March 2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
802.11 March 2011 Closing Plenary
Reports
Date: 2011-03-17
Authors:
Name
Company
Adrian Stephens
Intel
Corporation
NDS Ltd
Alex Ashley
Report
Address
Phone
email
+44 792 008
4900 (mobile)
+44 792 021
1351
adrian.p.stephens@intel.com
Slide 1
aashley@nds.com
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
March 2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Abstract
• This document is a digest of the closing reports of all
802.11 sub-groups for presentation at the January 2011
closing plenary meeting.
Report
Slide 2
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
March 2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
March 2011 Publicity
Date: 2011-03-16
Authors:
Name
Stephen McCann
Report
Company
Research in Motion
(RIM) UK Ltd
Address
200 Bath Road, Slough,
Berkshire, SL1 3XE, UK
Slide 3
Phone
email
+44 1753 667099
smccann@rim.com
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1/2 of 11/415r1 by Stephen McCann, RIM
March 2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
• Press release about recent published drafts
– TGu
• 11-11-0365-00-0000-p802-11u-press-release.doc
– TGv
• 11-11-0470-00-0000-p802-11v-press-release.doc
– TGz
• Leave until Palm Springs
Report
Slide 4
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 2/2 of 11/415r1 by Stephen McCann, RIM
March 2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
802.11 WG Editor’s Meeting (Mar ‘11)
Date: 2011-03-11
Authors:
Name
Affiliation
Address
Phone
email
Peter Ecclesine
Cisco Systems
170 W. Tasman Dr.,
MS SJ-14-4, San
Jose, CA 951341706
+1-408-527-0815
petere@cisco.com
Report
Slide 5
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1/7 of 11/318r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Volunteer Editor Contacts
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Report
TGs – Kazuyuki Sakoda – KazuyukiA.Sakoda@jp.sony.com
TGmb – Adrian Stephens – adrian.p.stephens@intel.com
TGaa – Alex Ashley – alex.ashley@hotmail.co.uk
TGac – Robert Stacey – Robert.J.Stacey@intel.com
TGad – Carlos Cordeiro – carlos.cordeiro@intel.com
TGae – Henry Ptasinski – henryp@broadcom.com
TGaf – Peter Ecclesine – pecclesi@cisco.com
TGah – Wongyu Song – wongyu.song@lge.com
TGai – Tom Siep – tom.siep@ieee.org
Editors Emeritus:
– TGk – Joe Kwak– joekwak@sbcglobal.net
– TGp – Wayne Fisher – wfisher@arinc.com
– TGr – Bill Marshall – wtm@research.att.com
– TGu – Necati Canpolat – necati.canpolat@intel.com
– TGv – Emily Qi – emily.h.qi@intel.com
– TGw – Nancy Cam-Winget – ncamwing@cisco.com
– TGz – Menzo Wentink – mwentink@qualcomm.com
Slide 6
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 2/7 of 11/318r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
March 2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
ANA Announcements
• Current ANA announced to group is 802.11-11-0270r0. (2011 Feb 25)
– See https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/11/11-11-0270-00-0000-ana-database.xls
– All new requests received by end of meeting will be uploaded and announced
via 802.11 WG reflector
• Procedure for ANA is contained in 07/0827r0.
– See http://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/public/07/11-07-0827-00-0000-assigned-number-authority-ana-mechanisms.ppt
• Editorial Guidance
– ANA assignments should be done before the time of moving from WG LB to
Sponsor ballot.
– If a resource number is not in the ANA Database, please use <ANA> in drafts!
– Editors to replace any ANA controlled resources numbers with <ANA> upon
incorporation of material into drafts.
– Editors need to check the ANA database to determine which resources are
controlled and ensure that values are requested from the ANA.
Report
Slide 7
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 3/7 of 11/318r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
March 2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
ANA Report
• Recent allocations to TGad (1 item) and TGs (9 items)
• Two Behavior Limits released (reserved) by TGmb
• Two “temporary” values used by TGmb replaced by
allocated values
• Reallocation of two values used by TGmb to avoid
collision with published .11v
Report
Slide 8
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 4/7 of 11/318r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
March 2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Numbering Alignment Process
• Update from all published standards. Posted as 1108/644r20 (2011 Feb 17) By Kazuyuki Sakoda
• TGz-2010 started a new update cycle. 11v-2011, 11u2011, REVmb D7.03 numbering needs to be completed.
11ae is the next, then 11af, 11aa, 11ad, 11ac, 11ah, 11ai
• Create a working group MEC that includes numbering
and ANA before going to Sponsor Ballot
• We use more columns for the two baselines.
Report
Slide 9
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 5/7 of 11/318r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
March 2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
802.11 Style Guide
• See 11-09-1034-01-0000-wg11-style-guide.doc
• Editor’s responsibility includes checking the 2009 IEEE
Standards Style Manual when creating or updating
drafts.
