WP8: Valuation
Online Deliverables
Sumaila and all members of WP8
WP1 Workshop: Data Tools & Outreach
May 16-19, 2006
WP8 team members
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Claire Armstrong, UiT, Norway;
Ratana Chuenpagdee, CDC, Thailand;
Moenieba Isaacs, UWC, South Africa;
Kungwan Juntarashote, CDC, Thailand;
Kevin Stephanus, UNAM, Namibia;
Abbie Trinidad, PRIMEX-FAME, Philippines;
Sheila Heymans, Namibia & UBC;
Patricia Susan Alexander, UNAM;
Jannike Falk-Petersen, UiT, Norway;
Rashid Sumaila, UNAM&UBC.
WP8 objectives
• Provide social & economic data to the
INCOFISH Db;
• Value marine ecosystem goods and services;
• Develop economic and social indicators of
ineffective management;
• Develop policy options for sustainable coastal
resources management;
• Publish at least 5 papers in the primary
literature.
Economic & Social Database
• Coastal stakeholders by country;
• Economic information;
– Ex-vessel prices by taxon by country by year;
– Cost of fishing by country by gear type;
– non-market values by country.
• Coastal institutions & management
mechanisms by country;
• Global database summary by country.
Coastal stakeholders by country
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Fishers – subsistence, artisanal, recreational;
Fishworkers;
Fishing Industries;
NGOs;
Unions;
Researchers – scientists, economists, social…;
Fish “mammas” sellers/traders.
Ex-vessel prices
• Point portal to SAUP website;
Cost of fishing
Region Country
Gear type
Africa
Wet fish
trawlers
Namibia
Fixed
costs
Variable
costs
References/
notes
…
…
…
…
…
…
Freezer
trawlers
Purse
seiners
Asia
…
…
Thailand
Bottom
trawl
Driftnets
Purse
seiners
…
…
…
Non-market: Data structure
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Title, year, author;
Country and district;
Ecosystem/species studied;
Type of publication;
Valuation technique used;
Results;
Policy implications/recommendations, if
any.
Market Values
Fisheries in US$
Non Market Values
Tourism w/
Coral
Reefs
Coral Reefs
in $US
Application
Country
CVM
Thailand
7.18
Belize
527
Belize
Belize
219
Belize
N. Antilles
115
Bonaire
Philippines
3.7
Anilao
Philippines
5.5
Mactan Island
Australia
136 million
Indonesia
3.8 billion
Philippines
Jamaica
TC
205.4 m
Phi phi
GBR
52.7 million
7.49 million
Vietnam
210 m
17.9 million
Malaysia
4.2
Pulau Payar
Mexico
11 million
Red snapper in
Gulf of Mexico
Philippines
15 billion
MER
Cambodia
233 million
Coastal Institutions
• Point portal to SAUP website;
Management mechanisms
Thailand
Namibia
SAfrica
Angola
Norway
Gear restrictions
x
?
?
?
x
Area Restrictions
?
?
?
?
x
Time restrictions
x
?
?
?
x
Entrance restrictions
x[1]
x
?
?
x
Bycatch restrictions
?
x
?
?
x
TAC’s
?
x
x
?
x[2]
IQs
?
x
x
?
x
Bycatch regulations
?
x
?
?
x
Taxes
?
x[3]
?
?
-
ITQs
?
x[4]
?
?
x[5]
Subsidies
?
x[6]
?
?
x[7]
Top down
?
x
?
?
x
Bottom up
?
-
?
x
x[8]
-
?
-
Transparency of
allocations
?
-
?
x
Offshore
?
x
?
?
x
Onshore
?
?
?
?
x
Inspectors aboard
?
x
?
?
-
Mechanisms
Input Restrictions
Output restrictions
Market mechanisms
Management forms
Local management
Catch Monitoring
Management mechanisms
Thailand
Stock assessment
Single species
x
Namibia
x
Multispecies
Ecosystem
Social parameters
Economic
parameters
x
SAfrica
x
Angola
x
Norway
x
Global database summary
Country
LSF catch
(t)
SSF catch
(t)
SSF values (US$)
# SS
fishers
Aqua (t)
Albania
2,365
271
665,796
119
500
Algeria
99,936
3,105
7,620,288
1,362
99
2,017
132
323,931
84
0
285,636
50,420
123,625,859
25,500
0
1,435
2,527
5,933,263
1,088
0
Argentina
675,093
8,184
20,084,235
1,690
24,393
…
…
Amer Samoa
Angola
Antigua Barb
…
…
…
…
Summary of top ten countries
Numbe
r
% Coastal
population
Large-scale
fisheries
production
Small-scale
fisheries
production
Aquacultur
e
production
Fisheries and
aquaculture
employee
# of tourism
1
Argentina
Peru
Indonesia
China Main
China Main
France
2
Australia
China Main
Japan
Japan
India
Spain
3
Bahamas
Indonesia
India
Egypt
Indonesia
USA
4
Bahrain
Russian
Fed
Viet Nam
Korea,
South
Bangladesh
Italy
5
Bangladesh
Chile
China Main
Greece
Viet Nam
China Main
6
Barbados
Japan
Chile
Turkey
Philippines
United
Kingdom
7
Belgium
India
Philippines
Italy
Myanmar
Malaysia
8
Belize
Norway
USA-Alaska
Spain
Nigeria
Russian Fed
9
Benin
USA-Alaska
Canada
Indonesia
Thailand
Germany
10
Brazil
Iceland
Venezuela
France
Russian Fed
Canada
Thanks for your attention