WEAK PRESIDENTS!!! 1 Rutherford B. Hayes 1876-1880 Republican • • • • • “Ends” Reconstruction Unfairly called “His Fraudulency” Temperance Advocate Negligible Record Unpopular with his own party (Republicans) 2 James A. Garfield (1881) Republican • “dark horse” candidate due to contest b/w “Stalwarts” and “Half-Breeds” in Republican party • Civil War General • “Rewards” his patron James G. Blaine • Assassinated by Charles Guiteau • Guiteau, likely insane, motivated by spoils system • Assassination prompts civil service reform 3 Chester Arthur (1881-1884) Republican • A spoilsman of the New York Conkling political machine • Surprising advocate of Civil Service reform • Pendleton Act of 1883 establishes merit based examinations and bi-partisan Civil Service Commission • Unintended consequence? LOBBYING and Corporate influence in Washington. 4 Grover Cleveland (1884-1888) Democrat • Defeats Blaine after defection of “mugwumps” from Republican Party • Cleveland was a noted reformer • Former mayor of Buffalo and governor of New York • Demoralizing campaign – little to distinguish parties other than greed for office • Blaine looses support of Irish Catholic voters, looses NY, looses race for failing to repudiate Nativist comments 5 Grover Cleveland (1884-1888) Democrat • Cleveland is “some-what” bipartisan due to Mugwumps influence • “Somewhat” upholds civil service reform • Personally takes on corruption in military pension system for Civil War veterans of the North, or the GAR (Grand Army of the Republic) • Forces the tariff issue into the debate for 1888 6 Cleveland’s Accomplishments • Dawes Act • Interstate Commerce Act • Returned much land to public domain, reversing power of cattle barons and railroads in the West • Personal integrity 7 Benjamin Harrison (1888-1892) Republican • Grandson of “Tippecanoe” • Possible Tariff spurs Republicans to action • Big Business backs Republicans with Big Money to preserve protective tariff • Harrison narrowly wins, though Cleveland won the popular vote 8 Industry Comes of Age 1865-1900 9 What do the failure of the Great Railroad Strike of 1877 and the Chinese Exclusion Act say about America after Reconstruction? 10 CLASS STRUGGLE? • 1877: Decline in Sectional Struggle marks opening of the class struggle • Panic of 1873 hits country hard • Railroad workers strike over 10% pay cuts • Pres. Hayes crushes the strike by sending in federal troops • Strikers tear apart on ethnic lines – Irish in West blame Chinese “Kearneyites” – Wave of anti-Chinese sentiment • Chinese Exclusion Act is passed 11 12 Railroad strike of 1877 Railroad strike of 1877 This engraving depicts striking railroad workers in Martinsburg, West Virginia, as they stop a freight train on July 17, 1877, in the opening days of the great railway strike of that year. Engravings such as this, which show the strikers to be heavily armed, may or may not have been accurate depictions of events. But the photography of that day could rarely capture live action, and the technology of the day could not reproduce photographs in newspapers, so the public's understanding of events such as the 1877 strike was formed through artists' depictions. (Library of Congress) 13 Copyright © Houghton Mifflin Company. All rights reserved. 14 http://www.msa.md.gov/msa/stagser/s1259/121/1797/html/0000.ht The Baltimore Railroad Strike & Riot of 1877 Chinese Exclusion Act • Irish and other European Immigrants attack Chinese, both physically and politically • Congress passes bill to close the “Golden Door” • Pres. Hayes refuses to sign it • Congress pasess law in 1882, ending Chinese immigration 15 What do the failure of the Great Railroad Strike of 1877 and the Chinese Exclusion Act say about America after Reconstruction? 17 Context • The Age of Monopolies, Trusts, and Big Labor • America accomplished heavy industrialization in the post-Civil War era. Spurred by the transcontinental rail network, business grew and consolidated into giant corporate trusts, as epitomized by the oil and steel industries. 18 QUIZ 1. What did the federal government give to railroad companies to encourage new construction of new track? 2. What is the name of the tycoon of the railroad industry? 3. What year was the “golden spike” driven? 4. Name one of the two railroad companies to create the transcontinental railroad. 5. What legislation attempted to regulate the railroads? 