Chapter 5 Elasticity You are responsible for reading Chapter 4!!! What have we done? • Chapter 3 gave us downward sloping demand curves – Law of demand • Now want to see how Qd changes when price changes Elasticity • Response of one variable to a change in another variable • Price elasticity of demand – Measure of the responsiveness of Qd of a product to a change in the price of that product %Q Ed %P Qd Q Ed P P So… • What if Ed = 3? – If price was increased from the prevailing point the % change in Qd would be 3 times the change in price • Shouldn’t it be negative? – So price increases and Qd decreases? • Yes!! – For ease we look at the absolute value, but know that the law of demand holds Point elasticity • Measures the change between two observed points. Qb Qa Qd Qa Q Ed P Pb Pa P Pa example • • • • • • • P1 = 10 P2 = 12 Q1 = 100 Q2 = 50 Elasticity?? Which is Point A??? Big Problem!!! 50 100 100 A 1; 2 .5 12 10 10 100 50 50 A 2; 6 10 12 12 Problem • Answers vary depending on where you start • Becomes more important the larger the change Arc Elasticity • To avoid the endpoint problem take elasticity at the midpoint (average) of the two points Qd Qd 1 Qd 2 Qd 1 Qd 2 Qd 1 Qd 2 2 2 Ed P P1 P2 P1 P2 P1 P2 2 2 Differences • With arc elasticity it is clear which points are used • P1 is the first price • P2 is the second price • Qd and Qd are the first and second quantity demanded respectively 1 2 Price elasticity of demand can yield 5 basic results • • • • • • Numerator > Denominator Numerator < Denominator Numerator = Denominator Numerator = 0 Denominator = 0 Each has a specific name and result Elastic Demand • Ed > 1 • % change in quantity demanded > % change in price • FLATTER CURVE • What are some examples of an elastic good??? Inelastic Demand • Ed<1 • % change in the price > percent change in quantity demanded • STEEPER CURVE • What are some examples of an inelastic good? Price Elasticity of Demand Price Part (a) Price Part (b) Ed < 1 Inelastic Ed > 1 Elastic P2 P1 P2 10% 10% P1 D 20% 4% D 0 Q2 Q1 Quantity Demanded 0 Q2 Q1 Quantity Demanded Unit Elastic Demand • Ed=1 • % change in price = % change in quantity demanded • Change in price brings a proportionate change in quantity demanded • CURVE Price Elasticity of Demand Part (c) Price Ed = 1 Unit Elastic P2 P1 10% D 10% 0 Q2 Q1 Quantity Demanded Perfectly Elastic Demand • Ed = (denominator = 0) • % change in quantity demanded is A LOT in response to a change in price • Price increases and quantity demanded goes to 0 • Totally flat --- horizontal • Extreme • Examples??? Perfectly inelastic demand • Ed = 0 • % change in quantity demanded DOESN’T CHANGE in response to a change in price • Totally steep --- vertical • Extreme • Examples??? Price Price Elasticity of Demand Part (d) Part (e) Price D P2 P1 0 Ed = 0 Perfectly Inelastic Ed = Perfectly Elastic 1% P2 D Q1 Quantity Demanded P1 0 10% Q1 Quantity Demanded Aren’t demand curve downward sloping? • Because the extremes (perfectly inelastic and perfectly elastic) are not. • Use as points of reference only How does a change in price affect Total Revenue of a Firm? • Revenue depends on elasticity • Michael Jordan and Nike shoes – No substitutes -- inelastic demand • What happens to Qd if price increases? – Substitutes – elastic demand • What happens to Qd if price increases? What is total revenue?? • Total revenue = price*quantity • Firm uses to decide if to produce more or less examples • Elastic demand – Price increase – Price decrease • Inelastic demand – Price increase – Price decrease • Unit elastic demand – Price increase – Price decrease P TR P TR P TR P TR P TR P TR Ed > 1 Ed < 1 Ed = 1 Elasticities, Price Changes, and Total Revenue Important to look at because… • Elasticity of the demand determines if with a price increase… – Total revenue increases – Total revenue decreases – Total revenue remains the same Price elasticity of demand and a straight line • Demand is downward sloping • Along the line elasticity varies from highly elastic to highly inelastic • But…remember SLOPE is constant Point A B C D E F G P 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 Qd 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Price Elasticity of Demand along a Demand Curve Price (dollars) (3) (1) (2) QUANTITY (4) POINT PRICE DEMANDED Ed Elastic Range 8 A 7 Unit Elastic Range B A $8 3 2.14 B 7 4 1.44 C 6 5 1.00 D 5 6 0.69 E F G 4 7 3 C 5 Inelastic Range D 4 E 3 F 0.47 2 0.29 1 8 2 6 G 9 1 (a) 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Quantity Demanded (b) 9 D Summary • Upper end of Demand Curve – Qd is low and price is high – Freak out more when price is high • Lower end of Demand Curve – Qd is high and price is low – Freak out less when price is low