PEARL ACADEMY OF FASHION Integrated Project Brand Extension of Koutons Retail India Ltd. Shavy Arora 11/28/2011 AUTHORIZATION LETTER This report is submitted as partial fulfilment of the requirement of PG Fashion Marketing, Pearl Academy of Fashion, Naraina. The report on the title “Integrated Project“ is an original work and has not been submitted to any other institution or university for the award of any degree or diploma. Place: Delhi-Naraina Date: April 20, 2010 SHAVY ARORA 2 LETTER OF TRANSMITTAL Dear Sir, I am submitting the report, due NOVEMBER 28, 2011, that you requested. The report is entitled Integrated Project. The purpose of the report is to inform you of the current scenario of Koutons brand and its market, problems and need gap and a business plan Koutons for entering into Fashion accessories market. The content of this report concentrates on the holistic study of the apparel and accessories market in perspective of models such as Porter’s 5 Force Model, SWOT analysis etc., thus gain a multidimensional insight of the fashion industry. I hope that this report will merit your approval. Yours truly, Pearl Academy of Fashion Student Shavy Arora 3 ACKNOWLEDGEMENT I would like to take this opportunity to express my gratitude and respect to all those who helped me through the duration of this project report. The pearl academy in particular has been the source of inspiration for me. I acknowledge the effort of those who have contributed significantly to my project. I would also want to thank my friends Pallavi Laroiya and Astha Tewary who helped me during my project. I also thank the staff of Koutons stores in Delhi for providing me whatever information they could under the laws of their company. I feel privileged to offer my sincere thanks and deep sense of gratitude to my faculty for providing their support, help and encouragement in implementing this project report. Their skilful teaching, precious suggestions and motivation added to the success of this project. I thereby take this opportunity to express my gratitude to my teachers; Mr. Rahul Jain, Mrs. Priyanka Aggarwal, Mrs. Anjuna Dhir, Mrs. Meha Jaiswal, Mr. Rajesh Kochhar and Mr. Ramesh Tahiliani for their valuable suggestions and support in helping this project take shape. 4 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The Indian retail market size is estimated at US$ 427 bn. Koutons Retail India comes under India’s top 50 apparel companies. It had a Market capitalization Rs. 3000 crores in 2008 and of Rs.70.73 crores in 2011. It generated 2.0% of aggregate sector revenue of the country in 2010 which was Rs.59, 336 crores. Koutons has had a profitable past. Unlike in FY 2010-11, when its stock prices declined, huge debts mounted and the sales have started drying up. Also, the popularity of other discount outlets of established brands and the quality issues of Koutons have paved the way for the downside for the brand. To do away with all the losses and negative image, Koutons may enter into a new market targeting a new set of customers. The fashion accessories market is an untapped segment with not many players in it. The market has a growth rate of 28-30% per annum. It could be a great opportunity for Koutons and give a new direction to the company. The main idea is to launch a new brand DIVA, under Koutons that deals with women’s fashion accessories. DIVA would be a sub brand under Koutons. It shall have its individual stores in tier II and tier III cities mainly. The brand would continue to focus on the middle income group of people. Unlike, the rest of its brands, this new brand will not follow any year long discounting strategy. As per the projected financial plan, the company requires to make an initial investment of Rs. 4,83,94,080 to open 18 exclusive stores of DIVA around the country. Out of this amount, 20% will be taken on loan. The sales for the 1st year are estimated to be Rs. 12,31,20,000 leading to a net loss Rs. 87,18,153. This loss will be covered up in the 2nd year by generating sales of Rs. 59,28,00,000 with additional 34 stores around the country. The net profit estimated for 2nd year is Rs. 9,07,88,442. 5 TABLE OF CONTENTS S.NO. 1 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 2 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 3 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 4 4.1 4.2 4.3 TOPIC CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION Description of project About the brand Problems with Koutons Idea generation Objectives Limitations Data collection and analysis tools CHAPTER 2 PROJECT OVERVIEW AND STRATEGY Summary sheet Strategy Project Scoping Form Work Breakdown Structure Network Charts 5Q's CHAPTER 3 ENVIRONMENT ANALYSIS Market Analysis PEST Analysis Porter's 5 forces SWOT Analysis Competitor Analysis CHAPTER 4 MARKETING PLAN Koutons - Brand Portfolio Koutons - Promotions Ad Analysis PAGE NO. 10 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 19 21 22 23 24 26 30 32 36 40 41 42 6 4.4 4.5 4.6 4.7 4.8 4.9 4.1 4.11 4.12 4.13 4.14 4.15 4.16 4.17 4.18 5 5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 6 6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 6.6 6.7 Brand Audit DIVA Brand Elements DIVA’s Customer Segmentation Consumer DILO Consumer Behaviour Perceptual Mapping Product Mix and Pricing Design Styles Strategy Promotions Media Plan Promotional Plan Promtion Exemplars Press Release CHAPTER 5 OPERATIONS AND MANAGEMENT PLAN Distribution Network of DIVA Organisational structure DIVA’s presence in India City Wise Matrix CHAPTER 6 FINANCIAL PLAN Resource List Expenses for the 3 years Initial investments for 3 years Initial investments under different scenarios (1st yr) Projected Income Statement for 3 years Projected Income Statement under different scenarios (1st yr) Financials - graphs 44 46 46 47 48 49 51 51 52 53 54 54 55 57 59 60 61 62 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 7 1 8 9 CHAPTER 7 REFLECTION CHAPTER 8 ANNEXURES CHAPTER 9 REFERENCES 73 74 84 8 Chapter – 1, INTRODUCTION Description of the project: I am a student of Fashion Marketing at Pearl Academy of Fashion. As per the curriculum of our course, an end-term project is to be done a fashion or lifestyle related brand. I, as a marketing consultant, have to provide marketing consultancy to a brand that may not be performing well. It might require some changes in its business model, brand positioning, brand extension, reconstruction, diversification or expansion. The chosen brand for this project is the apparel brand Koutons. The project involves brand extension plan for Koutons by entering into a new market of Fashion Accessories for girls. The brand: The retail market in India is anticipated to grow to 427 billion USD by the year 2011. Koutons Retail India Ltd. is number 29 out of 85 listed other apparels & accessories companies in India with a market capitalization of Rs.64.2 crores. With more than 1400 outlets across India, it has a wide range of apparel designs suited for all segments including corporate, formal and casual dressings. The company was founded by Mr. DPS Kohli. Mr. Kohli and his family owned a television manufacturing business which was destroyed during a riot. Mr. Kohli had to suffer huge financial losses from that even and had to work as an insurance surveyor for long. Later he ventured into the retail textile business. Koutons grew really fast. The company became India's largest retail apparel chain in a span of 10 years. In 2009, the company had around 1400 Exclusive Brand Outlets [EBO] making it the largest apparel chain. [1] 9 Problems with Koutons: Koutons has had a profitable past. Unlike in FY 2010-11, when it was hit by a sharp spurt in the pledging of promoter shares, a decline in the company’s stock prices, facing mounting debt and bad press regarding the financial position. The sales have started drying up and the cost and inventory started building up. Also, the popularity of other discount outlets of established brands and the quality issues of Koutons have paved the way for the downside for the brand. It lacks the glamour of brand-building and this will eventually kill the brand. The company has also opened up too many stores too soon, and is not closing the non-profitable ones early enough. [2] The failure is as much a failure of marketing innovation, as it