Classroom presentations to accompany Understanding Earth, 3rd edition prepared by Peter Copeland and William Dupré University of Houston Chapter 9 The Rock Record and the Geologic Timescale William E. Ferguson Geologic Time A major difference between geologists and most other scientists is their attitude about time. A "long" time may not be important unless it is > 1 million years. Two ways to date geologic events 1) relative dating (fossils, structure) 2) absolute dating (isotopic, tree rings, etc.) Amount of Time Required for Some Geologic Processes and Events Fig. 9.1 Some geologic processes can be documented using historical records (brown is new land from 1887-1988) Fig. 9.2 Ammonite Fossils Chip Clark Fig. 9.4 Petrified Wood Tom Bean Steno's Laws Nicolaus Steno (1669) • Principle of Superposition • Principle of Original Horizontality • Principle of Lateral Continuity Laws apply to both sedimentary and volcanic rocks. Principle of Superposition In a sequence of undisturbed layered rocks, the oldest rocks are on the bottom. Principle of Superposition Youngest rocks Oldest rocks Jim Steinberg/Photo Researchers Fig. 9.3b Principle of Original Horizontality Layered strata are deposited horizontal or nearly horizontal or nearly parallel to the Earth’s surface. Principles of original horizontality and superposition Fig. 9.3a Principle of Lateral Continuity Layered rocks are deposited in continuous contact. Principle of Lateral Continuity Map view Principle of Lateral Continuity Map view Principle of Lateral Continuity Map view Using Fossils to Correlate Rocks Fig. 9.5 Unconformity A buried surface of erosion Sedimentation of Beds A-D Beneath the Sea Fig. 9.6 Uplift and Exposure of D to Erosion Fig. 9.6 Continued Erosion Removes D and Exposes C to Erosion Fig. 9.6 Subsidence and Sedimentation of E over C Unconformity: a buried surface of erosion Fig. 9.6 Formation of a Disconformity Fig. 9.6 The Great Unconformity of the Grand Canyon Geoscience Features Picture Libraryc Fig. 9.7 Angular unconformity, Grand Canyon South rim of the Grand Canyon South rim of the Grand Canyon 250 million years old Paleozoic Strata 550 million years old 1.7 billion years old Precambrian South rim of the Grand Canyon 250 million years old 550 million years old Nonconformity 1.7 billion years old Nonconformity in the Grand Canyon Nonconformity in the Grand Canyon Tapeats Sandstone (~550 million years old) Vishnu Schist (~1700 million years old) Sedimentation of Beds A-D Beneath the Sea Fig. 9.8 Deformation and Erosion During Mountain Building Fig. 9.8 Erosional Surface Cuts Across Deformed Rocks Fig. 9.8 Subsidence and Subsequent Deposition Buries Erosional Surface Angular Unconformity Fig. 9.8 Formation of an Angular Unconformity Fig. 9.8 Cross-cutting Relationships Fig. 9.9 Schlumberger Executive Communications Fig. 9.10 Sequence A forms during lower sea level Fig. 9.11a Sequence B forms during higher sea level Fig. 9.11b Reconstructing Relative Sequence of Events Fig. 9.12 Generalized Stratigraphic Section of Rocks Exposed in the Grand Canyon after: Beus & Moral (1990) Some of the Geologic Units Exposed in the Grand Canyon Michael Collier The Geologic time scale • Divisions in the worldwide stratigraphic column based on variations in preserved fossils • Built using a combination of stratigraphic relationships, crosscutting relationships, and absolute (isotopic) ages The Geologic Time Scale Fig. 9.13 Absolute geochronology • Add numbers to the stratigraphic column based on fossils. • Based on the regular radioactive decay of some chemical elements. Isotopes Different forms of the same element containing the same number of protons, but varying numbers of neutrons. i.e.: 235U, 238U 87Sr, 86Sr 14C, 12C Radioactive Decay of Rubidium to Strontium Fig. 9.14 Half-life The half-life of a radioactive isotope is defined as the time required for half of it to decay. Proportion of Parent Atoms Remaining as a Function of Time Fig. 9.15 Isotopic dating • Radioactive elements (parents) decay to nonradioactive (stable) elements (daughters). • The rate at which this decay occurs is constant and knowable. • Therefore, if we know the rate of decay and the amount present of parent and daughter, we can calculate how long this reaction has been proceeding. Major Radioactive