So… • As move down the demand curve from higher prices to lower the price elasticity of demand goes from elastic to inelastic Determinates of price elasticity of demand • Number of substitutes available – Increase substitutes increases elasticity – More narrowly defined goods have more substitutes (compared to broadly defined) • Example: Fords vs all cars More determinates • Percentage of one’s budget that is spent on the good – More expensive??? More elastic – More affected by price (even small changes) Final determinate • Amount of time that passed since price change – Increase time passed gives more opportunity to change behavior or react to price change – Overtime can look for substitutes – Increase time increases elasticity – More elastic in long term than short Cross Elasticity of Demand • Measures the responsiveness of quantity demanded to a change in price of Qx 2 Qx1 ANOTHER good Qx 2 Qx1 % Qdx 2 Ec Py 2 Py1 % Py Py 2 Py1 2 When would you use Cross Price Elasticity? • To determine if goods are substitutes or compliments • Ec>0 – substitutes – % change in quantity demanded and price move in same direction • Ec<0 – compliments – % change in quantity demanded and price move in opposite directions • Ec=0 – goods unrelated Income elasticity of demand • Measures the responsiveness of quantity demanded to the change in income Qx 2 Qx1 Qx 2 Qx1 %Qd 2 Ey Y2 Y1 %income Y2 Y1 2 Why use income elasticity of demand? • Use to determine if a good is normal or inferior • Ey>0 – normal good – As income increases Qd increases • Ey<0 – inferior good – As income increases Qd decreases Can also say… • If |Ey| > 1 – % change in Qd > % change in Y – Income elastic • If |Ey| < 1 – % change in Qd < % change in Y – Income inelastic • If |Ey| = 1 – % change in Qd = % change in Y – Income unit elastic Can we use income elasticity in the real world?? • If invest in the stock market do you want to invest in a normal or inferior good? • Normal • Why • Increase income would increase quantity bought and increase stock prices Price Elasticity of Supply • Measures the responsiveness of quantity supplied of a good to the change in the price of that good Qs1 Qs 2 %Qs Qs1 Qs 2 Qs 2 Es %P P1 P2 P P1 P2 2 Classification is like demand • Es > 1 – Elastic • Es < 1 – Inelastic • Es = 1 – Unit elastic • Each of these will result in a “normal” upward sloped supply curve Any extreme elasticities??? • Yes!! • Es = elastic or horizontal – Perfectly • Es = 0 – Perfectly inelastic or vertical Price Elasticity of Supply Price Part (a) Price Part (b) S Es > 1 Elastic P2 P1 S P2 10% P1 20% 0 Q1 Q2 Quantity Supplied Es < 1 Inelastic 10% 4% 0 Q1 Q2 Quantity Supplied Price Elasticity of Supply Part (c) Price S P2 P1 Es = 1 Unit Elastic 10% 10% 0 Q1 Q2 Quantity Supplied Price Elasticity of Supply Price Part (d) Es = • Perfectly Elastic P1 0 P2 S Q1 Quantity Supplied Part (e) S Price P1 0 Es = 0 Perfectly Inelastic 10% Q1 Quantity Supplied Does time play a role in elasticity of supply? • Yes!! • Overtime producers are able to adjust their behavior and production patterns • Supply becomes more elastic as time passes Elasticity and taxes • If government levies a tax on a product who pays the tax?? • Producers?? Consumers?? Share?? • Depends on the elasticity of demand and supply How find?? • • • • Find equilibrium price Supply shifts left in the amount of the tax Find new equilibrium Find point of second equilibrium on ORGINAL supply curve – Shows the actual price realized by firm or equilibrium price – tax = point in question • Difference between points determines how much of tax you pay Who Pays the Tax? Price (dollars) Part of tax paid by consumers in terms of higher price paid. S2 (after tax) S1 (before tax) 9.00 8.50 B A $1 Tax 8.00 7.50 Part of tax paid by producers in terms of lower price kept. D1 0 Q2 Q1 Quantity of VCR Tapes Who pays more of the tax?? • • • • Perfectly inelastic demand Perfectly elastic demand Demand more elastic than supply Supply more elastic than demand Different Elasticities and Who Pays the Tax Part (a) Price (dollars) Part (b) Price (dollars) S2 D1 Producers pay full tax S1 9.00 S2 S1 $1 Tax B $1 Tax B 8.00 A A 8.00 D1 0 Q2 Q1 Quantity of VCR Tapes Consumers pay full tax 0 Q1 Quantity of VCR Tapes Different Elasticities and Who Pays the Tax Part (b) Part (a) Price (dollars) Price (dollars) S2 D1 Producers pay full tax S1 9.00 S2 S1 $1 Tax B $1 Tax B 8.00 8.00 A A D1 Consumers pay full tax 0 Q1 Quantity of VCR Tapes 0 Q1 Q2 Quantity of VCR Tapes Summary • Ed > Es producer bears most of the tax burden • Ed < Es consumer bears most of the tax burden • Ed = Es equally share the tax burden Homework Numbers 5, 6, and 8 Working with Graphs and Numbers 1, 2, and 4 Do we understand Chapter 5??