Course How Reserves to read the articles Open Yale Courses – Emotion Topics “Episodic, relatively short-term, biologicallybased patterns of perception, experience, physiology, action, and communication that occur in response to specific physical and social challenges and opportunities.” What are the 5 components of an emotion? (Keltner & Gross, 1999, p.468) How does an emotion differ from other constructs (i.e., moods, sentiments)? Readings: Ekman (1994); Frijda (1994) Classic Theories of Emotion – According to each theory, which of the components of emotion are important? Reading: Schirmer (2014, pp. 11-18) Drives (e.g., hunger) Moods (e.g., cranky) Affective Disorders (e.g., depression) Sentiments (“I hate Ohio State”) Personality Traits (e.g., Extraversion) [Ekman, P. (1994). Moods, emotions, and traits. In P. Ekman, & R.J. Davidson (Eds.), The nature of emotion (pp. 56-58). New York: Oxford.] [Frijda, N. (1994). Varieties of affect: Emotions and episodes, moods, and sentiments.] Duration EMOTION INTENSITY Emotion vs. Mood vs. Affective Disorder Recurring Emotion Episodes HIGH LOW TIME [Ekman, P. (1994). Moods, emotions, and traits. In P. Ekman, & R.J. Davidson (Eds.), The nature of emotion (pp. 56-58). New York: Oxford.] [Frijda, N. (1994). Varieties of affect: Emotions and episodes, moods, and sentiments.] Duration Emotion vs. Mood vs. Affective Disorder Recurring Emotion Episodes Moods may cause emotions, and emotions may cause moods Moods make it harder to control emotions Unique facial expressions and vocal signals Eliciting Event [Ekman, P. (1994). Moods, emotions, and traits. In P. Ekman, & R.J. Davidson (Eds.),The nature of emotion (pp. 56-58). New York: Oxford.] James-Lange Cannon-Bard Schachter-Singer Emotions are labels we give to the way the body reacts to certain situations. [Schirmer, A. (2014). (R)evolutionary ideas of the 19th century. Emotion (Chapter 1, pp.11-18). Los Angeles, CA: Sage.] Eliciting Event Brain Eliciting Event Brain Bodily Changes Behavior Change Eliciting Event Brain Bodily Changes Behavior Change Emotion Label Eliciting Event Brain “I feel afraid!” Bodily Changes Subjective Feelings Behavior Change Emotion Label BIG BEAR Quick Cognitive Appraisal Quick Cognitive Appraisal Brain quickly interprets event, physiological, and behavior changes Stomach Tightens I feel my stomach tightening and see myself running away! Turn to run! Fear!!! Bodily changes occur slower than the feeling experience of an emotion Cannon and Bard Interpretation/perception of the eliciting event may be a stronger determinant of the emotion label than bodily changes Specific bodily changes do not match specific emotions Cannon and Bard Cognitive appraisal, physiological change, behavior, and feelings are Separate, but Simultaneous Eliciting Event Physiological Change Behavior Change Subjective Feelings Cognitive Appraisal BEAR HR ↑ Run! Feels like fear! This is fear! Large amount of evidence contradicts Sudden events can quickly (in seconds) evoke physiological changes and an emotion Gun shot → HR increases → Fear! Importance: First to suggest that cognitive appraisal determines emotion label Physiological arousal determines strength of emotion; Cognitive appraisal identifies the emotion. Strength of Emotion Physiological Change Eliciting Event Cognitive Appraisal Behavior Change Label Emotion Subjective Feelings This is a very strong change in arousal! HR ↑ Bear Why is my heart pounding? I see a bear – this explains the heart pounding! Cognitive Appraisal Run! Feels like fear! This is a very strong change in arousal! HR ↑ My Significant Other Why is my heart pounding? I see my significant other– this explains the heart pounding! Cognitive Appraisal Run! Feels like love! Unexplained physiological arousal Look for an explanation for arousal (cognitive appraisal) Label Emotion! IV #1: Type of Injection (Epinephrine, Placebo) IV #2: Manipulated expectations of side effects (only epinephrine cond.) ½ told: will increase HR, sweating ½ told: NOTHING! IV #3: Manipulated Situation (Euphoria, Anger) Euphoria: confederate acted happy Anger: confederate acted angry DV: Ps’ self-reported happiness:anger ratio Epinephrine ½ told shot would ↑ HR, sweat, etc. Placebo ½ not told anything Euphoria Condition Euphoria Condition Anger Condition Anger Condition Euphoria Condition Anger Condition Epinephrine ½ told shot would ↑ HR, sweat, etc. Euphoria Condition Anger Condition Placebo ½ not told anything Euphoria Condition Anger Condition Euphoria Condition Anger Condition Same levels of happiness and anger Side Effects Expected ½ told shot would ↑ HR, sweat, etc. Euphoria Condition Happy < Anger Attributed arousal to shot Side Effects Not Expected Epinephrine Anger Condition Happy > Anger ½ not told anything Euphoria Condition Happy > Anger Anger Condition Happy = Anger Misattributed arousal to happy confederate Side Effects Expected ½ told shot would ↑ HR, sweat, etc. Euphoria Condition Happy < Anger Side Effects Not Expected Epinephrine ½ not told anything Anger Condition Euphoria Condition Happy > Anger Attributed arousal to shot Happy > Anger Anger Condition Happy = Anger Misattributed arousal to angry confederate Emotions are influenced by our interpretation of the situation Whether expect or do not expect side effects We experience unexplained arousal, and then look to our environment for an explanation Was it the shot? Was it the confederate’s behavior? Sometimes our interpretation is right, sometimes wrong! When a variable interferes with the cognitive appraisal process (such as by telling people which emotion to feel), then the type of emotion people report changes. Calculation of happy:angry ratio is confusing Epinephrine could affect people’s physiology in different ways Cognitive appraisal component is slower and conscious Less focus on quick, automatic appraisals Video Condition #1: Low Bridge Condition #2: High Bridge Assume experience low arousal Assume experience high arousal DV = Attraction to female experimenter DV = Attraction to female experimenter Low Bridge High Bridge Assume experience low arousal Assume experience high arousal DV = Attraction to female experimenter DV = Attraction to female experimenter 9% Called 39% called James-Lange Cannon-Bard Schachter-Singer Subjective in feelings change Physiological changes Behavior Change Cognitive Eliciting Appraisal Event James-Lange Theory Evolutionary Perspective Cognitive appraisal occurs quickly through unconscious processes in brain Schachter-Singer Theory Cognitive Appraisal Theory Body determines strength, not label Unexplained arousal leads to cognitive appraisal Slower cognitive appraisal Research supports both fast and slow cognitive appraisals Modern Perspectives of Emotion -What are the differences between the following modern perspectives: Basic Emotions, Dimensional Models, Appraisal Theory, and Component Process Theory? Readings: Schirmer (2014, pp. 42-69) Basic and Distinct Emotions – What is the difference? What are the limitations? Readings: Ekman & Cordaro (2011); Fischer (2013, Boston Magazine)