is of the brand. Koutons has not changed anything about its strategy in the last decade, and so now, people walk into a Koutons knowing that they are going to get a deep discounted price. They have never seen a section of fine clothing being sold at premium prices, and hence the weariness. Also, there are several other brands like Cantabil who have rented places in the same malls and are following the same strategy. Over the 20 years the brand has build up an image of poor product quality; or rather that is how customers would perceive it. Even to lower middle class, the products do not qualify in terms of quality, design, fabric. There has been an increase in cost due to heavy excise duty that the brand has to pay from 2011 onwards. Prior to the latest Union Budget for 2011-12, apparels like readymade garments and made-ups were under an optional excise duty regime. In the Union Budget for 2011-12, the optional excise duty levy was changed into a mandatory levy. This will hit Koutons adversely as it will reduce its profit margins to a great extent. [3] Idea generation: 10 The main idea is to launch a new brand under Koutons that deals with women’s fashion accessories. This brand would be a sub brand under Koutons. It shall have its individual stores in tier II and tier III cities mainly, also having some of them in tier I as well. The brand would continue to focus on the middle income group of people. Unlike, the rest of its brands, this new brand will not follow any year long discounting strategy. But rather have low prices for its products. The fashion accessories market is an untapped segment with not many players in it. The market has a growth rate of 28-30% per annum. It could be a great opportunity for Koutons and give a new direction to the company. Scope: The research done for the project is mainly in Delhi NCR region. It is on the basis of primary and secondary research done in the last four months. The primary research includes surveys at Koutons stores and its competitors and various accessories stores around Delhi. It was done through in-depth interviews, informal interviews and questionnaire surveys with loyal customers of Koutons. Another questionnaire was filled by girls of age group 18 t0 26 years who belong to middle income group. Various tools have been used to analyse the environment. These include tools such as PEST analysis; Porter’s five forces, SWOT analysis and competitor analysis have been done to study the marketing environment in depth and form strategies accordingly. Brand audit has also been done to study the customers’ perception about the brand Koutons. Objectives: 11 The main objective is to achieve higher sales and earn profits. For achieving this, the brand needs create its identity and an image in the minds of its customers. It also needs to position itself strongly in comparison with the existing players in the market. It needs to face the challenges coming in the market with the limited resources available. It needs to ensure quick inventory turnover avoiding the risk of obsolesces in its stock. It also needs to maintain systematic records of all resources and protect materials from losses and damages. The brand should focus on minimising the cost and optimising its resources. It should also ensure an effective and efficient supply chain. It must provide to its customers, what it promises in terms of design quality and price. 12 Limitation: The project undertaken is majorly a reflection of the class room knowledge and might lack practicality when the application is concerned. The secondary data relies on internet also containing personal views and opinions of people which may be biased towards the company or totally against it. Tastes and preferences of customers keep changing with the change in time. Thus, judgement can’t be made on their future likings and actions. A lot of secondary information is also procured from the customers of the brand who may or may not be honest while giving their opinions Our knowledge is restricted to a certain level and may not be up to the standards of an actual marketing consultant of a brand. It may even seem outdated at the time of its application. Market Research is a very broad concept, so it may not be possible to collect all the relevant information within a given time constraint. 13 Data collection and analysis tool: Secondary research: The initial research shall begin from the secondary sources such as books, journals, magazines, reports, publications, internet, articles, etc. Secondary research is on the basis of data that is already available in general. It may be collected and analysed by someone else for some other purpose. For this particular project, various websites on internet shall be referred which may include the company’s website, competitors website, related articles on internet. Books such as ‘The Marketing Whitebook’ shall be referred to get reliable statistical figures. Also, articles and journals of other brands and their different strategies shall be studied. Primary research: After the general information and statistics is available from the secondary sources, primary research takes place. The data may be collected individually in form of questionnaires, interviews, group interviews, etc, from a selected reliable set of respondents. It is entirely a personal approach for a specific purpose. To get the most reliable information, brand audit shall be done in the form of questionnaire surveys from the most loyal customers of the brand. Various customers using that brand shall be personally contacted. Also, personal meetings with some of the company’s executives or officials may provide with useful knowledge. 14 Chapter – 2, PROJECT OVERVIEW AND STRATEGY Summary Sheet: Name of Company Location Product Description USP Name of Competitors Number of EBO Number of MBO Number of Employees Average Product Cost Average Price Average Retail Margin Sales COGS PAT Growth in Sales Growth in PAT Initial Investment Fixed Asset Details Machinery Land & Building Other Assets Furniture DIVA BY Koutons 18 cities in India Fashion accessories Fashionable products at reasonable prices Big Bazaar & Reliance trends Year 1 18 0 100 Rs. 100 Rs. 200 50% 12,31,20,000 6,15,60,000 -87,18,153 Year 2 34 0 236 Year 3 26 0 340 4,83,94,080 Rs. 300 50% 59,28,00,000 29,64,00,000 9,07,88,442 381.48% -1141.37% 15,87,31,753 Rs. 400 50% 1,06,70,40,000 53,35,20,000 14,40,69,822 80.00% 58.69% 29,09,60,000 6,00,000 N.a (Rented) 1,56,00,000 93,00,000 2,55,00,000 10,00,000 N.a (Rented) 18,36,000 1,53,00,000 1,81,36,000 8,00,000 N.a (Rented) 14,04,000 1,17,00,000 1,39,04,000 15 Strategies: Pricing Penetration Strategy • The product prices will be at par with its competitors in the 1st year but gradually increase with coming years. Psychological Pricing Strategy • The prices of the products of DIVA end with the odd no. 9. example: Rs. 299. Product Centric Strategy • The selling strategy adopted by Diva will be focusing on its product's quality and giving value for money to the customer. Intensive Distribution Strategy • In the 1st year, 18 stores of DIVA will be opened in North and South Zone of India. It will further expand in other zones y opening more stores in2nd and 3rd year. Push Strategy • Diva will use various sales promtion tools such as seasonal sales, gift vouchers and student discount during specific periods to promtoe its sales. Pull Strategy • Diva will have an official website to provide information about its products and promotions. It will also advertise through newspapers and Radio to increase its awareness among people. 