Healthy Eating Without Costing the Earth Research & Training 2015 Delivered by Lourdes Youth and Community Services www.lycs.ie 1 THREATS FOR FUTURE OF FOOD 2 Life expectancy in Ireland is 80. What year will you turn 80? What year will your kids/grandkids turn 80? What will life be like on Earth then? 3 Our food system CAUSES climate change (40% total emissions) climate change THREATENS our food supply 4 The global food system as a whole produces nearly 40% of carbon emissions. This includes producing, packaging, transporting, storing and cooking food Worldwide livestock farming generates 18% of the planet's greenhouse gas emissions. Transport is only 13%of greenhouse gas emissions. This obviously has major implications for food policy. 2006 report by the UN Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) 5 Land - land ownership, esp in developing world is v unequal and dates to colonial times. Soil - since 1960, one-third of the world’s arable land has been lost through erosion and other degradation. Water - By 2025, two-thirds of the world’s population may face water shortages. Seeds/Genetic Modification - In last few decades a few huge companies have used intellectual property laws to commodify the world seed supply 6 It has taken between 50-300 million years to form, and yet we have managed to burn roughly half of all global oil reserves in merely 125 years or so. Cheap oil is running out. Oil is now being consumed four times faster than it is being discovered, and the situation is becoming critical. 7 The global population of 7.2 billion is set to increase to 9.6 billion by 2050 Many will want ‘western diet’ 8 Poverty reduction – more people in the economy Growing inequality Urbanisation & Westernisation Climate change Peak Oil & Growing energy demands Mass species extinction Soil, air, water pollution Hunger Obesity & disease of affluence Growing population, but rate slowing Corporate control/Free trade 9 10 LABOUR ISSUES 11 Banana Worker Shipper Shops & Supermarket Importer & Ripener Plantation Owner 12 Banana worker 1p Plantation owner 5p Shipper 4p Shop or supermarket 13p Importer and ripener 7p Total 30p 13 As food producers become locked into global food chains, their prices are forced downwards, they try to stay profitable by increasing their use of flexible labour. IN UK in 2002–03 a cut-throat price war by supermarkets on bananas led to prices falling by over 20 per cent, thus, the extremely low prices then being paid would have made it impossible for Costa Rican growers to continue to pay their workers the legal minimum wage. 14 In general, work in food sector, becoming more informal, less reliable. Women tend to get more casual and informal work. Migrants also vulnerable to exploitation Huge TNCs have the most power, and can control wages so as to keep profits up. Safety issues are also a concern e.g. use of chemicals, fertilisers for agricultural workers. Child labour e.g. cocoa & coffee industries Slave labour e.g. Thai shrimp industry 15 FOOD IS BIG BUSINESS 16 The Problems with Processed • • • • • • • Unhealthy – high sugar, salt, fat Addictive ingredients to sell Cheap Fillers e.g. cellulose, horse Lower welfare (people and animals) More impact planet High marketing, e.g. to kids Less educated, poorer more susceptible 17 Invents a new product/a new desire or ‘need’ Adds ‘value’ (profit) to food items e.g. Turns cheap or free (US corn) crop into highly profitable We pay for the ads and marketng and packaging ‘Externalises’ costs such as water, soil, land 18 Monoculture Needs lots of fertiliser & pesticide & water Huge areas land, removes people & animals Needs lots oil Send all over world GMO in US etc. Some subsidised e.g. Corn in US Floods 3rd world markets, small farmers lose 19 Big business Relies on cheap raw materials such as corn, soy, wheat, sugar, palm oil Grown using pesticides, lots of oil etc. Often uses bulkers e.g. wood or water Advertising & marketing important 20 21 22 High commodity costs Low labour costs TV ownership Low fat fad Access to water, environmental protection laws Intensive chicken farming antibiotics fertilisers cheap oil Grow it Yourself GMOs people in cash economy Subsistence agriculture Free trade laws 23 Product: ___________________________ Company: __________________________ Your profits rose by 21% this year. Congratulations! We’d love to know more about how you managed this. Can you tell us a bit about the product? What bulking agents did you use to reduce