19 Map: Transcontinental Railroads and Federal Land Grants, 1850-1900 20 Map: Expansion of Agriculture, 1860-1900 Expansion of Agriculture, 1860-1900 The amount of improved farmland more than doubled during these forty years. This map shows how agricultural expansion 21 came in two ways--first, western lands were brought under cultivation; second, in other areas, especially the Midwest, land Copyright © Houghton Mifflin Company. All rights reserved. was cultivated much more intensely than before. Map: Industrial Production, 1919 22 The Iron Horse – Age of the Iron Rail • Railroads were paid for through land grants and government subsidies. Why? – What problems does this raise? • Construction of railroad helped by Civil War. How? • Union Pacific (East to West) construction begins during Civil War • Central Pacific (West to East) begins after • Golden Spike driven in Ogden, Utah 1869 23 Golden Spike driven in Ogden, Utah 1869 EFFECT: United East and West; opens trade with Asia 24 http://www.archives.gov/publications/prologue/images/promontory-point-utah.jpg What are the effects of the finalization of the transcontinental railroad? • • • • • • • • • • Closing of the “Wild West”-ecological disaster Spurs industrialization Tie the country together/decline in sectionalism Decline in Native American societies Corruption/Speculation Population shift Time zones created Millionaire class created (i.e Vanderbilt) 1886 – Supreme Court’s Wabash decision!!! Interstate Commerce Act-1887!!! the formation of the Interstate Commerce Commission 25 (pp. 541-542) OTHER EFFECTS OF THE TRANSCONTINENTAL RAILROAD New Inventions: – Steel rail – standard gauge rails – Westinghouse brake – Pullman Cars – standardized time-zones 26 Railroads and Corruption SCANDALS Credit Mobilier Stock watering Bribery of officeholders Creation of “pools” Secret “rebates” REFORM EFFORTS Granger Laws (reversed by Wabash case) Interstate Commerce Act of 1887 Were these effective? How? (see page 544.) 27 Interstate Commerce Act -1887 • Sec. 5. That it shall be unlawful for any common carrier subject to the provisions of this act to enter into any contract, agreement, or combination with any other common carrier or carriers for the pooling of freights of different and competing railroads, or to divide between them the aggregate or net proceeds of the earnings of such railroads, or any portion thereof; and in any case of an agreement for the pooling of freights as aforesaid, each day of its continuance shall be deemed a separate offense. 28 Why was the ICC necessary? What was the intent of the ICC? What was the effect of the ICC? (Did it work?) 29 RISE OF MONOPOLIES Overview • Efficient use of expensive machinery called for bigness and consolidation proved more profitable than ruinous price wars 31 1. The nation’s first billion dollar corporation was ____ ________. 2. Carnegie made his wealth through ___________ integration. 3. Rockefeller made his wealth through __________ integration. 4. The transcontinental railroad was completed in the state of ________. 5. The first attempt by the federal government to regulate business was the __________ ________ ________. 32 1. Vanderbilt made his fortune in what industry? 2. Congress’ first attempt to regulate the railroads was the ________ _______ Act in 1887. 3. Carnegie made his fortune in what industry? 4. Rockefeller made his fortune in what industry? 5. The key invention in the steel industry was the B_________ process. 33 1. JP Morgan made his fortune in what industry? 2. Carnegie made his fortune in what industry? 3. Rockefeller made his fortune in what industry? 4. US Steel was the nation’s first _____ dollar company. 5. The key invention in the steel industry was the B_________ process. 34 Experience • When was the last time you felt that the “game was rigged”? • Have you experienced the power of a monopoly? • Do you trust “big business”? 