16 PROJECT SCOPING FORM Project Name: Brand extension for Koutons Retail India Project Manager/T eam Members: Shavy Arora Problem/Opportunity: Financial losses to the company further due to implication of heavy excise duty. Failure of marketing innovation Opportunity to tap a new market segment Project Goal: To develop extension strategies for Koutons Retail India Objectives [SMART]: To study history and literature of the brand [since inception] To conduct market survey for suggesting extension strategies and promotional plans to the company To study the buying habits of the customers [existing and potential] To develop a profitable venture plan for the new market 17 Success Criteria [Outcomes]: Managed to meet company officials and loyal consumers of the brand Develop the most profitable strategies for the extended brand Assumptions: Financial assumptions – SPF [Rs. 3000 – industry average] Scenarios [SPF- pessimistic - 30% of Rs.3000, most likely - 50%, optimistic - 75 %] COGS [50% of sales] Working Capital Investment [20% of Sales] Loan [20% of total funds required] Interest on loan [12% of loan] Preliminary expenses for 2nd & 3 rd year 5% of sales Preliminary expenses written off [1/5 of preliminary expenses] Income tax [33.99%] Advertising cost for 1st and 2nd yr [10% of sales] Advertising cost for 3rd yr [7% of sales] Logistics [3% of sales] Sales promotion for 2nd and 3rd yr [1% of sales] Depreciation[40% on comp., 18%on interiors, 13.91% on electronics p.a. Obstacles: Lack of honesty in the respondents surveyed through questionnaires Company officials are not very open about sharing the company information Lack of time due to social events 18 Work Breakdown Structure Activity Description of Activities A Assess Concept B Begin Industrial Analysis C Environmental Analysis D Marketing Plan E Development Plan F Operational & Management Plan G Build Strategies H Forecast Cost & Revenues I Create Financial Plan J Determining Funding Needs K Formulate Suggestions & Recommendations L Compilation & Submission of Project Report 19 WORK BREAKDOWN STRUCTURE Activity A B C D E F G H I J K L Description Assess Concept Begin Industrial Analysis Environmental Analysis Marketing Plan Development Plan Operational & Management Plan Build Strategies Forecast Cost & Revenues Create Financial Plan Determining Funding Needs Formulate Suggestions & Recommendation s Compilation & Submission of Project Report Time variance = {[tpto]/6}2 Tp 6 To Tm 4Tm 10 7 28 Te 7.33 6 10 7 28 7.33 0.44 6 10 15 10 15 20 7 12 17 28 48 68 7.33 12.17 17.17 0.44 0.69 0.69 9 12 10 40 10.17 0.25 10 15 12 48 12.17 0.69 10 15 12 48 12.17 0.69 9 12 10 40 10.17 0.25 6 10 7 28 7.33 0.44 0.44 7.33 6 15 10 7 28 20 17 68 17.17 15 12 127.8 108 9 5 3 Standard Deviation = √∑[variance]2 = 2.49 Z= Due date-Expected date/Std dev. = 2.8 0.44 0.69 6.19 Z is the probability of project completion by a target date. Since it is positive, there are 50% chances that the project will complete on time. 20 Network charts: Calculation for CPM: 1st Path: 1 2 3 5 7 9 10 11 9 10 11 7 + 7 + 17 + 12 + 7 + 7 + 17 = 74 2nd Path: 1 2 3 5 7 7 + 7 + 17 + 10 + 10 + 7 + 17 = 75 [Longest path] Therefore, the project will be completed in maximum 75 days or 11 weeks approximately and it gives of a buffer time of 7 weeks. 21 5 Q’s: 1. What important customer problem/need can you solve? This project is providing affordable fashion accessories for women in an organized format. There lies a need gap for fashion accessories market in the organized sector of India. 2. How are you going to do it? It will be done by opening exclusive accessories stores in various Tier 2 and Tier 3 cities around the country. The brand will be a sub brand of Koutons Retail India Ltd. 3. Who are the customers willing to buy from you? Females in the age group 18 to 25 years and having Rs. 5,000-15,000 monthly disposable income are the target group for this brand. 4. Why can only you provide the solution? Koutons already sells apparel for men, women and children and accessories for men. Since the new brand will be endorsed by Koutons, it will generate trust and confidence in the minds of its existing customers. 5. How can you defend against others? There are very competitors in the organized sector of fashion accessories in India. Thus, by providing quality products at affordable prices to the customers, it can compete against its competitors. 22 Chapter – 3, ENVIRONMENT ANALYSIS Market analysis: Indian Apparel market: Indian Retail Market size [total] 2010: US$ 427 bn/annum Domestic apparel market size – Rs. 1,48,500 crore Discount brands industry - Rs 2,000 crore Organized sector expected to increase at 8-9% by 2012 [4] Kouton’s Market Share: Koutons Retail India is India's 30th largest apparels company. It had a Market capitalization Rs. 3000 crores in 2008 and of Rs.70.73 crores in 2011. Koutons Retail India vs. Other Apparels & Accessories sector: Revenue of Rs1, 206.7 crores [US$255.8 million] 2.0% of aggregate sector revenue of Rs.59, 336 crores; down from 2.9% in the previous year.] [5] It made a net Profit of Rs. 80.3 crores [US$17 million] 5.2% of aggregate sector net profit of Rs1, 549.8 crores; down from 13.7% in the previous year.] EBIT of Rs.208.7 crores [US$44.2 million] 6.9% of aggregate sector EBIT of Rs.3, 006 crores; down from 11.1% in the previous year.] [6] 23 Fashion Accessories Market: The Global accessories market is estimated at USD 16.3 billion. Major raw materials for fashion accessories are derived from Australia, Africa, Russia and Canada. The manufacturing of fashion jewellery largely takes place in China, India, Italy and Turkey. The largest retail markets of fashion accessories are USA, Europe, Far East, Middle East and Asia. In India, Fashion accessories market size is nearly Rs. 10,000 crores. The value of exports of fashion jewellery and accessories is Rs. 886 crores. The growth rate at which this market is growing in India is 2830 percent per annum. [7] Indian Retail Sector is at its inflexion point awaiting multifold growth. The Retail Industry’s Size is presently Rs 1, 44,253 crore out of which the organized sector contributes to a mere 4 percent of the market size. Organized Share of retail sector is expected to increase to 8-9 percent in 2010-11 from 4 percent in 2007. [8] 24 PEST Analysis Political Factors: 1. Implication of Excise duty on apparels: Prior to the latest Union Budget for 2011-12, apparels like readymade garments and made-ups were under an optional excise duty regime. Manufacturers of readymade apparels could opt not to pay excise duty and thereby not claim the Cenvat credit on the inputs used for manufacturing these apparels. In the Union Budget for 2011-12, the optional excise duty levy was changed into a mandatory levy at a unified rate of 10% for branded garments with abatement of 55%. Within the branded garments space, apparel discount brands like Koutons would be the most affected due to the imposition of mandatory excise duty and has the potential to distort their cost structure. The MRPs of discount brands are disproportionately higher than the final sales prices. In addition, discounts are offered throughout the year. Therefore, the implication of excise duty as a percentage of actual realisations is much higher for discounted brands than non-discounted brands. As per ICRA estimates, effective excise duty would work out to 10%-45% for brands offering discounts between 50%-90%. [9] 2. Cheap Labour cost in India: Hourly compensation costs in India are among the lowest when compared with the 36 countries in the BLS [Bureau of Labour Statistics] hourly compensation series. In 2005, India’s average hourly compensation cost for all employees in manufacturing [$0.91] was approximately 3.1 percent of the level seen in the United States [$29.74] when measured in U.S dollars. [10] 25 Social Factors: 1. Value for Money: Consumers are becoming more and more aware about value for money. It’s the price that is the most important factor that comes into consideration while buying something. Shopping experience, ease of making payments, celebrity endorsements, online portals etc. are all secondary to price. 2. Fashion awareness: The awareness of global trends is growing along with the need to look fashionable. Newspapers, magazines, radios and television are spreading fashion awareness in different forms. The youth is also getting attracted from the Bollywood and wants to look stylish and up-to-date. 3. Major population: 70 % of our population is under 35 years of age. Urban population mostly comes from relatively smaller cities. Also, the middle class is growing and forming the major part of the population. 4. Growth of organised retail sector: With the entry of a large no. of domestic and international players the Indian retail sector is growing at a speedy rate. 5. Accessories retailers: The largest retail markets of fashion accessories are USA, Europe, Far East, Middle East and Asia Major raw materials for fashion accessories are derived from Australia, Africa, Russia and Canada. The manufacturing largely takes place in China, India, Italy and Turkey. [11] 26 Economic factors: 1. Increase in cost: Due to a shortage in the supply of raw materials for fashion accessories, there is a steep hike in the prices which has led to a great competition among the countries where polishing for fashion accessories takes place. 