• Call for interest to update this guide to match REVmb
conventions
Report
Slide 10
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 6/7 of 11/318r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
March 2011
Mar 2011
TG
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Draft Development Snapshot
Published or Draft Baseline Documents
Publi
shed
s
s
Y
9.0
mb
Y
mb
6.0
af
6.02
7.0
7.0
ad
ac
af
aa
ad
aa
ad
7.03
ae
aa
ae
2.0
1.0
1.0
0.06
3.0
1
2.0
7.0
0.2
ac
ah
Source
MEC
Style
Guide
Editor
Snapshot
Date
Frame 8.0
Yes
2009
Kazuyuki Sakoda
15-Mar
Frame 9.0
Yes
2009
Adrian Stephens
15-Mar
OpenOffic
e 3.2
No
2009
Henry Ptasinski
19-Jan
Frame 9.0
No
2009
Peter Ecclesine
15-Mar
Word
No
2009
Alex Ashley
16-Mar
Word
2007
No
2009
Carlos Cordero
15-Mar
Frame 9.0
No
2009
Robert Stacey
15-Mar
ah
Wongyu Song
ai
Tom Siep
Changes from last report
shown in red.
Report
Most current doc shaded green.
Slide 11
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 7/7 of 11/318r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Closing Report
Date: 2011-03-18
Authors:
Name
Company
Clint Chaplin
Samsung Electronics
Report
Address
75 W. Plumeria Drive
San Jose, Ca 95134
Phone
email
+1 408 544 5815
clint.chaplin@gmail.com
Slide 12
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1/3 of 11/0472r0 by Clint Chaplin, Chair (Samsung)
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Abstract
Closing report for WNG SC for March
2011, Singapore
Report
Slide 13
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 2/3 of 11/0472r0 by Clint Chaplin, Chair (Samsung)
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
• Presentations at March 2011 meeting
– 802.11 WNG Presentation on the use of UWB spectrum for 802.11 (11-110385-00-0wng-ultrwideband-spectrum-for-802-11.ppt) – Jim Lansford
– Lawrence Zimmermann
(http://www.ieee802.org/11/Documents/DocumentArchives/1994_docs/11941
32.DOC
• Minutes
– 11-11-0393-00-0wng-march-2011-meeting-minutes.doc
• Plans for May 2011
– 1 2 hour session
Report
Slide 14
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 3/3 of 11/0472r0 by Clint Chaplin, Chair (Samsung)
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
March 2011 Closing Report -TGmb
Date: 2011-03-17
Authors:
Name
Dorothy Stanley
Report
Affiliations
Address
Phone
Aruba Networks 1322 Crossman Ave +1 630-363Sunnyvale, CA
1389
94089
email
dstanley@arubanetworks.
com
Slide 15
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1/6 of 11/454r0 by Dorothy Stanley (Aruba Networks)
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Abstract
This document contains the TGmb closing report for
March 2011.
Report
Slide 16
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 2/6 of 11/454r0 by Dorothy Stanley (Aruba Networks)
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Accomplishments
• Completed Initial Recirculation SB Comment Resolution
(D7.0)
– 178 comments + 11u +11v
– Second Recirculation SB (20 day) to start shortly
• Scheduled Teleconference calls on
– April 29, May 6
– 10am Eastern (7am Pacific)
• Timeline Analysis
– No change from plan that 11mb will incorporate 11s
– Revisit in May
Report
Slide 17
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 3/6 of 11/454r0 by Dorothy Stanley (Aruba Networks)
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Current TGmb Plan of Record
 May 2008 – Issue Call for Comment/Input
 July 2008 – begin process input and old Interpretation requests
Acknowledge previous Task Group referrals









•
•
•
Report
Sept 2008 – PAR revision process started
Nov 2008 – close receipt of new input
Nov 2008 – WG/EC approval of PAR Revision
Dec 2008 – NesCom/SASB approval PAR Revision
May 2009 – First WG Letter ballot
Nov 2009 – Recirc start
July 2010 – Conditional Sponsor Ballot Approval from EC
August 2010 – Form Sponsor Pool (45 days) – Closes Sept 14
November 2010 – Initial Sponsor Ballot completion
Jan 2011 – Sponsor Recirc. Start
Nov 2011 – WG/EC Final Approval
March 2012 – RevCom/SASB Approval
Slide 18
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 4/6 of 11/454r0 by Dorothy Stanley (Aruba Networks)
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Goals for March
• Recirculation Sponsor Ballot comment resolution
(D8.0)
Report
Slide 19
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 5/6 of 11/454r0 by Dorothy Stanley (Aruba Networks)
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
References
Report
Slide 20
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 6/6 of 11/454r0 by Dorothy Stanley (Aruba Networks)
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
TGs Singapore Closing Report
Date: 2011-03-17
Author:
Name
Address
Affiliation
Phone
Email
Guido R.
Hiertz
Riedel Communications
GmbH & Co. KG,
Uellendahler Straße 353,
42109 Wuppertal,
Federal Republic of
Germany
Philips
+49-202292-9987
hiertz@ieee.org
Report
Slide 21
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1/5 of 11/0468r0 by Guido R. Hiertz (Philips)
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Abstract
TGs closing report for the March 2011 meeting.
