CAPTION “I love America more than any other country in this world, and exactly for this reason, I insist on the right to perpetually criticize.” – James Baldwin Bill Cosby, 1968 NARRATION VIDEO IMAGE MAP DATE Black History: Lost, Stolen, or Strayed. Andy Rooney. CBS News (1968) CONTEXT 2-3 paragraph intro to video, with info on Baldwin and why him – SC draw in R. Kennedy’s U of Capetown speech regarding his “deep affection” for a country . . . I’m speaking of the USA” (link to the This American Life episode on the same). NOTE James Baldwin, “Autobiographical Notes” (1952) Bill Cosby’s controversial NAACP speech in 2004 articulates themes that diverge from those celebrated in this 1968 documentary and much of his other earlier work (including his long-running children’s program Fat Albert and the Cosby Kids). The current remix foregrounds themes far more in keeping with this earlier work, echoing and drawing from critiques of Cosby’s 2004 speech—especially Michael Eric Dyson’s Is Bill Cosby Right? Or Has the Black Middle Class Lost its Mind? MISC. 1 2 “Of particular note in this critique is Dyson’s …” – SC? See also *“Cornel West Commentary: Cosby’s Comments” (The Tavis Smiley Show, 2004) *”Michael Eric Dyson Commentary: Cosby’s Comments” (The Tavis Smiley Show, 2004) *”Is Bill Cosby Right” (Talk of the Nation, 2004) Cosby later teamed up with Alvin F. Poussaint, extending his arguments in Come On People: On the Path from Victims to Victors (2007). “I Searched for Myself” 3 “I searched for images of myself in the historic photos of ET. My assignment was a remix of existing artifacts from the archives. I wanted to write about my people. I wanted to see faces like mine in the historical photos of the campus. Black students like me. Black athletes like me.” I kept searching. CAPTION William L. Mayo, 1889 I kept searching. NARRATION In 1889, William L. Mayo, a pioneering educator from Kentucky, established this … teacher training school for the area’s white farmers and their children. Mayo believed “…no student should be turned away for lack of academic preparation or funds.” Original: Jamar Mosley, the student athlete who created the original video essay that inspired the current remix. VIDEO Commerce, TX 2011 Jamar Mosley completed this assignment for an upper division writing course Carter taught Spring 2011. The course, “Remixing Northeast Texas,” served as a pilot for the current project (“Remixing Rural Texas”). “You might find…” http://desegregationtamu.weebly.com/the-struggle.html Commerce, TX 2011 Oral history with Mosley available in the Northeast Texas Digital Collections or on YouTube here. IMAGE Mayo at Desk. Photograph. 1915. Historic ET Collection, Commerce, TX. Northeast Texas Digital Collections. Web. Feb. 2012. Mayo with Plow. Photograph. MAP Commerce, TX DATE CONTEXT See East Texas State University, Texas Historical Marker Normal Guide Publications, Pamphlet principles, what’s going on in NE TX Commerce, TX 1889 College Hall. Class of 1897, Commerce, TX Commerce, TX 1900 1897 Original video upon which this remix is based available here. NOTE (Carter and Conrad 7) 4 5 6 MISC. 7 Carter, Shannon and Jim Conrad. “In Possession From the beginning, as David Gold argues, “Mayo sought to make East Texas integral to the community” by providing local citizens with extensive rhetorical training.” (Gold 122) Poor farmers For further reading, see Rhetoric at the Margins, Revising the History of Writing Instruction in American Colleges, 1873-1947. David Gold. Southern Illinois University Press, 2008. Brief bio of Mayo, cow lot fight, buildings symbolize the growth A little English intro before stats about what Mayo was trying to combat and what the situation was before he came , Kyle Wilkison info on poverty of Hunt County, use 1900 numbers instead of 1910 – no way to pull in Wilkison and use 1900 numbers, because he uses 1870 to 1910 as his dates. Between 1870 and 1910, the rural community in East Texas underwent a radical transformation. Immigrants led to a population increase, and Hunt County’s 1910 farm values were six times what they had been in 1870, even though the average farm sized halved over the same time span. Unfortunately for Hunt County residents, though 81.3% of the county’s land area consisted of farms, by 1910, only 32.4% of these farms were operated by their owners, with an astonishing 67.5% being worked by tenants, leading to in increase in the numbers of farmers still sharecropping. Due to need for tenants to 8 (Catalog, 1908). (Gold 153) 9 10 Gold, David. Rhetoric at the Margins, 1 plant cotton, self-sufficiency became almost impossible and absolute poverty rates in the country increased six times, and the wealthiest thirty percent of the population increased their wealth, with the remaining seventy percent losing ground.. Mayo, however, was working to combat illiteracy rates of 5.2%, with only 62.6% of county residents aged six through twenty (inclusive), being enrolled in school. (Wilkison 206 & 1910 Census) Sam Rayburn, Class of 1903 In terms of financial need, Sam Rayburn was typical of the students Mayo’s college was designed to serve. Rayburn “worked his way through by ringing the college bell, sweeping out classrooms, making fires and doing other odd jobs, [eventually] earning . . . a Bachelor of Science degree [in 1903]. He would go on to study law in Austin and, by 1913, begin serving this district in Washington DC. As Speaker of the House for 17 years, he would also help sign into law the most significant civil rights legislation since Reconstruction: the Civil Rights Bill of 1957. The farm ownership percentages contrast with state averages of 46.9% and 52.6%, respectively. “For a case in point, consider Sam Rayburn, our university’s most famous alumnus and the US Congressional District this congressman represented from 1913 and 1961. Throughout much of the 20th century, rural conditions and poverty defined North Texas. Forever loyal to the (white) farmers and small business owners who were his constituency, Rayburn was fond of saying: “I want my people out of the mud and I want my people out of the dark.” Rayburn’s tireless advocacy for rural electrification helped bring power to the remote farms (Rural Electrification Act, 1936). His first-hand accounts of the harsh, muddy soils of the region helped justify the paving of multiple farm-to-market roads, vastly improving access and connectivity among farmers in emote areas businesses in town. Though Rayburn himself was a long-time segregationist serving a conservative southern district widely opposed to civil rights legislation, he was also a fiercely loyal Democrat representing his constituency and his country in a rapidly changing world. As Speaker of the House, this mentor to LBJ was instrumental in passing the most significant civil rights legislation since the Reconstruction: the Civil Rights Act in 1957. It is in this sense that local rhetoric both connects—at times literally—and separates us to/from one another and the rest of the nation/world.” (Carter and Conrad 24-25) Commerce, TX Washington DC (Carter 14) 11 Carter, Shannon. “Writing Democracy in Rural