it upset him so much that he has not eaten property for several days. 9. The bank robbers tried to escape but were cornered by a polite dog. 11. A thief went into the changing room at Hastings United football club. Honey was taken from the pockets of five players. 12. The final practice for the children’s concert will be hell on Saturday afternoon between 2.00 and 2.30. 16 Class Presentations Take a periodical and speak about it (whether it’s a quality item or a tabloid, its layout, style and language, manner of reporting the events, photos and illustrations, readership, etc.) Reporting the ARTICLE ARTICLE V: edit, print, publish, review, skim, submit, summarise, work on, write ~ V: ~ deals with sth, discusses sth A: brilliant, controversial, dull, inspiring, interesting, libellous, scathing, scholarly, seminal, sensible ~ P: string of articles NEWS V: announce, break, bring, broadcast, catch up with, censor, collect, confirm, cover, gather, get, give, give out, leak, learn, pass on, receive, send, spread, suppress, tell, withhold ~ V: ~ alarmed sb, arrived, broke, is corning in/through, flooded in, leaked out, reached sb, slipped out, spread, trickled through, was delayed A: advance, alarming, contradictory, dramatic, encouraging, first-hand, fresh, glad, gloomy, grave, great, happy, heartening, important, joyful, latest, long-awaited, ominous, recent, sad, sensational, shattering, shocking, stale, startling, surprising, thrilling, tragic, unbelievable, unexpected, unsettling, up-to-the-minute, welcome ~ P: ~ flash; bit of, dissemination of, flow of, piece of, scraps of, snippets of – NEWSPAPER V: edit, print, publish, work for ~ V: ~ came out A: daily, evening, in-house, local, morning, quality, tabloid, underground, weekly REPORT (n) V: ~ advocates sth, appeared, calls for sth, claims sth, came out, condemns sth, covers sth, criticises sth, deals with sth, describes sth, discloses sth, draws attention to sth, endorses sth, exposes sth, highlights sth, hints ..., identifies ..., implies sth, indicates sth, makes clear that ..., notes sth, pinpoints sth, points out that..., raises questions, reaches the conclusion 17 that, recommends sth, reveals sth, shows sth, states sth, stresses sth. suggests sth, tackles sth ~ A: accurate, adverse, alarmist, annual/monthly etc, authoritative, baffling, balanced, (un)biasiul, bleak, candid, cautious, clear, complacent, confidential, critical, damaging, damning, definite, detailed, disappointing, disquieting, disturbing, draft, encouraging, exhaustive, eye-witness, factual, fair, (un)favourable, first-hand, forthcoming, garbled, gripping, illuminating, instructive, interim, intriguing, libellous, long-awaited, majority. minority, monumental, negative, objective, (un)official, optimistic, police, positive, preliminary, recent, reliable, revealing, scathing, tendentious, true, unambiguous, unanimous, unconfirmed, verbatim ~ REPORT (v) to report accurately, freely, briefly, extensively, faithfully, in depth/ detail, regularly, reliably, verbatim, word for word Other Collocations ▫ ▫ ▫ ▫ ▫ ▫ ▫ ▫ ▫ ▫ ▫ ▫ ▫ ▫ ▫ ▫ to premier/ debate/ examine/ explore/ discuss the topic to pit sth against sth to continue coverage to discuss the major talking points to deliver headlines/ in-depth reports keep the spotlight on to provide the news/ expert analysis… to stay informed/ up to date/ involved, spirited writing and evocative photography thought-provoking to bring a unique perspective an eclectic range of topics, to give a real insight into to bring food for the brain and a feast for the eyes a host of/ a hive of( extras/ activities) to be exactly what it says on the tin Translate the following into English Part 1 1. В статье обсуждаются…(главные темы дня/ публичные люди/ 2. В статье представлены детальный анализ проблемы и мнение экспертов/ 3. Статья открывает/ продолжает серию публикаций, посвященных… 18 4. Статья подчеркивает отношение автора/ выделяет одну точку зрения/ четко выражает отношение читателя к/ привлекает внимание к/ принимает точку зрения другой стороны/ поднимает вопросы сотрудничества/ раскрывает секреты…/ игнорирует мнение экспертов/ 5. Событие, попавшее в заголовки/ ряд событий, показывающих тенденцию к…/ 6. Автор сравнивает две точки зрения, противоположные друг другу 7. Информирует и вовлекает читателя в обсуждение целого ряда проблем 8. Статьи в этом журнале – пища для ума, а фотографии – настоящее наслаждение для глаз. 9. Для этого журналиста/ издания характерны экспрессивный стиль и фотографии/ четкое разделение фактов и личного мнения 10. Желтая пресса печально известна кричащими заголовками, интересом к скандалам и сенсациям, искажением информации, излишней эмоциональностью 11. противоречивая/ клеветническая/ академическая/ авторитарная/ шокирующая/ сеющая панику/ объективная статья/ публикация 12. последние/ долго ожидаемые/ радостные/ невероятные/вчерашние новости (известия) Part 2 Translate the following into English (for some sentences is advisable to use a reference file on Bill Mascull’s ‘Key Words in the Media’) 1. Бывший директор компании обвиняется в присвоении 2 миллионов долларов, принадлежащих компании. 2. В жизни, Давид Блум, корреспондент Эн-Би-Си, был энергичным, ярким журналистом, ведущим по выходным программу «Сегодня», несомненно обладающим харизмой и чувством экрана/студии. 3. Большую часть Пулитцеровских премий этого года получили журналисты, освещавшие политические и экономические события на Ближнем Востоке. 4. Освещение президентской избирательной компании на радио и ТВ составляет значительную долю новостных репортажей. 5. Совладельцами этой газеты, ежедневного делового вестника, являются «Файнаншиал таймс» и «Уолл-стрит Джорнал». 6. В новостных СМИ появились сообщения о пищевых отравления в детских учреждениях Китая. 19 7. Эта газета за последние годы стала сильно походить на бульварную. Теперь для нее характерны кричащие заголовки, сенсационные и скандальные репортажи о публичных людях, излишне эмоциональный стиль и провокационные фотографии. 8. Статьи в серьезной прессе отличаются глубоким анализом проблем, четким разделением фактов и личного мнения, точностью предоставленной информации и высококлассной фотографией. 9. Наблюдатели ООН оказывают давление на Иран, чтобы он подписал новый протокол, позволяющий МАГАТЭ проводить более масштабные инспекции. 10. Чтобы сделать сенсационные снимки, папарацци устраивают засады вокруг отелей и особняков знаменитостей, производят разведку на пляжах и в клубах, прячутся за живыми изгородями и насаждениями, подслушивают телефонные разговоры. 11. Многие знаменитости обращаются в суд с иском против бульварных СМИ по обвинению во вторжении в частную жизнь и клевете. Очень часто они требуют многомиллионные компенсации за нанесенный ущерб. 12.Некоторые знаменитости в целях саморекламы намеренно привлекают к себе внимание СМИ своим вызывающим поведением. 