Report
Slide 22
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 2/5 of 11/0468r0 by Guido R. Hiertz (Philips)
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Status
• Before meeting
• TGs passed its second recirculation based on Draft 9.0 with
95.0% approval rate (closed: 2011-03-05)
• We received 291 comments
• 5 general comments
• 142 editorial comments
• 144 technical comments
• During meeting
• The group resolved all comments
• The group approved the third SB recirculation
Report
Slide 23
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 3/5 of 11/0468r0 by Guido R. Hiertz (Philips)
March 2011
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
IEEE 802 Tutorial
• TGs presented a tutorial on 802.11s D9.0
– 2011-03-14, 19:30 – 21:00
– Well attended
– Good discussion
• ~5 attendees asked detailed questions
• 20 min to 25 min discussion
– Available in 11-11-0380-00-000s from
https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/documents
Report
Slide 24
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 4/5 of 11/0468r0 by Guido R. Hiertz (Philips)
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Timeline review
• TGs reviewed the timeline
• TGs is aware of the need for fast progress
• TGs works hard to finish early to be included in 802.11-2012
Currently envisaged scenario
date
Recirculation
March 2011
SB Ballot on draft 11
2011-04-20
SB Ballot on unchanged draft 11
2011-05-21
Request EC Unconditional Approval to go to
Revcom
2011-07-22
Revcom approval
September 2011
Publication
September 2011
Report
Slide 25
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 5/5 of 11/0468r0 by Guido R. Hiertz (Philips)
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
802.11aa – Robust Audio Video Transport Streaming
Singapore Closing Report
Date: 2011-03-17
Authors:
Name
Affiliation
Address
th
Phone
email
Ganesh.Venkatesan@intel
.com
aashley@nds.com
Ganesh Venkatesan
Intel Corporation
JF3-336 2111NE 25 Ave
+1 503 334 6720
Alex Ashley
NDS Ltd
One London Road, Staines,
Middlesex, TW18 4EX,
England
+44 1784 848770
Report
Slide 26
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1/6 of 11/0430r0 by Ganesh Venkatesan, Intel Corporation et al
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Technical Presentations
Document number
Title
1
11/288r0, 11/289r0
SCS Comment Resolutions
Alex Ashley
2
11/300r0
GCR Comment Resolutions
Alex Ashley
3
11/324r2
Interworking Comment Resolutions
4
11/283r0
Editorial Comment Resolutions
Alex Ashley
5
11/360r0
OBSS-MLME Comment Resolutions
Alex Ashley
7
11/292r0, 11/293r2,
11/294r0
Support for GCR coded BA using
Overlay FEC
8
11/168r2
Joint Meeting with 802.1AVB
9
11/426r0
CID #2096 resolution
Report
Author(s)
Ganesh Venkatesan
Jochen Miroll
Ganesh Venkatesan
Qi Wang
Slide 27
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 2/6 of 11/0430r0 by Ganesh Venkatesan, Intel Corporation et al
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
LB174 Comment Resolution Status
unresolved
Accept
Principle
Declined
Total
Approved_Editor
0
168
28
15
211
Approved_GCR
0
11
68
18
97
Approved_General
0
16
5
4
4
2
10
Approved_Interworki
ng
21
Approved_OBSS
0
19
33
5
57
Approved_SCS
0
7
13
5
25
Total
0
225
151
45
421
Completed %
Report
100%
Slide 28
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 3/6 of 11/0430r0 by Ganesh Venkatesan, Intel Corporation et al
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Joint Meeting with 802.1AVB
1. QoS Maintenance Reports
•
Are there additional statistics that are not covered by
802.11k/v?
2. Overview of .11aa features
3. MaxRes (not in scope for .11aa)
•
•
•
what would be the default bandwidth value (25% of
the potential bandwidth?)
what would be min link latency (20ms, 100ms,
seconds?)
MaxRes is described in 802.1BA and in P1722
4. STA-Bridge Issue (not in scope for .11aa):
•
Report
An ad hoc group (of 802.11/802.1AVB) that will create
a presentation on the STA-Bridge problem and bring
it to WNG
Slide 29
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 4/6 of 11/0430r0 by Ganesh Venkatesan, Intel Corporation et al
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Teleconferences
Weekly Monday 1130-1230 Hrs ET
Mar 28, Apr 04, 11, 18 2011
Report
Slide 30
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 5/6 of 11/0430r0 by Ganesh Venkatesan, Intel Corporation et al
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Plans for May 2011 meeting
•
•
•
Report
Resolve Recirculation 3 LB Comments
Complete Draft5.0 and start recirculation
Form Sponsor Pool
Slide 31
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 6/6 of 11/0430r0 by Ganesh Venkatesan, Intel Corporation et al
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
TGac March 2011 Closing Report
Date: 2011-03-17
Authors:
Name
Affiliations
Address
Phone
email
Osama Aboul-Magd
Samsung Electronics
75 W. Plumeria Drive
San Jose, CA 95134
408-544-5870
Osama.magd@samsung.c
om
Report
Slide 32
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1/6 of 11/0463r1 by Osama Aboul-Magd (Samsung)
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Abstract
This document is the closing report for the TGac for the
March 2011 session.
