AL-barrak 2009 1 King Saud University College of nursing Psychiatric nursing department Master program AL-barrak 2009 2 Objectives At the end of this session the students will be able to: 1. Discuss Adlerian’s perspective on human growth and development 2. Contrast & camper between Fraud & Adler's 3. Application of Adlerian counseling and psychotherapy. AL-barrak 2009 3 Outlines Introductions History Essential Adlerian concepts Advantage & disadvantage of Adlerian Theory Critique Conclusion AL-barrak 2009 4 Introduction I. Adler's personality theory is referred to as Individual psychology, as it focused on the unique aspects of each individual and refused the idea of biologically predetermined motives as proposed by the psychoanalysts. Also heplaced much importance on birth order. AL-barrak 2009 5 Adler proposed that each individual has an ideal self and that the purpose is to strive to achieve that ideal, and the motivation to do so was found within the inferiority feelings, which can transform into inferiority complexes if the individual is unable to compensate. Adler also proposed four personality types: the dominant, the getting, the avoiding, and the socially useful types. Adler emphasized the concept of free-will rather than adhering to the idea that humans are victims of their selves and their childhood AL-barrak 2009 6 Because of this breach in beliefs, the relationship between Freud and Adler was tenuous (weak). Freud Adler Freud saw all human motivation reduced to sex and aggression Adler saw people as being motivated mostly by social influences and the striving for superiority or success. Freud assumed that people have little or no choice in shaping their personality Adler believed that people are largely responsible for who they are. Freud’s assumption that present behavior is caused by past experiences Freud placed very heavy emphasis on unconscious components of behavior AL-barrak 2009 Adler’s notion that present behavior is shaped by people’s view of the future. Adler believed that psychologically healthy people are aware of what they are doing and why they are doing it. 7 History Adler's was born 1870; Died 1937 As child was sickly, suffering from rickets & pneumonia Theory was influence by a number of factors as: Competition with older brother (birth order) Illness (striving for superiority) Close relationship with father (rejected Oedipal complex) War (idea of social interest) Split from Freud over pan- sexualize & Oedipal complex AL-barrak 2009 8 Cont. Alfred Adler (1870-1937) developed the first holistic theory of personality, psychopathology, and psychotherapy that was intimately connected to humanistic philosophy of living. His lectures and books for the general public are characterized by a crystal clear common sense. His clinical books and journal articles reveal an uncommon understanding of mental disorder, a deep insight into the art of healing, and a great inspiration for encouraging optimal human development. In 1900 Adler began investigating psychopathology and in 1902 he became an original member of Sigmund Freud's circle, which met to discuss psychoanalytical matters. His disagreements with Freud began as early as 1907 – he dismissed Freud's view that sexual conflicts in early childhood cause ... AL-barrak 2009 9 Adlerian-based scholarly, clinical and social practices focus on the main seems of the theory Mental Health Prevention Social Interest and Community Feeling Holism and the Creative Self Fictional Finalism, Teleology, and Goal constructs Psychological and Social Encouragement Inferiority, Superiority and Compensation Life Style / Style of Life Early Recollections (a projective technique) Family Constellation and Birth Order AL-barrak 2009 10 AL-barrak 2009 11 Basic concepts of Adlerian Theory 1.Inferiority feelings and inferiority complex 2. Striving for superiority 3.Style of life 4. Social interest 5.Birth order 6. Fictional finalism 7.The creative self 8.Masculine protest 9.The interpretation of dreams 10.Theory of psychotherapy “ AL-barrak 2009 12 1. Inferiority Feelings Early concept based on organ inferiority People born with organ weaknesses that require compensation to overcome Broadened concept of feelings of inferiority Expanded to a sense of incompleteness Feeling motivate development Generally not a sign of abnormality but a cause for improving one’s position in life Can become exaggerated into an inferiority complex due to Physical limitations Parental neglect Parental overindulgence AL-barrak 2009 13 One of the central ideas in Adlerian Psychology is the individual's striving from a feeling of inferiority toward a feeling of significance. The feeling of inferiority can be used as a stimulus for striving or as a felt blockade and an