Slide 1 of XX Antiretroviral Therapy: A Case-Based Panel Discussion (Part I) Michael S. Saag, MD Eric S. Daar, MD From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. MERGED: 03-21-13 IAS–USA Slide 2 of 50 Case 1 – 30 yo white man – Diagnosed on routine insurance examination – PMHx remarkable for HTN, diet controlled – No medications – Understands treatment issues and wants to begin therapy if you think it is appropriate From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. Slide 3 of 50 Case 1b – 30 yo white man – Diagnosed on admission to jail for disorderly conduct – PMHx remarkable for HTN, diet controlled and paranoid schizophrenia – Doesn’t take any medications and doesn’t want to From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. Slide 4 of 50 Latently Infected CD4+ Lymphocytes HIV Infected Cells HIV virions Antiretroviral Rx Uninfected Activated CD4+ Lymphocytes M Saag, UAB Uninfected Resting CD4+ Lymphocytes From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. Slide 6 of 50 Effect on inflammation in predicting mortality higher in HIV disease than the general population (SOCA/SCOPE) From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. Hunt et al CROI 12 Slide 7 of 50 T cell “activation” is lower in treated than untreated adults, but consistently higher than “normal” P < 0.001 80 % CD38+HLADR+ CD8+ T Cells P < 0.001 60 40 20 0 HIV + HIV Negative Untreated (n=82) (n=82) NonHIV + Controller ART (n=65) (n=65) HAART HIV – (n=132) (n=132) Hunt et al JID 2003, PLoS ONE 2011 and unpublished From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. Slide 9 of 50 Permanent Loss of CD4 if Wait to Start – >350 CD4 counts return to near-normal levels – ≤350 cells/mm3: CD4 counts significantly increased but plateau after 4 years below normal range cells/mm3: • Differences in CD4 counts associated with differences in morbidity and mortality Median CD4 Counts Over 6 Years Stratified by Baseline CD4 Count CD4 Count (cells/mm3) • CD4-count increases on sustained suppressive (<400 c/mL) ARV treatment (n=655) by baseline count 900 800 700 500 500 400 300 200 <200 100 201–350 >350 0 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 Years After Starting HAART Moore RD, Keruly JC. Clin Infect Dis 2007;44:441-446. From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. Slide 11 of 50 HOPS Cohort: Resistance Development GT mutations and virologic failure1 p=0.076 p=0.007 Any mutation (n=78) NRTI mut. among NRTI-exp (n=50) p=0.051 p=0.103 50 Patients (%) • Major mutations 50% less likely in pts starting with CD4+ >350 vs <200 cells/mm3, despite greater treatment exposure 50 40 30 20 10 0 NNRTI mut. among NNRTI-exp (n=37) 0-199 cells/mm3 200-349 cells/mm3 >350 cells/mm3 1. Uy JP, et al. 4th IAS, Sydney 2007, #WEPEB017; 2. van Sighem B, et al. ibid, #WEPEB016 From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. PI mut. among PI-exp (n=48) Slide 13 of 50 Most New Infections Transmitted by Persons who Do Not Know Their Status ~25% Unaware of Infection account for… ~75% Aware of Infection Source: G. Marks et al. AIDS 2006 From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. ~54% New Infections ~46% of New Infections Slide 15 of 50 Reasons to Start Early: • • • • • • • The Biology Association of Inflammation and Disease Better Tolerated Medications Today Randomized Controlled Trial Data Cohort Data Public Health Common Sense! From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. Slide 16 of 50 From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. Slide 17 of 50 Relative Time on Treatment… 40 years on Rx CD4 650/ul 35 years on Rx 5 years CD4 500/ul 30 35 40 45 50 55 AGE (years) 50 From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. 