RUNNING HEAD: THE HEART OF BRAZIL Page 1 The Heart of Brazil Hidden Truths behind the Brazilian Identity by Jordan Pigott An essay prepared for CIS 110 Prof. William Cooper University of Kentucky Fall 2014 THE HEART OF BRAZIL Page 2 Abstract Perceptions of the Brazilian community are often flawed due to the inaccurate portrayal of its members in society and the media today. This work aims to challenge these preconceptions, by examining the numerous individual characteristics and traditions that help form the basis of the Brazilian identity. This in-depth analysis explores the background of the Brazilian culture as well as the many different individuals that come together to form one great loving community. Along with its vast diversity, the Brazilian culture contains many strong customs and beliefs that simply cannot be defined through one stereotypical public image. Brazilians are very proud and optimistic individuals, yet are deeply concerned with the misrepresentation of their national image. In order to fully appreciate the Brazilian culture, the hidden truths of its identity must be revealed. THE HEART OF BRAZIL Page 3 Many people cannot fully recognize what the world has to offer until they take a look through someone else’s perspective. As a matter of fact, this idea has become an increasingly common issue in today’s society. Most individuals simply stick to the “comfort zone” of the communities they belong to without ever feeling the need to branch-out to explore the countless other cultures that make up the world. Often times, this behavior tends to lead to stereotyping and the misrepresentation of cultures unfamiliar to us. The Brazilian culture is no exception to this everyday social norm. After exploring the hidden truths behind the culture, I have discovered this: The cultural identity of the Brazilian community is far more diverse and dynamic than what is portrayed in society and the media. One of the most important contributing aspects to a community’s culture is its history. Brazil was discovered by Pedro Álvares Cabral on April 22,1500. From that point on, Portugal ruled over the land focusing greatly on agriculture and European immigration to achieve its wealth and success. Brazil also relied heavily on the importation of slaves from Africa to keep up with the high labor demands, as well as to help fully develop the nation. These major factors in Brazilian history later led to a great mix in the country’s race and ethnicity and well as the declaration of its independence on September 7, 1922 (Poelzl, 2002). Along with its history, the geography of Brazil Figure 1: States and Great Regions in Brazil is a major factor in forming the diversity of its culture. Brazil is the fifth largest country in the world, and covers a total of 3.3 million square miles. It is composed of five regions, as denoted in Figure 1, that divide the country into the following: THE HEART OF BRAZIL Page 4 North, Northeast, Central West, Southeast, and South. Each region is composed of it’s own unique identity and characteristics, as further explained here. Ms. Gabriela Rangel, a member of the Brazilian culture, further expanded upon the idea of regional cultures through her experience growing up in South Brazil: “The place I’m from, and if you go to the south, is very European influenced, because there was tons of immigration-especially from Italy, Portugal, and Germany. So you see a lot of Southern Brazil is like European places. But if you go up north, it’s much more pure and just Brazilian people. It’s a whole different culture. So it is very hard to compare Brazil as one whole thing, because it is so diverse” (personal communication, September 24, 2014). The Brazilian culture cannot be defined as one culture, but rather, it is commonly known as a melting pot of diversity. The sheer mass of Brazil, along with the increasingly large amount of immigration and the geographic regional divisions, has led to the creation of various cocultures, each with their own unique characteristics and traditions (Poelzl, 2002, p. 48). One of the largest reasons for this mix is the large mass of immigration during the early years of colonization. Immigration is a leading aspect in shaping the identity of the Brazilian culture today. Therefore, when asked what is a Brazilian – there is much more complexity and ambiguity to that answer than one would typically realize. Most of the Brazilian community is composed of indigenous colonizers, black African slaves, and white European settlers. However, groups such as the mulatos, coboclos, and mamelucos also exist, which are composed of mixed combinations of those three main individualities (Branco & Williams, 2006, p.29). These main groups are THE HEART OF BRAZIL Page 5 directly a result of two waves of immigration that completely transformed the Brazilian community into the multifaceted and diverse culture it is today. The first wave of immigration refers to the millions of African slaves that were involuntarily