Sexuality and Gender Chris got up and went to the bathroom. Leaving pyjamas on the floor and turning on the shower, Chris stepped into the water. It was not a hair-washing day, so after a quick rub with the soap it was time to get out and dry off. After towelling and hair putty to the new short haircut, Chris dabbed on some moisturizing lotion and went to get dressed. Nothing special was happening today so jeans and a T-shirt would be fine. The only choice really to be made was between sneakers or sandals. Mary Holmes, What is Gender • How are biology and culture expressed in human sex/gender systems? How do gender, gender roles, and gender stratification correlate with other social, economic, and political variables? What is sexual orientation, and how do sexual practices vary cross-culturally? ◦ Sexual dimorphism: marked differences in male and female biology besides the primary and secondary sexual features. ◦ Sex differences are biological. ◦ Gender is a cultural construction of male and female characteristics. Sambia of Papua New Guinea Malawi rite of passage – initiation camps Ancient Greeks “Pink or Blue?” The Infants’ Department, June 1918, page 161. Sex: biological differences between males and females Gender: socially produced differences between being feminine and being masculine Sexual orientation: the direction of one’s sexual or romantic attraction Sexual identity: how one thinks of oneself in terms of being male or female Is sexual orientation inborn or learned? Complex interplay of biological and social factors Michel Foucault, “History of Sexuality” ◦ Homosexuality as a term coined in 1860s with medicalization of sexuality, from then on homosexuals regarded as a separate type of people with a particular sexual aberration In 1973, the American Psychiatric Association declassified homosexuality as a mental disorder. The American Psychological Association followed in 1975 and World Health Organization in 1990. Current research and clinical literature demonstrate that same-sex sexual and romantic attractions, feelings, and behaviors are normal and positive variations of human sexuality (reflecting the official positions of the American Psychiatric Association and the American Psychological Association). Homophobia Transphobia ◦ Avcılar Meis Sitesi ◦ Ülker Sokak The biological nature of men and women (should be seen) not as a narrow enclosure limiting the human organism, but rather as a broad base upon which a variety of structures can be built. (Friedl 1975) Fluidity of sex and gender. (Judith Butler) • Gender roles: tasks and activities that a culture assigns to the sexes Gender stereotypes: oversimplified, strongly held ideas of characteristics of men and women Gender stratification: unequal distribution of rewards between men and women, reflecting their different positions in a social hierarchy Job advertisement by Vestra Inet, an Ontario-based web development company. November 2015. Gender Differences Contrasting positions on interpretation of gender differences ◦ Biological basis to behavioral differences between men and women ◦ Socialization and the learning of gender roles ◦ Both gender and sex are socially constructed Gender and biology: natural differences? How far are the differences in the behavior of women and men result of sex rather than gender? Meaning, how much are they the result of biological differences? Some argue that aspects of human biology (hormones, chromosomes, brain size, genetics) are responsible for innate differences between women and men. Gender and biology Also claim that these differences can be seen in some form across all cultures natural factors are responsible for the inequalities between genders which characterize most societies. ◦ How about slavery than, also natural?? Gender and biology: Critique Theories of natural difference grounded in data on animal behavior rather than in anthropological or historical evidence on human behavior. (human behavior varies over time and place!) Because a trait is more or less universal, it does not mean that it is biological in origin. Gender and biology: critique There is no evidence of the mechanisms that link biological forces with the complex social behavior exhibited by women and men. Theories that see individuals as complying with some innate predisposition neglect the vital role of social interaction in shaping human behavior. Gender socialization Gender socialization: the learning of gender roles with the help of social agencies such as the family and the media. Distinction between biological sex and social gender ◦ An infant is born with the first and develops the second Through contact with agencies of socialization, children gradually internalize social norms and expectations that correspond with their sex. Gender socialization Gender differences are not biologically determined, they are culturally produced gender inequalities result because women and men are socialized into different roles. Functionalists favored gender socialization theory claiming boys and girls learn “sex roles” and accompanying male and female identities (masculinity and femininity). Gender socialization Social learning is guided by positive and negative sanctions (socially applied forces which reward or restrain behavior). If an individual develops gender practices that do not correspond to his/her biological sex inadequate or irregular socialization. Functionalist view: socializing agencies contribute to the maintenance of social order by overseeing the smooth gender socialization of new generations. Gender socialization: critique Rigid interpretation of sex roles and socialization Not a smooth process, different agencies (family, schools, peer groups, media etc.) may conflict with each other. Socialization theory ignores the ability of individuals to reject or modify social expectations surrounding sex roles. Gender socialization: critique Humans are not passive objects or unquestioning recipients of gender programming. People are active agents who create and modify roles for themselves. ◦ Drag ◦ Young girls in competitive sports * Patterns of gender learning are difficult to combat. Not only through formal instruction, but also everyday activities. Social construction of gender and sex Both sex and gender are socially constructed products. Gender is a social creation that lacks a fixed essense. Human body is subject to social forces that shape it in different ways. Individuals construct and reconstruct their bodies as they please ◦ Exercise, dieting, plastic surgery, tatoos, piercing, sex-change Social construction of gender and sex Human body and biology are not givens but are subject to human agency and personal choice within different social contexts. Gender identities emerge in relation to perceived sex differences in society and in turn help shape those differences. Gender relations: societally patterned interactions between men and women. Gender order R.W. Connell Masculinities are a critical part of the gender order and cannot be understood separate from it or the femininities that accompany them. How social power held by men creates and sustains gender inequality. Gender relations are defined by patriarchal power. From the individual to the institutional level various types of masculinity and femininity are arranged to sustain the dominance of men over women. Gender regime: gender relations in smaller settings, a specific institution. Gender hierarchy Hegemonic masculinity ◦ Complicit masculinity ◦ Subordinated masculinities Homosexual masculinity Subordinated femininities ◦ Emphasized femininity ◦ Resistant femininity Recurrent Gender Patterns The subsistence contributions of men and women are roughly equal crossculturally. ◦ In domestic activities, female labor dominates. ◦ In extradomestic activities, male labor dominates. ◦ Women are the primary caregivers, but men often play a role. • Differences in male and female reproductive strategies ◦ Men mate, within and outside marriage, more than women do. ◦ Double standards restrict women more than men and illustrate gender stratification. Gender stratification is lower when men and women make roughly equal contributions to subsistence. Generalities in the Division of Labor by Gender, Based on Data from 185 Societies Earnings in the U.S. by Gender and Job Type for Year-Round Full-Time Workers, 2006 http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article2776959/Boys-BE-superheroes-girlsaspire-date-Walmart-Target-fire-sellingkids-clothing-sexist-message.html https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CU040Hqbas Feminist Theories of Gender 1 Starts from a series of observations: Men earn more than women, even when they do essentially the same work The labour market is segregated by gender: jobs largely and traditionally done by women are paid less well and have less status than jobs largely and traditionally done by men Men are more likely to gain promotion to higher levels in organizations than women Feminist Theories of Gender 2 Men hold many more positions of authority and decision-making in public life than women Women take primary responsibility for childcare and unpaid care of the sick and the elderly Women – even those in full time employment – do more housework than men Domestic and sexualized violence is largely perpetrated by men upon women and children Feminist Theories of Gender 3 Sexualized violence and harassment, and the fear of it, is an ever-present characteristic of women’s lives These observations derive from modern Western societies but find their corollaries in (nearly) all societies There is nothing natural or inevitable about this situation Gender Based Violence http://sendika7.org/2015/11/kadincinayetleri-haritasi-5-yilda-en-az-1134kadin-olduruldu/ http://kadincinayetleri.org/