Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

advertisement
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
on the Payment Card Reform Framework (Framework)
1. What is the objective of the Framework?
The Framework aims to foster an efficient, transparent and competitive payment card
industry in Malaysia.
In this regard, the Framework seeks to ensure that the cost of accepting payment cards is
fair and reasonable. The Framework also seeks to promote wider acceptance and usage
of cost-effective payment cards.
2. What are the key measures under the Framework?
The key measures introduced under the Framework are as follows:
(i)
Objective and transparent mechanism for the setting of interchange fees
The interchange fees for domestic payment card transactions will be subject to
ceilings which are determined based on the cost structure of the respective
payment cards.
Interchange fee ceiling1
Type of card
transaction
Domestic brand
debit card


‘0.15%’ or ‘50 sen + 0.01%’, whichever is lower
0% (for payments to the Government or its agencies)2
International brand
debit/prepaid card


‘0.21%’ or ‘70 sen + 0.01%’, whichever is lower
0% (for payments to the Government or its agencies)2
Credit card


1.10% (from 2015 to 2020)3
0.48% (from 2021 onwards)4
To facilitate comparison, interchange fee rates will be published in the websites of
the payment card network operators.
1
Interchange fee ceiling that is expressed as a percentage refers to a percentage of the value of transaction.
2
The zero interchange fee is applicable only for an interim period of 6 years (2015 to 2020) to incentivise the
acceptance of debit and prepaid cards by the Government and its agencies. Post-2020, the interchange fee
would be subject to a ceiling determined based on a set of eligible cost components.
3
The ceiling of 1.10% is applicable to payment card network operators who establish a Market Development
Fund or 1.00% for operators who do not do so. Such ceiling would be lowered based on a pre-determined
formula if the yearly industry indicators on the number of point-of-sale (POS) terminals deployed and debit
card transactions are not met.
4
The ceiling of 0.48% is based on the current computation of the eligible cost components. The ceiling post2020 may differ based on the actual computation at that time.
1
(ii)
Measures to empower merchants to accept cost-effective payment cards
A list of measures will be introduced to improve the price signals and for merchants
to be:

informed of the cost of accepting different payment cards;

able to distinguish debit and prepaid cards from other payment cards;

able to identify the different payment card networks available in a co-badged
debit card (i.e. a debit card with two debit card networks/brands);

in a position to encourage customers to use lower cost payment cards by
offering discounts or other benefits; and

able to choose the lower cost debit card network to route a debit card
transaction made using a co-badged debit card.
3. What type of payment card transactions is covered in the Framework?
The Framework is applicable to domestic transactions originating from the use of
Malaysian-issued debit, prepaid and credit cards at merchants in Malaysia.
4. What is the impact of the Framework on consumers, merchants and banks?
(i)
Consumers
 Consumers would be able to use payment cards more widely as the lower card
acceptance cost brought about by the Framework would facilitate more
merchants to accept payment cards. Hence, there would be less need for
consumers to carry cash.
 Consumers are less likely to be surcharged (i.e. imposed with an additional fee
by merchants) for the use of payment cards, in particular the debit card.
 Due to the lower card acceptance cost, there is also less risk that merchants will
pass on the cost of accepting payment cards to the customers by raising the
price of goods and services.
(ii)
Merchants

Merchants would benefit from lower acceptance cost for debit and prepaid
cards.

Merchants would be protected from rising cost of payment card acceptance
caused by indiscriminate increases in interchange fees.

Merchants would be able to manage their cost of card acceptance more
effectively througho greater transparency in the cost of payment card acceptance;
2
o ability to encourage customers to use a lower cost payment card; and
o ability to choose the lower cost debit card network/brand to route a
transaction made using a co-badged debit card.
(iii)
Banks

Banks’ earnings are unlikely to be impacted as the interchange fee revenue after
covering the related expenditure to process the transactions, are mainly used to
fund cardholder’s rewards and loyalty programs.This is based on a cost study
conducted by Bank Negara Malaysia.

Acquiring banks would benefit from higher revenue due to increases in the
number of payment card transactions as more merchants accept payment cards
due to their affordability.

As payment card transactions increase, banks, in general, would benefit from
cost savings and efficiency gains through a reduction in their cash handling cost.
5. What is the impact of indiscriminate increases in the interchange fee?
One of the objectives of the Framework is to address the risk of indiscriminate increases of
interchange fees through the establishment of an objective and transparent mechanism for
the setting of interchange fees as explained in paragraph 2(i) above.
Indiscriminate increases in interchange fees may lead to an industry-wide increase in the
merchant fee or merchant discount rate (MDR). This would make payment card
acceptance less affordable and discourage smaller merchants from accepting payment
cards.. Merchants who incur higher MDR are likely to pass on the higher cost to
consumers by raising prices of goods and services or by surcharging their customers.
6. Would there be an increase in cardholder fees or introduction of new cardrelated fees after the implementation of the Framework?
Cardholders are protected from increases in cardholder fees or introduction of new cardrelated fees through the following measures:

Cardholders will be provided with an option to obtain a basic payment card with
zero or nominal fees.

Any increase in cardholder fees or introduction of new card-related fees is subject
to Bank Negara Malaysia’s prior approval and must comply with a set of principles
to avoid excessive fees and charges.
3
7. Would the Framework cause consumers to be worse-off as banks are likely to
cut back on loyalty points, cash rebates and other cardholder rewards?
Cardholder rewards such as loyalty points and cash rebates are funded by merchants
through the payment of MDR. Merchants are likely to recover such cost through higher
prices of goods and services. As such, consumers who do not use payment cards may
end up subsidising the cardholder rewards enjoyed mostly by premium cardholders.
With the implementation of the Framework, there is likely to be a dampening in the
cardholder rewards. Nevertheless, consumers are not worse-off. With more affordable
payment card acceptance cost, merchants will be less pressured to pass on such cost to
consumers through higher prices of goods and services. In addition, more merchants
would be able to afford the acceptance of payment cards, in particular the debit card. This
would provide consumers with the convenience of using their payment cards widely at
more merchant outlets, thus lessening the need to carry cash.
4
Glossary
What is interchange fee?
Interchange fee is a fee payable between the merchant’s bank (also known as the
“acquirer”)5 and the cardholder’s bank (also known as the “issuer”)6 in a payment card
transaction as illustrated in Diagram 1 below.
Interchange fee is typically payable by the acquirer to the issuer to compensate the issuer
for certain costs incurred by the issuer in facilitating a payment card transaction.
Interchange fee may also flow from the issuer to the acquirer to compensate acquirers for
the cost of enabling payment card acceptance by merchants.7
What is merchant fee or merchant discount rate (MDR)?
Merchant fee or MDR is a fee payable by a merchant to an acquirer for enabling the
merchant to accept payment cards.
What is the relationship between the interchange fee and the MDR?
Interchange fee is incorporated into the MDR by the acquirer. Increases in the interchange
fee would cause acquirers to raise the MDR.
Diagram 1: Transaction flow of a payment card transaction
5
An acquirer is the party who provides payment card acceptance services to a merchant.
An issuer is the party who issues a payment card to a cardholder.
7 Prior to October 2011, the interchange fee for EFTPOS, the domestic debit card scheme in Australia, was
payable by the issuer to the acquirer.
6
5
Download