13. Передовицы газет обычно посвящают наиболее важным событиям. 14.Многие серьезные издания перенимаю тактику таблоидов, чтобы повысить тираж, а некоторые и вовсе сменили имидж и аудиторию, чтобы выжить в схватке за целевую аудиторию. 15. Сегодня практически все печатные издания имеют параллельные веб ресурсы, которые предлагают читателю/пользователю не только информацию о главных событиях дня или недели, но и целый набор интерактивных программ и даже доступ к подборкам и архивам издания за последние десятилетия. Class presentation 2 Reporting the article (there is no particular order or plan according to which you have to report the article but the following points MUST be observed) 1. The source the article comes from (the name of the site, publication, etc., date of publication/placement, the author/contributor, etc.). Why did you decide to report this article? 20 2. The main topic discussed. 3. Summary of the article (what, who, where, when, how, why?) 4. The style and language (length of the article, visual presentation, information included or excluded/ distorted/the other point of view presented, the order of information, language and style.) Did you check the information in other sources/was it necessary, etc. is the content and quality of the article suggestive of the target audience? 5. Your appreciation of the article Use the following words and phrases when reporting the article 1. The article under my consideration is devoted to… /covers/ deals with/ treats of/ touches upon… the problem of…; The headline /title/name/heading) of the article /passage under my consideration is… 2. The contributor /author of the article is … 3. The passage contains /includes/consists of/falls into)…2 (3) parts; 4. The article is addressed to /is written for wide public/ research (scientific) workers/ all who … 5. The subject matter of the article is devoted to (relates to) the problem of… 6. The article provides the reader with some statistics data on…/ material on…/information on/ details on…, a list of useful references/ an array of... 7. The author /the article discusses /deals with/ covers/ considers/ describes/ gives a description/ outlines, emphasizes, lays emphasis on/ the idea /problem of…/that… 8. The article begins /starts with a discussion of…/a description of…, introductory notes… 9. The article also says that… . It is also said in the article that… 10. A careful account is given to the problem /theory of…A detailed (thorough) description is given to… ; Much /little/ no attention is given to…The major focus of attention is given to … 11. Of particular /special/ great, little interest is the statistics/ theory/ statement … 12. Of great/little/ importance is the idea/fact … 13. The author also gives the highlights of/ a detailed analysis / questions… 14. The article /passage ends with the discussion /idea of…/how to deal with … 15. In conclusion /to sum up/ to finish with/ to conclude I would like to say that… 16. In conclusion /to sum it up, summarizing/ the author says that… 17. It is notable /noteworthy,/to the author's credit that … 21 18. The article suffers from some mistakes /lack of information on… 19. (In spite of some drawbacks) the article is interesting to read (is helpful to…, is useful to…, is a valuable source of information). News flash What, who, where, when, how, why? What happened? Who did it involve? Where did it happen? When did it happen? How did it happen? Why did it happen? Read the paragraph and answer the questions. Brief the paragraph to class. Schoolgirl tragedy A 14-year-old schoolgirl drowned in a swimming pool yesterday while she was on work experience at a holiday camp. Who? ________________________ What? ________________________ Where? _______________________ When? ________________________ Why? _________________________ News in brief This article in its present form is fairly long for publication or presentation on TV because normally newspapers lack space and TV - time. A. Reduce it to exactly 50 words for publication/presentation as a News in Brief Item. The rewritten version must be an accurate summary of the original article, containing all information which is of central importance. B. When you are ready find a partner and exchange your versions. Decide whether your partner’s version is true and accurate. What is a Potted bio: + = ? A practice commonly found in the media (most often tabloid) and a way ‘cramming the most information into the shortest space’. ‘a curious side product of the name-tag industry is the growing tendency, particularly in headlines, to identify a person in the news either by what makes them newsworthy, as in coma boy, death-fall teacher, sex-ban star, stab dad, kidnap Briton; or, more obscurely, by some event or object associated with their newsworthiness – holiday girl, bridge man, rugby boot boy.’ 22 ‘A particular difficulty caused by this convention is that it may not be until quite far into the article that the biographical information becomes clear to the reader, and even then, the link may be extremely tenuous, if any at all.’ Keith Waterhouse, Waterhouse on Newspaper Style, Penguin. A. Find examples of potted biographies in the following extracts, say how the potted bios could be expressed in other words, e.g. Little Buddha screenplay writer Bernardo Bertolucci… could be rewritten as Bernardo Bertolucci, who wrote the screenplay for the film Little Buddha…: LOS ANGELES (Reuters) – Actor Charlie Sheen, star of U.S. television's hit comedy "Two and a Half Men," has followed his wife and entered a rehabilitation facility as the couple try to put their lives back together after a violent Christmas Day argument. Sheen, 44, checked in for undisclosed reasons in what his publicist on Tuesday called "a preventative measure," causing his top-rated CBS TV show to temporarily suspend production. (yahoo.com) LOCATED in the posh Bel Air community of Los Angeles -- this party palace has had several high-profile owners, including Rat Packer Dean Martin, Welsh crooner Tom Jones, and most recently Nicolas Cage, an Oscar winner who has appeared in more than 60 movies, according to IMDB.com, including "Raising Arizona" and "Leaving Las Vegas." (yahoo.com) VANCOUVER — Entering Tuesday night's women's figure skating short program at Pacific Coliseum, impish U.S. skater Mirai Nagasu playfully said she hoped to benefit from the apparent burden of expectations on reigning world champion Kim Yu-Na of Korea. (VOA) Alex: Rooney will be Utd legend TWO-GOAL Man U hero Wayne Rooney sunk West Ham to earn praise from Alex Ferguson (the sun.com) Jeeves Spoken Here Scornful of audiobooks, Christopher Hitchens puts actor Martin Jarvis to the acid test: P. G. Wodehouse’s novels. (VF.com) Michael Foot, politician and man of letters, died on March 3rd, aged 96 (The Economist) 23 PROUST QUESTIONNAIRE