shipped over to Brazil’s sugar plantations. Once slavery was abolished, these slaves started identifying themselves as part of the Brazilian community, by referring to themselves “Afro-Brazilians.” According to Darlington, (2013) “Today, more than half of Brazilians identify themselves as black or of mixed race” (p.1). This leads to the strong African influence seen in many of the famous Brazilian customs and celebration we see in modern-day Brazilian culture. This includes African ties to music, religion, samba, and the great Brazilian Carnival. Along with the heavy African influences in the Brazilian culture, very strong modern-day connections are seen through the second wave of immigration- European settlers. Facing hardships in their own countries, many people immigrated to Brazil in hopes of creating wealth and success for themselves. They, therefore, added their previous industrial ideals of progress and development to the Brazilian society and culture (Branco & Williams, 2006, p.41). This culture offers the unique opportunity to live in a community side-by-side with Europeans, Africans, Arabs, Jews, Japanese, and indigenous peoples, without any social segregation based on background (Darcy De Oliveira, 2001, p.2). According to President Fernando Henrique Cardoso of Brazil, “we Brazilians are an extremely homogenous people in cultural terms. Our regional differences are mere variations on a basic cultural theme, the result of a fusion of Western and Portuguese with Africans and Amerindian traditions”(Poelzl, 2002, p.47). Despite the huge mix in race, ethnicity, and origin, a very strong sense of national identity continues to exist in the Brazilian people. THE HEART OF BRAZIL Page 6 When it comes to the identity of Brazil, it’s best to think big. Brazilian people love to dream big and set high aspirations for themselves, although many times they can be a little unreasonable. This community is very self-sufficient, not only because of its sheer size, but also because of its language. Brazil happens to be the only country in Latin America that speaks Portuguese, rather than the traditional Spanish. According to Branco & Williams (2006), “one of the things that unifies Brazilians from all regions and social classes is their passions for TV soap operas, or novelas” (p.56). These shows portray the Brazilian’s distinct identity, while reflecting the way their community thinks and lives. They help to form individual self-concept, as well as shape their ideal image. One way they strive to achieve this goal is through optimism. Brazilians are very happy and lighthearted people. Gabriela Rangel defines the Brazilian culture: “From what I see, it’s a very happy and energetic culture. People don’t complain too much about their lives. Everyone is willing to work, not complain all the time, and still have fun. There’s just a lot of energy everywhere. People [in America] complain more and they’re less satisfied with their lives than people [in Brazil]. [Brazilian] people are much more content with what they have and they appreciate it more” (personal communication, September 24, 2014). The Brazilian culture focuses a lot on living in the moment and believing that everything will work out in the end. One of the strong principles that the Brazilians live by when dealing with life’s tribulations is known as “Jeitnho Brasileiro” (Branco & Williams, 2006, p. 60). This essentially declares that if there’s a will, there’s a way. Members of the Brazilian community hold very strongly to these beliefs. THE HEART OF BRAZIL Page 7 The leading belief of the Brazilian culture is religion. According to Darcy De Oliveira (2001), “Catholicism is Brazil’s dominant religion, with many influences from African and Pentecostal churches as well” (p.3). Eighty percent of the population is Catholic, making Brazil the world’s largest catholic country (Poelzl, 2002, p. 67). The Brazilian community is deeply spiritual and believes that God is everywhere in Brazil, acting and interfering with their everyday lives. In fact, one of Brazil’s most iconic symbol and tourist attractions is the Statue of Christ the Redeemer on Corcovado, located in Rio de Janiero, as seen in Figure 2. Along with Catholicism, there are numerous African and Native influenced religions practiced throughout the many different regions of Brazil. The most popular include: Protestantism, Candomblé, Umbanda, Macumba, and Spiritualism. Each religion has it’s own unique characteristics, values, and beliefs, as denoted here, that make up individual co-cultures of the Brazilian community. Protestantism originated during the second wave of immigration from Europe. Its Figure 2: Rio de Janeiro Jesus members focus on the Holy Spirit and the guidance of Jesus Christ, rather than on catholic saints. Candomblé is an African based religion made up of ancestral rituals and myths practiced by slaves in the early days of colonization. Rather than preaching in a church, these members partake in ceremonial