Presented by Cindy White, CPPO, CPPB Director of Purchasing Collin County Community College District 2012 TACCBO Annual Meeting and Conference What is eProcurement? eProcurement (Electronic Procurement): Conducting all or some of the procurement function over the Internet. Implies that point, click, buy and ship Internet technology is replacing paper-based procurement and supply management business processes. (1) What can eProcurement do for your organization? Streamline processes Manage or control Maverick spend Eliminate paper processes Provide analytical information on spend and processes Lead to greater discounts with enabled suppliers Provide detailed historical information on transactions Increase accuracy and completeness of the data (e.g. description and even images) Better meet the growing demands of the District without expanding the size of the staff in the future Eliminate duplication of effort for the Purchasing Dept (retyping of information into eBidding software) Reason for Collin’s eProcurement Decision Loss of functionality with Banner Finance implementation Disconnect between Banner Finance and our sourcing/bid management systems (Ion Wave Technologies) Inability to determine contract spend Banner Finance not user friendly User surveys Need to provide user’s with contract information and pricing Desire to reduce time between creation of requisition and delivery of goods/services Who can provide? There are numerous companies providing eProcurment software these days. Most provide a SaaS (Software as a Service), which is hosted on their servers. SciQuest Mercury Commerce (eSchool Mall) BuySpeed Ariba Unimarket These are just a few companies that I’m aware of. There are many others out there, so do your homework! Questions to ask when selecting an eProcurement provider: Will it integrate with our existing ERP or other systems? If so, how many integration points are available and what are those integration points? Is additional hardware or software required? (Servers, middleware, etc.) Will there be charges from my ERP or other systems for the integration? How long does the implementation take? Additional Questions What resources will we have to provide? What other functions can the software support? (Forms) Training and support References We had over 120 questions that we asked to determine the best solution and will be glad to share! Collin’s Decision SciQuest Higher Markets Express for Banner They were the Premier Partner for Banner Finance and had done numerous integrations with Banner They had done numerous integrations with Ion Wave Technologies Long-term cost was lower Most integration points with Banner Finance Synchronization with Banner vendor database done in real time Availability of Contract Manager Implementation CougarMart Kick-Off Meeting - January 4, 2011 We went with Remote Implementation Selected a Focus Group made up of heavy requisitioners, approvers and key finance staff Gathered input from Focus Group Based on input from Focus Group and months of testing, system was configured Big Bang roll-out for training and Go