Report
Slide 33
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 2/6 of 11/0463r1 by Osama Aboul-Magd (Samsung)
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Work Completed
Comment Type
Received
Approved
Resolutions
Editorial
1000
Assigned to the
Editor
Technical
814
232
• Resolutions were approved for 232 (28.5%) technical
comments.
• Resolutions were discussed for many other comments and
approvals were deferred for further review
• New revision of the draft (D0.3) will include approved
resolutions.
• Comments spreadsheet is available in 11-11-0276r6
• Meeting Minutes are available in 11-11-461r0.
• Agenda is available in 11-11-290r4.
Report
Slide 34
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 3/6 of 11/0463r1 by Osama Aboul-Magd (Samsung)
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
March 2011 Goals
• Continue with Draft D0.1 comments resolution.
• Prepare TG draft D1.0
• Start WG Letter Ballot
Report
Slide 35
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 4/6 of 11/0463r1 by Osama Aboul-Magd (Samsung)
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
TG Ad Hoc Meeting in May
• Request the WG to approve an ad hoc meeting of TGac
in the Bay Area, California on May 3-5, 2011 to
advance the TGac draft prior to the May IEEE 802
Wireless Interim.
Report
Slide 36
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 5/6 of 11/0463r1 by Osama Aboul-Magd (Samsung)
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Conference Call Times
• March 31 , April 14 , April 28 ,
– 20:00 – 22:00 ET
• April 7 , April 21
– 10:00 – 12:00 ET
Report
Slide 37
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 6/6 of 11/0463r1 by Osama Aboul-Magd (Samsung)
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
TGad March 2011 Closing Report
Date: 2011-03-17
Authors:
Name
Eldad Perahia
Report
Company
Address
Phone
email
Intel
Corporation
2111 NE 25th Ave
Hillsboro, OR 97124
503-712-8081
eldad.perahia@intel.com
Slide 38
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1/5 of 11/0331r0 by Eldad Perahia, Intel Corporation
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Abstract
This document is the closing report for TGad for the
March 2011 session.
Report
Slide 39
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 2/5 of 11/0331r0 by Eldad Perahia, Intel Corporation
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Work Completed
• Resolved all comments on LB 168 this week
• TG and WG approved motion for recirculation letter
ballot on D2.0
– D2.0 is in the members area
• Provided comments to WG on 802.15 PSC PAR & 5C’s
Report
Slide 40
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 3/5 of 11/0331r0 by Eldad Perahia, Intel Corporation
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Goals for May 2011
• Comment resolution on D2.0
Report
Slide 41
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 4/5 of 11/0331r0 by Eldad Perahia, Intel Corporation
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Conference call times
• Previously approved
conference calls
– Mar 31, Apr 14
• 10:00 – 12:00 ET
– Mar 24, Apr 7
• 20:00-22:00 ET
Report
• New conference calls
– Not overlap with TGac
– Apr 28, May 5, May 26, Jun 9
• 10:00 – 12:00 ET
– Apr 21, May 19, Jun 2, Jun 16
• 20:00-22:00 ET
Slide 42
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 5/5 of 11/0331r0 by Eldad Perahia, Intel Corporation
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
TGae Closing Report – March 2011
Date: 2011-03-17
Authors:
Name
Affiliations
Address
Phone
email
Michael Montemurro
Research in Motion
4701 Tahoe Blvd.
Mississauga, ON. Canada.
L4W 0B4
+1-905-629-4746
mmontemurro@rim.com
Report
Slide 43
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1/5 of 11/0466r0 by Michael Montemurro, Research In Motion
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Abstract
This document is the closing report for the TGae Task
Group for the March 2011 session.
Report
Slide 44
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 2/5 of 11/0466r0 by Michael Montemurro, Research In Motion
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Work Completed
• Matthew Fischer has agreed to become TG Secretary.
• Completed Comment Resolution for LB 172
– https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/11/11-11-0255-03-00ae-tgae-lb-172-commentresolutions.xls
• Motion to approve recirculation LB
• Teleconferences:
– Wednesday Apr 20, 27 and May 4, at 11am ET for 1 hour.
