Table of Contents ABSTRACT .................................................................................................................................................3 INTRODUCTION....................................................................................................................................4 ANALYSIS OF BUFFALO WILD WINGS DOMESTIC ENVIRONMENT ...........................4 History of Buffalo Wild Wings ...................................................................................................................................4 Competitive Analysis ...................................................................................................................................................6 Product Mix .................................................................................................................................................................8 Chicken Wings ...........................................................................................................................................................8 Table 3 Menu - ..........................................................................................................................................................9 Source: buffalowildwings.com .................................................................................................................................. 10 Promotion Mix ........................................................................................................................................................... 11 Layout......................................................................................................................................................................11 TV and Print Advertisements ...................................................................................................................................12 In-store Promotion ..................................................................................................................................................13 Endorsers ................................................................................................................................................................16 A COMPARISON OF MARKET OPPORTUNITIES ................................................................ 17 Marketing Opportunities in Kenya .......................................................................................................................... 18 Marketing Opportunities in India ............................................................................................................................ 20 Marketing Opportunities in Chile ............................................................................................................................ 21 Market Potential Index Comparison ....................................................................................................................... 23 A Comparison of the Government Forces ...............................................................................................................27 A Comparison of Social-Cultural Forces ................................................................................................................29 A Comparison of Competitive Forces .....................................................................................................................32 RECOMMENDATIONS ..................................................................................................................... 33 A NEW MARKETING STRATEGY FOR CHILE ............................................................................... 34 CHILE MARKETING ENTRY STRATEGY ............................................................................... 36 1 INCREMENTAL INTERNATIONALIZATION MODEL........................................................ 39 Where Buffalo Wild Wings will expand its restaurant in Chile ............................................................................ 42 Adoptions to the Marketing Mix .............................................................................................................................. 45 Promotions Adoptions ............................................................................................................................................... 51 Where Should Buffalo Wild Wings Position the Restaurant. ................................................................................ 53 Sponsorship Activities.............................................................................................................................................55 Print Advertisement ................................................................................................................................................57 Celebrity Endorsers .................................................................................................................................................58 Recognizing Cultural Value Differences .................................................................................................................61 CONCLUSION ...................................................................................................................................... 61 WORKS CITED .................................................................................................................................... 62 2 Abstract The analysis provides a detailed report and recommendations for future geographic expansion into Chile. We have evaluated three potential markets for Buffalo Wild Wings. Although Kenya and India were good choices based off of our analysis Chile is the market we choose to enter. The marketing plan that is provided will make sure Buffalo Wild Wings will be successful in Chile. The standardization component includes franchising, changes in the brand name, and also alterations with menu items. However, we thought it will be feasible to keep the American taste and add additional Spanish food items to the menu to appeal to Chile’s culture. As far as promotions we have chosen two Spanish, Latin American entertainers to represent both the United States and Chilean markets. We also decided to create relationships with local beer companies and soccer teams to bring awareness to Buffalo Wild Wings. Furthermore, our research shows strong potential for Buffalo Wild Wings to expand its restaurant into the Chilean market. However, to ensure success, Buffalo Wild Wings must appeal to the local market and provide adaptations to meet the standards and cultural differences in the Chilean market. 