REPORT 3RD HIGH LEVEL DIALOGUE UNDER STRATEGIC DEVELOPMENT PARTNERSHIP FRAMEWORK October 24, 2014 Islamabad Government of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Report of the 3rd High Level Dialogue Strategic Development Partnership Framework October 24, 2014 TABLE OF CONTENTS Background 1 Agenda 3 Welcome Address by Additional Chief Secretary, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa 4 Progress Update on SDPF by Secretary Planning & Development 6 Opening Remarks by Chief Minister Khyber Pakhtunkhwa 7 Discussion on Agenda Items 9 Action Points from High Level Dialogue 19 Annex 1: Programme Structure 20 Annex 2: Presentation by Secretary P&D, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa 21 Annex 3: List of Participants 31 BACKGROUND The Government of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa adopted an SDPF with the development partners which was formalized during the First ‘Strategic Dialogue on Development Partnership’ held on 2nd October 2013. The framework aims at creating synergies for gearing up the socio-economic development of the province through concerted efforts by the Government and its development partners. SDPF drives on the Government’s Agenda of transformational development which provides the platform for establishing development pacts building around the principles of inclusive and accelerated socio-economic growth and good governance based on the premises of enhanced social services delivery. The SDPF laid a solid foundation for aligning the donor financial assistance with the country policies and priorities as well as country system. In order to operationalize the SDPF and to realign government policies and priorities with the reforms agenda of the government, the Government has now formulated Integrated Development Strategy (IDS). The IDS comprehensively articulates the strategic objectives of SDPF by elaborating sector plans thereby identifying initiatives to be undertaken in various sectors. The IDS provides a roadmap for operationalizing the transformational reforms agenda through a consistent and robust approach for creating linkages amongst the sector strategies. 1 SDPF is reflection of the pro-people reform agenda of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. It is about enabling children going to school, poor people getting better health facilities, making government more transparent and accountable. In this context, it is heartening to note that international development partners are more than willing to support and take forward this developmental reform agenda of the Government Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. The meaningful collaboration of last twelve months provides solid basis for continuing and deepening this developmental partnership for taking forward the shared development agenda for the province. As a sequel to earlier strategic dialogues held between the provincial government and development partners substantial progress on has been made in different areas of the SDPF. Finalization of IDS and alignment of provincial ADP and annual development budget 2014-15 with IDS was a step in this direction. It has now been felt that focused discussion between provincial leadership and international development partners is needed to move ahead on the development policy of the government. This would ensure more meaningful basis for collaboration and joint pursuit of SDPF objectives amongst provincial government and its development partners. Government of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa organised a high level strategic dialogue under the aegis of SDPF on 24th Oct, 2014 for providing an interactive platform to provincial leadership and development partners to deliberate upon future shape of this collaboration. The dialogue provided an opportunity to both partners of stock taking of progress made so far and seeking agreement on any requisite course correction. The deliberations also gave a strategic direction setting to move ahead with developmental partnership in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. Last but not the least, this forum offered an opportunity to development partners to share feedback with provincial government on some of the policy level reforms. 2 AGENDA Agenda for the session was already agreed between the development partners and the government of KP and it was agreed that in order to have structured and meaningful dialogue the government and development partners will share their views on a number of topic in a candid and frank manner. The dialogue was led by the Chief Minister KP on behalf of the provincial government while the head of DFID initiated the dialogue on behalf of the development partners. The main agenda items discussed during the session were as follows: 1. Progress sharing by provincial government on SDPF operationalization 2. ADP utilization 3. Way forward on decentralization reforms 4. Effective monitoring of reform implementation The Additional Chief Secretary KP Mr. Khalid Pervez welcomed the participants on behalf of the government in the start of the session followed by a power point presentation by the Secretary Planning and Development Department on progress by the provincial government on SDPF and IDS during the preceding months. Soon after, the Chief Minster opened the dialogue with a brief speech. 