Report
Slide 45
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 3/5 of 11/0466r0 by Michael Montemurro, Research In Motion
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
TGae Timeline – March 2011
• Initial Working Group Letter Ballot: September ‘10
• Re-circulation Working Group Letter Ballot: January
‘11
• Form Sponsor Ballot Pool: May ’11
• Mandatory Editorial Check: May ’11
• Initial Sponsor Ballot: July ’11
• Sponsor Ballot Recirculation: Sep ‘11
• Final WG/EC Approval: Nov ‘11
• RevCom/Standards Board Approval: March ‘12
Report
Slide 46
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 4/5 of 11/0466r0 by Michael Montemurro, Research In Motion
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
May 2011 Goals
• Find Secretary for TGae
• Resolve comments from recirculation LB on D3.0
• Prepare for recirculation letter ballot
Report
Slide 47
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 5/5 of 11/0466r0 by Michael Montemurro, Research In Motion
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
IEEE 802.11 TGaf
Singapore Closing Report
Date: 2011-03-18
Authors:
Name
Rich Kennedy
Peter Ecclesine
Report
Affiliations
Address
Phone
Research In
Motion
Cisco Systems
7305 Napier Trail
+1-972-207-3554
Austin, TX 78729
170 W. Tasman Dr., +1-408-527-0815
San Jose, CA 95134
email
rikennedy@rim.com
petere@cisco.com
Slide 48
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1/7 of 11/0455r1 by Rich Kennedy, Research In Motion
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Abstract
This presentation is the closing report for the ninth faceto-face meeting of IEEE 802.11 TGaf taking place the
week of March 14, 2011 at the IEEE 802 Plenary in
Singapore.
Report
Slide 49
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 2/7 of 11/0455r1 by Rich Kennedy, Research In Motion
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Agenda
• Review the results of LB171
• Approve the LB171 comment spreadsheet in 11-11/277r3
• Review FCC database administrators workshop presentation in
https://mentor.ieee.org/802.18/dcn/11/18-11-0029-00-0000-fcc-tvbands-administrator-workshop.pdf
• Review Andy Gowans presentation on D1.0 and the Ofcom DD
plan
• Comment resolution
• Plan for May meeting, including an ad hoc the week prior, and
teleconferences
Report
Slide 50
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 3/7 of 11/0455r1 by Rich Kennedy, Research In Motion
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
TGaf Accomplishments
• Reviewed results of LB 171
• Began Comment resolution
• Planned for May ad hoc, and extended weekly
teleconferences to 3 hours
– Still begin Tuesdays at 22:00 ET
Report
Slide 51
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 4/7 of 11/0455r1 by Rich Kennedy, Research In Motion
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
TGaf Timeline – Updated March 2011
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Report
New
Initial Working Group Letter Ballot: January 2011
Second Working Group Letter Ballot: May 2011
Recirculation Letter Ballot: July 2011
Form Sponsor Ballot Pool: February 2012
Initial Sponsor Ballot: March 2012
Recirculate Sponsor Ballot: May 2012
Final WG/EC Approval: July 2012
RevCom/Standards Board Approval: September 2012
Slide 52
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 5/7 of 11/0455r1 by Rich Kennedy, Research In Motion
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Plans for May
• Ad hoc May 4 - 6 in the Bay Area
• Continue comment resolution
Report
Slide 53
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 6/7 of 11/0455r1 by Rich Kennedy, Research In Motion
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Teleconferences
• Weekly on Tuesdays:
• Time: 22:00 ET for 180 minutes
Report
Slide 54
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 7/7 of 11/0455r1 by Rich Kennedy, Research In Motion
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
IEEE 802.11ah Closing Report for
March 2011
Date: 2011-3-17
Authors:
Name
David Halasz
Report
Affiliations
Aclara
Address
th
2315 W. 9 Street
Austin, TX 78703
Phone
email
330-283-2715
dave.halasz@oaktreewirel
ess.com
Slide 55
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1/4 of 11/0460r0 by David Halasz, OakTree Wireless
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Activity in TGah
• Adopted 11/239r2 as TGah Selection Procedure
– Use Case, Channel Model, Requirements and Specification
framework documents are required
•
•
•
•
Use Case and Channel model submissions made
Adopted initial Use Cases document, see 11/457
Update timeline, see 11/285r0
Additional leadership roles
– Minho Cheong to Chair Ad Hoc Requirements Group
– Minyoung Park To Chair Ad Hoc Specification Framework Group
Report
Slide 56
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 2/4 of 11/0460r0 by David Halasz, OakTree Wireless
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Going forward
• Start on requirements and specification framework
documents
• Follow up on required guiding documents
Report
Slide 57
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 3/4 of 11/0460r0 by David Halasz, OakTree Wireless
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Teleconferences
•
•
•
•
•
•
Report
March 28, 21:30 US ET, 1.5 hours
April 4, 21:30 US ET, 1.5 hours
April 11, 21:30 US ET, 1.5 hours
April 18, 21:30 US ET, 1.5 hours
April 25, 21:30 US ET, 1.5 hours
May 2, 21:30 US ET, 1.5 hours
Slide 58
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 4/4 of 11/0460r0 by David Halasz, OakTree Wireless
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
IEEE 802.11TGai
Closing Report
Date: 2011-03-17
Authors:
Name
Company Address
Phone
email
Hiroshi MANO
ROOT Inc.
8F TOC2 Bldg. 7-21-11 NishiGotanda, Shinagawa-ku, Tokyo
141-0031 JAPAN
+81-3-5719-7630
hmano@root-hq.com
Marc Emmelmann
Fraunhofer
FOKUS
Fraunhofer FOKUS
Kaiserin-Augusta-Alle 31
10589 Berlin
Germany
+49-30-3463
7268
emmelmann@ieee.org
Report
Slide 59
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1/13 of 11/0464r0 by Hiroshi Mano (Root Inc.)