3 INTRODUCTION Buffalo Wild Wings was founded by two men from Kent, Ohio who missed the taste of wings from Buffalo, New York. The original name was Buffalo Wild Wings & Weck but later they dropped the last word Weck to Grill & Bar, which was made official in 1998 (buffalowildwings.com). Since they opened their first restaurant in Ohio, signs of growth have been substantial over the last twenty seven years. Consequently, Buffalo Wild Wings has been working on entering into airports as well as small and large cities. This report is a proposal for our company to expand into a foreign market. This report will discuss on who, where, and how we are going to penetrate our new markets. The goal is to “WOW people every day,” which is Buffalo Wild Wings’ company slogan. The report is divided into three sections. The first part is the domestic environment, which goes into a brief detail on the company’s history, competitive analysis, the product mix, and the promotion mix. The next part is the analysis of three potential countries, Chile, Kenya, and India. The analysis will cover the countries’ opportunities and constraints, which will lead to its recommendation of the best country out of the three for Buffalo Wild Wings to expand its company into the international market. ANALYSIS OF BUFFALO WILD WINGS DOMESTIC ENVIRONMENT History of Buffalo Wild Wings The story of Buffalo Wild Wings started with two wing craving men from Buffalo, New York. They had moved to Kent, Ohio and soon realized there were no local stores that sold New 4 York style chicken wings. This led the two entrepreneurs, Jim Disbrow and Scott Lowery to open up their first wing joint, Buffalo Wild Wings & Weck, in Columbus, Ohio in 1982. The original name is where the nickname BW3 came from and below is an image of the logo. The following is the original logo, circa 1982. Figure 1 Time Line Table 1 presents the following timeline given on Buffalo Wild Wings’ website which enumerates the highest achievements in the company’s history. Table 1 1981 1982 1992 1994 Two guys driven by hunger 1st Restaurant open near campus of The Ohio State University 8 company restaurants are open First franchised location opens Sally Smith joins Company Transitioned to professional management -focus on concept repositioning 35 locations are now open 1999 Private placement 2003 Initial Public Offering 2004 300th restaurant opens in December 2006 Launch of first national ad campaign on ESPN, CBS Sports, and WestwoodOne 2007 25th anniversary & Grand opening of new flagship restaurant in Columbus, OH 2008 500+ restaurants are open—half way to goal of 1,000 in U.S 2009 Buffalo Wild Wings rings the Closing Bell at the NASDAQ in celebration of Super Bowl Sunday Source: http://www.buffalowildwings.com/downloads/pdf/CompanyFactSheet.pdf 5 From the timeline, we can see how Buffalo Wild Wings is known as one of the top 10 fastest growing restaurant chains in America. Three hundred restaurants were opened within the first 22 years. As of July 2009, there are over 600 Buffalo Wild Wings restaurants open in across 40 states. Below is a figure of the restaurant’s logo after it became publicly opened in the stock market. Figure 2Buffalo Wild Wings Logo Competitive Analysis There are about 500,000 restaurants in the restaurant industry with combined annual revenue of $400 billion. Companies that hold the largest shares in the restaurant industry include McDonald’s, YUM! Brands; and Darden Restaurants. YUM! Brands include restaurants like KFC, Pizza Hut, and Taco Bell. Darden Restaurants include Olive Garden and Red Lobster. This industry is still considered to be highly fragmented because the 50 largest companies only hold about 20% of the market (Hoovers.com). 6 Buffalo Wild Wings’ top competitors include Brinker International, which consists of Chili, Maggiano’s Little Italy, and On the Border, Carlson Restaurants, and Hooters. Other competitors include the following restaurants: Applebee’s, Damon’s, Darden, Dave & Buster’s, Family Sports Concepts, Fox & Hound Restaurant, Houlihan’s, Rock Bottom Restaurants, Ruby Tuesday, Wingstop, and Zaxby’s. Below is a chart that compares Buffalo Wild Wings to Brinker International. The following table shows Buffalo Wild Wings’ annual sales, employees and market against those of Brinker International Company, Yum! Brands, and Darden Restaurants. Table 2 Financial Statements Buffalo Wild Brinker Yum! Darden Wings International Brands Restaurants 11,279.0 7,217.5 422.4 3,620.6 12,000 77,100 336,000 179,000 - 4,351.8 748.4 1,430.0 Annual Sales ($ mil) Employees Market Capital ($ mil.) Source: Hoovers.com 7 Product Mix Chicken Wings Buffalo Wild Wings offers a variety of products; however, they are best known for their signature wings that come in two types-- traditional and boneless. A big appeal for the restaurant’s wings is the different sauce choices. Buffalo Wild Wings offers the following fourteen signature sauces ranging from sweet to blazin: Sweet Barbeque, Teriyaki, Mild, Parmesan Garlic, Medium, Honey Barbeque, Spicy Garlic, Asian Zing, Caribbean Jerk, Hot BBQ, Hot, Mango Habanero, Wild, and Blazing.1 Buffalo Wild Wings discontinued the following sauces from their product mix: Curry, Lemon Pepper, Smokey Southwest, Thai, Captain Morgan, and Southwest Chipotle. Figure 3 twelve signature sauces 1 Buffalo Wild Wings Menu accessed on September 27, 2009 <www.buffalowildwings.com> 8 Buffalo Wild Wings also offers five different dressings that complement the wings. These dressings include ranch, blue cheese, honey mustard, southwest ranch, and sour cream. You can purchase wings in eight different bundles; you can order 4, 6, 8, 12, 18, 24, 50, or 100 wings. Blue cheese ranch dressing and celery sticks are available with an additional cost. Below on Table 3 provides a summary of the food that Buffalo Wild Wings serve on their menu. Figure 4 product mix Table 3 Menu - 9 Appetizers Mozzarella Sticks, Onion Rings, French Fries, Potato Wedges, Popcorn Shrimp, Mini Corndogs, Chicken Tenders, Nachos, Roasted Garlic Mushrooms, Chicken Quesadilla, Pulled Pork Slammers, Cheeseburger Slammers, Crispy Southwest Dippers and Chili Salads Honey BBQ Chicken, Chicken Tender, Grilled Blackened Chicken, Grilled Chicken, Chicken Caesar, and Garden Salad Burgers Classic Cheeseburger, Big Jack Daddy Burger (Served on Kaiser rolls with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and fries) Wraps/flatbreads (Tortilla chips and Salsa included) Sandwiches (Served on Kaiser rolls) Pizza Honey BBQ Chicken, Parmesan Garlic Chicken, and Buffalo Chicken Ribs and Combo ½ lb ribs -Combo with popcorn shrimp, traditional or boneless wings, or ½ lb of ribs (Cole slaw, fries, and BWW sauce) Kids Menu Cheeseburger slammers, mini corn dogs, traditional or boneless wings, naked or breaded chicken tenders, or macaroni & cheese. (Fries and small drink included) Non-Alcoholic Coca-Cola’s products (includes coke, diet coke, and sprite) Beverages Iced tea and coffee Alcoholic 50 beers- ex. Budweiser, Miller, Heineken, Blue Moon, 321, etc Beverages (Select variety in bottle or tap form) Special Mixed drinks- Bloody Mary Desserts Chocolate fudge cake, New York cheesecake, Deep-dish apple pie Source: buffalowildwings.com 10 Promotion Mix Layout Buffalo Wild Wings is a restaurant with a bar and grill theme. Their typical store layout contains 4 sections, which are the take out section, the family section, the bar section, and the arcade section. The take out section is near the entrance that is in the hallway that leads to the family and bar section. The family section has booth seats that can seat 6 adult size customers and there are both circular and square tables that can be manually arranged to seat more than 6 people. The bar section have the same tables that are in the family section and have tall circular tables with tall stools on the floor. By the wall is a bar with stools for customers to sit on. The arcade section is located either in between or split in the family and bar section. Throughout the store, there are big and small screen televisions that have sports, news, or card games displayed. The interior has a sport theme design, with lots of sports pictures, jerseys, and neon beer signs. The interior has a light colored wood paneling throughout the store and is painted with a dark blue paint. Shown in figure 5 is one sample of a store layout for Buffalo Wild Wings. Figure 5Buffalo Wild Wings Inside Layout 11 Buffalo Wild Wings target market is consumers that are between ages 18-35 