35 Vocabulary • Vertical integration = combining all phases of manufacturing in to one organization (Carnegie) • Horizontal integration = allying with competitors to monopolize a market (Rockefeller) • Trust = a board of directors/stockholders that coordinates companies within an industry to avoid competition • Syndicates = “interlocking directorates” of various competing enterprises and to consolidate an industry (JP Morgan) 36 Tycoons • Profiteering from the Civil War gives rise to millionaire class • Transcontinental railroad mechanization, industrialization, expansion of markets • Surplus of raw materials (coal + oil + iron), cheap labor, foreign investment • CAPITALISM Inventions Industrialization Inventions∞ ALL OF THIS GIVES RISE TO TYCOONS 37 Key Industrial Inventors and Inventions • Alexander Graham Bell = telephone • Thomas A. Edison = electric lights, phonograph • Bessemer Process/William Kelley = process to convert iron to steel • Kerosene lamp • Typewriter • automobile 38 Edison Lab at Menlo Park Edison Lab at Menlo Park Always a self-promoter, Edison used this depiction of his "invention factory" to suggest that his development of a durable light bulb in 1879 would have an impact on life around the globe. (Departrment of the Interior, National Park Service, Edison National Historic Site) 39 Copyright © Houghton Mifflin Company. All rights reserved. Thomas Edison Thomas Edison This photograph from 1893 shows Thomas A. Edison in his laboratory, the world's leading research facility when it opened in 1876. By creating research teams, the Edison laboratories could pursue several projects at once. They developed a dazzling stream of new products, most based on electrical power. (Library of Congress) 41 Copyright © Houghton Mifflin Company. All rights reserved. The Manufacture of Iron The Manufacture of Iron Manufacturing iron was a hot and strenous process, requiring workers to spend longs hours stoking hot blast furnaces. (Library of Congress) 42 Copyright © Houghton Mifflin Company. All rights reserved. Henry Demarest Lloyd: “The Lords of Industry," North American Review 331 (June 1884) http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/mod/1884hdlloyd.html We have given competition its own way, and have found that we are not good enough or wise enough to be trusted with this power of ruining ourselves in the attempt to ruin others. Free competition could be let run only in a community where every one had learned, to say and act "I am the state." We have had an era of material inventions. We now need a renaissance of moral inventions, contrivances to tap the vast currents of moral magnetism flowing uncaught over the face of society. … If the tendency to combination is irresistible, control of it is imperative. Monopoly and antimonopoly, odious as these words have become to the literary ear, represent the two great tendencies of our time: monopoly, the tendency to combination; antimonopoly, the demand for social control of it. … Our young men can no longer go west; they must go up or down. Not new land, but new, virtue must be the outlet for the future. … We cannot hereafter, as in the past, recover freedom by going to the prairies; we must find it in the society of the good. 43 Henry Demarest Lloyd: “The Lords of Industry," North American Review 331 (June 1884) 44 Andrew Carnegie = Steel Kingpin • Steel is King : US pouring out 1/3 of world’s steel by 1890’s • “bootstrap” story: poor immigrant to tycoon • Carnegie uses vertical integration with “Pittsburgh millionaires” • Controls all means of production, eliminates middle man • Sells to JP Morgan for 400 million • Becomes a philanthropist – gives away $350 million before his death; establishes endowments 45 Dangerous conditions at the Meadville, Pennsylvania Steel Company Dangerous conditions at the Meadville, Pennsylvania Steel Company Steel became a vital component of American industrialization in the late nineteenth century, both as a product itself and as a material necessary for countless new machines. Steel mills--such as this one in Meadville, Pennsylvania--employed large work forces in ever more expansive, and dangerous, settings. (Library of Congress) 46 Copyright © Houghton Mifflin Company. All rights reserved. J P Morgan – Banker’s Banker • • • • Builds financial empire through railroads, banks Employs syndicates/interlocking directorates Buys out Carnegie and enters steel business Uses syndicates to consolidate wealth & power • Forms US Steel Corporation – 1st billion $ corp. 47 Rockefeller – Standard Oil Corp. • Kerosene and then Automobiles drive US oil consumption • Rockefeller ruthlessly uses horizontal integration to create largest monopoly • See “The Octopus,” 1904 - Cartoon • 1877 controls 95% of oil refineries in US • Robber Baron’s Baron 48 Standard Oil Monopoly Standard Oil Monopoly Believing that Rockefeller's Standard Oil monopoly was exercising dangerous power, this political cartoonist depicts the trust as a greedy octopus whose sprawling tentacles already ensnare Congress, state legislatures, and the taxpayer, and are reaching for the White House. (Library of Congress) 49 Copyright © Houghton Mifflin Company. All rights reserved. WHAT ARE SOME OF THE TRUSTS FORMED IN THIS PERIOD? WHAT ARE THE PROS AND CONS OF THE TRUSTS? 