Texas ( Carter and Conrad. “In Possession of.” CCC, 2012. (forthcoming) We need dates for all the Sam Rayburn pics, and their locations, in order of appearance Source: Carter, CCC 2012 Indeed, Mayo’s original mandate would guide the college for more than half a century: “Any person,” Mayo insists in a 1908 college catalog, “of whatever age, wealth, or previous advantages” who desired a college education could have one, “regardless of their ability to pay.” Like any such institution across the Jim Crow South, however, “any person” meant “any white person.” Class of 1905 A.B. Graduates. Commerce, TX 1905 More about Rayburn (Carter and Conrad 7) Carter, Shannon and Jim Conrad. “In Possession. Greenville sign Greenville, TX 19211969 ** Across from the train station, right at the entrance to Greenville’s downtown area, a sign that read “Welcome to Greenville: Blackest Land. Whitest People” was installed in 1921 and removed nearly half a century later. Conversations about the sign, its legacy, and its intent remain charged more than forty years later, even after the installation of a very different sign, in 2010, the result of extensive lobbying and fundraising by one long-time resident and city council member: “Welcome to Greenville. Building Toward an Inclusive Community.” Both signal formal connections with a national project to improve race relations at local levels. A future documentary will explore the complex ebb and flow of critical race narratives at local levels, offering the complex interplay of local and national rhetoric surrounding this controversial sign as a case in point. Paul’s article, Texas Black Codes http://home.gwu.edu/~jjhawkin/BlackCodes/pdfTexas.pdf (Carter and Conrad 8) 12 (Catalog, 1908) 13 Carter, Shannon and Jim Conrad. “In Possession also consider: http://www.shannoncarter-blog.org/2011/05/05/welcome-to-greenville-blackest-land-whitest-people/ and See also 60 Minutes (Geter case, 1983) Huey, Brenda. The Blackest Land, the Whitest People: Greenville, Texas. Bloomington, IN: AuthorHouse, 2006. For further reading, see The Path to a Modern South: Northeast Texas between Reconstruction and the Great Depression. Walter L. Buenger. University of Texas Press, 2001. ISBN 0292708882 Print. I kept searching. I kept searching… I did not see myself in photos of the basketball team. Black screen Basketball Action. Yearbook. Print. Commerce, TX 1955 Race in Sports? Losingtowin.wfu.edu Henry Ross, Carlos, Page, Jamar 14 15 2 There were no faces like mine on the football field. Football Action 1 Commerce, TX Date? I didn’t see myself in the band, at social events, East Texans Band. Social Event. Commerce, TX Commerce, TX 1940 1952 in the classroom. 1930class-2 1940scienceclass Commerce, TX Commerce, TX 1930 1940 “[P]eople who imagine that history flatters them (as it does, indeed, since they wrote it) are impaled on their history like a butterfly on a pin and become incapable of seeing or changing themselves in the world.” –James Baldwin "Old South Week was an event held each year by the fraternity Kappa Alpha. The event filled the campus with images echoing all the glory of the era depicted in Gone with the Wind. Old South Week 1 Commerce, TX 1970 Plantation System in Southern Life. Even at the height of the Civil Rights Moment, the event often included mock slave auctions where fraternity pledges dressed up in black face to play the role of slaves. Old South Week Commerce, TX 1955 Plantation System in Southern Life. Old South Week, Kappa Alpha This event was finally moved off campus in 1973 when African American students protested. “Black Awareness Week.” Commerce, TX 1973 The 2006 Disney film, “Glory Road,” is based on the first all-black basketball at Texas Western, present day UTEP, in 19651966. The Texas Western Miners went on to win the national title in 1966, and overcome racial fueled mental and physical attacks. The movie shows East Texas State University, present day Texas A&M University – Commerce, as a home team playing the Miners. East Texas State University is portrayed a racially hateful institution, “throwing drinks and popcorn and yelling racial slurs at Texas Western.” Shortly after the film’s release, Texas A&M University – Commerce desired apology from the Walt Disney Company, as the film harshly inaccurately portrayed the University. The game between the two schools that year was actually played at Texas Western. It is a good speculation that the institution would have issue at that time with an all-black basketball team; however, the movie was inaccurate. The outcome of the game was better portrayed, as Texas Western defeated East Texas State in the movie as was in reality. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bear_Bryant#University_of_Alabama http://loneliberal-teamman42.blogspot.com/2012/01/roll-tide.html Bear Bryant: Symbol for an Embattled South Carlton Cooper What did they do for fun? Talk about the innocence of the era, but underneath the façade, the Cold War is forcing change to occur because of interest convergence – Elvis, national, Communism and the labor CRM leads to death of movement because of the spectre of Communism Academics, teacher training + Gee *Additional context needed (national, international) - African maxim ““Until Lions write their own history, the tale of the hunt will always glorify the hunter.”” Explain it Malcolm X autobiography -recognize the positive, but don’t forget that there’s a story not being told 16 17 18 19 Baldwin, James. 20 Kappa Alpha Order is a fraternity that started in Virginia at Washington College in 1865. At the time, General Robert E. Lee served as president of the institution. The fraternity was inspired by General Lee, and glorified him as a hero and representative of the perfect gentlemen. Even now, the order maintains a strong belief in the traditions and values of the South. Though they argue that they are not racially biased, their event, “Old South Week”, promoted the old values of the region and point in time that held slavery to be essential. From Adam – Perfect gentlemen, Birth of a Nation *Additional context needed (national, international) Came from the days when plantation life was in full flower. Wright 12MBV pg 98 “The slow southern drawl” Apology indicating the positive spin on it, readings of symbols then and compare to what the symbols mean now 21 *Additional context needed (national, international) 24 “Elihue Smith. poet, gave viewers a dramatic background while they saw the display of Black Art in the Texas Ballroom. The first annual of Black Awareness week was held September 18-22.” Source: The East Texas State University LOCUST Yearbook 1973. 25 22 23 The unconscious absent absence Plantation System in Southern Life. 26 3 5_oldsouthweek (2) Eventually I found them. “Eventually I found them” They were in fragments of slave receipts in the library archives. Commerce, TX Date? Black Screen Stevedores. Photograph. 12 Million Black Voices. (Richard Wright). New York: Basic, 2008. 