who love to watch sports and enjoy socializing with friends and family. Therefore, the company uses a broad differentiating market strategy. Buffalo Wild Wings uses many types of media to promote their restaurant. A further explanation of TV ads, print ads, endorsers, in-store promotion, and the internet are explained next. TV and Print Advertisements The most common used media are TV commercials and print ads. The advertisements are shown on channels or magazines that are mostly viewed by a male audience, such as sports related media. The commercials presents Buffalo Wild Wings as the best place to be to watch sports, play games, and enjoy great meals with friends and family. At the end of the commercials, Buffalo Wild Wings catch phrase “You Have To Be Here,” is advertised underneath their name and logo, illustrated in Figure 6. The company also hosted a contest for film students to create and submit their own commercials that can be viewed on the company website. For print ads, they are focused on the food and alcoholic beverages. Since, Buffalo Wild Wings serves alcoholic beverages and are famous for their wings dipped in a choice of 14 different types of sauces. Figure 6 Buffalo wild Wings Logo 12 Figure 7 Coupons In-store Promotion Print ads are also used throughout the inside of the restaurant. The ads are displayed on the windows, doors, podium, restrooms, and in take out counter. Buffalo Wild Wings also have promotions displayed about their great deals on food and drinks every day of the week, such as their 25 and 45 cent special offers on Tuesdays and Thursdays for its famous traditional and boneless wings (Select towns). Another promotion it has is night hunger specials and specials that are related to the new sports season. During every sports season, the restaurant will have a contest placed by the entrance where customers can enter in to win prizes. To receive email 13 updates on events and promotions, customers can join the Buffalo Circle by signing up in store or on the company’s website. Internet Buffalo Wild Wings website allows customers to interactively click around to find company information, events and promotions, the menu, gift shop, and the latest news (Figure 8). It offers free games, such as wing ball (Figure 9), sauce and slide, 3 point challenge, and night hunger, free downloads for their computer, such as wallpaper for desktops, icon buddies, posters, free advice on how to leave work early (like fake excuses and a free method to search the nearest location). The website offers links to Facebook, where customers can follow up on what other customers’ post, and Twitter, where fans can follow up on the company. During sports seasons, the website offers additional links. Such related links in football is Fantasy Football All-Star Bloggers, where customers can follow up on the Buffalo Wild Wings Football leagues. Figure 8 Interactive Website 14 Figure 9 Wing Ball 15 Endorsers For every sports season, the company has a new endorser. Trey Wingo, the host on ESPN’s NFL Live, is the Buffalo Wild Wings celebrity endorser during the football season. He posts updates on twitter and serves as the representative for the Buffalo Wild Wings Fantasy Football All-Star League. Also, Buffalo Wild Wings’ very own customers serve as endorsers. They are walking advertisements that would display in public. Consumers can purchase clothes and products on the company’s website or get a chance to buy a special t-shirt in the restaurant. To purchase the t-shirt in the restaurant, they must participate in the “Blazin’ Challenge.” They must succeed in eating 12 wings dipped in the hottest sauce under 6 minutes. 16 Figure 10 Customers Figure 11 Blazing Wings Eating Contest From the product mix, promotion mix, history, and competitive analysis, Buffalo Wild Wings is a strong company that maintains competitive in the restaurant industry. Even though the restaurant has great domestic success, Buffalo Wild Wings has never expanded outside the United States. This will be the first opportunity the company will have to analyze where and how they can expand globally. A Comparison of Market Opportunities In the next section, we will determine the most valuable market for Buffalo Wild Wings to expand its restaurants. We followed the framework of Hult, which suggests examining market opportunities by evaluating a market’s economic forces, governmental forces, social-cultural forces, and competitive forces. This process will also include environmental analysis by CZinkota, Ronkainen, and Donath. In addition, included in this analysis is Global Edge’s 17 framework for evaluating emerging marketing potential based on our analysis and evaluation of each of the four environmental forces. Therefore, we will recommend Kenya, Chile, or India as a market to enter into. We will then recommend the country that seems to hold the most potential for expansion of Buffalo Wild Wings. We will begin by providing a country profile of the target markets followed by our analysis. Marketing Opportunities in Kenya Kenya borders the Indian Ocean and covers an area of 224,960 square miles. To the south lies Tanzania and Kenya, which shares a border with Sudan and Ethiopia? With its tropical location you may expect the country to be hot and wet, however, weather varies from steaming tropics to desert areas and the average temperature is 79 degrees Fahrenheit. Kenya has two seasons, summer and winter; that has variation of vegetation and climate. Kenya’s major source of energy is petroleum but, unfortunately the countries entire supply is imported. This country increases its value with the amount of oil it contains. Kenya’s physical geography is diverse and it has large areas of good farmland. Nairobi is the largest city in Kenya with one of the finest climates in the world and it’s the capital of Kenya which is governed by its own council. Kenya became an independent country on December 12, 1963. In the following year the country became a republic, as Jomo Kenyatta was elected president. Today, the chief of state is President Mwai Kibaki and the head of government Prime Minister, Raila Odinga. Despite the changes in the political system and ethnic turmoil in 2008, Kenya held democratic and open elections which were judged free and fair. According to Global Edge.com Growth should slow slightly by 4% in 2008 that is a growth drop from 6% to 4% from 2007 to 2008 .However, this will -not affect banking or telecommunications and Agriculture 18 remains a crucial sector of the economy, generating 25 per cent of Gross Domestic Product. In addition to overall share, GDP has declined 40% in the 1960’s to about 20% by 2001. GDP per capita is $1,700 in 2007 and the inflation rate is 9.8%; at the same time the service sector increased to 39% to 62%. The service industry accounts for 62% of Kenya’s GDP. This category includes services provided by restaurants, hotel, and safari industries and also government services. Mining and construction combined total is 19% of GDP in 2000. Electricity is the second most important energy source. As Over 71% of Kenya’s electric is generated by hydroelectric plants in the Tana River basin, in their neighbor Uganda. With the rise of fuel and food, inflation should remain over the 5% target. Even though Kenya suffered political problems it has survived as a political stable country. Kenya belongs to Commonwealth of Nations, an association headed by Great Britain. Kenya and Britain consult one another on economic, educational, scientific, financial, and military matters. Map of Kenya 19 Marketing Opportunities