excuse for not striving. An individual who feels blocked from achievement in one field may cross over to another field and compensate or over-compensate for his feeling of inferiority. AL-barrak 2009 14 AL-barrak 2009 15 noissimreP tuohtiW detibihorP noitcudorpeR , 1997Copyrighted AL-barrak 2009 16 2. STRIVING FOR SUPERIORITY (OR PERFECTION) The basic dynamic force between all human activity striving from a feeling of inferiority to one of superiority. All individual progress, growth and development result from the attempt to compensate for one's inferiorities, be they or real. AL-barrak 2009 17 Striving for Superiority Concept evolved over the years Organ Inferiority Aggressive Drives Masculine Protest Superiority Striving Perfection Striving AL-barrak 2009 18 How does one strive toward the final goal? Innate striving force ↓ Physical deficiencies ↓ Feelings of inferiority / Exaggerated feelings ↓ Personal gain ↓ Personal superiority ↓ Final Goal dimly perceived AL-barrak 2009 / feeling of incompletion ↓ Social Interest ↓ Success ↓ Final goal clearly perceived 19 3. Style of Life Adler used the terms "style of life," "pattern of life," "life plan," "Life scheme," and "line of movement" interchangeably. For Adler, the individual's STYLE OF LIFE is one's personality, the unity of the personality, the individual form of creative opinion about oneself, the problems of life and his whole attitude to life and others. AL-barrak 2009 20 Four types of Style of Life (typology) Emerges from combining degrees of activity with social interest. Socially useful person. High social interest and high degree of activity. Ruling person: Low social interest and high degree of activity. Out for own self interest, not others. Might be persecutor Getting person: Take all and give nothing. Recluse: Low social interest and low activity. AL-barrak 2009 21 Basic life styles (1) The well-adjusted does not strive for personal superiority, but seeks to solve his problems in ways that are useful to other as well as himself. (2) The second type wants to prove his personal superiority by ruling others. (3) The third type is the getting type. They want to get everything through others without any effort or struggle of their own. (4) The fourth tries to avoid every decision. AL-barrak 2009 22 4. Social Interest Social interest comprised of Need to develop social feeling Need to associate/cooperate with others Adler said that man is not bad by nature Social interest is inborn but that inborn quality is brought to its fullness by guidance and training. The child comes into this world completely dependent upon others. A person's style of life cannot be understood without considering the people whom he comes in contact. The style of life is influenced mostly by the quality of the individual's SOCIAL INTEREST. AL-barrak 2009 23 5. Birth Order Adler focused on child’s perception of the family’s dynamics Relationship with both parents seen important to development Mother played critical role in early life Enhances infant’s social interest First to interpret society to child Encourages interest in others Teaches reciprocity AL-barrak 2009 24 Birth Order: The First Born Inexperienced parents spend inordinate amount of time with the child Dethroned by arrival of second child Experiences loss of singular position If excessively pampered experiences resentment As oldest child inherits position of responsibility Understands both significance and exercise of power AL-barrak 2009 25 Birth Order: The First Born Interested in preserving tradition As adult Organized, responsible, conservative If deficit of social interest, insecure, hostile, suspicious AL-barrak 2009 26 Birth Order: The Second Born Shares personal time and attention Unconcerned with loss of power If older child is supportive develops efforts to excel If older child is resentful develops irrationally high goals and tend to fail Typically strives in opposite direction of oldest child AL-barrak 2009 27 Birth Order: The Middle Child Often believes self to be in unfair position Strives to establish themselves outside the family Thrive on personal relationships Often manipulative and have strong negotiation skills AL-barrak 2009 28 Birth Order: The Youngest Child Often overindulged Since no younger competition may be self assured and high achiever If over-pampered may become dependent and manipulative AL-barrak 2009 29 Birth Order: The Only Child First born who is never dethroned(defeat) Influenced by adults and matures early. May experience difficulty in social situations. Develops rich imagination and creativity. Does not learn to share. AL-barrak 2009 30 6. Fictional Finalism Adler's Fictional Finalism is an interesting idea for hypnotherapist. Fictional Finalism simply