South Ayrshire Local Development Plan (Retail and Town Centres): Development Plan Scheme
South Ayrshire Local Development Plan (Retail and Town Centres) Participation Statement
The purpose of this subject-specific LDP is to provide an early review of the policy framework
relating to town centres and retailing, as contained within the adopted LDP (2014). This subject LDP
is being produced in light of the persistent pressure on out-of-centre retailing policies (which limit
the extent and nature of goods that can be retailed outwith town centres) that has arisen through
planning applications, and consents, for out-of-centre retail proposals – particularly at the Heathfield
retail park, as an identified commercial centre; and the South East Ayr strategic urban expansion.
There is a wider benefit in commencing this early review of retailing and town centre policies. While
the examination of the adopted LDP (2014) concluded that all retailing and town centre policies
were sufficient for inclusion in the adopted Plan – even in light of representations challenging all
elements of those policies; the Council recognises that the defence of some policy elements was
based on the historic success of retail policies in South Ayrshire – rather than current evidence
underlining that they will continue to be successful. As such, recognising retailing pressure, and the
dynamic, fast-changing nature of the retail industry, a comprehensive update of the evidence base
on retailing will ensure that future LDP policies are based on the best available evidence.
It is intended to commence this subject review, early, with a view to adopting this subject LDP within
12-18 months. It is intended to progress to proposed plan stage in 2015. A full LDP review will
commence later in 2015, and will, given the scope of the full review, inevitably be a longer process
than the subject LDP on retailing. It is intended that the adopted LDP on retailing will be able to
merge into the full LDP review process, providing an up-to-date policy framework on retailing, when
the full LDP review reaches proposed plan stage.
The following provides detailed guidance on each stage of the Local Development Plan (LDP)
process, including guidance on when and how strategic environmental assessment (SEA) will fit into
the process; and how we will consult and engage with key stakeholders at each stage.
Summary of LDP and SEA stages:
1. Publish the Development Plan Scheme (DPS)
The Council requires to publish a DPS at the outset of the process of preparing a development plan;
and update it at least annually. This is the beginning of the LDP process and it is important that
people are aware of their opportunities to engage with the process to shape its outcomes.
The DPS provides a clear commentary of what will be involved at each stage in the process of
preparing a new LDP and the opportunities for engagement and consultation – known as the
“Participation Statement”. The DPS also includes a timetable for the progress of the Plan, as well as
intended consultation dates for key consultation events.
The DPS will be available on the Council’s website, in local libraries and to view at certain Council
offices. We will publish a notice in a local newspaper to highlight that the document is available to
ensure that as many people as possible have an opportunity to view it.
The methods that we will be using to bring the DPS to the attention of a wide range of interest
groups include:
•
•
•
•
Publishing a notice/article in a local newspaper stating that we are undertaking a review
of the adopted LDP (2014), with a focus on town centres and retailing, and that the DPS
is the first stage in the process. This will also provide information on where you can view
a copy of the DPS;
Making the DPS available on the Council’s website;
Making copies available to view in local libraries and Council offices; and,
Making all interested groups aware of the subject LDP – as part of this, all parties that
made representations to retail and town centre policies through the preparation of the
adopted LDP (2014) will be notified of the production of this LDP.
2. Publish the main issues report (MIR) and environmental report
The MIR is a significant stage in the process and will involve us setting out general proposals for
town centre and out-of-centre retailing. The MIR will set out preferred and alternative options. The
MIR will generally focus on any significant changes in direction in terms of policy, any new issues
which have arisen and require to be considered within the plan. This is also the principal stage for
anyone who is interested to engage early in the plan process, and we will use a wide variety of
methods to involve the public in shaping the plan. In order to identify key issues relating to how we
protect and promote town centre, as well encourage investment in South Ayrshire, through retailing
that doesn’t harm town centres, we will perform a full review of the evidence base on retailing prior
to the publication of the MIR. This will be published in a Monitoring Report to accompany the MIR.
SEA process
We will prepare and submit a draft environmental report to accompany the MIR. The report will
assess the environmental impact of the issues being considered at this stage. Given that there will be
a number of alternatives put forward at this stage we will also be assessing their environmental
impact.
The methods to be used for engagement at this stage will include:
•
•
•
•
•
•
Holding facilitated consultation events in relation to retail and town centres issues which
are raised within the MIR. Any relevant issues raised at these sessions will be given
consideration in progressing the plan;
Use online consultation for focused consultation on retail and town centre policy
options, based on the particular interests of Forum members;
Publish the MIR, monitoring report and environmental reports available on the Council’s
website;
Publish a notice/article in a local newspaper stating that the documents are available to
view at certain locations and that comments on their content are welcomed and
encouraged;
Making documents available to view at Council offices and public libraries;
Meeting with community groups and other interested parties where appropriate – this
will include all parties that made representations relating to retail and town centre
•
issues in the adopted LDP (2014), and consultation groups that have participated in the
Ayr Renaissance project, to date (including shop owners); and
Consulting/engaging the following key agencies:
o Transport authorities (including Transport Scotland, Network Rail, Strathclyde
Partnership for Transport, Stagecoach);
o Neighbouring Councils (Dumfries and Galloway, East Ayrshire and North
Ayrshire);
o Scottish Enterprise;
o Scottish Natural Heritage;
o Scottish Environmental Protection Agency (SEPA);
o Historic Scotland;
o Scottish Water; and
o the Scottish Government.
3. Publication of proposed plan, proposed action programme and revised environmental report, if
necessary
The proposed LDP will be formulated through considering the responses to the MIR. It is therefore
anticipated that there will be some consensus on a number of issues by this stage.
The Proposed Plan will a material consideration in the determination of planning applications
following its publication, though is unlikely to outweigh the adopted development plan prior to any
consultation on the Proposed Plan. The Proposed Plan will include a ‘proposals map’ specifically
relating to town centres and relevant out-of-centre retailing locations.
The proposed plan will be made available to view at a number of locations including on the Council’s
website. A consultation period of 6 weeks will be allowed for anyone wishing to submit comments
on the content of the proposed plan.
We would hope that as many people as possible take the opportunity to have an input into the plan