in India India is shaped like a giant pear and the seventh largest nation in terms of land area. The people in India show cultural diversity and they speak 16 major languages. The main language is known as Hindi. India is surrounded by villages although 30% of its population lives in cities and towns. India has many major cities but the most popular are Delhi, Bombay, and Mumbai. India country shows a growth rate of 9% and GDP of 906 billion. There GDP PPP is 3,362,960 trillion; however, India is a low income poverty country and has thousands of people unemployment. Measured by value of a year’s output of goods and services, India has an enormous economy, and is ranked the twelve largest countries in the world. In regards to capita income per person, India ranks the poorest in the world. India’s constitution was adapted in 1950 and India is a union of states and has federally administered territories. India has no major power bloc and most 20 of their difficulties have been with Pakistan and China. India began reexamining its policies toward Western nations after the breakup of the Soviet in 1991.The residing president in India today is Smt Pratibha Devisingh Patil, Education level, seems to be good in the country, about 61% adult male and female can read and write. Map of India Marketing Opportunities in Chile Chile is located on the southwestern coast of South America, with the Pacific Ocean to the west and Argentina and Bolivia to the east. Chile’s total area is 292,260 21 square miles and is slightly smaller than Texas. Chile’s main resources are rich in copper, fruits, forest, and fish. Chile climates include hot, desert temperatures that decrease at increasingly higher latitudes. The coast range affects the middle of Chile’s Mediterranean climate. Temperatures in Chile can reach 90 degrees fareinheight. The average annual temperature is just 44 degrees. Bernardo O Higgins, sometimes known as the George Washington of Chile, led rebels to victory in Chile’s war of independence with Spain that lasted from 1810-1818. In addition, a power struggle was taking place between the president and congress. Chile is now run by Michelle Bachelet, the fourth president in Chile to win an election. Despite Chile’s progress, the 19th century ended on an unstable note and the economy was beginning to fail. The number of unemployment nitrate miners and landless mestizos was growing. GDP per capita is $13,900 and inflation rate is 4.4% since 2007.Chile has purchasing power of 231.1billion and a 5% real GDP growth rate. Household income or consumption by percentage is at its lowest and highest at 10%. The labor force rate in Chile is 6.97 million as the unemployment rate is 7%. Chile’s external debt is at 49.65 billion, however, Chile seems to have a strong economy with its 3.326 million telephone and 13.955 million cellar phones. Chile has 4.156 million internet users and Chile’s transportation includes railways, highways, and airports. Map of Chile 22 Market Potential Index Comparison According to Global Edge, marketers face the challenge of determining which international market to enter and the appropriate marketing strategies for those markets. The market Index chart listed below is useful for comparing market potential in emerging markets. By comparing countries on seven factors, marketers entering international markets can determine market potential. However, this analysis does not include country risk. According to Table 3, from an economic wealth perspective India has power over both Kenya, and Chile. In addition India would be the first choice if you were evaluating Market size, growth rate, and Market Intensity. Chile would come in second with Kenya 23 being the smallest market. Even though India is a stronger competitor than Chile, Chile still has a potential growth, and market size and potential. GDP growth numbers are strong in India, however, Chile has had good growth numbers and Kenya has the least amount of growth. Based on the analysis, India appears the strongest but we must do further analysis to determine between India and Chile. Table 3 Market Potential Index Comparison 2003-2008 Market Size(Population) Largest City Size Market growth rate (GDP Kenya Chile India 38,534,000 16,601,000 1,660,000,000 582,646 756,096 437.7 1.7% 3.2% 6.6% $857 $10,124 $2,900 0.4 44.9 34.0 1.9 0.2 1.5 11.07 57.61 30.5 Growth rate) Market intensity(GDP PPP/Capita) Commercial Infracture (PCs + cellular Phone Subscribers/per capita) Economic Freedom (2009) Market Receptivity (per capita imports $$$) CIA.com A Comparison of Economic Forces 24 In table 4, we will compare the economic environment in the three potential markets. Data was taken from the economic freedom index, in 2009 and Chiles score is at 77.3. Slightly more economically advanced than Kenya at 74.0 then India at 69.3. India’s index score is the lowest with a score of 44. And Kenya, has a score of 65, however, Chile has the highest index score at 100. Chile has the largest GDP/Capita (10,124) by continent according to Global Property Guide, Which suggests they have more buying power over India (1,016) and Kenya (857) Chile. India’s Gini score is lower compared to Kenya’s and Chiles. This means a more equal wealth in Chile than in India. If Pc and cell phone usage were added in the equation GDP will increase consumption power. In Table 3 Chile has a higher cell phone usage (44.9%) than India (34.0 %) and Kenya (0.4%), which will be important for buffalo Wild Wings promotion strategy in Chile. Finally, two other attributes are useful when comparing level of economic development. First, the UN’s Development Programme developed the Human Development Index (HDI). One advantage with the index is that it exposed some countries with relatively high GDP/Capita if they are lagging in healthcare and education. Therefore, in regards to our previous analysis Chile is slightly stronger than India and significantly stronger over Kenya. Second, the Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU) developed an even broader quality-of-life index. In addition to material well being (GDP/capita), it also captures health, political stability and security, family life, community life, climate, and geography, job security, political freedom, and gender equality (Economist, 2005). According to the EIU Quality-life index Chile has a quality life, score of 6.78 and rank of 31, GDP per person is 10,124 and rank at 44. Compared to India quality life score at 5.75 and rank 25 their GDP person is 1,016. Excluding Kenya 25 from the chart Chile seems to have the better quality of life than India as stated in our previous analysis. Table 4 A Comparison of the Economic Environment (Average 2003-2008) Kenya Chile India Population 39,002,772 16,601,707 1,166,079,217 Labor Force 17,370,000,00 7,000,267,000 523,500,000 26.3% 8.7% 8.3% Total GDP (US$M) 53,600,000,000 214,100,000,000 1,100,000,000,000 GDP PPP(US$M) $34,504,000,000 $183,286,000,000 $3,362,960,000 $857 $10,124 $1,016 7% 5.1% 9% GDP Growth 6.1% 3.2% 6.6% FDI Inflow (US$M) Total Exports (US$M) Total Imports (US$M) Distribution of Income (Gini)Index) PCs/Capita/phone 5.7% 7.7% 4.5% $4,958,000,000 66,460,000,000 $176,400,000,000 11,070,000,000 57,610,000,000 305,500,000,000 42.5% 54.9% 36.8% 0.541 0.878 0.612 Rank 31 Rank 23 Rank 25 Score 49 Score 13 Score 2 (High) (Low) (Low) Rate of Inflation GDP/Capita GDP PPP/Capita Human Development index Quality of life index CIA.com 26 A Comparison of the Government Forces According to the EIU’s (index of democracy) it evaluates a country’s level of democratic stability in a greater