3 WELCOME ADDRESS BY ADDITIONAL CHIEF SECRETARY, KHYBER PAKHTUNKHWA Honourable Chief Minister Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, members of Provincial Cabinet, Excellencies, Representatives of Development Partners, provincial secretaries, ladies and gentlemen, Assalam-o-Alaikum and Good Morning. It is a matter of great pleasure for me to welcome distinguished guests of today’s event. We were required to hold this dialogue just after budget, but we could not do that. For today’s session we have some what changed the format. Now we shall have more interactive session. In fact modifying the format is a reflection of maturing of our relationship with the development partners. Starting with endeavours for charting broader policy “Starting with endeavours for charting broader policy vision vision documents, we have now entered the phase of actual documents, we have now implementation and course correction. Ever since launch of entered the phase of actual SDPF, KP Government has been making all out efforts for implementation and course ensuring smooth progress on strategies designed for economic development and improved governance in the 4 correction” province. In this pursuit, provincial government has been constantly guided by political leadership for deepening of these reforms. Substantial progress has already been registered, some of which would be shared in a subsequent presentation. However, several challenges and constraints have “peer to peer sharing of ideas also surfaced during this process, necessitating remedial would be of mutual benefits for measures. I am sure our development partners would also provincial government and its have noted these key developments and constraints during development partners in terms of realizing goals of prosperity and development for KP province” last twelve months. Objective of today’s event is to provide a joint platform for sharing of these perceptions with a view to agree on future course of action. We would like to hear from our development partners both in terms of issues identified as well as suggestions for improved implementation of our reform vision in future months and years. Outcome of today’s deliberations would carry immense value for provincial government, in terms of impacting our future course of action. I am sure, peer to peer sharing of ideas would be of mutual benefits for provincial government and its development partners in terms of realizing goals of prosperity and development for KP province. My best wishes are with you. Thank you. 5 PROGRESS UPDATE ON SDPF BY SECRETARY PLANNING & DEVELOPMENT A comprehensive presentation on the progress made on SDPF was delivered by the Secretary Planning and Development Department. The presentation established tone and context for discussion during the dialogue by providing the details on SDPF implementation around key strategic outcomes as defined in the SDPF. The presentation started with a brief on SDPF, its purpose, and rational in the backdrop of the transformational reform agenda of the government which resulted in SDPF directed Integrated Development Strategy. He built on to explain the very basic design features of the Integrated Development Strategy and also informed the participants on the recent events that had been held in this front. During the presentation, the Secretary Planning and Development informed the participants on a number of initiatives that had been undertaken under various thematic areas of the Integrated Development Strategy with particular focus of twin social sectors i.e. education and health. He also briefly responded to the claims of some segment of the society as highlighted in the media on low utilization of the ADP and maintained that the picture was exactly the opposite. The presentation ended with posing some structural considerations for the donors to ponder upon to successfully support the effective implementation of the SDPF. 6 OPENING REMARKS BY CHIEF MINISTER KHYBER PAKHTUNKHWA Honourable members of the Provincial Cabinet, the Excellencies, Mission Heads, Provincial Secretaries, Ladies and Gentlemen, Assalam-o-Alaikum and a warm good morning. It gives me immense pleasure to be among you once again and leading this very important session to which my government pays high priority and ownership. Ladies and Gentlemen! Let me inform you that this time the dialogue is different from the previously held exchanges. In addition to sharing the progress, I would like the development partners and my colleagues to have an issue-based and frank discussion on the provincial government development agenda. Dear Participants! Our government is now in its second year in office and several developmental challenges have surfaced during this period. I am pleased to inform that in our first year, we have set the basis to facilitate and translate our reformed vision. 