states that people act as much from the "as if" as from reality. One of the understandings of the subconscious mind is that whatever the subconscious mind accepts as true, it acts "as if" it is true whether it is or not. AL-barrak 2009 31 7. Creative Self emphasizes the existential philosophy of free will and self determination. Personality is self-created. People assign meaning to their lives according to their perceptions of the world, themselves, and others. People have environmental and genetic influences on them, but they are free to act on these influences however they wish. These influences may provide the bricks of the self, but how individuals stack them is up to their AL-barrak 2009 32 8. Masculine protest Feelings of inferiority is overcome by compensation through what he termed “masculine protest”, a tendency to become strong and aggressive, in both males and females. (Note the influence of the patriarchal culture from which he came: masculine = strong, feminine = weak). Feelings of inferiority serve as a motivator for all personal accomplishments. But they can also create neurosis. If the feelings are so overwhelming that the person is prevented from accomplishing, the person has an inferiority complex. AL-barrak 2009 33 9.Dreams Cannot foretell the future but can provide clues for solving future problems “Everything can be different”, that is, if on interpretation doesn’t feel right try another Dreams can be self-deceptive and are best interpreted by someone besides the dreamer AL-barrak 2009 34 10. Psychotherapy Psychopathology results from lack of courage, exaggerated feelings of inferiority, and underdeveloped social interest The chief purpose of psychotherapy is to enhance courage, lessen feelings of inferiority, and encourage social interest. This is difficult because patients hold on to their existing, confortable view of themselves. To overcome resistance to change, the therapist asks questions like “what would you do if I cured you immediately?” AL-barrak 2009 35 Psychotherapy Goals of psychotherapy Establish collaborative relationship based on empathy & respect Gain comprehensive understanding of client’s lifestyle Dynamics of family constellation Childhood disorders Day/night dreams Early memories Exogenous factors (what was present at onset of disorder) Basic mistakes (irrational ideas in style of life) AL-barrak 2009 36 Psychotherapy Goals of psychotherapy Explain client’s lifestyle Assist the client in new options Therapeutic relationship Viewed as partnership Supportive Empathy & understanding openly expressed AL-barrak 2009 37 Psychotherapy Initial procedures and strategies Assessment a continuous process Unique lifestyle of client and therapist determine approach Behavior viewed as purposeful Treatment viewed as collaborative effort Resistance viewed as an incongruence in Tx and client's goals AL-barrak 2009 38 Psychotherapy The course of Treatment Family constellation Earliest recollection Day/night dreaming Interpretation AL-barrak 2009 39 Psychotherapy Additional techniques in treatment Surprise tactic Anti-suggestion Confrontation Spitting in the client’s soup Act as if AL-barrak 2009 40 Comparison of Safeguarding Techniques Adler’s Safeguarding Techniques Freud’s Defense Mechanisms 1. Limited mostly to the construction of neurotic style of life Found in everyone 2. Protect the person’s fragile selfesteem from public disgrace Protect the ego from the pain of anxiety 3. Can be partly conscious Operate only on an unconscious level AL-barrak 2009 41 Adler’s Safeguarding Techniques Freud’s Defense Mechanisms 4. Common types include:- Common types include:- a. Excuses a. b. c. d. e. f. g. h. i. j. b. Depreciation *Repression * Accusation * Self-accusation c.Withdrawal obstacles Aggression Reaction formation Displacement Fixation Regression Rationalization Introjection Projection Sublimation Undoing * moving backwards * standing still * hesitating * constructing AL-barrak 2009 42 GOALS OF THERAPY 1. Creating the collaborative relationship 2 .Assessing the psychological dynamics operating in the client 3 . Encouraging insight and self-understanding by associating early life experiences with presenting neurosis (“How would your life be different, and what would you do differently, if you did not have this problem?”) 