Document Based Question AP World History First three steps: 1. Dissect the Prompt 2. Group the Documents 3. Formulate the Thesis Grouping • At Least 3 groups in each DBQ • Groupings should be based on the different responses to the prompt – Be as specific as possible in descriptions of groupings – Are there any connections between reactions, trends or events and the historical time period? – All Documents must be used at least once – Documents can be used in more than one grouping! – At least two documents in each group Thesis Statements • Good DBQ Thesis Statements: – Takes a stand – Answers the question – Previews the argument – Details Time and Place – Groupings – Can be more than one sentence • What Your Thesis Needs to Have: – Time – Region(s) – Topic – Groups – Previews (brief descriptions of groups) What Your DBQ Thesis Should NOT Include: • References to specific documents • Quotes from specific documents Point-of-View • Point-of-View statements should analyze how aspects of the author’s character/background or time period influence their statements in the given primary source. • Must have at least THREE Point of View Statements • Tip: Include one for each of your three groups (body paragraphs) More tips for POV • WHY does the author have this opinion • What informs the author’s opinion or target audience? • Is the document trustworthy? Why or why not? SAMPLE AP WORLD HISTORY DOCUMENT • Source: Zong Mi, a leading Buddhist scholar, favored by the Tang imperial household, essay, “On the Nature of Man,” early ninth century C.E. • “Confucius, Laozi, and Buddha were all perfect sages. They established their teachings according to the demands of the ages and the needs of various beings. They differ in their approaches in that they encourage the perfection of good deeds, punish wicked ones, and reward good ones; all three teachings lead to the creation of an orderly society and for this they must be observed with respect.” KEYS TO FINDING POINT OF VIEW IN THIS DOCUMENT • Author was Buddhist scholar, “favored” by the Tang ruler • A Buddhist scholar “in high position” in a time when Buddhism was being threatened would expectedly extol the virtues of Buddhism • Ties Buddhism to traditional Chinese philosophies of Confucius and Laozi A SAMPLE POINT OF VIEW USING THIS DOCUMENT • There are a variety of ways for students to include point of view in their paper; some are more sophisticated than others • As a Buddhist scholar in a time when Buddhism is being threatened in China, it is expected that Zong Mi would closely tie Buddhism to Confucianism in order to keep his “favored” position at the imperial court. My own thoughts on POV • Person X thinks Y because of Z • Who? (Attributions? Important background? What is influencing them?) • When? Where? • What? (What do they think?) Why? • Why write this? Audience? • Is this person reliable? Why or why not? • Use terms like perspective or even point of view; avoid the word bias • POV Template: " It makes sense that ______ (person) holds this position because he/she is ______" Additional Document Recommendation • Need to recommend at least one additional document • More than one could help you get into an expanded core if done correctly • Does NOT have to be a specific author or title of document • Can be placed anywhere in your response Makes for a good conclusion Questions for Additional Document • Whose voice is missing from this discussion? What could that additional voice tell you about the topic? • Should NOT be someone who is too similar to the given authors or information/POV similar to the given sources • Must be realistic Outline for DBQ • 1st Paragraph: Thesis • 2nd Paragraph: First Group • 3rd: Second Group • 4th: Third Group • 5th: Conclusion • Additional document can go anywhere most people put it in conclusion • Should have at least one POV in each body paragraph • Do not mention docs in Intro or Conclusion • Do NOT refer to sources by anything other than title or author. Cite sources in Parentheses. Ex (Doc #5)