depth. If a country qualifies as a “full democracy”, it means that it has a strong government system. Therefore, Chile has a flawed democracy with a rank of 30 and score of 7.89. India’s rank is 35 and score of 7.68 compared to Kenya’s rank of 101 and score 5.08. According to the HDI index, Chile is still slightly higher in democracy over India. Chile has a political freedom score of 1 and civil rights score at 2 and is free. India’s political freedom score is a 2 and civil rights score 4 partly free. Kenya has a political score at 5 and civil rights score of 4 and they too are partly free. Our analysis of government forces is summarized in Table 5. Kenya’s the youngest country; however, they didn’t receive independence until 1963. Mwai Kibaki is now residing as standing President in the Republic/Democratic country. India is the second youngest and declared their independence in 1950 Smt Pratibha Devisingh Patil is president of India. Chile being the youngest republic country gained independence in 1980 and is ran and governed by Michelle Bachelet. The EIU’s index is based on the following: Electoral process and pluralism, free and fair elections, functioning of government, how decisions are implemented and forced, political culture where the majority rule is expected, how well citizens in the county can freely participate in elections, and civil liberties, human rights, free speech, expression, press, freedom of religion, and right to the judicial process. The EIU’s democracy index suggests that Kenya is a country of large political risk and unstable government. India and Chile are about equal in their political government however, Chile seems to be the strongest 27 government due to widespread corruption in India. All countries are members of the Regional Trade Bloc, Chile, is a Free trade country which (NAFTA), is an agreement signed by the United States, Canada, and Mexico creating a trilateral trade bloc in North America. Kenya belongs to the East Africa Free Trade Zone. It’s an organization of African Union states establishing grounds for mutual economic development among the majority of African States. India belongs to the SAARS Asian Pacific Economic Cooperation, where 21 Pacific Rim countries cooperate on regional trade and investment Liberalization and facilitation Table 5 A Comparison of government Forces Independenc e Government Type Kenya Chile India 1963 1980 1950 Republic/ Republic Union Republic democratic Legal System Government Kadhis Muslim Law Ordinary Common Law Law Regional Trade Bloc East African Free NAFTA APEC SAARS Rank 101 Rank 30 Rank 35 Score 5.08 Score Score 7.68 Trade Zone Index of democracy 7.89 Global Edge.com 28 A Comparison of Social-Cultural Forces Our analysis on culture begins with a comparison of cultural values based on Hofstede’s (1980) culture framework. Hofstede’s conceptualization of culture suggest that surface-level differences in consumer tastes, behavior, language, housing, clothing, can be traced to differences in his five core cultural values: Individualism vs. Collectivism, Power distance, Masculinity vs. Femininity, Uncertainty Avoidance, and Long-Term orientation. Figure 16 graphs the three potential target markets cultural value scores. The graph indicates differences in cultural values that Buffalo Wild Wings must oblige by. Figure 16 cultural value Difference Cultural value Difference LTO UAI India Chile MAS Kenya IND PDI 0 50 100 150 Hofstede.com 29 200 Table 6 extends this line of inquiry by calculating a summative cultural distance score from the United States. India is the most culturally different of the three countries, followed by Kenya and Chile. With an agreement with the United States and Chile it’s understandable why they will have more in common cultural values with the United States opposed to India. India has the lowest level of uncertainty avoidance meaning they are the strictest of the three countries. Kenyans, next with a score of 52, however, Chile has the highest score at 86. In comparison to Individualism, Chile has a lower score over India at 23, and then India at 48 and Kenya at 27. This could mean that Chileans have a hesitation to try new products which may cause problems when foreigners are trying to enter. India has the highest Individualism and the lowest uncertainly which means their willing to try new products. Table 6 Cultural Value Comparison Power Distance IndividualismCollectivism Kenya Chile India 64 63 77 27 23 48 MasculinityFemininity Uncertainty Avoidance Long Term Orientation Cultural value Difference Hofstede.com 41 28 56 52 86 40 25 0 61 105 153 140 30 Table 7 shows that education and life expectancy are lagging significantly in Kenya, which may be due to the high poverty and AIDS academic. Although Kenya seems to have a younger population over Chile and India, Chile seems to have the highest Life expectancy, literacy rate, School life expectancy and population growth. According to HDI life expectancy chart Kenya, life expectancy for male is 52 and female is 56.73. Female life expectancy for India is male 67.46 and female 72.61. Chile has male life expectancy rate of 74.07 and female 80.77 making them the oldest growing population in comparison to the other two. Chile has a literacy rate of 96.5 which is higher than Kenya second 73.6 and India third at 61.0 according to HDI life expectancy chart. According to the chart for education, Kenya is definitely last at 0.690 compared to Chile at 0.918 and India at 0.638 from the Index chart shows Chile, being more political stable at 0.56 than Kenya -1.25 and India -0.99 when it comes to political freedom and government (- 2.5 was being the worst, 0 average, and 2.5 best). Compared to the data collected it still looks as if Chile will be a better fit to market. 31 Table 7 Comparison of Social Cultural Forces Kenya Chile India Life Expectancy 57.86 77.34 69.89 Literacy rate 73.6% 96.5% 61.0% 4.3 13.5 10 Largest Religion Islam Catholic Hindi Population Growth rate 1.5% 0.97% 4.1 School Life Expectancy Age structure 0-14 years 42.1% 25.2% 1.047% 15-64 years 55.2% 66.7% 0.998 65+ years 8.2% 2.6% 0.72% CIA.com A Comparison of Competitive Forces The final environmental force that we will analyze is the competitive situation that exists in each country. For all three countries, there seems to be an equal amount of low competitive environment. There are not any foreign restaurants that serve hot flavored wings which indicate an open market for the product. In the three countries listed, they all seem to have the same foreign restaurants such as Pizza Hut, and McDonalds, these are hamburger and pizza places. Buffalo Wild Wings is a wings restaurant so there is no competition existing in either country. Chileans’ tend to eat Chicken, beef, pig, and rabbit. Kenyans like to eat live cattle such as curry goat and vegetables. Indians diets consist of non vegetarian foods like rice and breads, so bringing chicken to India would not seem reasonable. 