4 . Reorienting and reeducating: courage and optimism awakened 5 .Moving from “felt minus” to “felt plus”: finding meaning in life AL-barrak 2009 43 TECHNIQUES OF THERAPY The four entrance gates to mental life: 1. Analysis of birth order: each child has a different experience; first, second, youngest, only 2. First memories: one’s subjective starting point that shapes the world view 3. Dream analysis: expression of one’s lifestyle; dreams are self-deceptive and therefore unhealthy; Adler believed that healthy people did not dream 4. Mannerisms: eye contact, distance from others, body language, dress, vocabulary, walk, etc. AL-barrak 2009 44 Empirical evidence for birth order as a variable in personality: controversial topic from “sheer waste of time and money” to “plays a bit part in the drama of sibling difference”. What we do know: 1. Firstborns: more responsible and achievement oriented; resistant to innovations, new ideas; comfortable with the known; defender of the status quo; more rule-bound and right-thing oriented 2. Laterborns: more socially successful; typically lower selfesteem; more accepting of innovations, more challenging of the status quo; questioning and rebelling; searches for an unoccupied family niche and is more open to new experiences; more versatile. AL-barrak 2009 45 Adler’s Contribution Emphasis on social variables, family constellation Lifestyle Inferiority Complex Importance of subjective reality Personal freedom and responsibility in living life Forerunner of Existential-Humanistic movement AL-barrak 2009 46 Where Adlerian Approaches are Applied? Education Parent Education-Children the Challenge-Rudolph Dreikurs & Soltz, 1964 Marriage Counseling Family Counseling Group Work AL-barrak 2009 47 Advantages of Adlerian Theory It can be used for numerous issues and disorders. Uses encouragement. It is phenomenological. It does not consider people to be predisposed to anything. AL-barrak 2009 48 Disadvantages of Adlerian Theory The amount of family and lifestyle information that is collected. Sometimes difficult to do the interpretations, especially the dreams. Adlerian therapy works best with highly verbal and intelligent clients. This might leave out many people who do not fit that category. Might be too lengthy for managed care. Adlerians do not like to make diagnoses as it labels people. AL-barrak 2009 49 Applications of Individual Psychology Family Constellation *Birth order Early Recollection *ER are always consistent with people’s present style of life and their subjective account of these experiences yields clues to understanding both their final goal and their present style of life. *ER’s effect how one sees one’s self *ER’s does not determine the style of life but rather ER’s are simply shaped by present style of life AL-barrak 2009 50 Critique not falsifiable average in generating research organizes research well guides everyday action very well (5) low internal consistency – Poorly defined terms emphasizes free will & choice is a very optimistic theory AL-barrak 2009 51 Cont. on causality this theory is teleological in nature (is moving forward and individuals are motivated by future goals) is both conscious/unconscious emphasizes social interests while emphasizing the unique nature of each individual AL-barrak 2009 52 Criticisms Vaguely defined terms and concepts not conducive to research Birth order research has had mixed results Concept of creative self provides such flexibility in interpreting reality that it becomes impossible to predict adult personality AL-barrak 2009 53 Conclusion Although Adler's theory may be less interesting than Freud's, with its sexuality, or Jung's, with its mythology, it has probably struck you as the most common-sensical of the three. Students generally like Adler and his theory. In fact, quite a few personality theorists like him, too. Maslow, for example, once said that, the older he gets, the more right Adler seems. If you have some knowledge of Carl Rogers' brand of therapy, you may have noticed how similar it is to Adler's. And a number of students of personality theories have noted that the theorists called Neo-Freudians -- Horney, Fromm, and Sullivan -should really have been called Neo-Adlerians. And so the "positives" of Adler's theory don't really need to be listed: His clear descriptions of people's complaints, his straight-forward and common-sense interpretations of their problems, his simple theoretical structure, his trust and even affection for the common person, all make his theory both comfortable and highly influential. AL-barrak 2009 54 Reference Ivey, A. E., D’Andrea, M., Ivey, M. B. and Morgan, L. S. (2002). Theories of counseling and psychotherapy: A multicultural perspective, 5th ed. Boston, MA.: Allyn & Bacon. James, R. K. & Gilliland, B. E. (2003). Theories and strategies in counseling and psychotherapy, 5th ed. Boston, MA: Allyn & Bacon. Kottler, J. A. (2002). Theories in counseling and therapy: An experiential approach. Boston, MA: Allyn & Bacon. AL-barrak 2009 55 Cont. Oberst, Ursula, & Stewart, Alan. Adlerian Psychotherapy: An Advanced Approach to Individual Psychology. (2003). Brunner-Routledge. ISBN 1-58391122-7. AL-barrak 2009 56