Live System went live on May 23, 2011 Let’s take a look at CougarMart! CougarMart is our branded name for our eProcurement Solution Available to those users that have gone through CougarMart training and have a user profile set up in Banner Can be accessed through the Banner Luminus portal and single sign-on is in progress Approvals can be done by logging into the system or directly from their Groupwise e-mail from a computer or their smartphone Key Features Showcased Suppliers Showcased Services Approvals Welcome Messages CougarMart Support E-mails Multiple Search Options Quotes for Enabled Suppliers Contracts Reports Contract Spend Contract items can be loaded into Contract Manager from a bid Contract can be automatically tied to a vendor, except when a vendor has multiple contracts Purchase orders are tied to spend Board Approval Amount is input as the “Budget” Notification is sent to the Buyer when 85% of the “Budget” has been spent Buyer can then determine if the contract needs to be increased and go back to the Board for approval Reports Following are examples of some of the reports that we have been able to produce from information found in CougarMart! PO Summary Month May-11 Jun-11 Jul-11 Aug-11 Sep-11 Oct-11 Nov-11 Dec-11 Jan-12 Feb-12 Mar-12 Apr-12 May-12 Total POs 49 204 218 179 693 275 269 221 230 260 234 269 214 3,315 PO Lines 148 506 971 552 1,274 804 938 650 574 661 771 885 561 9,295 PO Dollars $ 59,402 $ 19,224,582 $ 400,996 $ 1,139,688 $ 4,811,381 $ 2,331,330 $ 1,758,027 $ 1,583,767 $ 571,669 $ 418,449 $ 1,052,003 $ 1,394,347 $ 1,235,949 $ 35,981,590 CougarMart Site Usage Cycle Time FY11 Days 0 Days 1 Day 2 to 5 Days 6 to 10 Days 11 to 29 Days 30+ Days Grand Total POs 59 112 282 125 42 32 649 % POs 9.1% 17.3% 43.5% 19.3% 6.5% 4.9% 100.0% PO Lines 160 335 750 472 247 211 2,175 Measurement of time from PR creation to PO distribution % PO Lines 7.4% 15.4% 34.5% 21.7% 11.4% 9.7% 100.0% Avg 0 1 3.4 7 18 54.3 10.2 FY12 Days 0 Days 1 Day 2 to 5 Days 6 to 10 Days 11 to 29 Days 30+ Days Grand Total POs 105 344 1,111 709 304 110 2,663 % POs 3.9% 12.9% 41.7% 26.6% 11.4% 4.1% 100.0% PO Lines 181 666 2,929 1,955 1,029 357 7,117 % PO Lines 2.5% 9.4% 41.2% 27.5% 14.5% 5.0% 100.0% Avg 0 1 3.4 7.2 15 70.6 9.2 Email Approvals (These are approvals that are done directly from their Groupwise e-mail via computer or mobile device.) User Name Leathers, Ed Hoyt, Dave Ammons, Shane Schumann, Sherry Johnson, Abe Hall, Ralph Harmon, Shirley Miller, Susan Davison, Kim Jindra, Barbara Martin, Tom White, Cindy Total Jul-11 Aug-11 Sep-11 Oct-11 Nov-11 Dec-11 Jan-12 Feb-12 Mar-12 Apr-12 Grand Total 2 2 4 124 35 22 27 43 43 3 3 124 72 63 9 5 12 3 3 59 25 30 16 41 3 65 50 23 16 14 4 5 3 61 37 18 25 20 3 4 2 1 12 299 62 43 32 39 26 4 1 4 2 110 74 50 76 62 1 291 174 180 168 214 372 42 43 41 26 16 3 2 4 2 3 1 183 44 33 35 36 27 1 2 3 1 8 1 191 693 414 314 270 254 71 20 15 14 10 6 3 2,084 FY12 Top 25 Suppliers: PO Dollars Supplier ID 13657772 13660041 13656795 13658991 4050097 13659643 13658280 13658750 13658702 13659653 13695803 13658177 13657173 13660572 4066394 13660109 