7 “in our first year, we have set the basis to facilitate and translate our reformed vision. Policy frameworks enabled and have been finalized and implementation processes have been streamlined” Policy frameworks enabled and have been finalized and implementation processes have been streamlined. While this crucial spadework might have somewhat slowed implementation process, yet it was essential for ensuring smooth and quality implementation in upcoming years. I am happy to share with you that the ADP utilization has now gathered momentum. Public interest legislation has started bearing fruits. Our government is now firm to further improve the progress. I am also thoughtful of several challenges and constraints which our development partners may also have noted. Ladies and Gentlemen! The objective of I am happy to share today’s meeting is to have a formal debate around with you that the ADP the issues so that future progress on reform utilization has now gathered implementation may be made more effective. Use of momentum. Public interest country systems and peer to peer monitoring of agreed course of development can substantially deepen our reform process. legislation has started bearing fruits Dear Friends! Today I am looking forward to hearing your thoughts on the discussion points and would like to express our opinion on these items. I would expect that this session achieves tangible outcomes which I assure you will be fully incorporated in future operation of SDPF and IDS. It will help us to better pursue our development and reforms agenda in KP. Ladies and Gentlemen! Let me once again express my gratitude to all participants in today’s event. Thank you all and best wishes. 8 DISCUSSION ON AGENDA ITEMS Following opening remarks by Chief Minister, an inclusive discussion ensued around discussion points by all participants. The Country Head DFID Pakistan opened the discussion on behalf of development partners. He appreciated holding the organizing the Dialogue in an interactive manner around very important and key themes of SDPF. He especially thanked Chief Minister, his cabinet colleagues and secretaries of provincial government for their presence. He referred to finalization of development policies in KP including Integrated Development Strategy as steps in right direction but stressed the importance of stocktaking of progress against the overarching policy documents in the province. While appreciating progress made under SDPF and legislations such as RTI and RTS he underscored the multifarious challenges posed by poverty, under development and IDP issues which also needed to be handled on priority basis. He was of the view that progress claims need to be contextualized in the broader perspective of provincial socio-economic parameters undermined by the by the challenges of job creation, energy crisis and stagnant economic growth. Appreciating the marked progress on education sector reforms, he also highlighted the unanimous concerns of development partners on sluggish progress on health sector reforms. He also drew the attention of 9 the participants to the issues regarding pace of implementation in service delivery departments. Deliberating on ADP utilization he referred to the government claim of 80% utilization of ADP, and expressed the opinion that alongside utilization figures, the quality of expenditure and its contribution to the overall goals of development was also vital. He specifically highlighted the challenges in service delivery and implementation at the grass root levels including the districts. The key area of mainstreaming gender concerns in the working of government was also highlighted especially in the context of health and education service delivery. He stressed the importance of wider and deeper debate on ensuring mainstreaming of gender concerns as a cross cutting theme in development and reform interventions by the provincial government. He appreciated the government’s concern for renewed focus on the mechanism of government-development partners’ interaction and agreed to the importance of alignment of development assistance with country systems. Mr. Montgomery quipped that any progress on this score would be concomitant on robustness of data collection and reporting systems within government. A more solid s y s t e m o f d a t a collection and reporting on the pattern of IMU in education sector could provide a meaningful way forward for more informed and better coordinated dialogue between development partners and the provincial government. 