65 70 Slide 18 of 50 Relative Time on Treatment… 40 years on Rx HARM? CD4 650/ul 35 years on Rx 5 years CD4 500/ul 30 35 40 45 50 55 AGE (years) 50 From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. 65 70 Slide 19 of 50 So ….what is the harm? • Destruction of Lymphoid Tissue • Inflammation • Increased Cardiovascular Events • Increased incidence of certain malignancies • Increased ‘Aging’ • Accelerated Cognitive Decline From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. Slide 20 of 50 Conclusions • Balance of data support starting Rx in ~ all individuals regardless of CD4+ T cell counts – Understanding of HIV pathogenesis – Cohort data – Public health implications – No randomized clinical trial data for higher CD4 counts (START study is enrolling) • Waiting until RCT data could well lead to harm that likely will not be reversible From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. Slide 21 of 50 Case 2 42 year old man diagnosed with HIV in 1999; several OIs Has ‘taken’ most existing antiretroviral drugs available, on and off, for years Currently on TDF / FTC / DRV / rit CD4 count is 33 /µL (nadir CD4 = 6) CD4 count 3 months ago was 76 cells/µL HIV RNA 128,000 c/mL (max VL 167,000) Phenotype: Pan-sensitive From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. Slide 22 of 50 Case 3 34 yo woman is diagnosed with TB As part of evaluation she is found to be HIV+ Initial lab values — CD4 82 cells/µL — VL 76,000 c/mL No other significant medical condition She is started on 4-drug anti-TB therapy (including INH and rifabutin) Virus is wild-type virus From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. Slide 23 of 50 Case 1 —30 yo white man —Diagnosed on routine insurance examination —PMHx remarkable for HTN, diet controlled —No medications —Understands treatment issues and wants to begin therapy if you think it is appropriate From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. Slide 24 of 50 A 49 year old asymptomatic man presents to your clinic after recently being diagnosed with HIV • • • • • History of HTN with CrCl ~75 mL/min HBsAb+, HCV antibody negative CD4 cells repeatedly 500-700 cells/uL Plasma HIV RNA 30-50,000 copies/mL Not anxious to start antiretrovirals but willing if you think it is necessary From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. Slide 25 of 50 Factors to consider in choosing first-line therapy • • • • • • • • Patient’s willingness to commit to therapy Baseline resistance Efficacy data Tolerability Convenience Comorbid conditions Consequences of failure (resistance) Since the introduction of potent ARV therapy preferred regimens all include NRTIs + third drug From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. Slide 26 of 50 Boosted-Protease Inhibitors KLEAN1 (ITT-E, TLOVR) 48 weeks 100 100 80 66 65 CASTLE3 (ITT, NC=F) 96 weeks ARTEMIS2 (ITT, TLOVR) 96 weeks 80 100 79 71 80 50 50 50 40 40 40 20 20 20 0 n=434 N=444 LPV/r FPV/r 400/100 700/100 BID BID 0 n=346 n=343 LPV/r DRV/r QD or 800/100 BID QD 0 68 74 n=443 n=440 LPV/r ATV/r 400/100 300/100 BID QD Adapted from: 1. Eron J, et al. Lancet 2006; 368:476-482; 2. Mills A, et al. AIDS May 29, 2009 3. Molina J-M, et al. 48th ICAAC/46th IDSA , Washington, DC, 2008. Abst. H-1250d From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. ATV/r vs. EFV