2. Rising disposable income: the disposable income of people is rising, also leading to improved lifestyles, increasing international exposure and increasing awareness among the customers. India has a large middle class as well as youth population, which has contributed greatly to the retail phenomenon. The middle class is considered to be a major potential customer group. The youth are perceived as trend setters and decision makers. [12] 3. Financial crisis: Koutons is now facing the worst period of its existence. It is facing mounting debt and bad press regarding the financial position and the stock prices are moving southward. [13] 27 Technological Factors 1. New software and technology: Advances in technology such as artificial diamonds, artificial rubies and sapphires, precision cutting and other refinements have made jewellery more affordable. The technological advances lowered the barriers of entry into jewellery business and this has allowed a stiffer competition to prevail. It has also made owning jewellery more democratic as more people can now afford to buy jewellery. Software such as CAD [computer-aided design] help to lower their production costs. 2. Precious stones and alloys: With the use of laser in welding, formulation of new metal alloys and the invention of precious metal clay have become possible. There are still many applications of technology in jewellery that are being tested and these will change the jewellery industry forever. 3. Prototype designs: The ability to see prototype designs without actually making them has made computers vital to the jewellery industry. Before computers were invented, a designer had to build a real sample to see how it turns out. This was otherwise, costly in terms of time, labour and materials wasted on a design that might be bad. 4. Innovation: With all such technological advancements, innovations can be seen in the fashion industry. It makes the manufacturers more experimental and initiate risk-taking to come up with different ideas.[14] 28 Porter’s five forces: Porter's Five Forces is a framework for industry analysis and business strategy development formed by Michael Porter. It has derived five forces that determine the competitive intensity and therefore attractiveness of a market. Three of Porter's five forces refer to competition from external sources. The remainders are internal threats. The threat of the entry of new competitors: Accessories market is a profitable market since it has high growth rate and profitable returns which will attract new players in this market. This may result in many new entrants, which eventually will decrease profitability for the firms and reduce its market share. The threat of substitute products or services: Unorganised retail is a huge market for fashion accessories. Also many brands under the organized sectors such as Shoppers Stop, Pantaloons, etc can also pose a threat to the new brand. The bargaining power of customers: Income level of consumers is rising which enables large number of buyers. Consumers are also becoming more prices sensitive. They have the availability of more choice. Therefore, they may not be ready to pay the quoted price. The bargaining power of suppliers: Suppliers of raw materials, components, labour, and services such as expertise to the firm can be a source of power over the firm, when there are few substitutes. Suppliers may refuse to 29 work with the firm, or charge excessively high prices for unique resources. Competitive rivalry: There is a limited number of competing firms in the organised retail sector of accessories. But there also exist some of the well established brands which may pose a threat to this new brand of accessories. 30 SWOT Analysis Strengths: Value for money: the main USP of Koutons is the fact that it provides value for money to its customers. Its deep discounting strategy fulfills the value proposition that it promises to its customers. Target group: Koutons mainly targets the middle and lower middle income group of people, which constitutes the largest proportion of population. With rising disposable incomes, the middle class in India is growing and forming the major part of the population. Brand for all: Koutons offers products for all age groups and genders. It has various sub brands under it. Koutons and Charlie Outlaw offer formal and casual apparels for men of the age group of 16-45 years. Les Femme offers formal and casual wear for women within the age group of 16-35years of age. Koutons Junior offers clothing for children in the age group of 2-15years. Franchisee arrangement: 98% of Koutons stores are run under the agreement of franchisees. This reduces the liability of handling individual stores. Also, low capital is required for expansion. It also reduces the risk of rising rentals for the company. Economies of scale: Koutons enjoys the cost advantages due its expanded product category. [14] 31 Weakness: Risk of obsolescence: Koutons has high inventory period due to which its products take a long while to move out of the stores. This increases the risk of its products becoming obsolete. Poor quality of products: Since Koutons has positioned itself as a deep discounted brand; its product quality is very poor. Most of the people also perceive it as a poor quality brand which hampers the brand image. Rising cost: There is an increase in cost due to heavy excise duty that the brand has to pay from 2011 onwards. This will hit Koutons adversely as it will reduce its profit margins to a great extent. Also, there are a lot of fluctuations in the prices, availability and quality of raw materials which causes delays and thus, increases cost. [15] Dependency: 98% of Koutons stores are run by franchisee. Also, it partially outsources its production, manufacturing and transportation. There for there is dependency on third parties Low brand loyalty: Koutons is not able to deliver good quality and designs in its clothing to its customers. Also, there are too many players coming up with the same strategy because of which customers are shifting from the brand and Koutons is losing down on its loyal customers. [16] 32 Opportunity: Increased Demand: People are becoming more fashion savvy nowadays. The middle class is rapidly growing and being more aware about the market around them. Also, the purchasing power of the people is increasing and there is a rise in per capita income of people, resulting in an increase in demand for fashion products. Market potential: Fashion accessories market in India is largely dominated by unbranded players; therefore there is a huge market potential for branded players in this segment. Also the growth rate of accessories market in India is 28-30% per annum. Potential in tier II and III cities: With the spread of information and technology, the standard of living of people is being upgraded. They are becoming more aware about brands. There is high growth potential in the tier II and tier III cities. [17] 33 Threats: Government regulations: In the Union Budget for 2011-12, the optional excise duty levy was changed into a mandatory levy at a unified rate of 10% for branded garments. Within the branded garments space, apparel discount brands would be the most affected due to the imposition of mandatory excise duty and has the potential to distort their cost structure. Threat from other players: There are a number of players from the unorganized sector offering cheaper, poor quality imitations to the customers. A lot of apparel brands are also trying to tap this gap and venturing into fashion accessories market. Thus, there is threat from the existing and upcoming players in the market. 