13658949 13656130 13637185 13657184 13835794 13659134 14334973 13657912 13657736 Grand Total Supplier Name Enablement Pogue Construction Non-catalog ServiceMaster Clean Non-catalog Gomez Floor Covering Non-catalog Temps of McKinney Non-catalog Dell Marketing LP Punchout Texas A&M University-Corpus Christi Non-catalog Flair Data Systems Inc Non-catalog Plano Office Supply Non-catalog Oracle America Inc Non-catalog Roach Howard Smith & Barton Non-catalog Grande Communications Networks Non-catalog LLC Dental Careers Foundation Non-catalog Northstar Services Inc Non-catalog TFE Non-catalog KI Office Furniture Punchout Videotex Systems, Inc. Non-catalog SunGard Higher Education Non-catalog Baker & Taylor Books Non-catalog EBSCO Information Services Non-catalog Oce' North America Inc Non-catalog Centennial Moisture Control Inc Non-catalog University of Texas at Arlington Non-catalog Boston Reed Non-catalog Applied Engineering Inc Non-catalog Zones Non-catalog FY11 PO's Lines Dollars 1 1 $18,488,126 1 1 33 1 1 21 1 1 6 4 1 $ 1 $ 45 $ 1 $ 3 $ 93 $ 1 $ 2 164,562 25,344 40,595 377,355 4,516 39,713 1,020 $ 143,120 12 $ 4 $ 9,634 36,978 1 1 $ 2,200 1 1 $ 169,980 1 649 1 2,175 $ 5,760 $20,823,609 PO's 8 3 13 208 2 14 61 13 2 1 1 2 11 9 47 2 3 10 5 1 1 8 1 2,663 FY12 Lines Dollars 9 $ 1,281,143 3 $ 820,586 17 $ 811,741 269 $ 473,130 2 $ 100,308 42 $ 434,576 243 $ 397,909 78 $ 427,936 10 $ 416,529 2 $ 232,692 1 $ 355,000 5 $ 301,937 95 $ 297,691 20 $ 290,008 74 $ 259,082 3 $ 220,467 3 $ 248,036 12 $ 200,054 9 $ 171,068 1 1 12 11 7,117 $ 150,000 $ 150,000 $ 149,379 $ 132,555 $15,211,376 PO's 1 8 4 14 241 3 15 82 14 2 2 1 2 11 9 53 6 3 11 5 1 1 1 8 2 3,312 994 Suppliers, Top 25 are 77% of PO Dollars Lines 1 9 4 18 314 3 45 336 79 10 4 1 5 95 20 86 7 3 13 9 1 1 1 12 12 9,292 Total Dollars $18,488,126 $ 1,281,143 $ 985,148 $ 837,085 $ 513,725 $ 477,663 $ 439,092 $ 437,622 $ 428,956 $ 416,529 $ 375,812 $ 355,000 $ 301,937 $ 297,691 $ 290,008 $ 268,716 $ 257,445 $ 248,036 $ 202,254 $ 171,068 $ 169,980 $ 150,000 $ 150,000 $ 149,379 $ 138,315 $36,034,985 Avg PO $18,488,126 $ 160,143 $ 246,287 $ 59,792 $ 2,132 $ 159,221 $ 29,273 $ 5,337 $ 30,640 $ 208,265 $ 187,906 $ 355,000 $ 150,969 $ 27,063 $ 32,223 $ 5,070 $ 42,908 $ 82,679 $ 18,387 $ 34,214 $ 169,980 $ 150,000 $ 150,000 $ 18,672 $ 69,158 $ 10,880 FY12 Top 25 Suppliers: PO Lines Supplier ID 13656986 13637230 13658750 13659164 4050097 13658277 125769 3901 13658033 13659691 13657358 13613455 13637229 13658845 13657947 13637231 13660572 13660109 13658721 13637232 13658702 13637239 13657366 13637238 13637233 Grand Total FY11 Supplier Name Enablement PO's Lines Dollars Flinn Scientific Inc Non-catalog 6 118 $ 6,747 Pocket Nurse Enterprises Inc Non-catalog 9 238 $ 20,668 Plano Office Supply Non-catalog 21 93 $ 39,713 Ward's Natural Science Non-catalog 3 55 $ 5,572 Dell Marketing LP Punchout 33 45 $ 40,595 Thermo Fisher Scientific Non-catalog 6 90 $ 11,230 Grainger Punchout 1 14 $ 874 VWR International Inc Punchout 4 35 $ 3,753 Carolina Biological Supply Non-catalog 3 29 $ 5,230 IDEX Global Services Inc Non-catalog 3 36 $ 