the raw material bill? What other innovative technology did you avail of? (GMO, antibiotics, modern pesticides etc.) You also own the plantation in ____________. How did you deal with the emerging trade union movement there, which is trying to get higher wages for workers? Do you avail of any off-shore tax solutions? Do you enjoy any government subsidies or have you benefited from any recent free trade agreements? Environmental legislation is a growing problem for many manufacturers in that part of the world, due to the threat of climate change, soil erosion and habitat destruction. How did you minimise costs in this area? What about the demand from consumers and government to lessen dangerous additives and sugar? What was your marketing strategy? Which age group did you target and why? 24 25 Fertilisers (after 2nd World War from munitions plus cheap oil) Consequences: Monoculture to produce large amount grain/other cash crops • Disease from processed food in US, UK • Hunger when poor can’t buy food • Loss habitats/biodiversity/climate change/soil erosion What to do with surplus? • Give as Food Aid to 3rd World (make dependent) • Process to add value • Force Free Trade laws to open new markets Pesticides to control pests from monoculture Antibiotics for intensive produced animals 26 27 28 2 billion extra people to feed Many demanding more meat, animal produce Climate change – reduced fertile land Water scarcity? Peak oil, lack cheap energy? Soil degradation Who owns seeds? 29 Some Global Food Issues 30 FEED THE WORLD? 31 2.1 billion people – nearly 30% of the world’s population – are either obese or overweight (The Lancet) Huge rise in last 30 years Major public health epidemic in both the developed and the developing world. 32 Obesity rises in line with inequality (e.g. US high, Japan low) Lower education/income associated with obesity Poorer (low and middle income countries) now seeing huge rise in obesity & related illnesses those on $1/$2 a day target market for food corporations 33 34 805 million people of the 7.3 billion people in the world, or one in nine, hungry. 42 percent reduction in the prevalence of undernourished people between 1990–92 and 2012–14. World produces more than enough food, but these people lack land to grow or money to buy food. 35 36 In rich countries since 1970s , more processed foods, away from home eating and more edible oils and sugar-sweetened drinks. Less exercise. In poorer countries from early 1990s but only recognized when diabetes, hypertension and obesity began to dominate the globe. Few countries are serious in addressing prevention of the dietary challenges faced. “Western diet.” high intake of refined carbohydrates, added sugars, fats, and animal-source foods. Diets rich in legumes, other vegetables, and coarse grains are disappearing in all regions and countries. 37 38 Western Diet and Disease 39 40 41 9 biscuits = global food supply Following is LOST: 1 biscuit = lost @ farm (e.g. no fridges) 2 biscuits = 3 fed to livestock, but 2/3 of that turns to heat and feces 2 = throw away directly into bins. 42 Ireland is 8th-13th richest countries in the world 11th most developed, UNHDI (education, income, life expectancy) 43 66% of men and 60% women overweight or obese Higher than European average and growing rapidly Four out of five over-50s in Ireland are overweight or obese. 1 in 4 children is overweight or obese 440 diabetes-related amputations were carried out in 2014 44 Number % all deaths 1. Coronary Heart Disease 5,276 22.76 2. Stroke 2,107 9.09 3. Lung Cancers 1,669 7.20 4. Influenza & Pneumonia 1,536 6.63 5. Lung Disease 1,248 5.38 6. Colon-Rectum Cancers 1,039 4.48 7. Alzheimers/Dementia 874 3.77 8. Breast Cancer 806 3.48 9. Prostate Cancer 525 2.26 10. Diabetes Mellitus 474 2.04 45 46 Food poverty is on the rise in Ireland with over 600,000 people affected in 2013 (1 in 10) defined as the inability to afford or access healthy food children, lone-parent families and the unemployed hit particularly hard. One in five of our children go to school or bed hungry 47 In small groups take 3 photos of low, middle and high income country family & what they eat in 1 week. Compare photos from the 3 places. What are main differences Which are healthier, more sustainable diets? What do the pictures say about trends in food as we get richer? Why are diets changing? How do the photos compare to food consumed in Ireland past and present? 