Proust Questionnaire: Martin Scorsese The Oscar-winning director of Mean Streets, Raging Bull, and this month’s Shutter Island describes his funny walk, his inability to cook, and his issue with the word “wonderful.” (VF.com) Joel Surnow, the creator of 24, is making a History Channel miniseries called “The Kennedys” in which J.F.K. comes up with the idea for the Berlin Wall and … (VF.com) …So let me see if I have this straight. Joseph Stack, an engineer and anti-tax activist gets good and mad, burns… (theroot.com) The ‘JFK’ star, Kevin Costner, returns to Camelot for the Red-alert thriller ‘Thirteen days’. (Entertainment) Battle-wise Aboriginal leader Pasepa Close, 49, who for two decades has been fighting for land claims in the area, says…(New Idea, Australia) B. Create potted biographies for a) yourself, b) other students in class, c) the people in the public eye you know. Photographs – photo stories Every Picture Tells a Story Directions Before you come to class: Find an image which you think tells a story or is illustrative of the current event(s). Print it out or download it for further use in class. Make sure you can display it to other students appropriately. In class: You are the top editors of the famous newspaper. A. Work in small groups, exchange the images you’ve brought/displayed or distributed by the teacher, then choose the image you feel is the strongest and list five reasons why you chose it. (Criteria to consider might include the story the photo tells and how it tells that story; its historical, political, or cultural importance; its composition and aesthetic qualities; and its 24 emotional power.) Each group should then argue for the image they chose by stating their reasons. B. Each group must determine how your newspaper will cover this story by deciding where in the newspaper you will display this photo and how you will caption it. Further Questions for Discussion: Do you agree with the point of view that photographers are simply doing their job by capturing controversial images and presenting them for the public to judge? How do photographs effect you emotionally? What makes a news photograph transcend mere illustration and become a story in itself? Can you think of other famous images that have done this? How can photos be manipulated? How could either of the photos you’ve chosen be cropped or otherwise changed to portray something different? When do you think pictures can tell a story better than words? What techniques do photographers use to make their images memorable and interesting? What other images do you expect to see in upcoming days and weeks? Why? What photos have been important to you in your life, whether personal or widely published? Why? Wrap-up Homework & Extension Activities: 1. Research photojournalistic images to find one image or a series of related images you feel are especially important and memorable. Mount/download your image(s) and write an accompanying paragraph or short essay in which you discuss why you chose it. In a future class you may display these for other students to read about and discuss. 2. Analyze famous images from photojournalism to determine what makes a photograph go beyond mere illustration to become a cultural or historic icon. 3. Capture some controversial issue in your own community through photojournalism that tells the story. Try to take pictures that document an aspect of conflict or emotion in the controversy. In a future class you may display these for other students to see and discuss. 4. Compare different types of images of a famous person or event. Collect examples of photography, caricature, cartoon, drawing, sculpture, video or 25 any other form of imagery, then analyze how each form conveys different information and a different point of view. What a Caricature! Directions: Find an example of a political/ social caricature in the newspaper, on television, on the Internet or from another medium and analyze it below by answering each question. SOURCE and DATE: TYPE OF CARICATURE (e.g., a cartoon, parody, spoof, skit, etc.): CARICATURE ANALYSIS: What person or people is/are being caricatured here? What features, mannerisms or other characteristics did the caricaturist choose to exaggerate or distort? What general message about this or each political/ social figure do you think this caricature is supposed to convey, and why? Do you think this caricature effectively satirizes this or each political/ social figure? Why or why not? How, if at all, does this caricature reflect your own impression or opinion of this or each political/ social figure? Why? How, if at all, do you think this caricature (or ones like it) might influence public opinion about this or each political/ social figure? Why? Class Presentation 3: Character Caricature Directions: Follow the steps below to create a caricature of your character. 1. Who is your character? Make a list of details that describe this character's physical appearance, personality, talents, demeanor, attitude, behavior and other attributes: 26 2. Which of these attributes would you exaggerate to capture the "essence" of, and "send up" this character? Why? 3. On a separate sheet of paper, create a visual representation of your caricature. In addition to your exaggerations or distortions of this character's appearance, you should also caricaturize his or her non-visual traits by adding a clever caption or speech bubble. Advertisements Sample ads a. b. c. 27 e. f. g. 28 h. j. i. k. How Many: 10 Price: $300.00 Is Buyer/Seller a Breeder?: N Item Location: Brooklyn, NY Payment Terms: Visa, MasterCard, American Express Registries, Clubs? CFA Web Site: http://furrydream.visit.ws 29 A. Look at sample ads and say fairly quickly which one/ones 1. cannot be called classified as they are not published by individuals? 2. offer services? 3. will help you rent an apartment/ office/ buy property/ a pet/ a car? 4. will help you find a job? 5. is placed by an individual/ company that seeks job/employees? 6. is aimed at people that do not speak English? 7. announces a competition/ tender for professionals? 8. is historically valuable? B. Look at sample ads B, D, I and J. Use Appendix 3 to explain abbreviations used. C. Now imagine you are selling something. Fill in a classified ad coupon giving the details of your item: age, size, colour, make/brand, condition, guarantee, etc. and the price asked. CLASSIFIED COUPON ADVERT DETAILS: one word per box, price included Please fill in details below Your name ______________________ Address ________________________ _______________________________ Phone number _________________ ADVERTISE YOUR ITEMS UNDER £500 IN VALUE FREE use block capitals ONLY Weather forecasts Sample weather forecasts and maps a. 30 b. c. d. 31 e. f. 32 g. Look at sample weather forecasts and maps and say fairly quickly which one/ ones 1. 