50 Justifications for Big Business • Old Rich displaced by plutocracy of “new rich” • Gospel of Wealth – discourages helping the poor • Justified by Social Darwinism – survival of the fittest • Poor are poor due to lack of initiative 51 William Graham Sumner (1840-1910): The Challenge of Facts http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/mod/1914sumner.html The truth is that the social order is fixed by laws of nature precisely analogous to those of the physical order. The most that man can do is by, ignorance and self-conceit to mar the operation of social laws. The evils of society are to a great extent the result of the dogmatism and self-interest of statesmen, philosophers, and ecclesiastics who in past time have done just what the socialists now want to do. Instead of studying the natural laws of the social order, they assumed that they could organize society as they chose, they, made up their minds what kind of a society they wanted to make, and they planned their little measures for the ends they had resolved upon. … let us not imagine that the task will ever reach a final solution or that any race of men on this earth can ever be emancipated from the necessity of industry, prudence, continence, and temperance if they are to pass their lives prosperously. 52 William Graham Sumner (1840-1910): The Challenge of Facts http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/mod/1914sumner.html 53 Taking on the Trusts • Plutocracy defended by 14th amendment’s due process clause • Constitution’s “interstate commerce” clause inhibits states from controlling trusts • Sherman Anti-Trust Act of 1890 – Largely ineffective – IRONY: Used effectively against unions More trusts formed in 1890’s during President McKinley’s so-called anti-trust era than any other!!! 54 Industry and the South • 1900: less manufacturing than before Civil War • James B. Duke: mechanizes tobacco industry & creates tobacco trust • South acts primarily as source of raw materials • Shift in cotton mills from NE to S in 1880’s • Cheap labor (virtually sharecropping) brings rural white southerners to mill towns, traps them there 55 Impact of Industrialization • Urbanization • Erosion of Jeffersonian ideals • Women’s roles change – Delayed marriages – Smaller families • Accentuated class division – 1900: 1/10 of US owns 9/10 of US’s wealth – 1900: 2/3 of Americans are “wage slaves” • Workers’ lives increasingly precarious 56 Scribner's magazine cover Scribner's magazine cover Athletics, the bicycle vogue, and colleges for women such as Wellesley, all portrayed in this May, 1898 magazine cover, helped give middle-class young women a sense of new possibilities at the dawn of the twentieth century. (Courtesy, Wellesley College Archives) 57 Copyright © Houghton Mifflin Company. All rights reserved. Industry Comes of Age 1865-1900 Part 2 – Impact of Industrialization 58 1. Changes in the national economy in late-nineteenth century America resulted in a. b. c. d. A lower standard of living for most A decline in agriculture relative to manufacturing No significant changes in marriage patters or family life. Sharper class distinctions 2. The Knights of Labor were weakened by a. b. c. d. Its refusal to endorse social reform and the 8 hour day Stiff competition from the National Labor Union Its association in the public mind with the Haymarket riot Its inclusion of both skilled and unskilled workers 59 Context • The Age of Monopolies, Trusts, and Big Labor • Industrialization radically transformed the condition of American working people, but workers failed to develop effective labor organizations to match the corporate forms of business. 60 Experience • What do you think of unions? • Have you ever signed a petition? • Do you work now? – Do you think you are treated fairly? – Do you want to change your working conditions? – How would your boss/employer respond? 