10 After the opening remarks by DFID head, Chief Minister, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa provided a comprehensive response, touching upon various issues raised. He explained the issue of perceived delays on ADP implementation and highlighted government’s efforts for putting the systems right with the objectives of transparency and accountability. He elaborated that it was provincial government’s commitment to improve and mainstream systems of implementation in such a manner that minimum chances of leakages and wastage could be possible. Bringing about this transformation across implementation sectors needed some time and it is heartening to note that after setting the basics right, progress of implementation in the province has gathered momentum. He stressed that development partners should see the logic behind first strengthening systems before making any meaningful progress on ADP implementation leading to inclusive growth in the province. Refereeing to the governance challenges the Chief Minister stated that there were no monitoring systems within provincial government to enable an informed assessment of people’s needs and performance of service delivery departments. There was little idea about the exact number of education or health facilities; or whether these were functional or closed. Putting in systems for capturing this vital information and data needed time and systems, which have now been put in place and are fully functional. Now we have comprehensive monitoring systems for school education sector which are 11 also being extended to health sector. By systemic monitoring, we will be ensuring quality access and timeliness of service delivery. After comments by Chief Minister, H.E. Ambassador European Union Delegation appreciated the progress made by the KP government on development agenda. He pointed out that a deeper look at details was needed to capture a true picture at implementation level. He specifically highlighted the issue of decentralization which had assumed greater relevance in the context of eighteenth amendment. In view of the ambitious decentralization reform agenda of the provincial government, he also highlighted the likely bottlenecks and challenges which could hamper progress on this count. He drew the attention of government and developed partners embarking on comprehensive electoral system reforms as a sequel to conduct of local bodies’ elections in the province. He stressed that provincial government will ensure greater c l a r i t y o n t hese issues and indicate a clearer roadmap for implementation of devolution reforms in the province. Chief Minister explained the question of local governance reforms in the province by providing the latest status on the subject. He informed the participants that provincial government had already written to Election Commission of Pakistan for conduct of elections as necessary legislation in this regard had already been made. He also invited attention of participants to the KP local Government Act which ensures decentralization to more grass roots level than other provincial local government legislations. He specifically referred to the provisions of KP Local Government Act 12 providing for devolution of 30% development resources to the local level and establishment of village councils for deepening of decentralization reforms. He was of the view that existence of district; tehsil and village level tiers in local governance would ensure improved service delivery and empowerment of masses at the grass root levels. In terms of devolved service delivery improvements, he explained government’s efforts at monitoring teachers’ performance at the school level. He also informed that by adopting English as medium of language for all schools, an effort had been made to end the discrimination between rich and poor in terms of provision of quality education. He also drew the attention of participants towards government’s efforts for enhancing teacher performance by institutionalizing results-based promotions of school teachers. On the whole, this a policy shift from brick and mortar to results based management and incentivized improvements in school education system. Chief Secretary also joined the discussion by substantiating the facts highlighted by Chief Minister. He informed the forum that all the policy and implementation improvements would be easier to achieve if a culture of good governance is nurtured within provincial government. He highlighted the efforts of provincial government to strictly adhere to principles of merit in senior level postings and transfers for improved performance and results-oriented management. He also informed the meeting that a system of monthly progress review was being institutionalized both at the level of 13 Chief Minister and Chief Secretary for timely highlighting of implementation delays. These meetings will be used as instruments of target