34 Competitor analysis: Apart from Koutons, some of the major players in this market would be Cantabil, TNG, TQS and The Loot. These brands also work on the same business model of deep discounted strategies. Also, brands like Pantaloons, Reliance trends, Big Bazaar, Provogue and Spencer’s to name a few give a tough competition to Koutons since they cater to a similar target group. In terms of the accessories segment, major competition would come from MBO’s like Big Bazaar, Reliance Trends, Shoppers Stop, Lifestyle, Westside, Pantaloons. Also, the local retail shops would cater to the same segment of customers. At present, Cantabil could be considered as the strongest competitor of Koutons in terms of its price, quality, locations, customer clientele and USP. [19] 35 Cantabil: CANTABIL RETAIL INDIA LIMITED was incorporated in 1989 as Kapish Products Private Limited. It opened its 1st store in New Delhi in 2000. The Company is involved in the business of designing, manufacturing, branding and retailing of apparels under the brand names of “CANTABIL” and “La FANSO”. Company launched the second brand “La FANSO” on October 25, 2008 and has 141 exclusive outlets [as on July 31, 2010]. The “La FANSO” brand caters to men’s segment in lower to middle income group and focuses on casual, ultra casual and formal wear. It also retails various accessories like ties, belts, socks, caps and handkerchief under our brands. It mainly offers men’s shirts and trousers in formal, semi formal & casual wear range. The brand has 279 exclusive retail outlets across India. It also launched women’s wear in 2006 offering formal shirts to cargos. It came up with children’s collection as well for the age group of 2 to 14 years of age. Cantabil’s summer collection 2011 has been styled by Rocky S. The company is also listed on BSE and NSE. It operates its outlets under two models either company owned & franchisee managed or franchisee owned & operated. [20] 36 Competitors – Accessories Big Bazaar: Big Bazaar is a chain of hypermarket in India. It is part of Future Group, which also owns the Central Hypermarket, and is owned through a wholly owned subsidiary of Pantaloon Retail India Limited that is listed on Indian stock exchanges. Currently, there are 210 stores across 80 cities and towns in India. Big Bazaar offers a wide range of merchandise including fashion and apparels, food products, general merchandise, furniture, electronics, books, fast food and leisure and entertainment sections. [22] Reliance trends: A subsidiary of reliance Industries Limited, With multiple in-house brands, various shop-in-shop formats, product range for the entire family, Reliance Trends is a onestop-shop for apparel and accessories ethnic and contemporary, formal and casual, Indian and western. Trends also has a unique collection of technology clothes like fragrant clothes for infant, stain-free trousers, shirts and trousers with in-built moisture management and the likes. [23] 37 Factors Big bazaar Reliance Trends Parent group Future Group Reliance Industries Limited Founded 2001 2007 Outlets 133 60 Tagline ‘Isse sasta aur accha kahin nahi’ ‘sirf dikhne me mehenga’ Advertisements TV commercials, newspapers, hoardings TVs, newspapers, hoardings Social media Facebook, online shopping Facebook 7 twitter Promotions Offers of the day, hot deals Gift coupons, online discount coupons Revenue Rs. 210 crores Rs. 330 crores 30% of total revenue Net profit[2009- Rs. 495 crores [future 10] group] Loss- Rs. 211 lakhs 38 Chapter – 4, MARKETING PLAN Koutons - Brand Portfolio Koutons [1998]: o Age group of 22-45 years o Formal and casual men’s wear Charlie outlaw [2006]: o Age group of 14-25 years o casual men’s wear brand Les femme [2008]: o Age group of 16-34 yrs o Formal and casual wear for women Koutons junior [2008]: o age group of 2-15yrs o Trendy and playful apparels for kids K2One [2009]: o Footwear for men, women and kids o Leather accessories for men 39 Koutons – Promotions The advertising agency for Koutons Retail India is IMM Advertising PVT. LTD. IMM Advertising is a young, full service Advertising Agency with a very strong grasp on the areas of Graphic Design & other Advertising. It also provides advertising solutions to the brands like Bentley, Charlie, TNG, Suncity, Crossriver Mall, Body Care, Cantabil, Malhotra's, Clone Mannequins Inc., Appu Ghar, Nino Mantelli, TQS, Rabael, Cairo, Divine City, TDI City, Advertising Service, Food Forum India 2008, India Fashion Forum 2008, Images Multimedia, Zardozi, West Wood and many more. [23] Print ads of Koutons: 40 Visual analysis of an ad: Visual elements: Mood Money Saver Typeface Serif font [logo] Logo Wings, Blue & white Colour Blue, purple, yellow Shapes Rectangular boxes, circles in the background Overall Composition Stresses mainly on the discounts which is written bolder than the logo 41 Story components: Character[s] Discounting promotions Plot Saving money Setting An international model happy to use Koutons Symbols A male model, brand logo, emphasis on discounts Sub‐text THE WAY AHEAD…ALWAYS [serif] Needs under the budget, Pocket friendly, helps saving money 42 KOUTONS A brand audit was done on 17 customers, to know more about Koutons. What people feel and like about the brand. Following are a few similar answers given by the customers. What What else comes to comes to your mind your mind Others Self image wearing it Memories Other brands High discounts Blue & white logo Stylish Not wasting Bulk money shopping Cantabil Value for money Wings in logo Mass usage brand Spending wisely Heavy discounts TNG Affordable Newspaper ads Routine brand stylish Praises from friends Pantaloons Good quality Hoardings Fit for Indian mind set satisfied Great deals COBB Cheap & trendy Reasonable Up-todate Trendy at low price Clothes remain in Good quality Variety & colors 50%+40% off Love for discounts Comfortable Birthday top Budget brand Good quality Good use of money Big bazaar TQS 43 Brand: A brand is a name, term, sign, symbol, or design which is intended to identify the goods or services of one seller or group of sellers and to differentiate them from those of competitors. The aim of branding is to convey brand message vividly, create customer loyalty, persuade the buyer for the product, and establish an emotional connectivity with the customers. Branding forms customer perceptions about the product. It should raise customer expectations about the product. The primary aim of branding is to create differentiation. Brand Prism: Quotes by the consumers: “I made a bulk purchase of 7 shirts during heavy sales and they all still have good quality and fit.” -Varun Aggarwal, 27 “I bought my birthday top from Les Femme & got lots of compliments from my friends.” – Shikha Gupta, 1 44 DIVA: DIVA is a sub brand under Koutons. It will have fashion accessories under it being sold through exclusive outlets around the country. In the 1st year, 18 exclusive stores are targeted to be opened mainly in tier 2 and tier 3 cities of north and west zone of India. Further 34 stores to be opened in the tier 2 and tier3 cities of south and east zones of India. By the end of 3rd year a total of 78 stores to be opened in differnt parts of the country. Koutons stores are already present in all of these cities. There are various reasons for introducing DIVA as a sub brand of Koutons. Koutons has a negative image about its quality in the minds of its non consumers. Therefore, it is important for a new brand to not to fall under the same category as that of Koutons. As a sub brand, DIVA will be able to attract new customers and have an identity of its own. Also, it is being endorsed ‘by Koutons’ which will help generate trust and confidence in the existing customers of Koutons. Brand Elements: Name: The name, Diva, sounds very bold, chic, trendy, fun, attractive and confident. It explains that it is a brand for girls. Logo: The logo includes a female figure in the form of the alphabet ‘I’. This symbolises that it is a girls’ brand. Color: The colors used are pink, black and white. Pink is the girl’s color. It adds the element of brightness and boldness in it. 45 DIVA’s Customer Segmentation: Gender: Females Age group: 18 to 26years Geographic: Region- North and East India [1st year] City- Amritsar, Jalandhar, Ludhiana, Chandigarh, Rohtak, Gurgaon, Noida, New Delhi, Shimla, Jammu, Jaipur, Agra, Lucknow, Kanpur, Dehradun, Ahmedabad, Mumbai, Pune [18 cities] 34 cities in 2nd year and 26 cities in 3rd year. Demographic: Family size- 3-6 members Income of parents [per month] – Rs. 25,000 – Rs. 80,000 Pocket money of students [per month] – Rs. 5,000-10,000 Occupation – college students, working girls Education – graduates, post graduates Social class – middle class Psychographics: She is smart, trendy and bold. She is experimental and wants to concur the world. She is fun loving and wants to be independent. She desires to be the perfect women as she grows. She is both culture-oriented and outdoororiented. She goes for holidays in India and spends wisely on necessities Behavioural: Occasions – window shopping, casual outings, shopping User status – potential user, first time user Usage rate – light, medium Loyalty status – none, medium Attitude toward product – enthusiastic Source: Questionnaire survey 46 Consumer DILO: 47 Consumer Behaviour: To understand the customers of fashion accessories market, a questionnaire survey was conducted with the target group for Diva. 20 customers were interviewed. The following views and preferences were obtained: 1. From where do you normally buy fashion accessories? 