2. 3. 4. is not/are not about Britain? How do you know? warn(s) you that it’s not the best day for an outing? tell(s) that there is a spell of good weather awaiting? is intended as a joke? Weather - Newspaper Stories The weather in a newspaper can be a main headline or it can be the daily weather report. The weather section in a newspaper reports 33 what the weather will be like for the day or the week. The weather predictions aren't always right. They are just predictions, a really good guess based on weather satellite pictures, and what the weather has been like over the past few days. Not only does the weather page tell you what they predict for the next few days, but it also tells you what the temperature will be, the air quality, the county forecast, national weather systems, national high and low temperatures, global temperatures, and California temperatures. The weather reports also tell you county temperatures, about the tides, a diving report, a surfing report, a Marine report, and where there are polluted waters. Here is an example of a weather heading (Text A) and a weather forecast (Text B). The story Night of the Twisters is based on the bone chilling tornado disasters in 1980, when 12 tornadoes strike in Grand Island, Nebraska. Text A Grand Island Nebraska Daily News Tuesday, June 6, 1980 Issue 21 Night of the Twisters 12 Twisters Hit Grand Island, Nebraska Boy Saves 3 Lives, Separated from his family, Reunited By TQ22, Canyon View Press – On June 4th, 12 twisters hit Grand Island, Nebraska. Dan Hatcher, a 12 year old boy, tried to save his 2 year old brother Ryan, his friend Arthur, and himself as a twister overhead ripped apart his home. Nothing but the cement floor and basement were left. After the first twister had gone, Arthur’s sister Stacy, came and helped the 3 boys out of the basement. As soon as Dan Hatcher found his mother and had given his little brother Ryan to her, Stacy, Arthur, and himself went out to find their good friend Mrs. Smiley, an 81 year old woman. Dan Hatcher and his friends found Mrs. Smiley asleep in her basement. Fortunately she was not hurt. They took her to shelter for care and they went on to the armory. As Dan Hatchter and his 2 friends were taken to the armory for the night, a 2nd twister hit the police car they were in. The driver was injured by flying glass. The driver quickly lost his vision, so 12 year old Dan Hatcher drove the police car to the armory. After Dan Hatcher and his friends, Stacy and Arthur, spent the night in the armory, they went in search of their parents. They found Arthur’s father in his office. He had not seen Dan’s family, so Dan 34 went to the local K-mart to find his mother. A police officer told him everyone was evacuated to the churches, high schools, and other places that were not damaged by the twisters. On his way to the park Dan found himself reunited with his father, along with his mother and little brother Ryan. Text B Weather Report Today’s forecast calls for clear skies with a high of 72 and a low of 61. Tomorrow, a calm, sunny day is in store for the Grand Island area with temperatures in the high 70’s, a nice change after all those twisters. Thursday and Friday will be cooler with light breezes and temperatures in the middle 60’s. To make your own weather section of a newspaper, you can predict what it will be like for the next couple of days. You could even draw pictures of your predictions to show what you think. Now create your own weather heading or weather forecast. Contemporary Media: the Change Read this article about some of the ways that news has changed The Nature of News What do people mean by the term "news"? More than a century ago, an editor at the New York Sun explained it this way: "If a dog bites a man, it's not news. It a man bites a dog, that's news." That statement is still true today—unusual things make the news. Conflicts and events that are very recent are also news. When famous people do something, that's news, too. The way we get the news — the media—is undergoing tremendous change. For example, more and more people today have access to the Internet, where they can choose what type of news to look at. These days, people are choosing "news you can use." Rather than looking for in-depth news stories about events in the world, they want news about their own needs and concerns. People want reliable information about the traffic on the roads near their house, where to buy the cheapest plane tickets, or whether it's going to rain tomorrow. "News you can use" means accurate information that people can act on directly, by taking a different route to work, by buying a plane ticket online, or by changing their weekend plans. 35 Another feature of today's news is its focus on analysis. In the past, the news gave people information about individual events. Today, people depend on the news to get informed about how individual events happen together to affect the world, their work, or their lives. They want to know what's happening, but they also want to know what it means for their lives. News reporters are constantly searching for groups of events that signal new trends. For example, a reporter in Chicago went to several supermarkets in one week. He noticed that they were all offering free child-care for their customers. Shoppers could leave their children in a supervised play area while they shopped. The reporter did not report on one store and its new childcare feature. He reported on a new trend on the part of businesses to become more parent-friendly. This kind of news analysis helps people keep up with trends and better understand how to adapt to them. The new emphasis on practical news applies to every type of news medium—TV, print media, radio, and especially the Internet. With so many media choices, there is almost no limit to the amount of "news you can use." Will Newspapers Survive? Look at the charts below and outline the main findings of a national opinion and statistic surveys on newspapers, newspaper reading habits, news and the change in reading habits and getting access to the news. a. b. c. d. 36 Jigsaw reading ‘_We Media: Introduction to Participatory Journalism’ Group A You will read text 1 ‘_We Media…’ Group B You will read text 2 ‘Citizen journalism – What is it?’ Group C You will read text 3 ‘Participatory journalism starts conversation’ Read the texts and answer the following questions: 1. What do you learn about citizen /participatory journalism? 2. What changes have taken place in the media? Can you give examples? 3. What is said about the origins, quality, reaction of the traditional mainstream journalism to citizen /participatory journalism? 4. Do you get the impression that the statement that ‘participatory media aims at validation of the truth about what is happening in the world’ is true? Can you give examples from the texts you have read/ from real life of today? 