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Abstract
This presentation is the closing report for the Singapore
meeting of the IEEE 802.11 TGai.
Report
Slide 60
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 2/13 of 11/0464r0 by Hiroshi Mano (Root Inc.)
February
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Agenda for this week
March 2011, Singapore
• Official agenda of WG
–
–
–
–
Monday PM1
Tuesday PM1, EVE
Wednesday AM1,AM2
Thursday PM1
• Goals for the Meeting:
– Review and Approve the Los Angels and Teleconference meeting
minutes
– Presentation of submissions
• Draft use case scenario documentation
– TIME line of task group
– Plan for May & Teleconference
Report
Slide 61
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 3/13 of 11/0464r0 by Hiroshi Mano , Root Inc
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Accomplishments TGai 1/3
• Submission of Presentation
– 0357/00 A focused path forwad Tgai D1.0
– 0334/00 TGai scope discussion (A. Yamada/ NTT Docomo)
– 0326/00 Use-Case-Reference-List-doc discussion (Tom Siep /
CSR)
– 0148/06 Use cases for TGai Lee Armstrong (US DoT)
– 0281/00 Proposed Dynamic Mobility Use Cases for TGai (Carl
Kain / Nobils)
– 0333/00 TGai possible use cases (A. Yamada/ NTT Docomo)
– 0337/00 discussion-points-on-portal-locations (Dwight Smith
,Motorola Mobility)
– 0356/01 Selection Procedure for TGai (Y. Nagai Mitsubishi
Electric)
Report
Slide 62
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 4/13 of 11/0464r0 by Hiroshi Mano (Root Inc.)
March 2011
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Accomplishments TGai 2/3
• Submission of Presentation
–
–
–
–
0343/00 Pedestrian model (Hitoshi Morioka, Root Inc.)
0408/00 Use Case Characteristics discussion (Tom Siep / CSR)
0238/04 Use Case Documentation (Tom Siep /CSR)
0435/00 Definition of terminology from 802.11.2 (Marc Emmelman
/Fokus)
– 0408/01 Use Case Characteristics discussion (Tom Siep / CSR)
– 0441/00 Self growing use cases requiring fast link set up (Marc
Emmelman Fokus)
– 0238/05 Use Case Documentation (Tom Siep /CSR)
Report
Slide 63
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 5/13 of 11/0464r0 by Hiroshi Mano (Root Inc.)
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Accomplishments 3/3 TGai
• Reviewed and Approved the Los Angels and
Teleconference meeting minutes
• Drafting Use Case Scenario documentation
– Approve the terms and definitions in 11-11/0408r2 as official TGai
terminology.
– Approve the values of high/medium/low given for each definition as
in the 11-11/0408r2.
• Approved Weekly Teleconference schedule
• Approved Plan for May
– Finish the use case scenario
– Finish the functional requirement
– Finish the technical requirement
Report
Slide 64
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 6/13 of 11/0464r0 by Hiroshi Mano (Root Inc.)
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Motion:
• Motion: Approve the terms and definitions in 1111/0408r2 as official TGai terminology.
•
•
•
•
Report
Moved :Tom Siep (CSR)
Second: Lee Armstrong (US DOT)
Result 14-0-1
Passed
Slide 65
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 7/13 of 11/0464r0 by Tom Siep, CSR
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Motion:
• Motion: Approve the values of high/medium/low given
for each definition as in the 11-11/0408r2.
•
•
•
•
Report
Moved :Tom Siep (CSR)
Second: Lee Armstrong (US DOT)
Result 10-0-3
Passed
Slide 66
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 8/13 of 11/0464r0 by Tom Siep, CSR
March 2011
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Teleconference Schedule
• Motion:
–
–
–
–
–
Approve the following schedule of weekly teleconferences.
Tuesdays 08:00 EST (NY Time) continue until 29th Mar.
Tuesdays 09:00 EST (NY Time) start from 5th Apr.
Duration 1Hour
Using WEB-EX that will be provided by Task Group Chair
• Moved: Marc Emmelmann ( Fokus ), Seconded: Dwight
Smith (Motorola Mobility)
• Result: 14-0-3
• Motion passed
Report
Slide 67
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 9/13 of 11/0464r0 by Hiroshi Mano (Root Inc.)
March 2011
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Time line of TGai to draft 1.0
•
•
•
•
•
•
Use case scenario finished
May 2011
Functional Requirement
May 2011
Technical Requirement finished
May 2011
Call for Proposal start
May 2011
Proposal submission close
Jul 2011
Evaluation and down selection proposal, Jul11 to Sep 11
Report
Slide 68
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 10/13 of 11/0464r0 by Hiroshi Mano (Root Inc.)