32 Table 8 Competitive Forces Major Fast Food Brands Kenya Chile India Pizza Hut Hooters Pizza Hut McDonalds KFC MC Donald’s Recommendations After collecting all our data and analyzing three potential countries based on statistic data from Marketing Potential Index as well as reviewing the economic, government, social cultural and competitive environment, we recommend that Buffalo Wild Wings should target Chile for future geographic expansion. India is one of the three markets that are running a strong competition with Chile, however based on our analysis Chile showed more promising on factors such as, economic climate, political stable ability, and the competition risk is low in Chile due to not as many foreign restaurants present in country. India has more economic wealth than Chile but Chile shows continued growth and has a free trade policy established with the United States. GDP per capita in Chile is 12,000 opposed to 3,000 per person for India. India may show a stronger purchasing power however, income is distributed among the country and that makes India’s country poorest when conducting the analysis. When comparing cultural differences India ranked low among the other two and Chile had the highest ranking. Indians have a different diet and they are mostly vegetarians so bringing meat to that market would not seem feasible. Chile already has a established foreign relations and they like to eat chicken making them a stronger market to enter. Kenya has ranked low in all categories and it does not seem fit to enter the market at this time. They have a very 33 weak and poor economy and wealth partly due to the AIDS academic that is affecting its country. Their political system has corruption and it has low political ties to the United States making them a low competitor to compete. Some disadvantages to entering Chile are that based on their cultural values from Hosted’s theory, they are not likely to try new things. With not many foreign restaurants, it could be a challenge to become recognized. Mc Donald’s and Pizza Hut already have a presents in the country so bringing a different restaurant to the market may seem plausible at this time and chicken is already included in their diet this has a competitive advantage for Buffalo Wild Wings to make be the first chicken restaurant in Chile. After doing our analysis of the three competitive markets, in the next section we will analyze and determine the most appropriate entry strategy for Buffalo Wild Wings in Chile. We will also develop a marketing plan accounting for cultural differences in Chiles’ market and producing recommendations for products and promotions adaption. A New Marketing Strategy for Chile After, deciding that Chile is the best suitable market, where Buffalo Wild Wings will expand its restaurants. In the upcoming section it will describe how Buffalo Wild Wings will modify its domestic marketing strategy to be a successful restaurant in Chile. In addition, it will include the appropriate entry strategy, and what modifications will be needed to the product. This section will discuss and develop a promotional plan; also it will include the store layout, menu items and operation process. Table 8 and 7 are pictures of Chile. 34 Table 7 Santiago City 35 Table 8 Santiago Chile Marketing Entry Strategy In the beginning it was mentioned that Buffalo Wild Wings was founded by two men from Kent, Ohio. Buffalo Wild Wings was made official when they opened their first restaurant in 1998, since they opened their fist restaurant they have shown twenty years of services. Now, there are 600 owned and operated franchises in 41 states. Buffalo Wild Wings has been able to be competitive in the United States by using product adaption. Now is the first time they can franchise into Chile with the opportunity to compete within their franchising market, with 113 franchises and a 15% growth rate using a product adoption strategy. Therefore, we will compare and contrast franchising versus wholly owned- operation in the Chile market. 36 In table nine, it compares the advantages and disadvantages of franchising versus wholly-owned subsidies. The disadvantages of WOS are that it can be extremely costly and requires a strong knowledge of the business environment and language. It will require the knowledge of how to read and write the language, which is Spanish. The advantages are that wholly- owned subsidiaries firms can gain full control of business and protect its brand image in the process. The risk of doing business in another country is pragmatic due to the culture barriers such as language, advertising, and cost of doing business. Moreover, franchising seems to be a method that is less risky and have more advantages. However, franchising is a challenge in Chile if one goes outside the capital of Santiago. Fast food franchises are the largest of the local markets, and foreign investments are protected equally in comparison to local business. There are higher labor wages and taxes on foreign investments such as the withholding tax at 30% and VAT as high as 19%. In Table 9 below you will see a chart depicting the advantages and disadvantages discussed using the analysis above. In addition, Table 10 will show the costs of Buffalo Wild Wings and its competitors KFC and Hooters, who both already have a strong presence in Chile. Furthermore, it will be beneficial to know the financial investments that will be needed to start each restaurant. Therefore; the Franchisor will know how much is needed in upfront costs. 37 Table 9 A Comparison of Franchising versus Wholly- Owned Subsidiary Franchising Advantages Disadvantages Free trade no restrictions Removal of capital controls Fast Food 29% market (highest) Same protection as local business Duty Free Tariffs’ for United States Geography(stable ability) Low cost (financing) Language barrier product must be labeled in Spanish Local Trade Laws Franchises are a challenge Higher labor wages energy Financial costs withholding tax Value added tax Low corruption Absolute protection Wholly- owned Subsidiary Control Cultural barriers Protect brand Name Language barrier costly location Risk learning to do business in new culture Losing control (technology) 38 Table 10 Comparisons of Franchise Fees Franchise Fee Buffalo Wild Wings $32,000- KFC Hooters $45,000 $75,000 $42,000 Basic Royalty Advertising 5% 5% $2,000,000,000 N/A 5% N/A Royalty 5% 5% N/A Start up Fee $500,000- $1,379,900- 800,00- $1,000,000 $2,391,000 1,500,000 Incremental Internationalization Model There are two frameworks that help firms determine which, are the most appropriate strategy developed by Johanson and Vahln. These two frameworks are the Internationalization Framework model that suggests how firms should enter in a incremental fashion and minimize risk. So the first objective is to test the models responsive toward foreign markets and then investigate the firms, industry, and hosting country responsiveness. The Incremental Model approach is based off of historical data and a firm’s operation progression. 39 Buffalo Wild Wings has no International stores, thus, the first Buffalo Wild Wings opened as a corporation. However, it has evolved into franchises. It will be the first franchise to enter Chile, and the best strategy will be to franchise rather than using WOS or Joint venture; based on our previous analysis and the Incremental Model data, the fact that all of the Buffalo Wild Wing’s restaurants are franchises. Since most of the restaurants in Chile are franchises, they will use the appropriate strategy to franchise best. To enter as a wholly owned it will take the knowledge of economics about the country and to know the language. A Joint venture will lose the brand name and risk the company’s reputation. Additionally, Chile has a great economy for service firms and manufacturing firms. Their service industry is stable, and after further analysis and evaluating the Incremental Internalization Model. It has been proven to show that Buffalo Wild Wings can compete in the open market. Chileans are in need for more American restaurant a franchise, a chicken diet is popular. Buffalo Wild Wings would fit into their market because franchises are a growing business and have low start up costs. After doing the resource analysis framework in the previous section, it suggests that Buffalo Wild Wings will be able to sell and set up a retail location in Chile. As mentioned earlier, the question was whether to open a wholly owned or Franchise model given the language, cultural, and legal differences between the United States and Chile. Given these facts, we recommend that Buffalo Wild Wings enter as a franchising operation in Chile. There are disadvantages for Buffalo Wild Wings to enter the Chile franchise market. One of the disadvantages is that Buffalo Wild Wings would have to find an investor with money who has the knowledge of the country to own and operate the 40 business. However, Hooters and KFC have an advantage over Buffalo Wild Wings in that they already have franchises internationally, and this will be Buffalo Wild Wing’s first entry into an international country. Although, Buffalo Wild Wings is a corporate owned company such as its competitors, so the capital and company size make them a candidate to learn global strategies due to the difficulties for franchises to compete. 