5. What is said about different forms of participatory journalism? 6. Do you agree with the statement that citizen journalism often attracts the community’s attention/causes reaction and starts the ongoing conversation more often that the mainstream media? Give examples from the texts you have read/ from real life of today? 7. To what extent is citizen journalism involved with the local community, nation and the rest of the world? 8. Compare the situation in mainstream media and citizen journalism, their relationship in Britain and the US (as presented in the texts) with your country. Give examples. Text 1 ‘_We Media: Introduction to Participatory Journalism’ (How audiences are shaping the future of the new and information) Citizen Journalism has put democracy back in people's hands. An army of individuals with mobile phones, portable cameras, and blogs is rapidly replacing traditional media as a reliable and wide-ranging source of information. Chris Willis and Shayne Bowman, ‘_We Media…’ 37 Unfortunately, popular belief has it that news coming from official, mainstream channels is superior in quality and reliability than news reported by a blogger or someone with a shaky camcorder. Traditional media keep being preached as the source of truth, but what they lack is exactly the essence of truth: validation. How do you establish what is true from what is false? Mainstream media have a one-way dialogue with their audience: there's no way to check back what was told or written. Participatory journalism, on the contrary, finds its very strength in the continuous, ongoing validation process operated by a large community. You can easily share your opinion, agree / disagree with what is being said by taking advantage of new technologies and the web. This is why it is also called Participatory Journalism. Participatory journalism is: The act of a citizen, or group of citizens, playing an active role in the process of collecting, reporting, analyzing and disseminating news and information. The intent of this participation is to provide independent, reliable, accurate, wide-ranging and relevant information that a democracy requires. In his 1995 book Being Digital, Nicholas Negroponte predicted that in the future, online news would give readers the ability to choose only the topics and sources that interested them. "The Daily Me," as Negroponte called it, worried many guardians of traditional journalism. To actively allow a reader to narrow the scope of coverage, observed some, could undermine the "philosophical underpinnings of traditional media." The vision that seemed cutting edge and worrisome eight years ago seems to have come partly true. The Wall Street Journal, MSNBC.com, The Washington Post and CNN, to name a few, all offer readers some degree of personalization on the front pages of their sites. Millions of Yahoo members customize their MyYahoo personal news portal with the same news wire reports that editors use in daily newspapers across the globe. Google's news page uses a computer algorithm to select headlines from thousands of news sites - creating a global newsstand, of sorts. In the view of futurist and author Watts Wacker, the question is not about greater personalization but about greater perspectives. According to Wacker, the world is moving faster than people can keep up with it. As a result, ideas, styles, products and mores accelerate their way from the fringe to the 38 mainstream with increasing speed. Now, it appears, the vision of "The Daily Me" is being replaced by the idea of "The Daily We." Behind The Citizen Journalism Revolution The venerable profession of journalism finds itself at a rare moment in history where, for the first time, its hegemony as gatekeeper of the news is threatened by not just new technology and competitors but, potentially, by the audience it serves. Armed with easy-to-use web publishing tools, always-on connections and increasingly powerful mobile devices, the online audience has the means to become an active participant in the creation and dissemination of news and information. And it's doing just that on the Internet: According to the Pew Internet Project, the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, generated the most traffic to traditional news sites in the history of the Web. Many large news sites buckled under the immense demand and people turned to e-mail, weblogs and forums "as conduits for information, commentary, and action related to 9/11 events." The response on the Internet gave rise to a new proliferation of "do-it-yourself journalism." Everything from eyewitness accounts and photo galleries to commentary and personal storytelling emerged to help people collectively grasp the confusion, anger and loss felt in the wake of the tragedy. Immediately after the Columbia shuttle disaster, news and government organizations, in particular The Dallas Morning News and NASA, called upon the public to submit eyewitness accounts and photographs that might lead to clues to the cause of the spacecraft's disintegration. ABCNews.com's The Note covers political candidates and gives each an individual weblog to comment back on what was reported. (A future president of the United States might be chosen not only on his or her merits, charisma, experience or voting record but on the basis of how well he or she blogs.) College coaches, players and sports media outlets keep constant vigil on numerous fan forum sites, which have been credited with everything from breaking and making news to rumor-mongering. "You can't go anywhere or do anything and expect not to be seen, because everyone is a reporter now," says Steve Patterson, who operates a web site devoted to University of Georgia sports. 39 Text 2 Citizen Journalism - What Is It? by Chriss Hogg and and David Silverberg of DigitalJournal.com Weblogs Come of Age The Internet, as a medium for news, is maturing. With every major news event, online media evolve. And while news sites have become more responsive and better able to handle the growing demands of readers and viewers, online communities and personal news and information sites are participating in an increasingly diverse and important role that, until recently, has operated without significant notice from mainstream media. While there are many ways that the audience is now participating in the journalistic process, which we will address in this report, weblogs have received the most attention from mainstream media in the past year. Weblogs, or blogs as they are commonly known, are the most active and surprising form of this participation. These personal publishing systems have given rise to a phenomenon that shows the markings of a revolution - giving anyone with the right talent and energy the ability to be heard far and wide on the Web. The growth of weblogs has been largely fueled by greater access to bandwidth and low-cost, often free software. These simple easy-to-use tools have enabled new kinds of collaboration unrestricted by time or geography. The result is an advance of new social patterns and means for self-expression. Blog-like communities like Slashdot.org have allowed a multitude of voices to participate while managing a social order and providing a useful filter on discussion. Weblogs have expanded their influence by attracting larger circles of readers while at the same time appealing to more targeted audiences. "Blogs are in some ways a new form of journalism, open to anyone who can establish and maintain a Web site, and they have exploded in the past year," writes Walter Mossberg, technology columnist for the Wall Street Journal. "The good thing about them is that they introduce fresh voices into the national discourse on various topics, and help build communities of interest through their collections of links. 