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Time line of TGai
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
WG Letter Ballots Initial / Recirc
Sep 11 / Jan 12
Form Sponsor Ballot Pool / Reform
Jul 12
MEC Done
Jul 12
IEEE-SA Sponsor Ballots Initial / Recirc
Sep 12 / Dec 12
Final 802.11 WG Approval
Jul 13
Final or Conditional 802 EC Approval
Jul 13
RevCom & Standards Board Final or Continuous Process Approval Sep 13
ANSI Approved
N/A
Report
Slide 69
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 11/13 of 11/0464r0 by Hiroshi Mano (Root Inc.)
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Documents
• Approved Minutes
– 11-11-0115-01-00ai-tgai-meeting-minutes-for-the-ieee-802-11january-2011-interim.doc
– 11-11-0213-06-00ai-january-march-teleconference-minutes.doc
Report
Slide 70
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 12/13 of 11/0464r0 by Hiroshi Mano (Root Inc.)
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Thanks to all who participated!
Report
Slide 71
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 13/13 of 11/0464r0 by Hiroshi Mano (Root Inc.)
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
JTC1 ad hoc closing report (March 11)
Date: 2011-3-11
Authors:
Name
Andrew Myles
Report
Company
Address
Phone
Cisco
email
andrew.myles@cisco.con
Slide 72
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1/9 of 11/0467r0 by Andrew Myles, Cisco
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Abstract
Closing report for JTC1 ad hoc
for March 2011, Singapore
Report
Slide 73
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 2/9 of 11/0467r0 by Andrew Myles, Cisco
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
JTC1 ad hoc generated a number of
liaisons in Mar 2011
• Progress in Singapore (March 2011)
– Review extended goals
• The ad hoc is now responsible for 802 matters
– Review status of liaisons previously sent to SC6
• No comments on any Sponsor Ballot drafts
– Discuss identifier conflict liaison previously sent to SC6
• Considered responses from Chinese and Swiss NBs
• Developed liaison offering a new IE and two new status codes
– Update on status of ISO/IEC 8802-11:2005
• Likely to be reconfirmed based on ballot
– Update on status of ISO/IEC 8802-3:2000
• Likely to withdrawn based on liaison from IEEE 802.3
Report
Slide 74
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 3/9 of 11/0467r0 by Andrew Myles, Cisco
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
JTC1 ad hoc generated a number of
liaisons in Mar 2011
• Progress in Singapore (March 2011)
– Update on WAPI progress
• Late breaking news: IEEE 802 comments objecting to claims that
IEEE 802.11i is insecure have been rejected as irrelevant in proposed
comment disposition submission. Similar comments from US NB also
rejected.
– Discuss a proposed 802.1X/AE related liaison
• Developed liaison inviting SC6 members to attend 802.1 WG in July,
and included analysis on proposed NP for replacement of .1X/AE
• Was discussed in 802.1 closing plenary
– Approve delegation for next SC6 meeting
• Recommended Bruce Kraemer be appointed head of delegation
• Bruce authorised to select other candidates
Report
Slide 75
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 4/9 of 11/0467r0 by Andrew Myles, Cisco
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
JTC1 ad hoc will prepare for more liaisons
out of Singapore meeting
• Plans for Palm Springs (May 2011)
–
–
–
–
Prepare ppt versions of recent liaisons to SC6
Develop liaison on proposed .11 replacement NP
Possibly develop liaison on proposed .16 security replacement NP
Review latest response to liaison related to security of IEEE
802.11i
– Confirm delegation to SC6
• Likely to include 802.11, 802.1 and maybe 802.16 members
Report
Slide 76
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 5/9 of 11/0467r0 by Andrew Myles, Cisco
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Motion to appoint HoD to SC6 meeting
• The JTC1 ad hoc unanimously approved a motion to
appoint HoD to SC6 meeting
– The IEEE 802 JTC1 ad hoc recommends to IEEE 802 ExCom that
Bruce Kraemer be appointed Head of Delegation of the IEEE 802
delegation to the SC6 meeting in San Diego in June 2011. The ad
hoc also recommends that as Head of Delegation that he have the
authority to add other interested parties to the delegation
• IEEE 802.11 WG should consider an equivalent motion
– The IEEE 802.11 WG recommends to IEEE 802 ExCom that
Bruce Kraemer be appointed Head of Delegation of the IEEE 802
delegation to the SC6 meeting in San Diego in June 2011. The
WG also recommends that as Head of Delegation that he have the
authority to add other interested parties to the delegation
Report
Slide 77
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 6/9 of 11/0467r0 by Andrew Myles, Cisco
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Motion to allocate an IE identifier and two
status codes
• The JTC1 ad hoc unanimously approved a motion to
allocate an IE identifier and two status codes
– The IEEE 802 JTC1 ad hoc recommends to the IEEE 802.11 ANA
that two status codes and an IE identifier be allocated for use by
ISO/IEC JTC1/SC6/WG1 in the proposed WAPI standard
• IEEE 802.11 WG should consider an equivalent motion
– The IEEE 802.11 WG approves the IEEE 802.11 ANA allocating