48 WHAT INFLUENCES FOOD CHOICES 49 What people chose to put in their own mouths is a personal choice and responsibility 50 An Guatemalan farmer who lives off land and sells corn in local market A lone parent non-driver in council flats in north east inner city Dublin, family benefit, 4 kids A disabled elderly person living in residential care in Monaghan 51 Amount of land they have and the weather/climate Price of food Their class, social group or ethnicity Government advice on healthy eating e.g. food pyramid Food advertising Fussy eating in kids What is available nearby Weight-loss diets, or other special diets e.g. diabetes Cooking skills Climate change Commodity prices on stock exchange Trade agreements Culture Large corporate influence 52 Car/House/Body exercise 53 FOOD ADVICE 54 What we hear Alternative voices Eat lots of starchy food Starchy food is similar to sugar and makes us fat, esp. if added sugar or white version Fat is bad, chose low fat Fat is fine, chose full fat. Low fat and high sugar/processing is worse Chose low cholesterol food Cholesterol in diet is ok, epigenetics decide if problem for you Have some meat Meat is bad for planet. OR Meat is great, eat lots. (paleo) Sugar is bad No evidence that sugar is bad ‘Health Food Made Easy Programme’ Junk food is bad Junk food is bad! 55 56 Food Advice via Big Business Ignore mainstream nutritional advice. Many big nutritional bodies are funded by Big Sugar http://iquitsugar.com/funded-by-big-sugar/ 57 58 59 CHOSING FOOD 60 Which is alive? A Robot Vs A Person 61 Which produces what we need? 62 Which is healthier? 63 Chose plants, not food from a plant Foods, not food products. Enjoy your food, think about what you are putting in (maximum nutrients) not what you are depriving yourself of 64 65 66 Sugars Palm Oil, Refined veg oil, trans fats Industrial Crops/maybe GMO, corn and soy Fillers, e.g. cellulose Salt Non Irish meats Unsustainable fish products Fish or meat products or parts 67 Total sugar content. Should be less than 5% or 5gm per 100gm to be low sugar food. Allow extra 5gm more if a diary product as lactose is sugar. Divide gms of sugar by 4 to get teaspoons e.g. 8gm is 2 teaspoons. Max per day should be 6-9 for adults. Most getting 35-40 teaspoons. 68 69 Margarine – a healthy food? 70 How many ingredients? Can you pronounce? How much nutrition? Protein, iron, calcium.. Fat. Most oils (fat) in processed food are refined and not healthy. Low Fat/No fat Many experts say full fat diary is healthier as less refined. Salt Controversial whether we should avoid, but unrefined has more minerals. 71 Do we need a points or traffic light system for food health/sustainablility? 72 Look at nutritional info – do you have any high sugar or high fat foods. Is it healthy fat? Do you have non-food ingredients? Do you trust them? Compare the label images and claims with the nutritional info – any differences? Where do you think the main ingredients come from (small sustainable farm/ large industrial farms/Ireland or abroad/factory or farm) ? Which ingredients are addictive? Which are ‘bulkers’ or ‘enhancers’? Do you think any nutrients have been lost in the product? Is it good value for money in terms of nutrition? If no price, guess. Do you think your items are made sustainably? 73 74 Aspartame, (E951) (aka Nutrasweet ,Amino Sweet). Nuurotoxin and carcinogen. Known to erode intelligence and affect short-term memory. Other adverse effects: brain tumor, diseases like lymphoma, diabetes, multiple sclerosis, Parkinson’s, Alzheimer’s, fibromyalgia, and chronic fatigue, emotional disorders like depression and anxiety attacks, dizziness, headaches, nausea, mental confusion, migraines and seizures. 75 A relatively new artificial sweetener found in baking goods, gum and gelatin, has not been thoroughly tested and has been linked to kidney tumors. 76 Flavour enhancer. MSG is known as an excitotoxin, a substance which overexcites cells to the point of damage or death. Regular consumption may result in depression, disorientation, eye damage, fatigue, headaches, and obesity. Found in: Chinese food (Chinese Restaurant Syndrome ) many snacks, chips, cookies, seasonings, most Campbell Soup products, frozen dinners, lunch meats 77 Trans fat extends the shelf life of food products is among the most dangerous substances that you can consume. Banned in Denmark increases the risk of heart attacks, heart disease and strokes, and contributes to increased inflammation, diabetes and other health problems. Found in: margarine, chips and crackers, baked goods, fast foods. 