Elements Used in Isotopic Dating Table 9.1 Geologically Useful Decay Schemes Parent 235U Daughter 207Pb Half-life (years) 4.5 x 109 238U 206Pb 0.71 x 109 40K 40Ar 1.25 x 109 87Rb 87Sr 47 x 109 14C 14N 5730 Uniformitarianism The present is the key to the past. — James Hutton Natural laws do not change— however, rates and intensity of processes may. Calculating Relative Plate Motion Fig. 9.16 1871 Fig. 9.17 1968 Fig. 9.17 Fig. 9.18 Areas with Potentially Hazardous Amounts of Radon Paleontology The study of life in the past based on fossilized plants and animals. Fossil: Evidence of past life Fossils preserved in sedimentary rocks are used to determine: 1) Relative age 2) Environment of deposition Many methods have been used to determine the age of the Earth 1) Bible: In 1664, Archbishop Usher of Dublin used chronology of the Book of Genesis to calculate that the world began on Oct. 26, 4004 B.C. 2) Salt in the Ocean: (ca. 1899) Assuming the oceans began as fresh water, the rate at which rivers are transporting salts to the oceans would lead to present salinity in ~100 m.y. Many methods have been used to determine the age of the Earth 3) Sediment Thickness: Assuming the rate of deposition is the same today as in the past, the thickest sedimentary sequences (e.g., Grand Canyon) would have been deposited in ~ 100 m.y. 4) Kelvin’s Calculation: (1870): Lord Kelvin calculated that the present geothermal gradient of ~30°C/km would result in an initially molten earth cooled for 30 – 100 m.y. Flawed assumptions • Bible is not a science text or history book • Salt is precipitated in sedimentary formations • Both erosion and non-deposition are major parts of the sedimentary record • Radioactivity provides another heat source The heat inside the Earth The discovery of radioactivity at the turn of the century by Bequerel, Curie, and Rutherford not only provided the source of the heat to override Kelvin’s calculations but provided the basis for all later quantitative estimates of the ages of rocks. Oldest rocks on Earth Slave Province, Northern Canada • Zircons in a metamorphosed granite dated at 3.96 Ga by the U-Pb method Yilgarn block, Western Australia • Detrital zircons in a sandstone dated at 4.10 Ga by U-Pb method. Several other regions dated at 3.8 Ga by various methods including Minnesota, Wyoming, Greenland, South Africa, and Antarctica. Age of the Earth Although the oldest rocks found on Earth are 3.96 Ga (or even 4.1), we believe that the age of the Earth is approximately 4.6 Ga. All rocks of the age 4.6 to 4.0 Ga have been destroyed (the rock cycle) or are presently covered by younger rocks. Age of the Earth This is based on the age of rocks brought back from the Moon (4.4 Ga), and meteorites (4.6 Ga), that are thought to be good representatives of the early solar system as well as more complicated geochemical modeling. This data suggests that the present chemical composition of the crust must have evolved for more than 4.5 Ga. Double it and add 1 number of half-lives 0 1 2 3 4 5 number of parents number of daughters D/P 64 32 16 8 4 2 0 32 48 56 60 62 0 1 3 7 15 31 The geologic timescale and absolute ages Isotopic dating of intebedded volcanic rocks allows assignment of an absolute age for fossil transitions The big assumption The half-lives of radioactive isotopes are the same as they were billions of years ago. Test of the assumption Meteorites and Moon rocks (that are thought to have had a very simple history since they formed), have been dated by up to 10 independent isotopic systems all of which have given the same answer. However, scientists continue to critically evaluate this data. Frequently used decay schemes have half-lives which vary by a factor of > 100 parent 235U daughter 207Pb half life (years) 4.5 x 109 238U 206Pb 0.71 x 109 40K 40Ar 1.25 x 109 87Rb 87Sr 47 x 109 147Sm 144Nd 106 x 109 What if the rates have varied? What we think happened: rate of decay time What if the rates have varied? What we know didn’t happen: rate of decay time Best initial D = 0 Two ways around this problem: 1) Choose minerals with no initial daughter. 2) Use a method that tells you the initial concentration of D and P. Minerals with no initial daughter • 40K decays to 40Ar (a gas) • Zircon: ZrSiO4 ion radius (Å) 4+ Zr 0.92 U4+ 1.08 2+ Pb 1.37