41 Figure 17 Incremental Internationalization Model Domestic Sales Stage1 Franchising Stage 2 WOS Where Buffalo Wild Wings will expand its restaurant in Chile Where Initially, Buffalo Wild Wings first expansion thus, is important to determine the entry strategy for location. Nearly all Chileans live in cities; thus Santiago is the largest city in Chile and it is the nation’s capital. Santiago has a growing city population that includes offices, malls, streets, parking lots, and movie theaters. In relation Santiago continues to grow there are developments taking place in the downtown area. Santiago has a fastpaced lifestyle surrounded by intersections, and there are subway lines that connect from suburbs to downtown. Santiago’s downtown area has three income groups: the groups consist of very rich, middle class, and poor. These social classes will be important when determining a location because Buffalo Wild Wings wants to expand in an economy 42 where the citizens can afford the product. The three groups include the wealthiest 20% of the countries’ households and 40% of the nation’s annual income, plus the individual GDP per capita is continuing to grow. So expanding to downtown Santiago will be in the best interest of Buffalo Wild Wings due to the increase of the population. The job growth indeed, are growing because having the ability to have a quick meal is multiplying and women are entering the work force so they have less time to prepare traditional meals at home. In addition, Chileans are accepting towards American foods and fast food. The location will be situated in Town Square, one of the basic elements of Chile’s towns and cities. Therefore, 90% of all retail food takes place in large shopping malls within the town square where Chileans go to socialize because of the central position. It is the perfect place for Chileans to reminisce, gossip, discuss issues, or relax together. Chileans consider the Town Square to be the central place for gatherings and meetings. In Figure 18, is a map of Santiago’s central location to further illustrate, Figure 19 is showing where Buffalo Wild Wings will be located in Santiago. Therefore, now that we know exactly where Buffalo Wild Wings is located, we will shift our focus on our promotional plan in Chile. 43 Figure 18 Map of Santiago Figure 18 Santiago City 44 Figure 19 Zoomed in map of Santiago Rd/Town Square Adoptions to the Marketing Mix Product Mix Today, Buffalo Wild Wings has 600 franchise locations in 41 states. It currently does not have any international restaurants or franchises so this will be Buffalo Wild Wing’s first expansion. Buffalo Wild Wing’s goal is to provide a standardization marketing strategy with incremental changes and modifications to the local culture. In the next section we will discuss what modifications are recommended for Chile. Product Adoptions We recommend that Buffalo Wild Wings changes its store layout and add slight modifications to its brand logo to appeal to Chile’s market. In figure 20, it shows a menu developed for Chiles Market. So, the main language that is predominating in Chile is 45 Spanish, Knowing that information is important so the menu is written with the main language Spanish. However, local laws require that all products be labeled in English and Spanish to accommodate that law our menu will be written in both languages. Chile is not a vegetarian territory, so keeping all of Buffalo Wild Wings original food furthermore it’s important to add Spanish dishes to the menu such as corn, black beans, noodles, and potato-based breads would be food items which enjoyed by Chileans. Keep in mind that Chileans prefer meat as a main dish, and Buffalo Wild Wing’s main dish is Chicken and beef, plus Chileans also enjoy. Also, barbeque slabs are one of Buffalo Wild Wing’s popular food choices. Chileans accept American foods, so we think just adding some Spanish items to the menu that are choices Chileans prefer. With that said refer to tables’ figure 20 A and B to view the menus. Figure 20 Spanish menu 46 Figure 21 Additional Spanish Items 47 Figure 22 English Menus 48 In doing their further analysis, we think Buffalo Wild Wings would benefit more by changing the culture and atmosphere (lay out) of the restaurant. It stays mild in Chile all year around, and the average temperature is between 31 and 51 degrees fareinheight. So, they thought by adding a back yard patio to the restaurant, in connection to the indoor section will appeal to Chileans’. In the United States most stores are enclosed, so adding patios will enhance the experience for Chileans considering the temperature and the fact that they like to socialize. Instead of a sports theme like in America Buffalo Wild Wings, will change the logo to read Spanish” Bar and create a Spanish ambient feel to appear to the culture. In addition, Chileans use metric, rather than the English system of weights and measures. Grams and kilograms will be used to measure food and placed on packages for labeling purposes. Furthermore, the Chilean time zone is four hours behind the United States, and unlike the United States, they do not have daylight savings time. This difference means Chileans do not need to set their clocks back, however, they do turn their clocks ahead an hour in the spring and back an hour in the fall. As a result, we will have to change the hours of operation if its 3:00 pm in the United States its 12:00 pm in Chile so it will be opened at 12:00 pm Chile time zone and close at 5:00 am opposed to 11:00 am to 1:00 am in the United States. Chileans public holidays such as Labor Day, Good Friday, and Easter are also reserved in Chile when compared along with the United States cultural holidays. We don’t think it will affect our hours of operation, we will actually benefit by spending however, and we do not open on those days because Chileans will be socializing with friends and families. Table 23 shows Buffalo Wild Wing’s current Layout in addition to Table 24 depicting the change to store layout. 