Competition challenges in
food and agro-processing
Presentation to Parliament’s
Portfolio Committee on Economic Development
Shan Ramburuth
Commissioner, Competition Commission
10 November 2009
Towards a fair and efficient economy for all
Overview
• Background
• High food prices
• Structure of the food market
• Commission’s interventions
• Major cases
• Role of the state
Towards a fair and efficient economy for all
Background
• Regulation – Agricultural marketing boards, co-ops
• Liberalisation in 1996, tariff reform & trade agreements
• Effects of liberalisation since after 1996:
closing down of boards
market concentration
dominant private companies and co-ops
surge in imports in processed foods
SAFEX established
cartels replaced public regulation
Towards a fair and efficient economy for all
High food prices –
contributory factors
•
Availability of grains worldwide
•
Increasing demand including from economic growth and
biofuels
•
Unfavorable climatic conditions
•
Increasing energy and fuel costs – transport
•
Anti-competitive conduct in the agro-food chain including
inputs
Towards a fair and efficient economy for all
The structure of food markets
• Historical oligopolies and virtual monopolies
• Increasing vertical integration and horizontal concentration
• Limited new entrants due to barriers such as access to capital
and competing against established brands
• Transformation at the level of ownership in the established
firms
• Incumbent firms leverage historical positions to extract profits
and impose standards
Towards a fair and efficient economy for all
Commission’s interventions
•
Within mandate of the Competition Act
•
Enforcement and exemptions, merger analysis, advocacy and
market inquiries
•
Prioritisation of the food value chain
Impact on low income consumers
A number of complaints
Government interventions: monitoring prices, task teams, industrial
policy
Research and scoping exercises show strong indications of anticompetitive conduct
Towards a fair and efficient economy for all
Major cases
•
Fertilizer
•
Tinplate and other inputs
•
Bread and milling
•
Grain storage and trading
•
Dairy
•
Poultry
•
Fish
•
Fats and Oils
•
Food retail
Towards a fair and efficient economy for all
Fertilizer
• High levels of concentration in inputs to farming
• Fertilizer is the single largest input cost in production of
crops such as maize, wheat
• Long-running cartel:
Foskor applied for leniency;
Sasol reached settlement with Commission, penalty of R250m;
Case proceeding against Omnia and Kynoch/Yara
• Local monopolies in main inputs (abuse of dominance ):
Ammonia production- Sasol charges inland import parity prices
Phosphate rock- Foskor is settling
Towards a fair and efficient economy for all
Tinplate and other inputs
Tinplate
• Tinplate is major cost in canned foods for local and export markets
• Tinplate pricing impacts heavily on:
local production by farmers e.g. in tinned tomatoes competing with
imports, and canned fruit in export markets
consumer prices of canned foods
• Sole local producer, ArcelorMittal SA, increased tinplate prices by
around 70% in April 2009; Commission investigation underway
Other inputs to agricultural production being investigated
• Diesel
• Fencing wire
• Plastic irrigation piping
Towards a fair and efficient economy for all
Bread and milling
•
•
•
•
CC initiated & received a complaint
Blue Ribbon (Premier), Albany (Tiger), Sasko (Pioneer), Sunbake (Foodcorp)
Price fixing & market allocation –Western Cape & national
Progress:
Premier: leniency in terms of CLP
Tiger: penalty of R98.8 m
Foodcorp: penalty of R45.4 m
Pioneer: defending case, closing arguments were heard in Sept. 2009
• Research findings that margins increased at processing and retail of milled
products
• Initiated investigation in milling of wheat and maize, leniency application
received, investigations being concluded
Towards a fair and efficient economy for all
Bread, flour and wheat prices,
Rand per 700g brown loaf
8.00
7.00
Mark-up of bread over wheat, Rand per loaf
556g wheat SAFEX, Rand
500g flour, CPI, Rand
6.00
700g brown loaf, CPI, Rand
5.00
4.00
3.00
2.00
1.00
0.00
Towards a fair and efficient economy for all