40 Mossberg's description of weblogs as a new kind of journalism might trouble established, traditionally trained journalists. But it is a journalism of a different sort, one not tightly confined by the traditions and standards adhered to by the traditional profession. These acts of citizen engaging in journalism are not just limited to weblogs. They can be found in newsgroups, forums, chat rooms, collaborative publishing systems and peer-to-peer applications like instant messaging. As new forms of participation have emerged through new technologies, many have struggled to name them. As a default, the name is usually borrowed from the enabling technology (i.e., weblogging, forums and usenets). Text 3 Participatory Journalism Starts the Conversation Chris Willis and Shayne Bowman Participatory journalism is a bottom-up, emergent phenomenon in which there is little or no editorial oversight or formal journalistic workflow dictating the decisions of a staff. Instead, it is the result of many simultaneous, distributed conversations that either blossom or quickly atrophy in the Web's social network. While the explosion of weblogs is a recent phenomenon, the idea of tapping into your audience for new perspectives or turning readers into reporters or commentators is not. Many news organizations have a long history of tapping into their communities and experimenting with turning readers into reporters or commentators. Conversation is the mechanism that turns the tables on the traditional roles of journalism and creates a dynamic, egalitarian give-and-take ethic. The fluidity of this approach puts more emphasis on the publishing of information rather than the filtering. Conversations happen in the community for all to see. In contrast, traditional news organizations are set up to filter information before they publish it. It might be collaborative among the editors and reporters, but the debates are not open to public scrutiny or involvement. 41 John Seely Brown, chief scientist of Xerox Corp., further elaborates on participatory journalism in the book The Elements of Journalism: "In an era when anyone can be a reporter or commentator on the Web, 'you move to a two-way journalism.' The journalist becomes a 'forum leader,' or a mediator rather than simply a teacher or lecturer. The audience becomes not consumers, but ' pro-sumers,' a hybrid of consumer and producer." This raises some important questions: If participatory journalism has risen without the direct help of trained journalists or news industry initiatives, what role will mainstream media play? And are mainstream media willing to relinquish some control and actively collaborate with their audiences? Or will an informed and empowered consumer begin to frame the news agenda from the grassroots? And, will journalism's values endure? 42 In his 1996 book News Values, former Chicago Tribune publisher Jack Fuller summed it up well: "The new interactive medium both threatens the status quo and promises an exciting new way of learning about the world." This deftly describes both camps of opinion concerning participation by the audience in journalism. The most obvious difference between participatory journalism and traditional journalism is the different structure and organization that produce them. Traditional media are created by hierarchical organizations that are built for commerce. Their business models are broadcast and advertising focused. They value rigorous editorial workflow, profitability and integrity. Participatory journalism is created by networked communities that value conversation, collaboration and egalitarianism over profitability. Clay Shirky, an adjunct professor at New York University who has consulted on the social and economic effects of Internet technologies, sees the difference this way: 43 "The order of things in broadcast is 'filter, then publish.' The order in communities is 'publish, then filter.' Many traditional journalists are dismissive of participatory journalism, particularly webloggers, characterizing them as self-interested or unskilled amateurs. Conversely, many webloggers look upon mainstream media as an arrogant, exclusive club that puts its own version of self-interest and economic survival above the societal responsibility of a free press. "This kind of high-tech interaction is a journalism that resembles conversation again, much like the original journalism occurring in the publick houses and coffeehouses four hundred years ago. Seen in this light, journalism's function is not fundamentally changed by the digital age. The techniques may be different, but the underlying principles are the same." (The Elements of Journalism, Kovach and Rosenstiel) What is emerging is a new media ecosystem, where online communities discuss and extend the stories created by mainstream media. These communities also produce participatory journalism, grassroots reporting, annotative reporting, commentary and fact-checking, which the mainstream media feed upon, developing them as a pool of tips, sources and story ideas. Scott Rosenberg, managing editor of Salon.com, explains, "Weblogs expand the media universe. They are a media life-form that is native to the Web, and they add something new to our mix, something valuable, something that couldn't have existed before the Web. It should be obvious that weblogs aren't competing with the work of the professional journalism establishment, but rather complementing it. If the pros are criticized as being cautious, impersonal, corporate and herdlike, the bloggers are the opposite in, well, almost every respect: They're reckless, confessional, funky - and herdlike." Dan Gillmor, one of weblogging's most vocal defenders and a technology journalist and weblogger for the San Jose Mercury News, describes this ecosystem as "journalism's next wave." In a post to his