49 Figure 23 Layout Figure 24 layout 50 Promotions Adoptions Promotional Knowing that we have included product adoptions, we will now focus our attention on a promotional plan for Chile. The goal for Chile is the same promotional strategy of United States but it will not include the usage of the internet just yet. Due to the inefficient technology and skills in Chile, not many have adapted the technology skills of the United States so we do not think that the internet will be appropriate at this time. The promotional methods that Buffalo Wild Wings will be using are print advertising, store promotions, and sponsorship activities. Moreover, when technology increases, the need to add the internet will be considered at a later time. Next we will begin by describing the desired positioning image. Table Figure 25 is the channel Buffalo Wild Wings will run advertisements. Furthermore, In Table 26, 27, and 28 is advertisements such as magazines and billboard ads Buffalo Wild Wings will use to bring awareness to the brand. Figure 25 Chile TV 51 Figure 26 Chile Advertisement Figure 27 Chile Magazine 52 Where Should Buffalo Wild Wings Position the Restaurant. Positioning In the United States, Buffalo Wild Wings is positioned as a Sports bar restaurant. In Chile we recommend they position themselves as a Spanish Restaurant because Chilean’s views of sports are different from the United States. Chile’s only popular sport is soccer, so bringing one theme to a restaurant sports bar is unreasonable. The second recommendation is that Buffalo Wild Wings be known for its American taste. Keeping most of the original items is important because we want to bring an American taste to Chile’s market. However, we will add additional Spanish food items to the menu. Buffalo Wild Wings wants to position itself as an American food restaurant where Chileans can come and socialize and enjoy meals. Table 28 and 29 illustrate the changes that will be made to the store layout. 53 Figure 28 Back Patio added to Buffalo Wild Wings Figure 29 American Tastes in Chile 54 Sponsorship Activities Sponsorships To build awareness for our international expansion, we would like to include sponsorship activities. Since Buffalo Wild Wings is a bar we want to build relationships with different beer manufactures and wine sellers. These relationships will allow Buffalo Wild Wings to offer games, contest, and coupons using their products that are sold through retail stores. We will also have close relationships with soccer teams and host annual celebrations at soccer games to create awareness for Buffalo Wild Wings. Table 30 and 31 is an example of sponsorships. Table 30 Soccer Sponsorship 55 Table 31 Local Beer Company 56 Print Advertisement Newspapers and Magazines Like citizens in the United States, Chileans have a range of newspapers and magazines that readers read more than the people of the United States. There are 30 national newspapers, of the 30 newspapers the most popular is EL Mercurio published in Santiago. This 50 page dialer paper is comparable to the Chicago Tribune, or the popular New York Times. The Santiago Times is the English news papers. Thus, magazines are just as popular with that said newspapers the most popular weekly magazines are Que Pasa and the Ercilla which are similar to Times and Newsweek. Running print ads in the daily newspapers are important to create awareness to Buffalo Wild Wings and gain new customers as well. Buffalo Wild Wings will run local ads in all printing methods mentioned to further the awareness aspect. Table 32 is an example of print advertisement used in Chile. 57 Table 32 Print Advertisement Celebrity Endorsers Jennifer and George Lopez To bring awareness to the brand buffalo Wild Wings will include Jennifer and Mario Lopez to be sponsors for their products. They both are from Spanish decent and are famous celebrities in the U.S. and Latin America. We think they can create brand awareness using their Spanish heritage and celebrity background. For that reason they will surpass the American Buffalo wild Wings restaurant with their celebrity endorsers. Table 33 and 34 are Buffalo Wild Wings celebrity endorsers. 58 Figure 33 Jennifer Lopez 59 Figure 34 George Lopez 60 Recognizing Cultural Value Differences Cultural Value Difference in Chile In order to be successful in Chile’s market Buffalo Wild Wings must recognize the cultural differences and adapt all their promotional methods to become favorable to the market. Also, bringing the appropriate celebrity endorsers to the market is suitable for the culture’s sponsorships, endorsements, and awareness to the brand. Conclusion Closing After introducing Buffalo Wild Wings restaurant and evaluating three markets to enter Chile was chosen out of two choices India and Kenya. Once doing careful analysis of the market Chile was assessed for market strength based on economic conditions. Then Buffalo Wild Wings found a location in Town Square Santiago to locate their restaurant. In addition, changes were made to the logo, layout, atmosphere, hours, menu, and cultural differences. Sponsorships were chosen from Chile local market which includes beer companies and soccer sports. Two Latin America celebrities were chosen to represent the brand and create awareness. Lastly, when chosen an International market to enter Buffalo Wild Wings must recognize all cultural differences and tailor their products to meet the standards of the country. In order for Buffalo Wild Wings to be successful and compete, they will need to find a local investor who has the capital to open a franchise and have knowledge of the local market. 61 Works Cited Buffalo Wild Wings. “Menu”. (Retrieved on 20090927) [Available at <http://www.buffalowildwings.com>] Company Fact Sheet. “Timeline”. (Retrieved on 20090925) [Available at <http://www.buffalowildwings.com/downloads/pdf/CompanyFactSheet.pdf>] Hoovers Company Records. (Retrieved on 20090925) [Available at <http://www.ulib.niu.edu:2535/us/lnacademic/results/docview/docview.do?docLinkInd=true&risb=21_T746032 6596&format=GNBFI&sort=BOOLEAN&startDocNo=1&resultsUrlKey=29_T7460326502&cisb=22_T746032 6501&treeMax=true&treeWidth=0&csi=220619&docNo=4>] SSP America “Airline Industry Information”. (Retrieved on 20090926) [Available at <http://www.ulib.niu.edu:2535/us/lnacademic/results/docview/docview.do?docLinkInd=true&risb=21_T746017 6794&format=GNBFI&sort=RELEVANCE&startDocNo=1&resultsUrlKey=29_T7460176797&cisb=22_T7460 176796&treeMax=true&treeWidth=0&csi=159583&docNo=1> http://www.nationmaster.com/country/in-india/eco-economy http://franchiseinfo.buffalowildwings.com/index.php?page=developement-markets http;//0-1p.grolier.comlibrary.naperville-lib.org/cgi-bin/article?assetid=4048300 http://www.sdr-consulting.com/article11.html http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/list-of-countries-by-life-expectacy http://www.internetworldststs.com/sa/cl.htm http://www.internetworldstats.com/africa.htm http;//globaledge.msu.edu/countries/Chile/statistics http://0-1p.grolier.com.library.naperville-lib.org/cgi-bin/article?assetid=4100610&docKey http://globaledge.msu.edu/countries/kenya/statistics http://ww.globalpropertyguide.com/Asia/India/gdp-per-capita http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/list-of-countries-by-literacy-rate 62 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/education-Index http://earthtrends.wri.org/searchable-db/index.php?step=countries&cID%5B%5D=96&th http://www.epckenya.org/index.php?option=com-content&task=view&id=40&Itemid=59 http://globaledge.msu.edu/countries/Chile http://globaledge.msu.edu/countries/Chile/economy http://globaledge.msu.edu/countries/Chile/risk/economy/government/culture http://hdr.undp.org/en/statistics http://hdrstats.undp.org/en/countries/country-fact-sheets/cty-fs-Kenhtml http://www.mherrere.org/freedom.htm http://www.clearlycultrual.com/geert-hofstede-cultural-dimension/power-distance-index http://www.gwu.edu/~umpleby/recent-papers/2003-cross-cultural-differences-managin http://www.CIAcentralintelligenceagency.com.htm 63 64 65 66 67