Chapter 1 Not as much why or should; it’s which values and how? Who decides right vs. wrong? Being ethical creates trust, loyalty, commitment, creativity, and initiative It leads to problem avoidance, cost containment, improved constituency relationships, enhanced work life, increased competitiveness List of “why be ethical” on p. 32 Spectrum of freedom, law, ethics Vocabulary Stakeholders Normative ethics vs. descriptive ethics Values: underlying beliefs that cause us to act or to decide one way rather than another Ethics: how human beings should properly live their lives Ethical values Corporate Culture: what is normal about how we behave in the company Organizational risk assessment Responsible decision-making (personal and organizational) because it will result in more responsible behavior Connection between knowledge and behavior Manage the ethical behavior of others Business leaders have a responsibility for the business environments they create Skill of ethical business leadership: to create the circumstances within which good people are able to do good and bad people are prevented from doing bad LSP’s Reading Figure 1.1 (p.31) Titanic puzzle: less-expensive but faulty or potentially harmful products Chapter 2 What makes a decision involve ethics? (p.77) Businesspeople causing focusing failures / inattentional blindness to prevent you from factoring ethics into the decision Normative myopia Change blindness Bounded ethicality (part of the team at work, pleasing the boss) 7-step decision-making model 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Identify the facts Identify the ethical issues Identify the stakeholders Consider available alternatives: moral imagination Compare and weigh the alternatives a. Rawls justice: walk a mile in their shoes b. Predict the likely, foreseeable, and possible consequences; seek to create benefit and mitigate, minimize, or compensate for harm c. Are any principles, rights, and duties involved? d. What of your integrity, virtue, and character? 6. Make a decision and act on it 7. Monitor and learn from the outcomes Stumbling blocks to Ethical Decision-making Cognitive or intellectual o Consider limited alternatives o Simplified decision rules: finders keepers, losers weepers o Minimum decision criteria: satisficing Easier to do the wrong thing Lack the courage to do the right thing: go with the flow o Culture of intimidation or fear o Peer pressure Parable of the Sadhu High adrenaline flow Superordinate goal Once-in-a-lifetime opportunity The value of a process for identifying and responding to ethics issues When Good People Do Bad Things at Work Scripts (keep people out of highly repetitive situations) Distractions (motivating or requiring employees to be focused and driven) Moral exclusion (Eisai Pharma. = moral inclusion) Chapter 3 Ethical relativism 1. Utilitarianism / consequences: maximize the overall happiness Problems o How to measure consequences o No principles (e.g., allowed slavery) The Child labor discussion Ultimate goal of ethics: impartial promotion of human well-being 2. Principles/Rights Rules/Principles create ethical duties Legal, organizational, role-based, professional Categorical imperative justice: equality of outcome vs. of opportunity 3. Virtue: who a person is How are character traits formed and conditioned? In the workplace? Feinberg and executive compensation (p.129) Ruggie’s Guiding Principles: Protect, Respect, and Remedy Extraterritorial jurisdiction Safe harbor Chapter 4 Corporate culture (e.g., like an iceberg regarding movement and change) Heskett, Sasser, and Wheeler: strong, adaptive cultures (list of 10) Toyota: how culture can be positive and how it can be negative The effect of workplace culture on decision-making Compliance-based cultures vs. values-based cultures HOW to create a culture of ethics Role of leadership (e.g., role model—visible ethical action, connecting ethical behavior to success) Ethics officer Dedication of resources Integration Assessment Monitoring Determine its mission Vision Code of Conduct Processes and procedures Ethics hotlines (should be called a “helpline”) Incentives So much more Ethical, effective leader vs. effective leader (methods and ends/objectives) Key elements of successful codes Whistleblowing: how the organization can have an effective systems of internal reporting USSC guidelines (FSGO) Mitigated penalty vs. aggravated penalty The seven steps The 2010 amendments Credo is about personal responsibility 96.6% make whistleblowing a duty of employment Confidentiality vs. anonymity