20. Print. Slave Receipt. Houston, TX Commerce, TX Date? 1865 *Draw relevant information on international and national aspects of narrative. Nuance KA Blurb on compensatory history & its purpose 27 *Draw relevant information from sources like Wright, including relevant quotes to push the narrative forward. 29 replace with Stevedores in Houston 28 Absent absence & absent presence Available jobs from lords of the land & bosses – Richard Wright’s 12 MBV, Native Son, Black Boy? Quotes from bell hooks, Patricia Hill Collins, Zora Neal Hurston, Phyllis Wheatley How was slavery in E Texas? Quote from William Owens on paternalism of slavery, This Stubborn Soil, Juneteenth Including something about Juneteenth? (see also Juneteenth collection) Empire for Slavery: the Peculiar Institution in Texas, 1821-1865; Randolph B. Campbell, Louisiana State University Press, 1991. ISBN 0807117234 30 The Laws of Slavery in Texas: Historical Documents and Essays. William S. Pugley, Marilyn P. Duncan, Randolph B. Campbell. University of Texas Press, 2011. ISBN 0292728999 Blacks in East Texas History: Selections from the East Texas Historical Journal. Bruce A. Glasrud, Dr. Archie P.McDonald, eds. TAMU Press, 2008. ISBN 1603440410 Till Freedom Cried Out: Memories of Texas Slave Life. Julie P. Baker. TAMU Press, 1997. ISBN 0890967369 The Slave Narratives of Texas. Ron Tyler, ed. State House Press, 2006. ISBN 1933337036 The African American Experience in Texas: an Anthology. Bruce A. Glasrud, James M. Smallwood, eds. Texas Tech University Press, 2007. ISBN 0896726096 "Slavery is, as an example of what white America has done, a constant reminder of what white America might do.” --Derrick A. Bell Black Texans: a History of African Americans in Texas, 1528-1995. Alwyn Barr. University of Oklahoma Press, 1996. ISBN 080612878x Conrad’s black towns info 03_Laborers and Labor Houses Where did they settle? On land no one else wanted. (Bell 22) Faces at the Bottom of the Well. 31 Need Jennifer to source this picture because it’s not in 12MBV (positive side? About neylandville, Juneteenth, a positive side of “freedom” (see also WPA guide on “first and oldest all-negro community in Texas”), A Thirteen-year-old Sharecropper. “I found them in photos of cane press workers.” Cane Press Workers. “They were in records of cafeteria workers in the 1930s” African American Cafeteria Workers 1930s. Commerce, TX 1930 *Draw relevant information from sources like Wright, including relevant quotes to push the narrative forward. (perhaps emphasizing negative/downside, limits, in contrast to above) Sharecropping, economic stats, perhaps from Wright, link to Neylandville? For further reading, see The White Scourge: Mexicans, Blacks and Poor Whites in Texas Cotton Culture. Neil Foley. University of California Press, 1999. ISBN 0520207246 Texas, Cotton, and the New Deal. Keith J. Volanto. TAMU Press, 2004. ISBN 1585444022 General life of farmers Maybe emphasize more of above, perhaps the element of paternalism? *Draw relevant information from sources like Wright, including relevant quotes to push the narrative forward. – formations of NC & paternalism; court cases, Opal Pannell walkout (link to OH), James Baldwin “the black face is not qualified 5:25-5:30 pt1), Patricia Hill Collins – jobs on campus 17-118 12MBV paternalistic code, This Stubborn Soil 32 33 34 “By the late 19th century, former slaves and their children had begun moving into Commerce from area farms, settling into this historically segregated neighborhood on the other side of the tracks (literally) to take jobs on campus serving meals to students, cleaning offices and faculty homes, and maintaining the growing physical plant. Opal Pannell was one many denied access, walking to work from the Norris Community each day to feed students on a campus neither she nor her neighbors could attend until 1964.” (Carter and Conrad, “In Possession of Community,” forthcoming) 4 “In 1937, they were captured in photos of sewing room employees” Sewing Room Employees. Commerce, TX 1937 Also: Jobs on campus, in Norris, paternalistic code (pastor on “benevolent paternalism Use panel as lens for this More on panel, specifically, as it helps us understand local access to work (Pannell in high school working on campus from neylandville) 35 *Draw relevant information on international and national aspects of narrative. Forms of employment open to blacks & black women, especially – more on employment discrimination – Conrad CAPTION “Separate educational facilities are inherently unequal.” -- Judge Warren, 1954, on Brown vs. the Board of Education NARRATION VIDEO Fade to black IMAGE MAP DATE CONTEXT On May 17, 1954, the Supreme Court of the United States reversed its decision in 1896’s Plessy v. Ferguson when it ruled that state-sponsored racial segregation in educational facilities were unconstitutional. African Americans across the nation greeted the Brown decision with elation and immediately bestowed upon it the ability to alleviate all forms of racial discrimination, not merely education. However, the Brown decision addressed de jure racial segregation in public schools. It said nothing about the de facto segregation that plagued housing, employment, and socialization. Those battles may have drawn upon the example provided by Brown, but Brown itself did not address them. Unfortunately, racial segregation did not disappear May 18, 1954; in fact, some might argue that it has not disappeared. Where racial segregation has faded into memory, it took a long, often painful, struggle on the part of activists. The when, where, and how of desegregation plays a major role in the effects of desegregation that American continue to live with. FOOTNOTE Oliver Brown, et al. v. Board of Education of Topeka, et al. 36 MISC. 37 347 U.S. 486 Though the Brown decision enjoined schools to desegregate “with all deliberate speed,” districts across the South were able to postpone desegregating for years. Rural Commerce, Texas, desegregated its schools only in ????, ???? years after Brown. Even after black and white students attended schools together, racial discrimination in Commerce remained. Blacks living in the Norris community continued to endure substandard housing conditions and access to city services. Brown eliminated racial segregation in education, but did nothing to improve the lives of black Americans outside the schoolhouse. More about intro of de facto segregation in the South, and the differences between South & North http://www.naacpldf.org/case/brown-v-board-education For further reading, see Brown v. Board of Education: a Civil Rights Milestone and its Troubled Legacy. James T. Patterson. Oxford University Press, 2002. ISBN 0195156323 Mosley, in the archives (2012) June 1964. Commerce, TX "Complete Integration Ordered ET: To Be Effected Next Registration." The Commerce Journal [Commerce, TX] 11 June Commerce, TX 2011 1964 NPR + contemporary; footnote 81 from US v. Texas (reformat and include), domino effect, Wright 64-7, black schools Segregation was, of course, a deeply divisive issue in Commerce. However, the events that most characterize local struggles here and, indeed, throughout much of the rest of the southern states, were fought not in the streets among local publics but in mundane documents ranging from