setting and mid-course corrections. Implementation delays in ADP as well as under -utilization of resources would not be tolerated under any circumstances. Target-oriented working is also being introduced at the district level for gauging performance of District Administrations in terms of tangible results in areas such as polio eradication, enrolment etc. Last but not the least, regular conduct of Secretary Committee meetings and sharing of progress with Chief Minister’ Secretariat will ensure timely achievement of laid down targets and goals within provincial government. After these points by Chief Secretary, further discussions ensued from the side of development partners. Head of DFID Pakistan raised the issue of Devolution and underscored the importance of achieving results at the district and service delivery level. While appreciating legislative work in this regard, he conveyed the commitment development partners for working with provincial government in ensuring service delivery dividends at the local level. He also agreed for closer collaboration on effective coordination and data generation for improved performance monitoring. He was followed by First Secretary, AusAid who highlighted the importance of civil service reforms as corollary to local governance reforms in the province. She wanted to know how best development partners could support provincial government in deepening decentralization reforms at the local level through areas such as civil 14 servants’ trainings. Country Director, World Bank inquired about the arrangements which may have been made for training of prospective local government elected representatives in core capability areas. He underscored the importance of putting in place a proper system for poverty reduction through enhanced decentralization reforms. Concerns of development partners on local governance were addressed by Mr. Inayatullah Khan, Senior Minister, Local Government who informed the participants that provincial government had already completed the important task of delimitations. However, the same had to be abandoned in the light of latest decisions on this issue from Supreme Court of Pakistan. Provincial government has already taken necessary measure in the light of these decisions and a request has been sent to Election Commission for conduct of local bodies’ elections. He also raised the issue of Provincial Finance Commission and p o i n t e d o u t t hat it could not be made functional due to absence of compulsory membership. Issues are being faced in the absence of Provincial Finance Commission Award regarding transfer of 30% share of development resources to the local level and provincial government is constrained to transfer money as per old PFC formula. Provincial Government has also requested Election Commission for conduct of Local Bodies’ elections by using biometric system. He also suggested formation of a committee having representation from development partners for facilitating 15 implementation of local governance reforms in the province. Secretary Local Government Department highlighted the importance of a robust communication strategy to enhancing public awareness on the issue of local governance reforms and sought support of development partners for this purpose. Representative from UNDP highlighted that UNDP was already working with provincial g o v e r n m e n t f o r supporting devolution reforms and welcomed the idea of forming a joint committee to move this agenda ahead. Representative from AusAid underscored the importance of greater interaction amongst service delivery departments at the local level for strengthening devolution reforms. She specifically highlighted the importance of enhanced awareness of these issues within health and education departments. On the subject of aligning donor assistance with country system, she highlighted challenges in selling this to host governments and suggested improved revenue generation at the provincial level as a means to facilitate this transformation. Country Head, World Bank further elucidated these points by appreciating a greater focus on results and civil servants’ incentives issues. He appreciated legislation such as RTI and underscored the need for informed decision making process for improved reform implementation. He also agreed to the proposal for looking at Integrated Development Strategy as a means to align donor assistance with country systems. He also referred to the experience of Multi-Donor Trust Fund and importance of institution building as an objective of such partnerships. He also drew the attention of provincial 16 government to importance of issues such as lessons learning, handling quick staff turnover for effective implementation. He also stressed the importance of monitoring progress on outcomes in addition to the processes alone. He also agreed to move ahead with the issue on adoption of country systems provided a more