78 A source of sugar used in processed food especially drinks Contributes to heart disease, obesity, cancer, dementia, liver failure, tooth decay. 79 May contribute to behavioural problems in children and lead to a significant reduction in IQ. Animal studies have linked other food colourings to cancer. Watch out for these ones: Blue #1 and Blue #2 (E133), Banned in Norway, Finland and France. May cause chromosomal damage Red dye # 3 (also Red #40 – a more current dye) (E124) Banned in 1990 after 8 years of debate from use in many foods and cosmetics. This dye continues to be on the market until supplies run out! Has been proven to cause thyroid cancer and chromosomal damage in laboratory animals, may also interfere with brain-nerve transmission. Yellow #6 (E110) and Yellow Tartrazine (E102). Banned in Norway and Sweden. Increases the number of kidney and adrenal gland tumours in laboratory animals, may cause chromosomal damage. Found in: American cheese, sweets and carbonated beverages, lemonade and more. 80 Organic Fair trade Sustainable Made in Ireland Low fat/fat free Contains Omega 3 Natural Flavourings Traceable 81 Healthy antioxidants and lower levels of toxic metals and pesticides. (latest 2014 researchhttp://www.theguardian.com/environment/2014/jul/11/organic-food-moreantioxidants-study) switching to organic fruit and veg could give the same benefits as adding 1 or 2 portions of the recommended "five a day". Organic farming protects soil and pollutes water less. BUT it is more expensive. Check out Dirty Dozen list of most toxic fruit and veg. 82 True or False - processed/junk food is cheaper, which is why disadvantaged groups are more likely to chose it. 83 HEALTHY EATING ON A BUDGET 84 NOT GREAT BETTER BEST Cornflakes & Skimmed Milk Ready Brek & Full fat milk Organic Porridge & Homemade Kefir or Raw milk Packet of Crisps Packet of Popcorn Bag unsalted nuts Fish & Chips Take Away Prawn Cocktail (prawns from Thailand) Tesco Coleslaw Centra Breakfast Roll Burger & Chips Take Away Can of Coke Cup a Soup Nutrigrain Bar 85 Instead of this: Get this: Tesco Value Chicken Curry & Rice (for one) €1.29 2 Value fillets, healthy tikka sauce, frozen peas, pepper, sweet corn. €2.40 per person Potatoes Sweet Potatoes StrawberryYoghurt Natural Yoghurt with fresh fruit Frozen chips Sweet potato wedges homemade Packet of crisps Packet of popcorn (not cheesey one) Bacon & Egg Sandwich Egg Sandwich, egg and cheese sandwich 86 Tesco Chicken nuggets and Moy Park whole chicken, almost same price per kilo, €4, but nuggets only 55% chicken Bowl organic porridge and Tesco Cornflakes both 10c, but porridge much healthier Tesco Value Cod fillets, €11.96/kg, Birds Eye Fish Fingers, €10.69/kg 58% Pollock, Tesco value Fish Fingers €3.88/kg, 65% Pollock. Donegal Catch Breaded Cod €14.98/kg Tesco Everyday Value Chicken Curry 400G €1.29 but 13% chicken 87 Tinned wild salmon Tinned cooked beans Tinned Tuna Organic potatoes Organic/Free Range Eggs Sweet Potatoes Large natural live yoghurt Organic cheddar cheese Mussels , cod, smoked makerel Sundried tomatoes (though have preservative) Avocados, bag €2 Organic minced beef Brown Rice Whole wheat pasta Almonds, other nuts Brown pitta bread Nuts in shell Free range chicken Organic apples, oranges Tinned tomatoes, passata Fair trade organic bananas Olives Organic porridge oats Range fruit and veg 88 TIPS HEALTHY SUSTAINABLE EATING 89 90 91 92 93 Real (whole) food, i.e. food in the form that it grows in. The less done to it the better. Cook from scratch as much as possible. Vegetables (fresh or frozen, preferably Irish grown in season) Fruit (as above, whole and fresh better than juice or dried but all have nutrients) Pulses e.g. Peas, beans, lentils (cook from dried or in cans but not in sauce) Eggs (free range if affordable) Poultry (free range if affordable) Fresh fish (sea caught, not farmed) Nuts, seeds, nut and seed butters Tinned fish (esp. dolphin friendly or pole and line caught) Healthy oils (e.g. olive oil, coconut oil) Avocados Live yoghurt, whole milk Unprocessed cheese, any type Organic soya products Irish beef, lamb, pork (not cold cooked meats) Brown/whole grain/whole wheat bread, rice and pasta (or other starches such as buckwheat, wholegrain couscous etc) Whole oats (porridge) Corn (on the cob, polenta, tinned corn, frozen corn) Jacket potatoes or sweet potatoes Home-made baking and treats Very dark chocolate Fresh or dried herbs and spices Add wheat germ, sunflower seeds, pumpkin seeds, sesame seeds to cereals. Garlic, parsley and turmeric to stews and curries 94 WHERE OUR FOOD COMES FROM - IMPORTATION 95 Write down 10 things you eat/drank yesterday and if home made/take away/GIY/organic etc. What would you like to be eating more or less of? Share (what you want) with partner. Discuss: What do you think are the issues facing Irish people in general in terms of food. What determines what you end up eating? 