Grain storage and trading
•
Complaint received by trader against Senwes
•
Abuse of dominance in the storage & handling of grain linked with
virtual monopoly positions of privatised co-ops
•
Tribunal found exclusionary conduct related to independent traders
of grain
•
Tribunal decision being appealed at CAC – awaiting CAC decision
•
Other cases in grain storage under investigation
Setting of storage prices for futures contracts in the industry association (GSI)
RMB and Noordwes Kooperasie (alleged market allocation and price fixing)
Towards a fair and efficient economy for all
Dairy
•
Commission referred complaint -Dec 2006
•
Collusion & abuse of dominance by processors: (Clover, Parmalat,
Lancewood, Woodlands, Nestle, Milkwood)
• Appear to have regulated the markets themselves following
governments de-regulation
•
Suppressing raw milk prices, raising barriers to entry through
exclusive arrangements
•
Case is currently tied up in legal processes
Towards a fair and efficient economy for all
Poultry
•
Poultry industry main source of protein for majority
•
Commission referred case against Astral and Elite in 2008
•
Abuse of dominance, especially in breeding by engaging in
exclusionary conduct
•
Following extensive background research, investigations into
different levels of the market including feed, breeding stock, broiler
production, and poultry products
Towards a fair and efficient economy for all
Fish
•
Pelagic fish – historical single marketing channel in the 1990’s
known as Federal Marine. Deregulation led to competitors
allocating brands through auction
•
Initiation into pelagic fish at different levels of the market – fishing,
processing and retail
•
Key concerns include exclusive agreements and alleged collusion
•
Investigating allegation of export cartel in hake
Towards a fair and efficient economy for all
Edible vegetable fats and oils
• Initiated investigation against Unilever and 14 others
• Retail price of cooking oil increased by 116% between 2006 and
2008
• Allegations of collusion in vegetable oil
• Allegations of Unilever abusing dominance in margarine
Towards a fair and efficient economy for all
Supermarkets
• Public outcry about high food prices
• Complaint from Milk Producers Organisation
• Preliminary study
• Initiated complaint against major retail stores: including Pick ‘n Pay,
Shoprite Checkers & Spar
• Buyer Power: Rebates & listing costs
• Long term lease agreements: raising entry barriers
• Category Management: facilitating collusion
• Information Exchange: role of market intelligence consultants
Towards a fair and efficient economy for all
Progress on major cases
Animal feed
Poultry feed
Yeast
Tin plate
Diesel
Fertilizer
Wire fencing
Plastic irrigation
piping
Production
Poultry
Milling
Poultry
Storage/
Trading
Grain
Processing
Bread
Fish
Fats and oils
Retailing
Fish
Dairy
Supermarkets
Fats and oils
Investigation
Inputs
Fertilizer
Grain
Bread
Dairy
Bread
Dairy
Hearing
Settlement
Grain
Dairy
Decision
Towards a fair and efficient economy for all
Appeal/Review
Commission’s work
• High concentration levels prevail, barriers to entry, poor
competitive outcomes
• Need to:
undermine cartels, opportunities for new entry
examine the role of industry associations
increase agricultural production by addressing effects of anticompetitive conduct on costs
improve understanding across govt and relevant public institutions
Towards a fair and efficient economy for all
The role of the state
• Commission investigations uncover past conduct and its consequences
• Proactive measures required to increase competition and change
outcomes
• This requires coordination on the part of government and public
institutions, including:
Development finance to support new entry
Leveraging government shareholding and support to encourage
competitive conduct
Supportive government interventions in economic infrastructure, R&D,
and skills development
Procurement to support new entry
Industrial and trade policy; and regulation
Towards a fair and efficient economy for all
Thank you!
Tel: 012 394 3332
Fax: 012 394 4332
email: shanr@compcom.co.za
Towards a fair and efficient economy for all