Primary Endpoint Daar ES, et al. Ann Intern Med 2011; 154:445-456. From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. Slide 27 of 50 Slide 28 of 50 STARTMRK: RAL vs. EFV ITT, NC=F Percentage of Patients with HIV RNA Levels <50 Copies/mL 100 86 81 75 76 69 67 71 80 82 79 50 61 40 20 CD4 Change: RAL +374 vs. EFV +312 0 Weeks 0 12 24 48 72 96 280 281 281 282 281 282 120 144 168 192 216 240 Number of Contributing Patients Raltegravir 400 mg BID Efavirenz 500 mg QHS 281 278 279 282 282 282 250 281 280 281 281 282 281 282 Rockstroh J, et al, 19th IAC; Washington, DC; July 22-27, 2012; Abst. LBPE19. From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. 250 282 279 279 Slide 29 of 50 Pooled ECHO and THRIVE: Virologic Response (ITT-TLOVR) 84.3% 82.3% Rimsky L, et al. 50th ICAAC 2010, Boston, MA. Abst. H-1810 From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. Slide 30 of 50 Pooled ECHO and THRIVE: Virologic Response (ITT-TLOVR) Rimsky L, et al. 50th ICAAC 2010, Boston, MA. Abst. H-1810 From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. Slide 31 of 50 GS102 & GS103: EVG/COBI/TDF/FTC vs. EFV/TDF/FTC or ATV/RTV + TDF/FTC Randomized, Phase III, Double-blind, Double Dummy, Active-controlled, International Studies GS 102 Quad QD ~89% men 33% >105 c/mL CD4= ~385 c/uL EFV/FTC/TDF Placebo QD EFV/FTC/TDF QD Treatment Naïve Quad Placebo QD HIV-1 RNA ≥5,000 c/mL Any CD4 cell count eGFR ≥70 mL/min Quad QD ATV/r +TDF/FTC Placebo QD GS 103 ~90% men ~41% >105 c/mL CD4= ~370 c/uL QUAD Placebo QD ATV/r +TD/FTC QD 48 weeks Sax P, et al, Lancet 2012: 379::2439-48; DeJesus E, et al, Lancet 2012; 379: 2429-38 From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. 192 weeks Slide 32 of 50 Study 236-102: Primary Endpoint: HIV-1 RNA < 50 copies/mL +3.6%, 95% CI 3.6 (-1.6% to +8.8%) CD4+ change: Quad +239 vs. EFV +206 c/mm3 (p=0.009) No difference by baseline characteristics Sax P, et al. 19th CROI; Seattle, WA; March 5-8, 2012. Abst. 101. From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. Slide 33 of 50 Study 236-102: Common Adverse Events Quad (n=348) Treatment Emergent Adverse Events in ≥ 10% of subjects (%) Diarrhea 23% Nausea * 21% Abnormal Dreams ^ 15% Upper Respiratory Infection 14% Headache 14% Fatigue 12% Insomnia * 9% EFV/FTC/TDF (n=352) 19% 14% 27% 11% 9% 13% 14% Depression 9% 11% Dizziness ^ 7% 24% Rash # 6% 12% * p<0.05; ^ p<0.001; # p=0.009 Sax P, et al, Lancet 2012: 379::2439-48 From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. Slide 34 of 50 Percent with HIV RNA <50 c/mL (ITT, M=F) Study 236-103: ATV/r vs. TDF/FTC/COBI/EVG HIV-1 RNA < 50 c/mL 100 92% 90 88% 80 Diff: 3.5% (95% CI: -1.0 to 8.0) 70 50 QUAD ATV/r 50 40 30 20 10 0 BL 2 4 8 12 16 24 32 40 48 Week Changes in CD4+ count: Quad +207 vs. ATV/r +211 cells/mm3 (p=0.61) No difference by baseline characteristics DeJesus E, et al, Lancet 2012; 379: 2429-38 From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. Slide 35 of 50 Study 236-103: Adverse Events Adverse Events > 10% in Either Group Quad (n=353) ATV/r + FTC/TDF (n=355) Diarrhea 22% 27% Nausea 20% 19% Upper respiratory infection 15% 16% Headache 15% 12% Fatigue 14% 13% Ocular icterus 1% 14% Discontinuation rates due to renal events were identical in both arms (0.3%) DeJesus E, et al, Lancet 2012; 379: 2429-38 From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. Slide 36 of 50 TDF/FTC/EVG/COBI vs. EFV or ATV/r: Lipid changes P <0.001 P= 0.001 P =0.001 P =0.44 P =0.006 Conclusion: While some lipid fractions better with Quad than