dancing, chanting, and drumming followed by a sacred meal. Spiritualism, also known as Kardecism, focuses on positivism and the reincarnation of the spirit after it has departed. Umbanda is based mainly on the idea that members are guided through life by their own wisdom, which allows them to understand and solve any type of conflict in the world around them. Lastly, Macumba, also known as THE HEART OF BRAZIL Page 8 Quimbanda, explores the idea of the ambivalence between good and evil in everyday life. Members of the Macumba religion believe they work for evil, while members of the Umbanda religion work for good (Branco & Williams, 2006 p. 73-77). Many times these religions interact with one another, allowing their ideas to blend together, forming new philosophies and create new mindsets. Aside from their religion, Brazilians have several other customs and traditions that help to shape their cultural identity. What is the first thing that people think of when someone mentions Brazil? Futbol- more commonly know in the United States as soccer. The most dominating social norm that sweeps throughout the entire culture of Brazil is the love and devotion to the sport of futbol. This is one of the most important identifying aspects of the Brazilian culture. Futbol is a key cultural identity that originated when the African slaves arrived in Brazil during the early years of colonization. Today, “Futbol can be seen as the cult that brings together Brazilians from all belief systems (Branco & Williams, 2006 p.79).” Futbol is an enjoyable sport for all Brazilians, regardless of age, race, or social class. This is a sport that evokes such strong passion to unify the entire Brazilian community. Throughout this community, a lot of corruption, social exclusion, violence, and racism exist, but futbol is one of the few things that does not take any of these things into account. Everyone is welcomed into the sport. According to Murad, “It is the most spontaneous, unpredictable, easiest, cheapest, and democratic sport of all” (p.2). Futbol is more than just a game; it symbolizes acceptance and equality throughout the entire Brazilian community. Many families gather around their TVs to watch and cheer on their teams to victory. Whether a Brazilian team wins or loses, the people are directly impacted by the devastation or celebration of each game. THE HEART OF BRAZIL Page 9 One event in particular that is often cherished and religious followed by Brazilians is the “Fifa World Cup.” This is an event that draws all Brazilians together to celebrate the sport of futbol. As a matter of fact, the most recent 2014 World Cup was hosted in one of Brazil’s major cities - Rio de Janeiro. This publicity led society and the media to stereotype the Brazil community as solely futbol-based, with no other cultural identity. Although it seemed like a great opportunity for a nation with such a strong love and passion for the game, there were many ugly truths surrounding this event, as revealed here, which are typically hidden from the media and public eye. Due to such little care from the government, it is a strong tradition in the Brazilian culture that families must stick together and act as a support system to one another. The Brazilian culture is a very tight-knit culture. They are a very dependent community, and help each other out through the good times and the bad. Family comes first in Brazil. Ms. Deborah Rashidi, a current member of the Brazilian community, explained the importance her culture places on the tradition of family. One very common custom in her family was that she would always attend church on Sundays with her family. After church, she would then gather at her grandparent’s house for Sunday lunch (personal communication, September 25, 2014). This is a very common ritual in the Brazilian community. Another very common aspect of the Brazilian culture is the Machismo, or patriarch-based attitudes and customs. Although the Brazilian families are very tight-knit, a great deal of gender inequality is present throughout community. Women must conform to the “masculine territories of power,” while having to hide in their own private lives (Darcy De Oliveira, 2001, p.3). Women are expected to adhere to the “traditional role” of caring for the home day-by-day. They are considered weak and are their purpose is to serve the dominant male in their lives. Men have a lot more privileges and a much greater voice in the Brazilian community. Men are the THE HEART OF BRAZIL Page 10 providers and act as the head of the family. They are far more superior to women in Brazil. Machismo depicts men as aggressive and domineering, while women must remain passive and respectful. Branco & Williams (2006) explains this idea by saying, “the women will decide on the décor and the man will choose the family car (p.100). Men get to make all the major decisions, while the women must focus on the home and the children. This is a very common principle, not only in Brazil, but