interoffice memoranda among campus administrators, letters exchanged between campus leaders and area, state, and federal officials, legal documents, and petitions (Shabazz; Sokel; Dittmer). A particularly useful example of this can be found in in the circulation of documents surrounding two local segregationists and bitter enemies: US Senator Sam Rayburn, this university’s most famous alumnus, and James G. Gee, ETSU president from 1947-1966. From 1913 until 1961, Sam Rayburn represented this rural district dominated by voters loyal to Jim Crow and remained himself equally loyal to his constituents and, especially, ETSU, the institution that had given this poor farmer without a high school diploma a chance at a college education. Despite his stance on the issue (which some argue had softened considerably after decades in Washington DC) and the likely threat to his voting base it posed, he was an even more loyal Democrat and, as Speaker of the House, helped sign into law the most significant civil rights legislation since Reconstruction: the Civil Rights Act of 1954. His public connections to Lyndon B. Johnson, combined with this piece of legislation, made him a bitter enemy to a number of powerful local leaders. (Carter, “A Clear Channel”) “ That summer then university president and outspoken segregationist James G. Gee called together all faculty and staff to announce ET’s immediate compliance with civil rights legislation mandating desegregation at the last two public colleges still upholding racial barriers.” (Carter and Conrad, forthcoming) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_Rights_Act_of_1964 Gee/Rayburn rivalry 38 Clipping in Gee Papers, along with countless other such headlines from across the nation. Clearly Gee 39 5 1964: 1. Jerrold Moore, --and/or His harshest local critic by far was President Gee. However, like Rayburn, Gee would find himself overseeing public transformations that effectively ended de jure segregation. Though a loyal segregationist, he did not challenge what he called the “inevitability of racial integration” (Gee). Instead he formed “a secret committee” whom he charged with studying desegregation elsewhere and offering recommendations. The primary and stated goal for our campus was what Gee and the committee called “a dignified integration,” arguing demonstrations against desegregation would threaten the local community’s sustainability far more then any new admission policy ever could (Carter and Conrad; Wilkinson; Shabazz). In June 1964, Gee followed the committee’s recommendations to the letter when he announced the lifting of “racial barriers” to admissions. By all accounts desegregation at ETSU occurred largely without incident. In this sense, perhaps it was, indeed, a “dignified integration,” a characterization that remains a significant point of pride for local citizens. (Carter, “A Clear Channel”) was following this issue very closely. Northeast Texas Cold War fears – from Sokol or Gilmore (Moore 179) James G. Gee at Field House. Commerce, TX Link Gee’s position to the Cold War bit from above, perhaps also foregrounding his links to folks like Shivers and Daniels Its advocates expected that the Brown decision would cut through the dark years of segregation with laser-like intensity. The resistance, though, was open and determined. At best, the Brown precedent did no more than cast a halflight on that resistance, enough to encourage its supporters but not bright enough to reveal just how long and difficult the road to equal educational opportunity would prove to be. St. Paul School Bus Neylandville, TX Velma Waters applied for enrollment four times before she was finally admitted. Velma Waters. I particularly remember his attitude toward integration of the college which he announced by saying there would never be any blacks at East Texas State Teachers’ College. James G. Gee, President, East Texas State University, 1947-1966 Velma Waters (Commerce, TX), Class of 1968 James G. Gee at Desk. Moore, Jerrold. Memories of Old ET. 1948 Neylandville, TX 1938 Our arguments throughout this remix are significantly informed by Derrick A. Bell and other criticalists of the movement his work helped establish (Critical Race Theory). As a tribute to Bell, our remix draws from several of his key texts, especially those articulating his notion of “interest convergence” as it helps shape our own local context and relevant responses. This particular quote is from his later work Silent Covenants (2004), published on the occasion of the 50th anniversary of the Brown decision. (SC) (Bell 19) Bell, Derrick A. Jr. Silent Covenants: Citizen’s Council & Southern Manifesto, so Rayburn & LBJ, busing for school 42 NOTE: consider Bell excerpt from lecture on same For further reading, see Brown v. Board of Education: a Civil Rights Milestone and its Troubled Legacy. James T. Patterson. Oxford University Press, 2002. ISBN 0195156323 Commerce, TX For further reading, see (Wilkison 2) Paragraph about struggles they faced on campus – pull Belford Page & Harry Turner snippets (Sunchai), and upload or locate so we can link to them – link to JN OH, Q from Turner on advancing ???? Wilkison, Debra. “Eyewitness to Social Change: The Desegregation of East Texas State College.” M.A. thesis, East Texas State University, 1990. Print. (Wilkison 2) Advancing Democracy: African Americans and the Struggle for Access and Equity in Higher Education in Texas. Amilcar Shabazz. University of North Carolina Press, 2006. ISBN 0807855057 – desegregation attempt at Texarkana As a small child, Velma Waters could walk across the campus of East Texas State Teachers’ College to bring her father his lunch where he was employed as a laborer on a WPA project, but she could hardly hope to grow up and study at this whites-only state-supported 41 See http://www.shannoncarter-blog.org/2011/05/03/in-the-archives-correspondence-between-gee-and-daniel/ 1948 1938 40 Velma Waters. Commerce, TX African American Air Force veteran James Meredith petitioned to enter the University of Mississippi in 1961 and met with opposition from university officials, the state college board, the governor, lieutenant governor, and other state officials. Though the university lost its legal battle to deny Meredith admission, federal marshals and attorneys from the U.S. Justice Department had to escort him to ensure his admittance. Unfortunately, Meredith’s admission sparked a riot that left two dead, hundreds injured, nearly 200 arrested, and required 16,000 federal troops to put down. President Gee would have witnessed the upset in Mississippi, perhaps further highlighting the need for a “dignified” integration. There would be no Mississippi riots or Arkansas attacks here. Wilkison, Debra. “Eyewitness to Social Change: The Desegregation of East Texas 43 Gee Segregation Letters refusing admittance to Negroes, 44 Gee Segregation Clippings on Brown v Board of Education 6 institution of higher learning in her hometown of Commerce, TX. “… we could only work for the university, but we could not go to school here.” More about Neylandville & Waters, focus on dignified integration as compared