2 3 max 10 big bazaar 5 reliance trends local markets Majority of the girls buy fashion accessories from the unorganised local markets. Some of them prefer buying from Max, Big Bazaar or Reliance Trends. 2. How much do you normally spend on a single purchase at such stores? 3 1 2 <150 6 151-300 301-500 8 501-1000 1001< Mostly girls spend around Rs. 300-500 on their single purchase at such stores. 48 3. Which of the products do you buy most frequently? 3 jewellery 2 bags & purses 10 hair accessories 4 scarves & wraps 1 belts Most of the girls buy jewellery most frequently from such stores. 4. How frequently do you visit such stores? 1 more than once a month 2 1 once 2-3 months 4 12 semi annually special occasions sales period Mostly, girls visit accessories stores more than once a month. 5. Which factor affects your purchasing decision the most? 1 price 4 8 quality design 5 functionality 2 brand name Price is the most important factor for girls to be considered while purchasing an accessory. 49 Perceptual Mapping: The parameters taken into consideration for perceptual mapping are price and quality of products. Diva will be positioned above its competitors such as Big Bazaar and Reliance Trends in terms of both quality and price. Product Mix and Pricing for DIVA • • • • • • • • • Jewellery - Rs. 49-499 Bags – Rs.199-1199 Belts – Rs. 89-799 Hair accessories - Rs. 49-399 Scarves - Rs.149-799 Sun glasses - Rs. 349-1499 Clutch bags – Rs.199-1499 Hats – Rs. 199-799 Gloves/stockings – Rs. 99-799 50 Design Styles: Victorian Contemporary Retro Bohemian Ethnic The products will be displayed as per these five themes inside the stores for the convenience of the customers to make choices easily.[25] 51 Strategy: The product mix and pricing has been defined keeping in view the product range of the competitors of DIVA such as Big Bazaar, Reliance Trends and local markets. The strategy adopted for pricing is competitive pricing psychological pricing. Even high end brands use this strategy, i.e. prices should end with odd numbers; instead of Rs. 200, the price of a product will be Rs.199. No year-long price discount or allowances will be given. It is because it is not good for the brand’s image. Discounts will be given only at the time of sale season and on special occasions. Various other incentives will be offered to the customer at different periods. Gift vouchers will be made available at all the stores of DIVA as well as online. Customers can be gift vouchers of different amounts for further gifting to someone. They can also buy these online from DIVA’s official website which will be applicable on the purchases made at any of the DIVA stores. This will be applicable for 3 months during the launch period. Student discounts of a particular amount on the purchase will be given to students while purchasing from any of the DIVA stores around the country. This will not be applicable on online shopping. This sales promotional activity will start after the launch period for 5 months. The quality of products and their prices have been set at a slightly higher level than its competitors Big Bazaar and Reliance Trends so that the customers get the best of products at affordable price. 52 Promotions: DIVA will be performing different promotional activities through various mediums of advertising. Since it is a new brand, it will invest in various launch promotions. A detailed media plan is explained below which explains the different mediums of advertising that will be used for various objectives. It also mentions the time duration, costs involved and other details of the activities to be performed. DAGMAR - Defining Advertising Goals for Measured Advertising Results The main goal of advertising is to spread awareness about the brand by using print media, audio media and public relations activities in the first 4 months during the launch period of brand by investing nearly Rs. 1.23 crores in 18 cities of North and West India. Media Plan Objective Brand Awareness Teasers And Informative Month Media Vehicle(Ht) March & April'12 Print AdNewspaper Hindustan Times Htcity, Ht Café,Mint March & April'12 Audio AdRadio Jingles 94.3 Fm Cities Details Page - Back Size9*8cm=72sqcm Avg Cost=Rs.245/Sq cm 18 Insertions -2 Per Month Duration - 2 Months Timings-Popular Prime Time ( 11a.M To 2p.M &6p.M To 10p.M) Avg Cost=Rs.550per 18 10sec Duration - 10 Seconds Cost Per City Total Cost 70,560 12,70,080 4,84,00 0 87,12,000 53 Repetition 20times Daily For 2 Months On Weekdays Brand Awareness Persuasive Persuasive April, May, June, July'12 Pr-Gift Hampers Barter Deals In Fashion Shows 18 April, May, June'12 Sales Promotions - Gift Vouchers Gift Vouchers At Stores And Online 18 April'12March'1 3 July, Aug'12, Jan, Feb'13 Sales PromotionOnline Promotion Sales PromotionSeasonal Discounts AugDec'12 Sales PromotionStudent Discount Diva's Website 1 50 1 Website Of Diva For Online Shopping 18 Retail Stores 18 Persuasive March Onwards Sales Promotion - Retail Vm Stores 18 Informative MarchJuly'12 Brochures March Onwards Public Relation Website Persuasive Informative Koutons Stores Internet Offers Available On Online Shopping Stock Clearance Sales At The End Of The Seasons 10% Student Discount Applicable For A Limited Period After Launch Cost Of Jewellery Mannequins, Posters And Signage Brochures Of Diva Available At Approx.50 Koutons Stores In Different Cities Retail Stores Persuasive 3 Colleges Per City Gift Hampers Worth Rs.1000 To Top 3 Winners Of Each College 2000 Gift Vouchers At Each Store During Lauch Period To Be Availed At Stores Only 18,000 3,24,000 1,500 27,000 0 0 1,100 20,000 1,000 18,000 30,000 5,40,000 25,000 12,50,000 1,50,00 0 1,50,000 Total Cost = 1,23,11,080 54 Promotional Plan Year 2012-13 Promotions Opening of stores Barter Deals With Colleges Gift Vouchers Newspapers Ads Radio Jingles Online Promotions Seasonal Discounts Student Discounts Mar’12 Apr May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec Jan’13 Feb Mar Website for DIVA: 55 Sales Promotions for DIVA: Exemplars: Gift Vouchers Brochures Student Discounts Seasonal Sales Launch promotions for DIVA: Newspaper ad: 56 Radio Jingles: College fashion shows: 57 Press Release: Koutons Retail India Ltd. KOUTONS ENTERS WOMEN ACCESSORIES MARKET 18 EBO’s to open by the end of 2012 28th November, 2011 Koutons expands its brand portfolio by launching DIVA, a fashion accessories brand for women. The new brand will have 18 EBO’s in the 1st year in mainly Tier 2 and tier 3 cities of India by the end of 2012. Koutons had been catering to the apparel segment for men, women and children. Now it sees the opportunity of entering into the fashion accessories market. This sector is mainly in the unorganised format in India and has very few players in the organised sector. Indian brands like Big Bazaar, Reliance trends, Shoppers Stop, etc. are offering fashion accessories like jewellery, purses, hats, belts, hair accessories, scarves, clutch bags, etc. to the consumers. In the 1st year, Koutons plans to open 18 stores in North and West zone of India. 2nd year onwards it plans to penetrate in the entire country by opening more stores. The brand DIVA will be a sub-brand of Koutons and will sell its products only through Exclusive stores. ENDS For more information: Shavy Arora (PR Manager) Contact no.: 7897635590 Koutons Retail India Gurgaon. 