also throughout the rest of the Latin American. Although women have been taking steps to counter these sexist attitudes and social norms, men continue to remain the dominant figures in the Brazilian culture. Along with these gender roles, appearances mean a great deal to the overall image and attitudes of Brazilians as well. An old Brazilian saying exists that states: “The world treats people better when they dress well.” Brazilians strongly believe that you are what you appear to be (Branco & Williams, 2006, p. 64). The individuals of this culture are very conscious of how they want to represent themselves in the public eye. Brazilians care a lot about beauty and believe that everyone should strive to be proud of who they are and what they look like. Communicating in the Brazilian culture is a tad different than here the United States. First of all, the dominant language of the Brazilian culture is Portuguese. Besides the language, there are many different expectations and standards when communicating in the Brazilian community. In the Brazilian culture, individuals have a very relaxed and easy-going body language. Conversations are very lively and energetic, with many vibrant gestures and interruptions. Brazilians also utilize a great deal of humor throughout their exchanges, even if it is not always politically correct. Hellos and Goodbyes, on the other hand are quite formal. It is custom for men and women to kiss on the cheek - twice if they are single, and three times if they are married- when they are introduced, and repeated when they are leaving (Branco & Williams, THE HEART OF BRAZIL Page 11 2006, p. 157). Brazilians are very open and hospitable communicators so they love getting together and putting on these elaborate celebrations for their community to enjoy. When it comes to celebrations, nobody does it better than the Brazilians. The Brazilian community holds a long-standing tradition for its spectacular festivals and holidays celebrated all throughout the year. Not only does the Brazilian community celebrate traditional holidays such as Easter, Christmas, and New Year’s, they also have various cultural holidays, such as the June Festivals and All Souls Day. The June Festivals are a series of celebrations throughout the month of June to commemorate the three Catholic saints: Anthony (June 13th), John (June 24th), and Peter (June 29th). The largest festival of the June Parties takes place on the day of St. John the Baptist. This festival includes an enormous street party with traditional Brazilian food, drinks, music, and dancing. Every school, church, and family holds their own little party in honor of the catholic faith. “All Souls Day,” is the Brazilian version of “Day of the Dead,” and is dedicated to remembering the loved ones who have passed away. Many families visit the cemeteries and celebrate the lives of those they have lost. There are also many local festivals throughout the Brazilian communities that vary based on region such as: The Paratins Folklore Festival, Candles of Nazareth, and Castainho’s Black Mother (Branco & Williams, 2006, p. 91-94). The largest festival of celebration in the Brazilian community is the Carnaval. These celebrations are held in major cities like Salvador and Olinda, but the biggest and most famous one is held in Rio de Janeiro. This Carnaval is the largest demonstration of Brazilian Culture in the World, and is composed of samba dancing, cultural music, folklore, and a massive parade, that completely takes over the city and it’s streets. What most people don’t realize is that this parade is actually a competition as well, as further explained here. Each “samba school” in the top division of the nation designs a float, based on the Brazilian culture, and then coordinates THE HEART OF BRAZIL Page 12 visuals, music, dance, and narrative elements to form a perfectly staged performance for all of Carnaval to see. Carnaval is a very special tradition that allows people of all races, ethnicities, and social classes come together to celebrate their culture and identity. Members of the Brazilian community are known to be very proud and happy individuals. They hold very strong to their cultural values and beliefs, while living everyday to it’s fullest. They have a very strong sense of nationalism, and are often very laid-back and optimistic people, until their identity is questioned or misrepresented. According to Steve Kingston (2007), “Behind the carefree exterior is a nation deeply concerned, perhaps even paranoid, about what outsiders think” (p.1). The problem with society and the world today is that everyone is so quickly to judge and stereotype people of different communities. Little do they know how much these labels actually affect those people, and leave a lasting impact on their cultural identity. Stereotypes are very powerful in forming the identity of a culture unfamiliar to us. Bradley Gorham (1999) describes stereotypes as “a particular subset of social reality beliefs: they are understandings about particular social groups that we have learned from our social world” (p.232). Essentially, stereotypes are formed as a result of a society assigning certain characteristics and traits to a distinctive culture, regardless of any real accuracy. This is very true when analyzing the preconceptions of the dominant culture towards Brazil. Brazilians are forced to accept and comply with these labels throughout many different aspects of their culture. Most people, when they think of Brazil, they think about the beaches, Carnaval, the urban poor, the violence, and the women. Although these are all important aspects of the Brazilian culture, they are often not accurately perceived or portrayed in the dominant American society. Some of the most common stereotypes towards the Brazilian community refer to appearances. For starters, people believe that all Brazilians must be dark-skinned Latinos. Therefore, if they THE HEART OF BRAZIL Page 13 are Latinos, they must speak Spanish as their primary language. Another common presumption is that Brazilians are believed to be lazy, unmotivated, and worthless individuals, who just go out and lie on the beach all day. Although these seem like very little misconceptions to us, this plays a huge role in affecting how various Brazilians view their public image in society. These appearance-based stereotypes are especially apparent when referring to the public image of women in the Brazilian culture. Sexism is the nation’s dominant stereotype (Portela, 2014, p.2). Whether Brazilians like it or not, they are perceived as highly focused on female beauty and Figure 3: Perception of Brazilian Women sensuality. Therefore, Brazilian women are viewed in very hyper-sexualized ways, as pictured in Figure 3. Ms. Deborah Rashidi further expanded on her views of this common portrayal of women in her culture: “I think the first thing is that [people think] girls are very easy. All the guys, when I say I am Brazilian, they’re like, “Ooo you’re Brazilian!” Then they look at me differently- and I don’t like that. But it’s what they see in movies. They show Brazilians almost naked. It is terrible and I don’t agree with that. But that’s just how it is, I guess” (personal communication, September 25, 2014). As a result of these harsh stereotypes, Brazilian women are not taken seriously and are constantly expected to conform to the idea of the “perfect body.” Nowadays, this stereotype has lead to the center of Brazil’s tourism to be focus on the “sex appeal,” or making the country one of the top destinations for sexual tourism (Portela, 2014, p.2). In reality, this ideal is not how Brazilian THE HEART OF BRAZIL Page 14 women truly wish to present themselves, and it is only a result of the dominant American stereotypical society. Another main conception Americans have about the Brazilian culture relates to the urbanization and violence in Brazil. Many people do not realize that cities in Brazil are very similar to cities in America. Ms. Gabriela Rangel gives her view on this common misconception towards the Brazilian culture: “People always ask me, do you live in the rainforest or do you see monkeys waling around? People think Brazil is like Figure 4: São Paulo Skyline one big rainforest and that there are just indigenous people everywhere, when really, it’s so industrialized and developed” (personal communication, September 24, 2014). Figure 4 portrays a realistic image of a major city of Brazil. The Brazilian community is also very commonly linked to heavy violence and massive gangs. Many Americans believe it is too unsafe to enter Brazil, and therefore all Brazilians are dangerous people. With a precarious political system, as well as an unstable economy, the Brazilian community is very well known for its never-ending struggle to make ends meet. Because of this, many are forced to live in the infamous favelas, or shantytowns that line the outskirts of the major cities. Often times, these favelas are portrayed in the media as very dangerous and violent, therefore reflecting that image upon the members of the Brazilian community. Although sometimes Brazil may be a little risky, there are bad parts to every major U.S. major city as well. The Brazilian community is a very friendly, tight-knit community that is forced to comply with these stereotypes affecting how others view them in society. THE HEART OF BRAZIL Page 15 The most important factor in forming the dominant perception of the Brazilian community is the media. Stereotypes in the media heavily influence people’s interpretations of dominant racial myths. The media primes the idea of racial stereotypes into the forefront of the viewer’s thinking in order to maintain harmful and dominating understandings of a certain cultural background (Gorham, 1999, p.246). Many times, the media will only portray the Brazil of popular imagination and stereotypes, rather than give an accurate depiction of the realities surrounding the Brazilian culture and