to upset experienced elsewhere Coming Together: A Conversation with Norris Community Members and Other Experts. Maydell Pannell (Commerce, TX) As Derrick Bell insists, “Whites may agree in the abstract that blacks are citizens and are entitled to constitutional protection against racial discrimination, but few are willing to recognize that racial segregation is more than a series of quant customs that can be remedied effectively without altering the status of whites.” Diversity Now Commerce, TX 2011 Cambridge, MA April 28, 1990 Getty Images “… racial segregation is more than a series of quant customs that can be remedied effectively without altering the status of whites.” At table w jack Greenberg place date http://legalhistoryblog.blog spot.com/2007/05/newarchive-derrick-bellpapers.html *Draw relevant information on international and national aspects of narrative. – OP OH ???? iles to nearest black college, Gee letters in response to African student applications, Lulu B White In Struggle Against Jim Crow born in Elmo (Kaufman), TX, six miles from Terrell, and had to go to PV for college, became leader of Houston NAACP http://books.google.com/books?id=ohivicYNUs8C&printsec=frontcover#v=onepage&q&f=false -Patterson re-segregation along socioeconomic lines, negative impact still hits black Americans because of income and earnings power, plight of black ghettoes. -desegregation only benefitted middle class -Brandt -Lopez case pushes theme of access - new underclass is poor ppl -Neylandville *Include relevant information about the work Bell was involved in, especially as it informs our arguments and lived experiences here. Who is Bell, Crenshaw tribute -CRT can’t eradicate w/o changing societal norms -paternalistic code -intro to Bell & CRT, link to CLJ Paternalistic code – include info about meeting – Pull from Jack Greenberg autobiography State College.” M.A. thesis, East Texas State University, 1990. Print. 45 Gee Segregation Letters on the issue of desegregatio n (Bell 19) 46 Bell, Derrick A. Jr. “Interest Convergence.” Harvard Law Review, 1980. (Bell 19) 47 Bell, Derrick A. Jr. “Interest Convergence.” Harvard Law Review, 1980. --Derrick A. Bell What About Prejudice? *Include regarding interest convergence -material determinism, magic pill -recognitions of limits of law and multiculturalism -will continue until its no longer in their interests not to -Lamos interests 2011 Velma Waters was the first African American to enroll in classes and attend East Texas State University. Waters Commerce, TX Family and neighbors like Maydell Pannell and her children would soon follow. “Last state college drops racial barriers” Commerce, TX Dallas Morning News 6 June 1964. Print. *SC for additional details, including info regarding “stolen typewriter” from CCC piece (2012) 1964 SC additional, especially regarding the Norris Community and Norris Community Club (see Community Literacy Journal, 2012) Evans – AA came, but then left, so efforts died – Talbot article, Brewer article Increase numbers of blacks on campus – Amilcar Shabazz has some information Wilkison, Debra. “Eyewitness to Social Change: The Desegregation of East Texas State College.” M.A. thesis, East Texas State University, 1990. Print. Wilkison, Debra. “Eyewitness to Social Change: The Desegregation of East Texas 48 What is prejudice? And why does it exist? What do you think? 49 50 7 Maydell Pannell would later earn her (BA and MA I think) from ET, as would her children. Find Pannell in Alumni Records from Jane Martyn “Here, as in the abolition of slavery, there were whites for whom recognition of the racial equality principle was sufficient motivation. But, as with abolition, the number who would act on morality alone was insufficient to bring about the desired racial reform.” John Carlos, Harlem, New York, attended East Texas State University, 1966-67 In the case of Brown vs. the Board of Education, Derrick Bell insists, “… as in the abolition of slavery, there were whites for whom recognition of the racial equality principle was sufficient motivation. But, as with abolition, the number who would act on morality alone was insufficient to bring about the desired racial reform. Derrick bell walking East Texas State University recruited John Carlos from Harlem in 1966, just two years after this rural teachers college began the process of desegregation and one year before Dr. Carlos would join Tommie Smith on the medal stand at the 1968 Olympics, raise a gloved fist in black unity and solidarity, and then to history. He didn’t expect to find in Texas the racial issues he was seeing elsewhere across the south. John Carlos as a student (source info coming soon) John Carlos's Raised Fist. place date *Draw connections between what happened nationally and local experiences information about the present presence of blacks at ETSU, and the material changes required by the admittance of blacks Jefferson/Douglas interest convergence What’s July 4th to Negro, Douglass Juneteenth Checkerboard society Commerce, TX Mexico City, Mexico Image of dog attacking child in Alabama. Elizabeth Eckford and Hazel Bryan http://www.army.mil/article/ 2004/ Birmingham, Alabama 196667 State College.” M.A. thesis, East Texas State University, 1990. Print. (Bell 518) 51 Brown v. Board of Education and the Interest Convergence Dilemma. (Carter 16) 1968 In 1968, at the Mexico City Olympics, sprinters John Carlos and Tommie Smith rhetoricized race, calling global attention to the persistence of racism by taking full advantage of the means of persuasion available to them as black athletes representing the nation to the world (see Figure 2). That single iconic image of two African Americans, black-gloved fists raised and heads bowed as the national anthem played and millions booed, remains indelibly etched in our collective memory. Until recently, however, the message they intended, like the meaning behind much of the rhetoric of black power (see Stewart, Burgess, Scott and Brockriede), was rewritten and then altogether silenced by the racist politics the movement opposed. (Carter, “A Clear Channel”) 1963 *NOTE: Details concerning events in Alabama and Little Rock, perhaps just a good link to reputable description will do. (Carter 16) http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/northamerica/8813134/Elizabeth-Eckford-and-Hazel-Bryan-the-story-behind-thephotograph-that-shamed-America.html http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Little_Rock_Desegregation_1957.jpg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Rock_Nine http://www.npr.org/books/titles/140953114/elizabeth-and-hazel-two-women-of-little-rock http://www.vanityfair.com/politics/features/2007/09/littlerock200709 http://www.army.mil/article/2004/ Carter, Shannon. “Writing Democracy in Rural Texas 52 Carter, Shannon. “Writing Democracy in Rural Texas 53 Of his time spent at this Dallas area school, he’d later tell reporters: Like most Harlem kids, I thought any place away from the ghetto would have to be beautiful. . . Texas was in the South but I was sure it was nothing like Mississippi or Alabama” (New York Magazine, 1968). It was Alabama, of