EFV or ATV/r, overall differences were modest and unlikely to be of clinical significance. Sax P, et al, Lancet 2012: 379::2439-48; DeJesus E, et al, Lancet 2012; 379: 2429-38 From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. Slide 37 of 50 EVG/COBI/TDF/FTC vs. EFV or ATV/r: Creatinine Changes Conclusion: Cobicistat is associated with reduced active secretion of creatinine in the renal tubules leading to initial rises in creatinine levels. Sax P, et al, Lancet 2012: 379::2439-48; DeJesus E, et al, Lancet 2012; 379: 2429-38 From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. Slide 38 of 50 A5202: Study Design Arm A HIV-1 RNA ≥1000 c/mL Any CD4+ count > 16 years of age ART-naïve 1857 N=1858 enrolled B Randomized Randomized 1:1:1:1 1:1:1:1 C Stratified by screening HIV-1 RNA (< or ≥ 100,000 c/mL) Enrolled 2005-2007 D Followed through Sept 2009, 96 wks after last pt enrolled TDF/FTC QD ABC/3TC Placebo QD ABC/3TC QD TDF/FTC Placebo QD TDF/FTC QD ABC/3TC Placebo QD ABC/3TC QD TDF/FTC Placebo QD From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. EFV QD EFV QD ATV/r QD ATV/r QD Slide 39 of 50 A5202: Time to Virologic Failure in Patients with HIV RNA >100,000 c/mL Probability of No Virologic Failure Probability of No Virologic Failure (%) 100 TDF-FTC (26 events) 80 ABC-3TC (57 events) 60 40 P<0.001, log-rank test Hazard ratio, 2.33 (95% CI, 1.46-3.72) 20 0 0 12 24 No. at Risk 36 48 60 72 84 Weeks since Randomization 96 108 ABC-3TC 398 363 313 267 222 188 137 87 49 20 TDF-FTC 399 361 321 284 236 204 150 104 65 23 Sax PE, et al. NEJM 2009;361:2230-2240. From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. ABC/3TC vs. TDF/FTC Low Viral Load Stratum Sax PE, et al. JID 2011: 204:1191-1201. From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. Slide 40 of 50 Slide 41 of 50 HEAT: Virologic Failure by Baseline HIV-1 RNA (A5202 Efficacy Endpoint) 90 87 87 90 80 60 40 20 15% 22% 4% 80% 18% ~59% ~37% 19% 50% 18% 40% 63% 20% 41% 0% 0 n= 100% Proportion of Subjects with VF Percent without Virologic Failure 100 <100,000 ≥100,000 188 155 205 ABC/3TC 140 ABC/3TC ≥500,000 c/mL 250,000 - <500,000 c/mL Pappa K, et al. 17th IAC, Mexico City, 2008. Abst. THAB0304. Young B, et al. 48th ICAAC/46th IDSA, Washington, DC, 2008. Abst. H-1233. From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. TDF/FTC 100,000 - <250,000 c/mL <100,000 c/mL Slide 42 of 50 Relative Risk of MI (95% CI) D:A:D Study: NRTIs and Risk of MI 1.9 1.5 1.2 1 ** 0.8 Recent Exposure*: yes/no Cumulative Exposure: per year 0.6 #PYFU: #MI: ZDV 138,109 523 ddI 74,407 331 ddC 29,676 148 d4T 95,320 405 3TC 152,009 554 ABC 53,300 221 TDF 39,157 139 Adjusting for eGFR does not change ABC MI finding: Adjusted RR 1.89; 95% CI (1.46 – 2.44; P=0.0001) * Recent use=current or within the last 6 months. **Not shown (low number of patients currently on ddC) Lundgren J, et al. 16th CROI, Montreal, Canada, 2009. Abst. 44LB. Sabin C, et al. Lancet 2008;371:1417-26. From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. Slide 43 of 50 Concerns regarding NRTIs • Many studies have not seen relationship between ABC and CV events • TDF-associated with greater decline in bone mineral density • TDF-associated with variable decline in renal function From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. DHHS Guidelines for Adolescents/Adults: What to Start Preferred Regimens • EFV/TDF/FTC • ATV/r + TDF/FTC • DRV/r (once daily) + TDF/FTC • RAL + TDF/FTC [Pregnant Women Only: LPV/r (twice daily) + ZDV/3TC] Alternative