ISE4 Alternate Demo Scenario
Incorporates suggestions B. Kassel, S. Gordon, & B. Gischner
with input from: T. Briggs and S. Moore
May 23, 2005
Revised Arrangements Demo Scenario
AP 216 Hull
Design Agent
Initial
Arrangement
Initial ASSET
Arrangement
+ Requirements
(LEAPS)
Vulnerability
Analysis
(LEAPS)
Complete
Arrangement +
Equipment
Vulnerability
Report
Build Yards
May 23, 2005
Engineering
Analysis
ISE4 Future Ship Acquisition Demo Proposal
Steel
Processing
2
ISE4 Revised Future Ship Acquisition
Demo Scenario
•
Mission Requirements and Initial Arrangements provided by the Navy via ASSET
– TWR 841 will be used as input
•
TWR 841 Model Captured in FORAN to be treated as Concept Design
– Send AP216 file to Navy (ASSET) for Analysis
•
ASSET will pose new mission requirements and generates an initial Arrangement
(AP215 Model)
– List of Compartments with Requirements plus possibly some minimal Geometry
•
•
Arrangement returned to Design Agent (FORAN) which sets up compartmentation
and generates updated AP215 file (Part 21)
Demonstrate Initial Electrical System design (KSSI)
– Electronic System in Pilot House
•
Navy selects Diesel Engine which fulfills base requirements and incorporates into
ship contract
May 23, 2005
ISE4 Future Ship Acquisition Demo Proposal
3
ISE4 Revised Future Ship Acquisition
Demo Scenario cont’d.
•
Two build yards (CAD Systems: ISDP and TRIBON) will be doing a
collaborative design and are awarded a preliminary/detailed design contract
– TRIBON will design Topside
– ISDP will design below Decks
•
•
Shipyards add Diesel to CPC Catalog and receive AP203 file
Arrangements Model is transferred to TRIBON (P28) via AP215 exchange
– Transfer requires Mediators between Part 28 and Part 21 files
•
Designs are created in ISDP, and TRIBON
–
–
–
–
•
Arrangements transferred via AP218 to LEAPS and COMMANDS for Analysis
COMMANDS creates mesh and sends to Analysis tools (e.g. PATRAN, ABACUS)
FEM Analysis performed on revised model of Engine Room
Analysis report generated
Design Agent sends Arrangements Model to LEAPS for Vulnerability Analysis
May 23, 2005
ISE4 Future Ship Acquisition Demo Proposal
4
ISE4 Revised Future Ship Acquisition
Demo Scenario cont’d.
•
•
•
Extract Structure for Manufacturing (Intergraph)
Develop neutral structural manufacturing model (ISPE)
Generate yard-specific manufacturing data (EB, Avondale)
– Compare EB and Avondale manufacturing outputs
•
Ship check existing TWR design
– Provide scanned shots of Engine Room from Ship Check Data Capture Project
– Emphasize synergy between these NSRP funded projects, even though Demo is
separate and not part of Ship Check Data Capture
May 23, 2005
ISE4 Future Ship Acquisition Demo Proposal
5
Flowchart of Revised New Design Demo Scenario
Concept Design
(ASSET/LEAPS)
Navy Analysis
(LEAPS)
Preliminary Design
(FORAN)
Engineering Analysis
(COMMANDS)
Collaborative Detailed Design
(ISDP)
(TRIBON)
(Electrical – KSSI)
Production
(Steel Processing)
Operations & Maintenance
(Ship Check Results)
May 23, 2005
ISE4 Future Ship Acquisition Demo Proposal
6
ISE4 Alternate Demo Proposal
NAVSEA
Proposes
Concept Design
Alternative
Proposals
Analyzed
Initial
Arrangement
FORAN
Below Decks
Arrangement
ISDP – Des. 1
Topside
Arrangement
TRIBON – Des. 2
May 23, 2005
COMMANDS
See
EAD
S
LEAPS
STEP Description of
Selected Model
Transferred for Steel
Processing
Analysis Tools
PATRAN
ABACUS
etc.
Results
Des. 1
See
EAD
S
Results
Des. 2
ISE4 Future Ship Acquisition Demo Proposal
7
Engineering Analysis Demo Scenario
AP 203
P21
Vendor
AP 209
P28
Shipyard
(Add to CPC, CAD)
AP 227
P28
(COG, weight,
location)
Compartmentation
AP 215
P28
Analysis
AP 209
P28
Equip arrangement
Ship
Product
Model
(ISDP)
AP 216
P21
AP 218
P28
AP 209 /218
P28
May 23, 2005
CAD
CPC
Parts
Equip arrangement
GUID, doc URL
Feedback
EADS
ISE4 Future Ship Acquisition Demo Proposal
Note: Feedback loop only for winner (ISDP)
Equipment exchange precedes competition
8
Mediators Required
209
218
P28
P28
216
P21
203/
PLM
215
P28
ARM
AIM
227
P28
P28
P28
P28
P28
P21
P21
P21
P21
Processing Capability
Currently Available
May 23, 2005
P28
Lower Priority
(Possibly Optional)
P28
ISE4 Future Ship Acquisition Demo Proposal
Higher Priority
(Needed as Soon as Possible)
9
Backup Slides
May 23, 2005
ISE4 Future Ship Acquisition Demo Proposal
10
TWR Propulsion Engine (Caterpillar 3512) Model
May 23, 2005
ISE4 Future Ship Acquisition Demo Proposal
11
TWR Reduction Gear Model
May 23, 2005
ISE4 Future Ship Acquisition Demo Proposal
12
Demo Scenario Issues
•
Scenario has analysis software used to discriminate among three proposed
designs
– More realistic than usual Demo Scenarios
•
•
Must find way to work Electrical and ISPE (Steel Processing) more
smoothly into Demo
Steel Processing should be easily integrated with the Arrangements and
Analysis scenarios, but we must determine what can be exchanged from
this task
May 23, 2005
ISE4 Future Ship Acquisition Demo Proposal
13
Notional Mediators Required
AP
ARM -> AIM
216
215
Arrangements
AIM-ARM
ARM-> 209 AIM
P21
Eng Analysis
Eng Analysis
Arrangements
218
Eng Analysis
227
Eng Analysis
209
May 23, 2005
Eng Analysis
??
ISE4 Future Ship Acquisition Demo Proposal
14