course, not Texas, making headlines in a fight for social justice-where Rosa Parks refused to give up her seat, where Dr. Martin Luther King would write his Letter from Birmingham Jail in 1963, insisting that “injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere”The Freedom Riders stopped short of Texas, reaching only as far West as Louisiana. A second ride began in California and ended in Houston, but the disconnect between the image of civil rights struggles of the Deep South and everywhere else was clear. Despite the invisibility of Texas in our collective memories of the civil rights movement, this state played a surprisingly significant role. Before James Farmer helped launch what became Freedom Riders, he was in Texas--the son of a university professor in a town far more remote than Commerce, where he studied at Wiley College with the radical poet, activist, and formidable debate coach Melvin Tolson (played by Denzel Washington in the 2007 film The Great Debaters). It was in Texas that one of the earliest challenges to segregation was launched—Sweat vs. Painter in 1947, leading to the desegregation of the University of Texas law school. It was, of course, a Texan who signed into law the crucial Civil Rights Act of 1964—Lyndon B. Johnson, the same Texan who envisioned the Great Society. Before that, yet another Texan—then Speaker of the House Sam Rayburn, helped pass the Civil Rights Act 1957, the most significant civil rights legislation since 8 Reconstruction. Though an outspoken segregationist serving a conservative district in Texas with similar views, Rayburn was an even more loyal democrat who graduated decades earlier from the same rural university Dr. Carlos would later attend. Indeed, the rhetorical events that capture our imaginations when we consider the strength and impact of the civil rights movement are not these protracted struggles. Rhetorical events like these unfold through a series of interrelated “mundane texts,” which, as Rivers and Weber point likewise shape far more dramatic and powerful events like those surrounding the Freedom Riders or Rosa Parks silent protest. Rivers and Weber suggest “the scope of public rhetoric” should include the “mundane”–the “multiple, mundane documents, interpersonal networks, historical influences, and rhetorical moves and countermoves” that likewise shape any rhetorical event. They look at the texts surrounding the Montgomery Bus Boycott. The national “text” (Rosa Parks refusing to give up her seat on the bus) was surrounded and enabled by a great variety of far more mundane texts, which deserve our attention as well. I suggest similar insight may be drawn from an investigation of the network of mundane texts leading up to the Silent Protest at the 1968 Olympics, drawing attention to the local articulation of this rhetorical event. John Carlos Book Signing, Paris Incubator. 2011. Belford Page (Dallas, Texas) attended East Texas State University 1968-71 Paris, TX Belford Page as a student (source info coming soon) Belford Page, 2012 Black History Month Speaker Series 2011 Commerce, TX 1968? Commerce, TX Date? Commerce, TX 2012 No doubt Dr. Carlos was right. Texas was not Mississippi or Alabama. Neither was Commerce Birmingham or Memphis or Selma. Yet racism is here, present and obvious and altogether complicated. No less firmly entrenched than anywhere else. Oral history with John Carlos available at <http://dmc.tamu-commerce.edu/cdm/> Recorded February 2012, with interviewer Shannon Carter John Carlos Oral History ET recruited John Carlos from Harlem in 1966, just two years before this global demonstration of what Edward P.J. Corbett would call “The Rhetoric of the Closed Fist.”9 In Harlem, Dr. Carlos had walked with Malcolm X—literally, catching as many of Malcolm X’s frequent presentations at the mosque on 116th street as he could, then following him around the neighborhood “like a scampering puppy dog” (Carlos and Zirin 26), peppering him with questions along the way. As part of the counterpublic called up in the discourse surrounding collective resistance “by any means necessary” (Malcolm X), Carlos was highly attuned to racism’s complexity and ubiquity. He knew racism’s key challenges were just as present in the North as they were everywhere else. Yet he had never before experienced the covert forms of racism segregation presented--not personally, at least. Along with his young wife and their two-year old daughter, “We agreed to make a home for ourselves in Commerce,” Dr. Carlos recalls decades later. “But every last shred of dignity that we took with us to Texas was challenged” (Carlos and Zirin 64). (Carter, “A Clear Channel”) Oral history with Belford Page available at <http://dmc.tamu-commerce.edu/cdm/> 54 55 Recorded February 2012, with interviewer Shannon Carter Urban-rural tensions, Q from Peace, Carlos, move from black neighborhoods in DFW to rural locations Details about ubiquity of similar incidents across the nation. Commerce is hardly unique. – I thought we were going to get the Loved them some Belford Page snippet. Are we dismissing that in favor of what’s here? 56 Articles from 1968-1971 in East Texan/Locust about football team? Dallas at that time versus Northeast Texas? Elizabeth Jacoway, Turn Away Thy Son, they finally got in, and it was horrible because no one inside school worked to protect them Belford Page, 2012 Black History Month Speaker Series. Belford Page as a student (source info coming soon) Commerce, TX Date? Belford Page, 2012 Black History Month Speaker Series. http://remixingruraltexas.pb works.com/f/James+Belfor d+Page032jpg.jpg Commerce, TX 2012 Point about how Page moved from majority-minority situation in Dallas to a minority-minority situation in Commerce. For first time in his life, he was outnumbered by whites, and surrounded by whites unwelcoming of his presences. *Additional details about the local, drawing in activist efforts on campus and in the community to overlap with Page’s time on campus (see especially the Afro American Student Association and the Norris Community Club). Draw extensively from Carter’s CLJ piece on activism (2012) AASET/NCC This is the rocks story Carter, Shannon. “Writing Democracy in Rural Texas 57 58 Turn Away Thy Son about how the students were allowed in, and abandoned to their fate with no protection and no redress for grievances Or: consider something on Peace on perception of Norris (not thinking there was something inequitable about local conditions, rather “I just thought they were country” (but maybe this goes better with NCC vid, actually)—move to the master 9 Decades later, I find myself. I know the struggles aren’t over. I know there struggles are my struggles; my struggles are theirs. Velma Waters (Commerce, TX), Class of 1968 Jamar Mosley (recorded 2012) I search the archives, and I wonder. Commerce, TX Velma Waters Commerce, TX 2011 themes *Draw connections across national and international timelines, as well as Jamar’s original insights 59 1968 JC renounced by fellow athletes, Delmar Brown apology, Baldwin, Detroit violence, Rodney King beating, London riots, Rivers of Blood, desegregation