weblog on March 27, 2002, Gillmor described the principles that define the current "we media" movement: My readers know more than I do. That is not a threat, but rather an opportunity. We can use this together to create something between a seminar and a conversation, educating all of us. 44 Interactivity and communications technology - in the form of email, weblogs, discussion boards, websites and more - make it happen. [This material is originally written by Chris Willis and Shayne Bowman, and first published on September 21st 2003 as "We Media: Introduction To Participatory Journalism", PDF free download is available at http://www.hypergene.net/wemedia/weblog.php?id=P36 ] Everyday ethical dilemmas facing journalists Here are a number of everyday ethical issues that can confront journalists: Should journalists ever lie or use deceit in the pursuit of a story? • Should they ever edit a direct quotation? Is it legitimate to tape a conversation and not inform the interviewee of this? • Should journalists accept freebies? Should they do so only on certain conditions? Are there any significantly different ethical issues in being offered a book for review, a free ticket to review a play and a free trip to the Seychelles for a travel feature? What is the impact of the plethora of awards on standards? What considerations should a journalist have when interviewing children? Should a reporter contact the parents of a student who has committed suicide at university? Should newspapers carry columns by local Christian leaders but not by those of other faiths? • To what extent should newspapers provide readers with the right to reply to inaccuracies? • What special consideration should a journalist have when dealing with the mentally ill? • How important is it for journalists to protect their sources? • Is cheque-book journalism (paying sources) justified? Is it legitimate to invade someone's privacy for a story? Do different standards apply to public figures and to members of the general public? 45 • To what extent does overt commitment to a political party or campaigning movement interfere with professionalism and notions of fairness? • Should newspapers carry government misinformation during times of war (and peace)? • Is it legitimate ever to break an embargo? • Is it possible to provide guidelines on questions of taste and the use of 'shocking' photographs or obscene language? • To what extent does newspaper language reinforce militarist and ageist stereotypes and how can journalists confront this issue? 46 Appendix 1 1. Structural features Abbreviations and acronyms Abbreviations and acronyms are often used in headlines to save space. Razor-sharp legal star beaten by the OJ factor NATO envoys bring peace hope Organ donor in CJD shock NHS faces a terminal lack of faith AIDS clinic to close Sea birds could help set EU fishing quotas Omission Articles and other determiners, possessive adjectives and parts of the verb 'to be' (particularly in passive constructions) are frequently omitted in newspaper headlines. Pound falls Biker loses arm in crash Man stabbed after rail row Tenses 1 The infinitive is used to refer to future events. Minister to quit France to sell 20% of Telecom 2 The -ing form of the verb, representing the Present Progressive, is used to refer to events that are happening at the moment. Au pair agency facing huge damages claim Authorities failing child ME sufferers 3 The -ing form of the verb, representing the Present Progressive, is also used to refer to future events. Women facing poverty in old age 4 The Simple Present is often used to refer to events which happened in the past. Beatles' PR man dies aged 65 Elephants kill 7 in rampage 5 The Simple Present can also be used to refer to events happening at the moment. France prepares for World Cup mania Bank expects high rate of interest in open day Short headlines Many short news reports, particularly News in Brief items, are accompanied by headlines made up of only two or three words. Although a number of different variations are possible, there are several fairly common combinations. 47 1 noun + noun Tunnel death Birthday rat 2 adjective + noun Lethal attack Lucky numbers 3 noun + verb Sailors rescued Trains withdrawn Pound falls 4 noun + noun + noun Poison case wait Briton arrest fear Ferry fire payout 5 noun + verb + noun Animals left fortune Court delays crucifixion Racer loses title 2. Stylistic and structural features of newspaper headlines Stylistic features Alliteration Alliteration is the repetition of the same initial sound in a group of words. Wives' war of waiting and writing Spice Girls feel the fickle finger of fame Assonance Assonance is the repetition of one particular vowel sound in a group of words. Wotto lotto bosh on lotto dosh Cliché The word cliché is used in a pejorative sense to refer to a word or expression that is considered to be over-used, or used indiscriminately. Clichés come in several different forms, including alliterative phrases, over-dramatic adjectives, metaphors and single words. Skiers safe and sound Proud parents win coveted title Tower of strength Fairy-tale romance Soap star in love-child mercy dash Euphemism Euphemism is the use of a particular word or expression which is considered more acceptable or pleasant, or less controversial, than certain other words or expressions. It can be used as a way of being vague and unclear, or to cover up the truth or reality of a situation. Minister threatens air support [i.e. bombing] BA reports passenger underflow [i.e. very few passengers] 48 IBM announces job rationalisation [i.e. job cuts] Irony Irony in newspaper headlines can be used for news events in which a person seems mocked by fate or events. Although frequently tragic, there is often an element of black (graveyard) humour to be found in such headlines. Bike crash kills flying phobia man Bull savages anti-bloоdsport campaigner Metaphor Metaphor is when a phrase or expression usually used to describe one thing is used to describe something else. Ministers read the riot act by PM [i.e. the Prime Minister was angry with his ministers] New hospital put on ice [i.e. the building of the new hospital has been suspended] Pun A pun is a play on a word which has several meanings or which sound like another word. It is a feature frequently used in tabloid newspaper for humorous effect. Fisherman nets lotto jackpot Xerox present the fax to shareholders [i.e. the facts] Car-makers drive up profits Repetition Repetition of words in headlines is for emphasis and very strong dramatic effect. Out Out Out Why, Oh Why, Oh Why? Shared knowledge Many headlines assume shared cultural knowledge and shared general knowledge between the headline writer and the reader. This includes the use of only first names or surnames of people who are considered so well-known that