58 Chapter – 5, OPERATIONS AND MANAGEMENT PLAN Distribution Network of DIVA: 4 level distribution network: Outsourcing the product Warehouse/ Distribution Centre Retail Stores Consumer DIVA will follow a 4-level distribution channel. It will outsource its products from various agents and wholesalers of India. All the outsourced products will be assembled at the distribution centre from where it will be further sent to all the DIVA stores around the country and finally to the end consumer. 59 Organisational structure: Brand Manager Marketing Dept Purchase & Sourcing Dept Sales Dept Marketing Manager 18-store Managers VM Manager 2- Assisstant VM Managers 2 - Head Sourcing Managers 2 Assisstant Product Coordinators Quality Controller Assisstant Quality Controller Sales Manager Assisstant Sales Manager Logistic Manager 2 Regional Logistic Managers Warehouse Manager 2- Support Staff VP Finance 2- Regional Fin. & A/Cing Managers HR Manager 2- Senior Executive Managers IT Manager 2 Executive Staff CEO Supply Chain Dept Finance Dept HR Dept IT Dept 2- Sales Executive Support Staff The head office of Koutons Retail India Ltd. is at Udyog Vihar, Gurgaon [India]. The departments have been categorised under different heads such as Marketing, Purchase and Sourcing, Sales, Supply chain, Finance, HR and IT. Each department has their manager and the assistant managers under them. These will lead to a decentralized organisational structure where employees can maintain a greater level of control over their own departments. People are more motivated by the increased ownership of responsibility. 60 DIVA’s presence in India: 1st Year North Zone Amritsar Jalandhar Ludhiana Chandigarh Rohtak Gurgaon Noida New Delhi Simla Jammu Agra Lucknow Kanpur Dehradun 14 West Zone Ajmer Ahmedabad Mumbai Pune South Zone East Zone 4 0 0 Total Stores = 18 North Amritsar Bhatinda Jalandhar Patiala Chandigarh Ambala Sirsa Ghaziabad New Delhi Nainital Manali Bareily Meerut Roorkee West Jaipur Kota Bhopal Indore Surat Nagpur Nasik 14 7 2nd Year South Bangalore Mysore Chennai Hyderabad 4 Total Stores [34+18] =52 East Bhubneshwar Raipur Cuttack Jamshedpur Patna Darjeeling Kolkata Siliguri Imphal 9 61 3rd Year North West South East Abohar Udaipur Mangalore Bargarg Batala Vadodra Cochin Bilaspur Pathankot Gwalior Calicut Dhanbad Vishakhapattnam Ranchi Panipat Faridabad Gaya New Delhi Durgapur Aligarh Agartala Saharanpur Gangtok Varanasi Shilong Guwahati 9 3 4 10 Total Stores [26+52] = 78 Stores DIVA, although being a sub brand of Koutons Retail India Ltd., will operate as Exclusive brand outlets unlike its existing sub brands. Majority stores are being opened in the markets of Tier 2 and Tier 3 cities of India targeting the people of middle income group. The focus in the 1st year is on tier 2 & tier 3 cities of North zone and West zone by opening 18 stores in total. By the 2nd year, stores will b opened in some parts of south and east zone as well, adding 34 new stores in 2nd year and 26 stores in the 3rd year. By the end of 3rd year, a total of 78 stores of Diva will be opened throughout the country. 62 City Wise Matrix: Cities Pop.[In Lakhs] Chandigarh 10.54 Ahmedabad 5.57 Lucknow 27.67 Dehradun 10.25 Jalandhar Ajmer 9.03 4.85 Avg Household Income [rs/Household] 484775 317856 280393 200458 296651 159761 Total [in Rs.] Average Household Consumption Radio Ad Newspaper Expenditure as a Rentals [In Rs./10 Ad[in share of Income [in Rs.] Sec] Rs./sqcm] Colleges 45% 57,000 704000 42% 20900 58% 23560 47% 38000 77% 17860 53% 22040 INIFD, 108000 NIIFT, PU 64800 INIFD, NID, GIFT 57600 AHFI, JMI, IMS 264000 28800 INIFD, SAFT, JD 352000 APJ, LPU, 108000 DAV 264000 INIFD, AIC, 57600 SGC 968000 440000 1,79,360 29,92,000 4,24,800 30,000 50,000 70,800 Some of the cities have been taken into consideration for understanding the cities profile and expenses involved. [28] [29] Prefernces Population In Terms Of Avg Hh Inc Rentals Radio Ads Cost Newspaper Ads Cost Most preferred Lucknow Chandigarh Jalandhar Dehradun Dehradun Least preferred Ajmer Ajmer Chandigarh Chandigarh Chandigarh 63 Chapter – 7, FINANCIAL PLAN Resource List: Resource List [Head Office-Gurgaon] Total value [in Rs.] Laptops 2,64,000 Printer & Scanner 24,000 Cost Of Interiors Per Sqft 12,00,000 Erp Software [Enterprise Resource Programme] 3,00,000 Airconditioners [2ton] 1,50,000 Other Resources 0 Total 19,38,000 Resource List [For 1 Retail Store - Chandigarh] Computers 22,000 Printer & Scanner 12,000 Cost Of Interiors Per Sqft [Avrg Rs. 1200-1500 Per Sq Ft] 4,50,000 Cctv With Dvr Recording System 20,000 Airconditioners [2ton] 25,000 Total 6,19,250 Total resource list for 18 stores 95,22,000 64 Expenses for the 3 years: 1st year 2nd year 3rd year 64,80,000 1,87,20,000 2,80,80,000 17,28,000 49,92,000 74,88,000 1,58,88,000 2,79,88,000 4,17,16,000 2,57,59,079 1,52,22,152 9,61,20,820 7,56,000 21,84,000 32,76,000 5,06,11,079 6,91,06,152 17,66,80,820 1,23,12,000 5,92,80,000 7,46,92,800 Logistics [2% to 5% of Sales] 36,93,600 1,77,84,000 3,20,11,200 Sales Promotion [1% to 3% of Sales] 38,000 59,28,000 1,06,70,400 Expenses Office and Administration Overheads Rentals [Rent per store*Area *12*Number of Stores] Electricity Salary 532000+[44000*18] Depreciation [40% on comp., 18%on interiors, 13.91% on electronics annually] Other Office Overheads [stationery, internet/phone] Total Selling and Distribution Overheads Advertising [7% to 12% of Sales] Total 1,60,43,600 8,29,92,000 11,73,74,400 65 Initial investments for 3 years: Initial investment Total initial investment in fixed assets Pre operative expenses Working Capital Investment [20% of Sales] Year 1 Year 2 Year3 1,14,60,000 18,13,600 2,42,00,000 1,23,10,080 2,96,40,000 5,33,52,000 2,46,24,000 11,85,60,000 21,34,08,000 loss to be recovered in 2nd year Total Sources of Funds Loan [20%] equity 87,18,153 4,83,94,080 15,87,31,753 29,09,60,000 Year1 Year2 Year3 96,78,816 3,17,46,351 5,81,92,000 1,49,45,184 12,69,85,402 23,27,68,000 66 Initial investments under different scenarios [1st yr]: Initial Investment Most Likely Pessimistic Optimistic Total initial investment in fixed assets 1,14,60,000 1,14,60,000 1,14,60,000 Pre operative expenses 1,23,10,080 1,23,10,080 1,23,10,080 Working Capital Investment [20% of Sales] 2,46,24,000 1,47,74,400 3,69,36,000 Total 4,83,94,080 3,85,44,480 6,07,06,080 Sources of Funds Most likely pessimistic optimistic Loan [20%] equity 96,78,816 77,08,896 1,21,41,216 3,87,15,264 3,08,35,584 4,85,64,864 67 Projected Income Statement for 3 years: 1st year 2nd year 3rd year Sales 12,31,20,000 59,28,00,000 1,06,70,40,000 Less: Cost of Goods Sold 6,15,60,000 29,64,00,000 53,35,20,000 = Gross Profit 6,15,60,000 29,64,00,000 53,35,20,000 Less: Office and Administration Overheads 5,06,11,079 6,91,06,152 17,66,80,820 Less: Selling and Distribution Overheads 1,60,43,600 8,29,92,000 11,73,74,400 = Operating Profit /loss -50,94,679 14,43,01,848 23,94,64,780 Less: Interest on loan[12%] 11,61,458 38,09,562 69,83,040 Less: Preliminary Expenses [ Written Off] 24,62,016 29,54,880 1,42,27,200 -87,18,153 13,75,37,406 21,82,54,540 0 4,67,48,964 7,41,84,718 = Net profit/Loss Less: Income Tax [33.99%] EAT [Net profit/ loss -87,18,153 9,07,88,442 14,40,69,822 68 Projected Income Statement under different scenarios [1st yr]: Pessimistic Most Likely Optimistic Sales 7,38,72,000 12,31,20,000 18,46,80,000 Less: Cost of Goods Sold 3,69,36,000 6,15,60,000 9,23,40,000 3,69,36,000 6,15,60,000 9,23,40,000 Less: Office and Administration Overheads 5,06,11,079 5,06,11,079 5,06,11,079 Selling and Distribution Overheads 1,60,43,600 1,60,43,600 1,60,43,600 =Operating Profit [loss] -2,97,18,679 -50,94,679 2,56,85,321 Less: Interest on Loan[12%] 9,25,068 11,61,458 14,56,946 Less: Preliminary Expenses [ Written Off] 24,62,016 24,62,016 24,62,016 -3,31,05,763 -87,18,153 2,17,66,359 0 0 0 -3,31,05,763 -87,18,153 2,17,66,359 = Gross Profit =Net Loss Less: Income Tax [33.99%] EAT [Net loss] 69 Projected Gross Profit for 3 years: Gross profit 600,000,000 500,000,000 400,000,000 300,000,000 200,000,000 100,000,000 0 year1 year 2 year 3 Projected Initial Investments for 3 years: 300,000,000 250,000,000 200,000,000 150,000,000 100,000,000 50,000,000 0 year 1 year 2 year3 70 Projected Sales and Net Profit/Loss for 3 years: 1,200,000,000 1,000,000,000 800,000,000 sales 600,000,000 net profit/loss 400,000,000 200,000,000 0 -200,000,000 year1 year 2 year 3 After doing all this research, analysis and implementation, it shows that this project can take a practical shape. Thus, this project is viable. 