of the North (de jure turns to de facto, and remains), AASET Stats on current population of African Americans enrolled in the school, showing steady progression from the 1960s – Jane Martyn for info *Draw connections across national and international timelines, as well as Jamar’s original insights 60 What did this mean for me? For my people? For those missing African American faces? For those there? The NAACP, in its campaign in favor of Brown, defined segregation as inherently evil, regardless of its purpose. This would call into question the legitimacy of black institutions created or made essential by the reality of racial segregation. In time, the effect of the NAACP’s ideological framework would put Historically Black Colleges and Universities on the defensive because they were relegated to the status of constitutionally suspect institutions that had to justify their very existence. continued struggles, HBCU justification & nationalism – Is Separate Unequal, impact of a person like Meredith, Breaking the Huddle http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CnOpZvEulvY&feature=related ; http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9N7grNxOaSU&feature=related ; using sports to desegregate, effects of desegregation on teams, Rodriguez vs SA ISD and focus on property taxes, JC & Mex Charles Garvin (Greenville, TX), Class of 1966 Dr. Ivory Moore (Oklahoma), Dean of Minority Affairs Charles Garvin Commerce, TX 1966 Charles Garvin was ETSU’s first African American graduate student. 61 Dr. Ivory Moore Commerce, TX Date? Glenda McKissic (Mineola, Texas) Homecoming Queen 1969 Dr. David Talbot (Georgetown, Guyana), Professor of Counseling Glenda McKissic Commerce, TX 1969 Ivory Moore was ETSU’s first African American administrator. He became Dean of Minority Affairs, brought in millions of dollars of grants to establish a range of campus and community programs for local poor and minority citizens. He was also the first African American citizen to be elected to the City Council, a position he held for 18 years before becoming Commerce’s first African American mayor. Moore is the subject of our first remix “A Clear Channel,” also available at this site. In 1969, Glenda McKissic became ETSU’s first African American Homecoming Queen (see the Commerce Journal) 62 http://newspaperarchive.com/the-commerce-journal/1969-11-13/ Dr. David Talbot (source info coming soon) dates Dr. David Talbot was ETSU’s first African American professor (Counseling). 63 See also North Texas eNews. J. Mason Brewer (Texas), Professor of English CAPTION It meant change. Commerce, TX NARRATION It meant change. VIDEO J. Mason Brewer (source info coming soon) Commerce, TX Dates ? IMAGE Buildings on campus over a few different decades showing change over time MAP Commerce, TX DATE Date? *Additional details on Talbot here, especially with respect to his impact on local scene and through nationally-recognized programs like the Checkerboard Society and other integrated housing initiatives. Much beloved, outspoken - link to Henry Louis Gates incident & lawnmower incident -ET Special article http://remixingruraltexas.pbworks.com/w/file/fetch/50813245/KIC%20Document%200007.pdf http://remixingruraltexas.pbworks.com/w/file/51031961/ETSpecialMay84p19.pdf http://www.ntxe-news.com/cgi-bin/artman/exec/view.cgi?archive=3&num=4136&printer=1 J. Mason Brewer was ETSU’s first African American Professor in English Department and to teach courses in “Negro Folklore.” Professor Brewer was also the first African American president of the Texas Folklore Association. Evidence of his extensive contributions in both poetry and folklore can be found in his many publications, including the first collection of poetry by African Americans in Texas, the most comprehensive study of African Americans in the Texas legislature, and several collections of African American folklore in Texas. In this time, many compared Brewer to Zora Neal Hurston, especially their work recovering African American folklore (Hurston in Florida, Brewer in Texas) and extensive use of dialect (Hurston in prose, Brewer in poetry). --See also, Texas State Historical Association http://remixingruraltexas.pbworks.com/w/file/51031958/ETSpecialDec69p4.pdf CONTEXT Jamar Mosley used “All Black Everything” in his original remix and we felt it was perfect for this extension of his original story. For details about his original choices for the remix he produced, see his oral history interview in the Northeast Texas Digital Collections. 64 FOOTNOTE MISC. 65 10 --------------We claim “Fair Use” for this song (“All Black Everything”), utilizing it not only as tribute to Jamar’s original remix and because of its relevance to the current project but in order to demonstrate principles of “Fair Use” as it applies to music held by a major record label. Journey Into Blackness. Commerce, TX 1976 Field House. 1951. Commerce, TX 1955? Pottery Demonstration. Commerce, TX 1976 Whitley Hall. Students. Photograph. Black Awareness Week. Commerce, TX Commerce, TX 1969 1976 For further reading on Fair use, see see especially Bound By Law (Duke Law, Center for the Study of the Public Domain) and Lessig’s Free Culture (2004) and Remix (2009) -----------------------For further reading, see Library. 1930. It meant “change.” It is really sad to me that these people are still fighting a battle that was over years ago. I hope that one day they will get enough White money from the White taxpayers to pay for the education they will receive from White institutions with White professors so they can learn just exactly what it is they are fighting against. – Elvin Helmsley, Seagoville Senior 1930 Campus Guest Gloria Steinem_6. Commerce, TX 1972 Campus Guest Gloria Steinem_1. Commerce, TX 1972 Letter to the Editor. East Texan. November 6, 1970. *Additional, details about change over time, including black awareness week and associated efforts in the community (SC) - local & national explosion of activism -problem seemingly solved, so activists left and headed on to the next cause, but problems still existed -backsliding *Can we get some blurb about the history of Black Heritage Week or related events on campus, including details concerning controversy on Dick Gregory, who we invited yet soon disinvited. Much about this in the East Texan and the Locust. 66 For further reading, see Commerce, TX I meant “change.” The Struggle for Black Equality. Harvard Sitkoff. Hill and Wang, 2008. ISBN 0809089246 Links to Wikipedia on Dick Gregory, complete citation for Gregory’s autobiography (1964) and related local and national headlines, etc) *Details on Steinem’s visit to ET and her work more generally 67 *Details on Steinem’s visit to ET and her work more generally feminist movement *Unfortunately, the heavy upsurge in activism was tempered by ____ & ____. Tie to CRT and national events Reaction and rejection of African Americans on campus through Letters to the Editor, Cross Burning, introduce theme *Draw forward connections with more contemporary challenges and international perspective. 