robust and detailed discussion covering all aspects of this theme is undertaken in a collaborative manner, especially on the basis of sectors or groups of sectors. The representative from Canadian High Commission appreciated the holding of an interactive dialogue on three counts. Firstly, ownership of this dialogue by Chief Minister and his cabinet colleagues was important in terms of facilitating effective decision-making. Secondly, it was heartening to note the discussion round the theme of accountability and he offered to support local government electoral reforms for enhancing accountability. Thirdly, he appreciated the fact that themes of communication and involving people in local governance debate were being tabled for dialogue and as a way forward. At this stage, Mr. Muhammad Atif, Minister for E&SE, highlighted the government’s efforts for de-politicization of governance in the province. He informed the audience that postings and transfers in the province had been depoliticized for improved working of government departments. 163 disciplinary cases had so far been initiated. These are politically tough decisions but owing to CM, we are able to take tough decisions including merit-based recruitments, disciplinary proceedings, student-teacher 17 rationalization and launch of management information systems for strict accountability in education sector. Chief Minister concluded the discussion by highlighting the importance of discussing progress in future against targets. He highlighted the importance of generating more revenues through improved taxation systems in the province. He also expressed the resolve of introducing local governance reforms as cornerstone of pro-poor reforms. He expressed the opinion that holding of local bodies’ elections in KP on biometric system could be a breakthrough in country which could be replicated in other provinces by Election Commission. He also desired to put in place a mechanism for joint progress review through an inclusive committee with well-defined terms of reference. Head of DFID Pakistan made concluding remarks from the side of development partners. He was thanked the government for organizing this frank but structured dialogue and welcomed the response from Chief Minister and his cabinet colleagues. He requested provincial government’s attention to the two key issues of future of local governance reforms with or without local government elections as well as on the future shape of engagement with provincial government. He suggested a monthly or bimonthly stock taking of progress against mutually agreed outcomes which would be covering both provincial as well as local levels. Lastly, he expressed the hope that a document on achievements against outcome areas could be produced by provincial government in the coming months. The session ended with concluding remarks by Chief Secretary who thanked the participants of interactive dialogue and expressed the resolve of provincial government for fast-track progress on reform agenda in the province. 18 ACTION POINTS FROM HIGH LEVEL DIALOGUE Sr# Decision 1 Implementation Delays in ADP utilization will be minimized P&D Department All Administrative Secretaries 2 Existing monitoring by P&D and Reform Implementation Cell to be strengthened for producing & sharing evidence of progress across all reform sectors/initiatives on regular basis P&D Department Directorate General M&E Change Management Unit Reform Implementation cell 3 Operationalization of Performance-based Incentives system in School Education Department for teachers & Managers Secretary Elementary & Secondary Education 4 Monthly Progress Review of ADP utilization and implementation P&D Department Administrative Secretaries 5 Secretary’s Committee meeting for progress stocktaking and resolving implementation hurdles Establishment and Administration Department 6 Performance Monitoring System at the district level against well-defined benchmarks 7 Formation of a Government-Development Partners Committee for regularly reviewing progress on implementation of Local Governance Reforms in KP covering following areas 8 Establishment and Administration Department Secretary Local Government enabling legislative spadework, improved electoral processes, creating citizen awareness on proposed LG reforms and resolving capacity issues in LG employees Formation of an inclusive (Apex) committee including government as well as development partners (from within Sectoral Coordination Committees) for joint review of reform progress and implementation issues 19 Implementation Responsibility P&D Department ANNEX 1: PROGRAMME STRUCTURE Sr.