61 62 Women telephone workers, Roanoke, Virginia Women telephone workers, Roanoke, Virginia As this telephone office in Roanoke, Virginia, reveals, women office employees usually worked under the direct supervision of male managers. (Library of Congress) 63 Copyright © Houghton Mifflin Company. All rights reserved. Child worker, glass factory Child worker, glass factory Child labor was common in the factories of 19th century America. (Library of Congress) 64 Copyright © Houghton Mifflin Company. All rights reserved. Children in textile mills Children in textile mills Much of the new southern textile industry was based on child labor. These children were photographed by Lewis Hines in 1908. (National Archives/ Lewis Hines) 65 Copyright © Houghton Mifflin Company. All rights reserved. Rise of Big Labor • Increasing economic change social & economic disruption in workers’ lives • Labor strengthened by Civil War, then declines. Why? • Big Business doesn’t fight fair – Pools wealth to hire lawyers & scabs – “lockouts,” “yellow dog contracts,” blacklists” – “company towns” • National Labor Union – 1866 67 http://memory.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/r?ammem/hay:@field(DOCID+@lit(ichihayv03)):@@@$REF$ PREAMBLE AND DECLARATION OF PRINCIPLES OF THE KNIGHTS OF LABOR TO THE PUBLIC: The alarming development and aggressiveness of great capitalists and corporations, unless checked, will inevitably lead to the pauperization and hopeless degradation of the toiling masses. It is imperative, if we desire to enjoy the full blessings of life, that a check be placed upon unjust accumulation, and the power for evil of aggregated wealth. This much-desired object can be accomplished only by the united efforts of those who obey the divine injunction, "In the sweat of they face shalt thou eat bread." Therefore we have formed the Order of Knights of Labor, for the purpose of organizing and directing the power of the industrial masses, not as a political party, for it is more - … But no one shall, however, be compelled to vote with the majority, and calling upon all who believe in securing "the greatest good to the greatest number," to join and assist us, we declare to the world that are our aims are: 68 Knights of Labor Collective effort needed to counter trusts • Founded as a secret society in 1869. Why? • Led by Terence Powderly, Irish, utopian • Inclusive and Diverse: – men and women – white and black – skilled and unskilled • Broad (utopian? Socialist?) goals • HURT by Haymarket Square riot, 1886,Chicago • Associated with anarchists, falls into decline 69 Knights of Labor Knights of Labor Black delegate Frank J. Farrell introduces Terence V. Powderly, head of the Knights of Labor, at the organization's 1886 convention. The Knights were unusual in accepting both black and female workers. (Library of Congress) 70 Copyright © Houghton Mifflin Company. All rights reserved. STRIKES GREAT STRIKE OF 1877 HAYMARKET AFFAIR 1886 Railroad strike Paralyzed rail & commerce Labor march Bomb thrown Several deaths Pres. Hayes Sent US troops to end it 8 Anarchists arrested 4 hanged, 1 suicide CHINESE PUBLIC TURNS EXCLUSION ACT AGAINST LABOR HOMESTEAD STRIKE 1892 STEEL STRIKE Protest work & living conditions Pinkerton Detectives protect scabs, Several deaths US troops end it WEAKENS LABOR PULLMAN STRIKE 1893 Pullman Comp. cuts wages during Panic of 1893 Does not raise after ends Workers strike US troops end it Debs arrested Workers Blacklisted 71 LABOR WEAK Management and Labor Management and Labor 72 Copyright © Houghton Mifflin Company. All rights reserved. Management and Labor Management and Labor This cartoon, from Puck, April 7, 1886, shows Terence Powderly, in the center, advocating the position of the Knights of Labor on arbitration. The Knights urged that labor and management (identified here as "capital") should settle their differences this way, rather than by striking. Note how the cartoonist has depicted labor and management as of equal size, and given both of them a large weapon; management's club is labeled "monopoly" and labor's hammer is called "strikes." In fact, labor and management were rarely equally matched when it came to labor disputes in the late nineteenth century. (Puck, April 7, 1886) 73 Copyright © Houghton Mifflin Company. All rights reserved. American Federation of Labor • • • • • Skilled workers split from Knights of Labor 1886 AF of L was elitist in membership, narrow in goals Led by Samuel Gompers, Jewish cigar maker Foe of socialism and “utopian” policies Avoided politics and focused on union goals: – Better wages – Eight-hour day – Better working conditions • AF of L successful in many of its strikes and in meeting many of its goals 74 1. The Knights of Labor were weakened by a. Its refusal to endorse social reform and the 8 hour day b. Stiff competition from the National Labor Union c. Its