68 69 white backlash & being turned off -forum response from ET JC to Jesse Owens Contextualize this in terms of jobs & freedom Hillbilly v Black Panther 99% movement join forces CLJ By the time African American students like Carlos and Evans enrolled, local whites largely accepted racial integration’s inevitability. Increasingly, however, the material changes that accompany that process--especially in this era of student revolt and black power/women’s rights rhetoric—began to be characterized by many locals as “the racial problem.” “In regard to the increasingly troublesome ‘racial problem’ in Commerce,” says a local sophomore in a 1970 letter appearing in the campus paper, “. . . things may be getting worse” (Helmslwy). For him and many other whites, evidence of this was the increasingly common presence of “incidents” like the one he describes in his letter. Not only had an African American box office worker recently challenged a white patron who had treated her unfairly, but the local press had printed letters from others praising black resistance. He appears as outraged as he was eloquent: It is really sad to me that these people are still fighting a battle that was over years ago. I hope that one day they will get enough White money from the White taxpayers to pay for the education they will receive from White institutions with White professors so they can learn just exactly what it is they are fighting against. (Helmsley) 11 The fight “over long ago” included abolition of both slavery and segregation, of course. The fight that remains, according to critical race studies, is the systemic racism that persists across an America that allowed the sale of humans and laws built on a logic of white supremacy. In our color-blind society, race had been rendered invisible while racism’s effects remain firmly entrenched in everyday life. While racism as a national problem, even at the height of the civil rights movement, may appear abstract, distant, symbolic, the local, the everyday, is rarely abstract. When that local is sparsely populated (rural), when resources are scarce, as is the case here, major changes at local levels are hard to enact. In fact, “… racial segregation is more than a series of quant customs that can be remedied effectively without altering the status of whites” (Bell 19b). Thus, perhaps, we can understand the town’s slow uptake on social justice issues like these, as I will explain. In similar ways, as Catherine Prendergast has argued, race has become what she calls “an absent presence” in our discipline—the ever present element we learn to look past or look around, forgetting the important ways race remains in our classrooms and our scholarship just as it remains a defining element in the rest of our everyday lives. (Carter, “A Clear Channel”) It meant opportunity. It meant opportunity. It meant “opportunity.” Civil Rights March on Washington, D.C. Washington, DC March on Washington Washington, DC 1963 Paris, TX 2009 White Supremacists. Photograph. KKK vs. New Black Panthers in Paris, Texas. 1963 “But one hundred years later, the Negro still is not free. One hundred years later, the life of the Negro is still sadly crippled by the manacles of segregation and the chains of discrimination. One hundred years later, the Negro lives on a lonely island of poverty in the midst of a vast ocean of material prosperity. One hundred years later, the Negro is still languished in the corners of American society and finds himself an exile in his own land. And so we've come here today to dramatize a shameful condition.” 70 I Have A Dream, Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., delivered August 28, 1963, at the Lincoln Memorial, Washington, D.C. Though the heady atmosphere surrounding the Civil Rights Movement seemingly heralded great change in American race relations, nearly fifty years after Dr. King, racial tensions remain problematic. In addition to continued discrimination against African Americans, Latinos, gays, and Muslims are experiencing oppression. Symbols, opportunity to exploit hatred, creating a protest for $$$$, staged demonstrations, the right to protest, link to controversy, Quannell X, short story about Patriots & Black Panthers, Patriot Act http://www.click2houston.com/news/Quanell-X-reacts-to-verdict/-/1735978/13416978/-/2ac8x3/-/index.html http://www.khou.com/home/Chad-Holley-bonds-out-after-latest-arrest-with-Quanell-X-by-his-side--159095845.html http://www.cnn.com/2011/CRIME/03/14/texas.alleged.rape/index.html?iref=obnetwork It meant “opportunity.” It meant opportunity. Black America Endures Modern Day Lynchings. Carlos & Zirin Jasper, TX date See CBS News, July 2009 and “Racial Unrest in Paris, Texas” (Southern Shift), 2009 “In 1998 in Jasper, Texas, James Byrd, Jr., a black man, was chained to a pick-up truck and dragged to his death by three white men. The town was forever altered, and the nation woke up to the horror of a modern-day lynching” (see PBS’s Two Towns of Jasper). Washington, DC 2011 See also the Humanities Texas exhibit, “Jasper, Texas: The Healing of a Community in Crisis” ------*Additional details concerning book launch of John Carlos’s memoir, to coincide with the Troy Davis memorials. As Zirin (wearing an “I am Troy Davis” t-shirt like many in the audience) asks why that Silent Protest still matters, we can certainly understand why. Carter was in the audience that day, paying tribute to this former student and the campus he features in the memoirs chapter “Trouble in Texas”). Later that night she would nominate Carlos for an honorary doctorate from this very university. In May 2012, he will receive this honor with great support and celebration from the vast majority of the campus and community. 71 Record numbers of black prison population, oow births, divorces, debt, etc, de facto segregation Hate crime legislation, non hate crime legislation, Sweet Tea, LGBT/Black controversy For further reading, see Race, Reform, and Rebellion: the Second Reconstruction and Beyond in Black America, 1945-2006. Manning Marable. University Press of Mississippi, 2007. ISBN 1578061547 12 And We are Not Saved: the Elusive Quest for Racial Justice. Derrick A. Bell, Jr. Basic Books, 1989. ISBN 046500329x It meant . . . everything. Transcript on this issue *Draw forward connections with more contemporary challenges and international perspective. Wrap up (SC) 72 With great appreciation for our university’s current and former students, faculty, and administrators. *Obituary (NYT, Washington Post), and link to Derrick Bell video tribute from the Geneva Crenshaw Society 73 74 Credits Please see “About” link at RRT homepage for profiles on each of these individuals. 75 Credits Please see “About” link at RRT homepage for profiles on each of these individuals. 76 End slide Funded in part by a grant from the National Endowment for the Humanities Office of Digital Humanities and extensive support from Texas A&M-Commerce. 77 “It meant . . . everything.” Dedicated to Derrick A. Bell, (November 6, 1930 – October 5, 2011) Any views, findings,conclusions, or recommendations expressed in this program do not necessarily reflect those of the National Endowment for the Humanities or Texas A&M-Commerce. 13