96 Imported Food • Half of what we spend on food and drink comes from abroad 60% of imports could be produced in Ireland e.g. potatoes, carrots, apples ,fish, poultry, pork. 40% we couldn’t produce due to climate, e.g. tea, chocolate, oranges 97 98 Are we self-sufficient? If there was a problem and Ireland couldn’t import/transport food, within 7 days there would be food shortages. If Ireland had to go back to being selfsufficient in food it would take 7 years. 99 Neoliberal Globalisation/Free Trade – all markets are ‘open’, food is another commodity to be traded. Via WTO Price – poorer countries often produce food at cheaper prices. Most fresh whole chickens here are Irish, once you go to catering level at the sandwich bar or café, nearly all of it is cheaper imports, often from Brazil and Thailand. Industry issues –e.g. Boyne Valley Honey, says most of their honey is imported from Europe and South America because of the wet climate, lack of beekeepers and demise of Irish bees. 100 In small groups brainstorm the pros and cons of importing food into Ireland, in terms of environment, sustainability, jobs, justice, nutrition, variety in diet etc. Watch the film on Kenyan Beans See if your list changes. Feedback 101 Where does our food come from? Type of food European Union countries Countries outside of the European Union Cereals Netherlands, France, Denmark, Spain Chile, Canada, Egypt, Pakistan, Thailand, Canada, Colombia, Costa Rica Prepared foods (includes processed food like sugar, chocolate, sweets) Spain, Germany, Republic of Ireland, Greece, France, Portugal USA, Israel, Turkey, India, China, Ghana, Egypt Fruit and vegetables Italy, Germany, France, Spain Costa Rica, Colombia, Argentina, Brazil, Canada, Honduras, New Zealand Dairy products Germany, Belgium, Netherlands, Finland Austria, Denmark Italy Kosovo, Thailand, Canada, Singapore Argentina, China, Beverages Germany, Netherlands France, Luxembourg Kenya, Israel, India, Brazil, Indonesia, USA, Canada Meat France, Germany, Netherlands Brazil, Thailand, Argentina, USA Seafood Germany, Belgium, Denmark Seychelles, USA, Thailand Philippines, India, Iceland 102 Promotes: economic liberalisation, privatisation, free trade, open markets, deregulation, reductions in government spending, enhance private sector. How: free trade agreements, CAP, World Trade Organisation (rules for members), IMF & World Bank, EU 103 Free (liberal) trade Policy Result Reducing/removing taxes and tariffs, subsidies, price controls You can’t protect indigenous food industry from cheap imports, food flown round the world Deregulation (labour standards) Wages go down, unions quashed, no minimum wage Deregulation (environmental protection) Big companies can cut rainforest to grow cash crops Deregulation (animal & food protection) Lower standards of welfare for animals and lower standards of 104 food production World Trade Organisation The World Trade Organization (WTO) supervises and liberalises international trade. Started 1995, replacing the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT), which stated in 1948 Deals with regulation of trade between participating countries; e.g. trade agreements, dispute resolution WTO is trying to complete Doha Development Round negotiations (deadline 2005) but developing and developed countries can't agree on rules to regulate agricultural trade (rich world want to keep subsidies and developing don't agree). Famously tens of thousands protested against WTO in Seattle in 1999. As with other international financial institutions such as the IMF and the World Bank, the WTO's policies have been critisised for contributing to the widening gap between rich and poor, for benefitting mainly richer countries and for not seeking to protect labour rights and the environment. 