and its content. To ensure that this is possible a wide range of opportunities for people to get
involved in the process will be made available.
We will also publish our proposed action programme at this stage. This will set out how we intend to
implement the LDP.
SEA process
Following the publication of the ER at the previous stage, the report may require to be amended
from any comments received. This stage of the process will involve making any amendments
considered necessary or to assess the impact of any new issues which have emerged.
Consultation arrangements at this stage will include:
•
•
Publishing the plan on the Council’s website;
Publishing a notice/article in a local newspaper stating that the document is available to
view at certain locations and that comments on its content are welcomed and
encouraged;
•
•
•
•
•
Making the plan available to view at Council offices and public libraries;
Sending a copy of the plan to each of the key agencies and having follow up discussions
where required;
Sending letters/e-mails out to all who responded or made representations following the
publication of the MIR and informing them of where the plan is available for inspection;
Hold information days with exhibition boards, in key retailing locations affected by the
proposed LDP; and,
Sending out neighbour notifications to those affected by site-specific proposals.
4. Modification of the proposed LDP, action programme and preparation of the Report of
Conformity with Participation Statement
This stage will consider the representations submitted as part of the consultation process. The Plan
can be modified at this stage, in light of representations; however, Scottish Government does not
expect modifications to proposed plans to be undertaken as a routine part of the process; more,
modifications at this stage should be rare, and only where there is an overwhelming reason for the
modification.
All unresolved representations will form part of the package of documentation submitted to the
Scottish Government for the examination of the Plan. We will summarise and respond to each
representation that objects to part of the Plan.
Should we decide to make alterations at this stage we will seek to involve you in the process by:
•
•
•
Notifying all previous respondents that alterations to the proposed plan have been
made and where you will be able to view a copy of the alterations;
Publish the alterations on the Council’s website; and
Make the alterations available to view at Council offices and within public libraries.
5. Examination of proposed plan
Prior to the commencement of the LDP examination, the appointed person (the reporter(s)) will
firstly assess the Council’s consultation activities with regard to consultation and the involvement of
the public in respect of the preparation of the LDP. This Participation Statement will be used as a
basis for undertaking this assessment.
The LDP examination will consist of an independent reporter(s) being appointed by the Scottish
Government to scrutinise the LDP, in light of representation received and in respect of the
consultation on the LDP. The reporter(s) will conclude the examination by publishing an examination
report, which will set out recommendations on any modifications to be made to the Plan.
The examination will be conducted mainly on the basis of the examination documentation
submitted to the reporter(s) by the Council. The reporter(s) can seek additional information from
any party, at their discretion and will generally conclude the examination of issues through written
documentation, but can conduct a hearing session into any issue, and invite those parties that made
representations, as appropriate. The examination can include a public inquiry session, however, this
is rare.
The Scottish Government conduct the examination, so will notify all representees, as and when they
are required to further participate in the process. The Scottish Government also notifies all
representees of the publication of the examination report, to clarify how their representation has
been concluded.
To ensure that interested parties are aware of the impending examination we will:
•
•
Advertise that the Plan has been submitted for examination within a local newspaper,
within public libraries and on the Council’s website; and
Notify all of those who submitted representations that the Plan has been submitted for
examination.
6. Consider reporter’s conclusions/recommendations and make modifications if required
In general, where reporter(s) recommend a modification to the LDP, that recommendation is
binding, and the Council must modify the Plan accordingly, unless there are specified exceptional
circumstances. These are set out in Scottish Government Circular 6/2013.
Where modifications require to be made, the Council will also update the SEA, as appropriate.
7. Adoption of the LDP, action programme and SEA post adoption statement
Following any modifications as a result of the examination of the plan we will publicise our intention
to adopt the LDP and its associated documents. Following the publication of this notice we must
allow for a 28-day period before the plan can be formally adopted. During this period the Scottish
Ministers have an opportunity to consider the proposed final content of the plan and to raise any
issues of concern.
SEA process
Once the adoption process has been completed we are required to undertake what is known as a
‘post adoption statement’. This sets out how we have considered the issues raised within the
environmental report and how we will monitor the effects of the LDP on the environment. The
statement will be made available for all interested parties to view, including the key consultation
authorities.
In summary this stage will involve:
•
•
•
Placing a copy of the plan within each of the public libraries within South Ayrshire;
Making an electronic version of the plan available on the Council’s website; and
Publishing a notice/article in a local newspaper stating that the plan has been adopted
and where it can be viewed.
8. Implementation, monitoring and reviewing the LDP
Prior to reaching this stage the LDP has gone through a number of processes to ensure that the final
plan is reflective of the majority of the community and to ensure that its potential impacts upon the
environment have been minimised. It is therefore important for us to monitor how successful these
processes have been.
We will monitor the effects of the LDP in terms of assessing whether the policies are delivering their
intended outcomes and whether the predicted impacts upon the environment were correct. This will
help to inform and refine the process in the future.
The next stage in the process will be a review of the LDP and to begin work towards the production
of a new plan. The Scottish Government requires that LDPs are updated every five years to ensure
that they are up-to-date, reflective of local circumstances and to ensure that there is a maintained
level of certainty in the planning process.
Project Management
Local Development Plan Project Board
The Local Development Plan Project Board was set up to oversee the project-management of the
South Ayrshire LDP, and to allow elected members to guide key issues, including policies and land
allocations. The Panel is an elected members/officer working group, without decision-making
powers. It comprises representation from 8 Councillors with roles relative to planning (such as
relevant portfolio holders and chairs or vice chairs of other Committees (panels) of the Council.
The Board will be used regularly throughout the preparation of the new retail and town centre LDP
in order to guide the process, consider various options, oversee the project management of the
process and to ensure that the interests of the wider community are represented. The papers put
forward at each of the panel meetings will be made available on the Council’s website.
Board Composition
The Board is comprised of the following Council positions:







Portfolio holder for Economic Development, Tourism and Leisure (Chair);
Portfolio holder for Sustainability and the Environment;
Portfolio holder for Housing and Customer First;
Portfolio holder for Social Services
Chair and vice chair of Regulatory Panel;
Chair of Service and Performance Panel; and,
Chair of Partnerships Panel
TOWN CENTRES AND RETAILING LOCAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN
Environmental Assessment (SEA & HRA)


Collate baseline environmental information
Main Issues
Report (MIR)





Publish Development Plan Scheme including Participation
Statement
Engage with key agencies
Gather evidence base and Prepare Monitoring Statement
Prepare Main Issues Report
Publish Main Issues Report and Monitoring Statement
Consult





Prepare Scoping Report and Submit to SEA Gateway
Consider comments from Consultation Authorities and refine methodology
Environmentally appraise Main Issues Report.
Publish Environmental Report and submit via SEA Gateway.
Consult on Environmental Report (ER)
Proposed
Plan


Consider representations
Prepare Proposed Plan and Action Programme



Consider responses
Environmentally appraise Proposed Plan.
Amend Environmental Report if necessary (i.e. if there are significant changes
between Main Issues Report and Proposed Plan).


Committee(s)
Publish Proposed Plan and Proposed Action Programme

Publish revised Environmental Report if necessary and submit via SEA Gateway.







Notify neighbours.
Period for representations
Consider representations
Prepare Summary of unresolved issues
Prepare Report of Conformity with Participation Statement
Committee(s)
Submit to Scottish Ministers Proposed Plan, Proposed Action
Programme, Report of Conformity with Participation
Statement
Publicise submission of Plan
Examination of Proposed Plan
Examination Report published and submitted to planning
authority.

Consult where required

Consider responses
Key Stage
Evidence
Gathering
Submit to
Scottish
Ministers

Submit HRA record to Ministers


Reporter refers to Environmental Report

Environmentally appraise modified Plan



Planning authority considers recommendations
Proposed Plan modifications
Statement of Explanation for not accepting any
recommendations.
Publish Modifications and Proposed Plan as modified.
Advertise intention to adopt Plan.
Send Ministers the Proposed Plan as modified etc.

Ministers publish revised Environmental Report (and revised HRA Record) if
required
Adoption

Planning authority adopts plan

Publish Post-Adoption SEA Statement and submit to SEA Gateway
Publish
Action
Programme

Publish Action Programme
Examination
Council
Considers
Representati
ons






Equalities Impact
Assessment
 Prepare EqIA on MIR
options
Publication and
Consultation Dates
MIR Publication:
May 2015
MIR/ER
Consultation: June
– July 2015 (6
weeks)
 Re-assess any modified
policies or proposals, as
a result of
representation
Proposed Plan
Council publication:
August 2015
Proposed Plan
Consultation:
September –
October (6 weeks)
 No action required
Submit Proposed
Plan for
Examination:
December 2015
 No action required
Examination:
January 2016 –
June 2016
 Update EqIA to reflect
Scottish Ministers’
modifications. (Note:
development plan
regulations do not allow
modifications to be
rejected on the basis of
the EqIA)
 No action required
 No action required
Re-submit modified
Proposed Plan to
Scottish Ministers:
August 2016
Adopted: August
2016
Publication:
November 2016