71 Reflection: This project gave me a lot of confidence to work such marketing projects in future. I learnt how to integrate various marketing components like Branding, Promotions, Finance and Project Management and work in a synchronised way. I also learnt and implemented various concepts like work breakdown structure, networking, 5 Q’s, PEST analysis, Porter’s % forces, SWOT analysis, competitor analysis, brand audit, perceptual mapping, media and promotional plan. I also underwent an entire financial plan from investment required, fixed assets, depreciations, expenses to income statements for 3 years and under different scenarios like pessimistic, optimistic and most likely. Overall, it had been very motivating doing this project. I hope I am able to be successful in performing live projects of such kinds in the fashion industry. 72 ANNEXURES Index ($29.74 = 100) Mean total hourly cost of manufacturing employees(2005) 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 European nations US Japan East asia excl. Japan Brazil Mexico Phillipines India Sri Lanka Source: ftp://ftp.bls.gov/pub/special.requests/ForeignLabor/ichccaesuppt01.txt 73 Source: The Marketing Whitebook 2011-12 74 Source: The Marketing Whitebook 2011-12 75 Demographic and economic indicators: 2007 Real GDP Growth [% growth] 10.0 Inflation [% growth] 6.4 Population Aged 65+: January 1st 53,626.7 ['000] Population Density [persons per 382.2 sq km] GDP Measured at Purchasing 3,254,212.6 Power Parity [international $ million] Consumer Expenditure [US$ 683,303.8 million] Annual Gross Income [US$ 950,439.7 million] Annual Disposable Income [US$ 942,928.2 million] 2008 6.2 8.3 55,132.7 2009 6.8 10.8 56,656.4 2010 10.1 12.1 58,215.2 2011 7.8 10.6 59,834.0 387.7 393.1 398.5 403.9 3,461,016.7 3,897,346.3 4,254,107.9 4,686,005.4 750,837.9 783,288.8 987,139.9 1,026,899.0 1,050,228.0 1,079,460.9 1,354,956.8 1,405,100.8 1,046,081.6 1,071,152.7 1,338,447.7 1,383,179.5 Source: http://www.euromonitor.com/india/country-factfile 76 Brand Audit Questionnaire [Koutons]: I am a student of Pearl Academy of Fashion, majoring in Fashion Marketing. For my project I am undertaking a primary research study on Koutons, and would appreciate your valuable contribution. I assure you that the details you provide will be strictly confidential and will not be circulated, in any form or manner. Thank you very much for taking time out. Name: Age: Occupation: Location: Gender: Personal monthly disposable income: Up to Rs. 5,000 Rs. 5,001- 15,000 Rs. 15,001-30,000 Rs. 30,001-50,000 Rs.50,000-above 1. When you hear the brand name “Koutons” what comes to your mind immediately? 2. What strikes your mind when you hear the following in connection with Koutons: Logo: ______________________________________________ Color: _____________________________________________ Advertising: _________________________________________ Quality: ____________________________________________ Any other thing: _____________________________________ 3. When you see others wearing/buying from Koutons, how do you feel? What thoughts come to your mind? _______________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________ 77 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. When you shop from Koutons how does it make you feel about yourself? What role does it play in your life? ______________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________ Can you describe any memory that you associate with Koutons? _______________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________ Which others brands do you prefer apart from Koutons? [please tick the most suitable choice] Cantabil TNG TQS Pantaloons Other [please specify] ________________________________ How do you compare Koutons with other brands? _______________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ How much do you normally spend on a single purchase at Koutons? Rs.100-500 Rs.501-1000 Rs.1001-2000 Rs.2001-above Why do you buy at Koutons? For the clothes For the price For the customer service For the store location What proportion of your wardrobe do you normally buy at Koutons? Some of them Half of them Most of them All of them 78 Newspaper and Magazine articles of Koutons: 79 Questionnaire for Accessories: I am a student of Pearl Academy of Fashion, majoring in Fashion Marketing. I am doing a project of introducing Women’s Fashion Accessories Brand under Koutons and would appreciate your valuable contribution. I assure you that the details you provide will be strictly confidential and will not be circulated, in any form or manner. [P.S – accessories include jewellery, hair accessories, belts, bags, purses, scarves, hats, gloves, etc.] Name: Age: Occupation: Location: Gender: Personal monthly disposable income: Up to Rs. 5,000 Rs. 5,001- 15,000 Rs. 15,001-30,000 Rs. 30,001-50,000 Rs.50,000-above From where do you normally buy fashion accessories? Big bazaar Splash Max Reliance trends Shoppers stop Lifestyle Local markets Any other place [please specify] How much do you normally spend on a single purchase at such stores? Rs. 50-150 Rs. 150-300 Rs. 300-500 Rs 500-1,000 Rs. 1000 & above 1. 2. 80 3. Which of these products do you buy most frequently? Jewellery Bags & purses Hair accessories Scarves & wraps Belts Any other thing [please specify] How frequently do you visit such stores? More than once a month Once in 2-3 months Once in 6 months or more Only during Sales/Promotion periods Only on special occasions 4. 5. 6. 7. Rate the following factors which affect your purchase decision [rate on the scale of 1 to 7 where 1=most important] Price Quality Design Functionality Brand name Would you appreciate if Koutons Launches an accessories brand for women? Yes No Which medium of advertising attracts you the most? Newspapers Magazines Radio Hoardings Television Mails and SMS 81 Projected sales for 3 years: 1st year SPF [3000 ind. Avg.] 50% Total store size Sales of 1 store [in Rs.] Average selling price [estimated] 1,500 380 5,70,000 200 2,850 2nd year 3rd year 2,500 3,000 380 380 9,50,000 11,40,000 300 400 3,167 2,850 Sales qty.[units] Total monthly sales of all stores 1,02,60,000 4,94,00,000 8,89,20,000 Total annual sales [in Rs.] 12,31,20,000 59,28,00,000 1,06,70,40,000 82 References: 1) 2) 3) 4) 5) 6) 7) 8) 9) 10) 11) 12) http://www.koutonsparivar.com/ buysellsignals.com http://www.futureinq.com/09/retail-revolution-in-india/ http://www.technopak.com/Perspective/vol4/Trends%20in%20I ndia's%20Domestic%20Fashion%20market.pdf http://indiafranchiseblog.blogspot.com/2011/01/fashionaccessories-companies-franchise.html www.buysellsignals.com http://smetimes.tradeindia.com/smetimes/news/topstories/2011/Jul/07/indian-fashion-jewellery-sector-all-set-togrow.html http://www.moneycontrol.com/news http://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2010/05/art1full.pdf http://www.futureinq.com/09/retail-revolution-in-india/ http://www.futureinq.com/09/retail-revolution-in-india/ http://www.business-standard.com/india/news/three-directorskey-executives-quit-koutons/423647/ 13) http://www.thejewellerydepot.com/the-technology-ofdesigning-jewellery.html 14) http://www.koutonsparivar.com/ 15) http://www.koutonsparivar.com/ 16) http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/business/bizarticlelist/18980 55.cms 17) http://indiafranchiseblog.blogspot.com/2011/01/fashionaccessories-companies-franchise.html 18) http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/koutons-retail-indialtd/stocks/companyid-15470.cms 83 19) http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/koutons-retail-indialtd/stocks/companyid-15470.cms 20) http://www.cantabilinternational.com/ 21) www.bigbazaar.futurebazaar.com/ 22) www.reliance-tracker.in/tag/reliance-trends/ 23) http://www.indiamart.com/imm-advertising/ 24) http://www.fashionproducts.com/fashion-accessories/ 25) http://www.hindustantimes.com/ratecard/Impact.aspx 26) http://www.ads2book.com/ads2book/ratecard/ht_ratecard.htm 27) http://www.releasemyad.com/tariff/newspaper-display-adstep1.php 28) http://www.myfmindia.com/myfm_advertise.php# 29) http://www.radioone.in/rate-card.aspx# 30) http://www.moneycontrol.com/mccode/news/article/article_pdf .php?autono=568012&num=0 84