105 The Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP) is a trade agreement that is presently being negotiated between the European Union and the United States. It aims at removing trade barriers in a wide range of economic sectors to make it easier to buy and sell goods and services between the EU and the US. On top of cutting tariffs across all sectors, the EU and the US want to tackle barriers behind the customs border – such as differences in technical regulations, standards and approval procedures. These often cost unnecessary time and money for companies who want to sell their products on both markets.. FROM: http://ec.europa.eu/trade/policy/in-focus/ttip/about-ttip/ 106 World food producers contracted by a known client who decides terms & price Small number of companies = huge power large food retailers or supermarkets (for example, Wal-Mart, Carrefour, Tesco, Metro); large food-processing companies (such as Nestlé, Unilever, Danone, Sysco); large fast-food chains (such as McDonald’s, KFC, Starbucks, Subway); and (iv) other non-food firms (such as Benetton) and private equity firms (such as Texas Pacific, Apax) operating fast-food and/or food-processing operations. 107 108 109 Globalisation ofSouth Agriculture in South Globalisation of Global agriculture 'free' trade in agri-products high-tech export oriented farming low spending on domestic farming open markets to food imports How were changes made? Through IMF loan conditionalities, or SAPs privatisation (e.g. patent DNA) increased use of fertilizers and pesticides less land-reform less rural reform e.g. irrigation 110 111 What change would I like to see happen? (Who, what, where, when, how) & to what end? If this doesn’t happen, what are risks for people and planet (bad health, poor exams, palm oil wrecking rainforest etc. ) What do I think are the barriers to this happening? What info do I need/questions do I need to ask to find this out? Of whom? 112 How can I check what services are already in place? Who are the various stakeholders?/Who is likely to act on the info I generate? What might they do, what do they need from me? What is my own capacity/budget for this research/for a future project? Can I combine getting info with a fun event/awareness raising? 113 Is there a creative way I can display my findings for 8 Dec? Can I use photos, posters, graphs, quotes, video, case studies, stat, art, drama, music? What are my top 2 or 3 ideas for my research project? Can I do a SWOT analysis on them? (Compare strengths, weaknesses, opportunities & threats. 114 AIM: reduce amount of sugary & highly processed food in creches and preschool level in Greystones FIND OUT: What is being fed to kids/extent of problem (visit creches?) FIND OUT: are parents/docs/dentists seeing diet related problems in kids locally? Are creches aware? Why do they do it? FIND OUT: more about the sugar industry globally, labour and environmental costs. 115 When societies are industrialised, what is lost? What are we addicted to? (Pre-mastication, far & sugar together, reward pathways) What does sugar and junk replace, spiritually, emotionally? Can we look at meeting a need rather than asking people to give something up? Can we make healthy fashionable/desirable? Are their role-models? Young chefs? Musicians?? 116 POTENTIAL OUTCOME: Display of finding in library, talks to parents at Cuidui meetings. PROJECT IN FUTURE: Campaign targeting creches etc. Produce a consent form that parents must sign before sugar given to their kids. (Not vice versa) Using photoshop design posters of people giving cigarettes to kids with shock warnings. Tap into Say No campaign by SafeFood 117 Get kids and elders cooking together Community gardens selling preserves and ferments or producing soup, healthy bars, herb packs, GIY packs, green smoothies, Sharing Backyards Coops sharing wholefood orders Food maps of village/town/city Cookery Classes with a difference e.g. sustainability Urban gardening Ingredient Cards @ cookery classes Hungry Planet style photos of people’s trolleys/dinners Art using recycled food containers Harnessing community orgs to help bring CSA/CG produce to more people. 118 119 A Community Kitchen is a group of likeminded individuals who come together on a regular basis to socialise and cook affordable and nutritious meals. The participants then sit down to share the meal or divide it up for each person to take home. http://www.communitykitchens.org.au/About/ Similar: http://www.hopecommunity.org/node/249 120 Action Ideas Changing Policy/Government Consumer Power Direct Action Cultural Action Communications/Awareness Raising Walking the Walk/Living Alternatives Symbolic/Spiritual Solidarity Labour action 121 122