Regimens • EFV + ABC/3TC • RPV + (TDF or ABC)/(FTC or 3TC) • ATV/r or DRV/r + ABC/3TC • FPV/r or LPV/r (qd or bid) ABC/3TC or TDF/FTC • RAL + ABC/3TC • EVG/COBI/TDF/FTC (9/18/12) Acceptable Regimens • EFV or RPV + ZDV/3TC • NVP + TDF/FTC or ZDV/3TC or ABC/3TC • ATV + (ABC or ZDV)/3TC • ATV/r, DRV/r, LPV/r, FPV/r , RAL + ZDV/3TC • MVC + ZDV or ABC/3TC • SQV/r + TDF/FTC or ABC/3TC or ZDV/3TC (with caution) Slide 44 of 50 DHHS Guidelines. Available at: http://aidsinfo.nih.gov/contentfiles/lvguidelines/adultandadolescentgl.pdf . Revision March 27, 2012. From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. Slide 45 of 50 ART: What to Start IAS–USA Recommendations, 2012 Component Recommended Regimens NNRTI plus nRTIs • Efavirenz/tenofovir/emtricitabine (AIa) • Efavirenz plus abacavir/lamivudine (AIa) in HLA-B*5701-negative patients with baseline plasma HIV-1 RNA <100,000 copies/mL PI/r plus nRTIs • Darunavir/r plus tenofovir/emtricitabine (AIa) • Atazanavir/r plus tenofovir/emtricitabine (AIa) • Atazanavir/r plus abacavir/lamivudine (AIa) in patients with plasma HIV-1 RNA <100,000 copies/mL InSTI plus nRTIs • Raltegravir plus tenofovir/emtricitabine (AIa) Thompson MA, et al. JAMA. 2012;308(4):387-402 From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. Slide 46 of 50 Your Patient • 43 year old man found to be HIV infected • HIV VL 56,000 c/ml • CD4 count 340 cells/ul • Seropositive for HBV From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. Slide 47 of 50 Initial Evaluation • Physical exam: normal; no hepatosplenomegaly • Initial laboratory studies – ALT 1.7 x ULN, bilirubin normal – Platelet count: 150,000 – HCV Ab negative – HBV DNA 6.1 x 105 IU/mL –HBsAg+ / HBeAg+ From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. Slide 48 of 50 FDA Approved Therapies First Line Therapy Year Peginterferon alfa-2a 2005 Entecavir 2005 Tenofovir 2008 Second Line Therapy Year Adefovir dipivoxil 2002 Telbivudine 2006 Third Line Therapy Year Lamivudine 1998 Available at http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/cder/drugsatfda/ Accessed 02/18/10. CLDF HBV Advisory Board From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. TDF: Virologic Suppression at Year 6 Response HBeAg- Patients (Study 102) Slide 49 of 50 HBeAg+ Patients (Study 103) Year 5 Year 6 Year 5 Year 6 HBV DNA < 400 copies/mL Intent-to-treat*, % (n/N) 83 (291/350) 81 (281/345) 65 (150/248) 63 (157/251) HBV DNA < 400 copies/mL On treatment†, % (n/N) 99 (292/295) 99.6 (283/284) 97 (170/175) 99 (167/169) ♦ 80% of 585 patients entering the open-label phase remained on study at year 6; 73% of enrolled patients remained on study ♦ HBeAg loss/seroconversion rates of 50% and 37%, respectively, through 6 years ♦ 11% of HBeAg+ patients had confirmed HBsAg loss (8% with seroconversion) ♦ No resistance to TDF was detected through 6 years Marcellin P, et al. AASLD 2012; Boston. #374. From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA. Slide 50 of 50 HBsAg Loss Occurred in 33% of HBeAg+ Pts Treated With 5 Years of ETV HBsAg Loss in HBeAg-positive Patients 33% Months Patients at risk 72 70 65 54 48 41 35 28 19 8 3 • HCC developed at yearly rate of 2.5% despite good viral suppression Conclusions: • Long-term ETV monotherapy efficiently suppressed HBV replication in naïve HBV patients • High rates of HBsAg loss can also be seen with this therapy Lampertico P, et al. 63rd AASLD; Boston, MA; November 9-13, 2012; Abst. 366. From MS Saag, MD and ES Daar, MD at San Francisco, CA: March 29, 2013, IAS-USA.