3,275 Sargent-Welch Non-catalog 1 2 $ 104 Western BRW Paper Company Hosted 9 51 $ 23,797 Moore Medical LLC Non-catalog 6 61 $ 3,422 Sam's Club Non-catalog 2 13 $ 576 B&H Photo-Video Inc Non-catalog 8 34 $ 6,041 Southeastern Emergency Equipment Non-catalog 2 18 $ 1,185 TFE Non-catalog Videotex Systems, Inc. Non-catalog 6 12 $ 9,634 Patterson Dental Supply Inc Non-catalog 1 44 $ 10,340 Authentic Promotions Non-catalog 8 10 $ 4,962 Oracle America Inc Non-catalog 1 1 $ 1,020 Medline Industries Inc Non-catalog 11 50 $ 7,337 School Health Corporation Non-catalog Journey Ed, Academic Superstore, Non-catalog CCV, Gradware 7 18 $ 16,335 AC Printing Non-catalog 15 21 $ 8,575 649 2,175 $20,823,609 PO's 10 14 61 13 208 13 69 15 13 10 9 30 12 21 21 4 11 47 13 24 13 9 4 19 39 2,663 FY12 Lines Dollars 334 $ 21,868 123 $ 13,845 243 $ 397,909 262 $ 41,100 269 $ 473,130 130 $ 44,768 199 $ 40,306 176 $ 19,818 129 $ 29,246 98 $ 25,817 117 $ 59,703 62 $ 88,720 52 $ 2,611 90 $ 20,988 68 $ 29,846 83 $ 16,329 95 $ 297,691 74 $ 259,082 38 $ 21,652 70 $ 35,414 78 $ 427,936 27 $ 3,680 75 $ 2,451 51 $ 33,939 47 $ 19,966 7,117 $15,211,376 994 Suppliers, Top 25 are 44% of PO Lines PO's 16 23 82 16 241 19 70 19 16 13 10 39 18 23 29 6 11 53 14 32 14 20 4 26 54 3,312 Lines 452 361 336 317 314 220 213 211 158 134 119 113 113 103 102 101 95 86 82 80 79 77 75 69 68 9,292 Total Dollars $ 28,615 $ 34,513 $ 437,622 $ 46,672 $ 513,725 $ 55,998 $ 41,180 $ 23,571 $ 34,476 $ 29,092 $ 59,807 $ 112,517 $ 6,033 $ 21,564 $ 35,887 $ 17,514 $ 297,691 $ 268,716 $ 31,992 $ 40,376 $ 428,956 $ 11,017 $ 2,451 $ 50,274 $ 28,541 $36,034,985 $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ Avg PO 1,788 1,501 5,337 2,917 2,132 2,947 588 1,241 2,155 2,238 5,981 2,885 335 938 1,237 2,919 27,063 5,070 2,285 1,262 30,640 551 613 1,934 529 10,880 Punchout & Hosted Enabled Suppliers Supplier ID Supplier Name 4050097 Dell Marketing LP 125769 Grainger 3901 VWR International Inc 13613455 Western BRW Paper Company 13613881 Joy Promotions Inc 4050097 Dell 125769 Grainger, Inc. 4066394 KI Office Furniture 3901 VWR International 4070444 Fastenal 13613455 Western Paper Company Inc Total Punchout and Hosted suppliers (11) Grand Total (994 suppliers) Enablement Punchout Punchout Punchout Hosted Hosted Punchout Punchout Punchout Punchout Punchout Hosted FY11 PO's Lines Dollars 33 45 $ 40,595 1 14 $ 874 4 35 $ 3,753 9 51 $ 23,797 7 14 $ 5,703 28 34 $ 12,259 16 29 $ 9,241 2 1 101 649 3 1 226 2,175 $ PO's 208 69 15 30 17 FY12 Lines Dollars 269 $ 473,130 199 $ 40,306 176 $ 19,818 62 $ 88,720 53 $ 16,590 9 20 $ 290,008 1 1 $ 72 349 2,663 780 7,117 5,340 $ 6,100 $ 107,662 $20,823,609 $ 928,644 $15,211,376 PO's 241 70 19 39 24 28 16 9 2 1 1 450 3,312 Lines 314 213 211 113 67 34 29 20 3 1 1 1,006 9,292 Total Dollars $ 513,725 $ 41,180 $ 23,571 $ 112,517 $ 22,293 $ 12,259 $ 9,241 $ 290,008 $ 5,340 $ 72 $ 6,100 $ 1,036,306 $36,034,985 $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ Avg PO 2,132 588 1,241 2,885 929 438 578 32,223 2,670 72 6,100 2,303 10,880 Questions? References (1) NIGP Public Procurement Dictionary of Terms