stating their full name, position or title or reason for prominence is considered unnecessary. Kiss for Harry as he meets pop idols [reference to Prince Harry, the son of the Prince of Wales] You cannot be serious [reference to the exact words used by an American tennis star in an angry outburst] Where in the world is our poor kidnapped Tinky Winky? [reference to a popular children's TV programme character] Odd couple who longed for a Mary Poppins life 49 [reference to a film character and the type of person she represents] Tragedy of A-level girl on joyride [reference to a public examination in the British school system] Simile Simile is describing one thing by likening it to another. Crash scene like a battlefield Villagers sick as a parrot 50 Appendix 2 Web sites This is only a small collection of Internet resources you might find useful. The best collections of newspapers and magazines can be found at http://www.onlinenewspapers.com/magazines/ - ‘The World magazines at your fingertips’, http://magazine-directory.com/ - alphabetic magazine directory and http://www.newspapers.com/ - a newspapers directory called ‘What in the world is going on…’, http://pppp.net/links/news - The Ultimate collection of news Links . Britain, Scotland & Ireland Daily Mirror Electronic Telegraph European Evening Standard Financial Times Guardian Independent Observer Telegraph Sunday Times The Times Electronic Herald Evening Times Scotsman Scotsman Sunday Mail Belfast Telegraph Examiner Irish Independent www.mirror.co.uk www.telegrph.co.uk www.the-european.com www.thisislondon.co.uk www.ft.com www.guardian.co.uk www.independent.co.uk www.observer.co.uk www.telegrph.co.uk www.sunday-times.co.uk www.the-times.co.uk www.dcthomson.co.uk/mags/tele www.cims.co.uk/eveningtimes www.scotsman.com/index.html www.record-mail.co.uk/rm www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk www.examiner.ie www.independent.ie USA Los Angeles Times New York Times USA Today Wall Street Journal Washington Post CNN Interactive www.latimes.com/HOME www.nytimes.com www.usatoday.com www.wsj.com www.washingtonpost.com www.cnn.com 51 Reuters www.reuters.com Russia Вести.RU Russia Today www.vesti.ru www.rt.com Cartoons and strip cartoons The Born Loser Cartoon Stock The Comic strip Garfield Online www.unitedmedia.com/comics/bornloser www.cartoostock.com www.unitedmedia.com/comics www.garfield.com 52 Appendix 3 Abbreviations used in classified advertisements Abbreviation Full form Abbreviation A-E Full form E-L a/phone; an/phone answerphone ex con; ex cond excellent condition appt appointment exel excluding att; attract attractive ext extension avail available F female bale balcony f/k; f/kit; f/kitchen fitted kitchen bath; b/room bathroom fir floor BB; B&B bed and breakfast fr from bed(s); bedrm(s) bedroom(s) fsh full service history bldng building f/ship friendship brkfst rm breakfast-room ft foot/feet b/w; b&w black and white f/t full-time c. circa (e.g. c. £30,000) gch gas central heating c chest (e.g. c 36" = gdn garden chest size 36 inches) gf; g/f ground floor cc credit card(s) gfch gas-fired central heating cent century gge; grge garage ch; c/h central heating g/con good condition charm charming grnd ground clkrm cloakroom gsoh good sense of humour c/o care of (e.g. Write do g/tee; guar guarantee The Manager) gwo good working order cols colours hrs hours cones concessions (e.g. h/some handsome student cones) immed immediately CV curriculum vitae in(s) inch(es) dble double inc; incl included/including dep deposit indpt independent det detached ins insurance/inches din rm dining-room int international DIY do it yourself ints interests d/g; d/glazing; d/glz double glazing k thousand (e.g. £l5k) educ educated kit kitchen ent entrance l length (e.g. / 24" = length 24 inches) ent'ment entertainment lnge lounge e/phone entry phone l/r; liv/rm living-room est established/estimate lrg large eves evenings lux luxury 53 Abbreviation Full form M-P M male max maximum min minimum/minute mins minutes mnth month mod cons modern conveniences mpg miles per gallon 'n' and new dec; new decor newly decorated no. number nr near n/s non-smoker nt night OAP old age pensioner ono or near(est) offer ovno or very near offer pa per annum pat patio pcm per calendar month ph; pr hr per hour poss possibly p+p postage and packing pppn per person per night (e.g. £25 pppn) prof professional prog programme prop proprietor p/t part-time pw per week p/x; p/exchange part-exchange Abbreviation Full form rec rm ref refs reg sip people) sngle sq tel tdh tic v VAT VCR VDU vgc w inches) wc w/d; w/day w/e wk(s) wltm yo years old) yr(s) 54 R-Y reception-room refund/reference references registered (e.g. reg childminder) sleeps (e.g. sip 2-6 = sleeps 2-6 single square telephone tall dark (and) handsome tender loving care very Value Added Tax video cassette recorder visual display unit very good condition waist (e.g. w 36" = waist size 36 water closet (i.e. toilet) weekday weekend week(s) would like to meet years old (e.g. 32 yo = thirty-two year(s) Resources and Further Reading 1. Chris Willis and Shayne Bowman. We Media: Introduction To Participatory Journalism", PDF free download is available at http://www.hypergene.net/wemedia/weblog.php?id=P36 ] 2. New York Times Learning Network (http://nytimes.com/learning/students/index.html) 3. Paul Sanderson. Using Newspaper in the Classroom. Cambridge Handbooks for Language Teachers. CUP,1999 4. Bill Mascull. Key Words in the Media. Collins Cobuild Series. Москва, Астрель, 2005 5. LTP Dictionary of Selected Collocations. LTP Language, 1999 6. Comparative Media Studies: MIT Communications Forum. http://cms.mit.edu/news/2007/01/mit_communications_forum_why 7. Countries Profiles http://www.atlapedia.com/online/country_index.htm 8. PBS.org: PBS for Educators. The Vanishing Verb. http://www.pbs.org/newshour/thenews/foreducators/index.php 9. Keith Waterhouse. Waterhouse on Newspaper Style. Penguin, 1993 10. Peg Sarosy & Kathy Sherak. Lecture Ready. Oxford, 2006 11. Ильина А.К. Язык СМИ: 500 «трудных» слов. Флинта, Наука, 2007 On-line Periodicals 1. Guardian www.guardian.co.uk 2. Independent www.independent.co.uk 3. Observer www.observer.co.uk 4. Telegraph www.telegrph.co.uk 5. Sunday Times www.sunday-times.co.uk 6. New York Times www.nytimes.com 7. Washington Post www.washingtonpost.com 55 Учебное издание Пластинина Нина Анатольевна ‘Media Guide: Учебно-методические материалы для студентов 3 курса по дисциплине «Особенности публицистического стиля: Язык средств массовой информации’ Издание подготовлено в авторской редакции Подписано в печать – апрель 2010. Формат 60х84 1/16. Бумага для множительных аппаратов. Гарнитура Bookman Old Style. Печать плоская. Усл. печ. листов 3,2. Тираж 50 экз. Нижневартовский государственный университет 628609, Тюменская обл., г. Нижневартовск, ул. Ленина, 56. 56