# Agenda Item Responsibility Time Guests to be seated 1100 1 Recitation from Holy Quran 1110 2 Welcome address Additional Chief Secretary 1115 3 Progress update (presentation) Secretary P&D 1120 4 Key Note Remarks Chief Minister 1130 5 Discussion on agenda items Moderated by Secretary P&D 1135 6 Concluding Remarks Chief Secretary 1250 Lunch 20 ANNEX 2: PRESENTATION BY SECRETARY P&D, KHYBER PAKHTUNKHWA 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 ANNEX 3: LIST OF PARTICIPANTS List 1: Provincial Ministers/Member Provincial Assembly Sr# Name Designation 1 Pervez Khattak Chief Minister 2 Shahram Khan Senior Minister for Health and ST&IT 3 Inayat Ullah Khan Senior Minister for Local Government Elections and Rural Development 4 Muhammad Atif Elementary and Secondary Education List 2: Government Executives and Officials Sr# Name Designation Organization 1 Amjad Ali Khan Chief Secretary 2 Khalid Pervez Additional Chief Secretary P&D Department 3 Syed Zafar Ali Shah Secretary P&D Department 4 Afzal Latif Secretary Education Department 5 Aftab Durrani Secretary Health Department 6 Sahibzada Saeed Ahmad Secretary Energy & Power Department 7 S. Hidayat Jan Secretary Social Welfare Department 8 Fazal Nabi Khan Secretary Population Welfare Department 9 M. Humayun Secretary Transport Department 10 Jamil Ahmed Secretary LG&RD Department 11 Akhtar Ali Shah Secretary Home Department 12 Akhtar Nazir Warraich Secretary Establishment Department 13 Dr. Raheel Ahmad Secretary E&T Department 14 Masood Khan Secretary Information Department 15 Syed Said Badshah Bukhari Secretary Finance Department 16 Ahmad Hanif Secretary C&W Department 17 Mian Waheeduddin Secretary M&M Department 18 Usman Yaqub Special Secretary Agriculture Department 31 19 Sajid Gul Secretary Delimitation Authority LG&RD Department 20 Shah Rehman Director General SDU – P&D Department 21 Dr. Ambar Ali Khan DG M&E P&D Department 22 Zahir Shah Additional Secretary Home Department 23 Taseer Jamal Executive Director UPU-P&D 24 Ziaullah Khan Toru Director AntiCorruption Establishment Department 25 Ayesha Ihsan Assistant Chief P&D Department 26 Abdul Haleem Chief Coordination P&D Department 27 Umar Farooq Manager GIS 28 M. Arshad Deputy Reform Coordinator 29 Nasir Azam A.P.O 30 Kamal Jehangir Chief Engineer Irrigation Department 31 Tanzeela Sabahat Chief Education P&D Department 32 Ali Raza Khan Chief F.Aid P&D Department 33 Samiullah Khan SPO UPU-P&D 34 Zainab Khatoon Research Officer P&D Department 35 Muhammad Islam Asst. Chief RD P&D Department 36 Waqas Salaheen Business Development Officer Transport Department 37 Dr. Idrees Masood Chief E&P P&D Department 38 Maqsood Gul Asst. Chief F.Aid P&D Department 39 Dilroze Khan Focal Person Donor Coordination Chief Minister Secretariat 40 Noroz Khan Director Exploration M&M Department 41 Saleem Jan Asst. Chief P&D Department 42 Abdul Malik Joint Secretary (PF) Finance Division 43 Umair Gondal NDU RMU-Finance Department List 3: Representatives of the Development Partners Sr# Name Designation Organization 1 Richard Montgomery Head DFID 2 Lars Gunnar Wigemark Ambassador EU 32 3 Rashid Bin Masud Country Director World Bank 4 Mitsuyoshi Kawasadi Chief JICA 5 David Fournier Head of Aid Canadian High Commission 6 B. Framis Head of Coop EU 7 Izam Schwendinger Head UN Resident Coordinator’s Office 8 Weingari Matthias Director of Coop SDC 9 Greg Huger Deputy Mission Director USAID 10 Mandy Zekcra Counsellor Development German Embassy 11 Akwut Knep 12 Sakandar Ali Representative for KP DFID 13 Ben French Governance Advisor DFID 14 Bill Kilby DFID 15 John Crihfield USAID 16 Ousman Jah World Bank 17 Arshad Abbasi Program Officer JICA 18 Ehtisham Khattak Energy Specialist ADB 19 Eva Asamabwra 20 Tracy Vienings German Embassy EU Deputy UNDP List 4: Media Representatives Sr# Name Designation Organization 1 Javed Kazmi PTV News 2 Nasir Saleem Express News 2 Asif ARY News 4 Aizaz Geo News 5 Zulfiqar Samaa 6 Bilal Khan Camera Man Metro TV 7 Peer Muhammad Reporter Khyber TV 8 Azam Siddique 9 Azhar Jatoi Reporter Ajj 10 Tooba Niazi Reporter Ajj 33 Khyber TV 11 Bilal Javeed Operator 12 Rameez Media Vision 13 Shafaat Media Vision 14 Mehtab Media Vision 15 Riyasat Ali Khyber News 16 Jamshed Khan 17 Muhammad Hafeez Camera Man DSNG ATPN AAJ List 5: Others Sr# Name Designation Organization 1 David Hoole Chief Technical Advisor Sub-National Governance Program 2 Nasir Khan Program Manager Sub-National Governance Program 3 Akmal Minnallah PFM Advisor Sub-National Governance Program 4 Jawaria Jillani Social Development Advisor Sub-National Governance Program 5 Khalid Khan Team Leader (KP) Sub-National Governance Program 6 Rizwan Mahbood Governance Advisor (KP) Sub-National Governance Program 7 Mohammad Fayyaz M&E Advisor (KP) Sub-National Governance Program 8 Jehanzeb Pervez PFM Advisor (KP) Sub-National Governance Program 9 Abid Awan Financial Consultant (KP) Sub-National Governance Program 10 Umar Khan Coordinator Governance Support Project 11 Mohammad Atif Communication Specialist Governance Support Project 12 Salman Donor CoordinatorSDPF Unit Governance Support Project 13 Nasiba Communication Specialist-SDPF Unit Governance Support Project 14 Asadullh Sajid ECO Education Network 34