two status codes and an IE identifier for use by ISO/IEC
JTC1/SC6/WG1 in the proposed WAPI standard
Report
Slide 78
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 7/9 of 11/0467r0 by Andrew Myles, Cisco
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Motion for identifier conflict liaison to SC6
• The JTC1 ad hoc unanimously approved a motion for a
liaison to SC6 in relation to the identifier conflict issue
– The IEEE 802 JTC1 ad hoc recommends to the IEEE 802.11 WG,
IEEE 802 ExCom and IEEE International ad hoc that:
• The content of 11-11-404r0 be sent to ISO/IEC JTC1/SC6 with an
appropriate cover letter
• Bruce Kraemer be given authority to make editorial changes, including
the insertion of allocated ANA values
• IEEE 802.11 WG should consider an equivalent motion
– IEEE 802.11 WG recommends to IEEE 802 ExCom and IEEE
International ad hoc that:
• The content of 11-11-404r0 be sent to ISO/IEC JTC1/SC6 with an
appropriate cover letter
• Bruce Kraemer be given authority to make editorial changes, including
the insertion of allocated ANA values
Report
Slide 79
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 8/9 of 11/0467r0 by Andrew Myles, Cisco
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Motion for 1X/1AE liaison to SC6
• The JTC1 ad hoc unanimously approved a motion for a
liaison to SC6 in relation to 1X/1AE
– The IEEE 802 JTC1 ad hoc recommends to the IEEE 802.11 WG,
IEEE 802 ExCom and IEEE International ad hoc that:
• The content of 11-11-442r1 be sent to ISO/IEC JTC1/SC6 with an
appropriate cover letter
• Paul Nikolich be given authority to make editorial changes
• IEEE 802.11 WG should consider an equivalent motion
– The IEEE 802.11 WG recommends to IEEE 802 ExCom and IEEE
International ad hoc that:
• The content of 11-11-442r1 be sent to ISO/IEC JTC1/SC6 with an
appropriate cover letter
• Paul Nikolich be given authority to make editorial changes
Report
Slide 80
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 9/9 of 11/0467r0 by Andrew Myles, Cisco
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
IEEE 802.11
Regulatory Ad Hoc Committee
Closing Report
Date: 2011-03-18
Authors:
Name
Rich Kennedy
Report
Affiliations
Address
Phone
email
Research In
Motion
7305 Napier Trail
Austin, TX 78729
+1-972-207-3554
rikennedy@rim.com
Slide 81
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1/4 of 11/0456r0 by Rich Kennedy, Research In Motion
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Abstract
This presentation is the closing report for the Singapore
2011 meeting of the IEEE 802.11 Regulatory Ad Hoc
Committee.
Report
Slide 82
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 2/4 of 11/0456r0 by Rich Kennedy, Research In Motion
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Agenda
• The regulatory summaries
• Regulatory issues status
– The end of FCC 10-174
– FCC 5 GHz rules changes update
• Critical issues actions
– Coming regulations for mobile hoptspots
Report
Slide 83
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 3/4 of 11/0456r0 by Rich Kennedy, Research In Motion
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Regulatory AHC Activities
• Discussed regulatory summaries from North
America and the EU
– FCC 10-174 is now the final rules for the TVWS untill
a new rulemaking
• Reviewed Ofcom document about TVWS issues
in the UK and EU
Report
Slide 84
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 4/4 of 11/0456r0 by Rich Kennedy, Research In Motion
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Smart Grid ad hoc – March 2011
Name
Company
Address
Phone
email
Bruce Kraemer
Marvell
5488 Marvell Lane,
Santa Clara, CA, 95054
+1-321-751-3988
bkraemer@marvell.com
Date: 15 March 2011
Report
Slide 85
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1/3 of 11/0469r0 by Bruce Kraemer, Marvell
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Smart Grid – March 2011
Tuesday & Thursday topics
• UK Consultation
• Update of activities in P2030
• IEEE Smart Grid
• FERC
• Australian Smart Metering RFI
• Revision NIST Smart Grid PAP#2 Report plan
• Open SG
• ITU-R paper - WP1A document
Report
Slide 86
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 2/3 of 11/0469r0 by Bruce Kraemer, Marvell
March2011
doc.: IEEE 802.11-11/0471r1
Deliverables
Paper & Matrix
1. Identify and fully define all necessary terminology (mesh, etc.)
2. Come up with sane metric definitions for Section 4
3. Come up with guidelines for filling out the wireless technologies matrix to
make sure entries are comparable across technologies
– This includes a selection of high priority, fully described “operating
points” representing deployment scenarios
4. Come up with dates for submissions for column entries for the matrix
and appoint coordinators for each technology represented in the matrix
5. Submit results to the PAP2 reflector and announce a comment period
6. Directly solicit SDO participation and schedule SDO calls to discuss
submissions and comments on all of the above – Bluetooth,
7. Discuss & adjust the deliverables content using OpenSG as the venue and
a proxy for the utility industry
8. Completion target: July? December?
9. Assessment of industry practices in deployment
Report
Slide 87
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 3/3 of 11/0469r0 by Bruce Kraemer, Marvell