association in the public mind with the Haymarket riot d. Its inclusion of both skilled and unskilled workers 75 KNIGHTS OF LABOR AF of LABOR 76 How was the Sherman AntiTrust Act used against Unions? (hint: look at Eugene V. Debs and the Pullman Strike in 1894) 77 America Moves to the City 1865-1900 78 Context • The Age of Monopolies, Trusts, Big Labor, and Big Cities • In the late nineteenth century, American Society was increasingly dominated by large urban centers. Explosive urban growth was accompanied by often disturbing changes, including the New Immigration, crowded slums, new religious outlooks, and conflicts over culture and values. Cities also offered new opportunities and new perspectives, especially to women. 79 Industrialization Urbanization Immigration 80 Growth (Rise?) of Cities • Booming population + immigration = explosive urban development • Cities hold best and worst of America: richest of the rich, poorest of the poor • Must solve problems of crowding, sanitation, education, and economic development/growth 82 http://www.archives.gov/research/american-cities/images/american-cities-034.jpg Dumbbell Tenement http://www.edteck.com/dbq/dbquest/quest11.htm 83 Immigrants: Who are they? Old Immigration = (Ireland + Germany) VS. New Immigration = (Southern Europe – Italians, Greeks + Central Europe – Slavs, Poles, Russians, Hungarians, etc. ) RESULT: US is increasingly diverse: we come from more countries and more religions, esp. Catholics and Jews 84 85 http://www.dallasfed.org/fed/annual/2001/ar01c.html Immigrants: Who are they? • Assimilation? • Many new immigrants form ghettos that preserve customs and languages. Takes several generations to “Americanize” • NATIVISM reemerges as a counterreaction, forms American Protective Association (APA) 86 ANGEL ISLAND VS. ELLIS ISLAND 1882: Congress starts to restrict immigration 1883 Chinese Exclusion Act 1886: Statue of Liberty. CONTRADICTION? 87 Important Folks to Remember: • Jane Addams: Reformer, studies social ills, founds Hull House in Chicago in 1889 • Mary Baker Eddy: founds Christian Science • Ida Wells: writer, activist; tackles lynching and discrimination • Booker T. Washington: founds Tuskegee and argues for “accommodation” to white society • WEB Du Bois: helps found NAACP, demands equality for “talented tenth” = 88 black community Ida B. Wells Ida B. Wells Ida B. Wells was a well-known crusader against lynching. (Schomburg Center for Research in Black Culture, New York Public Library, Astor, Lenox and Tilden Foundations) 89 Copyright © Houghton Mifflin Company. All rights reserved. W.E.B. Du Bois W.E.B. Du Bois A brilliant young intellectual, W.E.B. Du Bois had to choose between leading the life of a quiet college professor or challenging Booker T. Washington's claim to speak on behalf of all African Americans. (Schomburg Center for Research in Black Culture, New York Public Library, Astor, Lenox and Tilden Foundations) 90 Copyright © Houghton Mifflin Company. All rights reserved. Religion in the Cities • Most mainstream or old line Protestant churches struggle to address plight of urban poor • Catholicism thrives, founds schools and parishes • Salvation Army, YMCA and Christian Scientists are formed in this milieu • Darwinism undermines literal interpretation of Bible, “modernist” clergy respond. 91 EDUCATION • Americans believe education is THE ANSWER to fixing problems of industrialization and urbanization • Public HIGH schools are built at this time • Attendance at school (truancy) is enforced • Catholic school systems are built 92 EDUCATION • Many colleges for women and minorities are established • Teacher colleges are formed • Philanthropists fund universities (i.e Johns Hopkins, Vanderbilt, etc.) • Adult education begins Chautaqua Movement 93 NEW MORALITY & THE NEW WOMAN MOVEMENT • Families in industrial era experience sharp increase in divorce rate • Birth Control developed delayed marriage and dropping birth rate • Women challenge stereo-types limiting their roles in home and workplace 94 http://images.encarta.msn.com/xrefmedia/aencmed/targets/maps/map/T046212A.gif 95 NEW MORALITY & THE NEW WOMAN MOVEMENT 1871: Victoria Woodhull argues for “free love” 1873: COUNTER-REACTION Comstock Law – Targets “obscene pictures and photos” 1898: Charlotte Perkins Gilman publishes Women and Economics 1890: Foundation of National American Woman 96 Suffrage Assoc. (NAWSA) STOP AT PAGE 591, before “PROHIBITION OF ALCOHOL AND SOCIAL PROGRESS 97