community. The media is the leading reason as to why Brazil is misrepresented and misperceived the way it by America today. Unfortunately, the Brazilian community doesn’t do much to change these perceptions of their culture. Ms. Deborah Rashidi explains this phenomenon, by saying, “[The Brazilians] don’t feel like they can change it. They are tired of trying and it’s just like they get too used to it- and I don’t like that” (personal communication, September 25, 2014). Brazil is desperate to be taken seriously as a nation and a culture, but they are constantly left feeling inferior to nations perceived more developed (Kingstone, 2007, p.1). This has resulted in the Brazilian community simply accepting their fate and working to represent themselves to the best of their personal abilities. When I first began my exploration of the Brazilian culture, I didn’t know what to expect. My only previous knowledge of the community came from the stereotypical views of the media and the dominant American society. Therefore, when I thought of Brazil, The only things I could think of were futbol, Carnaval, and the massive urban poverty. I viewed the community as a very poor and undeveloped community, composed of mostly indigenous people, with little to no diversity. I pictured the nation of Brazil to be one great big rainforest, except major cities that were simply composed of shantytowns and favelas. When I first thought of the Brazilian THE HEART OF BRAZIL Page 16 community, I had no idea how strong and passionate its members are for their values, traditions, and cultural identity. As my research progressed, I noticed how little of the culture I knew prior to my exploration. I realized how complex and diverse a culture separate from my own, could truly be. As I gained a well-rounded understanding for the community, I saw my views dramatically shift. The Brazilian community is actually a very happy community, with many rich traditions and beliefs that form a very define cultural identity. I also noticed how poorly cultures are portrayed in the media, and how one must educate themself, before making any assumptions or judgments about any particular community. The Brazilian community cannot fully be appreciated until the hidden truths of its cultural identity have been found. For a country with such a define self-concept and prominent mix of diversity, little recognition is shown throughout our stereotypical America. This community is composed of so much more than just futbol and Carnaval, but instead, a wide variety of beliefs, customs and traditions that help shape the image of the Brazilian people today. Although they face many hardships, the members of the Brazilian community always stay positive and live life to it’s fullest. Expanding knowledge of any particular community can help see past the barriers of communication and develop a new sense of understanding for what’s its like to go through life misrepresented in society. THE HEART OF BRAZIL Page 17 References Branco, S., & Williams, R. (2006). Culture Smart! Brazil (Rev. ed.). London: Kuperard. Darcy De Oliveira, R. (2001). 500 Years of Brazil: Global and Cultural Perspectives. LusoBrazilian Review, 38(2), 1-5. Darlington, S. (2013, July 24). From Samba to carnival: Brazil's thriving African culture. Retrieved October 5, 2014, from http://www.cnn.com/2012/10/23/world/africa/africanculture-brazil/ Gorham, B. (1999). Stereotypes In The Media: So What? Howard Journal Of Communications, 10(4), 229-247. Retrieved October 6, 2014. Kingstone, S. (2007, February 22). No stereotypes please-we're Brazilian. Retrieved October 6, 2014, from http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/programmes/from_our_own_correspondent/6383919.stm Murad, M. (n.d.). Football and Society in Brazil. Retrieved October 31, 2014, from http://www.kas.de/wf/doc/kas_9018-544-2-30.pdf?060830124836 Perception of Brazilian Women [Photograph]. Retrieved October 11, 2014, from: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/travel/article-2661609/The-sexiest-nations-world-Brazilcomes-Great-Britain-isnt-far-behind.html Poelzl, V. (2002). Culture shock! Brazil (New expanded ed.). Portland, Ore.: Graphic Arts Center Pub. Portela, S. (2014, April 3). Brazil: The hypersexualisation of a nation. Retrieved October 5, 2014, from http://www.pulsamerica.co.uk/2014/04/03/brazil-the-hypersexualisation-of-anation/ Rangel, G. (2014, September 24). Personal Interview. Rashidi, Deborah. (2014, September 25). Personal Interview. Rio de Janeiro Jesus [Photograph]. Retrieved October 11 2014, from: http://nonlypictures.blogspot.com/2011/04/rio-de-janeiro-jesus.html São Paulo Skyline [Photograph]. Retrieved October 11, 2014, from: http://www.discoveringsaopaulo.com/2012/10/eric-bergeris-aerial-shots-of-saopaulo.html THE HEART OF BRAZIL Page 18 States and Great Regions in Brazil [Photograph]. Retrieved October 11, 2014, from: http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File: States_and_Great_Regions_in_Brazil.png